Dissent on making pseudoephedrine prescription only

The very sensible MacDoctor disagrees with the decision. He blogs:

Unfortunately Mr. Key is being poorly advised on this matter by his science advisor, Peter Gluckman – who has no medical qualifications, BTW

The strike through is after a commenter pointed out Sir Peter actually graduated medical school, and spent two years as a doctor before going into research. He is also a former Dean of the Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences at the University of Auckland.

Once again, I link to a real scientific study on phenylephrine and pseudoephedrine so the Sir Peter can actually read something useful on the subject. There are dozens of others, but this one is freely available to be read in full. All the scientific evidence (as opposed to the anecdotal ones) shows that phenylephrine is essentially useless as a nasal decongestant. If you want relief from your cold, you are going to have to use pseudoephedrine. All that making this a prescription item will do is make the treatment of a cold more expensive for people. It will also move the monitoring of drug seekers from the pharmacy to the GP, who is even less likely to spot the serial script seeker. “Shoppers” for pseudoephedrine will just move from doctor to doctor, gathering scripts.

Stuff also reports dissent:

The Pharmaceutical Society’s chief pharmacist adviser, Euan Galloway, said the proposed replacement, phenylephrine – which Mr Key said was a “safe and effective alternative” – was not as good.

“Ask any community pharmacist and they’ll tell you they may make one sale [of a phenylephrine medicine], but never again,” Mr Galloway said.

Phenylephrine had a very high “first past metabolism effect”, which meant most of the drug was metabolised or rendered inactive before it reached the parts of the body where it was needed.

Appalling

The Herald reports:

Television New Zealand introduced Sensing Murder medium Deb Webber to the family of Aisling Symes just two days after the little girl had gone missing. …

Media at a police press confidence on Wednesday were surprised when a One News journalist Amy Kelley asked:

“This morning One News (and I believe you’re aware of this as well) did some filming with Deb Webber,” Kelley said.

“She’s a medium on the television show Sensing Murder and she gave us some information on what she believed happened to the little girl. How seriously are police likely to take that information,” said the One News reporter. …

Brotherston said Webber had said after her appearance that she had some information for the family.

TVNZ had approached a friend of Aisling’s family and subsequently Webber had met up them.

Asked what the public news organisation was doing introducing a TV medium to the family two days after they had lost a child, Brotherston said:

“You know what they are doing? They are being human. They have a family out there that are desperate to find their child.

“We are just being human by ringing a family friend and asking if they want the medium’s contact details. After the family friend said they would be interested in talking to her all we did was facilitate the exchange of contact details.”

No you are not being human. This is disgusting behaviour. If you were offering a counsellor that would be being human.

The last fucking thing the family needs is a medium being offered to them by TVNZ two days after their 2 year old has gone missing. It is ghoulish.

Even putting aside that the mediums are all fakes who prey on vulnerable families, the fact they appear on a TVNZ show is beyond tacky, as it suggests commercial motives in offering them.

And then to have a One News reporter ask about it at a Police news conference. Every aspect of this affair is appalling.

Unimpressed

The Herald reports:

The Maori Party co-leaders wrote letters of support for Taito Phillip Field, saying he was a man of integrity who had made a major contribution to his community and pleading for it to be taken into account in his sentencing.

I’m very unimpressed. I don’t mind so much pointing out his contribution to the community (as 87 other people also did) as he had done some good, outside his offending.

But to label him a man of integrity is a very bad call. He is not. He was convicted of trying to pervert the court of justice. He lied to Noel Ingram QC. He pressured others to lie to Mr Ingram, and they did. He lied to the Police and he again tried to get others to lie to the Police. He manufactured fake documents and lied about them. He is many things, but he is not a man of integrity.

The letters were on parliamentary letterhead and sent as MPs and co-leaders rather than in their capacity as ministers.

Sadly I think their “loyalty” to a “cousin” has over-ridden common sense. As I said above, I don’t have a big issue with pointing out his community service but I suggest the co-leaders re-read the Ingram report before they label him a man of integrity.

Thanks Westpac

Stuff reports:

The Inland Revenue Department is welcoming a ruling from the High Court in Auckland ordering Westpac to pay $961 million in back taxes.

That must be a record!

I’d say Bill English and Peter Dunne are pretty happy today.

Welcome Mr Ambassador

The Herald reports:

The United States Senate is expected to confirm an openly gay lawyer – David Huebner – will be its next ambassador to New Zealand.

The appointment has generated some publicity in the United States because it is the Obama administration’s first appointment of an openly gay ambassador.

Mr Huebner is currently a lawyer based in Shanghai for a United States law firm where he specialises in international arbitration and mediation. He also acts as general counsel for the Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation.

People may be unaware that both Presidents Clinton and Bush appointed gay Ambassadors. Bush appointed Michael Guest as Ambassador to Romania.

As the US has around 150 Ambassadors, I’d expect around half a dozen of them to be gay, all other things equal.

490

His law firm bio is here. He currently works in Shanghai, and before that worked as an assistant to a Japanese Diet member. His legal career seems pretty distinguished. His law firm represents 56 of the Fortune 100 companies.

Often Ambassadors are major donors, but as far as I can tell he gave only $3,000 in 2008 – $2,000 to Obama and $1,000 to the DNC.

Stimulus Plan

Grant Robertson blogs:

Barack Obama is facing all kinds of issues in the US at the moment- healthcare reform, whether to put more troops into Afghanistan, climate change, you name it. All the while, he faces huge expectations on the left and visceral anger on the right.

