Not the one which counts

Sort of nice to read on Francis Till’s blog that in the first post-election poll, National is up 2.6% and Labour down 4.6% from the last pre-election Roy Morgan poll. Also Greens up to 9%!

However there is only one poll which counts at the end of the day.

Normally though a Government has a honeymoon of some months, or longer. It will be interesting to see how long the new Government

More on electoral petitions

Dean Knight submits that in theory the High Court could actually declare a result, rather than just call a by-election, in certain cases of over-spending.

There is no NZ case law in this area, but he looks at some overseas cases.

An interesting side-question to this, is whether a successful electoral petition can change a party

One News presenters

Looks like TVNZ is going back to two presenters, and Simon Dallow will be one of them. Sadly for Simon, presumably for less than $800,000!

If he does get the job, I hope they can still use him for current affairs.

The co-presenter looks to be a choice between Bernadine Oliver-Kerby, Wendy Petrie and Kate Hawkesby.

I still associate BOK with the time when she did the body paint photo for the rugby magazine. A great photo, but possible one she regrets now. Anyway she comes across well on the shows she does do.

I didn

Sensationalist Headlines

Attorney-General Peters

Oh this has cheered me up. The though of Helen being so desperate for votes that she is offering Winston Ministerial posts.

Can you just imagine the confidence it will inspire in the Government to have Winston as Attorney-General.

And imagine the Greens if Winston is there and they are not!

Please, please let it be true.

H2

Maori Party and National

By-elections and List MPs

The NZ Herald writes about the possibility of an eighth NZ First MPs if the electoral petition is successful, and if Peters wins any subsequent by-election.

They also talk about the option of him not resigning as a List MP, so the proportionality is not upset.

I am unsure that you need an explicit resignation. If a writ is returned declaring him as the MP for Tauranga, it may well be that he automatically vacates his place as a List MP.

I haven’t checked, but I seriously doubt you can hold two writs at the same time. By the same principle if you were MP for Auckland and then contested a by-election in Dunedin and became MP for Dunedin, your earlier seat would be vacated I believe.

NZ good place to study witchcraft

Edinburgh

I don’t normally fall in love with a place within seconds of arriving, but I have with Edinburgh.

scot 2.JPG

You leave the train station and just above it are a range of stunning castles and monuments. Right in the middle of the city.

And then looking to your right is a huge beautiful park that goes for around six city blocks.

At that point I am imagining working here and having lunch in the park most days.

Head off to a pub called Ryan’s to meet Donald. Very nice. Then just a five minute walk down a tiled street to Donald’s place.

scot 1.JPG

As you can see from this photo, you get a nice view in the morning to wake up to.

Anyway off sightseeing today. Probably here until Sunday.

I would have done far more than fine them!

The two men who made multiple obscene phone calls to Katherine Rich, have been given a fine and community service.

I understand the calls were absolutely vile. Unprintable stuff.

I do wondre what illness Mr Pryde has which makes him unable to work, and claiming the sickness benefit?

Coalition Manoeuvres

Vernon Small has a very useful article on the challenges Clark has in putting a Government together. She will, but it is a matter of how secure and happy everyone will be.

Also of interest is that the Maori Party and National are still talking to each other.

As I said, no-one should expect Helen Clark not to announce a Government next week. She will. But it will be fascinating how everyone is positioned.

Personally I’d be delighted if she can get all five left and centre parties voting with her Government. Because that means National and ACT have less competition.

Coalition Manoeuvres

Vernon Small has a very useful article on the challenges Clark has in putting a Government together. She will, but it is a matter of how secure and happy everyone will be.

Also of interest is that the Maori Party and National are still talking to each other.

As I said, no-one should expect Helen Clark not to announce a Government next week. She will. But it will be fascinating how everyone is positioned.

Personally I’d be delighted if she can get all five left and centre parties voting with her Government. Because that means National and ACT have less competition.

More on electoral petition

Adam Gifford has a useful recollection of a time when Winston was far less concerned about over-spending. Because it was one of his own MPs!

