Awatere-Huata hangs on

I was surprised that the Court of Appeal decided in favour of Awatere-Huata. The High Court ruling was that the decision of what constituted unproportional behaviour was one for a Leader and Caucus, and not for the Court to second guess unless it was clearly unreasonable. The Appeal Judges disagreed by 4 to 1.

Will ACT take the case to the Supreme Court? The law expires in a year anyway and it is also possible Awatere-Huata may be convicted on fraud charges (which would expel her from Parliament) by then anyway.

NZ Herald story is here.

Brash and Mossad

Alliance disintegrating again!

Wrong country, wrong time and no luggage!

I thought this trip was going to go well as I actually found my passport the day before I left, instead of the normal frantic search an hour before I am due at the airport. But I was wrong.

Left home at 5.30 a.m. to catch 6.30 a.m. flight to Auckland and then on to Singapore and Malaysia. We almost got to Auckland, then JAFA weather meant we circled for 30 minutes and then were taken back to Wellington as Auckland Airport had closed.

Spent a couple of hours on phone between Air NZ, Singapore Air and travel agent and managed to get on standyby to a 10.30 a.m. flight to Auckland. Mt flight to Singapore was however scheduled to leave at 9.00 a.m. and have just a one hour transit in Singapore before hitting Malaysia at 5 p.m Friday.

Arrived in Auckland to find my luggage had been lost. By the time of boarding to Singapore at 2.45 p.m. it still had not turned up. Also had argument with koro club lounge staff over my points status – my mood gets worse.

Flight to Singapore arrives at 9.30 p.m. and I find out the next flight to Malaysia is at 6.30 a.m. Never mind I have not slept for two days (I can not sleep on flights). I arrive at hotel (paid for by SAL) just after midnight and cheerily informed I will have to be up at 4.30 a.m. to leave for airport by 5.00 a.m.

Luggage has been found but will not arrive in Singapore until Saturday night and hence Malaysia until maybe Sunday morning. Never mind I am doing a presentation on IPv6 and .nz on Saturday afternoon!

Things can only get better from here!

Two good reasons to vote Bush!

Aaron doesn’t want to send a message to Wellington!

Bye Bye Minister Woger

I had very mixed feelings when told yesterday that Roger Sowry would be announcing that he would retire from Parliament at the next election.

For Roger’s sake, I was delighted because it means new opportunities and more time with the family. For National it will mean a loss of someone with great experience, and political instinct.

“Minister Woger” is the nickname his Ministerial staff gave him in the last Government, and it still gets some use today. Roger always had a very loyal and dedicated staff who gave him as much abuse as he gave back in turn. His office was always a fun place, and all of us who worked in the Beehive can recall some great late night sessions.

In my early years in Parliament Roger was very much a mentor to me (and many other staff) and in later years a damn good mate. His wife, Shirley, is one of the nicest people you can meet, and his kids are quite cool also (when they are not all yelling at the same time!).

Roger had a rapid rise, despite coming in at the worst possible time – just as one entered Government – in 1990. To become Chief Government Whip in five years showed his political abilities, later honed as Leader of the House. As Social Services Minister he oversaw some excellent effective programmes like Family Start which are still going today.

In Opposition Roger, both as Deputy Leader, and before, was the MP whom most staff turned to with problems. His incredible popularity with the staff (helped by a constantly regenerating drinks cabinet) was only matched by the bruised egos of some of his colleagues as Roger had the unfortunate tendency to say an idea was really really stupid, just because it was. I’ll keep more details for my long awaited book, but suffice to say Roger was having to say no on a regular basis to some MPs!

The best summary of Roger is probably on the award he got at the farewell dinner for the English/Sowry Leader’s Office team. Roger got the Napolean Award for “being loved by your troops, feared by your enemies, and hated by your officers”.

Why Labour will lose the election

Grants like the $500,000 on a toilet that brays like a donkey are why Labour are likely to lose the next election. I know from when National was in office how corrosive these are. Do you remember the outcry on WINZ spending $250,000 on the Tapuo start training jaunt? Well this is double that.

Add on $26,000 hip hop tours, $15 million on a computer CD and many many more and you get a lot of discontent.

This is the problem of just increasing government spending to keep up with GDP. Inevitably the quality of the spending decreases. It is pure human nature. I waste far more money on my current income, than I did as a student. Why should Government be different?

The 200 poorest list

No Right Turn has highlighted, and agreed with, a suggestion by John Darkin that there should be a poor list to match the NBR rich list.

