A referendum on referendums!

The Press reports:

Smacking referendum campaigner Larry Baldock wants a referendum, to run in conjunction with elections in 2011, on whether the results of referendums seeking repeal or amendment of any law should be binding.

The Kiwi Party leader and a leading organiser of the smacking referendum said the refusal of Prime Minister John Key to act on the result of that referendum raised questions about the abuse of executive power.

While I wish to see the law amended, and believe most of the public do also, the referendum was not a vote on repealing the anti-smacking law.

I, for one, would not vote in favour of repeal and returning to the old law.

I certainly would vote for amending the law, as outlined in the Borrows amendments in the Boscawen bill.

But the referendum did not specify that the law be repealed or amended. For Baldock’s proposal to work, the referendum would have to explicitly (instead of implicitly) state what law is to be repealed.

If we did have binding referenda, I’d be tempted to start one to get rid of the archaic criminal offence of blasphemous libel. Blasphemy should not be a crime – it should purely be an issue between a person and their church.

Somes Island

Despite living in Wellington for 40 years, I had never been to Matiu/Soames Island before this weekend. It has around 15,000 visitors a year.

I went there on Saturday to help with a treasure hunt for 20 five and six year olds for my niece’s birthday. It was a beautifully sunny day and I spent some of it wondering why I had never come out here before. It is definitely being added to my list of places to take out of town or country visitors.

si1

The island from the East by West Ferry as it approaches.

si2

The kids had to find seven treasures on the island (think 20 necklaces, 20 rings, 20 bracelets etc from $2 shop) at different places on the island, and once they had them all they could go to the finish for a picnic lunch. We split them into five groups of four and two of us adults went with each group.

You can see what a great place it would be for a lunch with a view.

si9

The sea was wonderfully blue, with Wellington in the background.

si3

Next to the lighthouse is an old tram track.

si4

The Southern Lookout, with a view of the harbour entrance.

si5

At the top of the island are the old WWII gun emplacements. The view from here is remarkable.

It is of course just common sense, but Somes Island gives you the best harbour views of all of Wellington – even better than Roseneath. You can see the harbour entrance, Wellington, Petone, Days Bay – the lot – as you are in the middle of it.

s16

The kids at the picnic at the end.

s17

The ferry returning for the pick up. I felt a bit sorry for the other passengers on board who suddenly had 20 noisy kids to cope with.

si8

And who knew it, they can actually line up in single file!

As I said it was a fun day. The concept of a treasure hunt for the kids was brilliant, and they had a great day. I also enjoyed getting to enjoy some magnificent views on a sunny day. Definitely aim to go back there with some friends for a picnic lunch over summer.

Two amusing things from the DOC briefing in the hut after you disembark. They close everyone in the hut, and you have to search your bags in case any mice (or rats) may have smuggled aboard. The signs on the wall proclaimed that if a mouse is found the doors must be kept closed until it has been killed. I had a wry smile at the thought of trying to kill a mouse in front of 20 five year olds. I suspect they may have formed a human defence barrier!

The other thing that amused me (doesn’t take much) was the DOC ranger who told the kids not to pet the lambs. She went on to say how one lamp is super cute and may even come close to you. However she told the five year olds than if you pat her, then her mother will probably abandon her, and then she will die, and then I (the ranger) will have to dig a hole and bury her. That seemed to do the trick and the lambs were left alone!

Approachable MPs

I noticed this letter in the ODT:

In an age of perceived isolation from our elected representatives in Wellington I was surprised as a 13 year old to be able to secure the Co-Leader of the Greens, Metiria Turei, onto my community radio show.

When I emailed her I was expecting some automated reply saying that she was too busy, but no I got a very helpful email from her PA wanting to call me and secure this interview, she was actually keen.

I can also testify to the responsiveness of Metiria Turei, and other MPs.

