Reaction Roundup on Doonegate

The NZ Herald has done a roundup of reactions from media, newsletters and blogs on Doonegate. The sources quoted are:

The Press
NZ Herald
Public Address
Just Left
Me
NBR
Transtasman
Molesworth & Featherston

It’s a nice wee feature that provides a good snapshot of the range of views.

Police Statistics

One of the issues which has not got much coverage is the highly misleading nature of the Police statistics with regard to 111 calls.

The Government and its proxies have repeated ad nauseam that there are no issues with police resources because the police stats show reported crime is down, and that x% oif 111 calls are answered with 10 seconds.

However the inquiry reports has discovered that 3,000 calls a month actually wait for longer than 75 seconds, get transferred to another centre, and then if answered there within 10 seconds is recorded as meeting the criteria.

The report scathingly concludes “Of concern, is that this practice essentially invalidates the reported call answering time statistics and indicates that the actual performance is lower.”

Now having found out that one set of police statistics is basically false, or invalid, one does have to wonder about the levels of recorded crime. Especially as more and more police officers have spoken up claiming some crime is not being recorded, and some crimes are listed as resolved when they have not been.

The credibility of any police statistics will be suspect for some time to come.

Past behaviour

As is obvious, I believe it is not just appropriate, but in fact expected, that the Opposition focus on the role of the PM in leaking information to the SST to force the Commissioner of Police to resign.

Characterising it as “the politics of personal destruction, as Jordan did, is nonsense. The fact that Clark’s actions have been condemned by almost every major editorial speaks volumes. This is an issue about how the Prime Minister used information in her role as PM. What could be more relevant?

The David Benson-Pope issue is less clear cut. The allegations relate not to anything he has done as an MP, but in his former occupation. As a general rule (but there are exceptions) I do not think it is relevant to traverse such allegations. The exceptions are illegal behaviour and hypocrisy.

I think almost everyone has a past. I know I do. For example I was a cub/scout/venturer leader for 15 years or so until 1995. Enjoyed it greatly and as far as I know no-one I had responsibility for has any issue with me, in fact to the contrary many of them are good friends today. But I can recall once or twice moving a disruptive 8 year old kid into a corner by judicious use of the vulcan death hold (ie holding their neck). And once one of the venturers pushed me down a 15 foot bank into a river (he was meaning to push me and grab me but forgot to grab me) and after bouncing off some rocks and landing in the river I was fairly (very) annoyed and promptly chased him down and dunked him myself. Nothing I regard as wrong, but stuff that could look bad out of context 20 years on. And shock horror even had drinks with some of the 16 and 17 year olds on occasion.

Anyway enough of my errant past, but onto the DBP issue. There appear to be a number (not just one) of ex pupils who say that DBP acted in ways which were outlined in the House. One of them has spoken on the Linda Clark show and Berend de Boer has the audio here. It is worth listening to. The gentleman concerned obviously is not at all a fan of DBP. Some may say that is because he was caned by him, but I got caned heaps and heaps at school, and do not hold any grudges against the teachers who did so.

Even if one accepts the allegations are true (and that is another issue) the question does remain whether the allegations are relevant to his role today.

Here it is a judgement call. The context is that DBP is not just a Minister, but the Minister in charge of schools. And he is launching an anti-bullying campaign. This is getting close to the hypocrisy area, if the allegations of bullying pupils are true. And the allegations of having caused one pupil to bleed from caning, and another from hitting his nose, are in fact allegations of illegal behaviour.

To some degree this is now somewhat academic, as DBP has denied all the allegations. Russell Brown points out this now turns into a matter of misleading Parliament, if the former pupils speak out.

I am still uneasy about whether it was a good idea to ask DBP in Parliament if the allegations were true. However one does wonder that if a group of ex-pupils have been pushing the allegations for five years, what must have happened to them to keep the grievance going for so long?

Berryman Ruling

Press Editorial on Doonegate

The Press has an editorial on Doonegate which I think nicely puts things in perspective. They highlight that Clark was elected promising to bring integrity and honesty to the political process and instead that she acted in a way “that would have made former prime minister Sir Robert Muldoon proud” as questions about the employment of the Commissioner of Police must be handled with complete constitutional propriety.

The Press also comments on how her statement “by definition, I cannot leak” was an obvious comparison to what Richard Nixon said. It is interesting that they use the abridged version of the Nixon quote, which has been used on blogs, rather than Nixon’s fuller quote which is “Well, when the President does it, that means that it is not illegal”. However the NZ Herald used the fuller quote.

Another blonde moment

Defending the PM

The behaviour of the PM in Doonegate has been so hard to defend, that it has been significant that the ‘left’ bloggers have almost all been silent on the issue.

