Armstrong’s View

John Armstrong touches on a number of issues:

No matter what spin the anti-smacking brigade puts on last week’s referendum, the result is still mind-boggling. …

The assumption of voter ignorance is the typical sort of patronising claptrap used by the liberal elites to conveniently explain away something that disturbs their comfort zones. …

Ditto with the smacking referendum. Voters understood exactly what they were doing. Politicians ignore the outcome at their peril.

There is a huge disconnect between the so called liberal elite and the rest of NZ on this issue. Armstrong is right – people knew exactly what they were voting for. This is an issue that has had two years plus of public debate.

Those in National’s senior ranks are most definitely taking note. The highest “no” votes were registered in provincial and rural seats held by that party.

Once it was clear that the turnout was going to be much higher than predicted, the Prime Minister ensured he had a response prepared. This amounted to more monitoring of the existing law to ensure it is working as intended.

That was obviously not going to satisfy the referendum’s organisers, who were seeking the repeal of the relevant section of the Crimes Act.

While Sue Bradford’s amended initiative remains the law, National has taken on board the message from the referendum that voters are drawing a line in the sand against any more measures which might be termed liberal, socially progressive or nanny state-ish.

I remain unconvinced that this will be enough. I think it will remain an issue until the law is amended.

And I don’t think one should include “socially progressive” in the same sentence as “nanny state”. Certainly some people are against both, but I see de-criminalising prostitution (or more correctly solicitation) as the exact opposite of nanny state.

In marked contrast, National’s reform agenda for the economy and social service delivery is meeting little resistance. For example, Bill English has now mentioned on several occasions three dreaded words that usually spell political death – “capital gains tax” – without his world caving in.

That is not to say the Finance Minister is about to bring in such a tax.

But the lack of opposition is emboldening the Government to move faster on the economic front than it might otherwise have done, another example being National’s willingness to allow mining of minerals on parts of the Department of Conservation estate.

I am pleased that National is showing signs that the status quo will not deliver the economy we need.

If nothing else, the politics surrounding the latter is proof there is a God – and that he or she has a wicked sense of humour.

How else to explain the private member’s bill promoted by Act’s John Boscawen, which allows parents to give their child a “light” smack for corrective purposes, making it onto Parliament’s order paper for debate.

The odds on the measure securing the sole spot available were a staggering 28-1 against. Beating those odds in the ballot of private member’s bills – plus the timing just days after the referendum result – suggested divine intervention.

I joked to a Christian lobbyist after the bill was drawn, that perhaps this does show that God is indeed on their side šŸ™‚

National is relaxed about Act getting a pay-off in the polls from Hide appearing principled by saying he would resign his Local Government portfolio rather than steer legislation through Parliament with which he could not agree.

Act has struggled to register above 1.5 per cent support since the election, while backing for National is up to 10 percentage points higher than the party got at the ballot box last year.

While Act appears to have decided to be less supine in its four-way relationship with National, the Maori Party and United Future, it has to ensure it does not overreach itself and become the docked tail wagging a very large National dog.

Most in National would like ACT to be close to 5% than 1%. And again to be fair to Rodney he did not publicise his stance on resigning over the Maori Seats. Whomever leaked the Tau Henare e-mail did that.

National ultimately holds the whip hand. Act’s survival as a parliamentary party rests on Hide holding his Epsom seat. National has no qualms about reminding him that it retains the right to select a quality candidate and make a proper fight of it in the electorate.

Hide’s threat to resign his portfolios is akin to the Black Knight’s sword fight with King Arthur in Monty Python and the Holy Grail. As Arthur hacks off the Black Knight’s limbs one-by-one, the latter insists his wounds are nothing more than a scratch and suggests the pair call it a draw.

Again I think it is fair to stress Rodney did not want this made public. But having been made public, is is true that there is limited room to take such a firm stance again without a degree of backlash.

If there is a lesson to be drawn from the Byzantine nature of MMP politics, it is not to view an argument over something like the non-establishment of Maori seats in isolation. The Maori Party has been the loser in that instance, it should be the winner elsewhere, thereby reinforcing its current inclination to stick with National.

