Strikingly beautiful

The Herald reports:

Mr Goff said yesterday that the woman was strikingly beautiful.

How helpful of Mr Goff. That will help protect her anonymity and not create more speculation.

Is he now trying to make this sound even more lurid?

Anyone got any idea why Goff thought it was a good idea to share his opinion of her attractiveness with the media?

Was it the Mayor?

Armstrong on Worth

John Armstrong writes:

Where to now for Richard Worth? The MP may yet face criminal charges in a court of law. He will as likely not.

There may be more information to come out, but I tend to agree with John that what is known at this stage does not indicate a criminal offence.

Regardless, there can now be little question about the verdict of the court of public opinion. And that verdict is driving the politics towards one inevitable conclusion – that Worth at least be suspended, if not expelled from the National caucus in reasonably short order.

The publicising of separate and detailed accounts from two women of alleged sexual misconduct on his part have tipped the political scales to the point where National MPs have little option but to eject him.

If he does not resign, it seems inevitable – unless Worth can make a case that he has behaved appropriately.

Putting as much distance between National and Worth is now the Beehive’s priority. However, the two weeks’ grace offered to Worth also gives Key some breathing space – as does the fact that Parliament is not sitting next week. That means no question time for Labour to try and score points over Key’s handling of the whole sorry episode.

It needs to be resolved by Caucus next Tuesday.

Editing Wikipedia

The Dom Post reports:

A worker in an MP’s office has been banned from Wikipedia the volunteer web encyclopedia for trying to censor information about his boss.

The website’s entry for Peseta Sam Lotu-Iiga, National MP for Maungakiekie, was repeatedly tampered with on Thursday morning.

Wikipedia users identified the computer as being from Parliament by its IP address and banned the user for a week for the “conflict of interest” and lack of explanation for the changes.

Mr Lotu-Iiga yesterday denied editing the entry himself, saying a member of his staff had done it. But he defended the changes, which related to his dual role as an MP and Auckland city councillor. …

Mr Lotu-Iiga said he had not read the page until contacted by The Dominion Post yesterday, but downplayed it as “not a biggie for me”.

“I have guys in my office who look after PR and where I am in the media, and one of them noticed that someone was tampering with it.”

After reading the piece, he said some of it was inaccurate because he regularly attended council meetings. “I’m happy to take some criticism, but I think the wording is a bit strong. Somebody from my office thought it was appropriate to take it down.”

Okay it looks like some staffers need a tutorial on how to edit Wikipedia. Here are my guidelines for editing a political page:

  1. Use the discuss page for that page you wish to edit. State why you want to make the change.
  2. So for example in this instance, the staffer should have said “I propose to delete the sentence that criticises the Council attendance record as the Herald has reported it is 86%, and higher than many others”
  3. Then if after a couple of days if no one has objected,make the edit, and refer to the discussion page in your one line summary of the edit
  4. If people do object to deleting the reference, then negotiate on the discuss page a compromise that people can live with – such as maintain the criticism, but also include the rebuttal.
  5. You don’t have to, but personally I would always identify yourself making the edit,so no-one can suggest you are being underhand
  6. If you make an edit, and someone reverses it, don’t just make it again. Find out why someone is reversing it, and discuss it with them. Do not get into an edit war.
  7. Always remember Wikipedia is meant to be a neutral point of view.

If you follow the above advice, you will avoid getting banned, and avoid embarrassing your boss.

A previous accusation by Worth accuser

The Herald reports:

A prominent member of the Korean community says he was once wrongly accused of inappropriate behaviour by the Korean complainant in the Richard Worth police investigation.

The man told the Weekend Herald the woman’s accusations, made in a Korean newspaper several years ago, were unfounded.

The man, who cannot be named because it would identify the complainant, said he was accused of having an inappropriate or dishonest relationship with the woman.

He said the article distressed his wife and children and he considered legal action but it was too expensive. “If it [the accusation] was true, why did she not go to police and court – why a newspaper?”

I’m not sure this affects the political problems for Worth, but it may well be a factor in whether the Police believe there was criminal offending.

