That looks familiar

I read the Sunday Star-Times main articles online, but later that day picked up a copy of the actual newspaper. On the letters page I saw a huge quarter page photo of Prince Charles and Camilla. That reminded me of something so I read the caption – “Would we rather have King Charles III and Queen Camilla as sovereigns of New Zealand?”

Suddenly I recall that I used that line in a letter to the editor I had fogotten about. Sure enough it was underneath the photo.

It was one of my very very few letters to the editor in the last decade. I tried to avoid them while working at Parliament in case it got me into trouble with the employers. Now I’m a free man I might crank them up again.

People are allowed to shoot me though if they ever hear me on talkback radio.

Newspaper Feedback

The NZ Herald published a useful selection of letters on Bishop Vercoe.

Several attack the NZ Herald for carrying the story, and I think their anger is misguided. One asked if they would publish a headline of “A world without Jews” and I hope the answer is yes. I would much rather had the odd views of people exposed than unknown. And the Herald wasn’t sympathethic in its coverage.

Also World Press has a good summary of editorials on Reagan. They range from Moscow to Annan to Libya and Sydney.

He won the war!

Heh!

Cultural Context

The new head of the Anglican Church in NZ, Bishop Whakahuihui Vercoe, is quoted in the NZ Herald as saying “One day society would find homosexuality unacceptable”.

The Herald has slightly beaten this up as saying he has a vision of a world without homosexuality, but the issue is pertinent. Considering that almost everyone accepts the majority of gay and lesbian people do not choose their sexuality, what sort of society does the Bishop advocate when he wants them to be deemed unacceptable.

What really annoyed me is the comments by Bishop Richard Randerson who said Bishop Vercoe’s views on homosexuality and women in the church arose out of a cultural context” and “There are areas within Maoridom today where leadership by women is not accepted as well as it is in other parts of Maoridom. Likewise with issues of homosexuality, I think probably most Maori would find that culturally very difficult.”

Quite frankly being Maori is no defence to bigotry. This is in fact the sort of political corectness which drives most NZers mad – that prejudice is okay in a certain cultural context. Should one justify female circumcision as being okay in a cultural context?

What I would like to see is a Government Minister condemn Bishop Vercoe with the same fervour that they would anyone else in a senior leadership position, with the same views.

Note I am not advocating that the Church should or should not ordain gays – that is an internal decision for the Church. My objection is the view that he wants a world where 5% – 10% of the population are deemed unacceptable.

Aaarrgh!

It is a gorgeous day in Wellington and I am stuck inside at an Executive Committee Meeting of InternetNZ. Only redeeming feature normally is the great wireless networking at 11Mb/sec. Unfortunately a cable has been snapped somewhere and even that is down.

So how am I blogging? Cafenet is reachable from here, and they have a stunning special of free access for every weekend in June. They’re great value even at their normal rates, but the ability to be almost anywhere in the Wellington CBD and have free high speed Internet at the weekend is excellent.

Students make front page

Nuclear Policy

I noted with amusement that as soon as a poll came out that most NZers were actually comfortable replacing a legislative ban with a policy ban, people starting claiming that the proposition was all based on lies, based on the opinion of the Centre for Peace Studies.

NZ Pundit has done an excellent job of highlighting the facts, so read away.

I am looking for the downside to a solution that keeps NZ nuclear free (for those who want it), yet also allows our relationship with the US to improve.

Luckily Marian Hobbs has found it. One does have to remember that for most of her adult life Marian was a member of the Communist Party (in fact I think she may have left it even after Mikhael Gorbachev left it, and he was the Party’s world wide leader). She thought replacing a legislative ban with a policy ban is “down the greasy slope of being subservient to American foreign policy”.

The reality as I have said many times is the ban is a historical nonsense, and putting the issue behind us requires both sides to compromise. The Creech solution seems a sensible way to get a win-win.

The choice is clear

The NZ Herald reports Rodney Hide has more support from the public to be ACT Leader than the three other contenders combined. In fact he has four times as much support as Ken Shirley who is second.

