US election update

Well turned out to be a great day for the Democrats and the Republicans have had their first casualty from the result – the resignation of Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfield.

In the House the Dems have picked up 28 seats and it is 228-196 with 11 too close to call. Final outcome looks to be 232-203 – a bigger majority than the GOp had in the last Congress.

The Senate is poised to flip to the Democrats. At present the Dems have 48, GOP 49, Dems leaning Independents 2 and Virginia which is very close and will be recounted.
.
In Virginia Democratic Webb leads Allen by 6,900 votes out of over 2.3 million. I would be amazed if this changed so in a couple of days the Dems will be confirmed as controlling the Senate also.

Amongst the Governors, the Democrats have picked up six and now govern 28 out of 50 States.

Congress also has its first Muslim MP, which in a general sense is a good thing, as it may demonstrate that the United States is open to people of all religious faiths.

Two bills thrown out

While the main focus of the night was having the Raise the Alcohol Purchase Age to 20 bill thrown out, immediately prior to that was the Reduce the Number of MPs to 100 Bill which was also thrown out.

Now while it is very much MPs who decide for themselves how to vote, one can have varying degress of influence with submissions and lobbying. So having put in a written and oral submission against the Number of MPs bill (which was quoted quite often by the Select Committee in their report) and also been involved in lobbying on the Alcohol bill, it’s nice to see outcomes which align with your efforts. It makes putting in the time very worthwhile.

What I am especially proud about with these two bills specifically, is that they were both supported in polls by a large majority of the public. Yes, I know this sounds counter-intuitive, but let me explain. It’s relatively easy to defeat an unpopular bill, but to defeat bills which on the surface has widespread public support means that the quality of your arguments has to be much much stronger.

A great night for a great victory

Oh dear, I really should be past punishing myself by getting in close to 4 am, but if one can’t celebrate defeating a drinking age bill, what can you celebrate???

Will post more details tomorrow, but the bill to raise the age to 20 was defeated by a huge margin 49 votes to 72. A week ago it was looking to comfortably pass the second reading. It wasn’t until around 1 pm today that I felt confident that the bill would be defeated. The Govt’s announcement of a review into liquor supply to minors came at around 3 pm and probably helped with a few additional votes, but the numbers were already there prior to that announcement. Just checked how MPs voted against how we thought they would vote and we had a 95% accuracy rate which is pretty bloody good,

For those interested, how each party voted was:

Labour 15 – 35
National 20 – 28
NZ First 7 – 0
Greens 0 – 6
Maori 4 – 0
United 2 – 1
ACT 0 – 2
Progressive 1 – 0

After the vote around 20 of us headed up to 3.2 (the parliamentary bar) to celebrate. Minor problem was it had closed for the night but we got it re-opened. There for a couple of hours and then seven or so hard-core decided that the Green Parrot was the compulsory next stop.

Lots of food and drink at the Green Parrot. Very good as always even though I missed not having the normal complimentary plates of bread. After a while there we then headed to Courtenay Place and settled into Kitty’s where we met up with some Vic Debating Society students. Was rather funny at 3.00 am when my phone started ringing and I then realised it was my normal wake-up alarm call!

Had a guy in the pub come up to us and congratulate us for helping keep the age at 18 as he said he was there with his 17 year old daughter and he couldn’t wait until she was 18 so she could go by herself. He didn’t fancy having to babysit here for a further two years!

At one point the group had three Jordans. A National Jordan, a Labour Jordan and an ACT Jordan. Far too many to cope with.

Has been a great experience working with everyone who was involved in the Keep It 18 campaign. A really good team effort. More details to follow after some sleep!! 🙂

US mid-term election results

Use this thread to debate the results as they come in.

Joe Lieberman has kept his seat, which is a rebuff to the hardcore left who outed him in the primary. He will caucus with the Democrats though.

In the Senate Santorum has been defeated in Pennsylvania (good – too much of a zealot for me) and Ohio is almost certainly lost also.

