Worried Guam may tip over

This is superb. Hank Johnson, a Democratic Congressman (from Georgia) is questioning Admiral Willard about the plans to have a base with 8,000 marines on Guam. Guam is a US territory that is 541 square kms in size with a population of 180,000.

Johnson asks questions about how wide the island is, and how long the island is, and then goes to say “My fear is the whole island will become so overly populated it would tip over and capsize.”

I like the comment on the You Tube page which says:

Everyone knows when an island tips over, the greatest danger is that it floats to the end of the world and falls off!

So true.

Paquin comes out

The media are hyping up the news that NZ film star Anna Paquin has announced she is bisexual. I expect TV news will make it a major item tonight.

The context of her doing so, can be seen in the video above. I think it was a pretty gutsy thing to do, is to reveal something that is quite private, in the interests of promoting an anti-discrimination campaign.

The video was actually filmed in January, so they have managed to keep it under wraps well.

I think Paquin is an incredibly talented actress, and I love her Sookie Stackhouse portrayal in True Blood.

The House of Lords

The Dim-Post dug this up, and it is real, not satire:

March 3, 2010

Palace of Westminster: Pest Control Question

3.07 pm

Asked By Baroness Finlay of Llandaff

    To ask the Chairman of Committees what measures are being considered to improve pest control in the Lords’ part of the Palace of Westminster.

The Chairman of Committees (Lord Brabazon of Tara): My Lords, the administration is fully aware of the problem with mice in the Palace of Westminster and is taking all appropriate measures to minimise their numbers. We retain the services of an independent pest control consultant and a full-time pest controller. The current focus is on poisoning and trapping, blocking of mouse access points, and more frequent cleaning of bars and restaurants to remove food debris. This programme was intensified over the February Recess and fewer sightings of mice have been reported since.

Baroness Finlay of Llandaff: I thank the noble Lord for his reply. How many calls have there been to the mouse helpline? Has the accuracy of that information been checked, given that the staff report seeing mice on a daily basis at the moment in the eating areas? Has consideration been given to having hypoallergenic cats on the estate, given the history? Miss Wilson, when she was a resident superintendent in this Palace, had a cat that apparently caught up to 60 mice a night. The corpses were then swept up in the morning. Finally, does the noble Lord recognise the fire hazard that mice pose, because they eat through insulating cables? It would be a tragedy for this beautiful Palace to burn down for lack of a cat.

The Chairman of Committees: My Lords, there are a number of questions there. I cannot give an answer to the number of calls made to the mouse helpline-if that is its title. I suspect that it would not be a good use of resources to count them up. But I am well aware of the problem of mice, as I said in my Answer. It is something that we take seriously.

As for getting a cat, I answered a Question from the noble Lord, Lord Elton, last week on this matter. I was not aware that such a thing as a hypoallergenic cat existed-I do not know whether our cat at home is one of those. There are a number of reasons why it is not a good idea to have cats. First, they would ingest mouse poison when eating poisoned mice, which would not be very nice for them, and there would be nothing to keep them where they are needed or stop them walking around the House on desks in offices or on tables in restaurants and bars-and maybe even in the Chamber itself. Therefore, we have ruled out at this stage the possibility of acquiring a cat, or cats.

Lord Bradshaw: I have spoken continually to the staff in the eating places in the House and I acknowledge that there has been some diminution in the number of mice around. But could I press the noble Lord, because further action needs to be taken? I know that this is an old building, but mice are still here and we are talking about places where food is served. I have no magic solution, but perhaps the consultant who is being employed might have some answers.

The Chairman of Committees: My Lords, I am well aware that there are still mice around. I saw one in the Bishops’ Bar only yesterday evening. I do not know whether it was the same one that I saw the day before or a different one; it is always difficult to tell the difference between the various mice that one sees. We believe that the problem is getting better. Cleaning is one of the measures we are taking, as I outlined in my original Answer. As I speak here this afternoon, the Bishops’ Bar and the Guest Room are being hoovered, so we can get rid of the food scraps from lunch. If you were a mouse, you would rather eat the crumbs of a smoked salmon sandwich than the bait. Therefore, we want to remove the crumbs as quickly as possible.

Lord Pilkington of Oxenford: Why should I and noble Lords trust the Executive to deal with mice when they cannot deal with the economy?

The Chairman of Committees: My Lords, I do not actually deal with the economy. I am glad to say that that would be above my pay grade, whereas trying to deal with the mice is probably just about right for me.

