Minto Bar gets $20,000

Former MP Ross Meurant has auctioned and then sold his former red squad baton for $20,000. He labeled it as a “Minto Bar” which not surprisingly has upset John Minto. Personally if I was John Minto I’d be more upset that someone was willing to pay $20,000 for it.

There is no truth to the rumour that the successful buyer was Trevor Mallard

Helen Clark loses election

Yes it is true – Labour MP Helen Clark has just been defeated and lost an election.

Not the NZ Helen Clark unfortunately, but a minute ago the UK Labour MP Helen Clark lost the seat of Peterborough. She had a majority of 2,854 and Stewart Jackson (Conservative) has won the seat.

Exit Polls predict large reduction in Blair majority

The exit polls (which do get it wrong as we saw in the US) are predicting Labour 37%, Conseratives 33% and Lib Dems 22%.

Assuming a uniform swing, this would reduce the majority from 159 to 66 with Labour having 356 seats, Conseratives 209 seats and Lib Dems 53 seats.

However swings are very rarely uniform, so results may vary significantly.

Foreign Billionaire funds Labour

One could only imagine the outcry if it was revealed a billionaire who has not lived in NZ for 40 years, had donated half a million to National.

Labour would be demanding to know what has been promised in exchange, and that it is evidence of the party putting the interests of foreign billionaires over that of ordinary NZers.

However as he gave $500,000 to Labour, then that is okay.

I presume it is the Owen Glenn whose company paid $800,000 to settle a case brought by the US Federal Maritime Commission Bureau of Enforcement.

Just to be clear, I have absolutely no problems with large donations to political parties, and Mr Glenn has very generously given to many good causes over the years.

However I have no doubt that if the only difference in the story was the donation was to National, not Labour, then the first paragraph would be:

“There has been wide-spread condemnation of the revelation that a billionaire who has not lived in NZ for 40 years has been funding the National Party with the largest donation in electoral history. Mr Glenn, who was prosecuted by US authorities and paid $800,000 in a settlement, had previously made secret donations, but they now stand revealed. In the US people can not donate more than $2,000 to a party, and donations from foreigners are banned. The donation scandal has led to calls for similar restrictions in NZ …… “

Tamihere’s Cats

The Gracchi Brothers

Richard at Philosophy, et cetera has an essay on whether the Gracchi brothers were genuine reformers or just political opportunists.

For those who, like me, enjoy studying the Roman Republic it is a good read.

Personally I disagree with Richard that they were reformers. I think they were the first in a long line of populists who destroyed the very stable government that the republic was. The Gracchi are probably second most culpable after Gaius Marius.

Should Swain resign?

As Peters names a third Saddamite in New Zealand, the question has to be asked whether Paul Swain should resign as Minister of Immigration?

I don’t mean resign in the sense of any personal wrong-doing, but in line with the honourable tradition that when a Department fails so miserably, the Ministers steps aside as a sign of accountability. Personally Paul Swain is (in my opinion) one of the better Ministers in the Government, and I will always hold him in some high regard for recommending to Cabinet that the telephone local loop be unbundled. So I am not suggesting he be removed from Cabinet, but that he resign the portfolio as a way of signifying to his department how bad their failure has been, and a new Minister can come in and kick some heads in. Having a Minister fall on their sword is the most powerful signal one can send to a Department about how badly they have failed.

I do not like NZ First’s stance on immigration. I think they have done a huge amount of scare mongering over the years. However the failures of NZIS (and there have been many over the years including the lie in unison scandal) have now given Peters some credibility. That may come to be the true tragedy.

More Immigrants

Slang

Sideswipe has a list of nostalgic slang words from previous generations.

I had heard of or used dork, gripper, goober, wicked, grouse, rad, pash, snog, PDA, yonks, spack, spaz, munted, stink and choice.

Incidentially PDAs should be banned!!

Hadn’t heard the term mole patrol before, but pissing myself laughing at the term.

UPDATE: Nick Enyon has his own list of slang terms. Very funny.