Too soon to say in the House. Exit polls make it look like the Dems should get a doble digit majority, but they have been wrong before!

A third Senate seat has gone to the Dems in Rhode Island. A bit of a pity as it was one of the GOP’s most liberal Senators.

In the House, the Dems have picked up eight seats and need just seven more.

In Florida, the GOP candidate has won teh race for Governor. He must have been nervous though as he refused to turn up and introduce Bush at a rally yesterday!

A Dem majority in the Senate is looking difficult. They need three more pickups.

In Virgina, GOP Allen is ahead of Webb by 30,000 votes (1%) with 95% of precincts in. Likely hold.

Tennesee has GOP Corker ahead by 5% with 71% in. Likely hold.

Montana has only 1% counted so too early.

Missouri has GOP Talent ahead by 8% with 33% in. Might still go.

And the networks are now all saying the Democrats have taken control of the House. Goodbye Speaker Hastert and hello Speaker Pelosi.

The right move on youth drinking

In a highly significant move, the Government has announced it will review the supply of liquor to under 18 year olds, if the alcohol purchase age bill fails it second reading tonight.

Keep It 18 has constantly argued not to make it an offence for an 18 or 19 year old to buy a drink for themselves, bot to target the actual acts which are a problem such as supplying it to under 18 year olds.

This means MPs can now vote down the Gallagher bill, knowing that the forthcoming review will lead to a far better outcome in terms of actually targetting youth drinking, without penalising sensible law abiding 18 and 19 year olds.

This review is what the Government should have done all along, in response to the issue. Congratulations to them though for agreeing to it, better late than never.

Ironically the review will not happen if the Gallagher Bill does proceed, so that’s another reason to vote the Gallagher bill down.

Getting in Early

Scoop are getting in early. They have published an article on how the Republicans stole the mid-term elections, before they’ve even had the poll!!

It seems verifying that someone is entitled to vote, is now stealing elections!

Talking of elections I’ll cover some results as they come in, but after 6 pm I’ll probably be at Parliament for the second reading of the drinking age bill, so no coverage from 6 pm to 10 pm probably.

Initial results should start early afternoon.

About time!

Globalisation

Bryan Gould, who was on the left of the left of the UK Labour Party, has started a one-man crusade against globalisation. He’s around 20 years too late incidentially.

Anyway he bemoans as a bad thing how Trade Me, 42 Below and Ihug were snapped up by overseas investors. Yes this is somehow a bad thing.

Never mind that Ihug now has huge capital behind it thanks to Vodafone purchasing it, and could help deliver huge benefits in being able to roll our its own equipment and comptere with the other telcos.

And hey why should Sam Morgan get so much money? Bryan Gould sees it as bad that Sam sold to the highest bidder. Yeah, just because Sam invented Trade Me and made it such a success, he should have been forced to sell it for less than half of what Fairfax would pay.

Pac-Man

Just came across this blog entry about how in 1999 Billy Mitchell got a perfect score of 3,333,360 on Pac-Man. To achieve this you need to eat every single bonus prize and every possible blue ghost in all 256 levels of the game. He did it without losing a single life – literally a perfect game!

I never knew the game had 256 levels!

Trials must be in public!

A Judge has barred the media from attending court during evidence from a 14 year old alleged rape victim.

This is an abuse of the Judge’s power and even the Prosecutor has said it is illegal. The media, on our behalf, have the right to attend any trial not involving national security. One can supress evidence but not bar the media from even being there.

This is surely grpounds for a complaint about the Judge concerned, if it has been reported correctly?

Another banning bureaucrat

MPs and bureaucrats seem to like nothing better than finding things to ban. The latest is the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment who wants to ban cheap gas heaters!!

I’m all for education and encouragement, even sometimes using the tax system as incentives. But the state should not be banning thinsg and removing choice from individuals except where the harm is so profound and indisputable.

Excellent

It is excellent news that NZ has come first equal for non corruption in a global survey. NZ, Finaland and Iceland all got 9.6/10.

