JPs suppress their own names

Very extraordinary to have a judicial officer (two JPs) suppress their own name. I mean even in Iraq the identities of the Judges trying Saddam are public.

One JP is quoted as saying he wants to keep a low public profile. Umm, if that is the case then you should decline doing court duty (not all JPs do court duty).

Orange Lights

If a light turns orange as you approach it, do you normally?

(a) speed up to get through before it changes
(b) slam the brakes on

Bob Harvey considers novel ways to stop red light running:

“I think if you pulled people out of their cars and had public executions, it would still happen.”

300 million Americans

Congratulations to the United States who last night gained their 300th million American. You can see their population change on their census clock.

Less than 100 years ago the population was only 100 million – in 1915. In 1800 the populaiton was a bit over 5 million.

The US is 80.4% “white” yet 31 ethnic groups have over one million members each.

The US today accepts more legal immigrants as permanent residents than the rest of the world combined.

Scrapping Sedition

The NZ Herald reports that the Law Commission released a report today, calling for the review of sedition laws. I strongly back their call.

People should not be going to jail for what they say, as opposed to what they do.

Yes there are some limits on free speech. You don’t want someone to be able to advocate the killing of political leaders etc, but that can be dealt with under other laws. The sedition clause that gives me the most problems is:

To bring into hatred or contempt, or to excite disaffection, against Her Majesty, or the Government of New Zealand or the administration of justice.

As someone opposed to both Her Majesty and the current Government, and who enjoys exciting disaffection, a zealous police force could cause problems. And after decades with no sedition prosecutions we have seen two this year alone.

The Law Commission notes:

The Commission has concluded that the seditious offences set out in the Crimes Act 1961 are overly broad and uncertain. They infringe on the principle of freedom of expression, and have the potential for abuse – a potential which has been realised in some periods of our history, when these offences have been used to stifle or punish political speech.

As expected No Right Turn has a post on this issue. Details of how to make a submission are on his site. The deadline is 15 December and given time I hope to make one.

In an earlier post NRT also highlights how the PM when asked about sedition laws said: “I have no view on it at all. I’ve never read the law of sedition. I’ve taken no interest in it whatsoever.” which is surprising as two Labour PMs have been charged with it in the past. Plus I can’t imagien she is unaware of the Tim Selwyn case.

Validating Legislation

It is quite obscene that in a democracy, the Government is about to ram a highly significant bill through Parliament, and as a citizen I can’t even find a copy online of the law about to be passed. Not that the MPs are in a much better position – they only got to see this morning the bill.

Ramming this bill, under urgency, through all three readings is an appalling thing to do. The public are being denied any say on this law, which I understand goes well beyond just validating the 2004/05 accounts.

This bill, depending on its wording, may make Labour immune from the Darnton v Clark lawsuit. It also stops any complaints or charges being laid against Heather Simpson, or even the Prime Minister, for breaches of the Public Finance Act.

Dean Knight raises a number of issues over both the need for the legislation, and especially the rushing it through Parliament under urgency.

The Government claims to be acting on Treasury advice, yet has not released this advice for people to verify, and by the time they do, the law will be changed.

The only bright spot today is that United Future has agreed to pay back their illegal spending. Well done. Only NZ First to go.

Green Stats

Just heard Sue Kedgley claim in Parliament we need to ban advertising of food in schools as 56,000 pies are sold (I guess a week) but only 4,000 pieces of fruit.

But this got me thinking. If a kid wants a pie for lunch, he has to buy it at school. You don’t eat cold pie from home generally.

However many many parents probably send their kids off to school with an apple or some fruit, so the sales figures may be irrelevant in terms of determining if there is a problem.

Heh!

Fallacies around the Auditor-General’s Report

Legal Beagle Junior at Sir H’s rebuts some fallacies so well, I’m stealing them below:

Proposition: Kevin Brady has adopted a definition of electioneering that means just about everything an MP does with his or her Parliamentary funds is illegal.

False: As the Auditor-General points out in his report:

“Clause 46(3)(d) of the Speaker’s Directions specifically prohibits electioneering advertising. It is clear that this prohibition does not apply to other activities undertaken by MPs

Proposition: Just about everything an MP does is electioneering.