Fran O’Sullivan makes this point:

But even if the police do not lay criminal charges – an outcome Key was hinting at – the allegations that Worth has been leveraging his official position to extract favours cannot simply be swept under the carpet.

This is not a matter of morality. Many marriages break up in Parliament and MPs stray from their partners and find new spouses.

But what doesn’t go with the territory are the allegations – made under Parliamentary privilege – that Worth also tried to extract sexual favours from an Indian woman for government-appointed positions.

The similiarity in both cases is that the role as an MP and Minister has been used to gain a conquest. Now again these are just allegations – and we are yet to hear from Dr Worth.

The supressed evidence

The Herald reveals evidence that was supressed. Would it have made a difference if made known to the jury? Who knows?

David Bain told a school friend that he could rape a woman and use his paper round as a false alibi, according to secret evidence that was suppressed during his murder trial.

The jury in the 12-week trial never heard the witness statements of the former Bayfield High School students, as the Court of Appeal ruled that the Crown evidence was too prejudicial against Mr Bain.

Now that Mr Bain has been found not guilty of murder, the Herald can reveal the evidence of Mark Buckley and Gareth Taylor, who say Mr Bain planned a rape of a female jogger while at high school. …

The pair told police Mr Bain had a sexual interest in the young woman and told Mr Buckley in 1990 that he could use his paper round to “get away” with the proposed crime. …

“Mr Buckley’s evidence is that the appellant proposed to free up time for this offending by arriving at the usual times at houses where he would normally see the residents (thus suggesting a normal delivery round) but delivering papers at other houses much earlier than usual,” said the Court of Appeal judgment.

Another Herald story covers the reasons for the acquital.

Trotter on Worth

Chris Trotter pulls no punches, but people may be surprised at his targets:

WHAT IS IT with left-wing women? Why does it take a Cactus Kate to spell out the bleeding-bloody-obvious about Phil Goff’s damsel-in-distress? And, where’s the advantage, when it comes to living a fulfilling, exciting and, yes, occasionally risky life, of behaving like a permanently helpless victim?

So Dr Richard Worth hits on women. So what? It’s a thing men do. Some with genuine style and
panache, others with all the finesse of a slobbering dog. Women worthy of the name take the stylish ones to bed, and tell the slobberers to take themselves somewhere else.

And, if the silly sods refuse to take the hint? Well, that’s what, workmates/bosses/girlfriends/boyfriends/husbands and, if worse comes to worst, police officers are for.

By the sounds of things, Dr Worth is a slobberer. A slobberer, moreover, who seems to have real difficulties taking the hint. Presumably, that’s why he’s become the subject of a serious allegation of wrong-doing, and why his political career lies in ruins.

If you behave like a slobbering prat, entirely unmindful of your responsibilities as a husband, a father, a minister of the Crown, a member of Parliament, a member of the National Party caucus (not to mention a member of the human race) then you deserve nothing better. …

Sex is a thing that grown-ups do. Learning to negotiate one’s way through the reefs of lust and longing is, therefore, an important and inescapable part of becoming a mature human-being. In an culture (one of the very few cultures, in fact) which proclaims and enforces the principle of sexual equality, it looks really bad when left-wing “feminists” start behaving like a bunch of Victorian maidens confronted with a naked table-leg.

If “girls can do anything”, then surely they can tell some randy old bugger to fuck-off and leave them alone?

And now the complainant is refusing to provide the text messages in advance of a meeting. This doesn’t seem a reasonable request to deny.

In fact considering the allegations have been promoted and publicised, it would be very useful for the public to be able to read both the texts received and sent to be able to form an opinion.

I’m no defender of Richard Worth. In fact my language about him has been very harsh. But having the full text conversations released does not seem inapproprate – especially as the identity of the complainant remains private.

Bain found not guilty

The jury has found David Bain not guilty.

Regardless of my personal views on who did it, he has won his day in court and the jury’s verdict stands. Joe Karam will feel a strong sense of vindication.

Ironically I believe Bain should thank the Police. If they had not stuffed up aspects of the original investigation, a different verdict might have occurred – but they did, and there was reasonable doubt

It will be interesting if he applies for compensation, as that required convincing a QC on the balance of probabilities you were innocent.