The review of the foreshore and seabed law will see it emerge the winner when it comes to concessions.

I have blogged previously that by 2011 the Maori Party will probably have a fairly impressive list of achievements or wins. And what will be more remarkable is all of them were gained voluntarily – National could have governed without them.

A step in the right direction

Pat Pilcher reports in the Herald:

In what could be a landmark move, US website www.filmfresh.com have joined the fray and are delivering over 600 downloadable big title Hollywood movies. …

Film Fresh’s movie titles are not totally hobbled with digital rights management (DRM) which means they won’t become unwatchable a week after you’ve downloaded them and can be burnt to a DVD or copied to a USB stick.

Perhaps most important of all, delivering a solid range of blockbuster Hollywood movies that are relatively un-crippled by DRM provides a legitimate alternative to copyright infringing downloads.

Absolutely. The biggest blow against illegal downloading is making material available for legal purchase immediately, without DRM, in all countries, for a reasonable price.

This goes some of the way there.

That’s the good news. The bad news is that Fresh Films is only available to folks living in the US and there’s no sign of it arriving here any time soon.

Stupid. That means the only way Kiwis wanting to view the film at home can do so, is to get it from a torrent site.

The other catch for those that can download Fresh Film titles is the price which ranges from US$10 to US$13.

Whilst that isn’t too steep (especially considering that the movie hasn’t been lobotomised by DRM), it is a little steep in that it is comparable to US budget DVD pricing and you don’t get the special features and other goodies usually bundled with a DVD.

I think this is significantly over-priced. In NZ you can go to the movies and see a film for around $10 on a weekday. Now bearing in mind you watching it at home means the studio does notĀ  have to pay for the theatre, the theatre staff, the cost of getting a film reel to them etc etc and my expectation is that a movie should be NZ$5 at most to really get people buying them.

Likewise I think $1 is around the sensible rate for a TV show.

Bad news aside, the move by Fresh Films backers (Paramount, Warner Bros., Lionsgate, and Sony Pictures) to allow semi un-crippled legit movie downloads could signal a softening in the hard-line stance of the major studios, potentially opening the floodgates for other similar local services.

As I said, a step in the right direction.

Misleading headlines

When you see the Weekend Herald proclaim “Nats’ chief helps in fraud probe” you automatically think he may be in some way involved with an alleged fraud, and/or criminal wrong-doing.

In reality it transpires he is an indirect victim having lent $100,000 to a friend who invested with a man who seemingly is being investigated by the SFO.

It would have been nice if the headline reflected this, assuming that what has been reported is al there is to the story. To be honest seems a non-story to me.

In another Herald story, they profile Goodfellow’s baptism of fire. An interesting tidbit:

It is a rare glimpse: his now 92-year-old father, Douglas Goodfellow, has never given a public interview.

The family have managed to keep their low profile despite wealth and philanthropy on a massive scale – a Listener article from 1996 detailed how Douglas Goodfellow gave away $285 million to various unknown charities, the largest gift in New Zealand history at the time.

Goodness, that is a huge amount of charity, and done very quietly it seems.

The family are 16th on the NBR rich list with an estimated wealth of $550 million from interests ranging across fishing, finance and agricultural chemicals. The mild-mannered Mr Goodfellow – often compared to Ned Flanders from The Simpsons because of his moustache – told the Weekend Herald that recent weeks had been “difficult”.

I hadn’t heard the Ned Flanders nickname before, but sadly for Peter can see it catching on šŸ™‚

Asked if the factional politics of the National Party in Auckland are “vicious” given the early pressure on his presidency, Mr Goodfellow prefers the word “robust”.

Ha, that is a euphemism!

He became the family’s first activist with the Young Nationals in the 1970s.

He recalled Tamaki MP and Prime Minister Rob Muldoon collecting him early one morning for an Anzac Day dawn service.

Good God. That could have been very traumatic!

