John Howard to address Nats conference

Australian PM John Howard is going to address next weekend’s National Party Anuual Conference by video-link.

This is quite a coup, as it is unusual to get incumbent Prime Ministers from other countries.

I met John Howard last year at the IDU Young Leaders Forum in Sydney. He hosted us for a few hours at Kirribilli House (which has one of the most stunning harbour views in the world) and was an extremely good host. Very keen to talk rugby with those of us there from New Zealand. Came over very much as a “fair dinkum bloke”.

Tamaki contest

A National Party member, Margaret Voyce, has announced she is challenging Clem Simich for the Tamki nomination.

I have a lot of time for Clem, and also know and like Margaret, so I’m not going to comment on any preferences of mine. Not that it matters anyway because unlike Labour only local members get a vote.

Tamaki is no longer a safe National seat. While it did have the 7th highest party vote for National in 2002, the electorate vote fell by 11% to just 35%. In fact Tamaki is now National’s most marginal seat with a 1,207 vote majority.

Three of National’s MPs won their seats after challenging a sitting MP for the nomination. John Carter for Northland in 1987, John Key for Helensville in 2002 and Judith Collins for Clevedon in 2002. One can argue Key and Collins were not quite challenges as Neeson and Kyd whom they beat were MPs for Waitakere and Hunua respectively, which had differeent boundaries (and names) to the new seats.

It will be an interesting contest to watch. Just as important will be the selections for the non National held seats. Under National’s new rules all but a maximum of five list candidates must also be electorate candidates. With polls indicating 25 – 30 new MPs, at least 80% of them will be from seats which National may not win, but will get a List MP. So expect to see contsted selection battles for almost every seat.

I got a pay rise!

My honorarium as Vice-President of InternetNZ has just been voted to increase!

However only by a $1,000 of which Dr Cullen will steal $390 for hip hop tours. Luckily I don’t have kids (or don’t think I do) otherwise I might lose $890 of it back to the Government.

Before people queue up to for my job (elections July 2005) I should point out that in exchange for $5,000 a year one does end up spending over twelve hours a week for it, which is an hourly rate slightly below McDonalds ($8.01/hour).

Happy Families

A rather sad story in the Dominion Post about National MP Brian Connell and his lesbian sister-in-law (and former flatmate).

I really wonder about the wisdom of telling your sister in law that yeah your kids have turned out okay I guess, but they are probably the exception to the rule. I shudder that her kids will be reading this.

What really staggered me though is the statement that Brian would still vote for homosexuality to be illegal (or celibate). Even the MPs who did vote against law reform in 1986 almost all now concede it was the right thing to do.

I recall fondly the previous MP for Rakaia who (despite a background of being a Minister’s daughter) was very tolerant and absolutely without prejudice on these issues. In fact several of her staff in the PM’s office were openly gay or lesbian, and not once was there an issue about their partners being welcome.

June Blog Summary

Okay have just wasted a couple of hours counting up all the (political) blog posts for June. The nominees are:

Under 10 posts

Heathey Roy 1, RBC 3, Belvedere 3, Tamihere 4, Grey Shade 4, Span 7 (just started)

Under 20 posts

My Right 11, Fighting Talk 11, The Whig 14, Holden Republic 17, Russell Brown 19 (but very long ones)

The contenders

Just Left with 21 posts but a lively 105 comments
Darkness 25 posts and 42 comments
Big News 25 posts and 30 comments
Aaron Bhatnagar 37 posts and 0 comments
Kiwi Pete 41 posts and 9 comments
PNN 41 posts and 9 comments
Kiwi Pundit 55 posts and 15 comments
I made 60 posts and had 289 comments
Capital Pundit 63 posts and 1 comment (which was me 🙂
The Prime Minister and friends had 67 posts with 50 comments
Rodney Hide is in third place with 91 posts and by far the most comments at 592
No Right Turn in second at 104 posts and no comments
NZ Pundit still hanging on to his crown with 144 posts and 334 comments

Relationships Bill voting details

The Dominion Post reported today that the Relationships (Statutory References) Bill passed its first reading 77 – 42.

I haven’t seen any published details of the full vote split, but have managed to track a copy of the vote down. It was:

Labour 48 – 3 (only Cosgrove, Field and O’Connor against)

National 11 – 16 (Key, Mapp, McCully, Sowry, te Heuheu and Williamson joining the CUB 5 in favour)

NZ First 2 – 11 (no change from CUB)

Green 9 – 0

ACT 2 – 6 (only Hide and Shirley in favour, despite six voting for the CUB!)

United 3 – 5 (Dunne, Copeland and Turner in favour)

Progressive 2 – 0 (no change)

Independent 0 – 1 (why is she still there?)

