Goff should get to negotiate with Key

I attended the AGM of the NZ Institute of Economic Research last night. After the AGM and guest lecture (which I will blog on separately) there was a dinner at Icon Restaurant at Te Papa.

It was perhaps the only dinner I had been to, where you could have a discussion about the pros and cons of an intensity based approach to credit allocations in an emissions trading scheme, and the entire table understood the discussion!

In discussing the ETS, it became very clear that the preferred options of the NZ business sector is for National and Labour to reach agreement on the ETS, rather than National to rely on the Maori Party or ACT. They want certainty of policy.

Now Labour and National do actually agree on around 32 of the 35 issues around an ETS. However the issues they differ on are pretty big – the dates certain sectors enter the ETS and the merits or otherwise of an intensity based approach (which I will try and blog on at some stage also).

Now NZ already has an ETS, passed into law. Labour did this in 2008. So if Labour and National do reach an agreement, it is Labour that is arguably making the greater concession in order to give businesses policy certainity.

The Herald reports:

Labour is trying to rope Prime Minister John Key into the climate change negotiations, saying leader-to-leader talks are the way ahead. …

This is an opportunity for Phil Goff. In fact again at last night’s dinner we discussed how if Labour does do a deal with National on the ETS, this could be the equivalent of John Key’s compromise with Helen Clark on the smacking law.

And if Labour do put the national interest ahead of partisan interest, and strike an agreement with National, Phil Goff deserves his day up on the podium with John Key, looking Prime Ministerial.

But the issue is at what stage do you turn this into a negotiation at the leadership level.  If I was advising John Key, I would have two reservations about negotiating with Goff at this stage.

  1. Can you trust him to be sincerely wanting an agreement, or is he just trying to get the PM involved so Key gets personally blamed when Goff walks away. Up until the Richard Worth affair, Goff would have been trusted. But his behaviour over the Choudary allegations, has dented Goff’s trustworthiness. And his use of confidential MFAT staff notes to embarrass Don Brash has not been forgotten either. In a negotiation both sides need to be able to put forward positions in confidence, and trust the other not to report the details.
  2. Can Goff deliver his caucus? Key had a strong enough grip on the leadership that he could strike a private deal with Clark, and cheerfully walk into Caucus and tell them all that they are now voting for the bill they have spent the last six months fighting. A deal with National might involve (for example) a change of stance on the intensity issue. Could Goff get his Caucus to agree to that, just to get him his day in the sun?

Now these are not reasons to not meet with Goff at all. If Labour does do a deal, he should be the one to get the credit and share the podium with the PM. For putting the national interest of policy certainty first, he would deserve it.

But such a meeting is unlikely to happen, until the lower level negotiators can report back that there are reasonable prospects of success.

Anti-smoking proposals

The Herald reports:

A proposal to license tobacco retailers and turn cigarette packs into plain packages bearing only health warnings has found strong support.

Now when I read that, I think of opinion polls and assume people have been talking to members of the public at large. But reading on we find:

In planning for the “end game” of widespread tobacco use, researchers canvassed public health physicians, policy officials in the Ministry of Health and other departments, and journalists.

I don’t think canvassing public health physicians, policy officials and journalists is the same as canvassing the public.

It’s like canvassing gang members in Wanganui on the gang patch ban, and concluding there is strong opposition to it.

I’m not actually against sensible initiatives that seek to reduce the incidence of smoking. But I urge caution against concluding that because policy officials think something is a good idea, that means the public will agree.

iPredict Column

I’ve resumed doing a regular (paid) weekly column for iPredict, for them to use in their e-mail newsletter to subscribers and on their blog. I’ll also normally publish them here also. This one went out yesterday and interestingly several of the stocks seem to have moved already based on my analysis. In future will try and blog them around the same time they are e-mailed out.

BuysBeing a long time studier of Winston, I never thought he would hand power over to someone else, or share it. So I managed to get 200 shares in Peters.Leader for under 39c. The recent NZ First conference confirmed he is carrying on as sole leader so I am looking forward to a good return on 1 January 2010 when the stock closes.

The current price is 89c. There is little risk of Peters standing down in the next four months, so traders can get a 12.3% return over four months – equal to an annualized return of 37%.

Personally I’ll be getting a 156% return over 10 months, equal to 188% return on an annualized basis. Thanks Winston.