August 2009 Cabinet Front Bench Blog Poll Results

We receivedĀ  around 600 votes in this third unscientific blog poll on how readers perceive the front bench Ministers to be doing. The results are shown below in two ways.

Net Approval Ratings

This is the sum of those who said Very Good or Good less the sum of those who said Poor or Very Poor. The change from May 2009 ago is shown in brackets

  1. Judith Collins +51% (+14%)
  2. Chris Finlayson +47% (-5%)
  3. John Key +43% (-14%)
  4. Tony Ryall +43% (-4%)
  5. Simon Power +31% (-10%)
  6. Bill English +31% (-13%)
  7. Gerry Brownlee +12% (+6%)
  8. Anne Tolley +3% (-10%)
  9. Nick Smith -15% (-7%)

Collins and Brownlee have had their net approval improve from May. All others have dropped. Remember it is not necessarily the same people voting each time – this is not scientific. Nick’s rating I suspect partly reflects his holding of the climate change portfolio.

Overall six of the nine frontbench Ministers continue to have very strong approval ratings from readers.

Weighted Average

The other measure is a weighted average which takes account of if people said they were very good or just good etc. Basically it assigns a value of 100% for a VG, 75% for a G, 50% for an average, 25% for a P and 0% for a VP. The overall weighted averages are:

  1. Judith Collins 73% (+7%)
  2. Chris Finlayson 68% (-3%)
  3. John Key 68% (-8%)
  4. Tony Ryall 67% (-3%)
  5. Simon Power 61% (-5%)
  6. Bill English 60% (-6%)
  7. Gerry Brownlee 53% (+3%)
  8. Anne Tolley 49% (-4%)
  9. Nick Smith 43% (-1%)

Now again these are not scientific, and only reflect the particular preferences of Kiwiblog readers who participated.

I expect to do the fourth blog poll around November 2009.

Paula’s new car

igovt identity verification service

Computerworld reports:

A review of igovt services has given the programme new legs with development continuing for a further two years at least.

Minister of Internal Affairs Nathan Guy says the government has agreed that the roll-out will continue following a review and a decision to “explore options for commercial sector involvement”.

Some parts of the programme, such as the igovt logon service, have already been delivered.

The igovt identity verification service (IVS) will go into operation later this year. This gives people a secure way of verifying their identity over the internet to access a range of government services.

“The review of the business case for the two igovt services shows that the programme is still viable, and the benefits are significant,” Guy says.

“The benefits over the 10 years from July 2009 are estimated to be between $321 million to $727 million from an investment of $65 million for the logon service, and between $320 million and $646 million from an investment of $57 million for the identity verification service.

I think there is huge potential if one can securely identify yourself to the Government online. Different agencies are doing some good stuff already. IRD now allows me to access huge amount of my tax info online. Ideally I’d love to also access my criminal/police record online, my ACC history, my hospital history etc.

Open Source in the Public Sector

Computerworld reports:


The New Zealand Open Source Society is launching a project to demonstrate the viability of free open source software on public sector desktops.

The Public Sector Remix project aims to help public agencies reduce the cost of desktop computing. The project will deploy free open source software for nominated staff to use for common business tasks and evaluate the results.

A number of central, regional and local government agencies are working together to run trials using free software for common desktop tasks, the society says.

The project was initiated locally, society president Don Christie says. He was unable to elaborate on agencies currently running trials apart from saying there were 14 and naming one which had given permission to be cited: New Zealand Post.

I’m a big open source fan. Not in an anti-MS way. I use MS products at both home and work. But what I love about open source software is that it is so easy to find third party plugins, enhancements or versions of software which better fits what you want.

ā€œWhen we asked participants what people need, they told us that 90 percent of the people, 90 percent of the time, have pretty simple needs,” Christie, says. “Document management — word processing, spreadsheet, mail and calendar; a web browser to access their modern line-of-business applications; and access to legacy client– server applications.ā€

The scary thing is you can now do almost all of that just through Google!

Metiria Turei blogs on this issue also at Frog Blog.

Brave or Foolish?

