Who will replace Helen?

The NZ Herald has done a poll on who in Labour should replace Helen Clark when she steps down as Labour Leader (hopefully on 25 September!).

The online version doesn’t have full results, but the order is:

1) Michael CUllen
2) Phil Goff
3) John Tamihere
4) Trevor Mallard
5) Steve Maharey

Dr Cullen is acknowledged as likely to be a temporary leader only.

Goff desperately wants the job but it is highly unlikely he could get significant support as the left can’t stand him for his law and order policies.

I have more chance of being elected Leader of the Labour Party than John Tamihere does.

Trevor Mallard can not be ruled out as an option. There are concerns over his aggressive style, and whether he has the ability to appear “presidential”.

Steve Maharey was once a reasonable contender but his absolute failure in tertiary education is a big black mark.

David Benson-Pope has been rumoured to be Clark’s personal choice as her sucessor.

Mark Gosche was once seen as a future leader, but he never really excelled in Cabinet and family illness has seen him out of the limelight.

Oh of course Darren Hughes has his eyes on the top job!

Student Allowances

Keith Ng has done some very good work by scooping a story on how the proportion of students receiving a student allowance under Labour has fallen by a massive 32%.

Ng points out that Labour made changes to allowances in last year’s budget which they claimed would deliver allowances to 28,000 more students. However the number on allowances actually went down by 3,000 so they were 31,000 out. And of course they have tried to keep this quiet, until Keith did his investigation.

The key issue is the threshold level for parental income has not increased, making more and more people ineligible. The same thing happens with income tax with more and more families each year being subjected to higher tax rates, as they move into new tax brackets.

Jordan Carter tries to add to the Mallard spin that at least the students are benefiting by their families being better off and calls for the government to lift parental income thresholds.

Personally I don’t want to see parental income thresholds lifted. I want to see them abolished. It is fairly ludicrous to declare a 24 year old is a dependent child. Fiscally it would be difficult to abolish them overnight, but a good start would be to reduce the age it applies to gradually. Say drop it to 21 over four years.

Frog has also croaked in with some nice research showing as recently as a few weeks ago Mallard was still proclaiming 36,000 more students will benefit. Lies, damned lies and statistics indeed. Labour probably knew by March that less students were getting an allowance so instead they spoke about the number of students the change was “designed to benefit”.

Bill English has commented here and here. In the latter release he ridicules Mallard’s statement that “part-time work is a disincentive to students picking up a student allowance” as giving students the Heineken treatment.

The NZ Herald has picked up the story, crediting ASPA whom Ng works for. They mainly just rehash the releases.

SPSS

If you think SPSS stands for smart pretty sexy slappers then you do not need to read any further.

If you live/work in Wellington, do know what SPSS actually stands for, and you are reasonably experienced with it, especially the reporting side, and would like to earn some quick and dirty money then please e-mail me on [email protected] today or tomorrow.

$50b more tax paid

John Key has just pointed out that the amount of cumulative extra tax paid since Labour came into office has been $50 billion. Think if taxation had been kept steady, then the average household would each have around $25,000 more money.

In 1999/2000 total taxation was only $34B. Over the previous nine years this had increased 25% from $26B in 1990/01. On the current forecast under Labour tax revenue over nine years will reach $55B in 2008/09, which is a massive 69% increase.

NZ is (I think) the only country in the world in recent years which has increased tax rates, not decreased them.

Southpark Conservatives

Phil on whoar links to an excellent article in the New York Times about Southpark Conservatives.

Phil thinks the right likes South Park because it has taken the piss out of Michael Moore and others, but think somehow I might be upset because they also took the piss out of the Republicans over the Terri Schiavo controversy.

I can only presume he missed this post on 2 April when I blogged approvingly about that exact episode. It was one of their best ones.

I like South Park because it is funny. I don’t care who it takes the piss out of, as long as they are funny doing that. Having said that it does tend to target “do gooders” on both the right and left, and as both equally annoy me I like it even more.