Mayor.Brown is also worth trading, as a short-term pick. I am not saying I think Len Brown will win the mayoral election – it is too far away. But I do think his share price will increase over time from the current level of 28c, as he is looking to be the main centre-left candidate. I grabbed 200 shares at 16c and will consider selling if the prices gets to around 40c.

His shares were only 20c a week ago, and have increased with his official bid announcement.

Sells

DL.King.09 is trading at 15c and only pays out if King retires as Deputy Leader by the end of 2009. Despite Annette’s protestations I still don’t rule out a possible mayoral bid in 2010, but we can be almost certain that she will not be making any announcement by the end of this year.

So if you short sell her stock at 15c, you can buy it for 0c when it closes on 1 Jan 2010. And that is an 18% return over four months, annualized to be a 53% return. Again some easy money in my opinion. Over time I have sold 445 shares in this stock at an average price of 25c.

Another easy sell is Lab.Shearer currently trading at 20c. This stock pays out if Shearer replaces becomes Leader before the 2011 election. That just is not going to happen. Now the stock will not pay out until end of 2011 so the return is 25% over around two years or 12% per annum. It is a very safe reasonable long term position.

My other recommended sell is GST.UP.JULY10 which pays out if GST is increased from 12.5% on or before 1 July 2010. The current price is 22c. I do not rule out an increase to GST at some stage. However the earliest such an announcement would be made would be the May 2010 budget, and it is highly unlikely the Government would give retailers only four weeks notice of a GST increase. Also many businesses pay GST over periods ending either on 31 July (if 2 monthly) or 30 September (is 6 monthly), so my conclusion is to sell the GST stock. I have sold 50 stocks at 23c, which will give me a 30% return over ten months or a 36% annualized return.

Polling Stocks

This Friday should see the next Roy Morgan poll published, so trades can still be made over the next two days. The polling stocks will open and close every two weeks and offer the quickest opportunities to make (or lose) money.

The next poll should cover the period from 17 August to 30 August, which includes the results of the smacking referendum. However the market seems to slightly favour National increasing support with that stock at 50c and the National drop stock at 45c.

By contrast the Labour drop stock is at 58c – perhaps reflecting Goff’s low profile of late.

If one had a bit of money to speculate, you could do worse by throwing a bit at the no change stocks which are at 4c for National and 5c for Labour. Since the election National has stayed the same in the Roy Morgan poll 19% of the time and Labour has stayed the same 6% of the time. You’ll probably lose your money but the chances of a 1900% return are not too bad historically.

Cheers,

David

Disclosure

David’s current iPredict positions are:
DL.KING.09 Short, FASA04.REPEAL Short, GST.UP.JULY10 Short, LEAD.GOFF.09 Short, MAYOR.BROWN Long, MIN.DEPART2.09 Short, MP.ANDERTON Short, MP.PETERS.2011 Short, NAT.MAORI.09 Short, NAT.UP.30AUG09 Short, OCR.INCR.APR10 Short, OCR.INCR.JAN10 Short, PETERS.LEADER Long, PM.2011.NATIONAL Long, ZIM.MUGABE Short

General Debate 3 September 2009

Dom Post on WWII

The Dom Post Editorial:

Seventy years ago today the New Zealand Government declared war on Germany, committing its citizens to fighting in the event that has defined our age.

The world that emerged from the ruins of 1945 was utterly changed from the one that existed when British prime minister Neville Chamberlain announced that his country had gone to war with Germany over the invasion of Poland. “Where she [Britain] goes, we go; where she stands, we stand,” New Zealand prime minister Michael Joseph Savage said.

And 11,929 New Zealanders died in that fight – the highest per capita in the Empire/Commonwealth.

It was a price that had to be paid. Victory for the Nazis would have meant the end of civilisation in Europe.

Even now, after 70 years of research and scholarship on the horrors of the Third Reich, it is hard to comprehend how a culture responsible for the poetry of Goethe and the music of Beethoven could also have produced Buchenwald and Auschwitz. The truth is that the Nazis sought to wipe the Jewish people and any others who did not fit in with their perverted racial ideology from the face of the Earth. They went about their task with a chilling, clinical efficiency. At its peak, 9000 people a day were being killed and cremated at Auschwitz.

And this was nothing to do with religion or beliefs. It was all about bloodlines.

Six million Jews died in the Nazis’ extermination camps. Others they targeted included Roma (Gypsies), Poles, Russians and other Slavic peoples. More than three million Soviet prisoners of war died, along with two million Soviet civilians in Nazi-occupied territories.