Last week I hosted a visitor from the United Kingdom, who is studying different legislatures for her politics degree. She has also worked for Conservative Central Office. She was especially interested in MMP and the Maori Seats

I e-mailed meeting requests to five MPs. A National Minister, a National Maori List MP, a Maori Party electorate Maori MP, Metiria Turei and one other Maori MP.

Within a few hours four of the five MPs (the two Nats, the Maori Party and the Green Party MPs), or their staff, had responded positively to arrange a time to meet, or if not in Wellington to offer a phone interview.

I think it is a good reflection on our Parliament and MPs, that they are so approachable. Many respond to their own e-mails. A growing number twitter, and Labour especially is blogging big time.

Sounds great not controversial to me

The Dom Post reports:

Prospective teachers could skip specialist university training and be fast-tracked into the classroom under a plan to cope with an ageing workforce.

Under the scheme, anyone who already has a master’s degree could bypass teacher’s college and learn on the job.

The suggestion follows a high-level meeting between Education Minister Anne Tolley and controversial United States schools leader Michelle Rhee.

Controversial is often applied by the media as a label for someone with views that journalists disagree with. It is a way of saying “Do not listen to this person”.

So before we look at what Rhee said, who is she. Is she some sort of academic whose has controversial theories never actually trialled?

Michelle Rhee is a 39 year old Korean-American who is the Chancellor of the DC Public Schools system. She is also the founder of The New Teacher Project that has recruited 10,000 teachers in the last ten years.

As Chancellor she is responsible for 168 schools, with around 58,000 students. 84% of her students are black.

So this “controversial” woman is in charge of the public schools of one of the poorest areas in America, and in an overwhelmingly Democratic area.

So what does she recommend:

The Washington DC schools chancellor has caused debate with proposals to give star teachers huge pay rises, fire ineffective ones and introduce a voucher system that gives pupils from low-income families thousands of dollars to attend private schools.

That sounds pretty good to me I have to say. The article actually has it wrong thought. She did not introduce the voucher system A voucher system for 1,900 low income families has been operating since 2004 (before she was appointed). She just does not oppose it.

Does she see it as undermining public education?

The five-year pilot program is up for renewal next year, but Ms. Rhee doesn’t see school choice as a threat to her mission in the public schools. She shakes her head. “I would never, as long as I am in this role, do anything to limit another parent’s ability to make a choice for their child. Ever.” Instead, she sees the competition presented by school choice and charter schools as part of the process of raising standards in the public school system at large. “We have an excellent choice dynamic for parents here… I’m a huge proponent of choice…” People have tried to get her to commit to a ratio of public schools to charter schools. Ms. Rhee won’t play that game. “I don’t enter this with defensiveness, about protecting [D.C. public schools’] share of the market. I believe we should proliferate what’s working and close down what’s not. Period

She doesn’t say that vouchers are the remedy for repairing public schools, she just says that choice is good and the answer to failing public schools is to close down the bad ones, and pay great teachers heaps more money.

I’ll be delighted if Anne Tolley moves in this direction. I’ll also be very surprised.

Plea bargains worth considering

The Dom Post reports:

Mr Hart wants the introduction of a US system of plea bargaining between prosecution and defence before approval by a judge. “It deals with the root problem we’ve got: there are too many cases going to trial. A lot of them could be resolved.”

I’m sure one of many defence lawyer readers will comment in more detail on this. I understand there already is some sort of informal plea bargain system? How would the proposal by Barry Hart be different? As a matter of principle I ave no problem with plea bargains that reduce court time.

He believes police should be removed from laying charges and instead a Crown prosecution agency should be appointed.

Well Crown Law get involved in the major cases. Not sure how cost effective it would be to have every potential charge referred to a Crown agency.

Both lawyers also said the district court procedure in which judges gave a “sentencing indication” for minor offences should be adopted in the High Court.

Often defendants just wanted to know what sentence they were likely to get. If that could be sorted out early on, they could accept it and plead guilty earlier, Mr Hart said.