The Dominion Post also has an article on the electoral petition, and reports on confusion as to what would happen if the petition is sucessful and Peters won the by-election.

I can clear up the confusion!

If there was a by-election and Peters won it, then he would have effectively resigned as a List MP, and NZ First would get an extra List MP (Susan Baragwanath) to replace him. So NZ First goes to eight and National drops to 47.

Mike Williams obviously does not know electoral law. Well about as well as he can predict electorate victories or estimate candidate spending!

I’m also unsure that the Dominion Post is correct when it says:

In 1979, as a National Party candidate, he won Hunua after the Appeal Court overturned a ruling by the High Court that nearly 900 ballot papers were invalid because they had not been filled in correctly. The Appeal Court said the determining factor should be whether a voter’s intention was clear.

My recollection is Peters won because in fact the decision was that those votes filled in incorrectly were deemed invalid, even though the intent was clear, and it took Parliament to change the law to what it is today. Not 100% sure on this so await someone who can research this.

Boors

Both Russell Brown and Damian Christie have blogged about the boorish behaviour of some people towards Don Brash at the NZ Music Awards.

Just confirms all my worst prejudices about certain segments of the arts community. Good on RB and DC though for their comments.

GOP in trouble

I’ve been thinking for a while that the 2006 mid-terms could be very very bad for the Republican Party and Bush.

Not because of Iraq or Hurricane Katrina, even though they are factors. But because Bush is alienating his own base.

Many conservatives are appalled at how fast spending has grown under Bush. A grass-roots effort to fund New Orleans reconstruction by cutting waste has been put down by the GOP leadership.

And the nomination of Harriet Miers to the Supreme Court has also not gone down well. Not because of what her likely views will be, but simply that she isn’t seen as qualified.

Ann Coulter has done a savaging, as only she can do, saying some pundits would praise Bush even if he had nominated his Scottish terrier Barney to the court.

Hat Tip: The Whig

Tauranga Electoral Petition

Winston Peters has lodged an electoral petition for Tauranga, alleging Bob Clarkson spent more than $20,000.

Well done to the NZ Herald who have correctly reported the outcome, if sucessful, is a by-election. Newstalk ZB are incorrectly saying that the seat could be forfeited to Peters.

I said a couple of weeks ago that it was logicial for Peters to file a petition. Regardless of the merits of the case (and no-one can know this), it will keep Peters in the headlines for months on end.

Damn

Heh I was right

I made the call that Davis had bombed and that Hague had been the true start of yesterday based on my own impressions. However all the media have gone the same line with Davis, and The Times has finished its story with “Hague for Leader”.

Hague hosted a function last night for the International Democrat Union (federation of centre-right parties) and was in very popular demand. Rather ironic to be an elder statesman of the party in your 40s.

Everyone says that the leadership race has made this the best party conference in over a decade. Very good timing for me to just happen to be here at the right time.

Boris Johnson has come out and strongly endorsed David Cameron. David Davis is almost guaranteed to be one of the two who will go to the members to vote on. If Cameron is the other, I think he might end up beating him.

Why I won’t donate to Salient

While fully supportive of Salient for standing up to Vic Uni, I will not be donating, or encouraging people to donate, to their legal fund.

The reason is simple. They are funded through compulsory student association fees. This is not some poor struggling organisation. If they had voluntary membership I’d probably be writing out a reasonably large cheque (much higher than an annual membership fee) today.

Sexual Disclosure

Some interesting debate on the blogs about the decision of a NZ court that an HIV positive man did not have to disclose he has HIV to his partner, as he used a condom. Previous cases have found unprotected sex does require disclosure of HIV – in fact a criminal offence not to do so.

On a moral level, I think there is an absolute duty to tell a sexual partner if you have HIV, regardless of condom use. In fact I regard it as vital you’re disclose any STDs at all. I doubt I would stay for a second with someone who I found hadn’t told me.

