Not a blogger

Fran O’Sullivan’s column today responds to the PM labelling her a “right wing blogger” as part of the PM’s new strategy to label anyone who criticises her as a “right wing blogger”.

It’s an amusing column as Fran details how some bloggers have criticised her as being too soft on Helen, or to use her term “a craven media love slave of Helengrad” šŸ™‚

Fran sensibly also denies being Cadmus šŸ™‚

The rest of the column details the disturbing trend to try and suppress criticism. Banning third party campaigning, hitting charities who do political advocacy and tougher media regulation rules etc.

Trevor vs Bob

I have a confession to make. In a perverse way I sometimes (only sometimes) quite like Trevor Mallard. Don’t get me wrong – I deplore some of his actions, and disagree with most of his policies. And he has probably (righfully) doomed his chances of replacing Cullen As Finance Minister with his behaviour over Dr Brash’s alleged affair which was disgraceful.

But a part of me responds to larrikins.

And most Ministers, if accussed by an MP of whacking him on the head, would do a profuse apology.

But Mallard comes out and tells Bob Clarkson to act like a “real Kiwi joker” and to “stop squealing like a baby”. Priceless. His press secretary must be wincing šŸ™‚

And it’s now at 20,000

The right to silence

Good God. Top Criminal Defence QC Kevin Ryan has called for an end to the right to silence, and also for juries to know the criminal history of defendents.

He says the right to silence is from an outdated era when most of the public were uneducated and illiterate, and points out the law allows no right of silence for SFO investigations, yet does for murder and rape which are more serious offences than fraud.

He refers to the Kahui Twins case, saying “In my view, we are assisting evil by just sitting there and not answering questions.”

Republican Shame

This graph shows one of the reasons why the Republicans may lose control of the House this year. Despite a Republican President, Senate and House, federal expenditure has skyrocketed, Fiscal hawks are not happy, and rightly so.

Hat Tip: Andrew Sullivan

Quality of Govt Expenditure

One of the problems of just throwing more money at portfolios, is the more money being spent, the lower the quality of expenditure.

A classic example of this comes from Sandra Goudie today. She reveals what has happened with the money for problem gambling:

* Pacific Peoples Addiction Service paid $143,160 for intervention services in the 2005/06 year and had only eight customers

* Te Whanau o Waipareira Trust paid $186,976 and had 13 users

* Te Rapuora Health Services in Nelson was paid $86,124 and had six people use its service

Also someone is counted as a client, even if they have just had a 16 minute phone conversation. So the Government is paying up to $18,000 for a 16-minute phone conversation or a single half-hour counselling session!!

Parliamentary Internet Caucus

On Tuesday night a gathering of MPs voted to set up a cross-party “Parliamentary Internet Caucus“, The PIC elected David Cunliffe and Maurice Williamson as co-chairs, and its purpose is to discuss Internet issues in a non-political, collaborative way, and also to increase and enhance knowledge and understanding by all MPs of the Internet and associated technologies.

I’m really pleased with this development, and not just because I was one of the proponents of it. The Internet is such a vital part of our country and economy, that it is great to have a commitment to work together on relevant issues. It’s not to say there won’t be issues (such as the telecommunications regulatory framework) where there are genuinely different views, but it’s in all of our interest to have sensible laws on ISP liability, digital copyright, etc etc.

People often call for there to be less posturing and argument in Parliament, and for MPs to work together more. Well this is a good example of MPs doing exactly that.

Tax Cuts and Growth

The CIS continues it good work, with its latest paper being on “Why tax cuts are good for growth“.

Some useful stats:

* The “deadweight loss” to the economy of the extra tax paid since 2000 is estimated to be at least $4 billion.
* Tax and benefit abatements rates combine to give a maximum 91% marginal rate
* Aust tax as % of GDP is 31.6% to our 34.9%
* Weighted OECD average is 31% of GDP
* In 1990 the OECD average corporate rate was 40%. Today it is 28.3%
* The top tax rate in NZ cuts in at just 1.4 times the average wage
* An OECD study estimates every 1% increase in the tax to GDP ratio leads to 0.6% to 0.7% reduction in per capita income.
* Another study found a 10% cut in corporate tax will raise the annual growth rate by 1% to 2%
* One could lower the corporate, top and middle rates to 30% and the lower-middle rate to 18% for just $3.15 billion per annum

Hat Tip: Not PC

Scouting Fraud

I was very sad to see Scouting NZ was defrauded by its finance manager for $200,000. That is a hell of a lot of money to them – one third of their income.

