Useless useless useless

One can have an academic debate about whether NCEA is good or bad, but the reality is that if employers are saying “we had no idea how to interpret the results” you have a problem because the main use of school qualifications is to help students get an appropriate job.

And don’t even start me on the crap where they only list what you pass, and miss out what you don’t. Almost Orwellian.

Ratana support for Maori Party grows

The Dominion Post reports that some of Ratana’s parishes are setting up Maori Party branches.

I understand there is huge conflict within Ratana on their official support for Labour. The hierarchy want to stick with the deal, but the vast majority of the rank and file want to support the Maori Party.

I think there is no doubt the Maori Party will win at least five of the seven Maori seats. The only question is whether they get more than five with Mahuta and Tamihere being the only possible survivors.

Labour will deny this, but watch for very high list rankings for all their Maori MPs to protect them.

Rathergate Report is out

The report on the CBS fake memos scandal has been released and CBS has sacked four senior staff who worked on the 60 minutes story.

The full report is around 250 pages and is here as a pdf. Worth reading if you have the time to see how completely lacking in integrity and checks CBS were.

If you want commentary, good blogs on this are:

TVNewser
National Review
Rathergate
Rather Biased

Readers should consider that if a major TV network so totally fails to do even the most basic things right for a major political story just before a presidential election, what reliance you you place on all the other stories?

Overall the independent report seems to have been comprehensive. It has kicked for touch on the issue of political bias saying their actions gave the appearance of bias, but that one could not prove bias. I think it is very obvious that there was – but people will make their own conclusions on that.

The CBS story on themselves is here.

What proved to be the real killer for CBS was not just running the fake story, but their “blind defence” of the story for 12 days after it ran. Indeed to this day Mapes and Rather still defend the story.

Incredible research

and again …

RMA strikes again

Shoot the sub-editor

A NZ Herald sub-editor has supplied a headline of “Marriage celebrants ‘shun’ civil unions“.

I read the article expecting to find that very few marriage celebrants had signed up to be civil union celebrants, but in fact this was not the case. The advert asking for celebrants only went out this weekend, and the story is based purely on one celebrant’s belief not many would apply, a view disagreed with by another celebrant.

So the headline is totally wrong. There has been no shunning. They could have said predicted to shun which would be a bit closer.

Ann Coulter

Vast Right Wing Conspiracy Lunch

The ANZAC branch of the Vast Right Wing Conspiracy met over lunch at Upper Hutt Cobb & Co today. Present were myself; Kiwi Bob, Tom Paine and Murray of Silent Running; and Dick Cheney.

One realises one is in Upper Hutt when you see the dress code on the door says “No beanies to be worn inside”!

As most of my colleagues are Jewish, I of course ordered the Pork Sirloin to minimise any chance they would steal my food.

We finalised our plans for increasing our military strength so we at least have the chance of a draw against Fiji. Also decided that the UN is welcome to Helen Clark as next Secretary-General. Left until our next meeting the issue of the invasion of Tasmania.

$100m wasted

Aussie Telethon riases $15m

The Aussie Telethon riased $15m for the tsunami relief. Once again I have to ask why has TVNZ done nothing like this?

I loved the joke in Australia that one finally got Eddie McGuire on all three channels!

If the three main channels combined forces here the hosts presumably would be John Campbell, Paul Holmes and Judy Bailey – now that would be a well paid high profile lineup!

Running Silently

Slow News Day

Shish Mahal

Got a call from Ross Friday afternoon to come to Malthouse for a drink. Got there to be pleasantly surprised that Kate was there, back in NZ after two years in the UK.

Spent many hours catching up, swapping stories, and eventually we all headed off to dinner as Shish Mahal which is one of the more hidden restaurants in Wellington, being upstairs at the corner of Cuba Street and Manners Mall.

The curries were pretty damn good actually. Not as good as the London ones according to Kate, but I enjoyed them. The staff were very helpful also explaining which ones go well together as we of course always share each other’s.

Kate incidentially will be looking for a job to supplement her income while she does her masters of design (she is, amongst other things, a very good painter) so I’ll do an ad in the near future.

UN attacks US again

At some stage I will do a long detailed post how the UN, how the end of the cold war changed it, and what now needs to change to redeem itself, but that will wait for another day.

I did get angry reading this CBS story where a UN official has complained the US military are not co-operating enough. Almost every report from the area has said that the US military are doing mthe roe than any other group to actually save lives. To attack them publicly is just stupid, petty and counter productive – even *if* some of the criticisms have a bit of validity.

But you know complaining that the American helicopters are working too fast in spreading relief supplies, and that they should slow down so survivor assessments should be done is well almost bizarre. At this stage the emergency relief is far more important that the assessments.

As expected the Diplomad has had an explosion of rage.

It is worth noting that the A$1B aid package from Australia will all be administered bilaterally and not go through the UN.

Trimming the Fat

It is excellent to see that National is not just going to focus on revenue, ie tax cuts, but also spending.

One should never let the public think that cutting spending is always bad, and that it means less services for example. There is a plethora of waste in the state sector which has grown by 20% under Labour. The $120 million on mainly community education scams is just the start.

Rick Barker responded saying “I’ve never been to a hospital yet where they tell me they’ve got too many doctors or nurses” which is true but every nurse and doctor I know does say there are far too many managers and bureaucrats in the hospitals and ministry.

Bush is now re-elected

At 11.19 am (NZDT) Goerge W Bush was declared re-elected as President. The challenge to the 118,000 majority Bush had in Ohio was massively defeated. In the Senate only one Senator voted in favour of the objection (Boxer) with 74 against.