Finally as this saga comes to an end, let us remember the dead – brave Stephen, Laniet, Arawa, Margaret and Robin.

And again regardless of my personal views on who did it, let us hope David has a quiet future, where he can finally move on.

I wonder how many pages the newspapes tomorrow will devote to the story? Half a dozen?

UPDATE: You can vote in the blog poll in the side bar on whether or not you agree with the verdict.

Goofynomics

Matthew Hooton hits the mark in NBR today. Go buy a copy for the full column, but here are some extracts:

It’s embarrassing to even chronicle Labour’s descent into economic lunacy this week but it now seriously proposes that borrowing to invest in global sharemarkets is not only a good idea but a one-way bet.

Borrow no matter how gaping our fiscal hole, nor how long the books will remain in the red, Labour insists.

This and only this, it claims, will stop superannuation entitlements to those aged 44 or younger being butchered.
It’s sad seeing Phil Goff reduced to such nonsense. Clearly, he now has no expectation of ever becoming prime minister.

Basically Goff has said that no matter how fire the deficit or debt is, he supports borrowing to save.

Dr Cullen launched his fund when permanent surpluses were forecast. With zero gross debt being on the medium-term horizon, it made sense to establish a sovereign wealth fund.

Connecting it with superannuation, though, was entirely political. Even Dr Cullen made clear there was no link to future entitlements and future taxpayers were always going to have to meet 89% of costs.

Bill English’s decision not to borrow for the fund will increase that by just 3%.

Moreover, in national-income terms, Mr English’s decision relates to just 0.2% of GDP from 2030.

It is ridiculous to worry about such a number. The smallest economic shock over the next two decades – positive or negative – could double or eliminate it, as could small productivity changes.

The media hysteria over the suspension has been put into context by Matthew. 0.2% of GDP.

Failing that, maintaining current entitlements would simply require reducing our surplus or increasing our deficit by 0.2% of GDP, 20 years hence. That hardly justifies the preposterous notion that we should borrow more now to invest in stocks.

Yet that is what Labour is demanding we do.

In reply, Mr Goff says governments can’t lose. He bases this on the banal observation in a Treasury paper that long-term returns from a diversified portfolio are likely to match the market average which, most probably, will exceed the risk-free rate over time.

Armed with these Corporate Finance 101 assumptions – and apparently with certain knowledge that sharemarkets are about to bounce back – Mr Goff demands that Mr English borrow another $20 billion over the next decade, and calculates it will deliver a net return of $8 billion sometime in the future.

No other politician in the developed world would contemplate such lunacy. Take Mr Goff’s argument to its logical conclusion and why stop at $20 billion?

Why not $200 billion to get $80 billion profit, dead cert?

Make it $2 trillion or more and perhaps tax could be abolished altogether with all government services being funded through the sharemarket.

This isn’t Goffonomics. It’s Goofynomics.

A name is born.

Mr Goff should ask why no other political leader in the history of the world has proposed this before.

Perhaps it’s because they understand it’s not government’s role to borrow from taxpayers yet to be born to risk on Wall Street with the promise of free money in the future.

What amuses me most of all is how Phil Goff treats a 50 year Treasury prediction of returns on managed funds as the holy writ, when Treasury can’t even predict from month to month what the deficit will be.

Buses in Manners Mall

Goff knew back in November 2008

I speculated this morning that Goff may have known about the earlier complaint for as long as 75 days. I was wrong. It seems he said on Morning Report that he was alerted way back in November 2008 – within days of the alleged harrassment beginning.

So in fact Goff knew about this for six months – including most of the period where the alleged 100 phone calls and texts occured. And then three months after they stopped, then raised it with the PM.

Cactus Kate also raises issues around why was Worth not told to stop early on.

I don’t think any of this excuses the alleged behaviour though.

The hypocrisy from Labour on this issue is quite stark. They are saying Key should not have taken Worth’s word for it, and investigated further.