I think this is an excellent idea.

We should highlight the awful case of a family on the DPB with one child, whom don’t even do a single hours paid work. The nasty taxpapyer will starve them on a net income of only $24,810. This equivalent to a gross income of $31,200.

And if they have another child, their net income increases to $31,154. That is ewuivalent to a gross income of $39,552 which is more than the average wage. So if a family doesn’t undertake even an hour of paid work, but has two children, they will earn more than the average wage.

Yep this is the sort of poverty we need to expose.

Judges’ ruling rewrites UN Charter on self-defence

Conference wrap-up

Just got back from five days in Auckland preparing for and helping run the National Party Conference. Exhausted as usual – as much due to the social functions as the work!

The band for once was superb. It was Mermaids, an all girl vocals band. They definitely rocked. One of the singers was ex-truebliss singer Joe Cotton whom I’m just watching on Celebrity Treasure Island – I should have asked her who won!

There was a fairly nasty item on TV3 last night showing a delegate looking semi-asleep. The person concerned in fact has a sleep disorder and if away from home gets almost no sleep at night, so to have TV3 ridiculing him for something he has no control over was pitiful.

Somehow I have ended up on the Party’s List Ranking Committee. This is a huge responsibility as the LRC will effectively select 20 or more of the 25 – 30 new MPs National looks to gain at the next election. I’ll be travelling to a lot of selection meetings around the region to get to know the candidates as much as possible.

Another close result

TVNZ’s monthly poll shows little change. Current standings are:

National 43% 54 seats
Labour 39% 48 seats
Green 5% 6 seats
NZ First 5% 6 seats
United 2% 3 seats
Maori 2% 3 seats
Progressive 0% 1 seat

So Labour/Green/Prog/Maori would be 58 seats. National/United 57 seats and Winston get to decide with his six seats!

Have to say I can’t see a Labour/Green/Progressive/Maori/NZ First Government!

Nats Conference has started

National’s annual conference in Auckland started at 2 p.m. today. I’ve been up since Wednesday helping set things up (I sort of act as stage manager for them).

Superb speech by Roger Sowry on Labour’s proposed employment law changes. A nice quote:

“There are no scarier words for a businessperson to hear than ‘I’m from the Government – I’m here to help – and I’ve bought the CTU with me.”

And some examples of how the law change will affect business:

“Your business uses a cleaning firm to clean the building, and they do a lousy job. You re-tender the contract and award it to a new company. Under this law, the new company is required to hire all the staff who were previously doing a lousy job of your cleaning under the same terms and conditions.”

“An electrical contractor employs six electricians and decides to sell his business. According to the new law he will have to notify all his staff when he is thinking of selling the business, thereby giving them the opportunity to leave and establish their own business in competition before any sale can take place.”

Madness!

Nuclear Free Iraq

More money wasted

The Dominion Post reports that milllions of dollars on “Closing the Gaps” has been squandered.

Hands up those surprised.

The report is absolutely damning. But what amazes me is that this is an internal report. Internal reports, as defined by Yes Minister, are meant to be white washes. It is only when you have the Auditor-General or a QC investigate that you sometimes get the full truth.

A summary of the report is:

* minimal achievement of the desired skill development, employment and enterprise development outcomes”.

* Guidelines restricting funding to established organisations were often ignored.

* A prohibition banning the payment of salaries to grant recipients was routinely “subverted”.

* CEG’s national office altered applications so they would meet criteria

UPDATE: The NZ Herald reports that the Government refused for six months to release the damning reports, until forced to by the Ombudsman. What else are they sitting on?

One can read the full reports for yourself on the DOL site. As you read them, ask why is there no accountability for what happened? How much money has to be wasted until a Minister is accountable. $15 million on a CD for community education isn’t enough either.

Wow this is desperate stuff

No Right Turn is trying to do a Sunday Star Times smear job, but instead of comparing Don Brash to Pauline Hanson, he is comparing National to Destiny NZ. I actually laughed at the thought he is serious.

He doesn’t even quote actual National policies. He just makes things up like “National thinks all beneficiaries are dope-smoking layabouts”.

I actually find such reactions incredibly heartening. The more hysterical the reaction, the more mainstream NZ will back National.

Thanks Gordon

Calling JAFA Bloggers

I’m up in Auckland for five days from Wednesday morning. If any Auckland based bloggers or blog addicts are keen to catch up for some food or drink on Wednesday or Thursday evening, then let me know. I’m thinking down at the Viaduct somewhere.

