Further to the mindless industrial action by the PPTA

They have acknowledged that high school students in affected schools will each miss 5 days between now and the end of the term. They have also acknowledged that this harms students and families.

They have not looked at more creative options, talked about how to rid the system of poor teachers, or detailed how they will improve outcomes if they received their desired pay increase.

This is their rostering home plan (as well as boycotting work on NCEA changes):

  • Tuesday, June 13: Years 9 and 10
  • Wednesday, June 14: Years 10 and 11
  • Thursday, June 15: Years 12 and 13
  • Monday, June 19: Years 9 and 10
  • Tuesday, June 20: Years 11 and 12
  • Wednesday, June 21: Years 9 and 13
  • Thursday, June 22: Years 10 and 11
  • Monday, June 26: Years 12 and 13
  • Tuesday, June 27: Years 9 and 10
  • Wednesday, June 28: years 11 and 12
  • Thursday, June 29: Years 9 and 13

When the system is this screwed – seek alternatives.

[email protected]

A ridiculous policy

The Herald reports:

New vape retailers would also not be able to operate within 300 metres of a school or marae.

This might not sound like much, but it is because the 300 metres is a radius, not walking distance. A retailer might be 800 metres walking distance away, but only 300 metres geographical distance.

What this policy actually means is that there could be no retailer within 28 hectares around every school and marae in the country. That will cover most of urban New Zealand.

Retail crime up 38% in two months!

Newshub reports:

Foodstuffs’ boss says the spike in retail crime, which has seen brazen offenders assaulting staff members, is “not acceptable” and is calling for change.

Data collected from New World, PAK’nSAVE and Four Square stores, released on Wednesday, found a 38.2 percent increase in retail crime between February and April this year – an average of 37 crimes a day.

Foodstuffs North Island chief executive Chris Quin said store owners have “never seen retail crime at these levels”.

“It’s an extremely concerning trend and it’s unacceptable.”

He said in one case, a repeat offender stole 31 whole eye, scotch and sirloin fillets over several weeks – costing the supermarket almost $3200.

Footage of some of the burglaries shows threats, intimidation and abusive behaviour towards customers and staff.

One crime shows a member of the public punching a staff member in the head. Footage of a second crime shows a man walking into a supermarket with a metal pipe before threatening a staff member with it.

The issue is here a lack of fear of consequences. Many of these thefts are brazen with no attempt to hide their identity.

General Debate 12 June 2023

Ipsos Issues May 2023

Ipsos have released their latest issues monitor. Let’s look first at what the most important issues are (respondents could pick three):

  1. Inflation 63% (+7% from a year ago)
  2. Crime 40% (+14%)
  3. Housing 31% (-6%)
  4. Health 31% (+2%)
  5. Climate change 23% (+5%)

No surprise inflation remains the most important issue, but of significance is 40% of NZers now pick crime as in their top three. This is up 14% from a year ago. This is a real achilles heel for the Government.

The overall performance rating for the Government is at a new low for the Government of 5.0/10. It has been on a steep decline from 7.3/10 since the end of 2020.

They also ask which party is best on the issues, and the current results are:

  1. Inflation National +6% (was +10% a year ago)
  2. Crime National +10% (nc)
  3. Housing National +3% (was +8%)
  4. Health Labour +5% (was +8%)
  5. Climate change Greens +19%

So National is seen as better on the three top issues, Labour on the 4th top and Greens on the 5th top.

They also have an interesting comparison of issue importance with Australia. The stark difference is crime – 40% of NZers have it in top three and only 15% of Australians. I guess Australia doesn’t have a catch and release policy Government!

Nazi hysteria from TVNZ

This is just beyond appalling, and a great example of why media trust keeps falling.

Christopher Luxon was asked a question about immigration settings, and he commented that since 2016 we are no longer replacing ourselves (this means fertility rate has fallen below the 2.1 replacement rate) and joked to the audience that they should have more babies.

It was not a policy, not a direction, not a speech. It was a quip in response to a question on immigration.

