Superb hypocrisy

This is George Rekers. He a leading US anti-gay activist who is one of the founders of the Family Research Council and a director of NARTH – the National Association for Research & Therapy of Homosexuality, which teaches men how not to be attracted to men. He has testified in court that the Bible is the infallible word of God and that homosexuality is a sin.

This is Lucien. He is a male prostitute, or a rent boy, and as you can see is available on rentboy.com. Lucien is 20 and claims to ave an eight inch uncut cock. I am no expert on these things, but understand most rent boys claim this size. Anyway back to the main story.

The Miami New Times reports that Mr Rekers and Lucien have just returned from a 10 day vacation in Europe. They were photographed arriving back in Miami together.

Now I know you are all assuming the worst, but there is an innocent explanation for all this. No Mr Rekers is not a hypocrite of the highest order. He did not spend ten days sinning with Lucien. He had a perfectly good explanation for their holiday together.

Rekers recently had back surgery and needed someone to help him with lifting his luggage!!!

I think there is a Tui billboard looking for a home.

Afghanistan Trip

I see Mr Key made a flying visit to Afghanistan the other day. Personally I completely understand the secrecy surrounding his visit- I didn’t tell my parents till after I got back home either. I was impressed how well they took the news, given their usual level of concern surrounding my travels in calmer areas and was highly amused to have my father offer to put me in touch with any contacts he might have there next time, if I told him in advance – his response when I ventured that we might go back in May?  To paraphrase politely, it was along the lines of “don’t you bloody dare!”.

I have to say, my four day visit in January this year (we left about 36 hours before one of the biggest attacks on Kabul in the past year) was one of my most favourite holidays of all time. It’s not every day you are escorted round by a former General and national war hero who infiltrated the Taleban, stole a Russian fighter from them, shot down several of their bombers over Kabul, strafed them on the ground, and landed safely.  Hats off to the General!

We bought Herati kilims (a type of carpet) on Chicken Street, visited the Darulaman Palace and Baburs gardens, ate out at a fabulous Lebanese restaurant (best kibbeh I’ve had anywhere in the Middle East), went drinking with contractors and CIA boys at L’Atmosphere (who knew there were bars in Kabul?), visited a military airbase (whoops, not really allowed), drove past the famous Hotel Serena (bombed in the attack after we left) and stopped in at the Kabul Museum. Sadly there wasn’t much to see as a great deal of the collection was travelling, or locked up in the basement at the time.  Robert Fisk has a column on the collection here.

One of the contractors we stayed with nearly got me arrested after telling me I could take a photo of a mini-drawbridge outside a CIA building – I checked three times then took the photo…big mistake, but luckily it was only a residence building and the guard let me go – and I got to keep the photo.  We had Blackwater over the back fence from our villa – the evacuation plan involved heading straight into their compound. 

The General was also kind enough to take us out to his home village in the inimitable Panjshir Valley (see also here) which was the highlight for both me and my travel companion.  Although eating whole, deep fried baby trout (complete with fins, teeth, heads…you name it) was interesting on a hangover.  Travel Companion and Other Visitor (a former bodyguard of the British royal family who trained up the new Iraqi equivalent of SWAT teams who was staying at the same villa and accompanied me on the trip) had a great old chuckle watching me grimace out a smile of pleasure for the General after chomping off the whole head to start – not that either of them were game enough to eat the heads!  After the first, I stuck to picking off the flesh- you can’t beat baby trout fresh from the river an hour ago. 

The Valley has a proud history, being the only part of Afghanistan that the Russians were never able to conquer…nor the Talib…and nor anyone else.  It’s long and fairly narrow, guarded by steep high mountains that look like they belong on a box of Swiss chocolates all the way down and a river runs though, and our General seemed to know pretty much every inhabitant we passed.  It was a treat to visit his village and meet his brother (no English but extraordinarily cordial) and what seemed like dozens of nephews and nieces (also no English, but gorgeous kids, shy and super friendly at the same time), and see the well that Weston Solutions had built there at the General’s request, saving villagers a couple of kilometre trek to the nearest water source each day.  Drinking from the mountain spring was divine – the complete opposite of swallowing a few mouthfuls of water in Kabul, before I decided to stick to bottled water.  In Kabul it literally tasted like effluent.

We stopped sevreal times on the drive and I had a great old time climbing all over abandoned tanks and anti-aircraft artillery- we even found an old tank from WWII, which the Other Visitor was rather excited about.  We also visited the tomb of Massoud (which looks nothing like the pictures on Wikipedia) and saw the wind farm built by Kiwi Tony Wood in the valley in 2008.  The General was very sombre at Massoud’s tomb, having known him personally, and fought with him against the Russians, and as he reflected on where Afghanistan might have been today had Massoud not been assissinated in 2001. 

The Valley was utterly beautiful and Travel Companion was very tempted to come back over her Summer break and spend a month teaching the village children English.  I was pleased to pull out some Farsi from many years ago, which is almost identical to Dari, spoken in Afghanistan, and which went down well everywhere- gave me some practice for my trip to Iran in February too.

Three things we missed out on – a visit to the mountains and Gardez pass (safety measures came in here as there had been unrest and attacks on convoys recently, and also time), a visit with an emerald dealer (cheap and quality similar to Columbian emeralds) and finally a trip over to Bamiyan (an army friend of mine who served there a couple of years ago gave me a contact at our base and assured me of a warm welcome – he said they came accross a couple of Kiwi tourists (generally hikers) in his time there and always gave them a meal).