Standby Student Fares

NZPA report:

Otago University students will soon be able to travel standby from Dunedin on Air New Zealand.

The Otago Daily Times reported the airline would next month introduce $39 standby fares for students.

Oh this brings back memories. When I was an Otago student, they also had very cheap standby fares for students. The problem was they were standby. I once spent two days and nights at Christchurch Airport, waiting for a standby fare to complete the journey home.

Oh the joys of being a poor student.

Top Ten things about being the Prime Minister of New Zealand

NZPA report:

Prime Minister John Key is going to sell New Zealand to the worldwide tourism market when he appears on a top US television show next month.

Mr Key is booked for the Late Show with David Letterman while he is in New York to speak at the United Nations.

He has a guest appearance on the show’s cheeky “Top Ten” slot.

“It’s an opportunity to promote New Zealand, it’s gold when it comes to New Zealand from a tourism point of view,” Mr Key said today.

“This is a show that millions of people watch worldwide, it really is a magnificent opportunity.”

I love Letterman so this will be good watching.

I’m not sure whether Key will get to write his own top ten, or if the Late Show writers will provide the script, but in case either of them are looking for inspiration feel free to leave your suggestions below for possible inclusion on the top ten list. I’m guessing the topic will be something like “Top Ten things about being the Prime Minister of New Zealand”.

Just two rules:

  1. This is for a US audience, so stuff about local issues won’t work
  2. They are meant to be funny

The archive of previous top tens is here.

More thoughts on Kennedy

A story in the Herald provides some food for thought:

Kennedy’s office, one of the best-staffed legislative engines on Capitol Hill, claims 2500 bills, 500 of which have been signed into law, over a 47-year Senate career.

Regardless of whether or not you agree with his policies, and also regardless of his shameful personal behaviour at times, there are few people in history who could claim to be responsible for 500 laws. That is more than most Presidents or PMs will achieve.

“Teddy was the only Democrat who could move their whole base,” Senator Orrin Hatch, another veteran Republican, said. “If he finally agreed, the whole base would come along even if they didn’t like it.”

Kennedy won countless battles by embodying an increasingly rare type of bipartisanship. It was perceived not as a threat to ideology or money-raising prowess but as a way of getting something done, however imperfect.

“Bipartisanship takes a person that has leadership and personal charm, quite frankly, and a desire to get a result,” said former Senate Republican Leader Trent Lott. “He didn’t try to destroy you. That’s what’s happening in Washington now. It’s gotten so mean.”

Over 47 years in the Senate, Kennedy evolved into an institution himself, equal parts liberal icon and effective dealmaker who combined those skills to forge agreement on some of the most sweeping and contentious social reforms of his time.

The praise from Republican lawmakers is significant I believe, and not just being nice to the man because he is dead.

Without Kennedy, the 99-member chamber lacks anyone playing precisely his role – to dole out the goodwill and procedural expertise necessary to make the Senate wheels spin through controversial legislation. …

No one is irreplaceable in the Senate, a popular saying goes. But Senator John McCain called Kennedy just that yesterday. McCain, last year’s Republican presidential nominee, was even clearer during the weekend.

“He had a way of sitting down with the parties at a table and making the right concessions, which really are the essence of successful negotiations,” McCain said.

I suspect part of why Kennedy could be so effective is that he was pretty much immune from attacks on his left. His liberal credentials were so established that he never had to worry about attacks from the “Daily Kos” faction of the Democrats, if he did a deal with the Republicans.

At large Councillors may be gone

Bernard Orsman reports:

The Government has dropped a controversial plan to have councillors elected at large on the Auckland Super City.

This follows widespread opposition to the proposal for eight at-large councillors and 12 ward councillors on the Super Auckland Council.

The Royal Commission actually proposed 10 at-large Councillors and only 10 ward councillors. The at large proposal is well motivated. The idea was that these Councillors would put the region ahead of their ward.

But I have blogged consistently against the at large since the Commission proposed them, and am glad they have been dropped. I don’t think you would have got sensible voting if Aucklanders were having to choose 8 or 10 at large Councillors for a possible pool of 40 to 50.