But one thing he can point to is a stimulus package that  has made some big investments in covers green jobs, extensive social assistance and research. The stimulus package included $21.5 billion in funding for research and development, particularly in leading edge genetic research. The money has been spread around the US, and is having a great effect in encouraging research where private sector funding has dried up.

This is the kind of long term thinking that has been missing from NZ’s response to the recession. Of course we don’t have $21 billion to do this, but our government has set on the sidelines, and worse still pulled back from research funding. If we want to improve productivity and develop a new economy, we need large scale investment. On this issue, the Obama administration is showing the way

While I am all for genetic research (then we can clone Hayley Holt), I think Grant’s drooling over Obama’s fiscal stimulus is rather regrettable. Even if one puts aside the huge fiscal deficit Obama is running (which makes you wonder about how large a deficit NZ Labour is planning), have a look at this graph from Harvard Economics Professor Greg Mankiw that someone linked to in the comments.

stimulus-vs-unemployment-september-dots

So the light blue line is what Obama said would happen without his fiscal stimulus, and the dark blue line is what he said would happen with his fiscal stimulus. And the red line is what has actually happened.

And this is Labour’s solution to rising unemployment!

Incidentally in NZ, where we had a more modest fiscal stimulus, consisting of tax cuts and advancing necessary infrastructure investment, the unemployment rate is just 6.0%. It was projected to peak at 8% (or even 9.8% on the downside scenario), but the latest Reserve Bank forecast is now for it to peak at 7.0%.

Now this doesn’t mean a massive fiscal stimulus spendup makes unemployment go even higher. I am not saying Obama caused unemployment to go higher than projected.

The lesson is that the Government impact on unemployment is limited. The private sector is what creates job, not the Government. Government created jobs are funded from private sector taxes and you need private sector jobs to pay those taxes.

Obama has saddled future generations with an out of control deficit, and debt which will soak up money which could be spent on health or education.

This is what Labour wanted for New Zealand. They have proposed mounds of extra spending that would have stuff all impact on unemployment, but leave a massive debt burden for the future.

Very cool

Chris Keall blogs at NBR:

A group of Chinese students have created a programme that can take a simple free-hand drawn sketchy, then turn it into a photo montage using images pulled from the web.

Check it out. Now that is true innovation.

Go Treasury Go

The Herald reports:

Bold tax reforms and changes to the mix of monetary and fiscal policy are needed if New Zealand is to rebalance its economy and close the gap with Australia, according to the Treasury’s head.

New Zealand needs to overhaul its tax system, bringing down income tax and potentially increasing GST or imposing a land tax, Treasury Secretary John Whitehead told a business audience in Queenstown last month.

I agree.

Dom Post on Field and Labour

The Dominion Post looks at both Field, and those who got off:

Bravo. Justice Rodney Hansen has resisted the temptation to let disgraced former MP Taito Phillip Field off with a slap on the wrist and sentenced him to six years’ imprisonment. …

As Justice Hansen said, he betrayed the trust placed in him as an MP and undermined the institutions it was his duty to uphold.

Jail time is warranted. New Zealand is one of the few countries in the world in which political corruption is not endemic. By his actions, Field threatened to erode standards that have served New Zealand well.

The court’s sentencing notes are very interesting. The appropriate penalties for the crimes were deemed to be five years for the bribery and corruption and four years for perverting the course of justice.  This would be a total of nine years.

Justice Hansen said nine years would be excessive as the two categories of offending are closely linked, even though they are distinct. It is because they are distinct the two penalties are cumulative, not concurrent. He said that seven and a half years would be the appropriate sentence for the offending.

He then deducted a further 18 months off to take account of mitigating factors, so got to the final sentence of six years.

However, if Field has got his just deserts, others have got off lightly. Those others are the senior members of the Labour Party who ran interference for him for almost 18 months and who are now ducking for cover.

They won’t even say if they agree he broke the law.

Readers might remember that former prime minister Helen Clark was slow to act when questions were first asked about Field’s conduct, perhaps because the 2005 election was in the offing, and that when she did, she established an inquiry with narrow terms of reference and without the power to compel witnesses to give evidence.

Hence Field was able to claim he had been vindicated by an inquiry that found no evidence he had misused his position as minister for personal benefit.

And no other conclusion was possible given the terms of reference as he had no portfolio responsibilities in the area. The issue always was whether he had misused his position as an MP, not a Minister. The framing of the inquiry was designed to clear him.

Deputy prime minister Michael Cullen appeared to agree. Field’s “fundamental fault was to work too hard for the many, many hundreds of people who come to his electorate office on immigration matters”, he said.

And he said this after he had read the numerous abuses of office detailed in the Ingram Report.

What he overlooked, deliberately or otherwise, was the numerous questions the inquiry raised about Field’s conduct as an MP as opposed to his conduct as a minister.

And which Labour has never condemned. He used his loyal Thais as slave labour, and Labour has not a word of criticism. How sincere are the about the need to raise the minimum wage, when they defended their colleague who was found to be paying no wages at all!

Field’s sentencing closes a sorry chapter in politics. He has shamed himself, his family and the Samoan community, which was so proud when he was first elected to Parliament.

The blame lies not with the Samoan community, however, but with Field and the Labour Party, which, for political reasons, tried to shield him from scrutiny long after his position became untenable.

And we are still awaiting a clear statement from Labour that they agree Field was corrupt, let alone an apology for their defence of him. One can only conclude they do not think his behaviour was corrupt.