I am not a member of ACT, and will not be voting. But I hope those who do vote are aware of what is at stake. Electing Rodney as Leader gives them a reasonable fighting chance to be in the next Parliament. If they do not, then sadly it will be “the longest suicide note in history”.

My order of ranking on Monday would have been:

1 Rodney Hide
2 Ken SHirley
3 Stephen Franks
4 Muriel Newman

After Stephen posted his newsletter this week (discussed here) I now put Muriel third and Stephen fourth.

People may wonder why I should care, not being a member. Well as much as I would like National to win enough votes to govern alone, this will be a rare occurence. So National needs coalition partners. And frankly ACT is the only one I would be comfortable with.

In fact if I had to rank preferred coalition partners in order, they would be:

1) ACT
2) Outdoor Recreation
3) Legalise Cannabis (and no I have never ever)
4) United Future (if they can dump the fundamentalist wing)
5) Labour
6) Maori Party
7) Alliance
8) Greens
9) Christian Heritage
10) Progressive
11) NZ First

Vic follows Auckland

After Auckland students displayed such good common sense as requiring their President to apologise to Don Brash, and calling for tax cuts, the Vice-Chancellor of Victoria fled to AUckland University to become their Vice-Chancellor.

Realising hwo enlightened Auckland students are, Victoria students voted at an SRC yesterday to support tax cuts, denounce communism, support capitalism and thank Richard Prebble for his contribution to New Zealand.

If they keep this up, I could almost reconsider my opposition to compulsory membership of students associations!

A good speech by Cullen

Michael Cullen delivered a speech to the Human Rights Commission Forum on Tuesday.

It is a good speech, and the part I especially agree with is:

” have been asked to speak on the human rights aspects of the foreshore and seabed debate, and to get us off to a good start I would like to begin by challenging a common assumption about human rights protections in New Zealand. If I were to ask you to name the primary body that protects the human rights of New Zealanders, there are many who would immediately answer: the Human Rights Commission, or perhaps the Courts.

Without any disrespect to either of these institutions, I have to say that this belief is wrong. The primary body which protects human rights in this country is in fact the New Zealand Parliament.”

Another good section is “Whenever judicial officers stray towards making the law we run into trouble, not because their views are wrong

Lock him up

The Dominion Post reports that a Wainuiomta man has just been convicted of his 22nd drunk driving conviction. He also has 26 convictions for driving while disqualified.

A lawyer has said innovative thinking was required to stop him driving.

Nonsense. One just needs courts to apply maximum penalties.

After the first two convictions, the maximum penalty for further convictions is two years. Yet he has served only five years in jail for a total of 48 convictions.

Maximum penalties should only be used for the worst offenders, but surely this guy qualifies.

Everytime he is convicted, he should be given the maximum two year penalty. And they day he is released he should have an officer follow him about until he next hops into a car, and then throw him away for another two years.

That would do far more for road safety than certain other measures.

The no bang budget

Another post budget poll shows Labour still trailling National. The NZ Herald has a large 8% gap.

The party vote results and likely seats in Parliament are below:

National 44.0% 59 seats
Labour 36.1% 48 seats
NZ First 5.6% 7 seats
Green 4.7% 0 seats
United 2.4% 3 seats
Maori 2.4% 3 seats
ACT 2.0% 0 seats
Progressive 0% 1 seat

Labour could only form a Government with support from NZ First, United Future, Maori Party and (optionally) Progressives.

This is based on Anderton, Peters, Dunne and Turia all holding their seats.

If ACT and the Greens won an electorate seat then the distribution would be:

National 54
Labour 45
NZ First 7
Green 6
United 3
Maori 3
ACT 2
Progressive 1

National and NZ First could just form a Government by themselves if the Greens and ACT secured representation.

Spending vs Growth

No Right Turn seems to see things in a very black and white fashion. In every single issue he comes across, the private sector or the market or profits are to blame.

Anyway in line with this black and white view he has proclaimed I contradict myself in promoting lower taxes to increase economic growth, but not wanting to have $30 billion of extra government spending due to economic growth.