Labour’s taxes and levies

Mallard does his usual act

The more badly the PM has stuffed up, the more ferocious the defence is.

Trevor Mallard did one of his usual performances yesterday when he claimed, under parliamentary privilege, former Commissioner Doone was drunk and interfered with the constable who breath tested his partner.

Labour are desperate to make Doone, not Clark, the issue. This is a red herring. As I have previously said (and the NZ Herald) one can form the view that Doone’s actions meant he could not continue, however it was still incredibly unethical and inappropriate to misrepresent the contents of confidential reports to a newspaper as a way to pressure him.

I also opine that if Mallard really has evidence that Doone was drunk and actively interfered with a police constable, then why did the Government not sack him, rather than give him a six month golden handshake?

Clark insisted in the house that all she would have done is tell the SST that details of the incident are contested. This is at total variance with what the reporter has said and I suspect the transcripts or the actual tapes will reveal this.

Silent Running expands

The editor of Salient, Emily Braunstein, has joined the Silent Running blog. Emily was previously featured on this blog for a mild controversy over the editing of the letters page.

It is rather ironic the editor of Salient is going to be blogging for one of the major right-wing blogs while her news editor blogs for the major left-wing blog – Public Address.

Oh and talking of Silent Running, yesterday I got a lovely surprise postcard from their patron goddess, Risawn, who is on service in Kosovo. Just shows the benefits of making offerings 🙂

Clark wants more powers for NZIS

The PM on Breakfast TV has just said that she wants more powers for the Immigration Service, to stop a repeat of the Iraqi officials fiasco, so they can do more investigations.

This seems to miss the point entirely. The diplomat actually wrote on his form his former role, and NZIS just did nothing with it. No amount of extra powers would fix that. It is the incompetence of NZIS that is the issue.

Personally I’d be nervous about giving an incompetent department even more powers.

Full Laura Bush Transcript

USA Today has the full transcript of Laura Bush’s comedy routine to the White House Correspondents’ Association.

Even though there was professional assistance with the script, delivery still counts and the standing ovation signifies how well down it went. What I like most of all was that she played on all the stereotypes about her husband – that he is lazy, dumb, has bad pronounciation (well that one is true), and loves destroying things.

Bloggers on TV

Stephen Cooper reports on David Young of DBM making an appearance on Eye to Eye. I missed it unfortunately.

Aaron Bhatnagar also reports that an item on blogging will be on Holmes tonight. It will feature interviews with Aaron plus Russell Brown and myself jointly. Must set the video!

UPDATE: Ali Mau from Holmes has just advised that it will now probably air on Thursday evening, as they still have an interview to be filmed.

Another tax – oh yay

Labour is expected to announce an array of new taxes today. They could push up food prices by 1.3% and public transport costs by 1.4%.

And what worthy causes does the Government spend our hard earned money on? A glossary of youth speak!!!

I’m sorry but I do not want my earnings taken off me, so parents can have a brochure telling them what phat and and skux are. Besides the whole point of teenage slang is that the olds don’t understand it!

Exposing the PM’s involvement

There has been considerable debate over whether the SST was justified in allowing the PM’s involvement in Doonegate to be exposed.

The NZ Herald Editorial takes the view that it was not justified, and takes a swipe at Fairfax, owners of the SST.

Former Dominion editor Richard Long writes that the convention to protect confidential sources is designed to “protect whistleblowers uncovering conspiracies and dastardly deeds” as in the the Watergate case of Deep Throat.

Long says that having the PM confirm *five* times the incorrect information is a different case as Helen Clark was not uncovering a grave injustice, a conspiracy, or dastardly deeds that needed to be exposed for the public good. Instead the only person benefiting from her actions, was in fact herself. Thus the convention is not there so the most powerful person in the land can misuse her powers against an individual and in the process misled a newspaper, its readers and caused the individual personal damage.

Richard Long is of course not just the former editor of the Dominion, but also my former boss, being Don Brash’s chief of staff.