Seems sensible.

Defending Provocation

Associate Professor Julia Tolmie calls for the defence of provocation to be reformed, not abolished. She first provides a good summary of problems with the current law and concludes:

There is something wrong with us, as a society, trying to discourage domestic and homophobic violence on the one hand, while using a criminal defence to excuse people who embark on its most horrible forms.

Her preferred response:

The problem here is that emotional and sexual rejection, as well as sexual advances, even indecent assaults, are not extreme circumstances. They are common human experiences and, although emotionally painful, ordinary people do not respond to them with murder.

So does this mean that we should we get rid of the provocation defence? I would argue, to the contrary, that we should first simplify it so it is easier to apply and automatically exclude it from being left to the jury in these kinds of cases. Only if such reform proves impossible should we get rid of it.

This could help, but I suspect defendants will simply pick an excuse justification of provocation that is not excluded, and claim this happened to them. As the victim is dead, it will come down again to trusting the liver killer over the dead victim.

The defence of provocation reduces a murder conviction to manslaughter. There are cases where a person has killed in response to circumstances that are so horrible that most people would not want to label the person a “murderer” and would not want them to serve life imprisonment (still the presumptive sentence for murder).

It is worth noting a Judge can give a lesser sentence than life now, and my preference is that where there really was legitimate provocation, the Judge uses discretion at sentencing. I’m not so sure a label is that important.

For example, in Australia a woman survived 20 years of what can only be described as torture at the hands of her husband, to finally learn he had regularly raped their daughters since they were 6 years old. She snapped in response and was allowed to argue the defence of provocation.

Interestingly it is not revealed if she was successful, but I think most would agree a preferable response would be to get him arrested.

Would we want Sophie Elliott’s mother, if she had attacked Clayton Weatherston when she opened her daughter’s bedroom door to find him stabbing her lifeless body, to be labelled a murderer and receive life imprisonment?

In this circumstance she would almost beyond doubt be able to argue self defence as he was still armed.

Silly justifications for tree law

The Herald reports:

Homeowners whose trees are illegally chopped down by neighbours will no longer be able to count on council help once a proposed law change likely to become final this week is passed.

What is not made clear is that only if the tree was protected, would the Council get involved anyway. And personalyl it is inane to try and justify a law that prevents a homeowner from trimming or felling their own trees, on the grounds that by banning homeowners from being able to fell their own trees, you also ban neighbours from felling your trees.

If there really is a problem with legions of neighbours sneaking onto properties in the middle of the night and chopping down trees, then deal with that problem directly – don’t pretend that the current law which imposes significant costs on homeowners with “protected” trees is the answer.

During a recent subdivision case, the Environment Court had accepted evidence that “quite a number” of people illegally chopped trees on someone else’s land to improve their views and/or sunlight, she said.

But few prosecutions were made because it was often difficult to prove who had done it “even when it was clear who would havebenefited”.

And in fact we find out that the number of times this law has actually helped a homeowner against tree cutting neighbours is so low you can probably count on one hand.

While the number of homeowners who have had to spend both money and time on getting permission to trim or chop their own trees is well into the thousands as I understand it – maybe tens of thousands.

Mt Roskill public meeting on anti-smacking law

ACT MP John Boscawen is holding a public meeting in Mt Roskill on Monday to put pressure on MPs to back his bill (based on the Borrows amendments) amending the anti-smacking law. This is the first in what will be a series of public meetings.

John has pointed out than in 56 of the 70 seats (including Mt Roskill), more people voted No in the referenendum than voted for the electorate MP.

The Mt Roskill meeting will be addressed by Emeritus Professor of Law Jim Evans. It starts at 7.30 pm, Mon 7 September at Hay Park School, 670 Richardson Road, Mt Roskill.

Families Commission on Maori Seats

Just watching a recording of Q&A and Paul Holmes has revealed that the Families Commission put in a submission on the Auckland Council legislation advocating for Maori Seats.