The survey was done by Transparency International.

Note that the recent election spending scandal happened after the survey was put together, and TI have condemned the validating legislation rushed through under urgency. Having said that, any impact in future will be relatively minor – it is not the same league as bribery etc.

Haiti was most corrupt scoring 1.8/10.

Interesting that of the top ten countries, seven were European, Australia and NZ were there also, so really the only non European dominated country in the top ten was Singapore. They may not be great on civil liberties but they are damn honest.

US race tightens

Two polls in the last 24 hours have shown the gap closing in the US. A month ago Gallup had the Democrats 23% ahead in a generic ballot, and now it is 7% amongst registered voters and 4% amongst likely voters.

There are more details in the monthly polling newsletter which is out tomorrow, but the Democrats winning the House has gone from being a dear cert to merely more likely than not. And the chances of a Senate mahjority are slim, but possible.

Multi-Party Press Conference

Stuff has an NZPA story about the press conference held this morning by Young Labour, Young Nationals, Young Greens and ACT on campus against increasing the drinking age to 18, organised by the Keep It 18 campaign..

Was very well attended by the media, and should also be on TV tonight. If anyone is watching and able to record a copy to upload to you tube, that would be really useful.

Britain’s biggest blog

Which Party?

Treaty Claims

The Chair of the Waitangi Tribunal has predicted that all Treaty settlements will be completed within 15 years at a cost of up to $3 billion.

This would be great, if it is accurate. The total quantum is fine (recognising inflation since the 1990 benchmark settlements) and it would be be nice to think that when I turn 55, the historical grievances will be settled.

However I am sceptical. The current pace of settlements is still fairly glacial, and significant extra resourcing will be needed to even make 2021 realistic. I recall that in 1990 the year 2000 was seen as the target date for settling all claims!

Saddam sentenced to death

DPF on Spam on Radio NZ

Just done a fairly lengthy interview with Radio NZ on the problems some NZ ISPs had this week with spam, and the resultant delays in e-mails. Should be on Morning Report sometime between 7 am and 8 am they reckon.

My views on spammers was captured well during this MSN conversation last night:

Grant dpf Can’t see Cyberspace command providing many purple hearts
dpf Grant but a silver star for killing a spammer
Grant dpf Medal of Honour from me
Grant dpf Although probably only the top award if it is done publically and painfully

Bjorn Lomborg on Stern Review

A very good review of the Stern Review by Bjorn Lomborg. Now before people call Professor Lomborg a “denier” (a term I despise), I should point out Lomberg says “climate change is a real problem, and that it is caused by human greenhouse-gas emissions”.

How-ever he finds Stern has:

* The review is one-sided, focusing almost exclusively on carbon-emission cuts as the solution to the problem of climate change.

* Even if global warming does significantly increase the power of hurricanes, it is estimated that 95% to 98% of the increased damage will be due to demographics. The review acknowledges that simple initiatives like bracing and securing roof trusses and walls can cheaply reduce damage by more than 80%; yet its policy recommendations on expensive carbon reductions promise to cut the damages by 1% to 2% at best.

* The most well-recognized climate economist in the world is probably Yale University’s William Nordhaus, whose “approach is perhaps closest in spirit to ours,” according to the Stern review. Mr. Nordhaus finds that the social cost of CO2 is $2.50 per ton. Mr. Stern, however, uses a figure of $85 per ton.

* Mr. Stern tells us that the cost of U.K. flooding will quadruple to 0.4% from 0.1% of GDP due to climate change. However, we are not told that these alarming figures only hold true if one assumes that the U.K. will take no additional measures–essentially doing absolutely nothing and allowing itself to get flooded, perhaps time and again. In contrast, the U.K. government’s own assumptions take into account a modest increase in flood prevention, finding that the cost will actually decline sharply to 0.04% of U.K. GDP, in spite of climate change.

