Labour’s electoral finance submission

Labour have put online their 41 page submission on electoral finance laws. I have three general points to make on it, and then will go into lots of detail.

  1. They have backed away significantly from their position on the provisions of the Electoral Finance Act, and are not supporting limits on third party expenditure etc or having the regulated period last all year.
  2. Most of what they argue for is reasonably self serving – it is what is good for Labour. In my submission I have argued for many things which I doubt National would find desirable (such as banning anonymous donations over $100 and requiring parties to published audited accounts). So Labour’s submission should be regarded very much as an affected party. That does not mean their arguments have no value.
  3. They make many assertions without evidence or proof. An example if their call for state funding when the evidence of 2008 is that it is not needed as both National and Labour raised enough money privately to spend to the limit.

Now into details.

Election rules should not advantage one party over another, nor should they place inequitable barriers to the formation and entry of new parties into Parliament.

Labour claim this, but the actual details of their submission do not match this. Current parliamentary parties have a huge advantage over those not in Parliament yet Labour proposes they be given even more additional state resources and further that parties not in Parliament be banned from purchasing broadcasting time.

Voter registration is one barrier to participation. From 2002 voters have been able to register up till the day before an election, and this has been an important step in improving participation. However, given that voter registration is compulsory, it should also be available on election day itself provided the normal statutory criteria for residence are met.

Good God. Never before have I heard voter registration be called a barrier to participation. That is like calling school enrolment a barrier to eduction.

Recent New Zealand political history has seen a number of occasions where significant sums provided to political parties across the spectrum have raised questions about their purpose in relation to the purchase of influence.

Yes the most recent was the revelation by the Serious Fraud Office that certain racing interests had personally paids debts on behalf of the Racing Minister in Helen Clark’s Government. Labour slammed the SFO for revealing this, and Helen Clark said she would not read the SFO evidence as she had better things to do.

This gives you some idea of how genuinely concerned Labour is by corporate influence in politics.

To better ensure transparency, the threshold for declaration of donations should be reduced to $1000 for both constituency candidates and for political parties.

The argument outlined in the Issues Paper that lower thresholds would be an unjustifiable imposition on freedom of speech is weak and contrary to the principle of transparency. It confuses the right to say what you think with the right to buy policy outcomes without disclosing your interest.

This is an example of Labour failing to back up their assertions with a shred of evidence. What evidence do they have that the current $10,000 limit allows people to buy policy outcomes? Are they speaking from experience?

They need to justify why the disclosure level should be lowered from $10,000 to $1,000.  In other words why should someone not be able to privately donate $1,500? Do they seriously assert you can buy policies or MPs for say $1,500?

$1,000 represents around 0.05% of a major party’s total election year expenditure. Are Labour really saying funding 0.05% of annual expenditure gets influence?

I’m not saying that $10,000 is the perfect limit – but I want a rational reason why why donors who give less than that should sacrifice their privacy?

The current provisions on protected anonymous donations should remain.

This is very self serving of Labour. Having railed against big undisclosed donations, they now say they want to continue the regime where a major donor can give $36,000 to them anonymously through the Electoral Commission. I advocate there should be no anonymous donations (above a minor level such as $100) as it is near impossible to prove or disprove that the party doesn’t actually get to know who donated the money. The protected anonymous donations regime should bs scrapped.

So everyone should remember this – Labour’s official position is to allow for $240,000 of anonymous donations per political party. They are for anonymous donations – not against them.

Overseas donations should be banned completely (except for New Zealand citizens, residents or voters for the time being overseas).

I have no problems with donations from any legal source, so long as they are disclosed if significant. It is ironic that we will accept $127 million donation of art work from Julian Robertson, but claim it is corruption if he donates $1,100 to a party. People can care about New Zealand without being citizens.

But having said that, I’m not greatly fussed either way. However if one is to ban overseas donations – ban all of them – can anyone not on the electoral roll(and over 18) from donating.

There should there be a limit on donations from a single source of $100,000 over a three year period. This limit should be inflation adjusted every three years.

This is from the party that took $500,000 from Owen Glenn. Think that would be their position if he still liked them?

Again Labour fail to make a case for their preference. What is the harm done by someone openly donating $120,000 (say $40,000 a year) to their preferred party. Transparency is crucial, and these should be publicly disclosed so the public can decide on whether or not they have a problem with said donations. Trust the public I say.

If Greenpeace International wanted to donate $150,000 to the Green Party, I would say let them. We should all know about it – so we can decide what we think that means in terms of desirability of supporting the Greens.

Political parties should be required to provide annual audited accounts with itemised categories of donations income so that actual income can be compared with declared donations.

Now this one I agree on, and in fact am very pleased to see Labour advocating it. After the NZ First funding revelations I concluded some sort of audited accounts with donations grouped by size is desirable. I only want the names of those who donate more than $10,000 (as that is level influence may be a factor) but it would be useful to see how many donations between say $1,000 and $10,000 are received. This allows the public to decide if (for example) NZ First’s claims of being all funded by cake stalls was the reality or not.

In election year, donations received by a party after its last annual return to the Electoral Commission should be publicly declared through the Commission on a regular basis after they are received, and up to and during the regulated election period.

This is one issue I forgot to cover in my submission. I actually think donations should be declared monthly during the whole three yearly cycle, and weekly or daily during the last month – we should know about donations when they are made, and always in advance of an election.

So I agree with Labour here, but think they do not go far enough.

The Labour Party believes that the corollary of tightened controls on private funding of political parties – with the greater disclosure and compliance requirements involved – is some provision of public funds for political parties.

Again Labour have failed to prove there is a problem. The Electoral Finance Act brought in much tighter controls on donations, yet both Labour and National spent to the limit. Both were able to raise all the money they needed privately.

