Anti-Spam Legislation

The Government has introduced into Parliament their proposed anti-spam legislation. The bill can be viewed here.

My comments are captured in the press release below:

INTERNETNZ WELCOMES ANTI-SPAM BILL

InternetNZ is delighted the Government has finally introduced proposed anti-spam legislation.

“We have been advocating such legislation since 2003, and congratulate Minister David Cunliffe on this latest step to an anti-spam law” said InternetNZ Acting President David Farrar.

“Anti-spam legislation by itself does not stop spam. However it is a necessary and vital part of the overall fight against spam, by allowing action to be taken against spammers. Education, technical solutions, and international co-operation are also necessary. The good thing about the legislation is it will allow New Zealand to more effectively co-operate with international authorities against overseas based spammers”.

“We urge all parties to support the legislation at the first reading. We are almost the only country in the OECD without legislation, and its lack has hampered our ability to contribute to stopping overseas spammers. The lack of a law has also allowed some New Zealanders to spam, by hiring people based overseas to do so on their behalf”.

“While we support the bill’s introduction, we do have a concern over the proposed enforcement mechanism. We do not believe it is practical for complaints to go via NZ Internet Providers, as in 99% of cases they can do nothing to assist. We will be strongly submitting to the Select Committee that this provision, if not changed, will place an unfair cost on ISPs who already bear a huge cost due to spam”.

“InternetNZ looks forward to the bill being referred to a select committee and detailed consideration of the bill later this year. We may have further comments upon completing a detailed analysis of the bill’s provisions”
concluded David Farrar.

TV3 Poll

The TV3 Poll shows National and Labour nexk and neck. Frankly I am amazed it does not show Labour in the lead after the last couple of weeks.

Mallard’s accusations about the US funding and writing policies for National were made up, but nevertheless mud tends to stick, which is why he did it. I honestly expected TV3 (which is normally the worst poll for National) to show Labour leading.

I tend to try and stay away from predicting polls, but all I will say is I expect the lead to change at least a couple of times between now and election day. I would be very surprised if either party took a big lead and never lost it. The final weeks may well prove crucial.

Think about this

The median loan balance is only $15,000. If one starts off on $45,000 and your salary goes up 5% a year, Labour’s calculator says at present you would pay the loan off in five years nine months (if no voluntary repayments) and under their policy it would be paid off in four years eight months.

What this means is that the 10% extra deduction off your income (over the threshold of around $17k) would not occur for that 13 month period in around five years time.

The lifetime saving to you is around $4,000 Labour predicts. It will actually be less than that, but we’ll ignore how a dollar tommorow is worth less in today’s dollars.

Now you may want to reflect the lifetime cost of Labour’s increase in the top tax rate to 39%. You’ll start paying it after six years, when you are probably 28, based on 5% annual income increases.

By the time you are 35 the 6% extra tax on over $60,000 has cost you $5,700.

By the time you are 40, the 6% extra tax in over $60,000 income has cost you $17,000.

And in theory by the time you retire at 65, that extra 6% may have cost you $250,000.

Now it is not as simple as that, because the threshold for paying the 39% tax rate should move by inflation. Even allowing for 2% inflation adjustments to the $60,000 level, one still ends up $87,000 worst off over your woking life if you think the increase of the top tax rate from 33% to 39% was a good trade-off for getting your student loan paid off a couple of years earlier.

What is the moral of the story? There is no such thing as a free lunch.

Farewell Richard Prebble

Richard Prebble gave an amazing and emotional valedictory speech at 5 pm today.

His stories of stealing furniture from Ministers as backbenchers in 1975 had everyone in hysterics.

His tribute to the genius of David Lange was especially touching, with Lange’s current illness.

And talking about the death of Bill Prebble after the battle of Crete was incredibly moving.

The NZ Herald has the full text of his speech up. It will go down as one of the great valedictories, as seen by the extended standing ovation he got from the packed public gallery.

The gallery, and the function at ACT afterwards, had almost every prominent ‘rightist’ in attendance. I joked that one bomb could have set the right back a generation 🙂

Was a nice opportunity to catch up with many old friends, and be part of a proper farewell to a great MP.

Blogs & Parliament

Last night, Jordan Carter and I were the invited speakers to a forum in Parliament organised by the New Zealand chapter of the Australasian Study of Parliament Group. The topic we had been asked to shgare our views on was Blogs and Parliament.

