Another one bites the dust!

Aaron Bhatnagar is getting too busy with his life outside blogging (yes there is one!) and sadly is retiring from the Blogosphere.

I’ll miss both his national political posts but especially his Auckland City posts. Best way to keep track of all the new up there.

UBS and LLU

Local Loop Unbundling and the Regulated Unbundled Bitstream Service are two very very different things.

Bruce Simpson has spotted that TVNZ last night seemed to totally confuse the two. He gives a summary of the difference.

Not totally surprised that TVNZ got it wrong, as the terms can be confusing. But it is still a pretty major stuff to portray the decision as being equivalent to LLU.

Terror Rewards – Air Miles

Heh satirical humour always goes down well. Today it is The Borowitz Report:

TERROR SUSPECTS TO RECEIVE FREQUENT FLIER MILES
New Program Makes Rendering Rewarding, Condi Says

Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice today acknowledged that the United States often flies terror suspects to foreign countries to be interrogated by means not allowed in the U.S., but said that the government was instituting a new program by which the suspects would receive frequent flier miles for their journeys.

Dom Post on Health Contracts

A new level of apology

Clark has mastered the art of not apologising by saying she regrets if anyone was offended by comments etc. A typical non-apology.

However Hodgson has gone one better. The NZPA headline is “Hodgson apologises over election incident” yet we read in the story “he would not be tendering a personal apology”.

Huh so how is that an apology. Oh I see he said “he was sorry for misjudging Mrs Flannagan’s intentions”.

As anyone of IQ above 50 knows he did not misjudge her intentions. He knew Mrs Flannagan’s intention was to wave a sign up so the media would see it. He grabbed her to stop her doing that, and then made up a nonsense story about how he though she could somehow stretch 15 feet past the Police and media scrum to whack the PM with a piece of paper.

Wouldn’t it be nice just to have one day someone say “I made a mistake. I’m sorry for it, and I don’t intend to do it again”.

$450m for Auckland Rail

The Government has said it is going to spend $450 to $600 million on the Auckland rail tracks it purchased for $89 million.

Now how many people take trains in Auckland? Around just under 9,000 a day which is 0.6% of Aucklanders. If they spend $600 million that will be a spend of $67,000 per passenger. Hmmmn. Think if they spent that much per Aucklander on roads – that would be almost $94 billion on Auckland roads. Even Banksie and Aaron would be happy!

Now some will say that this investment in rail will lead to many more people using the trains. Well yes there may be some increase, but according to an ARC report only 20% of new rail passengers will come from cars, so it will mainly be bus users swapping to trains.

As the AA said in 2001, rail works relatively well in Wellington because 45% of the region work in the CBD. In Auckland it is only 13%.

I’m very unconvinced that $450 to $600 million on rail will help Auckland’s transports woes greatly.

US President asserts authority for warrantless searches

Niagara Falls

My other scenic visit was to Niagara Falls. I had no idea when I got to Barrie that they were anywhere nearby, but when I saw them on a map, I knew I would be kicking myself if didn’t manage to visit them while here.

Like many I just knew Niagara Falls were pretty big, and stupid people go over them in barrels. I didn’t know there are in fact three sets of falls, and that the falls are on the US – Canada boundary. Each side has a city called Niagara Falls – one in Ontario and one in New York.

falls2.JPG

These are the American Falls, viewed from Goat Island. In summer one can get down even closer to the top, but I think they worry in winter people may slip in!

These falls carry around 10% of the almost 2.5 million litres of water a second that flows over the falls.

falls5.JPG

You can take an elevator down to the Cave of the Winds near the base of the American and Bridal Veil Falls. It’s pretty easy to work out these are not the falls you try and ride a barrel down. In fact no-one has ever survived going down these falls.
Continue reading »

More Mary Mapes

For the 1% of readers who still think the CBS Killian memos were not fakes (and also think the world is flat), here’s yet another element to show they are niot only fake, but clumsy fakes.

