Pope Benedict on Islam

A fascinating interview between Hugh Hewitt and Father Joseph Fessio, a friend of Pope Benedict’s.

Many people hope that Islam can bring itself into the 21st century with something akin to the Catholic Reformation. However the Pope himself pointed out at a discussion on the topic that it is virtually impossible as the Koran is seen as God’s word directly, and can not be adapted on re-intrepreted. The bible however is not seen as the word of just God, but the word of his human followers with him.

The other issue is that Islam has no “official interpreter” such as the Pope is with the Catholic Church. Worth reading the whole interview.

Hat Tip: Sir Humphrey’s

UK Liberal Leader resigns

The fate of the Liberal Democrat Leader, Charles Kennedy, has been forefront in the media of late.

There had long been rumours about his drinking, to the point that back in 2002 BBC’s Jeremy Paxman actually asked him if he liked to have a tipple or two by himself. This created such a fuss that the BBC was forced to apologise. Somewhat hypocritically politicans demanded this as it was fairly well known he had a problem.

Then a few days ago ITV were about to do a story on his drinking. Their chief political reporter being his former press secretary. Ouch. To stop their exclusive he revealed called a press conference and revealed that he “had” been an alcoholic for 18 months but the problem was “essentially resolved” as he had been dry for the last two months.

Commentators expressed some disbelief that he had only had a drinking problem for 18 months, and that being dry for eight weeks means you are better. As always being less than fully honest comes back and bites you.

After two days of vowing to stay on as Leadewr, even after 25 of his MPs signed a no confidence motion, the inevitable has happened and today he has resigned.

Whale Oil’s Dad and Dubya

A while back Whale Oil mentioned that his father had disccussed blogs with George W Bush over breakfast. A few silly people laughted and doubted this statement.

Whale Oil has posted a photo of his Dad with Dubya, for the doubters – I was never one of them incidentially!

Death List

Tumeke doesn’t hold back with his death list of people he wants to die in 2006. Seems almost anyone Tim disapproves of is a Nazi, but I did have to laugh at the depiction of Kurt Waldheim as a “Nazi Nazi”.

It does remind me of a certain former National Research Unit staffer whom in the mid 1990s just as the Internet was catching on, discovered the Internet Death Clock page and got it to calculate the day on which Winston Peters was scheduled to die – based on his age, ethnicity, gender, smoking habit etc. It was some 15 years in the future.

Said staffer then put up a big A3 sign on his wall saying “Winston due to die in 5,427 days” and he updated it every morning with a fresh sign counting it down. True dedication. Sadly it had to come down after NZ First chose to go into coalition with National 🙂

Nicknames

Bastard Operator From Hell

Silence from the Govt on Sharon

It took Winston Peters several days to comment on the Iranian President’s call for the destruction of Israel, and now again both Peters and Clark are silent on the incapacitation of the Israeli PM. Fran O’Sullivan comments on this in today’s column.

Phil Goff was however quick off the mark to pay respects to Yasser Arafat.

Secretary-General Helen Clark

While I think it is unlikely, if Helen Clark does emerge as a credible contender for UN Secretary-General, she should be backed with bi-partisan support. Just as Mike Moore, Don McKinnon and Russell Marshall were for their roles with international organisations.

I think however that Sue Kedgley is overly optimistic about Clark’s chances, despite Sue of course being the former girlfriend of Kofi Annan!

Clark would struggle with not just a US veto, but also China and France also. She could well get support from Tony Blair however. The US would not be supportive for the obvious reasons – mind you though they could potentially be persuaded she was better than the rest of the options, so not intractable.

China is highly unlikely to support a non-Asian candidate as Asia has not had a Secretary-General since the 1970s. If no Asian candidate comes close, then Clark could pick up their support as being at least from the region geographically, if not ethnically.

France is highly unlikely to support a female candidate. No easy way around that.

Never again

A nice story about Holocaust survivor Jack Efrat, who is 87 and living in Mission Bay. It is worth remembering that while the German state killed many Jews and others, there were many individual Germans who risked their own lives to extend a hand to those trying to survive.