* According to the background numbers in Mr. Stern’s own report, climate change will cost us 0% now and 3% of GDP in 2100, a much more informative number than the 20% now and forever.

* In other words: Given reasonable inputs, most cost-benefit models show that dramatic and early carbon reductions cost more than the good they do. Mr. Stern’s attempt to challenge that understanding is based on a chain of unlikely assumptions.

* Faced with such alarmist suggestions, spending just 1% of GDP or $450 billion each year to cut carbon emissions seems on the surface like a sound investment. In fact, it is one of the least attractive options. Spending just a fraction of this figure–$75 billion–the U.N. estimates that we could solve all the world’s major basic problems. We could give everyone clean drinking water, sanitation, basic health care and education right now. Is that not better?

Weasels

Dilbert has the results of its annual weasel awards. Over 40,000 people voted. Some of the awards are:

Weaseliest Pundit/Reporter: Michael Moore beats out the entire staff of the NY Times
Weaseliest Celebrity: Tom Cruise beats out Michael Jackson
Weaseliest Industry: Oil Industry beats out the Mainstream Media
Weaseliest Organization: The Republican Party beats out the RIAA/MPAA
Weaseliest Politician: No surpise George W Bush beats out Donald Rumsfield

US Technology Voting Guide

CNET have done a useful guide to the best and worse House and Senate members when it comes to technology issues.

The results were surprisingly mixed: In the Senate, Republicans easily bested Democrats by an average of 10 percent. In the House of Representatives, however, Democrats claimed a narrow but visible advantage on technology-related votes.

Libertarian Ron Paul was the highest scoring House Republican at 80%. In the Senate the second lowest placxe went to John Kerry on 15%.

It’s one of the things I like about the US system – the party whipping is so loose, that you can identify where lawmakers stand on various issues.

Climate Change Confusion

The SST editorial mainly hits the mark with cynicism and comments about Labour’s sudden desire to out-green the Greens. But there is one bizarre part as they talk about how hard it is to reduce carbon emissions. They say:

Green leader Russel Norman rightly asked how an anti-nuclear government could allow its state super fund to invest in the uranium industry. Clark has pooh-poohed the charge and Michael Cullen, in his drearily predictable way, says he won’t “micro-manage” the fund. It is becoming seriously difficult to see just what Cullen stands for aside from fiscal rectitude and self-congratulation. Withdrawing from the nuclear industry is not micro-managing and it is not a micro-issue. It goes to the heart of what the government stands for. So why doesn’t it put its money where its mouth is?

If the Government is serious about saving the planet by reducing carbon emissions, then the last thing it should do is reduce investments in nuclear power. If Europe and the US abandoned nuclear power, the effects on the environment would be massive and inevitably result in way more carbon emissions.

Oh also read this article in which the Climate Change Ministers defends having a huge gas guzzling car. Excuses would have been reasonable a few weeks ago, but with the PM claiming NZ must aspire to reduce net carbon emissions to zero, then one has to have leadership by example.

Now we know where the gutter tactics come from

Fascinating to read this in today’s SST:

Labour Party president Mike Williams said he was so irritated by the billboards that he mulled on what themes ran through the National leader’s life and came up with “comb-over” and “leg-over”, a reference to Brash’s alleged affair with Business Roundtable vice-chairwoman Diane Foreman.

Can’t blame that one on an out of control Trevor Mallard (whom I have always said was made a scapegoat and was acting with Clark’s blessing).

Is this news?

I felt very sorry for Amanda Scott, who has just had her past made front-page on the SST. When she was 22 she was the driver for a bank robbery and was sentenced to three years jail in 1991. So she has probably been out of jail for 13 years or so and is now a popular and competent teahcer a a decile one school. Good on her.

So what is the story here? Why make sure every single student, friend and colleague of hers knows about her past. I’m not saying the info should not be a matter of public record – I support that strongly. But what is the news interest in making it a front page story? There are presumably hundreds or thousands of people who committed a crime over a decade ago, and have not reoffended since and hold a responsible job.