Baroness Symons of Vernham Dean: My Lords, I was in total ignorance that there was anything of the nature of a mouse helpline until this Question Time. Can the Chairman of Committees tell us what helplines there are for Members of the House on other issues that we do not know about?

The Chairman of Committees: I rather hope that we do not have too many other ones. I was not going to advertise the existence of the mouse helpline, although it was advertised some time ago. Indeed, I invited Members of the House to telephone when they saw mice. The trouble is that when the person at the other end of the helpline goes to check this out, very often the mouse has gone elsewhere.

Danyl has a link to the Hansard if you don’t believe it is real.

Australia vs Alabama

AAP report:

Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd is in hot water with the governor of Alabama for his response to comedian Robin Williams’ “Australians are basically English rednecks” jibe.

Williams made the joke on the Dave Letterman TV talkshow in the US earlier in the week and Rudd, during a radio interview on Wednesday, hit back by recommending the comedian “spend a bit of time in Alabama before he frames comments about anyone being particularly redneck”.

Rudd has stuffed up quite majorly here.

First of all a Prime Minister doesn’t need to respond to a joke by Robin Williams on Letterman. You just look pompous and defesnive.

But secondly you don’t respond by insulting a state of another country. You’re not a comedian, you’re a head of government.

Rudd’s reference to Alabama and rednecks generated a terse response from Alabama governor Bob Riley.

“I’m not sure if Prime Minister Rudd has ever been to Alabama,” Alabama governor Bob Riley responded in a statement.

“If he has, he would know that Alabamians are decent, hard working, creative people.”

And to think Rudd used to be a diplomat.

A novel defence

AP report:

A Cornell University doctoral student from New Zealand who is charged with slashing his wife’s throat on a nature trail in central New York plotted the killing and tried to destroy evidence by setting their home on fire, a prosecutor said at his murder trial Thursday.

The defence doesn’t dispute that Blazej Kot, 25, killed Caroline Coffey, a postdoctoral researcher at the Ivy League school. But Joe Joch, his lawyer, countered in opening statements that Kot suffered from a psychiatric disorder known as “Capgras delusion,” which made him think his 28-year-old companion had been replaced by an identical-looking impostor.

The trial isn’t in New Zealand, so I can safely say Good Luck running that line.

While Kot will admit to the killing last June on the Black Diamond Trail near the couple’s apartment on Ithaca’s rural outskirts, the notion that he was propelled by an “extreme emotional disturbance” beyond his control is contradicted by his attempt to burn bloody clothing, computer records and other physical evidence, the prosecution said.

Funny that.

The powerful Rick Giles

Heh, I have just caught up with this. Act on Campus President Rick Giles has become a media sensation.

It started with this interview on Sunrise with Oliver Driver where he was advocating Edison Hour over Earth Hour.

The talk turned to climate change, and Rick was trying to say that his arguments against Earth Hour stood up, regardless of whether or not you thought man-made climate change was happening. However his exact use of words was:

I think my argument is so powerful, it’s not necessary to talk about it

He meant of course that you don’t need to debate whether climate change is happening to talk about whether Earth Hour is a good thing or not, but the phrase has become one of legend.

The “I think my argument is so powerful that it’s not necessary to talk about it” Facebook page was born shortly thereafter and is now up to an impressive 3,400 members.

TV3, knowing when they are onto a good thing, gave Rick the opportunity to submit a home video where he makes his case without interjection.

I especially like the part about the communists, the Islamists and all of Ghengis Khan’s hoardes.

I understand there is already a competition between certain MPs for who can be the first in the House to use the phrase “I think my argument is so powerful that it’s not necessary to talk about it” 🙂

Rod Drury on NZ Digital Divide

A guest post from Rod Drury:

New Zealand’s Growing Digital Divide

David Skilling, the former head of the New Zealand Institute, used to say that New Zealand is running the risk of becoming “Fiji with snow”. Certainly from a technology perspective the digital divide between us and the rest of the world is becoming more apparent.

We used to be a first world technology country. Things happened and were available in New Zealand first, we Kiwi’s were always keen to try the new gadgets. But over the last couple of years this has changed. Being third class technology citizens, not only has an impact on productivity, but an impact on attitudes and innovation. Our daily technology world is less sophisticated than our digital counterparts in the US and now even Australia. The gap widens.

