Well done Paul Swain

I was pleased to read a couple of days ago that Communications Minister Paul Swain did actually recommend the Government ask the Telecommunications Commissioner to reconsider his decision not to unbundle the local loop. Well done for this.

He got rolled in Cabinet, which is fairly rare for Ministers (may be less so for Swain who had some barmy traffic law changes squashed also). Few Ministers would know enough to contribute on this issue, so I suspect any over-ruling would had to have been led by either the PM, Cullen or maybe Mallard. I’d heard the PM was in fact supportive of unbundling, so my guess would be Cullen was oppossed.

My views on unbundling have been previously posted. I do look forward to the day I can use broadband at full speed for more than 67 minutes a month!

The Winston Allegations

TVNZ reported last night on allegations that there were “cash payments from Simunovich Fisheries to Winston Peters” and these have been made by way of a sworn affadavit, meaning criminal sanctions are possible if the affadavit is false.

Various MPs have been playing pass the parcel with the affadavit, none of them wanting to be seen to be endorsing the allegations, which are at this stage unsubstantiated.

Peters really need somethign more convincing though than claiming they are simply part of a vendeta by Bill Ralston.

There is an irony in Peters facing such allegations, as he built his political career on making unfounded false allegations against dozens of people, destroying many careers un the process.

The role of Ross Muerant is potentially pivotal in all this. He was once a National MP also, and few have good memories of him. He became a ROC MP and was eventually sacked by Bolger as an Under Secretary when (IIRC) he refused to accept that one can not be a member of the Executive, and also be a director of a Russian tax dodge bank registered in Vanuatu.

MPs on the Political Compass

No Right Turn has posted a copy of leading MPs (and a skinhead!) on the political compass. The original comes from DeepRed.

I’m copying it here so my comments can be viewed in context.

NZPoliticalCompass2004-6.gif

Don and Rodney look about right (being the only two in my quadrant, explaining why I support them both). Anderton I believe is actually very authoritarian and should be nearer Turia. I also would question Fitzsimons degree of libertarian as while no doubt very liberal on some issues, she does have a long list of things she thinks the state should ban (science) or censor (not nice things). I also think Tamihere might be in just over on the right hand side also.

But overall a fairly good estimate. I did once at work compile a graph of all the National MPs and staff who sat the test (it was very popular a while back), but I am keeping that secret until my death or my tell all book (which ever comes first 🙂

NRT also compiled back in November the scores of the NZ bloggers. It is fascinating how there are almost no authoritarian bloggers (Gordon take a bow) but that may reflect how Internet users generally are.

I am very proud of my position on the graph below.

nzblogspectrum.gif

There is also a graph of many global bloggers. I am the DF at the bottom right.

National nukes nukes

National has announced that it will not make any changes to the anti-nuclear legislation, without a referendum.

This is of course no surprise, as Don Brash has been saying for ages that National would make a change only if there was a referendum or by way of explicit election mandate. Goodness knows how a decision not to change your policy is now seen as a flip-flop but according to TVNZ it is.

So why would National choose a referendum route over an explcit election mandate? Two main reasons in my mind. The first is that once in office, one would want to talk to allies to see if the Creech solution would help improve relations. If it will not, then not much point in prceeding further.

The second and more important is that any change needs to be durable and preferably bipartisan. Only a referendum could do that. The one thing the US wants even less than the status quo,is having their ship visits become a regular election issue where they are in, out, in, out etc.

Now some partisan hacks will scream and rant that National will in fact go ahead and change the law anyway, without a referendum. This is of course lunatic raving as anyone of intelligence can work out.

Does anyone really really sensibly think Don Brash having made an explicit, no room for misunderstanding, commitment to make no change without a referendum, would then go ahead and change the law, knowing it would doom him to one term in office. It would not achieve any benefits at all (as such a law change would not survive the government) and only piss off even your own supporters for having broken your word.

Heh heh

John Tamihere’s latest blog entry is a classic – in fact the Dominion Post refused to print it, so he blogged it instead.

The portion on Rodney perk busting John Key for the 5th form ball he organised was very good, as was the description of Rodney phoning Don calling himself “Finance Minister Rodney Hide”.

Also the branding of Heather Roy, Muriel Newman, Deborah Coddington and Katherine Rich as the four horsewoman of the Apocalypse can only increase the number of doomsday cults because if they represent the Apocalypse, most men are going to say “bring it on”.

It’s nice to be able to see good satire from the left without it being personally nasty (which all too often it is). Of course those portrayed may see it differently but I thought it very funny.