However Jordan has now waded in. Sir Humphrey has already done a rebuttal, but I will also comment.

Jordan is careful not to defend what the PM did (who could) but says right wing bloggers have been hysterical in comparing Clark to Nixon. He overlooks that the NZ Herald have also compared her, as have the leaders of National and ACT. He also overlooks that people have not been comparing her actions so much as her attitude, and to be honest the quote she used about by definition not being able to leak is so perfect a fit for what Nixon said, that it is more than fair game.

Jordan then attacks those critical of police performance, putting aside that the Police’s own inquiry into 111 calls was brutal with the failings of the current system. Obviously Jordan feels that the Opposition should not point out when the 111 system is broken.

Then Jordan pushes the Labour spin line that the right are defending Peter Doone. For God’s sake I have stated half a dozen times I think he should have resigned. It is puerile to suggest that by being critical of Clark, one is defending Doone. It is not a bi-polar choice.

Then Jordan pushes Helen’s latest conspiracy theory that the Doones are co-operating with centre-right parties by leaking stuff to them. Does the absence of a shred of proof count at all?

Finally I love how Jordan calls criticising the PM over her having spread lies about the Police Commissioner as gutter politics. How then does he characterise Helen Clark’s attacks on Jenny Shipley over whom she had dinner with?

The interesting thing is not once does Jordan defend the actions of Helen Clark, he just says that it is unfair that the Opposition criticise her for her actions.

Almost a Darwin Award

Thanks to Robin Capper for the link to the story of a bored teenager who burnt the plastic ties of a shipping container and ended up swamped up to his chest in peas. Police used a forklift to get the youth out.

A few more peas in there and he could have qualified for a Darwin Award.

Today

The 111 system

Well where do you start? Who thought it was as bad as this?

The 111 system is the frontline of policing. Even if nothing else is up to scratch, people want to know that if the need help and call 111, the Police will be there. We can put up with not investigating burglaries much etc but the 111 system underpins our overall confidence in the Police.

I won’t even repeat that call that everyone else is making for Hawkins to resign. The whole country has no confidence in him, but to keep the Labour factions appeased he is untouchable until after the election. I am sure I remember Hawkins telling everyone that there were no problems, just the odd slip-up. Well 61 recommendations puts paid to that.

The NZ Herald has a useful report summary here and the full report is here.

Clark vs Nixon

The papers have reported the Nixonian comparisons at some length with both Dr Brash and Rodney Hide making the comparisons in the House.

I should state for the record that I don’t think anyone thinks Clark has committed crimes and commissioned break-ins etc. The comparison is about the arrogance of believing that your position allows you to do things such as leak incorrect details from an independent report.

The NZ Herald quotes from the Nixon David Frost interview.

The NZPA report on Stuff focuses on the ridiculous claims (invented by Clark as a desperate ploy to distract) that the Doones are being bankrolled by National Party associates.

Meanwhile in the Press, they report that the original tapes may have been lost between law firms, but almost certainly transcripts do exist.

Clark vs Peters

Whenever it is Clark vs Peters in the House, I suspect I am not the only one who doesn’t know who to cheer for.

Anyway I will give kudos to Clark (or her staff who did the research) for pointing out to Peters that when he was Deputy PM there were 2,627 spontaneous asylum seekers and last year there were only 714 – a 73% drop.

Peters is very effective at attacking others, but in almost 30 years in politics he has achieved almost nothing. Since he returned to the House in 1984 he has gone into every single election voting against the Government of the day on confidence and supply.

No tax cuts, we’ve spent it all

Australian Treasurer Peter Costello has delivered his third tax cut in three years, and at the same time as also increasing spending in key areas. That is a nice balanced approach.

The latest round will deliver $23 billion of tax relief. And despite the Australian surplus being less than one quarter the size of the ONZ surplus Dr Cullen says he will not give any back, instead he is going to spend it all.

The size of the surplus is so large that it has been embarrassing Dr Cullen. He has tried to obscure it, but having failed I now predict the spend-up in the budget will be the largest in history, so he can claim there is no possibility for tax reduction.

Garth George on Government spin

Tricky Clarky

The proclamation of our beloved leader yesterday that she “by definition, can not leak” has inspired an artist out there, whom I suspect reads this blog, as I have just been e-mailed the picture below.

Do feel free to e-mail around the image or the URL.

Tricky Clarky2.jpg

UPDATE: Don Brash has just used the Nixon quote in the House, and referred to Fran O’Sullivan’s description of her behaviour as Nixonian. Dim has started something here!

Blond Moment

Just had to share this tale from the weekend of a young student named Rachel who earlier this year was in a shop. She wanted to know the time so asked the shop assistant if she could tell her the time.