Others were selected to die on genetic grounds, such as the handicapped, or for political or behavioural reasons including communists, socialists, Jehovah’s Witnesses and homosexuals.

World War II was, quite simply, a war against evil.

It was indeed.

Headscarfs in Court

The Dom Post reports:

A judge who barred a Muslim woman from entering a courthouse because she was wearing a headscarf has admitted he made a mistake.

Yasmeen Ali was attempting to enter Hastings District Court on Tuesday to support her brother Carlos Manuel Brooking, 22, who was appearing for sentencing on a charge of assault. …

Ms Ali, a 25-year-old mother-of-three, was asked by a court attendant to remove her headscarf on entering the courthouse. She refused and took a seat.

When she tried to re-enter court after the morning break, she was blocked.

Unless the court would also force a nun to remove her headdress, or a Sikh his turban, it is inappropriate to require a Muslim woman to remove her headscarf.

However it seems, this was not intentional with regard to a general ban.

Her brother had earlier been put into custody after refusing to remove a hat while sitting in court awaiting his sentencing, despite being requested to do so by Judge Rea.

Brooking apologised later in the dock and was sentenced to 125 hours’ community work for the assault.

Judicial communications adviser Neil Billington said the incident was the result of Judge Rea’s “mistaken assumption of what was occurring in the courtroom”.

“The judge required the removal of the woman because of her association with [her brother] who had just been removed.

“The judge had mistakenly assumed that her headgear was a demonstration of protest at the court.

“He did not require her removal because of any objection to the wearing of Muslim headgear. “

So in a way, it is a fuss about nothing. The Judge has made clear there is no general ban. It was a mistaken assumption based on the conduct of her brother.

Afghanistanians

After I blogged yesterday about some media incorrectly calling Afghans, Afghanis, Grant Robertson pointed out that a few weeks ago John Key called them Afghanistanians.

I’d like to make clear I take no responsibility for the Prime Minister’s inventing of new words 🙂

He does this quite often. I suspect his staff have told him that even though he is Prime Minister, he really should stick to using existing words instead of inventing new ones. But to no avail.

I know the Dominion Post has been compiling a list of words invented by John, and in due course they will publish the extended New Zealand Dictionary (PM’s edition).

Respond with respect

The Dom Post reports:

A group of primary school children who wrote to Wanganui Mayor Michael Laws about the “h” debate are upset that they received a letter back suggesting their teacher be sacked and that they control their anger.

Mr Laws replied to letters from Otaki school children by telling them “there are so many deficiencies of both fact and logic in your letters that I barely know where to start”.

Ngarui Waahitia-Manukau, 12, and her year 7 and 8 classmates at Otaki School’s kura kaupapa unit wrote letters in Maori to Mr Laws at the beginning of August, saying they thought the spelling of Wanganui should have an “h”.

The seven children wrote in separate letters how they were annoyed that Mr Laws would not change the city’s name.

A fierce opponent of any name change, Mr Laws replied to the children that he would take their views seriously “when your class starts addressing the real issues affecting Maoridom particularly the appalling rate of child abuse and child murder within Maori society, then I will take the rest of your views seriously”.

He added: “Perhaps sacking your teacher for allowing such misapprehension to flourish?”

In handwriting at the bottom of his letter, Mr Laws wrote: “PS Controlling your anger might be a start!”

This is a silly response by Michael Laws, regardless of the merits of the issue the kids wrote on. A politician beating up on primary school kids is never a good look, and personally I regard it as a good thing if kids show an interest in civic issues.

Mr Laws was unrepentant last night. He said the pupils were “put up to it” by their teacher.

“Do you honestly think that children give a continental about how Wanganui is spelt? Children this age care about Harry Potter.”

Class teacher Selwyn Katene said last night that the children decided to write and he did not tell them what to say.

A much smarter response would have been to invite the kids to come up to Wanganui for a visit, and meet some of the locals who will explain why they don’t want the spelling of the name to be changed. That way they would start to learn about how there are two sides to every issue.

UPDATE: I’m tardy in pointing out Roar Prawn broke this story yesterday.

Submisions on S92A

Simon Power has releases the 113 submissions on s92A of the Copyright Act, and commented:

“There seems to be general support for the proposals. They’re regarded as a significant improvement on the original.

“This gives me encouragement that we’re on track to developing a fair and balanced process to deal with online copyright infringement.

