Winston to the rescue

Both the NZ Herald and Stuff are reporting that it looks like NZ First has been convinced to go from merely abstaining on supply and confidence to voting in favour. This would allow Labour to govern with the support of the two largest minor parties with at least 64 votes out of 121.

It’s as good a deal as one can get for Labour, and Clark should be happy with it. However one needs to remember that in a previous election she said relying on NZ First was her 99th preference. And one does have to wonder whether the pledge to vote for the Government will hold up, if NZ First drop below 5% in the polls (now they don’t have Tauranga).

For NZ First it isn’t so great. Yes they can claim some policy victories, but Grey Power tends to be grasping and the moment they get one concession they take that for granted and want another next time. And NZ First may find it ends up in the 1% to 2% range of United Future, propping up a Government from outside – and if so they face oblivion.

If as reported, there will be an increase in the rate of superannuation from 65% of the average wage, then NZ is definitely the loser. We already have the most generous superannuation scheme in the world, it is already not sustainable long-term, and this will just make it less and less likely current levels of superannuation will be available for future generations.

The “ruinously expensive” (to quote Cullen) increase in superannuation combined with the student loans bribe, are going to be nasty poison pills for the future.

One good thing though is that it hopefully means you don’t have a precedent of parties abstaining on confidence and supply votes. This is a total cop-out as far as I am concerned. You are there in Parliament to vote. I suspect the PM also had some concerns about going to the GG with less than 61 votes pledged in support. Saying oh we only have 57, but these parties will abstain is not a clear cut confidence of the House.

Cheaper faster broadband

The Commerce Commission has come out with what looks to be a very positive determination on the broadband unbundled bitstream service.

This has been a major issue for InternetNZ. We ended up spending close to $100,000 on submissions, cross-submissions, a conference, a technical workshop and general legal issues. I spent two days at the main commission conference in July, and generally got the feel it was going to be a good outcome.

I’ve yet to read the detailed determination (and it is not yet final) but the major aspects appear to be:

* No artifical limits on speed at the wholesale level. This will mean up to 7.6 Mb/s in many areas.

* A wholesale fee of $26.57 for the full-speed service. Telecom may offer cheaper fees for lesser speeds. This isn’t as cheap as hoped for, but still a definite improvement on the status quo.

* No differential in wholesale fees customers differently for business and residential access. Business customers may outraegous prices for broadband – sometimes almost tens times as much as residential. Now it will be one price for one service at the wholesale level.

Note that different ISPs will offer different retail packages based on this. Too early to predict quite what they will be, but there should be considerable variety.

News: NZ Herald and Computerworld.

Death of McCully – film at 10 pm

NZPA have a story about how some MPs want Don Brash to dump Murray McCully as a key advisor.

This reminds me of the old quote “End of world predicted – film at ten pm” which highlighted how often the end of the world was predicted.

Likewise this is around the tenth time I can recall predictions or speculation about Murray. Going off memory, others were:

* After 1993 election
* After 1996 election
* After Shipley became Leader
* After Tourism Board issue
* After 1999 election
* After English became Leader
* After 2002 election
* After Brash election
* After 2005 election

I’m serious. I recall people in 1999 saying the he was finished and would be retiring in 2002.

So this story is nothing new or unusual.

A close call with a cult

Blaming Don again

Russell Brown quotes from Anthony Trenwith on the Foreshore & Seabed Act. He says:

The problem with the F&S Act is simply that it was rushed (and not to mention wholly unnecessary) legislation brought about by a kneejerk reaction on the part of the government to Don Brash’s own speech at Orewa.

Except that the Te Arawa decision occured in June 2003, and the Government’s kneejerk decision to change the law happened a few days later.

Don Brash did not become National Party Leader until November 2003, and Orewa was in January 2004. So to portray the Government’s decisions as a reaction to Orewa is just making excuses.

Conservative Party Research

I mentioned last week a presentation of some fascinating research on UK politics presented to a breakfast meeting at the Tory Party conference. I’ve now got a copy of the presentation from The Bow Group. Not going to stick all 24 slides up, but just a few which I think are fascinating.

bow1.JPG

This shows that Europe (the big Tory bogey) is only No 8 issue for voters, and in fact Labour is now ahead on that issue. Also note how far ahead Labour is on the economy – the traditional strength for the right.
Continue reading »

Predict your future love life

UN and Israel relations improving

An optimistic article in the New York Times about how Israel’s relations with the UN are significantly improving.

Still somewhat pathethic thought that Israel is still restricted to the New York offices, when countries like North Korea are full voting members.