False: For something to be ‘electioneering’ under the Auditor-General’s interpretation it must have a “direct bearing” on an election. If there’s not an election in the offing what they’re doing ain’t electioneering.

Proposition: The Auditor-General’s report indicates that millions of dollars has been mis-spent since 1989 and all of this spending needs to be validated.

False: The Auditor-General, as Labour has repeatedly pointed out, has already signed off on the annual accounts from 89/90, 90/91, 91/92, 92/93, 93/94, 94/95, 95/96, 96/97, 97/98, 98/99, 99/00, 00/01, 01/02, 02/03, and 03/04 – so there is nothing illegal to validate.

LBJ in a different post also highlights there are criminal penalties for breaching the Public Finance Act. He wonders aloud whether H2 could be found to have broken it when she wrote an order to The Parliamentary Service instructing them to pay for the pledge card, despite their obvious reluctance. An interesting thought. Now will the validating legislation prevent legal action under the Act?

An asset rich party

Insolent Prick has done some detective work and discovered that Labour has a huge asset base of over $6 million in property:

Dannevirke Labour $15,700
Greymouth Labour Branch $40,000
Labour Properties Inc $4,800,000
NZ Labour Party Clubrooms Inc $140,000
Picton Branch $11,000
Thames Branch $83,000
Dunedin South $770,000

So tell me again why Labour won’t pay the money back until June next year?

Useful Herald feature

IPv6 Allocations

The IANA has just done a major allocation of IPv6 addresses to regional address registries.

Each RAR has been allocated a /12 which is 2^116 IP addresses. The total address pool is 2^128.

So what do they mean in real numbers.

Each RAR has 83,076,749,736,557,200,000,000,000,000,000,000 addresses to allocate. That is 83.1 decillion addresses. Each person in the world could have 12.8 septillion addresses to use up a /12.

But a /12 is only 1/4096 of the total IPv6 address space. That is 340,282,366,920,938,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 or 340.3 undecillion.

Definitely not going to run out anytime soon. In fact I doubt we will ever get to see an RAR needing a second /12.

Size of Tax Cuts

Okay there will be tax cuts in the 2007 budget (which is good), but how significant will they be?

Dr Cullen makes the point that a surplus is historical and the forecast surplus guides you as to what you can afford. This is basically correct.

However one needs to figure in the propoensity for actual surpluses to be much much larger than official projections. Let’s take the last three years as an example.

The actual combined OBERAC surplus for the 2003/04, 04/05 and 05/06 FYs was $24.2b. Absolutely massive.

Now what were these forecast to be? Well the first time all these years were forecast was in the 2001 DEFU. And the combined OBERAC forecast was $10.4b. So the actual surplus was 131% higher than forecast. And this is not a one off in one year, but over an entire three year cycle.

Now looking at the 2006 BEFU, what are the combined surpluses for 07/08, 08/09 and 09/10? They are $13.3b. Now if these forecasts turn out the same way as the last three years (131% higher than forecast), then the actual surpluses could turn out to be as high as $30.8b.

Oh and let us not forget there is currently $19.1b of contingency expenditure in the forecasts for those three years. Yes seriously.

There is room for massive tax cuts. The key restriction on how big they are would probably be monetary policy, not fiscal policy.

My taste in (fictional) women

Jacqueline Passey blogs her taste in fictional men from TV series:

Angel:
Would: Wesley (on this show)
Wouldn’t: Angel, Gunn, Lorne, Doyle, Conner

Battlestar Galactica:
Would: 1st or 2nd season Apollo, Chief Tyrol, Gaeta, Billy
Wouldn’t: 3rd season Apollo (so far), William Adama, Tigh, Baltar, Helo, Anders, any Cylon

Buffy:
Would: Giles, 5th-7th seasons Xander
Wouldn’t: 1st-4th seasons Xander, Wesley (on this show), Oz, Angel, Riley, Spike

Star Trek: The Original Series
Would: McCoy, Chekov, Sulu (no one ever said the *character* was gay…)
Wouldn’t: Kirk, Spock, Scotty