And a TVNZ reporter implicitly compares it to Lebensborn while questioning Nicola Willis. Lebensborn was a Nazi eugenics programme aimed at increasing the number of racially pure Aryan babies. It also involved mass kidnapping of children. This is what a reporter for the state broadcaster think is a legitimate comparison.

National to end GE ban

Judith Collins has announced:

A National government will end New Zealand’s ban on gene editing and genetic modification to unlock enormous benefits for climate change, agriculture and health science, National’s Science, Innovation, and Technology spokesperson Judith Collins says.

“New Zealand can be a world leader in reducing agricultural emissions and benefit from other innovations in health, nutrition and the environment with gene technology rules that are fit-for-purpose,” says Ms Collins.

“Gene technology is being used around the world to treat cardiovascular diseases, cancer, and blood disorders. It is also being used to combat climate change and protect the natural environment.

“It has been used in New Zealand laboratories since the 1970s, but restrictive rules, drafted in the 1990s, make research outside the lab all but impossible. This means our scientists must head overseas to conduct further research.

“A National government will make New Zealand’s biotechnology rules fit for purpose so we can benefit from the huge advances in gene technology which will help grow the economy, reduce the cost of living, lift incomes, and afford the public services New Zealanders deserve.

This is great news, and well overdue. The science is long settled that GE is safe. Any Green activist who actually sincerely is concerned about climate change should welcome this. Ag Research have been working on a strain of ryegrass that could reduce methane emissions by 23% from livestock. But they can’t even test it in NZ.

The former PM’s Chief Science Advisor, Sir Peter Gluckman has said:

The science is as settled as it will be… [I]t is safe, there are no significant ecological or health concerns associated with the use of advanced genetic technologies… If we are to remain a biological economy, we will have to have another [national]conversation about it.”

And the current PMCSA, Dame Juliet Gerard has said:

“[O]ur current legal and regulatory frameworks are not fit for purpose… Hypothetically, if CRISPR-Cas [gene editing] were used to cure your grandmother’s cancer, a case could be made that she was a new organism and therefore if she lived, she could not leave containment. These anomalies need addressing.”

The Productivity Commission has also identified our current regulatory settings as a major impediment.

The main aspects of National’s policy is:

  1. End the effective ban on GE and GM technologies in New Zealand
  2. Create a biotech regulator to ensure safe and ethical use of biotechnology
  3. Streamline approvals for trials and use of non-GE/GM biotech

I am very excited by the fact that if we get a change of Government, we may finally get a more balanced approach to GM in New Zealand.

General Debate 11 June 2023

Erick Erickson on Trump’s indictment

Erick Erickson is a leading conservative radio host in the US who voted for and endorsed Trump in 2020. He writes:

I’ve read the indictment, and I’m just smacking my head with how stupid this all is — not the indictment, but Trump’s antics as alleged in the indictment. This was all so avoidable.

Let me give you the highlights.

First, we’re not discussing love letters with the North Korean dictator. According to the indictment, after leaving the White House, President Trump kept plans for invasions of other countries, locations of American spies around the world, classified locations of soldiers, military vulnerabilities of the United States and its allies, classified assessments of nuclear capabilities of various nations, etc. That’s not small ball stuff.

According to the indictment, the National Archives demanded Trump hand over documents. Trump sent them 197 documents. Six months later, a federal grand jury demanded Trump hand over every other classified document he had. Trump sent the grand jury 38 more documents. When the FBI raided Mar-a-Lago, they found another 102 classified documents. In other words, Trump withheld classified documents from the federal grand jury.

More damning, the indictment alleges Trump ordered his valet to move classified documents to Trump’s residence so that Trump’s own lawyers could not find them. And then Trump’s own lawyer says Trump asked him to hide documents from the FBI.

Trump’s own lawyer admits that!

The indictment also alleges, with photographic evidence, that Trump stored documents on a stage in the ballroom at Mar-a-Lago and that some boxes fell over revealing highly classified information.

Keep in mind that a Chinese spy tried to steal intelligence from Mar-a-Lago in 2019.