Labour want state funding on the basis, there *may* be a problem in the future with inadequate private funding. Not good enough. The 2008 election has shown that there was no shortage of private funding, and Labour’s attempt to gain (even greater) state funding is sheer opportunism.

Both the registered party and parliamentary party contribute to the formation of policy on which the voters base their choice. The accountability provisions in the Electoral Act also devolve to the registered extra-parliamentary party.

Public funding would contribute to the independence of the extra-parliamentary party by providing a balance and the avoidance of parliamentary capture.

This is hogwash. The opposite is the case. One of the few accountabilities that the main party has over the parliamentary party is that they raise the money. This is why parliamentary parties suffer consequences if they ignore their membership.

You bring in state funding, and it allows the parliamentary party to marginalise even further the organisational party.

In our view, a base level of public funding should be available to parties who meet the statutory criteria of 500 members and contesting seats in Parliament. Currently the only available form of public funding for such parties is provided through the Broadcasting Act 1989, which on its own is clearly insufficient.

Parties outside Parliament are massively disadvantaged. But giving Labour $800,000 a year and the Alliance $2,000 a year is not going to change that – in fact it will make it far worse.

My proposal to help parties outside Parliament, is that the broadcasting allocation be restricted to non parliamentary parties only. The parties in Parliament get three years of broadcasting exposure through the media for free.

Broadcast advertising is the primary means that wealth-based electoral systems use to influence opinion.

What decade are they in? How many people even watch TV ads now? Heard of My Sky. Broadcast advertising is no longer as dominant as it once was.

The limitation of broadcast advertising to allocated public funds is an excellent feature of New Zealand’s political system and should be retained.

Far from being excellent, it is a travesty. If a party registers late in the piece they are banned from broadcast advertising. The current rules not only give National and Labour more money for broadcast advertising – but they ban the other parties from being able to spend as much as them with their own money. This is not a level playing field – it is one that favours the two main parties massively.

It may be preferable for the cost of the time allocation to be added to the broadcasting allocation and the time allocation discontinued and replaced with funding that can be used to buy time as best suits the parties. This would allow for freer use by political parties of the resource for broadcast advertising.

Here I agree. But again the hypocrisy – they are saying a party should not be allowed to (for example) spent $50,000 less on billboards and $50,000 more on radio advertising but they are saying parties should have freer use of broadcast advertising. Inconsistent.

Political parties should not be able to purchase broadcasting time with their own resources. This will only serve to advantage parties with access to money.

Nonsense so long as you still have an overall spending limit. The current law gives National and Labour a bigger spending limit that all the other parties as they can’t purchase broadcasting time beyond the allocation. This is about protecting Labour’s statutory advantage.

It must be made clear in the Electoral Act that no spending authorised for parliamentary purposes by Parliamentary Service rules can be counted as election expenses under the Electoral Act.

And this is what they tried to do with the Electoral Finance Act. They want to have the pledge card not count as an election expense. They want to be able to spend say $1.5 million in the final week of the election on “parliamentary publications” and not have it count as an election expense.

I go the opposite direction. During the regulated period, there should be a ban on parliamentary funding of advertising except essential advertising such as office hours.

You see what I mean about how self serving Labour’s submission is. They want to keep their anonymous donations. They want more state funding. They want to stop competitors from buying broadcasting time and they want to be able to spend thir parliamentary budget as late as they like durign an election campaign and not have it count as an expense.

The current limits for constituency candidates ($20,000) and political parties (a maximum of $2.4 million, if all electorates are contested) should be retained but be inflation adjusted (from the 2008 limits as a base) before the 2011 election.

Again Labour make assertions with no emperical basis to them. Mr argument is that the spending limits should be set high enough to allow an affective communication with the public, yet below the level at which you may be seen as “drowning out” others.

$20,000 is totally inadequate for being able to communicate with 45,000 voters. It doesn’t even allow one direct mail letter.

The 1996 limits should at a minimum be adjusted for inflation and population growth. Ideally though, as I submitted, there should eb an attempt to actually calculate what is a reasonable or desirable amount of communication from candidates and parties, cost it and then set the limit high enough to allow that. Don’t guess at what the limit should be – calculate it.

The extension of the regulated period in the Electoral Finance Act to the beginning of the calendar year in which an election takes place added greatly to compliance requirements.

And whose idea was that? Credit I suppose for admitting it was a disaster.

Considering the pattern of the last 25 years, a reasonable fixed date for the start of the regulated period would be 1 May of election year.

I am not against a fixed start date but 1 May is far too early. You have not even had the budget by then. I like the proposal of 90 days before the term of Parliament expires – which will be a known date. If a fixed date I would never go earlier than 1 July.

Provision would need to be made for where a particularly early election was called. We suggest that in the case of an election date being announced earlier than 30 April, the regulated period begin the day after the announcement.

Yes, The regulated period should never be retrospective.

The atomistic redefinition in the Electoral Finance Act (section 5) of “any form of words or graphics, or both” proved problematic.

And we warned against it.

The true name and address of those who promote election advertising should be disclosed.

Yes, but this need not be on the advertisement. The Electoral Commission could have on its website contact details for political parties, candidates, and registered third parties.

Where the third party campaign is issue based and does not seek to promote a vote for or against a particular party or candidate, we do not propose any spending cap but do propose transparency above, say, $100,000 of spending.

This is a better position than the EFA. Transparency is key I agree.

However they seemed to have not covered what rules should apply to advertisements against a party or candidate? Are they sayign these should be banned?

I think everyone accepts you can’t advertise urging a vote for National without National’s permission. But what say you wish to advocate people do not vote for ACT? Are Labour saying this should be banned?

Consequently, parallel campaigners should be regulated if they propose to spend over a specified threshold, say $100,000. They should be required to register with the Electoral Commission, and a list of all such parallel campaigners should be made public, as should their donors.

As I said this is an improvement on the EFA.

The financial agent provisions from Electoral Finance Act should be
reinstated – accountability is only possible if responsibility is clearly
defined.