So every party had at least two MPs in favour. However it could struggle as people see the details. According to Russell Brown, it extends relationships rights not just to those in civil unions, but also to those who have explicitly decided not to marry or have a civil union and are de facto partners. The select committee is going to have a lot of work to do.

CUB Hansard Quotes

The Hansard for the CUB First Reading is now online.

A total of 18 MPs spoke in the one hour debate. I’ve extracted a quote or two from all 18 speakers below.

My awards for best and worst speakers are as follows:

Best speaker in favour – Moana Mackey – its above love not legal rights.

Worst speaker in favour – Matt Robson – just shut up about the SIS please – this was a debate on civil unions!

Best speaker against – Peter Dunne – for not demonising gays

Worst speaker against – Bill Gudgeon – “this bill is an abomination to all mankind” indeed – what planet is this man on?
Continue reading »

A prediction …

Capital Pundit has blogged on how Clark is effectively backing Peters and saying people should put up or shut up. I would have thought a sworn affadavit was putting up personally.

Clark is suggesting it should be a police matter. And it might well be, but this is a red herring. Issues such as having a staff member on the payroll of both yourself and a company you are investigating are issues of ethics, not law.

But my predicition is that beyond doubt Jonathan Hunt will not refer it to the Privileges Committee. And why am I so confident? Because Clark has made it clear she wants it to go away.

As the chances of a Labour/Green Government after 2005 look increasingly unlikely, NZ First is the most likely coalition partner.

Winston sues everyone

Aaron Bhatnagar blogged yesterday Winston’s statement to Parliament that he was suing not just TVNZ and Yvonne Dossetter but also Radio NZ, Ken Shirley MP and David Carter MP.

Aaron also has the quote Peters used in Parliament, quoting Iago about protecting his good name.

Possibly unfortuntate that Peters quoted Iago whom is an amoral villain who “deceives, steals, and
kills
“. He constantly lies to his wife, steals form his friends but gets away with it because he can “say the right things at the right time”!!

EML

Eating Media Lunch was ine fine form again. Their 50 sexiest NZers was fun. Was I the only one who choked to realise Jeantte Fitzsimons was a babe when she was younger?

The highlight though was asking the farmers at a field day to rank in order from best to worst the following:

Al Quaeda
David Hartnell
Maori Activists
DOC

The expression of most of them seemed to indicate equal distaste for all four.

Moe on anti spam legislation

The Dominion Post has a story on the spam legislative options workshop. the debate on whether to exclude MPs from any spam legislation was amusing, if one sided!

Incidentially I did not “concede” to owing a polling and telemarketing company. I volunteered the information during discussion on the scope of any spam laws, and the company I own does not do telemarketing at all. We aks people questions (market research), not try to sell things.

A copy of the official InternetNZ submission to the Government on proposed anti spam legislation is now online.

Hedonistic deviant conservatives

The Listener had an article a couple of weeks ago on “The New Conservatives” and profiled a couple of Young Nationals.

Seems not all Young Nationals were happy with the profile of “Christian Virgin Males”, and two Young Nats have written to the Listener to point out that some of them are also “Hedonistic Deviant Females” – a claim I can certainly support knowing them both!

Well people say National is a broad church.

Shirley on Winstongate

Israel

Muldoon and Shrek

I tempted to quip that what they both have in common is an ogre as the star, but that would be unfair. In fact both are excellent entertainment.

I saw Muldoon on Saturday night and McPhail did a superb job. It was very funny at times, yet also somewhat sad. He worked into the performance almost every well known tale about Muldoon. Best of all it didn’t demonise Muldoon, but probably quite accurately showed how he viewed the whole world from his point of view – all about people he couldn’t trust or rely on.

Tonight I saw Shrek II. Shit it was funny. This is a must see. Puss in Boots was especially funny.

Process vs Substance

Those with a background in employment law will know that there is a huge fixation on process, to the degree that if you sack on the spot an employee, they will almost win damages no matter what their conduct.

A good SST article talks about how a hairdresser was sacked for lying that she had a bereavement, when she actually went to the Big Day Out, and she won $2,000.

In the most outraegous case a Nelson seaman was awarded almost $10,000 for the Employment Tribunal for being sacked after he and his colleagues

*behaved offensively to a visiting tour party at the Rutherford Hotel (which was owned by the same people who part opwned their fishing company)
*took off with the female tour leader’s bag
* indulged in some cross-dressing, with one man donning her clothing and her pearls.
* one of the men urinated in the bag
* someone also vomited in the room.
* scored a direct hit on the assistant manager of the hotel then standing outside the hotel, by urinating out of the 6th floor hotel window on to him.