Take for example the Amazon Kindle eBook reader. It’s been available in the US for years and last year a global version was introduced that’s now available in Australia and Fiji, but not here in little old Godzone. In the US during a business meeting someone might say, did you read that book about …, While waiting to board your flight home you download the book on your Kindle, skim to the key points and for the meeting the next day you’re engaging with your customers on the latest social media marketing approaches. Slightly more interesting and relevant than last weekend’s Super 14 scores and the weather.

Vodafone has been hinting at Kindle being available in NZ for a year. Where is it? I’m past being angry, I now need to understand what is the hold up and can we help? We need New Zealand business owners to be armed with the same ease of access to knowledge that our global counterparts are.

Visual Voice Mail is another productivity tool that most people don’t know they need. Voicemail on my mobile is annoying. Unlike email, which I can choose when to process, with Voicemail I have no control. When you turn your phone on and have 15 messages it may take 5 to 10 minutes to get through and write those messages down. Often I’ll forget to call back. Visual Voice Mail was released with the iPhone several years ago and is also available on the BlackBerry. It’s to voicemail what the CD is to the 30-year-old cassette tape – VVM allows you to see all your messages and dive into the one you need. It puts you back in control. How much time would our hundreds of thousands of small business owners and company workers around New Zealand save by bringing such a simple thing as voice mail into the 21st century.

Telecom and Vodafone need to make it clear on when this first world productivity tool will be available to us. I hope Telecom will finally do their deal with Apple and competition will drive service innovation.

Finally, the iPad is the latest example of how far we have fallen. It’s out in the US this week and Australia later in the month – there is no time set for the iPad in New Zealand.

The iPad represents the next evolution in consumer computing. The first true NetBook for the masses, the iPad brings instant connectivity to all the resources of the Internet, bringing school text books and global discussions directly into your hand. The opportunities for software developers, for students, for grandma doing her email, are limitless. But in New Zealand we’re watching as the train leaves the station as people in other countries exploit the opportunities and feeling of wonderment as this new technology generation takes off.

We need to understand why the iPad is not in New Zealand in April. Is it copyright for eBooks? Is it the lack of a carrier deal. I don’t want to live in a country with no iPad!

We need to make sure there is a plan to get us back to where we should be as soon as possible. I don’t want my children to be left behind. I don’t want to be left behind.  Removing data caps in New Zealand is a good step but we need to ask the above questions of our service providers. We need to stop this divide.

Rod Drury is the CEO of Xero

Karori Wildlife Sanctuary

The Wellingtonian editorial:

The Karori Sanctuary, rebranded last year at a cost of $25,000 as Zealandia for reasons that still remain elusive, is entering dangerous waters by raising its entry prices so steeply. …

Will the price rises cause visitor numbers to fall, and if so by how much? Is Ms Mcintosh-Ward being wildly optimistic when she says she expects visitor numbers to increase from about 70,000 a year to 190,000 over the next three years.

Ms McIntosh-Ward told The Wellingtonian last week the price rises were necessary to cover the cost of the new $17 million centre.

In addition, annual costs were expected to double to $4 million.

She said prices had to rise to reflect the value of the new experience offered.

But that value is strictly subjective.

Faced with having to fork out so much for a family outing, many parents may now elect to take their children for a stroll through the nearby Otari-Wilton bush reserve, where the birdlife and greenery are impressive and entry is free.

I love Otari-Wilton bush and first discovered it in the mid 90s when the soc.culture.new-zealand Usenet newsgroup had a picnic there. It was a fabulous day.

Anyway the editorial reminds me I have had in my inbox a guest post from Phil Lyth, a volunteer guide at Zealandia. Phil says:

“Nice” said the Dominion Post on Friday. That’s not how I describe ZEALANDIA. “Nice” is what I said about the raspberry lamingtons at Kirkcaldie and Stains last month.

“Magnificent” is the right word to describe Karori’s wildlife sanctuary, a place that now ranks alongside Te Papa as a must-see destination in my view.

And, contrary to the impression given by your headline, it is available to every family in the Wellington region for only $8.25 a month. The family membership of $99 for the whole year allows people to visit as often as they want for no extra charge. (The equivalent Wellington Zoo family membership is nearly double, $175 for two adults and three children)

I have been a volunteer guide for ten years, talking to visitors and the wildlife and the project. I am attracted to the valley because of the vision – to restore the place to be “typical of Wellington pre-European settlement.” That is a bold goal, and one that is making a tremendous difference to the 250 hectares within the pest-proof and pest-free fence.