Next time we hope! The General has offered to fly us by helicoptor to Bamiyan for a visit if we come back (he thinks he can borrow one from the Americans, and given his status in Afghanistan, he quite possibly can), and has also invited us to visit his family in Tajikstan later this year.  Now it’s just a matter of scrounging up some more leave…

Blog Bits

  1. David Garrett on the 2nd reading of the three strikes law and how Parekura claimed poor brown people will be locked up for stealing food for their families.
  2. Whale has audio of the two of us talking to Larry Williams on TV3’s lack of apology over their fake Paula Bennett story.
  3. Madeleine Flannagan blogs about the conviction of her former partner (and father of two eldest children) for rape, and her own protection orders against Travis Burrell. My sympathies go out to her, and her kids, for having to cope with this. There are lessons to other women in realising early that you should not tolerate domestic violence – or worse. Madeleine has been in court as a support person to his latest victim.
  4. Eric Crampton highlights the lack of analysis over the tobacco tax rise.
  5. Andrew Bolt excoriates Kevin Rudd
  6. Michael Moore has some advice for girls on how to get into a nightclub underage. Might be needed here, if they raise the age.
  7. Iain Dale blogs on how the Lib Dems were responsible for 73 of the 75 donations not reported on time to the Electoral Commission. Reminds me of how the Greens here also didn’t disclose donations in the time required by the very law they championed.

Maxim on Three Strikes

The Maxim Institute has a paper by Professor Warren Brookbanks and Dr Richard Ekins on the Three Strikes law. It sets out arguments against the law, the main being a third strike of a maximum sentence is not a proportionate response.

Now I disagree with them in opposing the law. I think it will e a welcome step towards stopping the idiocy that we keep letting offenders out after minimal sentences for repeated serious offending.

But Brookbanks and Ekins have also proposed some amendments to the law, which I do partially agree with, and the Government could consider at the committee of the house stage. They are:

Authorise judges not to impose the maximum sentence on strike three if this would be manifestly unjust (this amendment would bring the legislation into line with the assertions being made by the ACT Party).

At the moment the law directs a Judge to impose the maximum sentence without parole for a third strike, unless this is manifestly unjust in which case they can give the maximum sentence with parole.

So long as the threshold for “manifestly unjust” is very high (and case law suggests it would be) and not used frequently, I support this change. There may be times when a 14 year sentence for aggravated robbery, even with parole eligibility, is manifestly unjust.

Retain presumptive eligibility for parole, or if this is not done, authorise judges not to order the sentence be served without eligibility for parole on strike two if this would be manifestly unjust.

I don’t agree with this proposed change. I regard parole as generally being a failed experiment, and the certainty of no parole for a second strike is important. Possibly could live with a “manifestly unjust” exception again but I worry some members of the Judiciary would interpret that to apply to every case as they don’t agree with the law.

Modify what counts as a strike from a conviction for a qualifying offence alone to at least a custodial sentence for a qualifying offence and preferably a custodial sentence of some length, say at least two years.

This doesn’t catch enough people, and it means that if Judges keep giving light sentences for serious violent offences, the offender never comes under the three strikes regime.

Make provision for strikes to lapse over time (perhaps after ten years).

I think this can be reasonable. Maybe a bit longer period than ten years, but I have sympathy for someone who does a first and second strike at 18 and 19 and a third strike at say 55, and they automatically get the maximum sentence. One could argue this can be dealt with under manifestly unjust exceptions, but I think an incentive for a strike to lapse is a good thing.

However I would make it a condition for a strike to lapse, that the offender is crime-free for that entire period of 10+ years. Not just of serious offences, but of all offences.

Make specific provision in strike three sentencing to recognise a guilty plea, allowing judges to discount the maximum sentence by up to 25 percent, depending on when in the trial process the plea is made.

At present, an offender gets a “discount” on their sentence of 5% to 33% for an guilty plea, depending on how early they plead guilty.

There is a potential problem that there is no incentive to plead guilty to a third strike offence. Some discount for an early guilty plea could solve that problem, and not undermine the regime overall.

Authorise the courts not to impose a life sentence for murder and manslaughter if this would be manifestly unjust.

Again, so long as manifestly unjust holds a very high threshold, I could love with that.

Specify that some instances of manslaughter (most notably accidents arising out of gross negligence) do not constitute a qualifying offence.

I suspect very few people convicted of that type of manslaughter have criminal histories, and it would normally be a first strike anyway. However I think the proposed change has some merit, in differentiating between types of manslaughter.

I’m not sure if the Government is open to changes, but it would be good to hear debate on them. Maybe Opposition MPs can move them as amendments.

UK election get togethers

For Wellingtonians, the Backbencher has put aside a table for us at the back of the bar from 11 am (opening time) until 4 pm on Friday. Polls close at 9 am so results should start to be flowing by then.

We won’t be using the TV screens as the Backbencher doesn’t have BBC. In fact it seems no bar in Wellington does. But we’ll have laptops there so we can stream coverage and check out the latest results as they come in. There will be a power supply to the table, so feel free to BYO laptop.

I’ll be there from 11, and enjoying a few beers during the day.

For those in Auckland, an offer has been made to host interested people at the Harlequin Bar in Point Chevalier at 1130 Great North Road. If you are keen to go along, let Tony know by e-mail.