The plan against P

John Key has announced a wide range of measures, as part of a plan to reduce the supply of, demand for, and harm caused by P. The main measures are:

  • Making pseudoephedrine a Class B2 controlled drug, making it prescription-only. (I have attached the report from Sir Peter Gluckman recommending this)
  • Use proceeds of crime legislation to fund additional Police and Customs activities to fight gangs and organised crime plus an expansion of drug treatment services.
  • Investing in additional $22 million in clinical services to fund treatment for P addiction to more than 3,000 additional patients over the next three years.
  • Assigning 40 additional Customs officers to special dedicated drug-taskforce duties to help break the supply chain. Key also announced in just two weeks Customs has managed to make 26 seizures of ingredients with a street value of $13 million if they had been used to produce P.
  • A new Police Methamphetamine Control Strategy which aims to use intelligence in new ways to target gangs, investigate drug syndicates which import P precursors illegally, target P ‘cooks’ and seize funds and assets gained through P-related activity.
  • Reviewing the outdated Alcoholism and Drug Addiction Act 1966, to provide a more effective legal means to get P-addicts into compulsory assessment and treatment.
  • Making chief executives of Government agencies accountable for delivering on our plans, as measured against a range of targets that will be clearly set out in the actual Action Plan to be released next week.

The status quo has obviously failed. It is good to see that the plan does not just try to target one aspect, but is a balance of measures that aim to reduce supply, reduce the demand for P, and reduce the harm caused by those addicted to it – which is far far wider than self harm.

The Gluckman report is here – Pseudoephedrine report.

A recent story on how destructive the addiction to P is, was a great story in the HoS by Carolyne Meng-Yee on Lynne Carter:

One of Auckland’s poshest hotels has turfed out a high-profile socialite, saying her erratic behaviour has scared guests and staff and claiming she has left her $600-a-night suite uninhabitable. …

The eviction of Carter, who is facing methamphetamine and fraud charges in the Auckland District Court, is the latest twist in a sad fall from grace for the businesswoman who once boasted a $6 million waterfront mansion, a Ferrari and a booming property development business.

She was set for life.

“She smokes and we don’t allow smoking, and her dog pisses everywhere,” Bourke said. “We have chucked her out many times but she keeps coming back in the middle of the night.” …

“She was smoking all the time and the dog was in the room. It was peeing everywhere.

“She would get up in the middle of the night … She was out like till 3am, running up and down the hallways calling out ‘Louis, Louis’ and we had complaints from guests saying ‘who is the woman running up and down the hallway screaming?’

“Or we would have functions on… It was horrible, it really was.”

On another occasion, Bourke said Carter sat in the Herne Bay hotel’s library, staring vacantly at the ceiling.

And if not bad enough:

Bourke said that, in her opinion, Carter had “gone from someone who was well-dressed and well-spoken… and she has turned into a country bumpkin who walks around with no shoes and dirty hair”.

Bourke said Mollies could not hire out her suite because of the stench of dog urine and stale cigarette smoke. “We have to air it a little bit longer to get rid of the smell.”

And that is just a case of self-harm, and is nothing compared to the cases of William Bell, Antonie Dixon, and others where innocent Kiwis get butchered in P fuelled rages.

Vernon Small on Greens

Vernon Small writes:

The Green Party needed a mini-scandal about its accommodation allowances like it needed to lose a senior MP with thwarted ambitions or have its kuia head for the hills before the next election.

Challenging times indeed. Despite that I think the Greens are fairly well positioned to grow their vote at the next election. They can point to successfully advocating the home insulation scheme to both Labour and National, and make a case that while they are a left wing party, they can “green” the Government, regardless of who it is.

As the party making all the noise about reviewing parliamentary perks, it has exposed itself badly with the revelation that two of its MPs were essentially – if accidentally – double-dipping on rent for the Thorndon house owned by the party’s superannuation fund.

At this stage, just how the information came to light is unclear.

The Greens are sure they spotted it when they did an annual market rent review on the property in May or June and were preparing their disclosure of expenditure before the general release of MPs’ spending by Speaker Lockwood Smith in July. That was an attempt at a public relations coup that now looks hollow.

This is easy to resolve. The Greens simply need provide the e-mail or correspondence to The Parliamentary Service advising them of the “error” they discovered.

Ms Turei does concede that if they had provided a rent review of the house in February, as Parliamentary Service requested, the mistake would probably have been avoided.

So why was it not done?

But the failure to pay back the extra $6000 when it was discovered in June – even if that required a special meeting of the superannuation fund trustees – ceded a lot of the moral high ground. (More so, because when asked about it weeks ago by The Dominion Post after a tip-off from within Parliament, the Greens said there had been only a minor adjustment – not, as it turned out, an overcharging of $500 a week – and implied it was at the Greens’ own initiative.)

This is the part that spells very bad judgement to me. If I was advising the Greens, I would have insisted that it be paid back within days, and then do a press release advising of the error. That would have been a minor minor story.

From Parliamentary Service’s perspective, general manager Geoff Thorn could not be clearer.

“The double payment was identified when the service was reviewing processes for dealing with claims for Wellington accommodation in May of this year.

This is quite contradictory to what the Greens say. Now again, there is an easy way to resolve this. The Greens merely need provide the e-mail or correspondence where they alerted The Parliamentary Service to the error.

It is an important distinction. The party that found a mistake, corrected it and paid back the difference? Or the party that was caught out and reluctantly handed over the cash three months later?