Since 2000, I have seen tremendous changes. At the start there were almost no visitor facilities, few native birds insects and reptiles. We charged $5 per adult for a 90 minutes guided walk, talking mainly about what was to come.

The Visitor Centre opening at Easter is a spectacular facility, but is just the latest of many that have been installed over the years: the wetland at the head of the lower lake, the mid-valley toilet block, the restoration and opening of the Morning Star gold mine (now home to our living treasure the cave weta), the tuatara research area, the upper dam Discovery Area, the upper lake viewing hides, live-cam and video of kaka and saddleback chicks in their nests, and much more.

Then there is the bush restoration. Over 30,000 native trees shrubs and grasses have been plated including the forest giants that will in time tower 30 metres high: totara, rata, miro and matai. My favourite, the northern rata specimen 75 metres from the Visitor Centre, has grown from 1.5 metres to 5 metres. The flora is growing at a rate of knots, because there are no browsing pests: none of the goats, pigs and possums that devastate Wellington bush outside the fence.

Native wildlife is breeding after releases of over 15 species. Visitors can see kaka, North Island robin, bellbird, saddleback, stitchbird, falcon, silvereye and tui. On the water, there are shags, brown teal, and scaup. Reptiles include tuatara and gecko, and three species of the creepy-crawly weta are for the adventurous. North Island brown kiwi are heard and seen at night.

A walk to the upper dam is easily within the ability of visitors, and some choose to walk the 28km of tracks beyond that point. For myself there are still tracks not yet walked: one day I will enjoy the Tui Glen Track and the Rain Gauge spur.

I haven’t even touched on the Visitor Centre opening at Easter with two floors of interactive exhibitions created in Wellington by some of the world’s best designers, CGI specialists and model makers.

(And for the record, the total $17m spend includes far more than the Visitor Centre. It encompasses, for example, car parking at Appleton Park on Karori Road, and the Waiapu Road upgrade with retaining wall. Still for the record, ZEALANDIA is operated by a non-for-profit trust which must and will be financially sustainable over time, and which enjoys outstanding support from a tremendous number of Wellington businesses, community organizations, and individuals.)

There is far more at ZEALANDIA: the Karori Sanctuary Experience, that can be done in one visit or one day. The one-off admission of $28 compares favourably with the prices I would pay if I travelled within New Zealand: Auckland’s Kelly Tarltons in Auckland asks $31.50 per adult and the Antarctic Centre in Christchurch $55. Even a boat ride to Kapiti costs $55.

I recommend ZEALANDIA to anyone as one of the great New Zealand experiences, and attest that it is value for money.

For any Wellington family, $99 is excellent value for membership allowing one year’s unlimited visiting. And my friends from out-of-town will be encouraged to contribute $28 to experience a grand adventure of which I am proud.

Over 420 active volunteers are backing the sanctuary. Over 12,100 current members are. Positively Wellington Tourism is.

Will you?

It’s been a year or so since I have been to the sanctuary. Normally I take out of towners there, so will await my next international visitor, and will check out the new visitor’s centre, to see if it is good value for money.

No more smile and wave

My weekly column at NBR 24/7 is called “No more smile and wave“. My conclusion:

The first year of office was about getting through the recession. The third year will be campaign mode. This leaves the second year as the critical one for pushing through necessary reforms, and it is good to see the Government is willing to spend some political capital on pushing ahead.

Editorials 1 April 2010

The Herald approves of the balance in the foreshore & seabed proposal:

Division over the foreshore and seabed sparked a political upheaval, with Maori finally becoming an independent force in Parliament. Five years on, the Government, as part of its post-election agreement with the Maori Party, has revisited the issue. The outcome is an elegant compromise that has more of the attributes of a continuum than a radical response to the much-maligned Foreshore and Seabed Act. The proposal, outlined in a consultation document, will now be the subject of public submissions. It should attract widespread support.

Let’s hope.

The nub of the Government’s plan guarantees recognition of Maori customary rights while safeguarding all New Zealanders’ access to beaches. Central to this is the proposition that no one owns or can own the foreshore and seabed. The area would be called a public domain. Maori would again have the right to go to court to establish customary title, but not freehold title. This differs markedly from the 2004 act, which extinguished claims for customary title by vesting ownership in the Crown.

And the right to go to court is what it is all about, for many.

The Dom Post zeroes in on perks:

Finding the trough too high to get your snout all the way in? Don’t worry, the Speaker will be along with a saw shortly.

Want to treat your electorate committee but don’t want to dip into your own pocket? Don’t worry, just make sure you use the right slush fund.