If I had the time (this week is insanely busy) I would do my own portrayal of Helen negotiating with Tariana, Rod, Jeanette, Peter, WInston and Jim. How about some contributions from readers and and we can award prizes for the most humourous.

The four horseman of St Molesworth should be able to come up with something suitable.

Speed Facts from the UK

Sandy Myhre (the first woman member of the NZ Motoring Writers Guild and the first woman member and first President of the NZ Motorsport Media Association) has written an article for Xtra on Hiding Cameras and Facts.

UK data has found that excessive speed was the major factor in only 12.5% of crashes and that 70% of the crashes caused by excessive speed had the vehicle travelling under the official speed limit.

This reinforces my point that one should focus on educating drivers to drive to the conditions. Often driving at the speed limit will be far too fast for the conditions. At other times it is safe to exceed it.

On the weekend I saw a car spin out of control just ahead of me on a road in Thorndon. They were driving at under 50 km/hr but it was a raining and a corner so it was too fast for the conditions.

I agree with Sandy that a more effective way to lower the road toll would be far tougher drive testing, including in my opinion having to resit the exam every ten years.

Coalition Preferences

TVNZ has also polled on the preferred coalition partners for National and Labour voters.

Labour voters preferences in order are:

Green 76%
NZ First 58%
Maori Party 55%
United Future 53%
ACT 37%
Progressive 36%

Rather hilarious that more Labour voters wants ACT than Jim Anderton as a coalition partner.

National voters preferences in order are:

ACT 87%
NZ First 67%
United Future 56%
Greens 28%
Maori Party 27%
Progressive 25%

My own order of preferred coalition partners is somewhat different.

Test the Nation

I think the people who designed the test this year stuffed up somewhat. Last year the average IQ of people participating was around 110 IIRC which would be about right considering that this sort of show generally attracts those who think they will do well based on previous tests etc.

The average results this year is 95, and I am not surprised. The questions were not that hard but with the time limit, one barely had enough time to compare all the options before having to vote. I think the range of questions was very limited compared to last year also. I suspect many people were put off by this.

The standard deviation would be very interesting. I suspect it would not be the normal 15.

And yes I did still do well (but less than 57/60 last year) , so no sour grapes 🙂

And of course I am a life long Tolkien fan. Average IQs for studio groups were:

Models 85 (harsh, as that is close to retarded level which shows how badly designed the test was)
Reat Estate Agents 93
Taxi Drivers 93
60+ 98
Cricket Supporters 97
Celebrities 99
Tolkien Fans 107

The Destiny Cult

Okay they are not quite a cult, but I have to say I find little positive about the Destiny Church.

The Sunday Star-Times has a good article on them. The quick summary is:

* founder Brian Tamaki is raking in millions of dollars
* parishioners are pressued to give 10% of their income to him/the church (and may are form low income families)
* new members are asked to sign a contract agreeing to the tithe
* All 20 Destiney churches have a cluase giving Tamaki “absolute power of veto” over any decision they make
* elderly members get phoned up asking why their tithe has changed from week to week
* Tamaki is the de facto leader of the Destiney political party, which makes Christian Heritage look moderate

Hmmn, perhaps cult is not such a bad word after all.

UPDATE 28 AUGUST 2004: Okay with 260 comments posted, I have now closed this post for further comments. The debate has been very amusing.

Nice comparisons – not

For a party which claims to be secular, United Future are doing a good job o looking like a bunch of knee jerk fundamentalists.

They are pushing a referendum to repeal the prostiution reform laws (which only legalised solicitation – prostitution has been legal for decades) and claim “we don’t want to see them underground or pushed into back alleys – we think repealing this law will help prostitutes” when it is obvious repeal would do exactly that.

But what really offended me was MP Larry Baldock’s statement “laws concerning rape, incest, molestation and the sexual age of consent showed parliament is willing to determine morality issues”.

Rape does not involve a consensual act. Incest generally does not involve a consensual act. Molestation does not involve a consensual act. The age of consent recognises children are too young to consent.

So Baldock thinks prostitution betwene two consenting adults is on a par with rape and molestation.

Peter Dunne is a decent guy. He must be ashamed of some of his Caucus at times.

Latest One News Poll

TVNZ have just broadcast their first full poll since the budget. It is very close to the smaller one off poll they did just after the budget. That one had National 3% ahead and this one has National 4% ahead.

National is at 44% and Labour at 40%. No minor party is over 5%. Greenns at 4% and ACT at 2% would probably be out of Parliament. NZ First at 3%, United at 2%, Maori Party at 2% and Progressive at 0.1% would all keep some seats due to holding an electorate.