There was a good turnout, one of their larger recent ones, with around 40 people there, and a younger demographic than normal.

Rod Donald chaired the session and introduced us. Rod complained that everytime I say something nice about him on my blog, it causes him problems with his colleagues. So I just have to say he did a very good job as the chair 🙂

Jordan has blogged it from his view, and Keith Ng has suggested Jordan and I do joint gigs more often as we had very contrasting styles.

In case anyone is interested, a copy of the powerpoint I did is attached.

Anti-Americanism

Tracey Barnett writes in the NZ Herald about the unfortunate rise of anti-americanism in NZ.

This got me thinking more about Trevor Mallard’s incredible allegations that Don Brash was basically in the pay of the United States and having policy dictated to them. It is not unusual in politics around the world for a politician to try and smear their opponent by claiming they are controlled by the US. But the countries where these sort of allegations are made are normally Zimbabwe and Iran, not first world countries. I don’t think one can under-estimate how much damage Mallard’s stunt will have done to our relationship with the US.

Now on National Radio on Tuesday, Matthew Hooton provocatively pointed out on Nine to Noon that the left’s anti-Americanism sounds more and more like anti-semitism in Germany in the 1930s. Accusations of secretly controlling and bankrolling people formed the basis of anti-semitism.

The article linked above by an American saying Aucklanders refuse to talk to her at parties and say things like:

“You’re not American, I hope?”

“Yes, in fact, I am.”

“That’s too bad.”

Now Matthew may have been provocative but one can imagine the exchange in Germany 1930s:

“You’re not a Jew, I hope?”

“Yes, in fact, I am.”

“That’s too bad.”

Shame on Trevor Mallard for his part in fostering anti-americanism. His target may have been Don Brash but the damage he has caused goes far wider.

Borrowing Motivations

To my disbelief Traveor Mallard is trying to argue that having no interest on loans will not significantly affect the proportions who take them up. This is so ridicolous I do not know how he can say it with a straight face. Almost every known model of economics places huge reliance on the rate of interest as influencing behaviour with regards to investment.

I am hearing rumours that Michael Cullen fought totally against this policy, because he knows it is going to blow borrowing out. The fact it has not been checked by a single government agency suggests the decision making on this was incredibly rushed.

Investing more money into tertiary education is not a bad thing, but this policy is arguably the very worst way to go about it. Labour Party member, self-described socialist and former AUSA Office Stef criticises the policy as ir-responsible, and she is right.

It has also been criticised by senior academics as bad policy.

Reading Comments

Up until a couple of weeks ago, I used to basically read every comment made on the blog. This is no longer possible with the volume of comments being too large to keep up with.

So if I do not respond to something you say in a comment, it may just be that I haven’t read it. If you really really need me to see something, e-mail me. I will still browse most comments but not all.

This also means that if anything is posted which is defamatory, in contempt of court, or infringes copyright, I may be unaware of it. Hence I have reducued liability under the law, until such time as I am made aware of it. So lawyers stay away.

Another scenario

And here is another scenario, using a slightly more complex spreadsheet. This allows for 2% income growth.

Labour say a $15,000 loan balance and annual salary of $27,000 growing by 2% per annum will take 40 years to repay.

The attached spreadsheet has it repaid in the 24th year. And once again note this is not even allowing for interest writeoffs. As half of all payments (after inflation is accounted for) go towards principal repayment, there would be interest writeoffs for the first half dozen or more years, but to keep it simple I am ignoring those.

More on student loan calculators

I’ve just recalculated the scenario of someone earning $34,300, whose income is $34,300, and constant, and has a $15,000 loan. The Labour calculator tells us it would take 25.5 years to repay their loan and have interest of $11,891.

Now Labour have said their calculator allows for the repayment threshold to go up by inflation. Now inflation is targetted to be between 0 and 3% so the midpoint is 1.5% which I have used to see how much it changes from the IRD scenario of 14 years.

My simple excel spreadsheet, which doesn’t even allow for the possibility of interest writeoffs, has the loan paid off in 16 years. So still a 10 year time difference.

Note I am providing my calculations so they can be audited. Hopefully Labour will do the same.

Labour’s Student Loan Calculator

I have been checking the output of Labour’s student loan calculator and my initial findings are that it appears to be seriously incorrect. I understand that the calculator has not been put together by Treasury, IRD or Ministry of Education, but by Labour Party staff. I call on Labour to release the formulas the calculator uses.