All he had to do was hand over all the documents. But he lacked impulse control. It is all so, so stupid. We can “but Hillary” and “but Biden” all we want, but none of them were caught on audio tape admitting to showing people classified documents, and, to our knowledge, none of them ordered a valet to hide documents from their own lawyer, let alone asked their lawyer to hide documents from the FBI.

Boxes and boxes of top secret documents just sitting in the ballroom which hundreds and hundreds of people pass through.

Has Wood blown it for Labour?

John MacDonald writes:

Labour is toast. Who’s saying that, do you think? And do I agree with them? I’ll tell you shortly. …

I thought at the start of the year that Chris Hipkins was looking promising to take out the election. But he has just been let down time-and-time-again by his ministers. And he will be fuming over this latest stuff with Michael Wood.

I saw him on TV last night saying how, like the rest of us, he just can’t understand how the airport shares thing dragged on for so long.

I’ve heard many people say over the last few days that the Michael Wood thing and the Jan Tinetti issues are very Wellington – or “beltway” if we want to use the American term.

But I think Hooton is right. And even if stuff is beltway and not necessarily having an impact on our daily lives, you do always get to the point where, if there are enough of them, it is the last cab off the rank that breaks the camel’s back.

And I think the Transport Minister is that last cab off the rank. And I think he has blown it for Labour.

The issues are beltway, but the Wood one has cut through because Wood has become a laughing stock for being unable to sell shares in 30 months despite 12 reminders. It is a level of incompetence that has made him a punchline.

Only 90% short with two years to go

In 2017 the Government announced they would transition the entire Government vehicle fleet to be emissions free by 2025, which is now only 18 months away.

After three quarters of the eight year timeframe, you might think they’d be at somewhere between 50% and 75%. Instead they are at 10.2%.

This Government doesn’t just narrowly miss targets. They have a worse accuracy rate than stormtroopers against Jedi!

General Debate 10 June 2023

Radio NZ pushing Russian propaganda

This is quite amazing. Someone (I presume it is one person) at Radio NZ has been taking news stories from Reuters about the Ukraine conflict and editing them so they more closely reflect the Kremlin line that Ukraine had a coup in 2014 and is run by neo-nazis etc.

There are huge questions here about Radio NZ’s editorial processes. How could one person make these changes without approval, and how did they get away with it without being detected? It has only come to light thanks to people on Twitter.

What has happened would be embarrassing for any media outlet, let alone a state owned public broadcaster.

Radio New Zealand need to very quickly investigate this, and be transparent on what happened. An independent investigation might even be warranted.

PPTA continue to grind students and families into the ground in their own self-interest.

Unless you live in the proverbial cave you know that education in NZ is in deep trouble.

  • Nearly 10,000 students not enrolled anywhere.
  • Just over 50% of those students who are enrolled are regularly attending. 38% of Maori students.
  • 24% of Maori leaving school without even Level 1 NCEA.
  • Huge ethnic and socio-economic disparities.
  • Massive achievement spreads; e.g. UE for leavers from a high of 97% to lows where one quarter of schools are seeing their students achieve UE at a rate less than 20%.
  • A “curriculum” refresh that is already a disaster and included a bizarre sexuality curriculum intended to be imposed into every subject area and deeply intrusive to families.
  • Literacy testing for new Math and Literacy NCEA credits show high levels of failure that if implemented on time (i.e. 2024) would have seen 50% of students fail Level 1 NCEA (90% of decile 1 students).
  • A massively overblown Ministry of Education (2,700 to 4,200 bureaucrats over the last four years) that is not fit for purpose in any way and is increasingly losing the confidence of the sector.
  • A Minister who is at least in as much disarray as the sector she has responsibility for.

Labour’s solution? Bricks and mortar – 4 news schools and 300 new classrooms – when students are families are running for the hills due to the quality of teaching and learning in many of our schools.

The PPTA response? The ship is going down so lets grab all we can while we can and the kids can get stuffed (who cares about their qualifications – it is not like they are already hamstrung by the government’s covid response).

“The Post Primary Teachers Association (PPTA) says its members voted overwhelmingly against the ministry’s offer [because the executive told them to] of three pay rises over two years plus a $4500 payment.