Indeed, and in fact there is a lot of murkiness now. We have:

  1. How did the error occur in the first place?
  2. Who decided the level of rent to charge for Delahnuty after she moved in with Fitzsimons?
  3. Why was a market valuation not done in February, when the Parliamentary Service asked for it?
  4. Is there any proof of the assertion by the Greens they spotted the error, rather than the Parliamentary Service tell them about it?
  5. If not, why did they assert they found the error?
  6. Why did they tell the Dominion Post it was a minor adjustment, when it was almost $500 a week?
  7. Why did they not reveal the error, at the time they were trumpeting their commitment to transparency?
  8. Why did they wait three months to pay the money back – in fact only paying it back when TVNZ started asking about it?

Now I am not suggesting foul motives for the above, but it does suggest incredibly poor and sloppy management – both political, but also administratively.

Either way, the news has turned the spotlight back on the Green MPs’ pension scheme which buys houses and flats for its MPs and charges Parliamentary Service for their rent.

It is within the rules, and Mr Donald made sure of that when he set it up in 1998. (Ever aware of perceptions, he went around the press gallery to tell reporters what he had done, so there could be no accusations of underhand dealings.)

Rod was a very smart man.

But the scheme was always a ticking time bomb of bad perceptions, especially when, in the wake of the Bill English accommodation furore, the public is attuned to MPs using the perks of office to build up their own nest eggs.

It is a nest egg for the Greens that has already been depleted from four houses to two, as retiring MPs have withdrawn their entitlement.

It will take another big hit when MP Sue Bradford leaves later this month and an even bigger one when former party co- leader Jeanette Fitzsimons quits before the 2011 election.

Not necessarily. The new MPs may move into the houses used by the retiring MPs.

Ali Ikram’s satirical piece on Maori TV

The Herald reports:

Maori TV has accused its rival TV3 of racism after it broadcast an item lampooning what its coverage of the Rugby World Cup would look like.

The TV3 Nightline parody showed an All Black diving for the winning try in the final, with the broadcast interrupted by a public service announcement, saying: “Pakeha. It’s time to talk. There’s a few things we need to sort out and you won’t get to see the rest of the game until we have.”

The reporter for Tuesday night’s item was Ali Ikram, who is well-known for his satirical streak.

And this is key. Ali takes the piss out of everything and everyone. I’m reasonably supportive of the Maori TV bid, but really they need to lighten up.

But Maori TV spokeswoman Sonya Haggie said it was “basically racist” and it would be laying a complaint with the Broadcasting Standards Authority. The item also showed a match referee calling on the video referee, which turned out to be the Waitangi Tribunal, with Ikram warning “this could take a while”. There was also a “compulsory haka” for which the French did the can-can.

You can watch the clip for yourself here. I don’t think anyone is really going to think that the Waitangi Tribunal will be the video referee!

Ikram ridiculed Maori TV presenter Julian Wilcox, saying he presented virtually every show on the channel. …

TV3 received a number of complaints, including from its own staff, including Campbell Live reporter Mihingarangi Forbes who told the Herald it was disappointing and embarrassing.

“Given that it was supposed to be satire I didn’t find anything funny about it at all,” she said. “I think Ali [Ikram] would have hoped it was funny and clever but unfortunately for him and everyone else it was not.”

Ms Forbes said the jibes against Wilcox were hurtful.

“We have the utmost respect for Julian and it was unfair to pick him out like that.”

If the item was having a go at Wilcox, that would be regrettable. Wilcox is highly respected. But I didn’t see the clip as that. I actually thought it was paying Wilcox a subtle compliment by mentioning the large number of shows he presents.

Humour is always a challenge. Almost all humour can offend someone. My preferred Southpark type humour offends almost everyone :-). There is a difference between humour for humour’s sake, and using humour to attack or ridicule someone. I didn’t see anything in Ali’s item that suggested it was anything beyond his normal humour for humour’s sake.

My advice to Maori TV. Do your own satirical response! Fight humour with humour.

Kerr on Capital Gains Tax

Roger Kerr writes:

A gains tax on housing would not reduce inflation. Inflation is an ongoing increase in the general level of prices, not a one-off change in some prices.

The introduction of the Goods and Services tax resulted in a one-off increase in the consumer price index – it did not lead to ongoing inflation.

Similarly, a capital gains tax might reduce property prices initially but it would not affect longer-term inflation.

True, and any increase in GST would be a one off bump.

Moreover, if such a tax on housing were applied only to realised gains as is likely, house prices could even rise. This is because of the lock-in effect, with owners holding on to homes to defer the tax on gains. Anything that reduces supply is likely to lead to an increase, not a decrease, in price.

One could do it on unrealised gains, but that would be pretty draconian.

Evidence confirms what theory suggests: the inflation performance of countries with a capital gains tax doesn’t differ systematically from countries that don’t.

Australia, the US and Britain, which tax capital gains, have all had large and volatile house price movements this decade.

I always like a look at empirical evidence.

A second mistaken assumption is that investment in rental housing enjoys tax privileges.

As the deputy commissioner of Inland Revenue, Robin Oliver, told a select committee in 2007: “Rules about expenses for deducting costs such as interest, upkeep and maintenance, as well as paying tax on income, are the same for investments in shares or anything else. In fact under the housing case … there are tighter rules regarding what is a capital gain.”

People are misled into thinking that rental housing is tax-preferred since highly geared rental property may record tax losses. This is because the full economic income (including the change in the market value of the assets) earned on rental property is not taxed.