Likewise I love West Wing for the scripts and acting, not because I think Jed Bartlett’s policies are any good.

Accepting govt spin on numbers

Rodney Hide has an excellent piece of how the headlines of $3 billion more for defence, may in fact be a reduction in spending on defence as a proportion of GDP.

The key issues are how many years is this extra funding spread over, and how much is operational vs capital. For example an extra $1billion for a frigate to last 30 years is only $33 million or so per year.

It would be great if media actually refused to just take the spin as their headline, and actually analysed the actual composition of the package.

On a similar note I broke down the spin in January on the $225 million transport package for Wellington to point out that it it just $14 million a year for new roads, and that would only get you 500 metres a year of motorway.

To be fair when I worked in Government we enjoyed that the media would also take our funding packages over many years, and report them verbatim. However would be nice to have better scrutiny applied to all Governments.

Treasury backs mums against Clark

It is truly ironic that we have the Treasury, often categorised as an uncaring agency, defending mothers and pouring cold water on Helen Clark’s plans to get more mums back to work.

The Treasury report points out the desirability of time spent with young children, says getting more mothers into work was not the best way to help the economy (increasing productivity, or the value of goods and services people produce is) and says unpaid activities such child rearing, housework and leisure “are nonetheless valuable and contribute to the overall welfare of the country”.

However as this advice contradicts what the PM said, it has been removed from the Treasury website.

Congratulations Des & John

A nice story and photo in the Dominion Post of John Joliff and Des Smith who had their civil union yesterday.

As I have said before, in ten years most people will ask what all the fuss was about.

Good to see Kerry Predergast as the celebrant. Wellington has been lucky to have very inclusive Mayors since at least 1992.

Hunt’s Pension

Even the Greens, not known for commenting much on these sort of issues, have said that Jonathan Hunt’s inquiries into getting a UK pension, while serving as the NZ High Commissioner to the UK, is embarrassing.

I can just see the headlines in the UK tabloids. “NZ High Commissioner receiving over $200,000 a year claims pension off UK Government – meanwhile Mrs Jones survives on $10,000 a year after losing her husband in the Gulf War”.

I’m not one to say one should turn down cash you are entitled to, but when you are the representative of a foreign government, it would seem politically very unwise to even consider claiming payments from the country you are sent to.

Laura Bush the comedian

Laura Bush had a White House press dinner in hysterics as she stole the show, with a series of one-liners far removed from her normal librarian image.

The line which really floored people was:

“But I’m proud of George. He’s learnt a lot about ranching since that first year when he tried to milk the horse. What’s worse, it was a male horse.”

Heh.

The women of Tom Cruise

When Tom Cruise dumped Nicole Kidman, I thought he was mad, as I regarded Kidman as stunningly beautiful (I have a weakness for redheads).

Then last weekend I saw Penelope Criz in Sahara, and started to think that maybe he hadn’t done too badly by moving on.

Now this week it is revealed he is now dating Katie Holmes. I sat through every episode of Dawson’s Creek, just for her. Sigh!

Clark implicated further in Doone affair

The latest revelations in the Doone affair paint the PM in a far worse light than previous revelations. Today we learn that:

* Helen Clark encouraged the newspaper, and in one case said to hang tough
* Helen Clark said she was relying on an inquiry report but the four words (that won’t be necessary) were not in the report, issued publicly two weeks later
* Even after Doone publicly threatened to sue the newspaper, Helen Clark privately reassured the journalists their story had been correct
* According to the editor’s evidence, Helen Clark was adamant the paper had not reported any incorrect information
* Clark encouraged the newspaper to continue its investigation as the matter was reaching its critical stages.

Jonathan Milne sums it up by saying “not only did Clark use backdoor methods to undermine her “independent” police commissioner, but she somehow managed to misrepresent the contents of deputy police commissioner Rob Robinson’s report into his boss’s actions.”