It is understood the Government is considering a halfway house with six urban wards, each with three councillors elected within the ward at large. There would also be two rural wards for Franklin and Rodney with one councillor each.

My preference would be for the wards to elect one Councillor each. This keeps the wards small, and increases the chance that you will know something about the Councillors you vote for, rather than just go off name recognition.

In fact ideally I would have the wards mirror the parliamentary districts.

Brian Rudman agrees with me that smaller wards is preferable to six multi-member wards. That’s almost enough to make me reconsider my position šŸ™‚

Rudman proposes STV be used to stop winner takes all in the wards. Now initially I think it is appropriate the elections be FPP as that is what almost all the fomer Auckland Councils used. The Local Electoral Act makes it a decision for local voters via referendum if they wish to move from FPP to STV or vice-versa.

My experience of STV in local body elections is that I think it works well for single vacancies. In other words it is good for voting for the Mayor as you usually know enough about the Mayoral candidates to sensibly rank them.

For multi-member vacancies like DHBs, it is a nightmare. Ranking 32 people in order is near impossible to do sensibly. If Auckland goes with single member wards, STV would work well. With multi-member wards, my concern is that too many candidates will stand to make ranking them a sensible exercise.

Over the top language

NZPA make it clear that amongst the insults Tau Henare used to describe Rodney Hide, he called him a cunt.

Now I am no prude, but that is shocking language for an MP to use, especially about another MP. And to say it in front of media on the record is incredibly bad judgement.

I like Tau. He a passionate guy who stands up for what he believes. And his ability to wind up New Zealand First last term was priceless. But his use of the cunt word is pretty inexcusable. Never mind it was about a Minister in the National-led Government.

It’s one thing for a non MP like Matthew Hooton to use the term to refer to Helen Clark’s former Foreign Minister, but Matthew isn’t an MP.

Now Busted Blonde at Roar Prawn reports that Tau has done humble pie on Facebook, which is appropriate.

Big Kiwi Give

Transport Spending

Steven Joyce has announced:

An $8.7 billion programme of investment in New Zealand’s transport system has been detailed today with the launch of the National Land Transport Programme (NLTP).

Transport Minister Steven Joyce says this is the largest ever investment in the system and represents a 17 percent increase from the previous three-year period.

That’s close to $3 billion a year which is not bad.

The $8.7 billion includes investment of:

  • $4.6 billion in the state highway network (up 19%)
  • $1.9 billion in local roads (up 14%)
  • $900 million in key urban public transport networks (up 21%).

As anyone sane knows, it is not a choice between public transport only or roads only. You need to invest in both.

The $900 million in public transport investment is in addition to the $1.85 billion in capital investment currently being made into the Auckland and Wellington commuter rail networks.

Ouch. Thanks Michael.

The third man

Walter Nash and Sydney Holland

A friend of mine has acquired this photo of Walter Nash and Sid Holland. Can anyone identify who the third man in the photo is?

Also if anyone knows where the photos was taken, and in what circumstances, that would be a bonus.

No mandatory folic acid in bread

No surprise, but the Government has confirmed there will be no mandatory addition of folic acid into bread – at least for the next three years.

Today, Food Safety Minister Kate Wilkinson said mandatory fortification of bread would be deferred until May 2012.

The Government and Bakers were now likely to focus on introducing a voluntary range of fortified breads.

The deferral was the “best way forward”, Ms Wilkinson said.

“I agree with public health advocates that folic acid is beneficial to the health of women and can prevent neural tube defects, but I also understand consumers overwhelmingly want to be able to choose whether or not the bread they buy is fortified.

“This approach will provide for consumer choice while also helping to address folate deficiency and increase the protection for babies resulting from unplanned pregnancies.”

Works for me.

Shipping Containers Cells

a53

I saw these in Hawaii and tried to persuade the local authorities they should send them to Judith Collins to become the new Auckland Prison.

The Dom Post reports:

Corrections Minister Judith Collins is tipped to announce today a rollout of shipping container cells to cope with a burgeoning prison population.