The UK Polling Report has the average of the polls being Conservatives 35%, Labour 28% and Lib Dems 27%. They project this to be Conservatives the biggest party but 52 short of a majority.

Their projection has Conservatives at 274 and Labour at 264, so not impossible Labour could remain largest party, and govern again.

However 538.com are projecting Conservatives 308,Labour 198 and Lib Dems 113. You need 326 seats to govern.

Pollster.com is projecting 297 Conservative, 225 Labour and 96 Lib Dems.

So really it could be anything from a narrow Labour plurality of seats, to a narrow Conservative majority. That’s what will make the actual results so exciting.

I claim 13/15

Caption Contest

Red Alert claims this is them celebrating their first birthday, but I am sure we can come up with better captions for the. As always funny not nasty.

Congrats to Labour for their first birthday. I think it has been a great initiative, and have enjoyed interacting with Labour MPs there. I check it out almost every day. By comparison I check out the National MPs combined blog site around once a month, if that. I can only handle reading so many posts about the opening some local school hall without wanting to blow my brains out.

Red Alert has had some decent stats also:

Today we are One. So we thought we’d celebrate.1902 posts, 35,116 comments. 35 out of 43 Labour MPs have posted on Red Alert. Some more than others. Trevor Mallard still wins the prize for the most posts (550). Followed by me (212) Grant (198) Phil Twyford (156) and Chris Hipkins (136) …

We average about 30,000 page views a week
More than a million page views
465,000+ viewers

I could point out I have managed to blog more by myself than 35 MPs combined (and it is their job, not a hobby like for me) but that would be churlish :-). I am sincere when I say that overall I think Labour have done very well with their parliamentary blog, and I hope they continue with it, even when they make Government again one day.

Editorials 5 May 2010

The Herald calls on NZ to back Obama in Afghanistan:

No compliment was more apt than the one that came from the commander of the International Security Assistance Force in Afghanistan, US General Stanley McChrystal: “The forces that New Zealand provides are extraordinarily professional, as you know, and they are key members of the coalition.”

He had special praise for the work done in Bamiyan, which he said needed to be reproduced around the country.

“That’s really where we are building the foundation of Afghanistan.”

No doubt such compliments are sincere, but they come with a significant fish hook.

General McChrystal made no bones about the fact that he would like the New Zealanders to stay on and not just because they are doing good work. …

Before he left Afghanistan, Mr Key was giving some pretty broad hints himself. The PRT was likely to stay for another year, he said.

He was less forthcoming about the SAS but said that its role would also be looked at, with the possibility of a smaller contingent staying for longer. Indeed, he said this was the preference of the SAS itself.

It would be no bad thing if its wish was granted. Of course no one would want to see us bogged down. But the Obama strategy needs to be given a chance to work and New Zealand should stay with it for the long haul.

It must be noted that the Labour Government supported the Bush strategy in Afghanistan three times, sending the SAS in. However they oppose the Obama strategy.

The Press looks at airline alliances:

The last time Air New Zealand sought to forge a trans-Tasman strategic alliance it was with the biggest Australian carrier, Qantas.

That proposal was knocked back by the regulators, which was not surprising as the alliance between the two would have cornered about 80 per cent of the trans-Tasman aviation market. …

Ultimately the key question must be whether the benefits for consumers, as claimed by the proposal’s backers in terms of cost and convenience, outweigh the reality that the alliance would lead to a reduction in competition. It is this issue which should determine whether this alliance will fly.

I know I’d be pissed off to book Air New Zealand and end up on Pacific Blue.

The Dom Post calls for reality from teachers:

There has long been a suspicion that reality stops at the door to the teachers’ staffroom.

The Post Primary Teachers Association’s ludicrous claim for a 4 per cent pay rise for secondary school teachers lends credence to the theory.

The world is just emerging from the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression, the Government is effectively borrowing $200 million a week to maintain existing levels of services, tens of thousands of New Zealanders have lost their jobs, and hundreds of thousands have received little, if any, pay rise for the past two years.

I think one could do a science experiment on whether there is a connection between the PPTA and reality.

The majority reluctantly accept that is the price they must pay for job security. At a time of crisis, everybody – employers and employees – has to tighten their belts.

For the PPTA to demand a big pay increase at such a time is to show gross insensitivity to those who pay teacher salaries through their taxes. For it to demand the increase after its members received 4 per cent pay increases in each of the past three years is to show secondary teachers, or their union at least, are completely out of touch with the real world.

As the editorial noted, we are borrowing over $200 million a week.

Yet the present pay structure does not allow schools to differentiate between the performance of good, indifferent and bad teachers. They are all paid on the basis of their years of service and the responsibilities they hold.

If teacher unions are as serious as they say they are about wanting to keep good teachers in schools, they should work with the Education Ministry to devise a formula that allows schools to pay great teachers what they are worth and send a message to poor teachers that they should review their career options.

I agree there should be performance pay of course. But not even to a formula. Principals should have the ability to pay teachers as much as they think they are worth, within an overall budget. The top teachers should be on over $100,000 in my opinion. However the lousy teachers should be on $35,000 so they have the incentive to change professions or improve their teaching skills.

The ODT talks about John Key’s visit to Afghanistan:

There really was no choice: Prime Minister John Key’s trip to Afghanistan had to have been a “secret”.

Indeed it is standard operating procedure for all high-profile politicians and personalities who visit the volatile and dangerous region. …

To the many popular faces of Mr Key has been added that of a leader not prepared to send New Zealand troops “to a destination I am not prepared to come [to] myself”.