Want to take the family on the train to Kaikoura for a spot of whale watching but think you’ll need a car while you’re there? Don’t worry, the taxpayer will pay for a driver to bring the ministerial self-drive down from Blenheim – and for another car and driver to take the first driver back.

Just so long as you are a minister of the Crown.

Ouch, very scathing.

And the ODT opines on tasers:

Last weekend Tasers, otherwise known as as “stun guns”, made their debut in the South Island.

Not before time, many would say, given the alarming frequency with which police men and women have been assaulted in recent months. …

Nor does there appear to be any constructive advice forthcoming on how, precisely, police are supposed to deal with drunk, drugged or otherwise crazed individuals who pose an evident risk to the life and health of law enforcement officers, but also to members of the community.

As has been suggested, the committee’s thinking on such matters appears to be devoid of any of the context and harsh reality that faces the police every day in this country.

Which is why we will ignore them.

Crime Stats

As TV One reported last night, the crime stats out today are pretty ugly for violent crimes – the category that most people care about, along with sexual crimes.

As one can see, the trend since 2004 has not abated at all. The Government will be hoping that the 2010 statistics are not as bad, as by then people will be more expectant that law changes would have had an impact.

The sexual crimes rate has dropped a tiny bit, but had been pretty constant anyway.

The Police have also published a new report – on culpable deaths. It will be annual. Some key stats for 2009:

  • 88 culpable deaths, being 65 murders and 23 manslaughters
  • 66% of victims were male
  • 14% of victims (12 of them) were aged under five. A terrible figure.
  • 56% of victims are aged under 30
  • 50% of the victims were Maori
  • 34% of victims had a relationship to their killer
  • 75% of female victims were killed by a family member or partner
  • 1 parent was killed by their child
  • 13 children were killed by their parent/s (including step)
  • 17 people were killed by their partner
  • 50% of deaths involved a weapon –
  • 68% were killed in a dwelling,
  • 25% were killed on a road or in a public place

Mark Prebble on The Nation

Former head of both DPMC and the SSC, Mark Prebble, is on The Nation on TV3 on Saturday at 11 am, talking about politicians and civil servants,

I’ll be very interested to see what he says. The Dom Post may give us some idea:

A former top public servant has called for changes to the way MPs are funded to make them look less “self-serving”.

Former state services commissioner Mark Prebble, whose new book With Respect is launched today, said most of the practices around MPs’ allowances were fair and they were not overpaid.

“But the big issue is that the system as it is currently run looks too self-serving and that undermines Parliament. Till we get a more independent system it will continue to undermine Parliament.”

He said the rules were set by Parliament for Parliament.

“It should be by Parliament for the people of New Zealand or, to put it another way round, by someone else for the people of New Zealand so Parliament can operate well.”

One solution would be to give greater powers to the Remuneration Authority, which sets politicians’ pay.

“The really good news is that the Speaker has opened up the system and made it more visible to everyone.”

Fair comments. I await the interview with interest.

Why ECan was sacked

A reader has brought to my attention this 2007 minute by ECan Independent Commissioners:

Last week Dr Jenkins the CEO of ECan issued a media statement expressing disappointment with the interim decision we have made on behalf of ECan as its independent commissioners. He also indicated that “ECan” (we assume he meant ECan management) did not agree with many of our conclusions. He then went on to detail specific areas where he suggests we are wrong.

The statement reflects Dr Jenkin’s earlier comments made before the hearing commenced, where he suggested that ECan (which, for the present purposes is us) would be declining all of these applications.

We are not surprised by Dr Jenkins disappointment, or that he differs with our conclusions. However, It should go without saying, that it is inappropriate for the Council to publicly criticise or debate specific aspects of the decision we have made on its behalf, let alone before we have completed the hearing and issued a final decision.

This is a prime example of how ECan was dysfunctional. It is almost beyond belief that the CEO would be undermining decisions made by the Council’s own independent commissioners. Bad enough he tried to pre-empt their decision, but even worse to claim to speak on behalf of ECan, when in fact the Commissioners were the ones with the governance role on this issue.

They go on:

Whilst we presume that this was not the intention, the statement may be interpreted as an attempt by management to try and influence the outcome of either this and/or future processes. It also puts us in an invidious position, when in essence, our judgement and competence is being questioned by the organisation who we are acting for. Such comments bring the independent hearing process into disrepute.