Time will tell.

A key concern raised by some submitters was the proposal to terminate internet accounts as a remedy to copyright infringement. It was felt termination was an unreasonable ‘remedy’, especially where multiple users of a single account could make identifying an infringer difficult.

However, there was general support for the Copyright Tribunal playing the role of independent third party arbiter if necessary.

Mr Power said he was confident all issues would be carefully considered in the policy paper that will go to Cabinet later this year.

Good to see mention of the resistance to termination as an option.

A summary of submissions is online here.

The EMA has rightly cited concerns many businesses may still be treated as ISPs under the proposal. But their suggestion that a better alternative is filtering or blocking of file sharing sites is concerning.

Several copyright groups have said they support the model, but two of the major US dominated groups have said they want less checks and balances.

Afghans not Afghanis

TVNZ last night reported:

Witnesses say one of the attackers yelled out the name of an Afghani youth gang.

And NZPA today reported:

One of the attackers reportedly yelled out the name of an Afghani youth gang during the attack on Monday afternoon, which was possibly sparked by comments on the social networking website Bebo.

A citizen of Afghanistan is called an Afghan, not an Afghani.

An Afghani is the currency of Afghanistan.

From the Concise Oxford Dictionary:

Afghan noun: 1 a native or national of Afghanistan, or a person of Afghan descent.
adjective: relating to Afghanistan, its people or their language.

afghani noun: (pl. afghanis) the basic monetary unit of Afghanistan, equal to 100 puls.

Would media please stop calling Afghans, Afghanis. It is like calling a European, a Euro.

Backbenches tonight

Wanganui gang patch bylaw

While well intentioned, I have never been a fan of the gang patch law.

My concerns were heightened yesterday when I heard the local Police Commander explain why the City Council has passed the by-law (as allowed for by the law passed by Parliament.

The Commander said that local residents wanted to impose a dress code for their city.

People should impose dress codes on their private property. I don’t think it is the role of governments to impose dress codes on public places (so long as people are not indecent/naked).

District 9

Went to see District 9 at the Embassy last night.

It’s produced by Peter Jackson and set in South Africa.

The film is basically about two million aliens turning up in a damaged spaceship, and being housed in temporary camps which turn into slums. There are obvious parallels to apartheid era South Africa.

However the film doesn’t put the politics on the pedestal, and mainly focuses on telling a good story focusing on the very likeable Wikus van de Merwe. He is a somewhat bumbling bureaucrat and at first in the film you think he is going to do something very stupid that ends in disaster. He only got the job due to his father-in-law.

However over the film he transforms into the most unlikely of heroes, And I mean he literally transforms.

I really liked the film, and it is a good one to see on the big screen. It also has some very cool weapons!

My criticism though would be the weakness of parts of the plot. Without giving too much away, there is no sound explanation for why the aliens didn’t tell the humans what was wrong with the ship and that once they get it fixed, they could go.

Dom Post on teachers

A stinging editorial:

At least one school head has outrageously threatened publicly to undermine the education policies that contributed to National’s election win last year it promised to set literacy and numeracy standards for primary-school kids, and make the results available to parents.

Teachers, afraid that, because such results will be subject to the Official Information Act, the public will be able compile “league tables” that show how each school compares with its fellows, pretend theirs is principled opposition. Rubbish. Their objections are political this Government is not stuffed with former teachers and university lecturers and visceral. …

They fear any weaknesses will be exposed and that parents, some of them able to see for the first time that the empress in front of the class is naked, will opt to send their littlies to a school that does better. …

Though inspirational teachers are integral to the process, at the heart of public education should be the six to 16-year-olds for whom it is compulsory.

And regrettably often, these kids are let down. Last year, research showed that 90 per cent of prisoners are “functionally illiterate” their reading and writing skills are inadequate to cope with the demands of daily life.

Yet most of these inmates passed through a New Zealand primary school. As these kids struggled to read, write and do arithmetic, their teachers happily collected pay rises they saw as entitlements.

How can these teachers live with themselves knowing they have failed so many children? How do they explain the uncomfortably long tail of under-achievement throughout the public education system? How do they rationalise the millions the taxpayer must now spend helping the illiterate and innumerate recover wasted years? …

You know the more some schools try to suppress information and stop the public knowing how well the school is doing, the more you wonder what they are hiding.