Breast Feeding Age

Alison Barrett, clinical director of maternity services at Waikato Hospital, writes in the NZ Herald about how she still breast feeds her daughter who will soon turn five.

I am of course no expert on breast feeding, but my gut reaction is that having not weaned your child by the time they enter school is psychologically unhealthy for the child. The most extreme example of this was David Bain’s family, whose mother breast fed them until they were 13.

Dr Barrett says that the decision on when to stop breast feeding should rest with the child. Umm I think this is asking rather too much of your average two year old. You know “Hey Mum, I think I’d like to stop breast feeding now and try diet coke instead”.

Saddam’s official in NZ

Winston has just said that the Saddam official he has been referring may not be the diplomat that the Government has admitted to discovering.

Peters claims that the person he is referring to is a former Minister of Agriculture and Agrarian Reform for Saddam. He also claimed he was in NZ only since March on a UN passport of all things. And the diplomat has been here for a year, so it is a mismatch.

Clark will not name the person they have located, on the basis doing so may allow him to claim refugee status.

It looks like there are two former officials here! The former diplomat has been here a year, and only found out because they searched for all Iraqi passport holders.

The other one was on a UN passport. Winston named him but I have no chance of spelling it right based on phonetics. A quick Google suggests it might be Aziz Salih al-Numan. I will try to confirm this.

The fact he came here on a UN passport suggests there is more to this than meets the eye. Getting even messier for the Government that they found the wrong person!

UPDATE: The Minister is called Amer Mahdi Alkhashali, as named in a NZF press release. He was delegate to the FAO back in 1981, so not exactly a current regime member it seems.

Ambiguous terrorism guide

Just got sent an e-mail version of this webpage which points out in a very humourous way that many of the official pictures being used by the US Government for coping with terrorism are ambiguous.

The Michael Jackson one is my favourite.

A thoughtful defence piece

UK Political Guide

.nz names dispute policy

Both the Dominion Post and the NZ Herald have stories on the recommendation by an InternetNZ working group to introduce a dispute resolution process (involving meditation and arbitration).

The two stories have most of the details, but those interested in the details, and the reasoning can look at the paper here. This is not the final policy which is yet to be drafted, and consulted on.

Again, I’m a member of the panel which made the recommendation, so my view is obviously in favour, but feedback always welcome.

Clark claims evidence was contested

The SST has claimed that Helen Clark told them that the official reports into Doonegate indicated he said “that won’t be necessary”. Neither of the official reports did say that, which exposes her very badly.

She has responded that there was contested evidence on what Doone said. This may be true, but it misses the point.

An investigation into the behaviour of the top police officer in NZ is a matter of the gravest importance. The formal investigations are the ones charged with finding out what happened and testing any contested evidence. When you have the PM leaking untested allegations, it absolutely undermines the process. How on earth could she have thought it was appropriate to say *anything* at all while the reports were not final?

Some in the media and Labour are trying to make this an issue on whether or not Doone should have resigned or did anything wrong. That is not the issue. For what it is worth, I believe his other actions were enough to make it untenable for him to continue.

The issue is the PM’s egging on of a newspaper to pressure her own Commissioner of Police. Yesterday NZPA reported her saying that her ‘open relationship’ with journalists is in ‘the interest of open government’. This is almost farcical.

If the PM wished to comment ‘on the record’ to the newspaper and be quoted as saying the report says so and so, then that is in the interest of open government. An anonymous confirmation of a false or unproved rumour about what the Police Commissioner said is nothing to do with open government.

Peters gets it partly right

Firstly it must be acknowledge that Winston Peters has got something of a hit. He did break the news that someone who worked for Saddam Hussein has been living in NZ.

The man actually declared this on his immigration forms, but this was overlooked so the Minister only found out due to Peters. That is shocking, and Peters deserves credit for the detective work involved.

However as usual, it seems he has over-stated his case. He claims the man was a Government Minister when it appears he was only a diplomat. We’ll see who was right when the name is revealed today.

But either way a very bad look for the Government.