And further confirmation of a prime minister who likes to “see for himself” – to gather information or insight first-hand to enable better quality decision-making.

He told accompanying reporters that he wanted to make his own assessment of the work of the 70-plus SAS team on active duty in the country, and of the 140 troops in Bamiyan involved in reconstruction activities.

He would also have been wanting to get a feel for how the Nato mission of the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) is faring. …

But whether the occupation and the work of the ISAF is headed anywhere but towards a stalemate – and thus whether New Zealand should recommit troops towards its mission – is the burning question.

Mr Key is right, at this point, to remain non-committal.

Personally I don’t think the PM’s visit to Afghanistan was anything remarkable. It is inevitable a NZ PM will visit troops serving overseas, as conditions allow.

What has been amusing is the howls of anguish from those media organisations who were not invited along. The reality is of course one can’t travel with a full press corps into war zones.

It could be worth considering some sort of formal roster or random selection system for future trips, so that it doesn’t look like hand picked media. One could have a policy of one rep each from print, radio and television. The trouble is these trips are so infrequent, it might not be worth the bother.

Bring on Three Strikes

Later today I am going to blog some criticisms of Three Strikes by Maxim, and suggested amendments. But for now, want to highlight why I support it.

The Dom Post reports:

A burglar who terrorised a woman has dodged jail, despite a previous conviction for attempted murder after stabbing a sleeping teenager in his bed.

The woman, who was chased out of her home and down the street by Burt Te Manu Tangiata Rikihana, 27, described the sentence of supervision as “a joke”.

Rikihana was arrested in December after forcing his way into a Petone home, where the woman was home with her three-year-old child.

Rikihana tried to grab the woman, but she got away from him. She fled down the street, before police arrived and caught Rikihana as he chased her.

In Lower Hutt District Court yesterday, he was sentenced to 24 months’ intensive supervision and 200 hours’ community service on burglary and assault charges.

It is pretty obvious from his pursuit that he was not just there to burgle, but to rape or kill.

In February 2002, Rikihana was sentenced to nine years’ jail for attempted murder, after stabbing Hastings 15-year-old Paul Robertshaw as he lay sleeping in bed.

This was an unprovoked attack on a sleeping kid, who he didn’t even know.

Rikihana took a knife from the kitchen, held it with both hands and stabbed the teenager with such force the knife came out his back. The teen survived.

Now under three strikes, this assault would be the second strike. As the Judge did not give a jail term, the penalty would be the same.

But under three strikes, if Rikihana commits a third violent or sexual offence, he would be given the maximum jail term without parole.

That might prevent more victims down the track.

Text problems

The Dom Post reports:

Text messages have been mysteriously altered between sender and recipient in at least 20 cases, prompting a Telecom investigation.

Salvation Army church leader Steve Molen discovered the glitch last week when he sent a text to 10 people to remind them of an upcoming dinner.

It ended on a lighthearted note with “bring a date or your muma but would prefer it if you bought [sic] a youth and plenty of food should be a great night so see you there six o’clock”.

However, one recipient – his wife Faye – received a message that read “bring a date or your muma but would prefer it if you bought me she setting a bad example for me”.

Mr Molen, of Newtown, contacted Telecom’s call centre and was told he wasn’t the first to experience the problem. “[The call centre worker] said it was a software fault that adds lines to the last part of people’s texts … and there had even been swear words added on to some messages.

I had my own text problems this week. Had played a round of phone tag with a new client and left a voice mail message for them at around 2 pm.

At around half past midnight my Blackberry beeped. I was in bed but still awake, so leaned over to check it. It was the client asking if it was too late for them to call me now. My initial thoughts were unprintable, and I resisted replying at the time.

I then talked to the client this morning and gently inquired what time did they send a text to me yesterday. As I suspected it was not at half past midnight – it was at 5.30 pm, and it took seven hours to reach me. The client was somewhat mortified (it wasn’t their fault) and was extremely grateful I didn’t phone back at the time I received it 🙂

It would be really useful if text messages were like e-mails, and had both a time sent and time received stamp.

A fee is fair

John Hartevelt reports:

A proposed annual fee to be charged to more than 500,000 Kiwis with student debt will net the Government at least $15 million.

The fee, expected to be charged at about $50 a year on every person with student debt, is being floated as part of a package to try to recover the spiralling cost of the student loans scheme. …

The Government was “looking at” extending an annual fee system to charge everyone with student-loan debt between $40 and $50 as long as they have money owing. Students already pay a $50 fee every year that they borrow to study.

“The view I have taken of it is that I actually don’t think that is fair when you consider it compared with any other form of loan you have,” Joyce said.

“We’re looking at an ongoing account fee which will be a flat amount and just helps to recover the costs of administering the loan system.”

Administration of the scheme cost about $50m a year, and the existing fee collected only about $10m every year.

“There is a $40m hole,” Joyce said. “The writeoff of the administration costs is massive and so what we’re looking at is whether we can come up with a reasonable fee which people continue to pay as long as they’ve got a loan account.”

Loan recipients benefit to the tune of thousands of dollars by having the loans interest free. I don’t see why the administration costs of the scheme should also be picked up by the taxpayer. The proposed $40 to $50 annual fee is modest and will not even fully cover the administration costs.

Figures to be released today show that the total amount borrowed has increased by 20 per cent in the first three months of this year compared with the same period last year.