Corrections has been trialling four prototype cells at Rimutaka Prison and Mrs Collins has made it clear that she sees shipping containers as a low-cost solution to the prison muster crisis.

The containers cost $63,000 to convert, a fraction of the $643,000 cost per bed at the newly built Springhill Prison in Meremere, south of Auckland. Corrections say the containers can be built quickly, potentially using prison labour.

Well they certainly look secure to me. Maybe they can let prisoners choose their preferred colour.

I think stacking them vertically is worth considering also. Takes up less land, and probably much harder to escape from if you are 10 feet up. Especially if they greased the lower levels.

Phil’s Propaganda Pagani

The Dom Post reports:

Labour leader Phil Goff’s defeated choice for party general secretary has been parachuted into a top job in his parliamentary office.

John Pagani, a long-time adviser to Progressive leader Jim Anderton, will start work as one of four “directors” in Labour’s leadership team next week.

Mr Goff said he would be focusing on non-media communications. “John has skills that will be very useful for Labour in opposition and I am looking forward to having him in the office as communications director.”

Heh I always use to refer to the communications job as Director of Propaganda. They would never let me get business cards that said it though.

I suspect John’s role will go beyond communications, and he will have considerable input into both strategy and tactics. I expect to see Goff start to take a few more risks – some of which may pay off.

He will work with chief press secretary Gordon Jon Thompson, policy director Marcus Ganley and office director Murray Wansbrough.

Seeing I have profiled Pagani a bit, I should cover the other senior staffers. Policy Director Marcus Ganley is a lifetime Labour supporter. In his own words:

I have been a Labour support my whole life. I remember feeling devastated as a 6 year old when Bill Rowling’s Labour lost the 1981 election.

I wonder if his fellow six year olds were equally emotional about the 1981 election results?

Ganley worked for Michael Cullen up until the election and then was employed by Chen Palmer in December 2008. Not sure when he moved to Goff’s office. He has a strong background in political science and law – which is pretty sensible for a policy role.

Murray Wansbrough in 2004 worked for Infrastructure maintenance company, Transfield Services. It looks like he was private secretary to Goff as a Minister. Interestingly he was a leading figure in, and a Director of, the controversial Mike Moore Supporters Club in the early 1990s.

Gordon Jon Thompson was previously one of Helen Clark’s press secretaries. He also worked for David Parker before that.

He is a former Waikato Times and Dominion Post reporter and is the brother of Fairfax group executive editor Paul Thompson.

There doesn’t appear to be a chief of staff. This may prove to be a mistake. Having worked in an Opposition Leader’s Office with, and without, a Chief of Staff, my experience is that things work much better if there is one.

Spatial Data

Simon Hendry writes:

This week, directory company Yellow (formerly known as Yellow Pages before that brand become too low-tech to be associated with) said its new iPhone application, which makes good use of that particular device’s GPS capabilities, had become the most downloaded local Apple software tool just four days afterrelease.

The application lets users perform functions such as “local search” – using GPS to find details of, and directions to, the nearest business of a specified type.

Done well, this is a cute trick, particularly if you’re a visitor from out of town, in desperate need of a curry, perhaps, but without the first clue about where to find the local Indian restaurant.

I just hope they bring out a blackberry application soon.

The Yellow iPhone app’s popularity is a good example of how businesses and consumers are both eager to make the most of location-based services using spatial information combined with mobile data transmission.

Again – mobile phones and GPS technology is the new big thing.

But a new report commissioned by Land Information NZ, the Department of Conservation and the Ministry of Economic Development says we’re missing out on the full economic benefits of our own Government’s treasure trove of spatial information.

According to the report – Spatial information in the New Zealand economy – innovative use of spatial information added at least $1.2 billion to the economy last year through productivity gains, but that figure could have been $500 million higher if technology developers had better access to the Government’s various repositories of spatial data. …

The new report calls for the Government to develop a “national spatial data infrastructure” and Land Information Minister Maurice Williamson – himself a techie from way back – is at least making encouraging noises in agreement.