The fake memos are dated 1972 and 1973 and use Bush’s service number. However the Air Force stopped using them on 1 July 1969, and has used social security numbers since.

Also the forger used FG as a suffix when it was always a prefix.

Hat Tip: Power Line

PM’s driver wins appeal

New press secretaries

Just read today in Molesworth & Featherston that David Lewis is replacing Mike Munro as the PM’s chief press secretary. Both nice guys in a tough job (never judge a press secertary by whom they work for!).

Also should mention that Kevin Taylor from the NZ Herald is jumping the aisle to work for Don Brash. Always enjoyed Kevin’s writing so will miss his writings, but good for National to have another staffer whom the gallery know and respect.

David Cameron

I expected the UK Conservative Party to get a poll bump from the election of David Cameron as leader. Hence I didn’t think it worth blogging a couple of weeks ago polls showing the Conservatives 2% ahead of Labour.

However even the Labour-leaning Sun has said the Conservatives are back in business with the latest poll showing them 9% ahead of Labour.

Even though such a lead will not last, one can not under-estimate its importance. It means people are feeling comfortable about telling a pollster they could vote Tory. After almost 13 years flat-lined at around 30%, they have got up to 40%.

And this poll was done before the latest EU deal which may deliver a huge backlash to Blair and force him out earlier than he wants.

You know it is a bad deal for the UK when Jacques Chirac is praising Tony Blair’s “courage, initiative and responsibility”. This is like having George W Bush praise you for your diplomacy – electoral poison back home.

As the Telegraph points out, Tony Blair’s agreement to give

Replacing Leo as VP

Okay with the sad death of John Spencer, Leo is going to disappear from The West Wing in a few weeks. Now how he will be replaced depends on when his character (presumably) dies. The six main periods of time possible are:

1) Before the election and in time for a new name on the ballots
2) Before the election, but too late for the ballots to be changed
3) After the election, and before the electoral college meets
4) After the electoral college meets and before the Congress the votes
5) After Congress counts the votes, and before Inauguration Day
6) After Inauguration Day

Scenario 1 is simple. It varies a bit state by state but if the death occurs 60 days before the election, then the state party can substitute a name on the ballot.

Scenario 2 is fairly straight forward also. McGarry’s name would remain on the ballots, but any votes cast for him will still be valid for his electors for the Electoral College. The Federal Party will have nominated prior to the election a replacement candidate, and the electors would vote for the replacement candidate. This happened in 1912 with the death of he Vice President James Sherman on October 30th, 1912, a few days before the Presidential election. The GOP selected Nicholas Butler as his replacement. They lost incidentally.

Scenario 3 is more complicated. If the candidate dies after election day, and before the electoral college vote there is no “moral” mandate for the candidate. In 1872 presidential candidate Horace Greeley died after the election on November 29th. His electors split five ways with 42 votes for Senator Thomas Hendricks, 18 for Vice Presidential nominee B. G. Brown, a few votes for two other candidates and five votes for the deceased Horace Greeley. These latter votes were disallowed by Congress. Now as Greeley lost, it was not that significant. As McGarry is a VP, not a presidential, candidate one would assume Santos would ask the electors to vote for a person he chooses. They would however in theory have a free vote.

Scenario 4 which has McGarry die after the electoral college votes is even more murky. I am unsure if Congress can certify a dead candidate. The common sense answer is Congress certifies no Vice-President due to the death of the winning candidate. However a weaselly politician could try and argue that with McGarry dead, he is an invalid candidate and hence the next highest polling VP candidate (the Republican VP candidate) has to be certified by Congress. This could be a great plot line with Santos having a religious right Republican as her VP. Remember in TWW the Republicans control both the House and Senate so could arguably certify it that way.

Scenario 5 is clear. If after certification of the vote McGarry dies, there is a vacancy. It can’t be filled until after Inauguration Day however.

Scenario 6 is the most routine. McGarry dies as the Vice-President. Under Section 2 of the 25th amendment to the US constitution, Santos will nominate a new VP, which requires a majority confirmation from both Houses of Congress.