They defended their submission on the grounds that how Auckland is governed can affect families/whanau. What a ridicolous justification.

I would say every law passed by Parliament can be argued to have an impact on families. That doesn’t mean we need to be putting in millions of dollars into the Families Commission to be making submissions on laws that really are well outside what should be their core area of focus.

I’m still unconvinced we get anything near value for money by having a Families Commission. Some of the stuff they have been involved in is useful (I think the anti domestic violence TV ads are quite good), but these may well have occurred even if there was no Families Commission.

Caption Contest

Hos on mining review

The Herald on Sunday editorial:

Brownlee said in the speech that an estimated 70 per cent of the country’s mineral wealth – which might include zinc, lead, copper, nickel, tin and tungsten – lies under the surface of DoC-administered land and that almost half of it is in Schedule 4 land, beyond the reach of exploitation and locked up for ever. And, with the agreement of the Minister of Conservation, Tim Groser, he has ordered a review of that state of affairs.

This is scarcely high treason. Governments routinely review and repeal laws enacted by their predecessors. They know that they misjudge the public mood at their peril – when Don Brash as Opposition leader was sprung suggesting that the ban on nuclear warships would be “gone by lunchtime” if he were PM, he felt the chill wind of public opinion very quickly – but they are not elected to administer the decisions of their political opponents.

Well said. That applies not just to mining policy! Of course as I remind people Labour itself allowed mining on conservation land.

It was perhaps predictable that Brownlee’s speech would be greeted with horror by conservationists. Typical was Kevin Hackwell, the tireless advocacy manager for Forest & Bird, who, in an op ed piece in the Herald, conjured the images of an open-cast mine on the bird sanctuary of Little Barrier Island and a large pit scarring the face of Mt Moehau at the top of the Coromandel Peninsula. Others, including former Greens co-leader Jeanette Fitzsimons, spoke of the Schedule 4 land as “the jewels in the crown” of the conservation estate, by implication characterising mining as an inevitably destructive process which must, by its nature, consume something of beauty.

Yet good sense must see this as an overreaction: plainly there would not be more than a handful of people who would countenance the idea of mining activity that destroyed wilderness of surpassing beauty and conservation value. But conservationists need to accept that these values do not inhere in every square metre of every piece of Schedule 4 land. And beauty is in the eye of the beholder: an unemployed worker in a small provincial town may detect less lustre than a city yuppie who wants somewhere nice to go tramping. In this argument, as in most, no value is absolute and the minister is entitled to raise the matter for discussion.

As I said, it should be considered on a case by cases basis. What is the projected economic value of a specific area, and what is the environmental value of that specific area.

Nats up 3%, Lab down 3%

Fascinating poll result by Roy Morgan. It is for the period 17 to 30 August, so half of it is post the result of the smacking referendum on 25 August, yet National went up 3%, and Labour down 3%.

At iPredict, the stock for National to go down was up at 90c for a while. In fact it was so high I wondered if there was someone trading with inside knowledge of the result. Obviously not, and someone has lost a fair bit of money on it.

11 fatal accidents a week in the home

The Herald reports:

An average of 11 people died each week from accidents in their homes in the year to the end of June – an annual total of 573. That compares with the road toll last year of 366.

Of course people spend more time at home than driving, but that figure seems incredibly high.

The article gives a breakdown of total accidents in the home, but not of fatal accidents. I would be fascinated to see a breakdown of the almost 600 fatal home accidents.

Top Ten Conspiracy Theories

The Herald looks at the top ten conspiracy theories:

  1. 9/11 orchestrated by US Government
  2. Moon landing faked
  3. Princess Diana murdered
  4. Area 51 and Roswell
  5. Alternative energy sources suppressed by oil companies
  6. Secret group controls Earth
  7. JFK assassination
  8. Microsoft ‘Wingdings’ messages
  9. Nazi alien affiliation
  10. Facebook and the CIA

No 9 was new to me, but the others all old hat.