Now Worth not only denied the allegation, he wrote that he was prepared to sign a statutory declaration that they are false. This is a sworn oath on penalty of perjury – Jeffery Archer got a long jail sentence for making such a false oath. So you had a barriaster and solicitor of the High Court, an MP, and the Associate Minister of Justice saying he will sign a sworn statutory declaration, against a second hand complaint with no supporting documentation.

Sure with benefit of hindsight you can argue one should have asked for the text messages – but the complainant herself has said the text messages by themselves prove nothing without the phone calls.

Now for the hypocrisy compare Labour’s position on Owen Glenn’s donation to Winston Peters legal fees.

Helen Clark admitted that she had known for over six months that Glenn said he donated to Peters. She phoned Peters who denied it, and she left it there – saying it was not up to her to investigate – depute this being a breach of the Cabinet Manual.

Now Peters did not, as Worth did, offer to sign a statutory declaration. He did not state in writing they were false. He did not say he was so convinced they were false he would sue anyone repeating them.

So the double standard from Labour is immense. In Helen’s case she had direct first hand testimony from Owen Glenn, on a mater of absolute fact (did he donate to Winston’s legal fees or not – can be proven within minutes), and a mere verbal denial from Winston. And Labour says Helen was right to take Winston at his word, even though this was a simple factual matter that could have been proven by a request to Glenn for a copy of the bank transfer.

And here we have a PM who has an anonymous allegation from a Labour Party activist, who will not be named, who has not supplied any documentary evidence – against a Minister who denies it in writing, and says he will sign a statutory declaration at risk of perjury if false.

Now sure a reasonable person can say both Clark and Key should have inquired further. And a reasonable person could say neither Clark nor Key should have inquired further – you trust a Minister unless there is direct written proof. Also one can very reasonably say Key pushed as far as he could (given the offer of a statutory declaration) but Clark did not (as it was a simple factual matter which could have been proven in minutes)

But how can anyone reasonably claim Clark was right not to inquire further, while Key was wrong not to do so?

I’m sure some of the commenters will give it a good go though.

Gordon Brown under seige

The election results are not even through yet, and Brown already has a crisis.

A third Cabinet Minister has resigned this week, and told Brown he should resign as PM. His letter says:

“We both love the Labour Party. I have worked for it for 20 years and you for far longer.

‘‘We know we owe it everything and it owes us nothing. I owe it to our party to say what I believe no matter how hard that may be. I now believe your continued leadership makes a Conservative victory more not less likely.

‘‘That would be disastrous for our country. This moment calls for stronger regulation, an active state, better public services, an open democracy. It calls for a Government that measures itself by how it treats the poorest in society. Those are our values, not David Cameron’s.

‘‘We therefore owe it to our country to give it a real choice. We need to show that we are prepared to fight to be a credible Government and have the courage to offer an alternative future.

‘‘I am therefore calling on you to stand aside to give our Party a fighting chance of winning. As such I am resigning from Government.

Brown is gone – either this year, or at next year’s elections. What I am interested in is who will be the next Leader of the Labour Party?

And I wonder how happy Tony Blair is today?

The Press on Worth

The Press editorial:

During his six months in the job he had distinguished himself by quickly becoming the weakest link in the administration of Prime Minister John Key. The final straw was the police investigation into serious sexual accusations against Worth which made it untenable for him to continue to hold a ministerial warrant. Key, quite correctly, demanded his resignation and has made it clear that if this had not been given he would have sacked Worth.

Labour leader Phil Goff now has the gall to claim that Key has displayed a lack of leadership, as the Prime Minister had known of the issue for a week before acting. Yet Key actually showed a sense of natural justice in making his own inquiries into the accusations before casting Worth adrift.

And never mind Goff sitting on another allegation for up to 75 days before acting.

Effectively sacking Worth was also a stark contrast to Labour’s refusal to sack New Zealand First leader Winston Peters before the last election when accusations of funding irregularities were swirling around him. Admittedly it is easier for a prime minister to punish a member of his own party, but Labour’s refusal to act decisively over Peters for political reasons was a real failure of leadership.

And Goff voted against the Privileges Committee report. He voted to say that Winston did nothing wrong.