Breath Testing

As long as the request is in good faith, I think it is a bit short sighted for the Police to refuse to voluntarily breath test people who want to check they are under the legal limit. I mean it is saying we won’t check you when you ask sitting in the bar, but will the moment you get behind the wheel.

Having said that, I do agree that having breath-testing machines in bars has mixed results. You certainly do get competitions to score the highest – but admittedly only amongst those not driving. So the drivers stay under the limit, but the passengers get more drunk.

Many years ago myself and one other attended the Young Liberals annual convention in Hobart, Tasmania. And this lasts seven days with a major social event every night. The final night was a ball, with free alcohol and the venue had a breath-testing machine. There was a certain amount of competion between the Aussies and us two Kiwis for the high score. The end result was that the Kiwis won (of course) but then later that night were ahem affected enough that upon running into the captain and crew of a US nuclear sub in a nightclub, extended an offer on behalf of the NZ Government to come and visit us for a goodwill tour. We also thought we should let the Government know what we had done so thought it was a good idea to fax Don McKinnon that night to let him know of the invite. I understand that his MFAT officials spent a furious 24 hours talking to the Pentagon to try and check that the submarine wouldn’t in fact be turning up 🙂

MPs declarations

I tend to agree with Richard Worth that the Register of MPs pecuniary interests is going somewhat overboard by insisting that any airline upgrades have to included in their declaration.

Decisions on who gets upgraded on a flight are made at a relatively junior level, and by different people each time, I understand. Plus I don’t really see an MP getting an upgrade as anything out of the ordinary – thousands of passengers get them – I have on several occassions. The register should be for stuff where someone has gopne out of their way to give a gift to an MP – in their role as an MP. Such as giving them free season tickets to the rugby, or working on their house for $1 an hour.

The Fitzsimons Eco Friendly Defoliation Kit

Ariel Sharon

It is rather ironic that the death of Yasser Arafat allowed the peace process to advance significantly, while the incapacity of Ariel Sharon looks to set it back equally severely.

In a competition for most tasteless remarks we have Pat Robertson who has suggested Sharon’s stroke is punishment from God for dividing Israel by giving up territory, and our equally mad or bad friend, the President of Iran, who says he is hoping for his death. I’m not sure which of those two I would least like to have nuclear weapons. And to think Robertson once stood for US President.

A very stupid doctor

I thought the Kiwi doctor who thought it was a good idea to take photos of his genitals at work, and e-mail them around was stupid enough.

But in the UK we have a 42 year old doctor struck off for posing online as a teenage girl, to groom actual teenage girls.

His actions are not funny per se. It is how he got caught. He was doing it on a train!! Yes on a presumably crowded train he is logged into chat rooms and talking dirty pretending to be a teenage girl. And by chance the person next to him was a special constable. Duh!

Abortion

The Christchurch School of Medicine that concluded women who had abortions had increased rates of subsequent mental health problems compared with those who had not had abortions has generated a lot of debate.

I am not totally surprised, as I think the whole situation of an unwanted pregnancy, having to decide on whether to have an abortion, and possible guilt afterwards will often lead to mental health issues.

I am unsure, as I have not seen the full study, how comparable the results for those who did not have an abortion are to those who did. If one is comparing married couples who wanted kids to a someone not in a relationship who got pregnant, then it is no surprise if the latter has more mental health issues. However if the two groups were both of women who did not want or plan the pregnancy, then they are considerably more valid. The reputation of the primary author is first class, so I suspect the two groups are reasonably comparable.

I am personally pro-choice, yet am sometimes put off by the extreme elements of the pro-choice movement who seem to regard that one needs to be pro-abortion as well as pro-choice. We saw this at the Aro Valley Candidates meeting where one young woman in the audience lashed out at even the Green candidate for daring to suggest that while she was pro-choice, it would be better to also have programmes to reduce the number of abortions through education etc. Anything other than a total commitment to abortion on demand without question was seen as unacceptable.

Likewise it is rather alarming that four medical journals rejected the article before it was published in the Journal of Child Psychiatry and Psychology. Just as I oppose science taking a back seat to religion in the Intelligent Design debate, it is also regrettable if it takes a back seat to politics in the abortion debate.