Auckland Council Bill reported back

The report by the Select Committee is here.

Key points:

  • All 20 Councillors to be elected from wards
  • Issue of Maori Seats one for the Auckland Council and voters to decide in future
  • FPP confirmed as electoral system for 2010 elections
  • campaign spending cap to be in third bill
  • Mayor can set committee structure, committee chairs and deputy mayor
  • Mayor’s office budget to be 0.2% of total Council, up to $3 million a year to allow for independent advisors
  • rural northern area of Rodney District to become part of Kaipara District
  • southern boundary unchanged
  • two rural single-member wards, and the other 18 councillors to come from wards with LGC to determine how many are multi-member and single-member.
  • Number of local boards remains at 20 – 30. LGC to determine boundaries, and electoral subdivisions of a board if any.
  • Each board to have 4 to 9 members
  • local board boundaries to coincide with ward boundaries where possible
  • 10% tolerance for boundaries in terms of voters/representative
  • Great Barrier Island And Waiheke Island guaranteed local boards
  • decision on nature and level of services provided should be made by local boards except where decision on an Auckland wide basis will be better.
  • boards expected to be responsible for libraries, swimming pools, parks, rec centres, community halls, funding of local groups and local bylaws etc
  • can not be on both Council and a local board

I am pleased the Committee/Government has given local boards much greater powers, and the principle of subsidiarity. Also pleased at large seats have been deleted.

Labour has a minority report. They want:

  • Maori Seats
  • More Councillors – 25 instead of 20
  • Fewer local boards (making local boards less local)
  • Maximum two members per ward
  • Mayor only to nominate Deputy Mayor and Committee Chairs, not appoint them
  • STV for all elections
  • Pacific and Asian advisory boards to be enshrined in legislation
  • Wants to keep all of Rodney in the new Council and extend southern boundary to Waikato River

I have previously blogged on Maori Seats. Not too worried about 25 vs 20 for size of Council. I am puzzled that after arguing for more local involvement they want fewer local boards, meaning residents will have less of a local connection to them.

Trotter on Len Brown

Chris Trotter is unhappy that Labour are pushing for Len Brown as Auckland Mayor, ignoring the wider left:

WHEN will Labour ever learn? A party whose membership now numbers less than 5,000 nationwide, and probably less than 1,000 north of Taupo, has decided – unilaterally – to select the Left’s mayoral candidate for the new Auckland “supercity”.

“Cheek” is too small a word to describe this sort of behaviour. Why? Because, if we accept the well-established rule-of-thumb that only ten percent of any organisation’s paper membership should ever be considered active players, fewer than 100 people took it upon themselves to choose the person aiming to represent 1.4 million.

For the sheer, jaw-dropping arrogance of this pre-emptive strike against democratic procedure, Labour deserves a hefty political smack – to say nothing of the “good parental correction” required for putting its own, narrow, partisan interests ahead of Auckland’s future.
Yep, definitely not happy.
Of Labour (and City Vision, its front organisation) I did, however, expect something more imaginative (and democratic) than an old-fashioned “deal”, hammered out in a variety of smoke-free rooms, between a clutch of anonymous party hacks and the Mayor of Manukau City.

Strategically commissioned opinion polls, notwithstanding, Mr Brown has long been the Auckland Right’s preferred opponent. He comes across as an evangelical social-worker, who, when he’s not mouthing bogus Pasifika street-slang, delivers earnest speeches in which the buzz-words “vision”, “passion” and “community” are endlessly repeated.
Not exactly a glowing endorsement of Mr Brown.
I do, however, give Labour points for staking its claim so early and with such clarity. The other potential candidates: be he Waitakere City Mayor, Bob Harvey, or the Chairman of the Auckland Regional Council, Mike Lee; can now be intimidated into withdrawing from the race – on pain of “splitting the Left vote”.