I actually knew the employee involved, but not well, and would have thought him last person on Earth to be stealing money. I used to be very involvved with Scouting at group, area and national levels so knew most of the staff.

Two years is a fairly light sentence for what he has done.

Essay on 2005 election campaign

Pamzie has blogged a copy of her essay/assignment on National’s 2005 election campaign.

While parts of it are certainly debatable, it’s a pretty fair review all up.

One small error is the statement Saatchi and Saatchi had a hand in the billboards. They had no part in them (or in any part of the campaign).

Also citing Wikipedia will generally lose you a mark. Great resource, but not one academics like people to cite.

Why men are paid more?

A lot of angry people

I have been surprised by how angry people are about ramming the validating legislation through Parliament under urgency. Even though *some* of the legislation is arguably desirable, by ramming it through in this way, the public are naturally suspicious about what is it that Labour and allies are trying to cover up?

This explains the more than 5,000 people who have signed an online petition to the Governor-General in the last day and a bit. And every few seconds a couple of dozen more sign. One can spend quite a bit of time just hitting refresh and seeing the signatures roll in. It is now the second most active (most number of signatures per rminute) in the world.

This is well outside the beltway. People are signing from everywhere in NZ. It’s a pity Blair didn’t set up an optional column for comments – there would be some fiery ones I am sure.

As it so happens, I’m not signing it myself. I totally support the intentions, and that it is the only way people feel they can protest what Labour, NZ First and United Future have done. However it has a technical error in it, referring to the legislation validating Electoral Act breaches when in fact is illegal spending breaches being legalised.

UPDATE: In the couple of minutes it took me to do this post, the number of signatures increased by over 200.

UPDATE2: Has gone from 5,000 to 7,000 this morning. Also of great amusement are Google Ads which have been displaying Labour Party Ads on the petition site, which means Labour are paying for the costs of the petition šŸ™‚ David Slack has a screen shot.

Praise for Helen

I am pleased to see that the PM is backing John Howard with Howard’s tough line on the Solomons and PNG. Yes Australia can sometimes be ham-fisted with their approach to Pacific diplomacy, but the underlying issue is a vital one – good governance is the key to more prosperity and stability in the Pacific.

The $1,000 payment

Labour MP Taito Phillip Field gave Sunan Siriwan $1,000 a few days ago. Siriwan’s lawyer has said Siriwan has signed an affidavit which makes a serious allegation relating to that money.

For those who have been busy focusing on the pledge card scandal, this one has been ticking along also. Siriwan has now changed his story from what he told Ingram. He says he merely told Ingram what Field told him to say, and that Field had always promised his a visa in exchange for work on his place.

ACT took action against Donna Awatere-Huata without waiting for a court case. How long will Labour continue to take no meaningful action?

Superb headline

Hope this doesn’t give Helen ideas!

Internet users in southwest China who spread malicious rumours online face fines of up to 5,000 yuan (338 pounds) and possible detention, state media reported on Wednesday in the latest crackdown on dissent.

Hope this Reuters story doesn’t give our beloved leader ideas on how to deal with “right wing bloggers”.

Amendments Voted Down

Very sadly, Labour and allies have voted down amendments which would have made the validatng legislation less obnoxious constitutionally.

Amendments which they defeated include:

Clause 6A(1) Nothing in this Act shall affect the High Court proceedings of Darnton v Clark dated 29 June 2006 (Civ No. 2006-485-1398) in which the plaintiff seeks a declaration that the expenditure on the ā€œpledge cardā€ and related brochures by the Labour Parliamentary Party is a breach of the Constitution Act 1986, the Public Finance Act 1989 and the Bill of Rights 1688.

This means Labour have explictly voted to kill off a lawsuit against themselves. This is even more repugnant that what Muldoon did as he did not stand to personally benefit from his actions in Fitzgerald v Muldoon. This also cements in place the big lie that Labour pushes that the Auditor-General changed the rules. The AG is adamant he did not, and this lawsuit would have allowed a Judge to decide whether or not the pledge card was legal under the current rules.

6A No effect on political parties wishing to repay monies
Nothing in this Act prevents political parties repaying any expenditure identified by the Controller and Auditor-General as being outside of the appropriation for any financial year

This clause would have guaranteed parties can not use this Act to backtrack on their commitment to pay the money back.