According to USA Today five episodes have been filmed ahead of what has already showing in the US. With the Xmas break this will last until 19 March. The 8 January show is the one of the Vice-Presidential debate including Spencer. I suspect they will do a tribute to him with that broadcast.

They also report the election result has not yet been filmed, so that makes scenario 1 or 2 more likely. Scenario 4 would be a good plot twist though!

Commerce Commission on Broadband

The Commerce Commission has delivered a final determination and happily it appears relatively unchanged from its earlier draft, despite pending legal action from Telecom.

I blogged in November on the draft determination, and this will be a good step towards faster and cheaper broadband. It won’t take effect until around June 2006 though.

Also it is by no means the silver bullet. It will help, and is a big advance over the status quo, but still a long long way from what most other developed countries have.

It will be interesting to see if Telecom continue with their legal action against the Commission’s determination. No comment so far from them.

UPDATE: InternetNZ PR now on Scoop.

World Freedom

Freedom House has published its annual world freedom report, and as with other years the trend is still going in the right dsirection. They started doing this in 1972.

Every country gets ranked from 1 (most free) to 7 for political freedom and civil liberties. The number of “not free” countries declined from 49 last year to 45 in 2005, with the middle east being a region which has shown improvement.

However worth remembering that only 46% of countries are free – explaining much about the UN! But back in 1975 there were only 40 free countries, and today it is up to 89.

The percentage free in each region is not surprising:

Sub-Saharan Africa 23%
Middle East/North Africa 6%
Asia-Pacific 41%
Americas 68%
Central and Eastern Europe/CIS 48%
Western Europe 96%

The eight countries which have received the lowest possible rankings are Cuba, North Korea, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, Libya, Syria, Sudan and Burma. Tibet and Chechnya are not countries but rank equally badly as territories.

New Zealand of course is one of 50 countries ranked as most free.

Do not wiretap list

A different pick for Politican of the Year

Colin James picks his politician for 2005, and he picks Mike Williams!!

With all respect to Colin, but his budget stuff-up alone should disqualify him. Labour may have won by 8% or more if he hadn’t helped over-hype the budget. And his great strategic victory was lets scare all the state house tenants into voting, by telling lies about National.

And let’s not forget his predictions of huge victories in Napier and Tukituki etc.

Threesome of the Year

No this isn’t about some lucky bastard and the Ever-Swindell twins (sigh) but Time’s Man of the Year has gone to three people – Bill & Melinda Gates and Bono for their charitable work.

The cover story is here and you can only admire how effective Bono has been on getting the most unlikely pairings such as Susan Sarandon and Pat Robertson working together.

Also worth reading the interview with the three of them together. Melinda Gates especially comes across as very strong, and not just a “silent partner”.

One of the more interesting runner-ups was George HW Bush and Bill Clinton. Their work together for Tsunami relief was extremely sucessful, and I agree a very good sign of how we unite together when we really need to.

In the main story on them, I found it amusing when they were out at the Clinton Presidential Library and Bush sent them a message “Tell 41 and 42 that 43 is hungry.”

Time also has a joint interview with them.

Peter Griffin causes relationship break-up

My apologies to Mr Griffin for the tabloid headline, but I just had to draw attention to Maria von Trapp’s post about how she dumped her boyfriend as she kept thinking about Peter after meeting him, and realised she wouldn’t be doing that if she loved her boyfriend enough.

A very funny story – would made a good sideswipe item *cough* *cough *Ana*

Another assaulting Minister

Wow Dunedin now has both MPs having had the Police say they believe they committed assaults.

I actually regard what Hodgson did as considerably worse than what Benson-Pope did (in terms of the assaults, not the handling). The reason for this is three-fold:

1) Hodgson’s assault was done this year, not 20+_ years ago
2) Hodgson assault happened when he was a Minister of the Crown, and he did it in his political role
3) Hodgson’s motivation was not to get a noisy kid to shut up in class, but to suppress the freedom of speech of a NZ citizen at a public meeting

Now I again agree with the Police that it would not be appropriate to charge Hodgson. I doubt anyone ever expected that. But by the Police saying he committed a technical assault, it means his claims of doing it to protect the PM from being assaulted are not accepted by Police. And of course his defence is laughable – it is obvious he did it to stop a protester’s sign being shown on camera.