The truth, of course, is that the only splitters operating in the broader Auckland Left are Labour and its allies. By dividing the field of mayoral hopefuls into Mr Brown and “the rest”, they have very foolishly, and selfishly, made the best candidate the enemy of the first.
I recall Matt McCarten calling many months ago for some sort of primary on the left to unify them. Ignoring Matt and Chris on matters in their home city can be a foolish thing to do. They have loud voices.
But, if the Left accepts Labour’s fait accompli, what will it be getting in Mr Brown? A Palangi lawyer from Manukau, with a very thin portfolio of municipal achievements (unlike his illustrious predecessor, Sir Barry Curtis) and a rather goofy grin.
Again not exactly a vote of confidence,

Which eggs will make up the omelette?

Dim-Post on Stocktakes

A classic:

The National government is calling for a calm and reasoned debate after opposition MPs have raised fears about a recent Ministry of Health audit into the value of New Zealander’s body organs.

Health Minister Tony Ryall announced the stocktake of body parts last week, explaining that it was useful to know how much the total organ pool of New Zealand was worth. Some experts estimate that New Zealand is sitting on over $340 billion dollars in kidneys alone. …

The Prime Minister has reassured New Zealanders that they should not be concerned about the audit. ‘At this point we have virtually no plans to harvest any organs. We realise that peoples lungs and pancreas are important to them and you should feel confident that when you go to the dentist or the doctor for a checkup you have only a very small chance of being selected for the Ministry’s trial program and waking up in a tub of ice with an empty cavity where one of your kidneys used to be. I want to reassure people on that issue.’

Also to be checked out is the “Waiting for Voter: A tragi-comedy in two Acts” post. I won’t even quote from it as you really want to read the full thing.

Danyl obviously has far too much spare time on his hands, but we’re grateful of that.

Stupid Spin

Tom Pullar-Strecker writes in the Dom Post:

People might be forgiven for taking a joint media statement issued by Parents Inc and Youthline on Wednesday at face value. The charities said they were concerned the Commerce Commission’s proposal to regulate mobile termination charges might have a ”negative impact”.

Why would they be getting involved in this issue?

Vodafone’s charitable arm, the Vodafone Foundation, awarded Youthline $200,000 to build a centre in Papatoetoe in March and has also paid the salary of a Youthline counsellor. Parents Inc announced a three year partnership with Vodafone in June.

And their arguments:

Both Parents Inc. and Youthline are concerned about the other unintended consequences of regulation, such as the potential for an increase in text spam and text bullying. When a service is very cheap or free, it increases the risk of abuse.

They’re arguing that a reduction in the cost to phone or text someone is a bad thing as it may lead to text spamming and worst of all child abuse by text bullying.

That is like arguing we should introduce a charge to send e-mails, to reduce e-mail spam and e-mail flame wars. Absolute throwing the baby out with the bath water.

Yes it is possible more companies may try to send text spam, if sending texts is cheaper. However commercial text spamming is against the law, and further the telcos have a code of practice that bans it from their networks.

Pilbrow says, “One of the issues with young people and parents is that the technology is growing so fast we have not had time to put boundaries around it. Parents struggle with it, and when spam and other areas of abuse are factored in, the issues for parents increase immensely.”

So lowering the mobile termination rate will add to family stress for parents. I can not believe anyone in their right mind allowed this press release to go out with such vapid and stupid arguments – obviously motivated by a desire to please their funder.

Youthline CEO Stephen Bell is particularly concerned about text bullying. “The mobile is such a personal communications device, and teenagers in particular rush to read and respond to a text message as soon as they hear the phone beep. Texts can easily be anonymous, which emboldens bullies and intimidates victims. Anything that makes it easier for bullies is of grave concern and we should take it very seriously.”