I note Dr Jenkins is still the CEO. I am surprised that the Council did not officially sanction him for undermining the independent hearing commissioners.

The Press also reports on what the other local authorities said about ECan:

Canterbury council leaders attacked Environment Canterbury (ECan) as “zealot-driven”, “vindictive and spiteful” and “operationally, a rudderless ship” in a review of the regional council’s performance. …

Timaru District Mayor Janie Annear told reviewers that ECan had a lack of knowledge beyond Christchurch and a lack of rural understanding.

“Some [regional] councillors have said `rural New Zealand are the sewers of New Zealand’,” she said.

I suspect they were not the councillors from the rural areas.

Annear claimed “there is not one area they are doing well in” and that ECan chief executive Bryan Jenkins was “starting to derail” the Canterbury Water Management Strategy (CWMS) and the “goodwill” built up in its development. She called for a “change of chief executive”, but said problems transcended “one CEO – the problems are systemic”.

An interesting comment, when viewed in tandem with the above minute.

Hurunui District Council chief executive Andrew Dalziel called ECan “zealot-driven at times” and said: “We’ve got to the point of making sure ECan investigators are accompanied by our staff.”

It sounds like the entire culture was awful.

Waimakariri District Council chief executive Jim Palmer said ECan was “vindictive and spiteful”, and Kaikoura District Council chief executive Stuart Grant said: “What do we want? ECan gone by lunchtime. This is a chance to gut the organisation. If water is staffed by ECan, it is doomed.”

Selwyn District Mayor Kelvin Coe said the regional council was “operationally, a rudderless ship” and “arrogant, combative, litigious”.

These complaints are not new. They were made to Labour also when in Government, but Labour wouldn’t act on them.

Armstrong on Foreshore & Seabed

John Armstrong writes:

National’s long-awaited prescription for healing that weeping political sore otherwise known as the foreshore and seabed should be grabbed with both hands by the Maori Party.

It will not get a better deal than the one outlined in the discussion document released by Attorney-General Chris Finlayson yesterday. National has stretched beyond the normal limits of its flexibility to come up with a lasting solution.

A stark assessment.

The arrival (finally) of Finlayson’s discussion document heralds Decision Day for the party, however. It can no longer cling to the foreshore and seabed like some kind of comfort blanket.

It is now or never – or, at least, not for a long time to come.

That means swallowing National’s intention to make the the foreshore and seabed a “public domain” which no one owns, something which sticks in the craw of Maori who insist ownership of the foreshore and seabed is their inalienable right.

That can be insisted upon, but in no way is that what the Court of Appeal ruled.

A new system for comments

Starting from next week, we’re going to have a new premium content system for comments on Kiwiblog.

Readers will be able to access posts my me for free, as per normal. That will not change.

But if you wish to read or make a comment, there will be a small micro-charge, as a contribution towards the running costs of the blog.

The comments will be behind a premium content firewall, and there will be three levels of access:

  1. Bronze – Read only – $1/month
  2. Silver – Ability to make up to three comments a day – $2/month
  3. Gold – Ability to make up to 30 comments a day – $3/month

We’ll be using paypal primarily as the method of payment, as most people already have a paypal account. Credit cards will also be okay, but at this stage we can’t do automatic payment or direct debits.

The money from comments access will primarily be used to fund professional discussion board software that will allow easy moderation, tracking of all comments from an author, most popular comments highlighted and a few extra features you’ll see next week.

Support a Weta

Wellington Airport have not totally given up it seems on the Wellywood sign. They have said they are willing to consider alternatives that get across a message of “Wellington, “Film” and “Global”.

So unless enough people support an alternative, we may still end up with a Wellywood sign. So for those who like the idea of a giant weta, I’ve set up a Facebook page you can join to show your support.

A welcome u-turn from Labour

Labour have announced:

Labour today announced it would support the Government’s Copyright Infringement File Sharing Amendment Bill but remains strongly opposed to some aspects of the Bill.

Labour’s Communications and IT spokesperson Clare Curran said the bill includes some sensible provisions, so Labour will be supporting it to select committee to make sure people have a chance to have their say.

However, Labour is strongly opposed to the provision for suspension of an Internet Service Provider (ISP) account.

This is excellent to see – both that Labour are supporting the bill to select committee (as it is a huge improvement on status quo), but especially that they have now declared their official policy to be against any provision for suspension of Internet access.

As the original S92A was introduced by Labour’s Judith Tizard, it has been a remarkable change in position to go from supporting the original S92A, to now opposing any suspension of Internet access as a response to copyright infringing.