I tend to agree. But I also worry that parties often get off the hook by claiming x did this without y knowing, so hence no prosecution. This helped get Labour off the pledge card. I propose that parties themselves can also be held liable for breaches. So if they have crummy systems which leads too a breach, they get pinged.

Consideration should be given to reforming and amalgamating the electoral oversight agencies, and giving the oversight agency power to obtain further information about parties’ accounts. This is especially the case if additional state funding is made available to registered parties.

Amalgamation is well overdue.

The role of the Police should be retained for prosecution referrals.

No no no no no do. They don’t want the job. They don’t dedicate sufficient resource to it. They don’t have the expertise and in 2005 especially they made some appalling decisions.

Wow this is a long post. I am looking forward to the pubishing of the other submissions, or a summary of them.

Mount Vernon

On Monday I went to Mount Vernon. It is where George Washington lived for much of his life. Just as Ronald Reagan spent around 18th of his presidency at his ranch, Washington spent around 430 days of his presidency at Mount Vernon.

It is in Virgina, around 20 miles out of DC. Easy to get to though as you take the yellow Metro to the end of the line for $2.35 and then a bus to the estate for $1.35.

gw1

Washington, and his wife Martha, are entombed here. The flag on he right is Washington’s flag as Commander in Chief during the War of Independence.

gw2

Around 300 slaves worked at Mount Vernon and were buried there. Slaves did not get marked graves. Washington never took a position publicly on slavery as he thought it would divide the union (which it did) but he freed all his slaves upon his death – the only Founding Father to do so – and also wrote privately that he wished there to be a way forward to end slavery.

gw3

Washington was a farmer, and Mount Vernon was a large farm. Washington was often up at 5 am, and took a great interest in what crops were planted etc. After the War of Independence he went back to farming for close to a decade.

gw4

This is the interior of a typical slave cabin.

gw5

This is the original crypt where Washington was laid to rest. In his will he asked for a new one to be made, and he was transferred there around three decades later.

gw6

This is the view Washington got from his house. Makes you understand why he spent so much time there!

gw7

And this is the main house.

Definitely worth a visit if in DC. You can easily spend a day there as you have not just the house and grounds to explore, but also a museum.

I may do a longer post on Washington at some stage, but it is hard to describe how respected and revered he was. He was almost unique in carrying the trust of men from all the 13 states, regardless of their individual politics.

He wasn’t one of the legendary generals (he lost many battles) but he was a proven leader of men. He was made Commander in Chief of the Virginia militia at age 23. And while he lost many battles against the British, he had to forge an army that had never before existed – with no money, no uniforms, no established chain of command and little experience. And the British were amongst the best in the world.

One of his greatest acts may have been resigning as Commander in Chief at the conclusion of the war, and retiring to his farm.  Few Generals have done the same – which is what ended the Roman Republic. He also convinced a group of officers not to threaten Congress, even though they had not been paid. Washington himself was never paid a salary during his years of service.

His other great virture is that he genuinely did not covet power, and did see public office as a service. He set the vitally important precedent of a maximum two term presidency (broken only once) and had to be persuaded to even do a second term. He remains the only President to have been unanimously elected by the Electoral College – twice.

His farewell address as President in read into the Senate record annually. Various Senators take a turn at reading parts of it.

Various founding fathers playing important roles in the founding of the United States – Jefferson, Madison, Adams etc. Washington is unique in that is is quite arguable there never would have been a United States without him – no one else could bring national unity when it was most needed.

Loudon vs Trawick

Around a month ago Trevor Loudon blogged on Margaret Trawick. Trawick is a Professor of Social Anthropology at Massey University, teaching The Cultural Construction of Gender and Sexuality amongst other papers.

I didn’t see the original post, but did see a later post by Loudon where he responds to an e-mail from Trawick demanding he remove his post, and issue an apology to “all Tamil people, most of all to New Zealand Tamils, to Massey University, and to me.”

Trawick objected to Loudon quoting her comments on a Marxist feminist mailing list, being:

>
> Women and girls do 2/3 of the world’s work for 5% of the income.
> So when women stop everything stops.
>

…. and everyone starves. Don’t you think women know that? This is why we cannot go on strike. Be glad we don’t kill every one of you fuckers.

All we need to perpetuate the species is your sperm.

Funny that Marx didn’t think about this.

MT

It seems this is taken out of context according to Trawick.  Well the quote is online here, and people can read the context for themselves.

I did exactly that and started reading the other e-mails in the discussion. I then found this e-mail from Professor Trawick:

I cannot bring myself to hate any category of human beings so much that I would want to kill them all – despite what I said last night.

Isn’t this supposed to be a good thing?

Not sure about others, but that to me sounds like you hate men (as a category of human beings), just not quite enough to advocate their extermination.

Anyway, it is not guys’ fault that they are guys.

Not that it matters whether it is their fault or not.

After all, it was not the smallpox virus’s fault that it was the smallpox virus.

So men are like the smallpox virus?

But it got eradicated anyway – nothing personal.

The Holocaust was based on this idea. Better not go there.

Okay – we are clear on that – the Holocaust was a step too far – even a male only Holocaust.

But even lesbians do not as a rule advocate male infanticide – while female infanticide is practiced all over the place. And it is the mothers who do this, of course.

“Right-to-life” advocates say abortion is like the Holocaust. We disagree with them. But in a way they have a point. Selective female feticide happens in China and India. We think it is wrong. Too close to infanticide. But abortion is not wrong – as long as it is not gender selective.

But would selective male infanticide be wrong?

Well I tend to think so. Of course you are not advocating such, just asking the question of course.

And then another e-mail:

If female human beings have been exploited and misused by males since time began, if the most fundamental class division is between female and male human beings, and if females can get along fine without males, except for basic reproductive purposes, then why do not females simply eliminate males, cull them as male calves or goats or sheep are culled by farmers and sold for meat. Because if males are allowed to reach adolescence, they only make trouble from then on out.