I amongst others condemn the US Government when it starts to interview pupils on the basis of what library books they read. People should not take for granted our freedoms at home and also condemn the actions of a senior Government Minister who used force to stop a legal protester in a public place. No matter how much one may disagree with a person’s message, you should be concerned with such behaviour from a Minister of the Crown.

Role of Waitangi Tribunal

I am ever amazed by how the role of the Waitangi Tribunal has expanded over time. I certainly support most of the work it has done on resolving historical land grievances.

But it seems to have morphed into a hear any issue at all affecting one or more Maori. The latest is its recommendation that a WWII Maori solider should be given a VC.

I don’t disagree that the solider may well have deserved a VC. What I can’t work out is how this is in any way related to the Treaty of Waitangi.

Has the Waitangi Tribunal become a universal advocate for Maori on any and all issues? If Maori do suffer discrimination (which is of course wrong) isn’t that the role of the Human Rights Commission or Race Relations Conciliator?

Wouldn’t the Waitangi Tribunal be better to focus on the huge backlog of land claims that it has? They have a unique role in law to adjudicate and recommend on them. And the longer they take to do so, the longer they remain a source of division.

The CN Tower

On Saturday (Sunday NZ time) I did some sightseeing and as I was driving down near Toronto, I figured I should see what the view was like from the tallest free-standing building in the world – the CN Tower.

By pure coincidence the day I visited was the first day they were showing a new movie on how the tower was built, and I was the first person to view it so I got a free DVD of it.

The tower is 553 metres tall, and the top viewing platform is at 447 metres or 147 stories. This is the highest viewing platform of any tower. In comparison the Auckland Sky Tower viewing platform is at around 200 metres.

cn1.jpg

Toronto and suburbs stretching out into the hills.

cn2.JPG

A snow covered harbour area.

cn3.JPG

This shot of some tall office blocks gives you some idea of how very high up the tower is.

More photos after the break.
Continue reading »

Will there be accountability?

It hasn’t been very high profile, but the Auditor-General has just reported on another case of shocking behaviour within Government. We await with bated breath to see if anyone – whether Minister or staff, will take any responsibility and consequences for what happened.

This is all to do with Allen & Clarke, a firm set up by two former Ministry of Health staff. Back on the 19th of August 2004 Murray McCully asked Annette King how many contracts had that firm recieved from their former employer.

Now Ministers are required by standing orders to respond within six days. Or about a week. For week after week and month after month the Minister stonewalled and refused to answer. Then some 210 days after the six day deadline had expired, the answer came back there had been 24 contracts worth $1.2 million.

Then after the issue was referred to the Auditor-General, the Ministry admitted to another 18 contracts, making the total 42. But it gets better and twice more the number grew until they revealed that there had in fact be 60 contracts. And 56 of these 60 contracts were non-competitive – ie just given to the former staff members.

The Auditor-General has found “inadequate contracting rules, breaches of those rules that do exist, internal auditors being ignored, a lack of competent staff, breaches of conflict of interest rules, a failure to ensure value for money, a lack of monitoring of contractors

Book Monitoring

NRT has a post about how a student who ordered Mao Tse-Tung’s “The Little Red Book.” got visited by federal agents because of it.

If this is true (and it does come via Daily Kos) that is just outraegous. In fact that would concern me far more than the dubious legality of NSA wiretaps.

UPDATE: It’s a hoax!

An ACT ex-MP in support of inflation

Rather stunned to see ex ACT MP Deborah Coddington write yesterday that perhaps we should give up on this price stability thing, as after all we can enjoy more jobs and higher wages if we don’t worry about it.

I look forward to seeing Rodney’s comments. Perhaps someone should join Deborah a Social Credit application form 🙂