$75/week for $1m state house

I have no problems with the state assisting low income people with accommodation costs. But we see again an example of why income adjusted rent is a very inefficient way of providing assistance.

A $1m house is providing accommodation for a family for just $75/week. One could help three or four families into accommodation for the money tied up in that one house.

The accommodation supplement assists all low income families, instead of just those who have Housing NZ as the landlord.

April 2005 NZ Political Blog Statistics

March 2005 NZ Political Blog Statistics

A couple of new blogs and again a a few blogs dropping away. The number of need a life bloggers has increased significantly. Must be an election on!

Thanks to all those who sent their stats through – a real time saver.

Posts/Comments

Lite Bloggers

Number 8 Wire 2 7
Gman 3 3
Doing It Right 3 9
Kiwi Jew Pundit 4 4
Benzylpiperazine 4 8
Sagenz 5 12
Right kind of girl 5 26
Observationz 6 6
Sparrows are cool 6 6
Joe Hendren 6 17
Left and Lefter 6 27
James Gribble 7 1
Genius NZ 7 9
Industrial Relationz 9 0
Dog Biting Men 9

Medium Bloggers

Gun Control 10 3
Wilson’s World 10 9
Excruciatingly Correct Behaviour 11 25
Fighting Talk 11
Looke 12 4
VUWSA Pres 13 22
Three Point Turn 13 29
Kea 14 0
Peter Metcalfe 15 10
Hard News 15
Bertrand Bargolias 16 73
Darkness Network 17 11
Canary in the Mine 20
Michael Ellis 21 10
Gareth Robinson 23 8
Gonzo 23 16
Kiwi Pundit 24 19
MediaNZ 26 2
Big News 28 31

Heavy Bloggers (more than daily)

Home, throne & altar 31 68
Span 32 165
Just Left 37 412
Holden Republic 38 29
Zen State 41 47
I hate socialism 41 54
Philosphy et cetera 44 171
Philosphically Made 46 118
Bloggreen Aotearoa 53 19
NZ Political Comments 59 424
Prime Minister 77 53
NZ Pundit 85 412
Aaron Bhatnagar 95 255

Need a life bloggers

About Town 105 194
Frogblog 119 157
No Right Turn 123 392
Not PC 137 370
Rodney Hide 138 992
David Farrar 225 2752
Sir Humphrey’s 289 854
Whoar 355 51

We have eight over the 100/month mark and possibly Silent Running also (waiting for their stats).

The total number of posts on NZ political blogs was 2,574 in March with 8,396 comments made.

The average number of posts were 47 with 165 comments whiule the median was 20 posts and 25 comments.

Election Date Book

Hotel log: Samuels not sober

Hmmn this is interesting.

Labour whip Darren Hughes said yesterday that during a meeting after the incident “there had been no suggestion from the hotel that Mr Samuels was drunk”.

Yet the log entry form the hotel says Samuels was “not sober”, was aggressive and yelled at hotel staff.

So who do we believe? The hotel who recorded the incident at the time, or the spin several weeks later?

Another bad headline

Locke supports Defence Chief

MPs Assets

The NZ Herald has done a search of public registers, to find out what assets are owned by MPs.

The house values are always interesting. I’ll summarise below the top few and bottom few:

Under $200,000 in property

Parekura Horomia $114,000 for two houses in Gisborne plus land in Wairoa!
Nanaia Mahuta $126,000 for a property in Waikato
Darren Hughes $141,000 for a house in Howowhenua
Dave Heroera $160,000 for a house in Manukau
Keith Locke $193,000 for a house in Auckland