They fight and kill one another by nature. Better to cull them before they reach this stage.

Cull is a much nicer word than exterminate.

Please understand that I could not advocate such a program. My only children are two sons, and I love them more than I love anyone or anything else in this world, and after them comes my love for my partner, who is male. I would die for the sake of any one of them if I had to, no
questions asked.

Yep. You personally do not advocate the genocide of males, as you can’t hate “any category of human being” so much. But you are not sure if selective mail infanticide is wrong.

Now these are all e-mails from a publicly archived mailing list. Personally I have little interest in the ramblings of a Massey Professor. But demanding Loudon removes his post and apologises for quoting them is what got my interest in these – as universities are meant to be bastions of free speech.

Please note I will be deleting abusive comments on this post. Make your point without name calling.

What the Police should have done

The Police Complaints Authority is investigating the adequacy of the Police investigation into the Don Brash e-mails. As far as one can tell from the released file, the Police did nothing beyond chatting to half a dozen people.

From what I can tell, there was no forensic examination of the evidence – something that should have been the first step taken by the Police. What do I mean by this – I mean an investigation of what actual documents Nicky Hager gained a copy of.

Hager helpfully supplied around 1,000 references in his 350 page book. The very first step of a semi-competent investigation would be to examine the documents referenced. Here is what I would have done:

  1. Compile a masterlist of every document referenced in Hager’s book
  2. Sort them into groups – e-mails, faxes, etc
  3. For the e-mails record down when each e-mail was received, and when it was deleted if it was. This will provide a window of time as to when the theft occured.
  4. Also for each e-mail record who has access to it. Who was cc’d or bcc’d it. Who had access to a printed copy.
  5. Look for common patterns in access, to try and narrow down which e-mail account or accounts were probably accessed
  6. Look at the date of the final document used in the book. It is likely the theft took place soon after that.
  7. Obtain staff lists for National during that period. Look especially at anyone who joined just before the thefts occurred.
  8. Obtain swipe card records for the Leader’s Office for the period just after the final documents cited.

I’m not saying this would work out who did it. I’m saying this is the minimum first steps you would expect in a competent investigation – work out what documents were stolen, work out who had access to them, work out whether they were in electronic form or also existed in hard copy, and work out when they were probably stolen. This is basic stuff.

By failing to do this the investigation was, in my opinion, doomed to fail, Asking half a dozen people whether or not they will tell them who gave them the e-mails was never going to find anything. A proper detailed forensic approach to the investigation could well have led somewhere, or even provided clarity as to whether the theft came about from a one off access to someone’s inbox, or whether it was more systematic than that.

I am going to be very interested in the report and findings of the Police Complaints Authority.

BNP Babes

Vice interviews some young female supporters of the British National Party. Some hilarious extracts showing their intellectual depths:

What if immigrants could prove their usefulness – shouldn’t they then be allowed to stay? For instance, if they began life here with a six-month period of forced labour? Perhaps spent making shoes for the rest of the population in a giant shoe factory in the East Midlands?
No. They shouldn’t come to Britain at all in the first place.

Can’t even tell when the piss is being taken.

Are most of your friends BNP?
Some of them are. I kind of got into it through my friend Danny. He’s really racist. Everyone calls him “Nazi Danny”. He started telling me about them, and it made a lot of sense.

Her friend is called Nazi Danny. Sigh.

What do you think the BNP could do to improve its appeal to minority voters?
A lot of people have got an opinion against the BNP that they’re racists or bullies. I don’t think the BNP are a mainstream party that everyone should follow. I think they believe what they believe. I think if we came across more to the people, because I’ve spoken to people before, and they’ve been like, “Well, what is the BNP?” and they couldn’t even say what BNP stood for. A lot of people don’t really know much about it unless you’re quite racist or quite nationalist. So if they could explain themselves to people more clearly, a lot more people would listen.

Such clarity.

What if immigrants only asked to be allowed into the country on condition they had been sterilised, so that they couldn’t create any children to further burden the state? Would that be a potential solution?
Um, yeah, I think so.

Oh I love it when people don’t even understand they are being mocked.

Labour’s gap

Tony Milne blogs:

I don’t expect to see much movement in Labour’s polling for at least another 12 months.  The question is, can Labour do enough in the next 28 months to increase its support by the 6% or so needed to form a coalition Government with other partners?  And will there be any partners?  That’s a topic for another post.

Here is Labour’s problem. If we take the last Roy Morgan poll,  then Nat/ACT has 54.5% and Lab/Gre 40.5%. I am assuming Anderton and Dunne retire.

Now let say Labour gains 6%, all at National’s expense. That has Nat/ACT at 48.5% and Lab/Gre at 46.5%. Assume Maori Party gets five seats (two overhang) and the seats are Nat/ACT 60, Lab/Gre 57 and Maori 5.

Now if Labour can not convince the Maori Party to support them, then 57 seats is not enough. They need 62.

So without the Maori Party a 6% improvement from 33% won’t get them there. They need a 10% improvement to 43% – a figure they have never achieved in an election under MMP.

It as you work this out, you realise the importance of what Duncan Garner blogged about Labour’s tactics working against their own interest.

Dom Post on school assessment

The Dom Post editorial:

Education Minister Anne Tolley should stick to her guns.

Parents are entitled to know how their children are doing at primary school and, if unimpressed, should be able to march them off to a school that is performing better, taking the state funding attached to him or her with them.

Hear hear.

Regrettably, this Government is not brave enough to go that far. But it should not resile from implementing its “national standards” policy in the teeth of opposition from principals and unionised teachers or buckle to their wish to have such information kept secret. …

What is it exactly that teachers and principals so fear? What is wrong with sharing with taxpayers those who pay to keep state schools operating just which schools do well and which do not? Is it that teachers’ methods might be scrutinised if their pupils are not keeping up with their countrywide cohort? Are they afraid that pay rises might not be forthcoming if it turns out that the youngsters in their class are falling behind?