Kudos is due to primarily Clare Curran for getting this policy change though. Also been impressed generally with Labour’s outreach on this issue – the meetings they hosted with stakeholders were a good example of genuine engagement.

What will be interesting is to see if the Internet suspension clause survives select committee hearings. The Commerce Select Committee has ten members on it – four Nats, three Labour, one ACT, one Green and one Maori Party.

The Foreshore & Seabed proposals

The 65 page full consultation document is here.

The key aspects are:

  • repeal the Foreshore & Seabed Act 2004
  • no one to “own” the foreshore and seabed, placing it in the public domain
  • guaranteed public access to all, subject to certain limitations in discrete areas (such as health and safety restrictions around ports, or restrictions around urupa/burial grounds)
  • recognition of customary rights
  • protection of existing use rights to the end of their term
  • restore the right to go to Court to establish customary title, based on common law principles
  • customary title will not be able to be made into freehold title
  • no change to current private ownership of any parts of the foreshore & seabed
  • two tiers of rights can be sought – customary title and customary rights

I think this is a significant improvement over the current law. It passes the two critical tests of guaranteeing public access, and of restoring the right to go to court to pursue common law and other rights.

I also like the idea of the foreshore and seabed being in public domain, with no ownership at all. That means it can’t be sold without special legislation. It also means that the 30% in private ownership won’t increase.

I’m all for private ownership of most things – but not the foreshore.

A key issue unresolved is whether any claims should go to the High Court or Maori Land Court or both.

This issue is hugely complex and Chris Finlayson has done very well to get this proposal out there. Maoridom does not speak with a single voice, so doubtless there will be varying degrees of support for it, but I hope most will see it as an improvement over the status quo.

I also hope most non-Maori will agree that it is a bad precedent to have the Government remove the right of any group of New Zealanders to test their legal rights in courts, and that repeal of the FSA will be a good thing.

This is stage three of a four part consultation process.

The first stage was people submitting their views to the expert panel.

The second stage was people submitting their views on the recommendations of the panel.

This third stage allows people to submit their views on the proposals in the paper.

And after this consultation, a draft law will be drawn up, and the fourth stage will allow people to submit on the proposed law.

The process of genuine consultation can be almost as important as the substance of the issue. It was partly the then Government’s high handed nature with the FSA and EFA that galvanised opposition to them. The EFA was drawn up in secret and the FSA started life by having Clark and Wilson declare they would legislate no matter what.

Compulsory Taxi Cameras

The Herald reports:

The Transport Minister is pushing for security cameras in all city taxis and the taxi federation hopes they will be in place by the middle of next year.

Steven Joyce announced this morning that he would put to Cabinet the recommendation in May.

The move follows recent attacks on taxi drivers: on Saturday, two men held a knife to an Auckland cabbie’s throat for $30 in coins, and in January driver Hiren Mohini was stabbed to death in Mt Eden for a $15.20 fare.

Many Auckland cabbies have since said that they are now scared to work at night.

NZ Taxi Federation executive director Tim Reddish said the federation had been pushing for a Government mandate for security cameras for three years.

“We’re just delighted to achieve our objective and the fact that it will save lives,” Mr Reddish said.

If the recommendations gets through Cabinet, he expects the first cameras would be installed toward the end of the year and be complete by the middle of 2011, Mr Reddish said.

He expected a 24-hour distress alarm – that would let cabbies call for help – would also be part of the new legislation.

I’m confused.

The taxi federation say they are delighted and have been advocating cameras for years, as a safety measure.

So why haven’t they just gone ahead and done it themselves?

Why in God’s name do we need a special law for this?

It is a good idea to get the support of the Minister, sure. But why not just have the Minister write a letter to all taxi companies saying he supports cameras in cars.

Mr Joyce said the industry would pay for the cameras – a cost expected to increase fares by about 30 cents.

So why would individual taxi firms not decide to do this for themselves, without coercion? Wouldn’t drivers be demanding cameras be placed in their cars if the cost averages out to only 30c a trip.

And even if a few companies don’t implement cameras, then their drivers can choose to work for another company.

It’s sad that the NZ Taxi Federation thinks it needs a law passed, to be able to put security cameras into cars. Why don’t they just get on and do it.

Brown endorses Williams?