Watkins on Blogs

Tracy Watkins blogs:

I like David and he’s definitely one of the sharper knives in the drawer around Wellington, but sadly he seems to have lost his mojo. Back when Labour was in power, he did a sterling job of running issues and was the outlet for the voice of opposition. But nowadays he seems to be floundering over his purpose. Cheerleading is okay but it’s not why people started reading Kiwiblog.

Funnily enough, just a couple of days ago, Audrey Young blogged:

Key’s nervousness is aided no doubt by continued critical commentary on the right including from David Farrar’s Kiwiblog most recently on the Boscawen bill

So one political editor says I’m cheerleading and another says my continued critical commentary is making the PM nervous 🙂

It should be no surprise to anyone that Kiwiblog is less “edgy” with National in Government. Of course I am going to be happier with more of what the Government does.

But I do reject the label of cheerleader. Hell, I ignore most of the announcements from Government as boring. And I thought I had been pretty vigorous in opposing the Government’s moves to ban handheld cellphone use in cars. I’ve said many times I don’t support at large Council seats for Auckland. I have called for the anti-smacking law to be changed numerous times. I’ve continued to advocate Nancy Wake getting honoured (despite the change of Government) and have also said several times that the immigration allegations around a National MP should have gone to an independent inquiry.

But I hold centre-right beliefs. I enjoy pointing out lunacy and hypocrisy from the left, and while they keep providing me material, I’ll enjoy keeping that up.

This probably appears somewhat defensive. I think Tracy is probably quite right that Kiwiblog is not the same as in the last years of Labour – I agree. But I don’t like or accept the term “cheer leader”. My purpose in blogging is much the same as when I started – to have my say on anything I am interested in.

Anyway back to Tracy:

Whale Oil: I’ll admit it… once I got over my squeamishness, I quite enjoyed his blog. Utterly nihilistic and entertaining

Nihilistic – that’s a good term for it!

The Standard: They have picked up where Kiwiblog left off and do a good job of running issues as the voice of opposition. It’s a Labour blog in the same way Kiwiblog is a National blog, I guess, so it makes sense that they would fit more comfortably within the blogosphere now Labour is in Opposition. But The Standard is not yet required reading in the same way that Kiwiblog was during Labour’s final few years in government.

I said both before and after the election that I thought The Standard would do better in Opposition, and I agree with Tracy that they are. They seemed to more an anti John Key blog, even when he was in Opposition, than anything else, so having Key as PM gives them much more material.

NZ Herald on mining

The NZ Herald editorial:

Environmentalists say mining activity would be offputting to tourists lured to this country by the promise of a pristine landscape. But two factors undermine that argument. First, the sum of land in public ownership is so large – it occupies about a third of the country – that more than enough would be left over if mining were to occupy a tiny portion. And not all the land thought likely to harbour significant deposits of zinc, lead, copper, nickel and tin has high conservation value. Second, good modern mining practice pays due heed to the environment. The days of open-cast eyesores have been consigned to history.

On a per capita basis, New Zealand undoubtedly has a valuable mineral resource. The royalties from this can play a far greater role in economic growth.

The regions where mining takes place would receive a particular fillip. For every suspicious Coromandel resident, there will be those on the West Coast of the South Island eager to grasp the opportunity. Balance, not blinkered thinking, offers the way forward. Companies prepared to bring a responsible approach to mining carefully selected parts of the Department of Conservation estate should be welcomed to this country.

I’m told the Pike River Mine (on DOC land) takes up only 10 hectares above ground. That represents around one millionth of the conservation estate.

Legal Aid

The discussion paper by Dame Margaret Bazley is here.

At this stage there are no firm recommendations, just issues for discussion.

  • In last year grants increased from 73,905 to 85,158. Mostly criminal, followed by family.
  • Cost of legal aid increased in last year from $108 million to $124 million. Of that $67 million is criminal. Family cases cost more on average per case.
  • 45% of legal aid budget goes on 5% of cases
  • The top 100 cases (0.17% of total) cost 17% ($18.3m) of total scheme
  • Top ten cases cost 300 times the average
  • There is a reluctance by LSA to apply the “prospects of success” test for legal aid applications, as they do not wish to usurp role of court.
  • Legal aid for Treaty claims is available from three sources – LSA, OTS and CFRT, and double dipping may occur even though info is shared.
  • A small but significant number of legal aid lawyers are of low quality, often unprepared, and over-committed
  • Problems especially with sole barristers with no offices in Auckland – “car boot lawyers”
  • The relatively low rate for legal aid work may be responsible for the quality issues identified.
  • In UK they are looking at preferred legal aid suppliers which reduces compliance costs and providers greater certainty of income for those preferred suppliers
  • Another option is a fixed fee for categories of cases
  • Little performance monitoring of providers
  • The focus on legal aid payments on court events ,may encourage lawyers to use only court events to move cases forward
  • Pros and cons of capping certain categories of legal aid are discussed
  • Bulk funding of some services to be considered
  • Pilot of Public Defenders Service to be extended in Auckland. Review found savings in legal aid costs, savings in court time and costs, improved quality of services,better training of junior lawyers, and greater trust between prosecutors and defence.