Truth in Crime Stats

The Government spin line on law & order is that it is not an issue, nothing to worry about, because the crime rate has gone down under Labour.

This is sort of true, but what they and the media never point out is that it is a meaningless statistic. The total crime rate means almost nothing because it counts every murder or rape as equal to every under age drinking conviction. One could have a 50% increase in violent crimes and and a mere 8% decrease in dishonesty offences, and this would make the total crime rate go down.

As an example in 2,000 the numebr of sale of liquor offences dropped by 3,000 yet the number of violent crimes went up by 2,000, and Labour trumpet this as successfully lowering the crime rate.

So to talk intelligently on the subject, one needs to look at the breakdown. One can do this by individual offence category or by major groupings of violence, sexual, drugs, dishonesty, property and administrative.

Now almost everyone would agree violent crimes (murders, assaults, armed robberies) and sexual crimes (rapes, sexual assaults) are what most people want to see a lot less of.

Well in the last year of National violent crimes dropped by 2%. Since 1999 they have increased by 15%. Annual increases of 5%, 6%, 2% and 2%.

And sexual crimes dropped in 1999 by 8%. Then increased by 7% since 1999.

Also even if one does count the total number of crimes (as meaningless as that is), they dropped by 5% in 1999 and have gone up by 1% since 1999.

This is why you hear the Government refer to the total crime rate which is number of crimes per 10,000 population. Now it can be useful to use a population adjustment, but I would suggest a better measurement is the crime rate per 10,000 persons aged from 12 to 60 which covers almost all criminal offending. This segment has grown less than the overall population.

But even if one does use the meaningless total crime rate, let’s look at the trends. Was going down under National – dropped 5.6% in 1999. This slowed to 2.9% in 2000 and 1.1% in 2001. And then up in 2002 by 1.6% and down again by 1.2% in 2003. So a strong downwards trend has slowed and then basically stalled.

But they key thing is the overall crime numbers or rates are almost meaningless. The more serious violent and sexual crimes have increased both in absolute numbers and proportional to population, since 1999.

Orewa II

Don Brash has delivered what the media have been calling Orewa II – a key note speech on law & order. The speech is online.

I have been amazed by the amount of anticipation this speech has generated in the last few weeks. People from all parties have been speculating on what will be in there, what sort of impact it may make etc. This is incredible considering Brash is Leader of the Opposition, and not yet Prime Minister. When Clark, and before her Moore and Bolger were Opposition Leaders, no-one cared much at all about speeches they might make.

The summary is:

* reduce the age of criminal responsibility from 14 years to 12
* move offenders from the children

56 deceits in Fahreneit 911

I’be been avoiding Bush/Iraq type stories as so many other blogs are obsessed with the topic and blog every sneeze.

However Dave Kopel’s lengthy expose of Fifty-six Deceits in Fahrenheit 911 is worth taking the time to make your way through.

Regardless of one’s views on Bush or Iraq, it is clear that what Moore has produced is not a documentary but an extended rant. In fact many left wing commentators in the US have scorned the movie, as it is so over the top. It is one thing to think that Bush made the wrong calls on Iraq etc, but to seriously suggest he is in league with Osama Bin Laden and the Taliban is just demented.

I was right!

I predicted on Wednesday that Hunt would dismiss the privilege complaint against Peters (after Clark came out backing Peters).

Capital Pundit alerted me to the fact that Hunt has now dismissed the complaint.

One does have to wonder how if an allegation of bribery is not a matter of privilege (even if allegation is groundless), what is?

Stupid

It was pretty damn stupid for Express to label every MP who voted against the Civil Unions Bill as homophobes and bigots. Sure a few are, but it in insulting to call someone a bigot just because they did not vote for the civil unions bill. It’s also a great way to alienate supporters.

I did have to laugh at Shane Ardern’s comment which basically was that being attacked by Express will probably increase his Taranaki King Country majority! Having campaigned in that electorate, I can say he is right.

Full Employment

The Dominion Post reports that Mahara Okeroa will be appointed ot the Executive next week as an under-secretary. This will mean full employment for all five male Maori MPs – now that is closing the gaps. I wonder how many people could name all five unprompted? Even I struggled.

So one has Horomia and Tamihere in Cabinet, Samuels as Minister outside Cabinet plus Ririnui and Okeroa as under-secretaries. How could Labour have copes with only 27 members of the Executive – it must have 28 (the largest ever).

Ririnui is so overworked has done no releases or speeches since 12 May. Samuels has managed a whole 10 press releases this year or almost one a fortnight.