However, this is a quite general feature of the taxation of real assets, including plant and equipment and farms.

A real issue though is whether it is sensible to allow property owners to claim 3% depreciation on their property annually, when the empirical evidence is that almost no residential property depreciates in value – in fact it appreciates.

Herald on state funding

The NZ Herald editorial:

Until the Labour Government came to grief with its Electoral Finance Act, now repealed, many voters might not have realised how strictly elections were previously controlled in the interests of financial equality. …

The previous code, now back in force, limits the amount parties and candidates can spend on campaigns and particularly restricts parties’ access to radio and television. They are given a set amount of “free” time for opening and closing their campaigns and an allocation of public money for broadcast commercials. Parties are not permitted to use money they have raised themselves to buy more air time even if the spending would be within overall campaign limits.

Which is an antiquated restriction inherited from the days when the broadcast medium was all powerful. It is very very unfair that a party can not spend more money on broadcast ads than their allocation by the Electoral Commission.

National is part-way through a promised review of the law and has just published some options for public comment. It would retain public funding for party advertising either under present rules or with no restriction on the type of media in which the money can be spent and no limit on the broadcast time a party can buy from its own funds, provided it is within overall campaign limits.

And the latter option is preferable to the former.

A third option would allow parties to spend their public allocation for any election purpose, not necessarily campaign advertising. From there it would be a short step to full public funding of election campaigns. Once the taxpayers’ contribution ceased to be for a defined purpose, parties would soon press for public funds for all purposes.

I agree. I oppose that option.

If the review was being conducted independently of political parties we might be presented with another option: the end of this state-funding-by-stealth. There is no particular reason that taxpayers should have had to pay for the promotion of parties on television. It is nonsensical that even fringe campaigns can get on air by making an application on time. Let all contenders prove their worth by raising voluntary finance. And let them spend it where they think best.

I proposed a compromise. Have the funding available only to non-parliamentary parties, in recognition of the fact that parliamentary parties have a huge advantage. They get publicity over the whole three year cycle, and parliamentary resources such as MPs, staff and funding.

The previous Government’s vexed issue of “third party” campaigns – publicity for or against a party or on an issue that works to a party’s advantage or disadvantage – has not been resolved by the review so far. National, too, wants to regulate “parallel campaigns” as it calls them, but wants to make their spending rules simpler than those Labour laid down and “weighted in favour of freedom of speech”.

That is not quite correct. National has proposed two mutually exclusive options. One is for regulation and one is for the status quo of basically transparency only. I do not believe a case has been made that you need to regulate beyond transparency, and hope Cabinet will finally conclude to recommend no change.

And parallel campaigns should be allowed to broadcast during election periods.

I agree.

The red tape of electoral finance was hopelessly tangled even before Helen Clark got her hands on it. National is at least proceeding cautiously; the proposals offered for discussion until the end of the month are a response to comments on a paper issued in May. Public views will be invited again next year when legislation appears. Constitutional steps should be taken this way. It is for all of us now to have our say.

Indeed the existing law was far from perfect. As the Herald says, make sure you submit and have your say.

State house fraud

The Herald reports:

A man is facing allegations he lived off the taxpayer in state housing while he was a landlord owning two properties.

Allan Wilkins, a beneficiary, allegedly lived in two state houses – first in the city centre then in Orakei – over a period of three years. …

The Crown says during the three years that Wilkins was living in the two Housing NZ Corporation places and receiving big rent subsidies, he also owned 149 Browns Rd at Wiri and 2 Sheehan Ave in Papakura.

The Wiri property is valued at $260,000 and the Papakura house is estimated at $200,000.

Dale Dufty, prosecuting, said more charges would be laid against Wilkins over his tenancies which had defrauded the state of more than $68,000.

Now this is a rare case, but it does highlight one of the problems of providing housing assistance through cheap housing, rather than through income support. It provides an incentive for people to qualify for a state house by not disclosing other property.

I note Wilkins is on a benefit. I presume he was receiving rental income from his other properties, so WINZ may want to be checking that out also.

iPredict Accuracy

First have a look at this page detailing the accuracy of iPredict over the last year.

Eric Crampton explains some of it here.

And my weekly picks are out:

Bye Bye Wanganui

The market thinks Wanganui is a goner, with CITY.WANGANUI languishing at just under 10c. CITY.WHANGANUI is at 60c, having dropped from 80c earlier in the week. I thought it was over-priced at 80c and sold at 75c as a dual name is a real option and CITY.BOTH is trading at 20c.

Sell of the Week

ZIM.MUGABE pays out if Mugabe goes by the end of the year. It started the year at 75c and is now at 13c. There is nothing to suggest he could lose power by year end so a sell now gets a 15% return over three months.

A tale of two parties

There are two stocks – MP.TIZARD and MP.POWELL that will pay $1 if a List MP leaves Parliament before the next election for the Labour and National parties, as that will see Judith Tizard and Conway Powell respectively enter Parliament.

Now their caucuses are of similar size – 43 MP and 58 MPs, so one would expect MP.TIZARD to be no less than three quarters the price of MP.POWELL. However the Tizard stock is at 20c and Powell at 57c. So what explains the difference? My pick is that the Labour leadership will move heaven and earth not to lose a List MP for the next two years, as a return of Tizard would damage their brand. That certainly seems to be the assumption the market is making.