So what would Parliament look like on this poll:

National 58 seats
Labour 52 seats
NZ First 4 seats
United Future 3 seats
Maori Party 3 seats
Progressive 1 seat

The most likely Government is National/United Future with 61/121 seats. Labour would need support of NZ First, Progressive, United Future and NZ First to govern.

Unusual Visitors

A wee while ago I had a unexpected knock on the door. Looking the peephole I saw two women, and as neither was attractive, I went back to bed assuming they were selling something.

However they kept knocking so I finally answered the door, and the first words that greeted me were “Do you know what 666 stands for”. Now I have had bible bashers before, but normally they start off in a less direct manner.

I replied that it was “the mark of the beast” and one of the woman replied “yes, but it is also the mark of men who serve the beast”. Now I have to admit that at this stage I did begin to wonder if this was a random visit or if my msn email address of [email protected] had come to someone’s notice. I started looking for signs of hidden knifes.

A reading from the bible about the work of the beast and 666 followed and then several publications were given to me. They then asked if I would like them to come back and talk to me, when I had read them. As I would rather vote Labour than do that, I stretched the truth a wee bit and said that as I was Jewish, that might not be a good use of their time. I kicked myself later for not saying “Ha ha I’m Jewish and we killed your last Messiah also” (I must see Passion of the Christ at some stage) to see the reaction.

I noted as they left that they did not knock on any other door on my floor, so God knows whether it was targeted or not base don my email address. Perhaps they also saw my photo on this blog!

By coincidence I just did the Quizilla on which archangel are you, and whoops that wasn’t a good sign either. I was hoping to be Michael as he likes “cute naked people” but alas it was not to be.


Lucifer. The most misunderstood of all the
ArchAngels, you’re most like the ArchAngel of
Light. You’ve seen the darkside and have opted
for something better. You need better press,
though chances are no one will really
understand your motives.

Which ArchAngel are you most like?
brought to you by Quizilla

Conflicts of Interest

Most media interest on the Christchurch Polytechnic computer course scandal has been how they used funding rules to get an obscence $15 million of funding to merely provide people with a computer CD. This is exactly why I will never accept that more funding is automatically the solution to better outcomes.

What is alarming me is the refusal of the Government to order an inquiry into the role of Labour Party stalwart and former Mayor Vicki Buck in the scandal. As the AUS newsletter points out, Ms Buck is a staff member of CPIT and brokered the deal with Brylton Software to to set up the programme, which resulted in around $5 million to Brylton which Ms Buck is a shareholder and director of. There is no written evidence of a conflict of interest being declared.

I have personally been in a situation where a company or organisation I sit on the board of, has wanted to do business with a company I am a shareholder of. In each situation I have insisted on removing myself from any discussion as to which company is used, have insisted upon the minutes of the next meeting recording my conflict of interest, and even asked the Auditors to check whether the notes for the annual accounts need to record the transactions as being with a related party.

To do so is simply recommended best practice for dealing with conflicts of interest. The amounts concerned in my case were for under $10,000. For Ms Buck it is allegedly up to $5 million. Absolutely scandalous yet no inquiry.

Treaty and Aquaculture

No Right Turn is appalled that National is not supporting the aquaculture settlement, on the basis of similarity to the 1992 fisheries settlement which National agreed to.

But is not the reason marine farming was left out, because there was not agreement that it was a traditional activity carried out in any way before 1840?

NRT claims that the settlement should be made because “we stole it from them”. I’ll put aside the desire to use the quote from Tonto “Who’s this we white man” and ask whether people really think that Maori owned 100% of everything in NZ prior to 1840? They owned all the fisheries, all the land, all the forests? Not just in the areas where they lived but all the areas where there were no Maori living also?

The other unremarked on aspect of the proposed settlement, is that it is not at all for historical claims. The $50 million is only for claims since September 1992. It does not cover any claims for pre 1992.

Clark up in the polls

An amusing poll was carried out for Listerine on whom people would most and least like to kiss and that is one poll Helen Clark has topped.

Clark was named by 62% at least kissbale woman, compared to 19% for Brash as least kissable man. Personally I would avoid both 🙂

I note that the most kissable women, in order, were Rachel Hunter, Judy Bailey, Nicky Watson and Toni Marsh. Judy Bailey????!!!!

I’d actually rank Marsh the top of that list. The survey also found that National Party voters would rather kiss Eva the Bulgarian than Nicky Watson.

Pay Up!

I made $7.50 from my illegal ACT leadership book. The TAB should hire me as a bookie.