The legal situation is interesting. The practice in NZ for many years has been effectively abortion on demand. The law however says it shall only be granted if it will risk the woman’s physical or mental health. Now mental health has been interpretated very liberally, so that merely saying one would be an unwilling mother is taken as grounds for risk to mental health.

Now this study could be used to show that proceeding with an abortion will generally be more damaging to a woman’s mental health, so then the bar may be lifted in terms of needing to identify specific reasons why their mental health will be affected by not having an abortion. One would need a test case of some sort to go to court.

Personally I favour laws being honest laws. We have had abortion on demand for a couple of decades. The law should reflect the practice, and be amended accordingly. However we should not forget the best outcome is one where the unwanted pregnancy doesn’t occur in the first place.

Christian Peacemakers

The Christian Peacekeepers, who have four activists held hostage in Iraq, have said they want to meet Bush. Why? Bush isn’t holding their members hostage, the terrorists are.

And considering the group have already said they do not want Bush to use force to free their activists, what is there to talk about? Oh unless they want him to give in to the demands of the terrorists?

Hodgson nixes maternity review

It is a great pity that Pete Hodgson has rejected the coroner’s call for a full review of maternity services. As the number of GPs who provide maternity care has dropped from over 1,000 to a mere handful, mothers are losing their ability to choose.

It would be interesting to know the composition of the perinatal and maternity review committee which said no review was needed.

Burn baby burn

Oh dear, oh dear, oh dear.

Jeanette Fitzsimons and her husband started a fire to burn some gorse on New Year’s Eve, despite there being a total fire ban in the district.

A classic case of do what I say, not what I do. Such hypocrisy – one must revere all environmental protections, except those inconvenient to Jeanette personally.

Interesting pre-nuptial

Hey I thought pre-nuptials deal with what you do if you get divorced, but this Florida couple did one which includes:

* He will do backrubs on her three times a week for five minutes each
* she promises to cook breakfast a minimum of three times during the weekdays, and once on the weekends
* he will not wake her up on her ‘off days’
* If she uses the “F” word, she is sentenced one hour of yard work
* He has to pay $5 each time he complained, nagged or made “a fuss about her expenditures …”

What else should one include in a pre-nuptial?

Around the Blogs

Several good posts worth reading.

Rodney Hide highlights we have slipped from 5th to 9th on the Index of Economic Freedom. It’s not that 9th is bad per se, but that the trend is going the wrong way.

Sir Humphrey’s comments favourably on a Russell Brown column (Russell will be washing his hands nows 🙂 about the Keablog/Harrington plagiarism issue. I agree it is a good fair column.

Generation XY has a top ten list of ways celebrities can save the world. No 7 is very cruel yet funny.

The Whig highlights that of the 406 fatal crashes in 2003, only 65 were as a result of speeding with no alcohol involved.

Back in NZ

Microsoft censorship

Body Shop supports Smacking Ban

The Body Shop, after a staff vote, has decided to campaign for Sue Bradford’s bill which will repeal Section 59 and criminalise a parent smacking their child.

Such a pity they didn’t support the far more practical and sensible alternative of amending Section 59 instead.

I see the Public Health Association supports the ban also. Does anyone out there know how much, if any, of PHA funding comes from the Government?

MILF alert

A 30-year-old Nelson mother has won the Miss Kaiteriteri beauty contest.

While I think beauty contests are harmless fun (has been a long time since I’ve actually watched one), I do think it is sad they also had a Miss Junior Kaiteriteri contest for girls aged 12 to 15. It reminds me of those awful images from the US where you have mothers dressing up their eight year olds to win junior beauty contests. Yuck.

Fran’s suggested NY Resolutions

Fran O’Sullivan has proposed some New Year resolutions for seven prominent NZers, including Michael Cullen, Alan Bollard and Theresa Gattung.

I found it fascinating that Fran has effectively come out and expressed significant dis-satisfaction with the current telco regime in terms of broadband speed and access.

You see Gareth Morgan did the same a week or so ago. And both Gareth and Fran are both fairly heavily identified with the free market end of the political spectrum. There seems to be a wide-spread consensus about the need for change. This is a good thing.