It’s now a matter, as Williamson puts it, of “knocking away the remaining barriers to more widespread adoption of spatial information”.

The minister seems prepared to do the knocking. Let’s just hope his Cabinet colleagues open the door.

Agree strongly.

At risk youth

The Herald reports:

The Government will fund 15,000 idle Auckland youngsters who could get up to mischief in the school holidays to go on one-week programmes this summer.

It will also fund up to 200 places for 10-day adventure camps that can be ordered by the Youth Court or a family group conference.

The plans are part of a suite of programmes announced by Prime Minister John Key yesterday in what he termed “a great mission” to ensure the potential of the next generation is released.

Chief Youth Court Judge Andrew Becroft was later effusive in his praise of the Prime Minister’s move. “It is a clear signal that the Government means business to work with at-risk young people across the board.”

Some programmes announced yesterday are aimed at children from deprived homes, some at minor offenders and some at serious youth offenders.

I suspect the Government doesn’t mind this Judge’s comments on Government policy šŸ™‚

Taxpayer funded unions

The Herald reports:

Corrections Minister Judith Collins has accused prison union bosses of “living a jet-set lifestyle” on the taxpayer after they received $127,000 in expenses from her department in one year.

I wonder how many other unions receive taxpayer funding. I know many Government Departments pay staff more if they join the PSA which is a form of indirect funding.

GST on Housing

Brian Fallow writes:

Here’s a suggestion for the tax working group set up to figure out how to put the tax system on a more durable and efficient footing to consider: scrap the provision exempting mortgage payments and rents from GST.

A brave suggestion.

But remember, any recommendations the working group comes up with are expected to be revenue-neutral, taken as a whole. And the broader the tax base the lower rates can be.

The question I then have is how much extra GST revenue would ending the housing exemption bring in, which would indicate howmuch tax rates in other areas could decrease.

More than 40 per cent of the income tax – much the biggest single source of Government revenue – comes from the top 10 per cent of taxpayers ranked by income, which is dangerous when labour is as mobile as it is and the income gap with Australia and most other developed countries is as large as it is.

It sure is. The top 9% pay 42% of income tax and the top 14% pay 53%.

What is so special about expenditure on housing that warrants exemption from a consumption tax? Other necessities like food, clothing and electricity attract GST.

A fair point.

According to Statistics New Zealand’s household economic survey the average household expends just over $10,000 a year on rents or mortgage payments (including principal).

With nearly 1.6 million households, at the current GST rate and ignoring any second round effects, that would yield about $2 billion a year. That is also about what an increase in the GST rate to 15 per cent would yield and is reportedly enough to fund, for example, a cut in the top income tax rate to 30c in the dollar – an avowed goal of the Government.

Oh I love it when a journalist actually does research and provides the info you need.

It would cost around $800 million to drop the 38c rate to 30c and around $280 million to drop the 33c rate to 30c so GST on housing would easily allow that it seems.

But that is not all. Applying GST to mortgage payments deals with one of the biggest distortions in the current tax system, the problem of “imputed rentals”. Avoiding the need to pay rent is a large part of the return on investing in the roof over your head. An untaxed capital gain is the rest.

My incentive was to stop paying rent. Any capital gain is a bonus.

Compared with a land tax or the McLeod review’s wealth tax, attacking housing through the GST system has the advantage of not relying on what someone from Quotable Value – however professional and incorruptible – estimates a property is worth. How much you pay a bank or landlord is cut-and-dried, not a matter of opinion.

I wonder why Fallow advocates GST on a mortgage only, and why not GST on the sale of a house? Maybe because most sellers are individuals and not GST registered?

The brutal reality is that if politicians set their face against a shift in the tax mix from direct to indirect taxation because they think the short-term distributional effects are too hard to deal with, then they are bequeathing to their successors a tax system that resembles an iceberg drifting slowly northwards. It will just not deliver the revenue required to provide the services people have come to expect from the state.

This is the killer paragraph and one the Government should remember.