Highest Trading Stocks

The 91.OCT09 petrol series had trades of over $13,000. CONFSEP09.VHIGH traded close to $6,000 and CITY.WHANGANUI has $3,000 of trades.

UMR on perceptions of NZ’s media

UMR polled 750 New Zealanders from 24 to 27 September on what they think of the NZ media. Very interesting results:

  • Only 35% said the NZ media are accurate in reporting the news, with 25% saying inaccurate, 37% neutral and 3% don’t know.
  • Over 60s have the lowest score for accuracy – 23% compared to 43% for under 30s.
  • 30% say the NZ media are balanced and 30% say they are one-sided.
  • 27% say they are willing to admit mistakes, and 46% say they are not willing.

It is a pity UMR did not report party identification, as I would be very interested in if there was any significant differences between National and Labour voters.

Blog Bits

  1. Cactus Kate thinks appointing Michael Stiassny as the receiver for Crafer Farms is having the punishment fit the crime 🙂
  2. Phil Twyford blogs on war, peace and pacifism.
  3. Richard Long writes on how the history of NZ and Samoa has not always been so cosy.
  4. Colin James covers the recent Blue-Greens conference noting in 2002 Three National MPs were members, and now there are 18.
  5. Bryce Edwards blogs on the growing professionalism of party campaigning
  6. No Right Turn has the good news that all select committees can now accept submissions electronically. Excellent.
  7. Trevor Mallard blogs his denial of an alleged rumour, as a way to ensure the rumour gets plenty of notice. Propaganda 101.
  8. Tim Selwyn at Tumeke covers the sentence of Taito Phillip Field, noting “With Mike Williams as President of the party, with Helen as PM, with Cullen as the deputy, and with Margaret Wilson as the Speaker the government had become so sleazed up that an MP as corrupt as Field was tolerated for as long as they possibly could. It’s not a pleasant passage in the annals of the NZ Labour Party.”
  9. Cactus Kate (again) has a thoughtful piece on har far is too far when attacking someone.
  10. Whale Oil solves two problems at once by suggesting the Palmerston North be turned into a quarantine station for Gingas 🙂
  11. Liberty Scott muses on whether the TPK funding of the Maori TV bid breaches our WTO obligations.
  12. MacDoctor has the worrying news that the US Federal Trade Commission is now trying to regulate bloggers.
  13. Roarprawn defends the Maori TV bid for the RWC coverage and says people should get over it.

More on Chris Carter

Before I get into this substance of this, I want to say a couple of things. The first is that I have known Chris Carter for around 15 years, think he has a great sense of humour and has been an effective MP. In fact it isn’t a great secret that I was hoping he would beat Brian Neeson when they both stood for Waipareira in 1996 as I found Neeson just far too conservative for me (and note Neeson in 2002 broke his written pledge to not stand against a National candidate by standing as an Independent in 2002 when he failed to be reselected).

Also it drives me crazy that some people are unable to comment on any issue about a gay MP, without making some dig about his sexual orientation. People really need to get over it. And Chris has had a longer relationship with his partner than most married couples, let alone divorced ones.

Now I blogged on Sunday:

I’ve been musing about whether to post on this topic, because I think Chris Carter was acting with good motives in flying to Samoa, but nevertheless I do question the appropriateness of it.

I don’t think it is the job of the Opposition Foreign Affairs Spokesperson to fly into foreign disasters, any more than it is the job of the Opposition Police Spokesperson to fly into fatal crime scenes, or the Opposition Health Spokesperson to fly into quarantine areas.

Three times I stressed I was not questioning Chris’s motives in going to Samoa, just his judgement on appropriateness. And I still stand by that. I think the motives were honourable.

I got flak from Russell Brown at Public Address and The Standard for my post. The Standard said (and Russell agreed):

In the immediate aftermath of the disaster, Winne Laban headed to Samoa to assist her family there. Carter went as her support person, the two are close I understand. He did not go there to be Labour Foreign Affairs spokesperson.

Now I don’t know anyone at all who thinks or has said Winnie going there was inappropriate. And going as a support person for Winnie would be entirely uncontroversial. One could quibble whether it is a good use of parliamentary funding to have an MP go as a support person, rather than say a family member, but I don’t think that is an issue.

This has not been disaster tourism by Carter

I have never used the term disaster tourism, and would not. In fact the blogger I recall using the term is No Right Term who used the label against John Key.

But sadly for The Standard and Russell, Chris Carter himself shoots down their defence f him that he was there solely as Winnie’s support person. Chris blogged:

What a great posting from Winnie. I am so glad she agreed to go with me to Samoa. She was not only a wonderful travelling companion, but her understanding of the appropriate cultural approach and her Samoan language skills meant we could engage with those affected by this terrible natural disaster in the most sensitive ways.

This makes it very clear Chris was going regardless of Winnie going. Later on he says Winnie asked him to go, but that be referring to the specific flight they caught.

It was clear to us that Winnie as Labour’s spokesperson for Pacific Island Affairs, and me as our Foreign Affairs Spokesperson, needed to be there, on the ground, supporting the victims and listening to their plight.

And here Chris makes very clear he was there not just as Winnie’s support person, but as the Foreign Affairs Spokesperson.

And with respect I disagree that rushing into a foreign disaster should be the job of the opposition foreign affairs spokesperson, just as I don’t expect the opposition health spokesperson to rush to medical emergencies.

It was important for Samoans and holidaying Kiwis to know that the Labour Party cared about the disaster and was quick off the mark to demonstrate its concern.