Star Trek: The Next Generation
Would: Data, Geordi, later-season Barclay (after he was less of a dork), Wesley (once he was old enough)
Wouldn’t: Picard, Riker, Worf, O’Brien

Now this got me thinking what my choices would be, but for women of course:

Angel:
Would: Fred, Darla, Illyria, Eve
Wouldn’t: Cordelia, Harmony, Lilah,

Battlestar Galactica:
Would: Starbuck, Number Six (sigh), Cally, Dee
Wouldn’t: Roslin, Sharon, Number Three, Ellen Tigh, Admiral Cain,

Buffy:
Would: Buffy, Faith, Anya (my favourite)
Wouldn’t: Willow, Tara, Dawn, Drusilla, Cordelia, Glory,

Star Trek: The Next Generation
Would: Tasha Yar
Wouldn’t: Deanna Troi, Dr Crusher,

Grey’s Anatomy:
Would: Izzy, Christina, Addison
Wouldn’t: Meredith, Miranda, Callie,

Desperate Housewives:

Would: All 🙂
Wouldn’t: None 🙂

Shortland Street:
Would: Toni, Alice, Rachel, Kirsty
Wouldn’t: Sarah, Maia, Jay, Claire, Libby, Tania,

Remember these are based on the characters, not the person playing them!

Calm down Pete!

Trying to distract attention away from the growing awareness that Labour probably broke the electoral spending limit by $790,000 last election, Pete Hodgson has put out a hilariously hysterical release attacking National.

Putting aside the normal whining about the GSt error and the Brethren, Genius Pete comes up with three new complaints:

1) National raised almost $2 million in donations in 2005. My God, how dare they. It should be illegal for National to attract more donations than Labour.

2) National spent most of its parliamentary budget on staff instead of advertising. Oh my God – call the Serious Fraud Office immediately. They hired staff. This must be stopped.

3) National spent money on advertising outside the 90 day per-election timeframe. Good God. We can not have a political party using private funds to advertise outside the election period. This notion of free speech must be stopped.

I love it how Pete keeps comparing totally legal, legitimate actions of National with illegal, corrupt actions of Labour. The illegal refers to the taxpayer funding and the corrupt to the over-spending.

One has to ask. Does he know the difference between obeying the law and not obeying the law and he is just trying to confuse the public, or does he really not know the difference?

PM and Bloggers

Not PC links to the NewstalkZB interview with the PM where she lashes out at right wing bloggers.

But she gets very confused as she describes Fran O’Sullivan as a blogger not once but two or three times. So why the confusion? Here’s my theory:

H1: So Heather, am I the most popular in the land today?

H2: Yes you are

H1: And are there any who speak out against me?

H2: All joyfully sing your praises, except a few deviants and malcontents known as bloggers

H1: Bloggers? What is a blogger. Have we agreed to these bloggers?

H2: These bloggers spread their views without approval H1. And they say awful things about you.

H1: Like what?

H2: Like you want to suppress their freedom of speech

H1: That’s ridiculous. Is there anyway I can stop them making such claims?

H2: Wait a second, I have to go bid for that pledge card on the Trade Me auction

H1: (to herself) So my only critics are bloggers. Nasty right wing bloggers. Just wait until my 4th term and they’ll get theirs.

H1: (reading NZ Herald) Outrageous that Fran O’Sullivan is inventing stories about my caucus not loving H2 and myself as much as they used to. Who is this Fran person? She has criticised me, ha, so she must be a blogger.

H2: (returns to room)

H1: How did the auction go?

H2: Oh fuck, I bidded $400 but I think I bid on the wrong auction. I bid on the Darnton v Clark auction.

H1: And who is this Bernard Darnton character who is suing me?

H2: Just another blogger. But don’t worry Dr Cullen’s legislation is going to wipe out his lawsuit

H1 and H2: Cackle Cackle. And he won’t even get costs.

NewstalkZB

XtraGoogle?

Beware the Validating Legislation

Labour are attempting a con job on an unprecedented scale with their validating legislation. They are going to ram through Parliament a law which goes well beyond validating illegal expenditure. Let me explain.

The only expenditure that needs validating, is that identified by the Auditor-General from the 04/05 financial year.