Luckily for once sanity prevailed as the company appealed and the Employment Court ruled “this was an extraordinary case of atrocious conduct where the lack of procedural fairness was justifiable”.

Good to see there are law changes planned to make life harder for certain legal parasites who encourage personal grievances, no matter the merits. Both unions and employers are supporting the change.

Guilty or not?

UMR in January 2004 did a poll on whether people think Watson, Bain and Ellis were guilty of the crimes they were convicted of.

The article is somewhat useless though because they have combined those who say they are unsure with those who think someone is not guilty. There is a big difference between 55% think guilty, 45% not guilty and 55% guilty, 40% not sure and 5% not guilty.

Anyway the percentage guilty for each (comparison to April 2002 in brackets) is:

Watson 44% (59%)
Ellis 23% (25%)
Bain around 33%

For what it is worth I have no doubt at all that Bain was guilty. I also have no doubt that Ellis should not have been convicted.

Everything I have read and heard about Watson suggest he is an extremely violent, almost psychopathic, individual. The contradictory evidence of Guy Wallace has muddied things, but recalling Hope’s DNA was found on his boat, I think it is a safe conviction.

Weird!

Below is a transcript of an unsolicited MSN Messenger chat last night. I think he objects to my views on civil unions. Very very weird. He seems fixated with homosexuals.

I have changed his name (it is not really Andrew) as requested by him, when I told him I would blog the conversation.

Time From Message
11:41:28 p.m. Andrew die satan scum!
11:41:36 p.m. Andrew i spurn you like i would spurn a rabid dog
11:41:45 p.m. dpf really
11:41:55 p.m. Andrew yea
11:42:04 p.m. dpf well why bother to initiate a conversation then
Continue reading »

Further CUB Discussion

Labour MP Janet Mackey has attacked her own colleagues accusing gay MPs of hijacking the Civil Union Bill. She also said the Government is”spending more time engaged in social engineering than on good legislation.

What a number of people have mentioned to me (including several MPs) is that what is annoying people is the Beehive spin that a Civil Union is nothing to do with marriage. Of course it is a marriage in all but name. And I have no problems with that.

Several MPs have also argued it is not the role of the state to recognise relationships. I can have some sympathy for that argument. Jim Peron has posted an excellent article on this issue pointing out how libertarians may not want the state to own schools either, but while they do, they should be available to all.

Meanwhile Cardinal Williams has attacked “The Spiritual Bankruptcy of Liberalism” and likened liberals to barbarians – “The perennial work of the barbarian is to tear down existing standards”

I suppose I should point out that one can strongly believe in high moral standards, but also strongly believe the state should not be used by churches to impose such standards.

There is also further criticism of Ashraf Choudhary for not turning up to vote. I am led to understand that he may be supportive of civil unions but did not vote so not to upset the Muslim community.

If so, this is a huge pity. As I posted previously on Islam, it will only change if its leaders take a stand against fundamentalism, and an MP is part of that leadership. I also note several Muslims saying they would respect him more for voting and explaining, rather than not voting at all.

Fine the zombie owners?

The anti spam legislative options workshop was very good (except that the webcast used me as their static image when ever there was a pause!).

One of the interesting ideas proposed was that owners of computers than get infected with viruses and become spam zombies (where the spammer sends spam through their infected machine to disguise the spammer’s identity), should face possible penalties. An analogy was made to the user of a faulty car which causes an accident.

I was interviewed by Radio NZ on this, and other spam issues. I didn’t advocate liability for zombie users (preferring education) but did note it may become more of an issue in the future. The interview was on Checkpoint last night which is online, but it is around 45 minutes through the programme and there is no fast forward.

Blog reactions to CUB

Thought a summary of blog reaction to the sucessful first reading of the CUB would be useful.

Darkness – “the five minute marriage of Britney Spears degrades the religious institution much more than a gay couple in love confirming their commitment to each other”

Kiwi Pundit – “The other Act MP to vote against was the always appalling and anti-liberal Muriel Newman”

Aaron Bhatnagar – “What is the point in Mr Choudhary being in Parliament? He failed to speak his mind over the legalization of prostitution last year. He has again failed to speak his mind. He is a ditherer to the order of Alamein Kopu”

The Whig – “Still can’t quite believe Deborah Coddington voted against, but I suspect it was for ‘libertarian’ reasons, rather than conservative ones”

Big News – “MPs who have supported this bill have supported it for the first reading have no intention of supporting it any further”

Just Left – “Particular marks go to Bill Gudgeon for horrifying everyone”

Span – “those Labour MPs who voted against it should be ashamed”

Catholic Action – “Any MP who votes for the ‘Civil Union’ Bill is diabolically disorientated. Any MP who votes for the ‘Civil Union’ Bill is on the road to Hell for all eternity. Any MP who is cast into Hell will burn forever in an unquenchable fire.”