A fear of accountability I say.

If so, principals and the NZEI would profit from looking across the Tasman to Labor-ruled New South Wales, where a similar row has erupted. There, the Greens and the Coalition equivalent to our National Party have joined forces in the NSW Senate to make it illegal to compile league tables backed by fines of up to $55,000 for organisations such as newspapers from statistics publicly available on a federal website. Labor’s deputy prime minister, Julia Gillard, has ridiculed the NSW ban.

While Labour in NZ wants to make school assessment data more secret than the SIS.

Very smart appointment

The Herald reports:

The agency designing Auckland’s Super City has hired trade union leader Laila Harre to help it merge 6800 employees of the eight councils into one.

Ms Harre has resigned as national secretary of the Distribution Workers Union to take on a human resources and change management role with the agency, which has to forge the new Auckland Council by October 2010.

What a very smart move by the Transition Agency. One of the most delicate issues will be the merging of jobs, potential job losses, and also possible change in the location of where people work etc. Laila is likely to minimise any chance that this is done in a way which is unfair, or perceived by most people as unfair.

First hand account of Great Barrier Island plane propellor loss

The Herald reports:

Passengers on a Great Barrier Airlines flight watched in horror as a propeller came off in mid-air, smashing a window on their aircraft and ripping a door off.

“It was like an explosion going off inside the plane,” one told the Herald yesterday.

“The propeller came off and hit the side of the plane …

“Both propeller blades came off – the whole thing just destroyed itself. It just completely self-destructed.

“A door got ripped off and the side of the plane got smashed in – we all got covered in glass.

“There was a huge amount of debris that we were just covered in. There were chunks the size of golfballs that came back and hit you.”

I can imagine. The planes are tiny. No centre aisle. The roof is just above your head when seated – even for me. To have something hit the plane and rip a door off would be far more terrifying than on a larger plane.

I actually met the owner of the airline a few weeks ago – at the Great Barrier Island Black Tie Ball. I remember him telling me how they have never had a crash – a good achievement. This incident however, while not a crash, if disturbing. The internal and TAIC reports will be of great interest. Hopefully they will be public before I next travel there, and have to decide my mode of transport!

Garner on National and Maori Party

Duncan Garner blogs:

So the Maori Party offer Key the seats he needs to get over the line. Without Sharples and co, Key could struggle to get a second term.

He wants a second term – he doesn’t want the t-shirt saying: ‘I was a one term PM.’ And he’s being helped by Labour and particularly tough old Trevor Mallard. Mallard appears to be alienating the Maori Party MPs as each day passes.

I couldn’t help but witness the tension between Mallard and Hone Harawira and Te Ururoa Flavell in Parliament this week. The more Trevor needles them about their relationship with the Nats, the longer the marriage will last.

If Labour wants a shot in 2011, I suggest Goff grab Trevor by the neck and give him a smack in the chops – if he won’t then at least get Tau Henare to throw in the peoples elbow.

Mallard is seriously affecting Labour’s future chances of having any decent relationship with the Maori Party. One Maori Party MP this told me this week, “Trevor can get f….. and so can Labour in 2011.”

Assuming Anderton retires in 2011, this leaves Labour with only the Greens. Labour have an opportunity to have a better relationship with the Maori Party now that the author of “haters and wreckers” and “last cab off the rank” has been exiled overseas.  But to date they seem to be doing their best to push the Maori Party towards National – and that may be a decision they bitterly regret.

Hat Tip: Blaise Drinkwater

2degrees

BERL responds

I’m pleased to see that BERL have responded to some of the criticism of their report concluding the cost of alcohol abuse in NZ was close to $5 billion a year.

Treasury have apologised to BERL for some of their comments, on the basis that BERL were not asked to do a full cost/benefit study. In that regards, it is fair enough that BERL not be criticised for working to their brief.

However as someone interested in public policy, there are real questions abotu why Government agencies both commissioned something that was not a full cost benefit study and further why it was promoted by such.  The research was being treated as gospel, and we now know it was research only looking at costs without benefits.

BERL have said Crampton and Burgess made some mistakes in their analysis, and Crampton has blogged that yes there were two mistakes. However they only add $36 million onto the costs. And as it happens they had also missed out the portion of excise tax collected by Customs which increases external benefits by $197 million. This means that their original figure of a net cost of $146 million is now a net benefit of 38 million. That is close enough to zero – in other words the current excise taxes cover the external costs of alcohol, and there is no case for increasing them.

I hope suitable scrutiny will be directed towards other research reports which do not look at both benefits and costs, and get used by lobby groups and government agencies incorrectly.

Roger Kerr makes some good points in a recent column:

Liquor is in many ways not special. Hundreds of products – matches, detergents, electricity, pharmaceuticals, motor vehicles and firearms, for example – cause problems if misused.

Nevertheless, there are external social costs, such as drink driving, which give rise to legitimate concerns.

The challenge for policy is to target these problems with effective interventions (and enforcement of existing laws), not to penalise with regulations or taxes the vast majority of responsible drinkers.

As one commentator has noted, “Raising taxes on alcohol to prevent problem drinking is akin to raising the price of gasoline to prevent people from speeding.”

Absolutely. Too often the Government goes for the easy approach which pubishes everyone equally, rather than target those causing the problem.

The Law Commission needs to engage with this analysis and follow the Generic Tax Policy Process for any recommendations on tax.

Similarly, it should follow the required Regulatory Impact Statement process for any recommendations on regulations in its forthcoming discussion paper.

That process requires a demonstration that the benefits of any recommendations or regulations exceed the costs. Competent analysis requires benefits and costs to be quantified, not just asserted, otherwise serious public policy errors could be made.