“Members have given national executive and the negotiating teams a clear mandate to seek a better offer that meets the pressing needs of secondary education and the secondary teaching profession,” PPTA Te Wehengarua acting president Chris Abercrombie said in a statement.

Primary teachers settled their ongoing contract dispute this week, but the union for secondary teachers had been recommending its members reject their offer.

The offer PPTA members rejected was almost identical to what primary school teachers belonging to the Educational Institute accepted.

Union members also voted to continue industrial action.

For the next three weeks – the rest of Term 2 – PPTA members will not teach two year levels each day from Monday to Thursday, nor attend meetings or respond to emails outside regular school hours.”

None of this will solve the qualitative and quantitative teacher shortage as the PPTA executive’s moaning and actions make the sector far less desirable for aspirational and well qualified young people.

Families are looking for high quality alternatives where teachers very high quality and are there everyday, the curriculum is high quality, there is flexibility befitting education in 2023, the families are highly valued and the children achieve.

I no longer am involved but Mt Hobson Academy Connected is a good option wherever you are in New Zealand. None of the teachers are union members and they are NEVER on strike – i.e. they put the children first – and the staff is of the highest quality and the curriculum is first class.

[email protected]

Trump indicted on federal charges

Donald Trump has been indicted on seven charges relating to classified documents.

I blogged that the charges in the Manhattan case were weak and even dubious.

This case is very different. There is a huge amount of evidence in this case, and the consequences of a conviction are more serious also.

This case will not be about Trump having had classified documents he wasn’t meant to have retained, as has happened with a number of other people including Pence and Biden. It will be about what he did after he was asked to return then. It will be about lies and perjury and obstruction of justice. There may be evidence from his own lawyers that Trump lied to them or instructed them to lie.

If Trump had returned all the documents when asked, the public probably wouldn’t even know there had ever been an issue. It is about him lying to the FBI and the Government. If convicted, it will be because he is petulant.

Now the Government won’t even tell us basic health stats

Radio NZ reports:

Publicly available health data on wait times for emergency departments, operations and cancer treatment are now six months out of date, since Te Whatu Ora was forced to pull inaccurate figures from its website.

That has caused disquiet among some clinicians and patient groups about what they say is the lack of transparency.

Association of Salaried Medical Specialists head Sarah Dalton said health data mattered because it underpinned core decisions about funding priorities and treatment for patients.

“There’s not clearly communicated ‘here we are, there’s our destination, here’s how we’re going to get there’, which is really critical, whether it’s emergency wait times, first specialist appointments, planned care, bed block, ramping – but also vacancy rates, which absolutely feed into those things.”

Before the Govt’s health reforms, this data was published regularly and reliably. Now we have no data to measure how well the health system is performing.

As an example on 28 March I asked Health NZ for some basic data on health outcomes. On 28 April they extended the request and it is now the 9th of June and still no data for the majority of my request.

Having timely and accurate data on government performance is critical for being able to make informed judgments. We deserve better.

General Debate 09 June 2023

A stand down every 6.5 weeks

The Herald reports:

The Labour Party has endured a challenging six months since Chris Hipkins took over as Prime Minister.

NZ Herald deputy political editor and host of the On The Tiles podcast, Thomas Coughlan tells The Front Page that Hipkins has now stood down a minister every six and half weeks since he took office.

An astonishing fact. The good news is that at this rate, the entire Cabinet could be gone in 18 months!

Wood lied to media over his shareholding

Jonathan Milne at Newsroom writes:

What pecuniary interests, I asked the minister, did he have beyond those disclosed in the 2021 register of interests?

“None,” Michael Wood replied, unequivocally.

That was July 5, two years ago. I’d approached him for an explanation, after registrar Sir Maarten Wevers formally rapped him over the knuckles for filing his returns late. …

And now Hipkins has learned that Wood expressly denied having any undisclosed pecuniary interests, in an emailed statement to Newsroom.

National MP Paul Goldsmith says his email to Newsroom came at a time that the Cabinet Office had already contacted Wood five times about whether he had sold his shares in Auckland Airport, part of its lengthy and unsuccessful attempt to get him to follow the rules.