The House rejected it by 267 votes to 31 with even Democrats voting 89 to 31 against it. At one stage the live tally on CSpan even showed a Republican against but it must have been a glitch as the vote disappeared (or Congress uses Diebold also for electrnic voting :-).

The election is *now* over!

Karl Rove just got happier

Karl Rove just had a late Xmas present today with news out that California Senator Barbara Boxer will support an objection to the certification of the Presidential election which started at 7am local time. I stated last night that there is no way a Senator would be so stupid, but I was wrong.

An objection to be valid needs to be signed by a Congressman and a Senator. In 2000, when there was legitimate doubt over the outcome, not a single Senator would back an objection because they knew it would look like Congress trying to change the results of the election. Having decided not to do so in 2000, I am staggered that Boxer thinks it will help the Democrats doing so in 2004.

Incidentially CNN has one aspect of its story wrong.when it states “A simple majority vote in each chamber would overturn the challenge”. In fact a majority in either chamber is all that is needed to kill an objection. An objection will only be valid if *both* chambers vote to uphold it.

The Democratic leadership has been shitting itself over this scenario, because now they have to vote. A few House Democrats will vote for the objection because they are in seats which are almost unlosable. But most will not vote for it so the party will look split and unable to control its own reps.

One would have thought not just losing the Presidential election, but getting drubbed in both the Senate and House would have taught the Democrats a lesson – you need to appeal to middle America, not your own radical activist base. And Karl Rove will have a very easy job of painting the Democrats as sore losers, who are trying to have Congress over-turn the results of the election.

Of course there were problems with the vote in Ohio. In fact there would have been problems in every state in the US. But it is quite another thing to suggest they could change the outcome of a huge 118,000 vote majority in Ohio. The man with the most to gain, John Kerry, has said there is no possible way they could have changed the outcome.

The Democrats may want to think about the awful precedent they have started today – that Congress should ignore the results of an election because they do not like the outcome. When the Democrats win the White House, they might want to reflect that with Republican majorities in Congress which will take years to reverse, they better hope they do not win with a small majority.

Incidentially the 2000 certificate of the vote was very ironic as the (outgoing) VP presides over the joint session so Al Gore presided over the session which declared Bush elected, and he had to reject all the objections from the Congressional Black Caucus as each time no Senator would support it.

Thursday Night Curry

Stats Girl turned me down for dinner (some feeble excuse about prior plans just because I asked at 4.50 pm) so I went to Thursday Night Curry instead. Only my second time attending so a few new faces for me.

As I am only a pseudo-geek I made sure I had read my daily slash dot and went off ready to debate/talk about IPv6, VoIP, Enum, M$, Spam etc. Someone introduces me as the local neo-conservative blog and recent US exiles debate US and world politics with me for most of the night, instead of geeky topics. We did get onto favourites movies though.

Was in fact a very enjoyable night, once I had convinced people I don’t actually support torture, or at least not practise it myself very often.

The US Economy

The US economy concerns me, especially the deficit. It is so large I think people tune out and just assume the US is so big it can always turn it around. But to put things into context the US deficit as a percentage of government revenue is even larger than the NZ surplus, and that is huge!

Our current surplus is around 13% of government revenue. The US deficit is $521 billion and their income is $2.04 trillion which is a deficit to revenue of 25.6%. NZ just before Ruth saved us was facing a deficit of $5 billion which was around 17% of crown revenue, and look what it took to recover from that.

The US public debt as of yesterday is US$7,601,016,892,663.19 which is around three years expenditure.

If Kerry had campaigned on the economy, instead of Iraq, even he would have won the election easily. His problem was he reacted to the hard core activist faction of the left.

While Bush has done a few good things economically, the fact the US has dropped to 12th= on the list of most free economies speaks for itself.

More Global Warming

Australia Thinks Big

Australia is only five times our population which in theory still makes it a pretty small country, at best a small – medium one.

But what I like about them, is they have never thought of themselves as a minor country. They never go oh wow we are only 0.4% of the world’s population so lets not think we can’t have a proper defence force. They see themselves as a medium sized power, and in fact they are.

Howard shows this again today with a staggering A$1billion aid pledge just to Indonesia for tsunami relief.

Apart from the obvious humanitarian reasons for the aid, Howard has also set the stage for a radical redefining of the relationship between Australia and Indonesia, which could be hugely beneficial for regional stability.

Howard sees Australia as the major western power in this part of the world, despite their small population, and he is not afraid to be bold. Pledging that much aid to a country which many Australians worry is a likely adversary, could be unpopular back home, but I am sure Australians will back his leadership on this.

As tragic as the tsunami is, one has to take advantage of events as they happen. There is the potential to end the civil wars in Aceh and Sri Lanka, and redefine the relationship between Australia and Indonesia. Let’s hope such good does come out of such suffering.

Fresh Air

Extremists

Russell in his first blog of the year swiped at the US Government, various religious groups and right wing blogs whom have dared to criticise the UN.

Some of his criticisms were valid, but I thought it was somewhat cheap shots dragging out Rev Phelps. The man is insane, has around 20 followers, and why do we even give him publicity. He is to Christianity what Dr Mengele was to genetics.

To balance thinsg up, Aaron Bhatnagar has gone to the extreme left and found some nutty extremists there. One of them even blames the tsunami on a meeting in NZ. Read and enjoy.

2004 Roundup