Therefore the proper course of action for the Government is to introduce legislation that will validate only that year, and to not ream it through Parliament under urgency, but allow it to follow normal process, including select committee hearings.

If that is what Labour puts forward, then National should probably support it. But alas Labour are going for the big con job. As Matthew Hooton noted yesterday in the SST, no legislation should be passed anyway until the money has been repaid. You absolutely can not trust Labour to backtrack – because they already did it with the Chief Electoral Officer before the election. It’s a proven track record of agreeing to something and backtracking when the heat is off.

Now look at what else Labour proposes to force through Parliament. It also wants to change the law for the 2005/06 year (which is not yet signed off). This would retroespectively change the law to defeat a current lawsuit which looked likely to win – Darnton v Clark. .

It is vital Darnton v Clark be allowed to proceed? Why? Labour claim that the Auditor-General got it wrong. Well the court case will allow the issue (in terms of the pledge card anyway) to be settled for once and all. A ruling by the High Court that the pledge card was illegal will be even more damaging that the AG’s finding, so they are trying to kill the lawsuit.

The othe big con, is Labour are seeking to over-turn the Auditor-General’s report by passing legislation to temporarily allow them to spend their parliamentary budgets on whatever they like (so long as no explicit call for votes etc). This means that their pledge card would be made legal in future.

This is a totally seperate issue to the validating legislation and should be a seperate bill, which again goes to select committee. If this bill is passed, Labour will once again be free to spend $800,000+ during an election campaign of taxpayers money.

So I say yes to validating legislation for 04/05 only, but no to everything else.

Delusions of Honesty

On Thursday Night, was fortunate to enjoy hearing Theodore Dalrymple as an after dinner speaker. Dalrymple, a pen name for Anthony Daniels, was a very witty, thought provoking and entertaining speaker. Plus he has been getting Russell Brown and Chris Trotter upset which can only be positive 🙂

Anyway the absolute gem of the night came when Dalrymple talked about Tony Blair and said that Blair’s biggest problem is he suffers from “delusions of honesty”. Now you could hear the mutters go around the 60 or so people at the room as each of them independently turned to their neighbour and said a variation of “Oh my God, that is the perfect description of Helen Clark – she has delusions of honesty”.

I really do think the description nails it. Clark is, I am sure, absolutely convinced she is an honest person and that she sees no correlation between signing paintings she did not paint, illegally using taxpayer funds on her campaign, lying about Peter Doone etc and her being honest. This is why she so massively over-reacted to the “corruption” tag – she genuinely can not see that hundreds of thousands of NZers could see her or her Government that way.

So thank you to Theodore for his supplying of this wonderful term. It really is a perfect fit.

How much did Labour really overspend?

The Auditor-General had to work out what advertisements by parliamentary parties were legal and authorised as having a parliamentary purpose. Now the way he did this is to use the Electoral Act definition of “election activity” as the test for excluding it from having a parliamentary purpose.

Now what this means is that not only should Labour’s pledge card have been included in Labour’s election return, so should have a further $380,000 of expenditure (assuming the Electoral Commission agrees with the Auditor-General that the expenditure was also electioneering under the Act).

This shows a key flaw in the Electoral Act – there is no mechanism to reliably check that a party has not missed out items on their expenses return, which should be included.

Anyway Labour spent $2,351,788 against their limit of $2,380,000. But then add on the $824,524 of electioneering paid for by the taxpayer, and you find they have exceeded their limit by a massive $796,312. That is a 33.5% over-spend.

Incidentally, before you ask, even if you include National’s GST error (legally it does not count as an electoral expense as it is funded under the Broadcasting Act, not the Electoral Act) and National’s $11,912 of (refunded) taxpayer funds, their total expenditure is a miniscule 0.55% over the limit.

So did the over-spending affect the election result? Was it a stolen election?

One way to look at it is whether the additional $796,312 (worth remembering that Labour’s spending limit and broadcasting allocation were $340,000 higher than National, so in fact they spent $1.12 million more than National) was responsible for that 2% margin. Did it get 22,753 people to vote Labour instead of National? Well if the overspend was targeted that is $35 per vote.

