Net Neutrality

Auckland Rates

That explains it

I was puzzled by the fact the Commerce Commission set a $28.04 wholesale price for unconstrained UBS, when late last year it set the price at $27.87.

You see the wholesale price is calculated off the average Xtra retail price, and in early 2006 Telecom announced huge drops in Xtra pricing, so hence one would expect a drop in the wholesale price.

But as the Herald reports, while the monthly price dropped, there were reductions in non price terms such as data limits, and hence the overall value of the plan didn’t decrease by much, if at all!

7.6 Mb/s in November

The Commerce Commission has given Ihug and Callplus a determination similiar to the Telstra-Clear one of Dec 2005 (which they dropped after legal action from Telecom for an inferior negotiated package).

No constraint has been placed on download speeds so 7.6 Mb/s will be available in 18 weeks, or in November. You will need to live close to an exchange to get this though.

The wholesale price of $28.04 a month is higher than I expected though, so too early to predict what effect this may have on retail prices.

Test your broadband speed

Massive Current Account Deficit

Good God. The seasonally adjusted current account deficit for the last quarter was $4.1 billion. This is the worst deficit in the 52 years it has been measured.

That brings the annual deficit to $14.5b or 9.3% of GDP.

It’s a hard problem for the Government as most of the borrowing is private not public sector.

World Cup

People have complained about my lack of coverage of the Soccer World Cup.

Well I’m pleased to provide this coverage of the Sweden United team. They even have their own homepage.

WM2006_f.JPG

Actually I should work out what team to support. I could support England, Germany or Australia to win.

More Barker Bumbling

Fresh from making Civil Defence look like Dad’s Army, Rick Barker is just as confusing with Internal Affairs.

DIA in early June said the Karori bird sanctuary grant was turned down primarily because of the loan from WCC.

But last week in the House he said the loan was not an issue at all which affected the decision.

So do you believe the Minister or the Department?

No wonder Marian Hobbs was heard to exclaim “bullshit” when Rick Barker was speaking in the House.

More Barker Bumbling

Fresh from making Civil Defence look like Dad’s Army, Rick Barker is just as confusing with Internal Affairs.

DIA in early June said the Karori bird sanctuary grant was turned down primarily because of the loan from WCC.

But last week in the House he said the loan was not an issue at all which affected the decision.

So do you believe the Minister or the Department?

Anti-americanism in NZ

The Christian Science Monitor has an article on anti-american vitriol in NZ.

It is of course absolutely legitimate to object to the policies of the current US Government. But too many Kiwis really despise the US regardless of who is in Government there – they see it as the most evil country and as a bigger threat to the world than Al Qaeda etc. People on this blog have even commented that the world would be a better place without the US.

For my part I actually agree with Winston Peters when he said something like if the world is to have a sole super-power, he would rather it is the United States than any other country.

1,059 new police now needed

The major policy concession NZ First got from Labour was the pledge for 1,000 more police.

However current numbers are actually 59 below last June.

This leaves the Government with just over two years to increase numbers by 1,000. Now one will have natural attrition of perhaps 500 in that time, so in reality the Government has to recruit 1,500 police officers in 24 months.

I’m not sure this can be done. I hope they do, but I think they have left it too late.

Micro-chipping fallout

Sue Bradford (who was in the Wgtn studio with me this morning) did a good job explaining why the four Green MPs voted for National’s amendment. A partial victory is better than a loss. It’s the same principle that you would expect ACT to vote for a cut in tax rates, even if the cuts don’t go as far as they would like.

It is no bad thing that the Greens split on a non-core issue. National MPs also have the ability to split votes. Labour of course do not – you get expelled if you vote against the party without permission.

What is unusual though is to have the party leader in the minority, and quite clearly pissed off with her colleagues. It seems she only found out late yesterday that they were definitely going to vote for the amendment.

Anyway well done to Keith Locke, Sue Bradford, Nandor Tanczos and Sue Kedgley for not letting a difference in approaches between United Future and the Greens get in the way of stopping a measure which less than half of Parliament supported.