The increase came from a rise in the number of students taking out loans (up 13 per cent) and the amount each borrowed (up 6 per cent for fees and 5 per cent for living costs).

More and more students will take advantage of interest free loans, even if they don’t need the money. It is human nature. At some stage a Government will need to look at charging interest again – even if only to cover inflation.

O’Reilly on ETS

I agree with the sentiments expressed by BusinessNZ CEO Phil O’Reilly:

In business there is a wide range of opinion stretching across the spectrum, from zealous green through to emissions denial. The most common reaction has been concern about increased energy costs just as businesses start to recover from the recession.

Why not delay it, they say – especially since Australia is now pulling back from its earlier commitment to emissions trading. The answer is probably that delay wasn’t a feasible option.

New Zealand’s situation is very different from Australia’s. Australia has never had an emissions trading scheme, so delaying the introduction of one would have been relatively straightforward.

To delay it in New Zealand would mean introducing amending legislation under urgency and ramming it through Parliament without even going to select committee. This would be Labour’s wet dream – National breaking its election promise and doing an u-turn, and even worse forcing it through under urgency to over-turn previous legislation that had been the subject of three years or consultation and debate.

If National did this, they would be suffer much the same fate as Kevin Rudd just has (fallen behind in the polls for the first time ever), but arguably even more.

But New Zealand has been committed to it since the trading legislation passed in 2008 by the previous Labour-Greens Government.

The present Government came into power that same year, on an election promise to improve the scheme passed by Labour and the Greens. Their mandate wasn’t to dismantle or delay it but to improve it.

The failure of Copenhagen has happened since then, and we should respond to that failure. But scrapping the entire scheme is daft and would lead to higher Government debt.

Had the Government sought to dismantle or delay it we would have had a fourth parliamentary/select committee process in as many years, with even more divisive, rancorous debate.

With Labour committed to returning New Zealand to the previous draconian emissions scheme and the Greens unwilling to compromise on their climate change stance, the issue would have become a long-running, festering sore.

Labour’s scheme had less protection for trade exposed industries, and would see greater costs on businesses, despite their competitors not having them.

Taking the longer view, it’s hard to deny the certainty that the world is headed towards a price on carbon. Whether it’s by way of carbon taxes or emissions trading schemes and whether within two years or 20, the clear intent of Governments around the world is to restrain emissions using economic tools.

I agree a price on carbon is almost inevitable. Even if you do not believe the claimed indirect warming effects of carbon emissions (which there is debate about), even the direct warming effects (which there is almost no debate about) makes a price on carbon sensible.

Official figures show New Zealand is on track to meet our 2012 Kyoto target. In 2012 our gross emissions will be 23 per cent higher than in 1990, but this will be more than offset by forests planted since 1989, with many New Zealand foresters actively receiving tradeable carbon credits.

This is key. Forestry is already in the scheme. You can not simply scrap a scheme that has already started. Forest owners are owed hundreds of millions of dollars for their forests under the scheme.

The fact that we already had the legislation as far back as 2008 and the kinds of decisions made by other Governments over the last year have led to the situation where New Zealand is now a leader in taking action on emissions, rather than our desired position of fast follower.

And this is a concern. But the answer is not to scrap a scheme that has been in place since 2008. It is to use the 2011 review to decide whether to amend the rate at which businesses get exposed to the full cost of carbon, and when sectors such as agriculture enter the scheme.

We are scheduled to have a review of the scheme before the end of next year. Business NZ believes this review should be brought forward starting no later than the end of this year.

The review should cover issues like the cost impact on consumers and businesses, competitive disadvantage issues and the position of agriculture and other sectors within the scheme.

Positions need to be developed based on current economic and international considerations.

We should all keep in mind the fact that the world’s consumers are increasingly seeking low-carbon goods and services and our trading scheme is the vehicle for nudging our producers on to a profitable low-carbon path.

And we shouldn’t forget that taking action to reduce emissions and look after our environment is, in the long run, the right thing to do.

I think it would be useful to wait for the Mexico conference, and see if that is as unproductive as Copenhagen. If it is, then the review of the ETS should look towards slowing or delaying the impact of the ETS in trade exposed sectors especially.

Vodafone drops roaming rates

The Herald reports:

Vodafone will slash data roaming rates to Australia by 93 per cent and other international rates by 66 per cent by the end of the month, the mobile giant said yesterday.

This is a very welcome move by Vodafone. Rates will drop from $30/MB to $2/MB in Australia and $10/MB elsewhere.

I try to minimise data use when overseas, but it is very difficult to have zero use.

Great to see Vodafone respond to the numerous complaints.

UPDATE: A reader alerts me that the Vodafone rate cuts are for three months only. This is better than no drop at all, but people should be very careful after August to ensure if the rates have gone back to the normal daylight robbery.

Not public trees

The Herald reports:

Aucklanders hoping to save a favourite tree from being chopped when the law changes in 2012 could face a $20,000 bill.

A planning report for Auckland City Council estimated that as the cost of adding a single pohutukawa in Epsom to its list of protected trees.

In another case, the Tree Council (Auckland) was told it would have to pay an $11,000 deposit to try for a private plan change to protect an 80 to 100-year-old pohutukawa in Rosebank Rd, Avondale.

The story is accompanied with a photo of a tree in a park next to a beach. This gives the impression that tress in public parks and areas are under some sort of threat.

Not once in the article is it made clear that these potential costs are around trees on private land. It is the cost of trying to impose your will onto the tree owner.