Tony Milne’s blog

Labour’s Rakaia candidate, Tony Milne, has started a blog called I See Red.

I already disagree with both articles, Tony has done!

Firstly he says NZ is divided into two – old and new, with a clear implication that Labour gets support from “new” and National from “old”. Sorry Tony but National doesn’t just get support from those pining for Mother England, women marrying young and locking up gays.

But onto the more substantive post on the Maori seats.

Taking points in turn:

1) For 138 years New Zealand

Three things I like

The film – A History of Violence

Went to see this in Edinburgh knowing nothing about it. Greatly enjoyed it. It is R18 as some of the violence is fairly brutal and graphic, but this fits the plot well – which is basically why the cafe owner father is so good at killing people when threatened.

My favourite scene actually involved the son. I cheered.

Go see it, if it is out in NZ. Damn good.

EasyJet

The fares are great – only 14 pounds from Edinburgh to Belfast for example.

But also love the relaxed atmosphere and the staff. Very friendly and casually dressed in orange shirts rather than full uniforms other airlines have.

A very social secretary

Saw this on Monday. My God – NZ politicians get off lightly. For those who don’t know, this is a satircal production based on Labour’s David Blunkett’s affair with Kimberly Quinn,the pubisher of the right wing Spectator.

Bernard Hill as David Blunkett is perfectly cast. Tony and Cherie Blair are featured also – a great scene where Cherie tells Tony off for picking up the toys from the lounge, because they have a photo shoot there later.

Overall you end up feeling sorry for Blunkett, dislking Quinn and laughing at Tony Blair. Very cruel for all involved. In NZ affairs are not even publicised, let alone have a satire made based on them!

Nine different plans

Ethnic Precincts

Professor Paul Spoonley has called for Auckland to develop ethnic precincts.

I’m somewhat dubious. While certainly in some cities like Sydney’s Chinatown it has worked very well, in many other cities it has been a disaster having ethnic precincts. The Netherlands comes to mind – they are struggling with the issues of having realised that many immigrants are remaining isolationist, rather than contributing to a blend of cultures.

At the end of the day, I think it is up to the individuals. If indivudals from particular races tend to all live in one area, then that is their choice. But that is a different matter from having the City Council specifically try to create ethnic precincts.

Getting harder for Clark

The election was almost four weeks ago, and the job of forming a Government is proving more difficult that predicted.

Clark’s basic problem is even with NZ First abstaining, she only has 57 votes and needs at least 58. This means a formal deal with United Future or the Maori Party. The Maori Party is probably going to rule it out, so unless they also abstain then Clark needs both the Greens and United Future.

Complicating issues further is National and NZ First are now talking. This won’t be to talk Government, but hopefully about areas they can co-operate such as Clem for Speaker.

National Whips

NZPA report that Caucus prompted Lindsay Tisch from Junior Whip to Chief Whip, and Anne Tolley replaces Lindsay as Junior Whip.

Lindsay is a former party president, so has a good background for the organisational tasks involved with being Chief Whip.

Doesn’t sounds like they were contested elections, and that would have been my expectation. You don’t normally have elections for these roles. However Lindsay did become Junior Whip in a contested election I think.

UPDATE: Stories in Dom Post and NZ Herald.

Why the Greens’ Charm Offensive Failed

Roger Kerr has an excellent column on why the Greens’ charm offensive failed.

One extract is worth repeating:

A common view of greens generally is that they are well-intentioned and at worst harmless, if somewhat utopian in their ideas.

There is no basis for complacent assumptions. Many green crusades have been responsible for human misery and environmental damage.

A classic example is the campaign against DDT. Despite massive evidence that DDT was not harmful to humans or wildlife, the ideological ban on its use in many countries led to a resurgence in malaria and an estimated 50 million deaths. South Africa has gone back to using DDT and deaths have fallen away.

Driving Test Question?

You are driving along a two lane road with a NO PASSING sign posted, and come upon a bicycle rider. Do you follow this slow-moving bicycle rider for the next 2 miles, or do you break the law and pass?

Which is the correct choice?
Continue reading »

Corporate Blogs

A good article on the advent of corporate blogs in the Dominion Post. These are yet to take off much in NZ, but are big overseas.

One very well-read blog is Robert Scobie’s Scobleizer, who works for Microsoft.

Was interested to read that Telecom have some internal blogs, including one by Theresa Gattung. What a good idea.

Party and Electorate Votes

An article in the Dominion Post asserts that National lost the election because its local candidates were more popular than the party.

Ir is true that National got 40.4% of the electorate vote and only 39.1% of the party vote, but it is simplistic and wrong (in my opinion) to paint this as a reason they lost.