Clause 7(2)
To omit ā€œexplicitly

This would have meant that all electioneering would be illegal, not just “explicit” electioneering which has loopholes so wide you can drive a pledge card through them.

They are currently voting on the final amendments to the short title and commencement date. These are now debated last, not first (something I only learnt today) so after this the Committee of the Whole should report back to the House, and then proceed with a third reading which should conclude around 5.20 pm.

The Treasury Advice

Thank you to Dr Cullen’s office who kindly e-mailed me both the Treasury Advice on validating legislation and also Dr Cullen’s cabinet paper. They are both downladable as word docs.

Okay looking at the Treasury advice, it is quite clear that the only expenses they recommend are validated are those found by the Controller and Auditor-General. They do say it has implications for expenditure since 1 July 1989, but they do not explicitly say you need to validate back that far. The Cabinet Paper does recommend validating back to 1989, but the scope of that paper is “as requested” by Dr Cullen.

Also nowhere does Treasury say this needs to be done under urgency. In fact they say validating expenditure is fairly common and normally done as a “usual part of the overall budget legislative cycle”.

Also nowhere does Treasury say they believe a temporary definition of funding entitlement for parliamentary purposes is needed. This is only dealt with in the Cabinet Paper by Dr Cullen.

Turning to the Cabinet Paper, most of it is similar to the introductory note in the legislation. But there is one section in there which, unwittingly, proves my case that the Police botched the Electoral Act investigation.

One of the major criticisms of the police inquiry is that they spent all their time looking into whether the pledge card should have been funded by Parliament (which had nothing to do with them) instead of assessing whether it was expenditure as defined by the Electoral Act. The Chief Electoral Officer had made it very clear that who pays for something does not matter for the Act.

So what does Dr Cullen say in his cabinet paper:

For the purposes of the electoral finance regime, the source of funding for ā€œelection expensesā€, whether from parliamentary or private sources, is irrelevant. The focus is on whether the expenditure is an ā€œelection expenseā€ as defined under the Electoral Act, including whether the expenditure is authorised by the party or candidate and the advertising occurs within the 3 months before Election Day.

Now Dr Cullen here is entirely correct. But this is huge all the same. It is further proof positive the Police investigation was incompetent. National should send this extract to Commissioner Broad to point out even the Govt thinks their investigation was incompetent. Incidentally Dr Cullen’s advice varies from that of the defendant Heather Simpson who asserted to the Police the PSC guidelines over-ruled the Electoral Act in terms of what is an election activity. the Police seemingly accepted this view, despite it being obviously wrong (as Dr Cullen himself now points out).

UPDATE: Dean Knight reviews the advice and gives it a C-

Where are ACT?

Listening to the votes, I’ve noticed that ACT are not casting any votes. Are Rodney and Heather in Wellington?

UPDATE: Heather has kindly posted a comment clarifying the situation. ACT were not voting for only a short period of the overall debate and made many good contributions opposing the legislation.

Educating Helen

I’ve just listened to a second radio interview where Helen Clark refers to “right wing blogs” incorrectly. She earlier called Fran O’Sullivan’s NZ herald column a blog and in this interview also refers to (presumably) Matthew Hooton’s SST column as a “right wing blog”.

Can someone on her staff please explain to her that she looks foolish everytime she does this. It’s like calling a newspaper a TV broadcast. Here’s the three things you need to make sure she understands:

1) A blog, short for web log, is not a newspaper column (even if there is an online version of it). It is an opinion peice published on the Internet, using blog software.

2) Not all blogs are right wing.

3) Not all publications which criticise her, are blogs.

She seems to have been told these “right wing blogs” are a bad thing, so whenever something criticises her, she is now calling it a “right wing blog” to undermine it.

This is as silly as if Don dismissed a NZ Herald newspaper column attacking him as a “socialist propoganda broadcast”.

UPDATE: Russell Brown has also noticed the PM’s confusions with bloggers. He notes she tends to regard the phrase “right wing blogger” as the worst insult she could reach for.

I have to say that the thought we annoy her so much, so she now uses us an a term of insult gives me a warm happy feeling that could only be exceeded if Scarlett Johansen wanted me as a love slave.