Under the old law the tree owner had to pay the Council for the right to trim or fell his or her own trees on their private property. Now the cost falls on the busy bodies who want to prevent a property owner from trimming or felling a tree they own. That is how it should be.

It is a shame the Herald article not once makes it clear this change is about trees on private land only, not on public land.

Should Key have stayed?

The Herald reports:

Prime Minister John Key’s decision to quit an overseas trade mission to attend the funerals of three Air Force servicemen has been criticised as “short-sighted and irresponsible”.

The comments were made by Cognition Education chief executive John Langley, who was one of 90 business men and women in the delegation to Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates.

John Langley is, I presume, the former Dean of Education at Auckland University whom No Right Turn reports in 2005 defended David Benson Pope’s right to throw tennis balls at pupils. No Right Turn called him an “apologist for sadism”.

Dr Langley described the helicopter crash on Anzac Day as a terrible tragedy.

“But is that a reason for the Prime Minister to abandon his international obligations and rush back to New Zealand to do little more than pander to New Zealand public opinion and our moralistic and judgmental press?”

I am sure that some of those on the trip were disappointed that the PM had to leave them for a few days. But for my 2c I think it was absolutely the right call to return home for the funerals of the three servicemen.

Worst Prime Minister ever

A candidate in the UK elections this week has declared Gordon Brown the worst Prime Minister ever.

Now this by itself may not be surprising. Candidates say many harsh things about their opponents.

However in this case, Manish Sood was not speaking about his opponents, but his own party leader. He is the Labour candidate for north-west Norfolk.

Mr Sood, 38, said: “I believe Gordon Brown has been the worst Prime Minister we have had in this country.

“It is a disgrace and he owes an apology to the people and the Queen.”

I guess he won’t be making Cabinet if the Lib Dems put Gordon back in.

Personally I thought the Viscount Goderich (Frederick Robinson) might be the worst.

More hypocrisy exposed

Claire Browning at Pundit exposes the hypocrisy of Labour and Chris Carter on the whaling issue.

Chris Carter’s excoriation of the Key government on whaling is rubbished by official MFAT papers showing similar negotiations when Labour was the government and Carter whaling Minister.

Sigh. Why am I not surprised.

… documents released to Pundit under the Official Information Act confirm that diplomatic talks commenced and were actively pushed on Labour’s watch, by Carter and Phil Goff, as the former Ministers of Conservation and Foreign Affairs, on terms so similar that if you blinked you’d miss the difference.

So Labour chose to undermine the NZ Government attempts to get an agreement, for petty grand standing.

The papers make plain what I expected: that New Zealand does not support resumption of commercial whaling. But they also say that, if commercial whaling was to resume, it would need to be robustly regulated and managed. Therefore, despite New Zealand’s strongly anti-whaling position, between 2005 and 2008 it was actively participating in “negotiations on a revised management scheme, which would provide a regime to govern commercial whaling if it ever resumed”.

Sound familiar.

According to an MFAT communique of July 25, 2005: “The main new development from IWC57 was the resolution agreeing to consider a high-level diplomatic conference if needed to resolve outstanding issues on an RMS … As noted by Minister Carter in comments to the media, New Zealand is prepared in principle to support the idea of a diplomatic conference …”. You remember the RMS — the revised management scheme, that would govern commercial whaling if it ever resumed.

Hmmn were there two Ministers Carter in the Labour Government?

But the best is yet to come:

A bit over six months later, Ministers had warmed up to the idea quite a lot. An email dated February 20, 2006 records: “I had a call from Chris Carter’s office … about the submission on the approach the delegation should take at the Cambridge meeting. The Minister has ticked off on all the recommendations except the one that says the delegation should not push the idea of a diplomatic conference”. A briefing to the Minister of Foreign Affairs dated February 10, 2006, annotated and signed by Phil Goff, includes this response to officials’ advice:

It is recommended that you:

3. agree that … New Zealand does not support a resumption of commercial whaling. Nonetheless, if commercial whaling were to resume, we would want it to be regulated through a strong and robust RMS … commercial whaling under an RMS would be incompatible with current scientific whaling and … an RMS needs to address this issue … [Yes]

4. agree that New Zealand should not lead calls for a diplomatic conference to discuss the future of the IWC … [No]

This is stunning. The officials recommended NZ should not lead the calls for a diplomatic conference leading to a revised management system, and Chris Carter and Phil Goff over-rode that advice to set a policy that NZ should actively push for such a conference.

Editorials 4 May 2010

The Herald talks social media:

If anyone doubts how technology is changing the way people communicate with each other they should consult the latest research by the Privacy Commissioner.

Published this week, the survey of Individual Privacy and Personal Information shows that 43 per cent of us now use a social networking site such as Facebook or Twitter.

This is an enormous increase from the 14 per cent recorded three years ago. Clearly these sites provide a welcome service to large numbers of happy customers.

But there is a big difference which Privacy Commissioner Marie Shroff highlighted with the release of the survey results. She pointed out that more than half of those who used social networking sites assumed them to be private spaces.

However, this was really an illusion of privacy; personal details or pictures could be easily obtained by third parties, creating the real possibility of unintended, unacceptable and even dangerous consequences.

They are public places, but the sheer amount of info there, makes them semi-private. Unless someone is looking for your info for a reason, then people’s info generally stays with friends and families. But if you apply for a job, come to public notice in some way, it is all there to be seen.