He calls Wood’s response to Newsroom “demonstrably false”.

“He knew he owned the shares, and he knew they represented a conflict of interest. His answer rested on the fig leaf that he thought because the shares were held in a trust they didn’t have to be declared.”

Surely this is enough to get him sacked?

Soper says Wood should go

Barry Soper writes:

An embarrassed Chris Hipkins says it’s unacceptable for the minister to hold on to the shares for so long and after so many requests to rid himself of them. But it seems unacceptability is acceptable in this Government’s books.

It also seems, at least at the moment, for the Minister in his transport role to turn down a case by a North Shore airport to get a more formal status. Of course it would work in competition to the super city’s airport, and for a share-holding minister to turn down an application by competitors is what is really unacceptable.

There should be no coming back for Wood; he’s transgressed in one of the worse ways a minister can.

It’s incredible to think he follows a line of ministers who’ve crossed the line since Hipkins took over from Jacinda Ardern.

Stuart Nash is still under investigation; there’s Jan Tinetti, who faces the privileges committee on Thursday for either being dumb, or obstinate or arrogant by not correcting a statement she made to Parliament when she had plenty of opportunity to do so; and there’s Kiri Allan who’s faced a number of transgressions.

It’s almost quicker to list the Ministers not caught up in a scandal!

Ministers in other governments over the years have been given the boot for less. But it seems Hipkins, the sous chef in Ardern’s kitchen Cabinet, is as weak as her when it comes to Cabinet discipline.

If you don’t get sacked for ignoring the Cabinet Office 12 times, then what do you have to do to get sacked? Do it 13 times? 14 times?

General Debate 08 June 2023

Vaping vs Smoking

This chart nicely shows the huge impact allowing vaping has had on smoking rates in NZ, especially compared to Australia. We should celebrate such huge drops, especially with younger NZers.

There is no doubt that the best health outcome is if someone never vapes or smokes. But vaping is far less harmful than smoking, and if vaping gets people away from tobacco, then that is good for public health.

The Government is failing to educate people on the relative harm from smoking and vaping. Public Health England found the difference was massive – 95% less harmful. This is because is is the tar that kills you but the nicotine that is addictive and gives you the hit.

A poll Curia did in April 2023 for British American Tobacco NZ asked 1,000 people if they thought vaping was more harmful, less harmful or just as harmful as smoking.

Only one in five or 20% correctly said less harmful. 53% thought vaping was just as harmful and 16% even thought vaping is more harmful than smoking.

Even with current smokers, there is widespread misinformation. Only 30% of current smokers realise vaping is less harmful with 43% thinking it is just as harmful and 13% more harmful.

Think how many lives could be saved just by ensuring there is less misinformation on vaping vs smoking.

Wood vs Key share scandal compared

The Herald reports:

The Prime Minister wasted no time in standing down Michael Wood as Transport Minister yesterday after the Herald revealed he owned $13,000 of Auckland Airport shares that he was told to sell “half a dozen times” since 2020.

The Herald can also reveal Wood declined North Shore Aerodrome’s application for airport authority status while he owned shares in Auckland Airport, a potential competitor.

The aerodrome is in the Whangaparāoa electorate and its MP, National’s Mark Mitchell, said the situation appeared “dodgy” and that Wood’s actions were a sackable offence.

Chris Hipkins described Wood’s ownership of the stock while he was regulating the aviation industry as “not acceptable”.

This revelation changes things for Wood. As a shareholder in Auckland Airport, he should have recused himself from making a decision on North Shore Aerodrome’s application for airport authority status.

This revelation changes things from a potential conflict of interest to actually having made a Ministerial decision where he had a financial interest in the outcome.

Now again I would say I don’t think that was his motivation. $13,000 of shares to someone on $250,000 a year is not a lot of money. But when John Key had some shares in Tranzrail, Labour insisted he was acting corruptly and was motivated by his shareholding, even though they represented a minuscule amount of his holdings.

It is worth comparing the two situations of Key in 2003 and Wood in 2023, so I have done a table.