Where Key may be faulted is in his initial statement about Worth on Wednesday morning. In it, Key repeated Worth’s own line about “private” matters prompting the resignation.

Although Key would not have wanted to prejudice the police investigation, he still should have indicated that the reason for the resignation was the inquiry into Worth’s conduct and not ill health or a family bereavement.

Which is the point I originally made.

Even if the police inquiry clears Worth, he will clearly not regain a Beehive post, as several of the former government’s suspended ministers did, which reflects a tough streak in Key.

Unlike the previous Government that put fallen Ministers back into the Ministry on numerous occasions.

Key cannot sack Worth from Parliament, although the MP could be expelled from the National caucus. But even if Worth stays on as a lonely National backbencher, his chances of receiving a safe list position for the next election are nil.

Less than nil.

MPs expenses to be disclosed

Well that is quick work. NZPA reports:

Just hours after Green Party members of Parliament released details of their travel and accommodation expenses, Speaker Lockwood Smith announced that a disclosure regime for all MPs’ expenses will be developed.

The Greens’ release yesterday followed a pledge by new co-leader Metiria Turei to disclose the information as pressure continues for MPs to be more transparent in how they spend taxpayers’ money.

Dr Smith said a cross-party meeting was held yesterday afternoon to discuss the extent to which expenses should be disclosed.

“A regime for public disclosure of expenses by MPs will be developed as quickly as possible,” he said.

“The committee was conscious of the public interest in this issue and agreed to develop a disclosure regime … Members of the cross-party committee will take the ideas discussed back to their respective parties.”

Kudos to the Greens for their voluntary disclosure. The NZPA story has one aspect wrong though:

The seven MPs not based in Wellington claimed between $1386 and $2000 for accommodation when in the capital.

This is not their claim for the four months in total, but the amounts they claim every month. And it is this area that I have some questions. Let us look at the Greens statement.

I’m not too interested in the level of airfares, or taxis as that is simply the cost of doing the job. There is no self gain from these expenses. And in fact it can often be the harder working the MP, the more their expenses will be. An MP who doesn’t attend any community events will have far less travel expenses than an MP who is doing 80 hour weeks covering the electorate.

What I am interested in is how much each MP claims for their Wellington accommodation expenses. And for the Greens they are:

  1. Jeanette Fitzsimons $2,000/mth = $24,000/year
  2. Catherine Delahunty $2,000/mth = $24,000/year
  3. Kevin Hague $1,950/mth = $23,400/year
  4. Sue Bradford $1,560/mth = $18,720/year
  5. Kennedy Graham $1,560/mth = $18,720/year
  6. Metiria Turei $1,467/mth = $17,604/year
  7. Keith Locke $1,386/mth = $16,636/year

Now the question for the Green Party, is who is that expense paid to? In the past the Greens have avoided the ban on paying yourself rent, by having their Superannuation Fund buy the houses they stay in, and have the taxpayer pay rent to their Super Fund.

If their Super Fund is receiving the rent from all seven MPs, that is $143,080/year or $429,240 over the parliamentary term of rent.

Could someone from the Green Party confirm how many of the seven MPs are havung the taxpayer pay rent to their superannuation fund, and which ones?

Note that Fitzsimons and Delahunty have maxed out their expenses to the maximum $24,000 a year.

Herald has details of complaint

The NZ Herald has talked to the complainant.

With a police investigation underway, I’m not going to speculate too much on what happened. However what I will say is that it is clear that it was appropriate for Worth to be sacked as a Minister, regardless of whether there is a criminal element.

How long did Goff sit on complaint?

Phil Goff has been complaining about how long it took for John Key to investigate Richard Worth over the complaint that led to his suspension – he said a week was too long.

But it appears that he spent months sitting on an earlier complaint, before talking to the PM about it.

The Dom Post has a pdf of the statement from the married Labour Party activist. I should make clear that there is no criticism of her. In fact I think it is regrettable that she has been forced into making the statement. But the statement raises some questions of timing. It says there were 40 texts and 60 phone calls from 26 November 2008 to 23 February 2009.