A much better approach was suggested by Ms Shroff this week when she urged people to use internet safety resources available through Hector’s World, Netsafe and the Privacy Commissioner’s website.

As the survey has shown, most people join social networking sites with their eyes wide open and they understand the risks and issues and how to protect themselves.

Rather than bringing in more laws, the challenge should be to open the eyes of the few who fail to see the consequences of what they are doing.

I agree.

The Press wants better  roading infrastructure:

New Zealand has had a habit of under-investing in road infrastructure.

The most obvious example of this has been in Auckland, where decades of myopia has required multi-billion dollar catch-up projects, while in Wellington, the Transmission Gully route was until recently an exercise in dithering.

And in Canterbury it should not have taken a triple fatality crash on Saturday morning to highlight the driving risks on parts of State Highway 1 which require action. …

Steven Joyce has shown commendable speed in identifying roading priorities and pledging the money to them (the harder part).

This roading situation might have been adequate or acceptable a generation ago, when traffic volumes were far lower, but not today. Waimakariri and Selwyn, through which SH1 goes, are two of the fastest growing districts in New Zealand. Increasing numbers of commuters travel from small towns, including new ones such as Pegasus, into Christchurch, sharing the road with significant tourist traffic and with trucks.

The US do it quite well. Motorway and highways do not go through towns but around them.

The Dom Post looks at democracy in Tonga, or the lack of it:

The only good thing that could have come from the tragic sinking of the Princess Ashika off Tonga would have been a new openness and accountability in the Tongan political system.

The resignation of Attorney-General John Cauchi suggests that is a forlorn prospect.

The inquiry gave Tongans a rare glimpse of the inner workings of the elite who run their country – an elite who gain power based on hereditary links and personal contacts rather than talent. But having promised, and delivered, a fully transparent inquiry, it appears Tonga’s rulers are getting cold feet.

The Australian-born Mr Cauchi quit last week over government plans to abolish the judicial services commission which appoints judges. He believes the move is an attempt to interfere with the inquiry. Others say the cabinet is trying to discredit the royal commission.

The Tongan Government says Mr Cauchi was unable to properly exercise the powers he was granted and outsiders should butt out. Political reform is a matter for Tongans alone.

But as Tongans do not have the vote in a meaningful way, that is not true. They do not have the ability to get change internally.

And the ODT looks at ACC:

Unless it is a statistical blip, evidence points to procedures within ACC’s Sensitive Claims Unit having radically altered.

Figures show 32 sexual-abuse claims for counselling were approved in the first two months this year, compared with 472 in January and February 2009.

That is not far off a tenfold decrease.

And, on Monday last week, ACC Minister Nick Smith announced the way the corporation managed the claims of sexual-abuse victims was to be reconsidered.

To this end, he named a panel to undertake a “clinical review to ensure best possible practice in this sensitive area”. …

The conclusion must be that changes to the way in which ACC handles such claims, introduced in October last year by Dr Smith, have been responsible for the drop.

On the one hand, this will undoubtedly be helping to meet the savings of which the minister has made something of a mantra; on the other, it could mean that the changes have been “overcooked”, laying the minister open to charges of callousness and injustice.

Personally I don’t think sexual abuse victims should receive ACC. I do think they should get assistance for counselling etc from the state, but through Vote Health or Vote Justice. One of the problems of ACC is it has expanded too far from its original mandate.

2009 Party Donors

The Electoral Commission has published the donation returns for 2009 for political parties. Only donations of greater than $10,000 have the identity of the donors disclosed. So who are the parties attracting the major donations?

The party with the largest number of large donors is the Greens, who had $147,462 of large donations. In order they were:

  1. Stuart Bramhill $19,500
  2. Jeanette Fitzsimons $15,643
  3. Metiria Turei $15,307
  4. Russel Norman $15,250
  5. Keith Locke $14,468
  6. Catherine Delahunty $14,428
  7. Kevin Hague $13,928
  8. Sue Kedgley $13,868
  9. Kennedy Graham $13,302
  10. Sue Bradford $11,768

Mr Bramhill is a regular large donor to the Greens. I would have to check but think his total donations exceed $100,000 over time.

Next largest was ACT with one $20,000 donation from The Virtual Bucket Ltd. That company is owned by Roger Beattie of Christchurch. Mr Beattie is  well known entrepreneur who wants to farm wekas!

Third was Jim Anderton’s Progressives who banked $15,000 from Juken Nissho Ltd. Their declaration is technically incorrect as there is no company of that name. In 2004 they changed their name to Juken New Zealand Ltd.

It is a large company with $224 million turnover in 2009. They made a $165 million loss, but nice they could spare some money for Jim.

Fourth was the Maori Party, with co-leader Pita Sharples donating $11,142 in fortnightly installments.

Fifth was Labour with Phil Goff donating $10,063. I suspect Labour are still tithing their MPs a proportion of their salaries, and only Goff exceeded the threshold of $10,000.

National did not have any donors give over $10,000 in 2009.

Current mining on Section 4 land

David Garrett asked the following written question:

Is any mining or mining related activity currently taking place in areas listed in Schedule 4 of the Crown Minerals Act, if so, where, when were the permits granted, and what is the nature of the activity?