It is highly unlikely that proposals to restrict liquor outlets, for example, would meet a cost-benefit test.

I agree. They won’t stop problem drinkers getting alcohol but will make it harder for most people to buy alcohol conveniently.

Instead, the Law Commission should focus on ways of internalising the external costs of alcohol abuse.

For example, why should those who injure themselves in an alcohol-fuelled assaults or burglaries enjoy generous ACC benefits? Many foreigners would regard such treatment as ludicrous. Will Sir Geoffrey Palmer, one of the ‘fathers’ of ACC, be open-minded enough to look at such an obvious remedy?

Similarly, if we are willing to confiscate the vehicles of boy racers, why should we not confiscate the vehicles of serial drink drivers?

Target the offenders, don’t try and social engineer the entire population.

Blog Bits

  1. MacDoctor laughs at Jetstar blaming their bad press on Air New Zealand. I agree with MacDoctor that the wounds seem to be all self inflicted. Their attitude seems to have been the opposite of Ansett when they first started in NZ – which was to go overboard to make customers feel valued.
  2. Matthew Flannagan examines the claims that the Bible teaches that a rape victim has to marry her rapist, and does a very good rebuttal of the claim.
  3. Gonzo blogs that the first series of Mr Gormsby is now available at NZ on Screen. Great.
  4. Whale Oil blogs that Pearl Going has tried to involve the Police with regards to her claims of defamatory statements on websites about her. If correct, this is disturbing behaviour. One should not be using the Police to try and silence criticism of you. If the criticism is false there are civil remedies available.

What should be NZ’s 2020 emissions target

The Government is consulting on what should be New Zealand’s 2020 target for reduction in greenhouse gas emissions.

I know some think there should not be any reduction, as the science is doubted. But the reality is there will be a target, unless we want to risk losing trade access. And in case you think this is unlikely, I quote Colin James today:

Mr Key demurred. He asked the Feds if keeping agriculture out of the ETS would actually serve farmers’ interests. What if New Zealand got a poor reputation abroad on climate change and consumers, retail chains and governments put up barriers to New Zealand products?

(He had a point. The ETS bill which passed the United States House of Representatives on June 26 included provision for tariffs on imports from countries deemed backsliders on climate change.)

This is pretty significant. The US legislation includes such protectionist measures, and I have little doubt Europe will. NZ is far too small to survive if our trade access is blocked.

So what is a reasonable target for 2020? 1990 is the base year everyone measures against. Our Kyoto target was to keep emissions at 1990 level. They actually grew 22% to 2007, but were mainly offset by increased forestry plantings. And out 2050 target is a 50% reduction by 2050.

On a purely linear calculation, based on an ETS taking effect from 2010, the annual reduction needed is from 122% – 50%/40 years = 72%/40 years = 1.8% a year. Hence emissions in 2020 on a linear basis would be 18% less than the 122% we are at, or 104%. In other words if we manage to reduce emissions to 1990 labels by 2020, we would be on track (on a linear basis) to have a 50% reduction by 2050.

Aiming to return to 1990 levels is what Obama is aiming for by 2020. Canada is aiming for 3% below 1990 and Australia 4% below 1990 (unless there is a major international agreement in which case more). The EU is going for a 20% reduction.

The Greens are calling for a reduction of at least 30% by 2020. This is sheer madness. With agriculture making up half our emissions – the only way we’d reduce by that amount in just over a decade is by a huge reduction in agricultural output. You think the current recession is bad – just wait until the Green recession. They are basically saying we go from 122% to 70% or less in just ten years.

Personally I think we should go close to Australia. Say a unilateral reduction of 5%, but greater reductions if there is an international agreement and even greater if China, India and Brazil agree to limit emissions. Those three countries are now responsible for close to 30% of global emissions (the EU is only 13% and US 18%) and since 1990 have had emissions growth respectively of 121%, 80% and 55%.

One swallow does not make a summer

A number of people are getting all excited over Winston Peters appearing on Q&A and what this may mean for 2011. The saying “One swallow does not make a summer” comes to mind.

There is a huge difference between going on a TV show, and trying to get a party that has been booted out of Parliament back in – something never done in NZ. You have to find candidates, money, staff etc and that is hard work, and Winston has never been one for hard work.

Peters will be 66 in 2011 and his party has dropped away to 1% in the latest Roy Morgan poll. While I have no doubt Peters, with a good campaign, can lift it from 1%, that 5% threshold is a tough one to make. It means Peters has to find 100,000 more people to vote for him than the 25,000 who currently support him.

In a way I would like him to stand. That way we can all get to ask him about the $158,000 not repaid to the taxpayer.

Unnerving

As someone who has flown to and from Great Barrier Island around eight times in the last year, I was unnerved to read this Dom Post article:

A commuter airliner was forced to turn back after a propeller blade spun off the engine, sending aluminium shards into the cabin.

The three-engine Britten-Norman Trilander, with 11 passengers and pilot Sean Deeney, had just taken off from Claris Airport on Great Barrier Island on Sunday afternoon, bound for Auckland.

The blade struck the fuselage, then fell out of the fuselage and to the ground.

Regardless of how many propellers a plane has, I don’t like planes that lose any of them.

Mr Deeney shut the engine down and returned to Claris immediately. He told Mr Maguire it was a “normal approach and landing” on two of the three engines and the plane taxied back to the terminal.

Mr Maguire said the passengers had been concerned. “Any time you are in flight and something goes wrong there is reason to be concerned,” he said.

“The passengers were a little bit alarmed but were grateful to the pilot. He did an exceptional job getting the plane on to the ground. Everybody shook his hand and told him what an exceptional job he did.”

I’ve always flown Great Barrier Airlines and the pilots are good. However I will be very interested in the outcome of the official TIAC investigation.