MPKeyWood
   
CompanyTranzrailAuckland Airport
Shares value$100,000 approx$13,000
Est % of wealth0.2%2%+
Owned byFamily trust not managed by KeyWood directly
Breached standing ordersNoYes
Breached Cabinet ManualNoYes
Alleged conflicted actionAsked questions in ParliamentDeclined authority status to a competitor
RoleAssociate Opposition Transport spokespersonMinister of Transport
Sales of sharesDone within 12 months of being an MP for a loss of over $100,000Not done despite six twelve reminders from Cabinet office over 2.5 years

Now with the Key situation, Labour insisted this was an egregious breach of standards. By their own rhetoric, what Wood does is clearly much worse.

Also Hipkins has just revealed that the Cabinet Office asked Wood not six times, but 12 times if had sold the shares. This means surely he can’t continue as a Minister?

On School Lunches

You would think someone whose first degree is Economics would be able to manage loan repayments. Alas, no. I recently refinanced a mortgage and, in my enthusiasm, over-paid initial amounts. I managed to leave myself with $33 per day disposable income for 16 days. I am four days in, $6 down and thinking of dropping two cats off at the park. I am hoping there is no insurance AP lurking and am barely driving for fear of a fender bender (or having to fill the tank). I know I could find some temporary funds (I don’t have a credit card) and clearly I can normally feed myself and helped provide for three kids growing up. But it is an interesting exercise and it has reminded me of my childhood and so I have included a second chapter of the wee memoirish – novel thing I have written. There is a kicker at the end re current society.

Metonym for my Parents: The food they cooked

My parents loved me. They were pretty basic and strong supporters of the nation’s cigarette and alcohol industries. They had grown up in incredibly tough times. Times completely inconceivable in the 21st century. It is enough to say that my mother was born into a family in which she eventually had 11 siblings. She was born in 1934 during the Great Depression into a State House in a poor suburb (Aramoho) in a poor town (Wanganui). World War 2 followed. The man that later adopted me as his own left school before 14 and could never really explain much of his past.

However, they had character and, as I said, they loved me. They smoked liked chimneys and drank like fish. They were sometimes angry and stressed but they were never violent and supported me as best they knew how. Which must have been hard as I never really slowed down – or shut up. They tried so hard to shape someone well but being a parent in the generationally split 1970s and 80s was not easy. Neither was I. I must add that they both often worked two or three jobs to make ends meet and it is now deeply appreciated. They refused the dole when unemployed.

The food they cooked is highly symbolic of the time. In hindsight it seemed terrible – but it got us through. A mark of the times for the lower class in New Zealand. What child would eat lambs fry today? Bubble and squeak anyone?

The first note was the attitude. You ate what was put in front of you and, at times, learned not to gag. In fact, the most common saying was not “grace” but my father saying that you will “sit up, shut up, eat up and like it.” This was followed by discussions about starving children in Africa and the need to chew each mouthful, even milk, forty times. No even kidding. A friend of mine was chided about leaving food on his plate and the plight of the starving children in Biafra. He turned to his mother and glared, held up the plate and said, “Well send this bloody muck to them then.” It did not turn out well for him.

My mother’s lambs-fry you could not help to chew forty times – it could not be swallowed otherwise. In hindsight maybe that was the way it was cooked which was until there was less moisture in the product than on any single grain of sand in the Sahara. The vegetables alongside were boiled to the hilt. My mother also had a knack with bacon. She could turn a rich piece of this meat into a crumbling autumn leaf with the taste of charcoal. One of her specialties therefore was lambs fry and bacon. Something special indeed. Often, while trying to chew, your eyes watered involuntarily, and you gulped down milk to try and begin the digestion process. I had pure gratitude – no doubt.

A range of beans were also “good for you”. This included a never to be forgotten jar of beans that my mother had soaked in salt water for two weeks – for no good reason. Preventing these coming back up rapidly involved deep breathes and, again, tears rolling down the face. This mix was only done once as my mother did have a sympathetic bone.