NewstalkZB at 8 am reported Len Brown saying supportive things about Andrew William’s bid to be on the new Auckland Council. The item said:

Len Brown is showing his support for Andrew Williams intention to stand for election onto the new Council.  …

Manukau City Mayor Len Brown says he has worked well with Mr Williams in the past through the Mayoral Forum, and knows he has his community’s concerns at heart.

They also reported John Banks refused to comment – a much wiser strategy.

So far then, Len Brown has endorsed or said supportive things about both Sue Bradford and Andrew Williams being on Council.Is there anyone he won’t endorse?

I mean this is just after Williams puts up on his Facebook page a photo of Rodney Hide as Hitler (H/T: Whale).

Yes this image really is on the Mayor of North Shore City’s Facebook page – placed there by him.

Do I really need to even mention how offensive this is to actual survivors of the Holocaust. You might expect this behaviour from an anonymous troll on the Internet, but not from the Mayor of a major city.

And this is who Len Brown is supporting for Council – because he didn’t want to risk having Williams attack him, if he refused to say nice things about him.

This is one of the criticisms I hear about Brown. From all accounts he is a very nice guy, and quite personable. Someone you would find hard to dislike. Many people I know, from both National and Labour, say Len is a really nice guy.

But the criticism is whether he is tough enough to handle the job of being the inaugural Mayor of the Auckland Super City. You have to be able to sometimes call a spade a spade.

The job will involved both standing for 1.3 million Aucklanders to the national Government, but also being able to run a Council focused on regional issues and not be captured by the parochialism of the past.

And this is why Andrew Williams is unsuitable, in my opinion, for the Auckland Council. Even if you put aside his abusive and ranting style, he is also unsuitable because he seems only concerned with his local area – not Auckland as a whole. Of course you want ward Councillors to represent their communities, but you most of all want them focused on decisions that are good for Auckland as a whole.

It is almost impossible to see how anyone can think Williams would be a constructive member of the Auckland Council, and it does call into question Len Brown’s judgement, that he is effectively endorsing Andrew Williams.

Good comments

On most blogs the actual posts tend to be quite reasonable and well argued, and it is the comments that can sometimes go off the track and get hysterical.

But I’m pleased to report the opposite has happened on Red Alert. Carmel Sepuloni did a somewhat off the track post claiming:

Todd McClay says that beneficiaries are more likely to murder children

I thought this would set off a round of abuse of Todd, but in fact many of the comments were quite thoughtful, such as:

Rebecca:
Carmel I agree it was incredibly distasteful however, in many ways, while awkwardly put, Todd is right.

The bulk of the physical child abuse, neglect and maltreatment statistics comes out of the quarters of the lower socio-economic groups, most of whom are predominantly on benefits.

Lindsay Mitchell posted a useful link to some CYFS stats which “establishes that there is a statistical association between the two factors examined: benefit receipt and CYPFS notifications”.

Todd himself pops up and posts a draft of Hansard, with what he actually said:

And Lindsay again provides a useful point:

You have to understand that ‘are more likely to’ can co-exist with ‘most don’t’. For argument’s sake;

8 out of 100 beneficiaries abuse their children.
2 out of 100 non-beneficiaries abuse their children.

Therefore beneficiaries are 4 times more likely to abuse their children BUT most don’t.

However, inasmuch as child murder usually occurs at the extreme end of abuse, it is more likely to happen when the parent or other caregiver is a beneficiary.

So stop taking offence and start asking whether there is a link between welfare and child abuse.

Of course not all comments were high quality:

Olwyn said:

Furthermore, we did not have people regularly beating kids to death before we took up neo-conservative economic policies

Blame the neo-cons!

But overall I found the comments thread quite a useful wee debate. Someone also pointed out the difference between correlation and causation.

An end to The Bill

ITV in the UK have just announced that they will stop production this year of The Bill.

It has been on the air continuously since 1983 and I was at school when I first watched it!

My favourite character was the no nonsense DI Burnside.

I’ve never ever watched even one episode of East Enders or Coronation Street, but thanks to My Sky, have probably seen close to every episode of The Bill. They show both current episodes, and ones from the beginning.

No Wellywood sign

Yay. Wellington Airport has backed down on their plan to erect a huge Wellywood sign on nearby hills.

Good on them for listening to the community. They want alternate ideas. I still like the idea of a giant weta – unique to NZ, and is a way we can promote the creative industry that has built up around Weta.

Two anti-wellywood sign Facebook groups got over 15,000 and 4,000 members.

In a sign of Facebook’s power, the Airport is calling for ideas to be posted to their Facebook page.