Tazer preventing harm

I really can’t understand the lobbyists against the tasers. There is a very good chance Steven Wallace would be alive today if we had tasers back then, And today’s Herald reports on how the threat of one being used ended a stand off peacefully:

A shirtless fugitive who kept police at bay with tree branches and the occasional haka for nearly three hours threw his arms in the air when an officer threatened him with a Taser.

Police had ruled out using dogs or pepper spray to catch the 36-year-old, who had dragged an officer with his car before crashing into a tree in the Hamilton suburb of Pukete.

In the US, he would probably be dead by now if you have injured a police officer and not surrendered.

The CIB officer had been questioning the man after a complaint from a female jogger that she had been followed. …

The man took off his shirt on the river bank to reveal “Tuhoe” tattooed across his chest. He then waded knee-deep into the water before scrambling back to the river’s edge.

He gestured to a crowd of about 50 on the other side of the river, beat nearby bushes with tree branches and performed an impromptu haka as police tried to get him to give himself up.

I’m beginning to regret they did not use the taser.

Ms Henrikson said the officer with the Taser was introduced to the fugitive, who was told he had the device and was ready to use it.

“Its capabilities were explained,” she said. “This was enough to make the offender completely compliant.”

Funny how the threat of 50,000 volts means you won’t resist arrest.

Boston

Had a day in Boston before returning to DC. A lovely city and I ran out of time to see everything I wanted to. I got invited to a party by a couple of MIT students I met on Martha’s Vineyard so saw a bit of MIT but did not have time to see Harvard.

boston1

This is part of Boston Common – a very nice park in the middle of North Boston. They have lots of memorials up to those killed in the Civil War, the Boston Massacre, the War of Independence etc.

boston2

This is the Bull and Finch Pub whose outside was shown on every episode of Cheers. The interior does not resemble Cheers as that was filmed in a studio. However another Cheers bar has been established in Boston which was designed to look like the studio bar.

The cast of Cheers watched the series finale from this bar.

boston3

A state of Paul Revere on his horse. Revere is famous for his midnight ride starting 18 April 1775 to warn John Hancock and Samuel Adams that the British Army was on the move.

His ride was not famous during his life, but became so after Henry Wadsworth Longfellow made a poem of it in 1861.

boston4

This is the USS Constitution – one of the first three warships of the United States Navy – and still in service today!

She was built in 1797 and saw active duty until 1881. In 1907 she was designated a museum ship and is used to promote understanding of the Navy’s role. She sailed under her own power in 1997 for her 200th birthday.

The Constitution is captained by a Commander, and has 60 crew – all serving Navy personnel.

Eric the murdering economist

I have previously covered the damning critique done my Eric Cramption and Matt Burgess of the BERL study which found the cost of alcohol consumption was around $5 billion a year. Crampton and Burgess cited multiple errors in the BERL study (including no counting of benefits) and concluded it was actualyl less than 5% of that.

NBR reported last week a response (finally) from BERL:

Adrian Slack says Berl was only commissioned by the Ministry of Health and ACC to look at the social costs and not the benefits of alcohol, and would have needed an additional $135,000 were it to extend its remit to examining the benefits and policy implications. …

A pity that it was not made clear at the time it was costs only. I wonder why the Government would see value in commissioning a paper that looks at costs without benefits. Anyway onto the next comment my Mr Slack:

He accused Dr Crampton & Mr Burgess’s critique as being based on strong assumptions about perfect markets, perfect information, and individual rationality.

“So for example someone who murders someone, from the individual’s point of view, Eric would be, I presume, quite comfortable with that. The person who decides to murder someone else makes an evaluation of what are the benefits and costs to me of this action? Society says ‘well some people do murder other people’, but society says ‘that’s not good.’”

Now that was not a type. He just said that Eric Crampton would be comfortable with someone murdering someone (from an economic perspective). This is BERL’s response instead of a detailed point by point response to the 30 to 40 errors cited in the report?

Paul Walker responds with disbelief – not just from the sillyness of the analogy, but the repeating of economic mistakes:

If the only costs of murder were the internal cost to the murderer then we may not be too concerned with murder. BUT, there are some obvious, to most people if not Adrian Slack, external costs to murder, that is, the loss of life of the victim. The victim is the victim because they have not willingly agreed to be murdered, that is what makes murder, … well … murder.

I have no doubt that both Eric and Matt are opposed to murder, and for the very good reason that it violates the victim’s property right in themselves. Murder is not a market transaction in the sense that it is not a voluntarily agreed to trade resulting in both parties being made better-off.

One of the major points that Matt and Eric made about the BERL report is that BERL didn’t seem to know the difference between internal and external costs. The Slack quote above only reinforces that point.

Indeed an own goal. Eric Crampton also responds:

Economists tend to think that murder is a bad thing. Why? Well, despite the murderer presumably enjoying the act, his gain comes at a cost that he doesn’t personally bear: the death of his victim. That’s the kind of cost that economists tend to call an externality. And so economists tend to support laws against murder. We similarly tend to support laws against theft: while the thief tends to think taking other folks’ stuff is a good idea, the thief’s victims tend to be hurt by it and the thief won’t weigh those folks’ losses against his gains. In these kinds of cases, individuals’ rational calculation of their own costs and benefits lead to socially bad outcomes because of the substantial external costs.

Eric goes on to say that having BERL paint him as pro-murder (economically) is gettign close to a version of Godwin’s Law where you should concede defeat if that is the best you can do.

Blaise Drinkwater also comments on the costs vs benefits issue:

But just because I buy that the BERL report is a costs curvey only, I’m not obligated to buy the report, which bungled the costs badly. Remember, the BERL report said that alcohol costs New Zealand’s society the equivalent of $4,794m, using an “international framework” that seems to have as its main justification the academic equivalent of a circle-jerk. Burgess and Crampton, employing more mundane economics, came up with a figure of $662m. BERL is yet to explain satisfactorily why their headline figure seems to out by a factor of seven.