Perhaps a t-shirt is needed – “I am a right wing blogger and proud of it” šŸ™‚

Libz declare today Banana Republic Day

The Libz are declaring today Banana Republic Day, as Parliament under urgency and without proper scrutiny looks set to pass a special law which will protect the PM and Labour MPs from a lawsuit which is currently before the Courts. Hopefully the majority of MPs will vote for an amendment which preserves the lawsuit.

David Slack at Public Address blogs on what is happening in Parliament, comparing it to what Muldoon did 30 years ago, with a “haughty disregard for democratic niceties” .

Views on Validating Legislation

Dean Knight provides some excellent analysis of the validating legislation. He, like myself, is not opposed to legislation per se.

Dean makes two important points:

1) The legislation validates all illegal Parliamentary expenditure, not just those activities found to be unlawful by the AG. If for example a corporate box had been leased at the stadium, this would now be validated also. The Government has drafted the validation far too widely – it even validates advertising which was clearly illegal – stuff saying “Vote for Me”.

2) There is no need to legislate for temporary rules. The Speaker could simply issue new directions, as the interpretation challenges have occurred at the level of the Speaker’s directions, not at the legislative level.

The above shows why it is such a bad idea to ram the legislation through Parliament in 24 hours. A law with no scrutiny will be a bad law.

The NZ Herald covers the debate in the House last night. Their editorial also slams the legislation, and especially Labour’s “stubborn refusal to accept the Auditor-General’s judgment and let it stand.”

John Armstrong warns National about trying to be on the moral high ground. LBJ at Sir H also criticises some of National’s tactics in the House.

For my 2c, I think National is right to oppose the legislation, and especially ramming it through under urgency. However I do think they are emphasising the wrong things in opposing it. The focus shouldn’t be on whether it allows a party to not pay it back (the repayment was voluntary anyway). The focus should be on how it affects the Darnton v Clark lawsuit, making sure it is amended to exempt wiping that out, and also opposing the new temporary definitions.

The Dominion Post editorial is also critical of the legislation.

The Validating Bill

This went up yesterday on the Parliament website. The bill has gone through the first and second readngs and is now in committee stage where amendemnts can be considered. It will get voted on either part by part or clause by clause. There are seven clauses, of which four do the business:

Clause 4 defines the appropriations to be validated as being from 89/90 to the current day. This goes beyond what is needed. The Auditor-General has not found there to be illegal expenditure before 04/05. There is no legal requirement to validate back to 1989. Going back that far is Labour making a political statement that we believe the Auditor-General has changed the rules, so we need to validate all the way back. The Auditor-General is quite adamant he has not changed the rules.

Clause 5 validates the expenditure and deems it not have have breached the Cvil List Act or the Parliamentary Service Act(s). What is not clear to me is whether it does totally kill off the Darnton v Clark lawsuit. That lawsuit alleges a breach of the Constitution Act 1986 s.22(c), the Public Finance Act 1989 sections 4, 5 and 9, and Article 4 of the Bill of Rights 1688.

This is the problem of rushing stuff through under urgency – Parliament does not have time to make a considered decision. The best course of action would be for the Committee of the Whole to amend the Bill to specifically exempt the lawsuit (which was filed many months before the Auditor-General’s report) from being affected by the Bill. I hope all the minor parties would support this (it only affects Labour’s pledge card) and even Labour might agree that to kill off the lawsuit by retrospective legislation is an abuse of Parliament.

Clause 6 says this Act doesn’t affect the criminal liability of any person. That is good. What again is unclear (lawyers please chime in) is whether the offences listed under the Public Finance Act for breaches of it (and one lawyer has suggested Heather Simpson could well have a case to answer) are offences of “criminal liability”?

Finally Clause 7 over-turns the Auditor-General and former Solictor-General’s determination of the law, and redefines electioneering as Labour wants it to be. This definition will last until Dec 2007 and is:

“Any communicatiion that explicitly seek seeks support for the election of a person … seeks support for the casting of a party vote … encourages any person to become a member … solicits financial support”

The key word here is explicit. This has just legalised Labour’s pledge card for the next 15 months. If you have an early election, Labour can now legally plunder the taxpayer again. This definition allows state funded newspaper adverts the week of the election etc.

Here’s an example of what would be legal under these rules:

“Party B is going to destory this country with its policies. They have to be stopped. They will abolish the minimum wage and force children into slavery. If you don’t want this to happen, well don’t forget to vote at the election this Saturday”

Now this does not explicitly seek the party vote for a particular political party so is legal if this bill gets passed.

Barlow plans Privy Council appeal