A total of $60 was bet, and I need to pay out $52.50. Thanks Rodney for winning, as you had the lowest odds.

Ben, Gordon, Grant and Phil owe me a total of $25. I owe Berend, Drone, Scully, Millsy and Tomas a total of $17.50.

My next books will be on:

Will the Progressive Party ever make over 0.1% in a poll?
How many Maori seats will Labour lose at the election?
Will Winston Peters stop being Helen’s lapdog in the House?

Suggestions for appropriate odds are welcome.

Well done Rodney

Congratulations to Rodney on winning both the members’ primary and the caucus vote for ACT’s leadership.

I just hope this doesn’t mean he’ll be too busy to keep blogging. As expected Rodney has already blogged his own victory!

A National MP commented to me today that from National’s perspective they want ACT to get either 0.5% or 5%. The worst result would be ACT getting 4% and having that centre right vote wasted.

Heh just realised that now Rodney is Leader, he’ll get to write the letter to the Speaker asking for Awatere-Huata to be expelled from Parliament.

With Richard Prebble likely to retire before the next election, ACT will probably get both Kenneth Wang and Paul King as new List MPs in the next few months.

The final farewell to Reagan

I’ve just watched on CNN the final farewell to Ronald Reagan. The whole week of memorials has been incredibly emotional from the huge queues to pass his coffin, to the memorial services to even the tens of thousands of cars and people who pulled aside in California to see his hearse go by.

The tribute from his adopted son, and other children, was truly moving. And most of all the devotion from Nancy.

Reagan helped change the world, and it was for the better. Few people can have that said about them.

One of the things I really admire about the US is how they pay tribute to their former leaders. Federal Officers keep their titles for life, and generally regardless of partisan politics, they are respected for the contribution they tried to make. Of course Reagan was not a saint, and he did some things wrong – but this is a time for remembering all the great things he did.

In NZ, we seem to have lost this. One of my favourite spots in Wellington is the Massey Memorial near Shelley Bay. Apart from having the most beautiful scenery and stunning view of Wellington, it is a magnificent tribute to a former PM. The Savage memorial is good also. Nowadays what do we do – our second longest serving PM gets a little statue on Molesworth Street. Doesn’t compare much to the wonderful Presidential Libraries in the US.

Holiday Pay

I note the Government is talking of a change to the law so people do not get paid penal rates when they are sick.

It still doesn’t address the underlying problems the holidays act can cause small businesses. I suspect many people do not relaise that when the media talks about people getting time and a half on a public holiday, they in fact get double time and a half. You get time and a half for the day you work and time again for a day you don’t have to work.

To make it simple take the business I own – a small market research and polling company. My phone staff are paid well above market rates – around $15 an hour. They are mainly students and find the ability to earn extra income great. Some of them work five nights a week, others just one or two.

Now if one did a poll on the evening of Queens Birthday I would have to pay them almost $40 an hour. That’s right $40 an hour to make phone calls. So what happens is we simply don’t operate that evening as the costs of doing so would way exceed what one could charge to clients. The staff get pissed off because they lose money by not working, when they want to.

So the Holidays Act actually cuts income for many workers. We see this also with all the cafes which do not open. Would you open a cafe when you have to pay your staff 250% of what you normally pay?

It’s even worse!

No Right Turn has of course come out in favour of over taxing New Zealanders so it can equalise incomes.

He provided a link to a Herald table which made me realise it ws even worse than first thought.

Not only is there now only a $2,376 net income difference for families who earn $22,000 more, it is only $2,856 for a huge $32,000 income difference.

So what does this effective marginal tax rate of 91.1% do.

Well if you are on $38,000 and your partner gets offered a 40 hour a week job earning $32,000, then it will mean only $11 a day extra income. On an hourly rate that will be $1.38 an hour you keep of the $16 an hour you earn.

Reds under the beds!

When I read in the NZ Herald that John Key has accused the Government of communism, I thought it might be a bit over the top.

But upon reflection I’ve decided it a damn fair call – when you consider communism in the economic not the political sense.

The communist economies have everyone paid by the state and basically for example caretakers don’t get paid much less than lawyers or doctors. Everyone is equal comrade.

Well if you read the NZ Herald story, you will find that Labour is now redistrbuting wealth so much that a family on $60,000 income only get to keep $2,376 of the $22,000 income difference between them and a family on $38,000. Yep almost a 90% effectuve tax rate for middle income families.

I have no problems with a Government providing income support to people as a safety net so they can eat, have shelter, education and health care etc. Of course we should.