Celtic Tiger Lessons

Today’s exchange

Farm Dogs are exempted

Congrats to the Greens who just voted with National, ACT, Maori and United Future to exempt farm dogs from micro-chipping.

The Greens wanted no micro-chipping at all, and had held out for that but sensibly it seems decided getting some dogs exempt was better than none.

Very messy for the Government to lose the vote after piling so much pressure on. In the end only Labour, Progressive plus the Poodle Party voted for it, it seems.

UPDATE: The Greens split votes (rare for a party). Four Greens MPs voted for the farm dog exemption and two against. This means it passed 61:60.

In favour of exempting farm dogs:

National: 48
Green: 4
Maori: 4
United: 3
ACT: 2

Total: 61

Against:

Labour: 50
Progressive: 1
Poodles: 7
Green: 2

Total: 60

DPF on TV

For those up at twenty past seven tomorrow morning, I’ll be on Breakfast TV talking about ICANN (one of their meetings starts this weekend).

It may appeal to more than the usual tech audience as I’ll specifically be talking about ICANN turning down the .xxx domain and how it can (really) be traced back to Karl Rove!

Some very interesting stuff has emerged from Freedom of Information requests in the US.

Free speech at home

While we are complaining about free speech restrictions in Singapore, we should also be concerned about it back home.

The editor of New Zealand Asia and Capital Chinese News turned up to the Foreign Minister’s office to photograph (not interview, merely photograph) our beloved Foreign Minister meeting the Chinese assistant foreign minister.

The photographer had been granted permission to attend by the Minister’s press secretary.

However once there the Chinese Embassy staff objected to the photographer, because he “had published critical articles about China”.

So what did the Foreign Minister’s staff do? Did they say “I’m sorry but we have free press in New Zealand, and he has been accredited to take a photo”.

No they evicted Mr Wang from the building. Absolutely shameful behaviour.

Be worried, be very worried

If we are struck with a major disaster, the person in charge will be the Civil Defence Minister. He is the person whom we will rely on to oversee the recovery.

Now bearing that in mind, and go read John Armstrong’s column on how well Rick Barker is handling the portfolio.

If it has seemed in recent weeks as if Civil Defence is auditioning for some modern-day version of Dad’s Army, there is now a simple explanation – the ministry’s officials may merely be following the orders of their minister.

SOE Boards

The Herald reports on a survey of SOE Directors, saying too many of appointments are politically influenced and too heavily weighted towards political correctness.

This is no surprise. The name Helengrad came into play as Labour demonstrated a ruthless approach to dissent from Year One. Anyone who criticised the Government in one area of work, would be ineligible for appointment to a board no matter how qualified.

It is natural for a Government to prefer to appoint people it knows and trusts. But that should not rule out appointing good competent people regardless of their politics.

The full results of the survey are here. The nine SOEs covered represent 98% of Govt equity in SOEs. One excellent suggestion, supported by two thirds of directors, was that non voting stock in SOEs be made available to the public, so that the discipline of sharemarket scrutiny could enhance the accountability for business and financial performance.

Letter to Helen

The Leader of the Opposition in Singapore has written a letter to Helen Clark over her neglecting to mention freedom of speech issues to the PM of Singapore. He reminds us that Singapore ranks 140 out of 16 for press freedom.

I’m fairly moderate when it comes to how human rights issues should be raised. I’m not one of those who thinks you should refuse to trade with any country with imperfect human rights as that would leave a small trading bloc of New Zealand and Sweden probably. I don’t even believe one has to use megaphone diplomacy (even though sometimes you must) and rebuke other leaders in public.

But when you have private one on one sessions PM to PM, that is the time you raise them. It doesn’t have to be confrontational (the diplomats will be pre-warned) and can be something along the lines of:

“Many people in New Zealand react with concern when they read a leader of a political party faces prosecution merely for delivering a speech, and hope that you will be mindful of the need to balance your laws with your commitment to freedom of speech”

It just reminds the other head of government that people are watching how they proceed.