The party vote is generally a contest between eight parties while most electorate contests are between just two candidates. Thus it is quite normal and ordinary for a large party to have a higher electorate vote than party vote. Now if it is 10% higher as National did in 2002 that is a problem, but a 1.3% difference is not a big deal. You can not assume that those people were potential National party voters – they may be minor party supporters doing the sensible thing and not wasting their electorate vote.

What is unusual is that Labour did have less electorate votes than party votes – 40.4% to 41.1%. In 34 seats they got more electorate votes than party votes, but got less in 35 seats. However if you remove the seven Maori seats and the four party leader seats of Tauranga, Epsom, OB and Wigram you find in fact Labour elsewhere got 10,874 more electorate votes than party votes.

Another factor is exceptional candidates can attract wide cross-party support. Nick Smith in Nelson gets 8,000 or so more candidate votes than party votes. Now most of them are never going to vote National, they just think Nick is a good local MP.

Merkel 1st female German Chancellor

The deal’s been done and Angela Merkel has become the first female head of government of Germany. I think she is the first head from former East Germany also.

The SDP has driven a hard bargain though (they should give Peter Dunne some lessons) and get eight Ministries including foreign affairs, reform, employment, health, transport and finance.

She seems a tough cookie. Her party is against Turkey being admitted to the EU, and her response to the US (which supports it) was that the United States should first take in Mexico as a state 🙂

Also found some obscure facts about her, including that she once co-authored an article called “Nonempirical parameter estimate for the statistical adiabatic theory of unimolecular fragmentation carbon-hydrogen bond breaking in methyl”!

Election Analysis

After the final results came out, I did a reasonably comprehensive analysis of them, which I sent to the National MPs.

It seems to have circulated reasonably widely as Richard Prebble rang me yesterday to say he had a copy of it and wanted to refer to it in his weekly e-mail as “the best analysis we have seen of the election”.

All the information is based on the public 2002 and 2005 results, so I had no problems with that (while somewhat surprised it had got beyond National), so a copy in pdf form is now on the ACT website.

Auctions

North Korea

A conference which counted

What a difference a great speech and a mediocre speech at a conference can make.

A Sunday Times poll of 750 UK Conservative Party members (they all get to elect the next Leader) has shown in just a couple of weeks, a huge swing.

David Davis dropped from 30% to 14% while David Cameron has gone from 16% to 39%. That is a huge movement.

Ken Clarke is 2nd at 26% (David in fact is just 1% ahead of 4th place getter Liam Fox) but he has a very high 40% of members saying he definitely should not be Leader.

Most members want the two candidates they get to vote on to be David Cameron and Ken Clarke. However unlikely there will not be at least one candidate from the right – Davis or Fox.

With more members saying they would vote for Clarke ahead of Davis, this could lead to some of his support crumbling to Fox, as many of the right faction just want anyone who can stop Clarke.

I would not be surprised if one got a Fox vs Cameron decision to go to the members. The only certainty at this stage thought is Sir Malcolm Rifkind will be first candidate eliminated as he has only one MP publicly backing him at this stage.

Going alone

The Dominion Post says that it looks like attempts by Clark to get Greens, United Future and NZ First all into Government have failed.

According to the DP, all three parties were offered Ministerial positions, but they wouldn’t all agree to serve together.

I’ve always thought a simple Labour-Progressive Government most likely. Those two parties will have 51 votes and they need to get 10 out of the 18 votes held by NZ First (7), Greens (6), Maori (4) and United (3) to pass legislation.

If Clark is clever, she will get Green/Maori to support left-wing policies and NZ First/United to support more centrist policies. On each vote then she can win 61 to 60.

So long Richard

Richard Long, who has served as chief of staff to both Don Brash and Bill English, is retiring. Richard served for many years as Editor of the Dominion (not the Dominion Post!) and was employed by Bill in late 2002. The fact that Don kept him on, spoke for itself.

Richard was my boss for 18 months or so and a great guy to work for. Many former staff (including from the Dominion) said the same. And not just because he had one of the best wine collections around!

As well as being a nice guy, he was also very good at his job. The role of COS can be a difficult one as it requires someone who is both a good manager of people, and also someone with good political judgement. Quite a few had one but not the other, so Richard did well as he had heaps of experience with both.

The same article notes that Lindsay Tisch is moving up to Senior Whip. Not sure who will become Junior Whip – possibly a former MP who returned this election?

And in a related story, the Dominion Post notes that Mike Munro is also likely to retire next year, and that the Greens’ Michael Appleton is off to MFAT. Michael played a key role, from what I know, in getting Frog Blog started.