Here are examples of where it appears to be wildly wrong:

They claim that someone with a $15,000 loan balance who earns $34,300, and stays earning that much would take 25.5 years to repay their loan and have interest of $11,891. Plug it in and you will see.

If one goes to sorted.org.nz and plug in a $15,000 loan balance and $34,300 income it says it is paid off in 12 years 4 months and interest is $6,805 in today’s dollars.

So Labour’s calculator is claiming it will take 25 years instead of 12 under current policy. This is not a small error – this is almost electoral fraud. Now sorted.org is a neutral site from the Retirement Commissioner so I trust their calculator more.

We can go to the IRD calculator also which will tell you the repayments on $34,300 income and $15,000 loan will be $1771.20 a year. Now even if one totally ignores the fact that you may get interest writeoff, a simple calculation of 7% interest on $15000 shows inital interest of $1050 in the first year vs repayments of $1,771 shows the loan paid off in 14 years approx, not 25.

Here is another example. Say a $15,000 loan balance and annual salary of $27,000 growing by 2% per annum. Labour’s calculator says it will take 40 years to repay and interest of $27,693.

The Retirement Commissioner says 18 years 7 months and interest of $10,417. I plugged in a salary today of $27,000 and income in five years of $29,800 based on 2% growth.

I am happy for someone to point out if my comparisons and calculations are wrong and that Labour’s calculator is more correct than the Retirement Commissioner’s and IRD’s. The best thing would be to get Treasury and IRD to verify Labour’s calculator. They should so so immediately.

UPDATE: Bill English and his staff have also been checking out the calculator and have found Labour’s calculator out by 30% to 50%. Unless Labour can provide proof that their sums are accurate, their credibility will be zero.

Student Loan Editorials

The NZ Herald is scathing, labelling Labour’s move as smacking of desperation and “political bribery at its most base“.

They also label the approach as highly flawed saying it “will surely increase borrowing and encourage students to pay off loans at the minimum rate“.

The Dominion Post says:

The public is also entitled to be cynical about the timing. Suddenly, after telling the public there is no money for tax cuts, Labour has found the cash for a big-ticket item. Suddenly, after doing little while in government about a problem which had been growing for years, Labour has found the political will to address it.

And the Press:

If the beginning of this election campaign is any indication, such restraint looks like being thrown to the wind. Having sworn blind that there is no money to spare, particularly not for tax cuts (it’s all been spent, the Finance Minister, Michael Cullen, keeps telling us) suddenly a hitherto unnoticed $1.9 billion is available to be doled out. The student loan proposal will barely touch it, so presumably we will see more dipping into that particular cookie jar before long.

Black Humour

Nature of Loans scheme

Keith Ng makes the very insightful point that Labour’s announced loan changes will mean “it’s no longer a loan, it’s more like a universal allowance on one end and a 10% graduate tax on the other, with how much you take affecting how much you pay”.

This is very much correct. And it is something people may want to reflect on also. I’ll do something in more detail on this, but people may want to reflect for now how the proposed changes will affect them in the next few years. If you were projected to pay off your loan in 11 years, and now it will be paid off in nine years, what it means is this:

For the next nine years, you will not be one cent better off. You will pay the exact same amount as you do now, as compulsory repayments. It is only after nine years that your repayments will stop early and you will have a 10% drop in your effective tax rate (on income above $17K) two years earlier than otherwise would be the case.

And think about how much money you may be earning in nine years time, and whether a 10% tax drop for two years is better than say a permament 5% tax drop? Yes I am going to do some interesting calculations on this.

[Deleted para on National’s tax rebates being paid annually, as Jordan has pointed out they are just credited against loan balance also]

A promotion

The Press has given me a promotion, or maybe a demotion.

“Bugger, bugger, bugger. This may well be bad public policy, but try telling the students that. This one issue may well now cost National the next election,” wrote Mara on National candidate David Farrar’s blog site.

Confidential Discussions

Readers will recall how the forest owners were very upset with the Government as they confiscated without compensation the carbon credits generated by them under Kyoto.

This is partly why the projections turned out to be a billion dollar error.

Now the Kyoto Forestry Association had announced it was going to fund a $2 million advertising campaign on the issue of the confiscation.

But today they have said they have had “confidential discussions” with Ministers and are suspending their campaign.

I smell another u-turn.

Reason #52 to change the Government

Leaky Homes

The problem didn’t start under the Government, but at every step of the way their performance has been hugely unsatisfactory.