And in case people think I gave National an easy pass on foreign affairs when they were in Government, someone should ask a certain former foreign minister how welcome my remits calling for the National Government to recognise Taiwan and withdraw from UNESCO were!! He even devoted one of his conference speeches to reasons why my remit should be voted down!!

Immigration Discrimination

Sigh – the Human Rights Commission is opposing some of the proposed changes to immigration law, claiming one should not discriminate on the grounds of health.

They miss the point that in deciding who gets to be a New Zealander, we should and must discriminate. This is not a random lottery – we want the best and brightest. We discriminate on age (does anyone want to argue for allowing 95 year olds to move here), we discriminate on education (we need skilled and semi-skilled migrants, not labourers) and we of course should discriminate on health (we want healthy migrants who will be able to work, pay taxes etc).

We also discriminate on things such as criminal record and wealth etc.

The HRC also says airlines should not be fined if they fail to stop people entering the country on false documents as allegedly this would undermine our commitment to protect asylum seekers.

They again miss the point that we have no obligation or commitment to any asylum seeker until they are on NZ territory.

Mallard on Finance Minister

As others have reported Trevor Mallard was explicit on Agenda on Saturday that he wants to replace Michael Cullen as Finance Minister.

No Mallard is a smart operator generally and did say that he doesn’t expect it to until next term or even the one after. However despite that qualifier, I think he will find it was most unwise to say what he said.

The reason it was a silly thing to confirm, is because basically it was off message. It means that the media do more stories speculating on when Cullen will retire, rather than what positive plans Labour has for the future. It’s the main thing people remember from his interview.

The Twins

The death of the Mangere Twins is tragic, with one suffering head injuries and another a broken thighbone. I’ve avoided blogging on the issue to date, awaiting some facts to be revealed before commenting.

But this has not stopped Labour’s Tony Milne. He posted this morning that NZ’s high level of violent child deaths is linked to Section 59. He explicitly rejects “appropriate smacking” and links this also to the violent murder of children, saying “there is no middle path”.

But it gets even better. In the comments on his post Aaron Bhatnagar points out that it is nonsense to say a law against smacking will stop children being killed when laws against murder and abuse are not deterring it. Aaron points to the prevalence of drugs, alcohol and lack of parenting responsibility, rather than “smacking”.

Tony hits back claiming the lowering of moral standards which leads to children being murdered is:

– having a large gap between the rich and poor
– illegal wars where over 30,000 innocent people are killed
– people puting accumulation of individual capital ahead of community responsibility
– current generations to rape and shit in our environment
– tax no longer used used for the common good

And he sums up by saying “The problem is the conservative worldview has become too dominant”

So hey lets not have the coroners reports or a police investigation. Tony has worked out who to blame – George Bush for the war on Iraq and National supporters for their “conservative worldview”

Silly old me thought that maybe the individuals were bashed the twins up might be to blame. But no it’s all those people who voted National!!

UPDATE: Family First (PR not online yet) point out that when it comes to child abuse the major associated factors are domestic abuse, poverty, stress and substance abuse – not smacking! They also point out research shows that abuse is twice as likely in single parent families over two parent families.

FF also pont out that of the five countries with the lowest UNICEF child abuse stats, three allow smacking.

UPDATE2: Tony has responded.

Reasons galore for Helen

Fascinating to see all the different reasons the PM has trotted out for not raising the issue of the Opposition Leader in Singapore being prosecuted for speaking without a licence:

– No-one asked me to say anything

– she had not been advised to do so by foreign affairs officials

– free speech doesn’t meet the threshold for human rights issues

– Singapore is entitled to have its own laws upheld

I tend to view free speech as the most important human right. It is only in the absence of free speech do governments get away with further infringements such as arbitrary arrest, torture, political prisoners, fake elections etc.

75% majority

I think people are getting overly excited about the significance of the 33 to 32 IWC vote advocating an end to the whaling moratorium.

On the assumption none of the 32 anti whaling nations will change their votes, Japan and Norway need to gether 96 votes in favour!! Yes they need to triple their number of supporters to get a 75% majority.

I’m not sure even Japan’s foreign aid budget will stretch to signing up another 64 countries!