I have blogged previously my support for the PDS concept, and it is good to see the trial seems to have been successful. I think expansion of this service will be part of the solution – but only part.

Weird Animals

And even better hypocrisy

Chris Carter is competing with his Leader for hypocrisy. Earlier today, I quoted Phil Goff arguing against mining on the conservation estate, and pointed out the Pike River Mine on DOC land was approved in 2004 by the former Labour Government.

Now today, we have Chris Carter blogging, and he says:

The DOC estate – some 30% of New Zealand’s land area – not only brings millions of tourists to this country, but also ensures that all Kiwis have access to quality outdoor pursuits, and that we are world leaders in protecting our unique biodiversity. …

So much for Mr Key and the National Party being ambitious for New Zealand!  I guess they’re being ambitious for the fishing industry, the mining industry, …

Now for those who don’t know, Chris Carter was the Conservation Minister who approved the Pike River Mine in 2004. He approved it over the objections of his own department who told him not to.

Now I think Carter made the right decision in 2004. But as he tries to portray himself as the protector of conservation lands against the mining industry, it is worth reminding people of those inconvenient facts that they hope we will forget.

Minto advocates 100% tax rate

I was never sure of John Minto is a communist or just a socialist (in terms of economic philosophy). He answers that today with his blog advocating a salary cap and 100% tax rate on top of that:

My pick would be to set the maximum income at 10 times the minimum wage. This would mean a maximum income of $250,000. The easiest way to enforce this would be setting a 100 per cent income tax rate for the combined income from all sources (including share allocations, allowances etc) above this level.

This system of salary caps is not a new concept. Most communist countries have or had such salary caps. Most have abandoned such practices, as they have learnt what happens when you do. I think North Korea and maybe Cuba still have such salary caps though.

Note Minto’s proposal is not just for salaries. He proposes 100% tax on income over $250,000 from all sources.Can’t see a lot of people setting up their own companies or businesses in future.

What will be most amusing is to see how much the tax take drops. It wouldn’t just be people earning over $250,000 who would be leaving. Minto doesn’t understand what aspiration is.

The missing Minister

Victoria is missing a Minister gone tramping, and this one really is tramping – not in Argentina with his mistress (cf SC Gov Mark Sanford).

Tim Holding was last seen on Sunday heading up Mt Feathertop. He is an experienced tramper, but tramping by yourself in winter is never a good idea.

If they do not find him today, it will be looking bad.

UPDATE: He is alive. They have sighted him from the air. Not yet rescued but will be soon it seems. A relief for the family.

An over-reaction

The Daily Telegraph reports:

Council staff have been stopped from using Facebook during office hours after they ran up 572 hours, the equivalent of 71 working days, in one month.

Sounds awful doesn’t it. But then further on:

Portsmouth City Council introduced the organisation-wide ban on the popular website after the figures emerged under Freedom of Information rules.

Current internet usage rules allow staff to access Facebook during lunch breaks and after work, but now all 4,500 council employees will have to justify having access to the site.

On average this is seven and a half minutes a month on Facebook. They would be better to do what one Wellington firm does – restrict access during work hours but allow it during the lunch break, plus before and after work.

A calm rational analogy from the Greens

Jeanette Fitzsimons was interviewed last week on Checkpoint about the possibility of having mining done on portions of the conservation estate. The interviewer put to her that it might only be a couple of hundred hectares out of many thousands (in fact it is millions) of hectares of estate and Jeanette responded:

That’s like saying you’ve got six children, so it doesn’t really matter if you lose one does it.

I don’t even need to comment do I?

The key segment starts at 6:30 into the RNZ item. Listen for yourself – I am not making this up. Even the generally sympathetic interviewer sounded a bit stunned, and responded “Really, we are talking about land”.