Minister George Hawkins totally ignored warnings from industry experts. He displayed such incompetence that Cullen had to step in, and finally the issue was totally removed from him.

Helen Clark denied there was a problem and said people were scare mongering and said the issue was a media beat-up on an issue of no substance.

Then their resolution service was set up so badly that it is looking to take 20 years to get through the backlog and each resolution is costing on average $108,000 (not compensation, just the cost of the bureaucracy to make a decision).

This week we have heard the leaky homes resolution service is putting on parties for their staff. That may get media attention, but is not the real scandal. The scandal is how badly George Hawkins fumbled this issue.

Happy Birthday to me!

I’m on the cover of a woman’s mag

Back to the future?

An excellent anti-spam solution

Tsk tsk

The NZ Herald has got itself a copy of Nationals’ December 2004 board minutes.

Luckily for National the minutes are quite mundane, but there will be considerable angst over how they got out. A deliberate leak is almost unthinkable, so my presumption is a copy was carelessly left somewhere.

Student Debt Projections

I’ve gone to some official stats to try and estimate how much student debt will blow out by, due to Labour’s policy pledge. These come from the 2004 annual report on the student loan scheme.

In 2003 156,250 students borrowed $987 million, an average of $6,300 each. Only 60% of eligible students borrowed, and as more part-time students are now eligible the projected rate was 55%.

Now as one would have to be clinically insane not to borrow interest free money, the borrowing rate could go up to 100%. Allowing for 10% clinical insanity, I’ll assume 90% borrowing rate which means an extra 99,500 people will borrow. Let’s say 100,000 more.

So each year 100,000 more borrowers at the average of $6,300 is an extra $630 million a year borrowed.

Now in 2003 there were also 428,000 students enrolled at tertiary level, so this is still quite conservative predicting only 255,000 borrowers.

Of the $2.3b repaid since the scheme began, $1.2b has been compulsory repayments and $1.1b voluntary. Last year $200 million was voluntarily repaid.

Finally we also have that the average amount borrowed was $6,300, and now there will be no incentive to borrow less than the maximum which looks to be for an average student $9,000 to cover fees, materials and allowance. But again I will be conservative and say only an extra $1,000 will be borrowed per student, so this increase borrowing each year by $250 million.

Therefore we have a conservative scenario of an extra $880 million a year borrowed and $200 million a year of less payments. This is extra student debt of $1.1b a year. Against this you have $300 million a year of less interest so I think a conservative prediction is an extra $800 million a year of student debt.

So over a 15 year period, the total amount of student debt is likely to increase by $12 billion. And this excludes any upsurge in enrolments in wananga type courses due to the interest free money on offer to enrol.

Now this is just my unofficial calculations but the official ones when released after the election (would be a good idea for someone to try and PQ or OIA them beforehand) I am sure will also show a massive increase. When Labour did interest free loans while studying I predicted it would increase long-term debt projections, and indeed the official projections almost doubled. This will have at least as large an effect.

So people should be very aware of the huge distortions in incentives this policy will have. The incentive is to borrow the maximum and to never ever repay more than the minimum.

People should also read Kiwi Pundit on how Labour’s calculator is somewhat misleading.

Labour’s Student Loan Policy

Labour has announced it will scrap all interest payment on student loans. This will be popular in some areas, but I suggets people look very carefully about the motivations it now gives people:

1) You will be insane if as a student you do not take out a student loan. 100% of students will take loans out.

2) You will also be insane if you do not borrow the maximum amount. Even to stick it in the bank. Students are not stupid and like interest free money.

3) Likewise one would be insane to ever make a voluntary repayment. Given a choice of repaying a student loan or paying off a mortgage or even sticking money in a bank, there will be zero incentive to make voluntary repayments.

So what will be the overall effect of the policy? Total student debt is going to explode. It will be easier for some individual students, but overall student debt will have no limits on haw fast it will grow.

This is a prime example of something which looks attractive, but in fact is extremely bad public policy.

$11b surplus

Rodney Hide makes an excellent point on his blog. The official surplus projection for 2008/09 is $5.3b. But this includes an allowance for extra spending of $1.9b per year cumulative. This means on current expenditure one in fact is looking to have an $11b+ surplus in 2008/09.

Now it is sensible to have some allowance for additional spending initiatives but there is nothing magical about $1.9b/year cumulative. It used to be $600m a year.