Again this is just an outrageous argument. It is like arguing that lowering the price of petrol makes it easier for drunk drivers, or that lowering the price of newspapers make it easier for arsonists!

Incidentially Curia, which I own did some market research for Exceltium for their Lower the Rate, Mate campaign. This was well publicised at the time. My views on mobile termination rates pre-date that arrangement, and my response to these press release is entirely my own initiative fueled by outrage at the arguments used. No-one at all pointed the article out to me, suggested I should blog on it, or even knows I was going to blog on it.

There are valid arguments for and against mobile termination rate regulation. However scaremongering about text bullying and spam are not amongst them, and shame on whomever put these groups up to making such ludicrous assertions.

Zumwohl

As a blogger I get invites to a number of media events, ranging from a new printer range (yawn) to the launch of a new alcoholic drink, which is far more fun.

Zumwohl

On Wednesday Zumwohl had a briefing and tasting of their three Zumwohl spirits. It was on the top floor of the Majestic Centre, which was a nice backdrop for it.

The name Zumwohl, is German and is a traditional cheers type toast. Ulf Führer is a German born Kiwi who created the drink.

At first glance I thought Zumwohl might be a type of vodka, due to its clear nature. But it is considerably smoother than Vodka, being based on a German shot drink.

They have it in three flavours – natural, plum and feijoa. The natural was very drinkable, even without a mixer – considerably smoother than vodka.

We next tried the plum. The nose on it alone is quite superb, and the taste is very refined. The feijoa was similar. My favourite of the three was the plum, while Alexandra (a visitor from the UK who I dragged along to it) preferred the feijoa.

How good is it? Well I’m going to Liquor King this weekend to buy a couple of bottles.

I’ve been drinking vodka since I was 12 years old (yes explains a lot) and while I wouldn’t quite go so far as to say I’ll be giving up vodka for Zumwohl, it certainly will be my preference when I have a choice between them.

I’ve yet to put it to the ultimate test – how well it mixes with L&P, but it is surprisingly very drinkable straight. Possibly too drinkable as you tend to drink faster than entirely wise when it is very nice.

A few bars around Wellington are launching the drink this weekend. It is also available in Auckland, and a few bars elsewhere.  For my 2c, it is well worth trying if you are a spirits fan.

They are not your trees Brian

Brian Rudman writes:

So tell me again, and slowly: we have a Government that in one breath is trying to find a way to cut greenhouse gas emissions, yet in the next is fast-tracking a law declaring open season on every urban tree in the land.

Now you read that and you would think Rudman is talking about great swathes of urban forests  under threat. The Government is going to let developers destroy the Wellington Town Belt etc.

Alas the true story is far less exciting. What he Government is doing is allowing home owners to trim or chop down the trees they own on their private land. And even then, it is not absolute. They are merely saying that Councils have to have a valid reason to list individual trees as warranting protection, rather than list entire classes of trees.

So what this means is a homeowner will be able to chop down one of their own trees, or trim it, should they wish to do so. The thought this have any impact on carbon emissions is pathetically hysterical. We’re not talking hectares of forests here, but generally individual trees being trimmed or replaced.

The meal breaks law

I always regarded the law passed last year legislating for rest and meal breaks was a solution looking for a problem.

It now turns out the solution was somewhat flawed, as it imposed a national requirement that doesn’t take account of the flexibility needed for some individual businesses. The Herald reports:

Legislation allowing workers to take meal and breast-feeding breaks may be changed because it would cause the cancellation of nine domestic flights, Labour Minister Kate Wilkinson says. …

The current legislation meant regional airport control towers were being closed down while workers took breaks, she said.

Pharmacies, schools, meatworks and sole attendant operations had also raised concerns about the law, she said.

Imagine a parking building has a sole attendant. How would you feel if you were unable to leave the building for 10 minutes because the attendant is on their statutory break?

Or do you force the business to double its staffing budget just to cater for the ten minute breaks, and have two staff working, even though you only need one?