The shop assistant it seems replied in an unbelieving tone, “This is a clock store, there are nine clocks in front of you”.

Rachel is not blond, so we can only give her honorary status. Heh.

Silent Running’s 1st podcast

Silent Running have done their first podcast.

Was good listening. Tom Paine has a good “radio” voice. They have an interview with Rodney Hide about how he got into blogging etc. I got slightly alarmed when Rodney said that he got to know me intimately through reading my blog 🙂

Defending Labour from Jordan!

Jordan Carter has blogged his disappointment that Labour are not applying the same principles to tertiary education as they are to legal aid.

I can not resist the temptation to defend the Labour Government from Jordan’s criticism.

Jordan contrasts “It is based on the principle that access to justice ought not to depend on the ability to pay” with “The cost of participating in tertiary education is a significant investment for many individuals and their families”.

One has to look at why people access the justice system and why they undertake tertiary education.

The majority of people needing legal aid, would rather not be accessing the justice system. They are either defendants in criminal cases or having to get a protection order etc. I am comfortable with the notion that poor people charged with a crime should be able to have a lawyer represent them in court, and hence support legal aid (although there are areas which need changing).

Tertiary education is different. People choose to undertake tertiary education because they see benefit in doing so. Yes there is benefit to society also, and that is why the cost is split between the taxpayer and the student. I have issues with allowance eligibility and the exact split between taxpayer and student, but have no problem in saying that it is fair and reasonable that students pay some of the costs of tertiary study.

After all on average a graduate will earn over $500,000 more than a non graduate during their working life.

A must read editorial

The Dominion Post editorial on the education sector is a must read.

The editorial concludes that the education sector looks like a hospital emergency ward, pointing out:

* Te Wananga O Aotearoa on life support
* The New Zealand Qualifications Authority is reeling from two damning inquiries
* The Education Ministry has been implicated in the scholarship debacle
* The Tertiary Education Commission is under fire for its oversight of the wananga and funding of “sub-degree” courses.

With regard to the latter, they report that between 1999 and 2003, the number of students enrolled in sub-degree courses increased from 165,000 to a staggering 750,000. Some offered nothing more than a sing-along to Maori lessons, twilight golf or diving practice in Tonga for non-existent jobs. Students were recruited at shopping malls and burger bars and lured by the promise of free computers and mobile phones. But it took till 2004 for the Government to curb the growth of community education, the most frequently abused category of sub-degree courses.

The editorial concludes:

At some point, ministers have to take responsibility for what is happening on their watch. The problems in the education system cannot be explained simply as the doings of a handful of poor administrators.

Ministers have taken their eyes off the ball. Institutions have been allowed to spend vast sums of public money without adequate scrutiny.

Mr Mallard has admitted that he and Mr Maharey both had concerns about the wananga before becoming part of the Government in 1999. At that point, the wananga was receiving $4 million of government funding. Last year, it received $239 million.

Given their earlier concerns about “excessive growth, uneven levels of quality assurance, and management and governance capability”, it beggars belief that they did not act earlier. No organisation can grow that fast without problems.

That it was able to is an indictment on all concerned.

Objectionable Unbound

Peter Cresswell has links to (and a jpg of) the Chief Censor’s ruling that the magazine published 15 years ago is deemed objectionable.

I agree that the magazine is objectionable, both in the legal sense and the wider sense.

Peter expresses his deep scepticism that Jim Peron was not the publisher. Others say there is no concrete proof. Not sure either camp can persuade the other.

Millsy’s fine beer blog

The arrogance

Clark was just asked in the House whether she was setting a bad example for others by leaking cabinet documents.

Her reply was staggering in the arrogance.

Basically it was that it is up to the PM how all documents are released and “by definition I can not leak”.

So even bodies with statutory independence like the Police Complaints Authority, are subject to the PM’s whim as to how their reports are made public.

UPDATE: Dim in the comments provides the comparison quote, which is nicely appropriate:

‘If the president does it, it’s not illegal.’

– Richard M Nixon. 1977

UPDATE 2: Rodney has the Hansard quotes.

Also love comment no 6 on Rodney’s blog by Darren – “By definition I cannot leak- but Dover Samuels can!!!”

The tapes exist!

Thugs strike again

Last week all four tyres on the mobile billboard for Mark Blumsky were slashed.

Last night Mark’s campaign car was also vandalised with a window smashed.

It was in a car lot with 40 other vehicles, none of which were touched. There is no doubt it was politically motivated. We are informing the Police, not that there is a great chance of identifying who did it.

I am very dismayed that at such an early stage in the campaign this criminal vandalism is happening, and with such costly and serious damage. There is just no excuse for this.

Thank you very much for your kind donations