The other way to look at it, is what would have happened if National had broken the rules to the same extent as Labour, and could have spent an extra $800,000. My God that would pay for a hell of a lot of billboards and taxathon pamphlets etc etc.

Either way you look at it, it is near impossible to dismiss the possibility, that the $796,312 of excess advertising materially affected the election result. A 33% overspend is not trivial – it is enormous, and at least half was deliberate and done in contravention of three official warnings prior to the election.

Criticise the Government and there goes your tax free status

If a charity is judged by a seven member panel all appointed by the Government as doing too much “advoacy”, it can now be stripped of its tax free status.

So if an organisation which raises money for drought victims in Africa, criticises the Government for not contributing more, bang goes the tax free status. Plunket wouldn’t dare challenge the Government over it withdrawing funding for Plinketline, if the Government could retaliate by getting its mates to withdraw their charitable status.

On the plus side, if the churches ever try and organise another “Hikoi of Hope” as they did in 1999, then they can all be deregistered also! 🙂

Heh – you read it online first

A NZ First policy I might support

Lindsay Mitchell reports that New Zealand First wants to ban new residents from voting until they have lived in New Zealand for at least three to five years, and calls this stupid as people who by and large pay taxes and make other economic contributions wouldn’t be able to vote while people who don’t can?

I actually think there is considerable merit in restricting the right to vote to citizens, rather than permanent residents (of course grandfathering in all current permanent residents), as is the case in many other countries. The reason isn’t to punish immigrants, but to promote the uptake of citizenship.

I am going to go into this subject in far more detail in the future, but for now suffice to say citizenship is an opportunity to promote those common shared values that make us New Zealanders. As a country we have few legal differences between being a permanent resident and a citizen, hence little incentive for some to become citizens.

Rebutting Rex

An anonymous poster on Public Address called “Rex” has posted a lengthy diatribe on why all the officials are wrong, and why Labour did nothing wrong. The fact it is anonymous speaks for itself (I could understand the need to be anonymous if one was attacking the Gopvt, but not for defending it), but in case anyone takes silence as agreement, here’s a few flaws in Rex’s argument.

“None of the relevant watchdogs (including the Auditor-General, the Solicitor-General, and the Chief Electoral Officer) had, after previous elections, declared such spending “electioneering” – the Auditor-General had never declared the spending unlawful; the Chief Electoral Officer had never counted such spending towards party election campaign limits”

This spin overlooks the obvious reality. That said authorities were totally unaware that the pledge cards had been funded out of taxpayer funds, and that they were not included in their election returns.

I have absolutely no doubt the Chief Electoral Officer would regard the previous pledge cards as an election expense. But the system relies on the political parties including them in their return. Labour never included them, so they were never picked up.

Likewise the Auditor-General does not generally look at every payment made by Parliament. They do a small random sample generally. Hence again the AG had no idea the pledge card had previously been funded by the taxpayer.

Most of Rex’s argument rests on the fact previous pledge cards were deemed legal and not electioneering. This is absolutely not the case. The Chief Electoral Officer and Auditor-General were almost certainly unaware about previous pledge cards. And both gentleman warned Labour (one specifically and one generally) before the election about their spending.
Continue reading »

Pay It Back Suggestions

Both the Dominion Post editorial and Generation XY have handy suggestions for how Labour can fund-raise to pay the money back.

From the Dom Post:

Item 1: An autographed copy of the hitherto unpublished but legendary Why Prime Ministers Paint featuring original works by various artists, all signed by Miss Clark.

Item 2: A guaranteed no-fines high-speed trip, complete with police escort, to the footy with the prime minister. Not for the faint-hearted, but guaranteed to get you to the game on time.

Item 3: Cut-price home renovation with a Thai curry meal thrown in. Contact Phillip Field.

From Gen XY:

10. Helen Clark will defame someone, get sued, settle out of court with taxpayer money and the suer donates the money to the Labour Party who pays the Parliamentary Service.

6. David Benson Pope will run camping trips during school holidays.

3. Helen Clark will auction another painting on Trademe.

1. Labour’s billionaire will donate money to each union who will in turn donate it to the Labour Party who will pay the Parliamentary Service.