But Labour has gone miles beyond this. They now take money off a single person earning $30,000 and give it to a family on $100,000 if they have enough kids. Families on $40,000 with two kids don’t now pay a cent of tax – they are now effectively state beneficiaries. The changes made by Labour go beyond helping families in need to income redistribution on an unprecedented scale.

Just think about the incentives now in place. You might be in your job earning $38,000. Over the next five years you work your guts out, you do heaps of unpaid over-time, and you get three promotions and end up on $60,000. However your take home pay hardly changes at all – you get only $10 a day more after five years and three promotions.

Or say your partner is not working and you are on $38,000. Your partner gets offered a job for $22,000. Normally you would jumpt at the chance. But then you work out the $10 a day this new job will bring in won’t even cover his or her transport costs every day, so why bother.

As more and more New Zealanders become aware of the new reality, there will be outrage. Sure one has always had the odd high abatement rate for say people going from a benefit to part-time work, but never has it been over such a large income range.

The biggest blogger

In a few moments of boredom I deicded to count up the number of posts and number of comments made on each of the NZ political blogs I link to, to see who blogs the most, and which blogs get a lot of debate.

For May 2004 in order from least to most we have:

Heather Roy, NZ Pols and RNZ Bias all have a big zero. Time to delete the links I think (note all blogs mentioned here are linked on the left – I can’t be bothered linking each one again here).

Running Blog Capitalist has four posts and 12 comments. Quality not quantity eh Glenn.

John Tamihere has six posts and no comments (as he doesn’t allow them). Come on John we want more down and dirty goss.

My Right 13 posts and 5 comments

Hard News 16 posts and 0 comments. Russell’s do tend to be very long though.

Fighting Talk has 17 posts amongst the multiple authors.

Big News has 18 posts and 11 comments.

Darkness has 21 posts and a respectable 29 comments.

Just Left is getting there with 22 posts and 28 comments.

KiwiPete has 37 posts and 40 comments.

Aaron Bhatnagar has 38 posts yet no comments. Come on someone please talk back to Aaron.

I had 40 posts in May and 163 comments. Normally I’d have more posts but I had five weekends away travelling and a whole week without posts as I got snowed under. Lots like to argue with me though 🙂

PNN has a commendable 49 posts and 15 comments.

The Whig was busy with 57 posts, 8 comments and 17,652 downloads of pictures of the (ex) Whigette.

Helen Clark found enough time to make a large 77 posts. Only nine people dared to comment though.

Rodney Hide made 128 posts in May and he only started blogging that month! He needs to get elected Leader just so he has less time on his hands. A huge 346 comments – a real mini Parliament.

No Right Turn obviously needs to get a job, a haircut and a new suit. 152 posts in one month. No comments of course as they are not allowed.

And the supreme winner of the I need a life award is ……. (drum rolls)

NZ Pundit with 158 posts, plus a daughter to look after. As for the number of comments well I counted 115 in just one week so I gave up, estimating probably over 500 for the month.

At the end of June I may do another tally up. Lets see who will be first to make 200 in a month!

UPDATE: I overlooked Kiwi Pundit who has a worthy 32 posts with 31 comments.

This doesn’t make up for the Rainbow Warrior

TV Shows

I am loving Eating Media Lunch more and more. I was in hysterics at the item which purported to show Shrek slaughtered. I knew it would get some people worked up and as NZPA reports it got TVNZ deluged with complaints.

Hello people – it is a sheep. Thousands get slaughtered every day. Almost as funny as Jeremy Wells asking Linda Clark if she had had any Kiwi feline lately.

And yes I know I have a sick sense of humour before you all rush into to tell me. Incidentially the only bad review of Eating Media Lunch I have seen is by Pam Corkery, so that confirms it must be good. What made a newspaper think Corkery should review other TV programmes when she hosted one of the worst in history, I don’t know.

By contrast Quality Time with Havoc has stayed painful. Just trying too hard. Someone should put it out of its misery.

One of the problems of now being self employed is the amount of daytime TV I sort of watch (I like having it on in background). A diet of Buffy, Angel, Dawson’s Creek, Melrose Place and now Ally McBeal is not good. On the positive side reruns of Blue Heelers and The Bill are not bad.

Good one Tamihere

The Press reports that WINZ is up in arms because a staff member forwarded on a joke email about Maori TV line-up for June.

John Tamihere is quoted as saying some of the sppof titles were very witty and he did not find them offensive.

I would bet a lot of money that if one did a random survey of 100 Maori people, the vast majority would find the spoof titles more funny than offensive.