And here Chris says it was about showing the Labour Party cared. Now by his own words that raises the issue of appropriateness. Should the Greens have flown over also to show they cared? I think what was needed is to show New Zealand cared, regardless of political affiliation. And that is the job of the Government – whether that be National or Labour at the time.

It is an important role of the Opposition in a Parliamentary democracy to challenge, push and where appropriate support the actions of the government of the day. It is a legitimate role for Opposition MPs to provide a different voice and often alternatives to government policy or action, whether it be in domestic affairs such as Education, Health, Housing or Welfare, or dealing with issues concerning Employers, Workers, Unions, in International Relations/Foreign Affairs, and even in disaster relief.

That’s our job!

It was immediately obvious to us that what Samoa urgently needed was doctors, nurses, immediate food, fresh water supplies and medical equipment.

Now I absolutely agree Opposition MPs should and must hold the Government to account. But I do not accept that means it is appropriate for the foreign affairs spokesperson to fly into a foreign disaster, any more than you expect the opposition Police spokesperson to fly to the scene of an armed siege so they can comment on whether or not they think the Government or Police handled the siege well.

An Opposition spokesperson can critique the Government’s response to a foreign disaster by reports from the dozens of media at the scene, by talking to non-media on the ground, by asking MFAT (through the Minister) for a briefing etc etc. I’ve never before known an opposition spokesperson to assert they need to fly to the scene. And as I said in my original blog, Helen Clark would I am sure have ferociously denounced a National MP doing the same.

So if Chr ris had gone purely to support Winnie, I would have no criticism. But The Standard clearly invented that as a defence, to have Chris himself contradict it. And I think it is legitimate to have a debate on whether that is the correct role of an opposition spokesperson. Again, I have never criticised the good motives in going, but it is fair to question judgement.

Now Chris also made the TV3 news last night about the fact the published figures showing his spending on international travel over six months to be $83,000 was wrong, and in fact it was $131,000.

Now many will condemn him on that lavel of spending, but I do think people should not rush to judgement until all the facts are known.

I’ve had friends travel with Ministers in the past, and they get back absolutely knackered. One mate(ess) got back from a trip to UK and Netherlands for a week, and apologised for no souvenirs. She had worked from 7 am to 10 pm from when they land to when they took off apart from a two hour break one afternoon which she spent sleeping.

Many Ministers (and staff) do have punishing schedules on their trips. I suggest that the fairest thing would be for the itineraries for the travel in question to be released, so people can judge the value for the $131,000. Duncan Garner blogs that he has asked the Cabinet Office for the travel reports but for some reason this will take at least another week.

Wonderful satire

Clint Heine blogs:

WELLINGTON: Slavery should be rebranded as an ‘opt-out labour arrangement’, the New Zealand University Students Association (NZUSA) said today.

“Let’s face it, slavery has a bad name,” a NZUSA representative said. “For thousands of years slavery has been associated with force, compulsion and the negation of civil rights,” he said, “however we think slavery needs a new image”.

After exhaustive research conducted over two and half days NZUSA has suggested that slavery should be thought of as an ‘opt-out labour arrangement’.

“After all, even though slaves were forced into labour against their will, they could always leave—or opt-out—if they wanted to. They could run away or buy their freedom,” NZUSA said. “If slaves were really unhappy about servitude all they needed to do was make a bit of an effort. If they didn’t make the effort we can only assume they were happy.”

“The ability of any slave to opt-out if he or she chooses means that slavery doesn’t breach civil rights,” NZUSA said.

Hilarious. Especially the part about how a slave can opt out of slavery by running away.

NZUSA said their work on slavery was the first in a series. Future reports include: ‘Compulsory military service – opt-out warriors’ and ‘Prisoners – opt-out guests of Her Majesty’.

The reference to compulsory military service is very apt. For proponents argued this was not compulsory due to conscientious objection – the exact same argument used by compulsory student associations.

An easy one this week

This week’s Dom Post political quiz was pretty easy – no guesses needed for another 10/10 🙂

I used to write questions and MC quiz nights quite a bit. My policy for each round of 10 questions was to have five questions pretty simple on the basis you want every team to get at least 50% as people go to have fun, not to feel stupid.

Two questions would be a bit more challenging, a further two quite difficult and one would be a trick question or very hard.

For example one of my favourite questions would be what was Julius Caesar’s first name. It in in fact neither Julius or Caesar but Gaius, or if you were a very anal classics scholar, Caius.

Electorate Office ownerships

Whale Oil blogs on all the electorate offices owned by a Labour Party company, and rented to MPs, with Parliamentary Service paying the rent, and has a number of good questions.

This is a situation worth exploring, but it is more complex that it may appear, and isn’t quite the same as the issue of Wellington accommodation.

An MPs Wellington accommodation expenses are paid for out of a general parliamentary fund. If they do not spend the maximum $24,000 then they can’t spent the underspend in other areas.

An out of parliament office is a charge against the “individual members’ support budget”. This is $64,260 for electorate MPs and $40,932 for list MPs. That budget also has to cover all the communication expenses for an MP with their electorate such as postage, newsletters, advertisements etc. So the more that is spent on rent, the less they have to spend on communicating with constituents. This does provide some incentive for the rent to be reasonable.

There are incidentally some issues with this arrangement, as the cost of renting an office is much much higher in central city seats, than suburban and provincial areas.  This can disadvantage certain urban MPs. But that is a debate for another day.