The answer is of course quite simple. Yes I generally support government expenditure increasing as GDP increases, but not at the same rate.

An easy example. Would you rather have GDP increase at 2% and funding for health and education grow at 2% or have GDP increase at 4% and funding for education and health grow at say 3%?

Plus of course there is a legitimate debate about how much the state should pay vs people should pay. If a family has $10,000 less tax to pay, then they are in a far better position to afford services that the state will never be able to provide universally.

TVNZ Post Budget Poll

TVNZ have the results of a post budget poll. As expected Labour have had a boost from the budget, but they still are 3% behind National.

They asked a number of questions with interesting results. 57% believe the budget is an attempt to regain votes after the poll drop. Also there is net economic pessimism by 7%.

A huge majority (66%) said they would prefer tax cuts to increased government spending (24%).

GDP

Idiot has got very excited on his blog, as he has discovered that there has been GDP growth, and hence this makes it all okay for the state to be taking in $30 billion of extra revenue.

I’ll ignore his fairly personal comments about truthfulness and my former occupation (which he has wrong, but hey facts …) and concentrate on the economic issues.

First of all it is totally appropriate to look at the actual amount of crown revenue and expenditure, not just as a percentage of GDP. Just because my business grows by 10%, doesn’t mean we should spend 10% more on hip hop tours, simply because the money is there from taxation.

The tax and spend article refers to the 1990 to 1999 period where it mentions crown revenue also increased by $8 billion. This was against GDP growth of 42% over that period. Labour has $30 billion increase against 62% growth.

Idiot also refers to the accounting changes in 2002. The $30 billion increase takes that into account, as I have backdated revenue from 1999 on the basis of the new policy. The increase would be greater than $35 billion if I had not. Again those pesky facts.

I stated in the article that only $20 billion of the increase was from tax. People may be interested in a further breakdown on this. The amount of income tax paid by individuals is forecast to increase by 70% (more than $10 billion) from 1999 to 2008. Company tax increases by $4 billion which is around 108%.

Every year more and more New Zealanders pay more and more tax. This is a combination of bracket creep and tax and levy increases. And the more money the Government has to spend, the lower the quality of the spending. Just look at the $115 million on community education.

Tax and Spend

A new blog on the block is No Free Lunch. It is a joint effort with articles from Roger Kerr, Bryce Wilkinson and even myself.

The site is “dedicated to improving the quality of economic and public policy commentary in New Zealand”.

I’ve just posted an article on how, if Labour is re-elected, crown revenue will have increased by $30 billion over nine year. That is not a cumulative total, but a comparison of annual income going from around $40 billion in 1999 to over $70 billion in 2008.

Stupid is as stupid does

Thank you very much for your kind donation …

It is bad enough that I am funding several billion dollars of Labour’s electoral bribes, but I almost choked this morning when I read I also have to fund a $21 million propaganda campaign on their behalf.

This is quite simply outrageous. To put the amount in context it is 12 times more than the total broadcast time allocated to political parties for the election. It represents over $70 per household affected.

Sure there is a case that one should let people know how much of my tax money they are now entitled to. But a personalised letter and a smart website should cost no more than $3 per household. A cost of $70 per household is quite simply propaganda. It will be used on general TV, radio and newspaper advertising despite the fact only 20% of households are affected.

Whoops

Was driving to Waikanae yesterday and there was a policr car just south of QEII Park. They were within 200 metres of a speed change sign which is actually against their own regulations.

Being a friendly sort I did the customary warning to oncoming traffic by flashing my headlights. Many waves and smiles back. Then noticed one car was flashing their lights back also. How friendly I thought. Until I noticed it was a police car and they looked fairly unhappy at my good samaritan activities.

Card declined!

Yesterday I had my Mastercard declined at the petrol station. This was somewhat surprising as I was massively under my limit and pat on time by direct debit monthly.

I phjoned up BNZ and they said a freeze had been placed on the card due to a suspicious transaction(s). However the only two they had was $12 to Pod for coffee and $15 to the Companies Office for my company annual return.

I thought their fraud detection programme was somewhat oversensitive.