Broad beans were the ongoing worst. My mother was somehow convinced of their inherent and necessary goodness and tried all manner of methods to ensure they were in our diet. We protested, so she hid them in her already disgraceful mashed potatoes. Bangers and mash with the most disgusting after taste that no quantity of tomato sauce could alleviate. Her mashed potatoes had more lumps than the fields they came from and hiding broad beans in the mix seemed fool-proof – except for perceptive nature of a child’s palate. This also only happened once, again, on the basis of justice.

I cannot even bring myself to write a paragraph on her steak and kidney pie.

My father’s food contribution was not negligible either. He could deep fry almost anything that he deemed edible (and many things I did not). Going back to the time I first met my beautiful bride I was working for my father. His job was delivering dairy products. The scheme he devised to improve the family’s finances (and we needed it) was to bring home all of the drinks and yogurt that had passed their due date. “Just scrape the mold off!”; he would say.

Does this have any impact? Yes – but good things do not need to come from what the world would call a perfect platform – and the next two generations have stood on their shoulders.

My children were not immune from the gourmet skills of my parents either. They are unlikely to ever forget the time that my mother chose to extend her repertoire by purchasing a well-constructed McCain’s pizza from the supermarket. She then cooked it to the same level of moisture as was her way with lamb’s fry. This was to the extent that the base was a deep black and all topping tasted and looked like indistinct coloured cardboard. The children, maybe being brought up in more affluent and varied times, flatly refused to eat it and caused a month-long family feud as my mother took deep offense at the actions of the “spoilt brats”. My bride and I had been smarter as when my mother looked the other way, we threw our pizza out of the window and smacked out lips as if deeply satisfied.

Ray and Judy have long since passed.

The Kicker!

If we are going to feed children in NZ schools it must have three features:

  • The effects need to be monitored with regards to attendance and achievement.
  • The time period much be limited. We should never have go to this situation in a rich nation in 2023.
  • It must be deeply understood and communicated daily to students, families and staff that “We are feeding you today – so that you can get a good education and then feed, clothe and house your own children.


Anything less than that is simply not acceptable. If I taken all that my parents did for me – and not found my own way – it would have been a disgrace.

Independent Electoral Panel delivers wishlist for the left

It is perhaps no surprise that a panel hand picked by Labour and Greens has delivered a report recommending massive electoral changes that would benefit them.

I wanted to give the panel some benefit of the doubt, and did a submission myself, asking to be heard. I never was a asked to appear, which is surprising for someone who has written extensively on electoral issues for over 20 years.

Here are their key recommendations:

  • Entrench Treaty principles in the Electoral Act
  • Lower threshold to 3.5%
  • Abolish electorate seat threshold
  • Fix ratio of electorate: list seats to be 60:40 so Parliament size increases as number of electorates grows
  • Referendum on a four year term
  • No fixed election date
  • Abolish Waka-jumping law
  • Lower voting age to 16
  • Allow all prisoners the vote
  • Allow Maori to change rolls up to any including on election day
  • Ban donations of over $30,000 and increase taxpayer funding of parties to around $6 million per electoral cycle
  • Ban donations from companies and unions

Pretty much every cause championed by the left has been recommended. In theory I should welcome this report because it would be amazing for the Taxpayers’ Union. If donations over $30,000 are banned, then we would become like the United States (where donations are capped at $2,300) with PACs becoming mega-powerful and bundlers turning up everywhere. It amazes me that people who claim to be worried about the influence of money in politics always recommend a US style donation system.

The proposed changes to the threshold are interesting to look at, based on what would have happened in the past if they had been in place then.

  • 1996: Christian Coalition would have gained five seats giving potential balance of power to Rev Graham Cahill, now known to be a pedophile as National and NZ First would no longer have a majority
  • 1999: no change
  • 2002: Anderton’s Party doesn’t get a 2nd MP. Doesn’t impact overall outcome
  • 2005: United loses two List MPs and ACT one List MP.
  • 2008: NZ First remain in Parliament with five MPs. National and Act would no longer have a majority
  • 2011: no change
  • 2014: Colin Craig would hold balance of power with five MPs, Māori Party lose a List MP
  • 2017: no change
  • 2020: Māori Party lose a List MP

So what the panel recommends would have seen Rev Capill and Colin Craig both holding the balance of power.