Russell Brown – “it would have been spectacularly easy for National’s leader, Don Brash, to have played politics, but he voted with his conscience”

No Right Turn – “I’m pleased to see that ACT are acting more like a liberal party”

Civil Unions through 66 – 50

Well I am pleased the Civil Unions Bill got through the first reading 66 – 50. Apart from the fact I support the Bill, I think it is a pity if any conscience issue doesn’t get at least select committee consideration. A number of MPs voted for it on that basis, so final outcome very unclear.

The NZ Herald has a good article with who voted what way. They don’t do a summary by party though, so here it is:

Labour 42 to 6 (3 absent)
National 5 to 22
NZ First 2 to 11
ACT 6 to 2
Green 9 to 0
United Future 0 to 8
Progressive 2 to 0
Independent 1 to 0

Total 66 to 50 (3 absent)

Labour had eight MPs not vote for the Bill (would have failed without centre right votes). Only surprise for me was Tamihere voting against.

Rather disappointed only five Nats in favour – was hoping for 10 or so. Absoutely great Don Brash voted for it. He supported it of course because he believes it will be better than the status quo, but from my view it is politically useful that now harder to demonise him as an “uncaring racist conserative blah blah blah” when he has a sensible liberal voting record. Also great that Clem voted for it – I often forget he is not just a Tamaki conservative. Katherine, Pansy and Lockwood – well done also.

My two favourite NZ First MPs voted for it – Ron and Brian. The first time NZ First has split on a conscience issue I think. They do also get to have the MP who made the biggest pillock of himself – Bill Gudgeon who called the bill “an abomination to all mankind” and “despicable”. As part of mankind, my message to Mr Gudgeon is to shut the fuck up, and stop speaking on my behalf.

Also good to see ACT reflect their branding as a liberal party with 75% voting for including Rodney, Richard and to my huge surprise Stephen Franks. Good one Stephen. God knows how Deborah Coddington was ever in the Libertarianz as she was initially against prostitution law reform and also against this.

Every party leader except Peters and Dunne voted in favour. How often would one have that happen.

Quite funny how strongly I feel on this issue, despite being unaffected myself (I am quite traditional and would like a church wedding). Probably the fact I know so many people in long term committed same sex relationships, and that this bill means so much to them and their sense of worth as a couple.

It will be interesting to see how the Relationships Omnibus Bill goes next week. Should have well over 70 in favour as even some United Future MPs may be voting for it.

The Empire Strikes Back

NZPA has a good story on the statement by Peters that he is suing TVNZ for $7 million.

I did laugh at Bill Ralston’s statement that so far he has only received press releases, not legal papers, despite threats since January – but most of all him pointing out that Peters needs to go back to law school as under the law you can not specify the amount of damages sought in your filing.

Peters is also saying he may sue any other media which has carried the story. Hopefully there will be no need for a blog defence fund!

I could almost feel sorry for Peters in this, as it is entirely possible that Meurant has landed his boss in a pile of crap, without Peters knowing. However as Peters hold the all time record for making baseless defamatory accusations under parliamentary privilege, my sympathy is very limited.

A story on the TVNZ website refers to phone records showing a quick succession of phone calls from Meurant to Simunovich and Peters, which may not help the claim that Peters did not know Meurant was working for both him and Simunovich.

Anti Spam Legislation

I doubt I will be able to blog teh results of the Civil Unions Bill 1st reading vote until this evening as I am helping chair a Government and InternetNZ workshop on legislative options for dealing with spam.

Should be a good day with around 70 people attending. Had very pleasant night out with the Australian Government spekaers last night!

If anyone is interested the workshop is being webcast.

People may also be interested in this story in the Herald about the latest anti spam proposals from Microsoft and AOL. I have some reservations about the side effects of these proposals.

$300,000

Reports today that the affadavit in Winstongate alleges $300,000 in cash was paid to former Winston staff member Ross Meurant.

Haven’t they heard of Internet banking – much easier? 🙂

I’m not going to comment much as this is all likely to end up in court. But three things I have noted.

1 – The affadavit does not allege, it seems, that she had witnessed the cash, just that Meurant boasted about it.

2 – Simunovich have denied their company has done anything illegal, but do not appear to have denied the specific allegation (think Becks not denying he cheated on Posh, just saying the accusations were preposterous).

3 – Even if Meurant did receive any money, that is different to Peters having received any.

It is possible that the money was paid, but it was by way of contract for services as Meurant worked for them.

Any opinions here are based on my reading of public reports. I am not suggesting I have any knowledge not in the public domain.

Stuff also has a story on the allegations.