However had a call this morning that there had been $6,000 of transactions from Japan and Malaysia – neither places I have been to in recent years.

BNZ of course are not charging me, and have cancelled the card. Rather a pain as I pay absolutely everything on it (airpoints are nice) so will have a lot of direct debits to change.

Always knew there was a reason I kept my Visa card open – makes a nice backup.

A split in the ranks

Normally the NZ section of the vast right wing conspiracy stands united on important issues like Winona Ryder’s innocence, but a big split in the ranks has appeared on flag burning.

Stepehn Franks started it by stating that flag burning is not speech and should be banned (as the current law does).

The Whig disagreed and thought one should defend what the flag represents, not the piece of cloth itself.

PNN backed Franks. He argues the flag does not represent a government, it repreents the land, its people etc.

Thr normally demi-libertarian Kiwi Pundit also backed Franks. Nigel thinks it goes from being speech to action.

And NZ Pundit also backs Franks, while acknowledging reasonable people can disagree on this.

So poor old Whig is not only whigetteless, but his only support is from No Right Turn which is like being helped out by the French Government!

Never fear, help is here. I’m with Blair (the Whig) on this one, and if you want to read on, I’ll explain why they are all wrong and we are right 🙂
Continue reading »

Gone already

Now that was quick. In just 48 hours the Government’s position on the changes to the age of consent laws has gone from a we support the policy in the bill, to we are happy with the select committee choosing between two options in the bill (a minor porkie, there were no options, just the ability to accept the changes or not) to we are totally ditching the proposed changes.

The Government has panicked on the basis of merely two days of headlines, and is in the idiotic position where it says it thinks the law would be better changed, but it will not even try to debate the issue. Isn’t this sort of poll driven panic what got them into trouble on the foreshore?

What they should have done is recognise that such a move could be very inflammatory, and rather than just bring a bill into Parliament, they should have openly canvassed in a discussion paper the pros and cons of criminalising 15 year olds for having sex with each other, debated whether one can seperate out what we want society to do, and what we want people to go to jail for.

It’s not as if people don’t listen to reason. 90% of the people I have discussed this with reacted with disgust as first. When one askes them though do they think kids should be prosecuted for having sex with each other, they almost all say no. There was a debate out there which could be won, if the Government wasn’t too scared of its own shadow.

A few people have been critical of Opposition MPs for beating this up, but look that was inevitable. Mouthing off at conservative MPs for beating this up, is like yelling at your dog for urinating on a lamp post – it is natural behaviour 🙂

A good communications strategy would have been aware of the potential of this blowing up, and worked out how to minimise the chances of this happening.

I was going to post yesterday that Russell Brown had posted a good commentary on the issue. It even got NZ Pundit agreeing the changes were not as bad as thought, and this comes from a man who has a daughter starting puberty!

Russell has followed up with another post on the issue, and he even calls my last post on this “useful and well-informed” which will probably land me in trouble with the vast right wing conspiracy hierarchy 🙂

One Network News Poll

Another bad poll for Labour. In fact what has been interesting is how consistent the around 10% gap has been for what is four months now with the Colmar Brunton One News poll.

National 47% (-1)
Labour 37% (+0)
NZ First 5% (+0)
Green 4% (-1)
ACT 3% (+1)
United Future 1% (-1)
Progressives – ha ha ha ha ha

If this reflected an actual election the seat allocation would be:

National 63
Labour 49
NZ First 7
United Future 1
Progressive 1

So a National Government with 63 out of 121 seats

If the Greens and ACT both won an electorate seat and stayed in Parliament, then the results would be:

National 58
Labour 46
NZ First 6
Green 5
ACT 4
United Future 1
Progressive 1

National/ACT could form a Government with 62 out of 121 seats.

In further bad news for Labour, a Marae/Digipoll poll shows Labour having dropped 13% amongst Maori and Clark down 14%.

The age of consent

A lot has suddenly been written about the Government bill to change the age of consent laws. It is somewhat amusing, considering the bill was introduced six months ago on 9 December 2003. People have just read it I assume!

Also the changes in the bill are not actually a lot different to the current law. I