Over $1,000,000 in property

Lockwood Smith $1,005,000 for four farms
Wayne Mapp $1,035,000 for houses in North Shore and Wellington
Phil Goff $1,045,000 in Manukau
Tariana Turia $1,140,000 for a house in Wanganui and farm in Rangitikei
Pansy Wong $1,154,750 for two houses and a plot.
Ann Hartley $1,233,000 for five houses in North Shore and Auckland
Richard Worth $1,330,000 for a house in Auckland
Maurice Williamson $1,450,000 for a house in Auckland and a house in Manukau
Sandra Goudie $1,450,000 for property in Hauraki District
Sue Kedgley $1,450,000 for a house in Wellington
Judith Tizard $1,530,000 for homes in Auckland and Coromandel
Dover Samuels $1,900,000 for motel and dwelling in Matauri Bay
Murray McCully $2,110,000 for three houses
Jim Sutton $2,120,000 farm in Waimate and flat in Wellington
Dail Jones $2,129,000 for five properites
David Carter $2,141,100 for four farms and a unit in Canterbury
Pita Paraone $2,260,000 for three orchards and a house
Muriel Newman $2,826,000 for three farms and a house
Brian Connell $2,940,000 for a farm in Ashburton and two properties in Christchurch
Shane Ardern $3,125,000 for two farms in South Taranaki
John Key $8,395,000 for four properties

No ACT MPs in the over $1,000,000 list. They must be better at hiding their assets 🙂

UPDATE: That is no ACT MPs except Deputy Leader Muriel Newman. Missed noticing her.

Internet Banking Fraud

Did the SST name a source?

Audrey Young in the NZ Herald says “The fact that a newspaper named a source of one of its stories about former Police Commissioner Peter Doone was a shock to the industry this week”.

However it is not clear to me, that they did. Later in the story we read that she was not subpoenaed, and in fact chose to give evidence to avoid Margaret Wilson having to testify, and also “to avoid the possibility of having her own involvement revealed by someone else giving evidence during the case”.

So I am unsure how that can be construed as the SST naming a source.

Later in the article, we read that the PM had the two official reports into Doone, and neither of them stated thet he said “That won

Interns in Washington

A Washington intern for the Daily Telegraph writes about how she is propositioned on an almost daily basis.

bfeatintern26.jpg

I could make some comment, about it being no surprise, but that would be wrong so I won’t 🙂

Her article is worth reading, because it does point out it is not just old politicians and lobbyists hitting on young interns, but also some interns do use their sex appeal to ‘climb the ladder’.

Life is much more boring in NZ. Office structures are much flatter in Parliament, so not much in the way of ladders to climb up. Generaly staff being involved with MPs has harmed not helped their careers I would say.

Monthly Blog Stats

For those political blogs which want to be part of my monthly stats roundup, it would be a great time-save to me, if you can count up late on Saturday the number of posts and comments for the month and send them to me ([email protected]). It takes hours to count them all up manually.

The dumbest hacker either

An article on Slashdot alerted me to this online chat transcript involving the world’s dumbest hacker.

Basically the person he is threatening to hack tells him that his IP address is 127.0.0.1 (which always point back to the person’s own machine). The moronic hacker gets to work and strangely he disappears. A few minutes later he is back saying “dude be happy my pc crashed otherwise you’d be gone” with no idea of why his PC crashed – his own hacking.

He then carries on hacking and boasting that he has deleted his victim’s G drive, F drive etc etc until he gets to the point where he says he is 30% through deleting the C Drive. At this point he disappears and has not been seen since.

Priceless!

Asian Flu

I really should stop linking to items on the Greens’ blog, because well deep down I do actually want to wipe them out 🙂

However they have pointed out Winston’s hypocrisy so well, I can’t resist a link. Winston is trying to scare-monger that by 2022 there will be more Asians than Maori (which is not what the stats say anyway), and the Greens point out that this is not consistent with his calls in the past for Maori to see themselves as New Zealanders first, Maori second.

In another blog item, the Greens claim credit for getting Civil Unions passed. Certainly their support was needed, but so was the support of those liberal National and ACT MPs who voted for it. No one party can claim credit for getting the law passed.