Now it is not just political parties than sometimes own the building rented to the MP. Sometimes the MP will own the building themselves. This can lead to an assumption that the MP has done so, as an income generating activity.

However there are other reasons an MP will want to own their electorate office. The main reason I know of, is that it means they have a permanent office – no worries about having to shift location every so often. Also it means they can make any changes to the building they want to make it functional, which can be difficult for buildings you do not own.

Now I am pretty sure that Parliamentary Service do require a market valuation for an electorate office, in approving any rent. And especially so if a party or MP has an interest in the office.

However this does still leave open the possibility of perception that it is an easy money making activity for an MP – buy a building and rent it to yourself. Maybe there is a return on capital greater than you would get by having it in a term deposit.

My solution would not be to ban ownership of electorate offices by MPs (I am not quite so sure about the party owning it) as ownership often allows an MP to provide a bigger and more effective office to service constituents than would otherwise be the case.

But what I would do is have a rule where any rental paid by The Parliamentary Service can only be say 75% of an independent market valuation. This would mean that the MP or party would not be perceived as making money on the property. Maybe even set it at 66% – basically i would aim for a lvel where any income would be slightly less than the return on capital you could get in a risk free investment (ie money in a bank). This would protect the MP from being seen to benefit from it, and in my experience the MPs who have purchased an electorate office have done so for practical, not commercial reasons – especially as any rent paid comes out of their budget.

Possibly this notion of setting the maximum rent at say 66% or 75% of the market rate, could also be applied to MPs Wellington accommodation. If your super fund owns your house, then you are not eligible for $24,000 a year but instead $16,000 or $18,000.

Does Labour think Field broke the law?

A friend pointed something out to me. He told me that never ever had Labour said they agreed that Field was corrupt and broke the law. I didn’t think he could possibly be right, but I went back to check their statements, and this is their exact words. On being found guilty:

Labour acknowledges the jury’s decision today on charges brought against Taito Phillip Field after a long and difficult trial, Labour Chief Whip Darren Hughes said.

“Mr Field was expelled from the Labour Party in 2007. Labour has acted in good faith throughout this process.

“The jury has decided that Mr Field acted illegally.

“The judge is yet to sentence Mr Field. Labour will make no further comment.”

They “acknowledge” the decision. They do not accept the decision. They do not welcome the decision. They do not say if they agree what Field did was corrupt. They do not say if they think it was wrong he obstructed the course of justice. They “acknowledge” the decision.

And yesterday:

Deputy Labour Leader Annette King made the following statement on the sentencing today of Taito Phillip Field.

“This sentence demonstrates that all New Zealanders are equal under the law.

“Taito Phillip Field has been judged by his peers. He must now serve the sentence handed down in the Auckland High Court.”

Labour will not be making any other comment on this matter.

Again not a word on whether or not they agree that Field was corrupt. They merely state he has been judged by his peers. Their language is the classic language of people who disagree with something.

So that is my first question to Phil Goff. Does the Labour Party agree that their former colleague acted corruptly? Is this why they won’t express remorse for defending Field – is it because they think he did not break the law?

The Dom Post reports on how Labour is refusing comment:

Labour has pulled down the shutters over the fall from grace of former MP Taito Phillip Field, after standing by him for more than a year during claims of bribery and corruption. …

Labour stood by Field for more than a year and continued to defend him after former prime minister Helen Clark was forced to order an independent inquiry by Auckland QC Noel Ingram.

Dr Ingram’s report cleared Field of a conflict of interest but the Labour government was heavily criticised after Dr Ingram revealed he had been given no power to compel evidence. …

Dr Ingram said yesterday that it was “clearly the case” that his inquiry had been frustrated by the refusal of witnesses to co-operate. He agreed that the outcome would have been different if that had not been the case.

Now bearing in mind that report from the Dom Post, prepare to damage yourself laughing at this post on The Standard from Eddie:

Taito Philip Field has been sentenced to six years jail for bribery and corruption.

Field is a prime example of the ability of power to corrupt. He let down all those who put their trust in him – his community, his former party, and the voters.

We are fortunate that in New Zealand corruption by politicians is not tolerated. This sentence will be a healthy reminder of that for any others who are tempted to exploit the trust placed in them by the public for their personal gain.

This is such an audacious attempt to rewrite history that it is obvious why Eddie refuses to blog under his real name. He would be a laughing stock if people knew who he was.  I mean even after the multiple abuses were detailed in the Ingram Report, Helen Clark said Field could return as a Minister one day, and Michael Cullen said:

“the fundamental fault Mr Field committed was to work too hard on behalf of the many, many hundreds of people who come to his electorate office on immigration matters.” …

“He works harder on those matters than I suspect the entire National Party caucus does on constituency cases. If that is what he is guilty of, then I am sure he is happy to plead guilty to working hard on behalf of his constituents.“

Again this was not a statement made in the early days, when the allegations were just that. This was after the report by Noel Ingram QC laid out bare and detailed the multiple abuses by Field. And anonymous Eddie at The Standard claims there is no tolerance. Not only was there tolerance, there was an active defence.

For those who want a reminder of the timelline, I have it here. Also back in July 2006 I blogged a summary of all the abuses that Ingram detailed in his report. And again all these abuses were known about by Labour when they decided to defend him in Parliament, led by the then Deputy Prime Miinister.

I can’t quite decide if Eddie is secretly ashamed of how Labour behaved, but won’t admit it, or if he actually honestly believes Labour was right to defend Field, and that this did not constitute tolerating corruption.