But whether you legislate is a very different matter. Already the court gets into difficult areas, as Tumeke points out, by ruling that you don’t need a condom for oral sex (if HIV positive) as long as you don’t come in your partner’s mouth. Will the next step be timing how long until one pulled out?

In theory it is almost impossible (not totally) for a man to catch HIV off a woman through PIV sex. Could a court rule a lower level of disclosure requirements for women over men?

Also why does legal requirement to disclose only apply to HIV? How about all the other nasties? Frog asks whether this might be a slippery slope that you have to disclose any known genetic issues?

Perhaps the law should focus on harm? That is, if through non disclosure a partner is infected with something nasty, they have legal recourse?

Salient – finally free!

Ministers speculations

NZPA has a story on potential new Ministers. I note that in several stories Winnie Laban has been mooted as a replacement for Phillip Field if he is not reappointed.

Rather sad tokenism that she is only mentioned as a replacement Pacific Islander in the Ministry, not any talk of qualifying in her own right. I mean if she is good enough to be a Minister that should hold irrespective of whether there is another Pacific Islander as a Minister.

On the same basis Nanaia Mahuta is mooted as a possible Minister because

Transmission Gully

UK Tory Party Conference Day 3

Started off with a breakfast meeting which included a presentation on poll and focus group results of the Tory Party. Around 50 people there and the panel included Charlie Whelan, who is a very well known spin doctor who used to work for Gordon Brown – the next UK Prime Minister.

I’m getting a copy of the full data, so will post more on this in the future. It was a stark presentation though on how a negative brand can be so fatal to a party. One piece of research described the Tory Immigration Policy to a group of voters without saying whose policy it was. 64% said they agreed with it. Another group were told the same policy but told it was the Tory policy – only 30% agreed with it.

The bottom line is that the public so doubt the motives of the Conservative Party, that it doesn’t matter how good your policies are, they can’t win without changing their brand. Blair managed to do this to old Labour by scrapping the Section 4 commitment to nationalisation. The Tory job is harder as they have no one big thing they can do.

This is probably National’s biggest debt to Don Brash – restoring the brand. After the wipe-out in 2002 it was miserable being a National parliamentary staffer and party supporter. People would feel *sorry* for you. God I hated that. Brash has restored the brand so that people can feel proud to say yeah I’m a Nat. Few can say that in the UK about the Tories. However in Australia saying you support Howard is popular and acceptable.

Voters were also asked to place MPs on a scale from -100 (ultra left – say George Galloway) to +100. Gordon Brown got around -15. Labour around -12. Tony Blair got +4 – dead in the centre (the population is +2) so has positioned himself more centrist than his party. Now Ken Clarke was +24 and he is regarded as the left of the Conservative Party. Michael Howard got +52, and you can not win elections from out there.

There was some discussion of whom would be best placed to beat Gordon Brown. Charlie Whelan said that David Cameron is the one he would worry about most if he still worked for Brown. This is against the perceived wisdom that Clarke is the one most able to win. Whelan told a story of how at the last Tory leadership election Michael Portillo was the one they feared most. So what they did was type up a fake memo about how Ken Clarke was in fact the one they thought could damage them most, and leaked it to the media. This resulted in helping Clarke’s campaign at the expense of Portillo. Very cunning indeed!

We than had David Davis speak to conference. He was frankly disappointing. A good speech but not a great speech. I think it will lead to the leadership race becoming tighter.

In the afternoon was Liam Fox. He is the shadow foreign secretary and hence concentrated on foreign issues. At one point he talked about the EU and how the new members coming from Eastern Europe have just thrown off one repressive regime and don’t want to endure another one. When I suggested to some of the locals that it was a bit harsh to compare the USSR to the EU, I was firmly told not at all – well maybe only to Stalin 🙂

The real highlight of the day was former leader William Hague. Gave a superb and confident speech that got everyone talking. There seems to be a pattern that MPs who struggle when leader, often gain a new level of ability and confidence once they are former leaders. I can see Hague still as Prime Minister one day.

Anyway now off to meet Ian Paisley and the Democratic Ulster Unionists!