That is what I am most interested in. I do hope BERL does a more robust and detailed response than they have to date, so people can then judge with confidence which figure is most useful.

Payne ordered to pay costs to National

I previously reported on the attempt by Roger Payne to overturn the result of the Selwyn election via electoral petition. He lost on every issue.

Payne has cost the party, and various individuals, a huge amount of money. In his earlier case regarding the Selwyn selection he was ordered to pay costs of around $10,000.

The High Court has now determined costs for the electoral petition. I quote their decision:

The major issue in the case was the proper interpretation of s 71 of the Electoral Act 1993. This issue had already been determined against Mr Payne by Panckhurst J. Mr Payne failed to persuade us to any different course. In addition, Mr Payne failed to establish that he had standing to bring the petition; we found that his challenge to the National Party’s selection process fell outside the ambit of the Electoral Act; we found that there was no breach of any duty of natural justice in relation to the disapproval of Mr Payne’s application to be the National Party candidate in the Selwyn Electorate; and that there were no other grounds for invalidating the election of the first respondent.

This Court has power to award costs under s 250(1) Electoral Act 1993 and under the High Court Rules. In Re Taupö Election Petition [1982] 2 NZLR 244 at 266, the Court held that costs should, in the usual way, follow the event. We see no reason not to follow that course in the present case. There were elements of public interest in this case but, in the main, Mr Payne was pursuing an agenda of his own and for his own benefit.

We therefore order the applicant to pay to the respondents the sum of $23,520 plus disbursements as fixed by the Registrar.

And after National gets the cheque, hopefully that will be the last of Mr Payne.

Rewarding safe workplaces

The Dom Post reports on how unions are against ACC rewarding employers with safe workplaces:

The Government is set to reintroduce lower ACC levies for firms with the best safety records, a move unions claim will see bosses cover up accidents.

Sigh – the paranoia is rampant. Do they actually have any proven examples of this happening from last time? Failing to register workplace accidents is basically a criminal offence. So unions are saying we should not reward safer workplaces because they think so many employers are criminals who will cover up accidents. Really – at times they are just dinosaurs.

ACC Minister Nick Smith said he wanted an upcoming review of the corporation to consider bringing back “experience rating” of the 1990s, which saw employers pay levies according to the number of accidents in their workplace.

It’s called a carrot. The left want only a stick – prosecutions after the fact if an accident happens. I would much prefer getting the incentives right before an accident by having some carrot.

Student Loans for Over 65s

The Dom Post reports:

Scrapping financial help for students aged 65 and over would put retraining out of reach for many older workers, senior citizens say.

Education Minister Anne Tolley said last week she had asked for advice about scrapping student loans and allowances for senior citizens.

Ms Tolley said although she supported lifetime learning, “in tough economic times we do have to carefully consider how and where our investment in education is best placed.”

About 150 people over 65 got a student allowance in the first three months of this year and 655 received a student loan.

Grey Power national president Les Howard said cutting funding for older students was discriminatory and ignored the increasing number of people choosing to work past retirement age.

The reality is that if you take out a student loan at age 65, you will probably never pay it back, and it is ridicolous to think that in these tight economic times the priority should be totally free tertiary education for people who have mainly retired from the workforce. The state subsidises tertiary education partly because a more educated workforce has an economic return to it.

The latest student loans annual report has the percentage of borrowers aged over 50 having increased from 0.4% in 1992 to 4.3% in 2007.

The former President of Grey Power was not as greedy as his sucessor – he agreed it was perverse:

“I struggle with the concept that money will be lent to people who are not working and can’t pay it back,” said Grey Power national president Graham Stairmand.

And Dr Cullen also said it was an issue:

Tertiary Education Minister Michael Cullen told the Herald he was aware of the issue and was looking into it.

He told National MP Pansy Wong in Parliament last week: “One of the slightly stranger features of the student loan scheme is that once one reaches a certain age, in effect one does not have to pay the loan back.”

If someone over 65 wants to do tertiary study then good on them. The taxpayer is still going to subsidise 70% or so of the cost of their course – which is bloody generous. But by giving them a student loan they will never repay, we are effectively increasing that subsidy to 100%. If you are over 65 and want to study you should pay for the course fees yourself – not borrow off the next generation of taxpayers. I hope the Government does change eligibility.

The Zespri Monopoly

The Herald editorial:

Zespri is the country’s last remaining produce export monopoly. The kiwifruit industry has operated a single-desk system since 1987, first under the Kiwifruit Marketing Board and for the past decade through Zespri. Those 10 years have been an undoubted success story, with impressive increases in volume and export value. Not profitable enough, however, according to Turners & Growers, which says it is time to allow competition “to release the potential of the kiwifruit industry”. …

Significantly, however, Fonterra does not have the status of a monopoly. It has to withstand competition that would increase if dairy farmers lost faith in its management or corporate strategy. Zespri should be no different. It is fundamentally wrong to prevent the likes of Turners & Growers striking out on their own in export markets if they are disenchanted with the present selling arrangements. Any grower that believes Zespri is inefficient or too cumbersome to react quickly to changing market conditions should be able to try to do better.

The Government surely recognises this. It also knows the history of producer boards, why they were deregulated, and that Zespri is the last of the line. Yet it seems content to take the course of least resistance. Agriculture Minister David Carter says the stripping of Zespri’s monopoly status is not on the Government’s agenda. It would be guided by what most growers wanted.

Mr Carter knows the answer to that, but that answer smacks of self-interest, not principle. Additionally, protectionism like this sits oddly with New Zealand’s championing of free trade. Turners & Growers and other growers confident of the quality and pricing of their produce should have the right to compete in export markets. If Zespri is on top of its game, it will be equal to this.

I have to say I agree with the editorial. Just because 80% of growers want a monopoly, is not sufficient reason to stop the other 20% from following their own path.