And the answer is:

Mining activity of a modest nature is currently taking place in three areas listed in Schedule 4 of the Crown Minerals Act. The details of the permits are as follows:

Mining Permit 41870:  Granted to Peter Fielding on 17 March 2005 to undertake small scale alluvial gold and gemstone mining in the Hart Creek catchment within the Paparoa National Park.Special Purpose

Mining Permit 42024: Granted to the Broken Hills Gold Company Limited on 2 August 2000 to undertake underground mining for gold, silver, quartz and clay by traditional mining methods at Broken Hills within the Coromandel Forest Park.Waiho River Gold Fossicking Area:

Gazetted by the Crown on 19 September 1996, under section 98 of the Crown Minerals Act 1991, to allow for public recreational gold mining (using hand held non motorised equipment) without the need for a permit in the Waiho River within the Westland Tai Poutini National Park.  Gold fossicking areas are administered by the Department of Conservation.

So Labour granted two permits for mining on Section 4 land.  So mining is now okay on Section 4 land, so long as it is small scale? Is that what Phil Goff told the marchers?

And when Labour says they will cancel all mining permits for Section 4 land, does that include the permits they granted?

Air NZ and Virgin

Stuff reports:

Air New Zealand chief executive Rob Fyfe has warned that Jetstar and Qantas could soon dominate the trans-Tasman market if Air New Zealand’s new alliance with Virgin Blue is rejected by competition authorities.

I love Air New Zealand and think they are a great airline, but I do wish they would spend less time trying to reduce competition on the trans-Tasman routes.

This must be the third or fourth time I’ve heard they cry that Air New Zealand is doomed unless it does a deal on the trans-Tasman route, and regulators turn them down, and what do you know they continue to be very profitable.

Average airfares across the Tasman could fall between 10 per cent and 20 per cent as a result of the planned alliance Mr Fyfe said.

Yes, reducing competition of course leads to cheaper airfares. Not.

Mr Fyfe said unlike Air NZ’s attempted tie-up with Qantas, which would leave one player with three-quarters of the market, a deal with Virgin would create a player with around 56 per cent share.

And this is not so bad, as the proposed Qantas deal. However I prefer three way competition, rather than a duopoly.

Performance Pay

The Dom Post reports:

Primary school teachers fearing a move toward performance pay have proposed an alternative plan.

God forbid that teacher’s performance have any impact on their pay packet. It is vital that the worst teachers be paid no less than the best teachers.

A draft NZEI claim suggested a “potential counter” to any proposal to move toward performance pay. Teachers had said they did not want performance pay.

“However, a skills-based pay model that can objectively identify exemplary teaching practice and provide additional remuneration has merit, and further developmental work on it should be done,” the draft claim said.

This may have some merit. Encouraging exemplary teaching practice is worthwhile. However it is unclear how it would work. Is it something that 99% of teachers would easily be able to claim they do, and hence qualify for the extra remuneration?

“This is very different to, and is potentially a counter to, any proposal to move towards performance pay.”

Any skills-based pay system would have to be objective, fair and rigorous and not based on student results, the draft claim said.

“It must not lead to competition amongst teachers.”

Basing pay purely on student results s stupid. But it is equally stupid to not take any account at all of student results. They should be one input into the remuneration.

My performance pay system is simple. Each principal is free to pay each teacher whatever they think they are worth, within an overall budget. In other words, just like almost every other sector of society.

Not a smart call

The Dom Post reports:

Telecom landline customers face a steep rise in the cost of off-peak national calls from next month.

The company is increasing the cost of calls by more than 25 per cent from 19 cents a minute to 24c. …

The company’s toll call revenues have been falling more steeply than any other major part of its business as more customers use internet phone services such as Skype, discount calling cards on sale at dairies, and a recent spate of cheap mobile offers for both overseas and national calls. …

Slingshot, the third biggest residential phone provider, has peak and off-peak national toll calls for 8 cents a minute.

Hmmn you’re losing money because customers are using cheaper services such as Skype, calling cards or competing toll providers.

So your response is to put prices up, so even fewer customers will use you!

Will NZ stay on in Afghanistan?

NZPA report:

The head of international forces in Afghanistan wants New Zealand troops to stay longer and Prime Minister John Key says he will consider the possibility.

General Stanley McChrystal, commander of the International Security Assistance Force, told New Zealand journalists in Kabul that progress in areas such as Bamiyan, where New Zealand has 140 personnel, was critical to securing peace.

The Government wants to phase out NZ’s presence in Afghanistan. The rotation for the Provincial Reconstruction Team (PRT) in Bamiyan is set to end in September and the 70 Special Air Service soldiers in Kabul are due to leave in March. …

“In places like Bamiyan, the work we’re doing, they don’t get the headlines because we don’t have as many suicide bombs going off or violence in the area, but that’s really where we are building the foundation of Afghanistan.

“Now we will eventually make progress like that everywhere in the country but it will take longer in areas where it is violent now.”

Mr Key said the PRT commitment was likely to roll over for another year and then start reducing with more civilians coming in.

“Over time the composition is going to change away from the military capability to a civilian capability and that’s the plan. That will be starting in 2011. And that’s part of the handing back of control, if you like, to the people of Afghanistan, so there will be a military capability, it might be around 50 people.”

Mr Key said the SAS’s commitment would be looked at. “The SAS preference would be to have a smaller contingent to stay for a bit longer.”

He said the SAS had recently had a big success uncovering a “tremendous” cache of weapons in Kabul including missiles and hand grenades.

However, he would not commit himself to allowing them to remain.

It’s a tough call to make. Any extensions increases the odds that NZ soldiers will be killed in the line of duty. However this is not a risk unique to Afghanistan – four NZ soldiers have died serving in East Timor.