These dates are very specific, and it is not clear if the communications stopped on 23 February 2009. If they did stop, then why was the matter referred to Phil Goff in May?

But you keep reading the statement, and it mentions going to Phil Goff earlier in the year. Now Goff did not approach John Key until 9 May 2009, yet he may have had the complaint as far back as 23 February – 75 days before the 9th of May.

The Herald has also worked out there was a delay:

But Mr Goff was questioned yesterday about his handling of the matter. He did not approach Mr Key until early May, some time after he had found out about the matter.

Asked why he waited so long to raise it, Mr Goff said he had several conversations with the woman and her husband and the matter had been embarrassing for them.

“It took the woman and her family some time to determine how best to deal with the matter that was obviously troubling to them.”

His main concern had been to protect the privacy of the woman and that was why he took the matter to Mr Key privately.

It took 75 days?

Also Goff got details wrong:

Mr Goff had said there was email evidence of Dr Worth’s communications, but yesterday said he was wrong and there were only texts.

As I have said previously, I thought Goff acted appropriately in raising the matter privately. And he kept the matter private when he got a response. Presumably the texts/calls had stopped – and that was the desired outcome.

But since then he has tried to be holier than thou, and if you try to do that, then his own actions come under scrutiny. People ask how long did he sit on the complaint for? Why did he not gather up evidence and pass it onto the PM’s Office. Why did he not respond with said evidence when Key came back to him?

The fall and fall of Richard Worth

Statement by Richard Worth

Put out by Star PR on behalf of Worth:

“The public should suspend any judgment until allegations against me have been resolved.

“I have not committed any offence. I am presently co-operating fully with the police and will continue to do so.

“There has been a rush to judgment on the basis of rumour and speculation, which has been damaging to my political career and hurtful for my family and friends.

“There is a well known principle in New Zealand that a person is presumed innocent until they have been proved guilty. At the moment, I have not even been charged with any criminal offence, let alone had the opportunity to defend myself.”

“I maintain that I am innocent of any crime, and I will defend myself vigorously against any accusations that I have broken the law.”

The David Bain case

Okay the trial is over, and the jury has retired. I’ve checked and the jury is sequestered until they reach a verdict which means opinions here should be unable to sway the jurors.

I decided when the trial started to note down all the improbable things you have to believe for David to have done it, and for Robin to have done it. And while it is not a matter of who is guilty on the balance of probabilities, looking at such things can help determine if doubt is reasonable.

So what do you have to beleive, to think Robin was the killer. This list is not comprehensive, and is even a bit repetitive. But here goes:

  1. It was a lucky guess when David Bain told 111 ambulance officer they are all dead, despite later saying he only saw two bodies
  2. Again a lucky guess hen DB told police officer they are all dead
  3. The 25 minute gap between DB finding his family dead and calling 111 is in no way connected with trying to wash clothes and removed blood.
  4. The bruise on David’s head and scratches on his chest and graze on his knee – none of which he could explain, were just a coincidence
  5. The lens from his glasses found in Stephen’s room happened weeks ago and he never noticed OR someone else had borrowed the glasses
  6. The lack of fresh injuries on Robin despite the massive struggle with Stephen is just the product of healthy living
  7. David’s finger prints on gun are from a previous time
  8. David telling a friend he had premonition something bad was going to happen was a genuine psychic experience
  9. Stephen’s blood on David’s clothing was nothing to do with the struggle – OR someone else borrowed his clothes
  10. Robin managed to execute his family on a full bladder
  11. The lock and key to the rifle being found in David’s room is not relevant as they were obviously placed there
  12. Robin decided to wash David’s green jersey to remove blood and the fibres from jersey found under Steven’s finger nails
  13. David’s bloody palm print on the washing machine was from him checking the bodies
  14. The Ambulance officer was wrong when he said in his opinion Bain was pretending to have a fit
  15. Robin Bain would logically wear gloves to prevent fingerprints despite it being a murder-suicide
  16. That Robin Bain would type a message on a computer for David telling him he is the only one who deserves to live, instead of writing a note. A hand written note incidentally would have cleared David.
  17. Also that having just shot his family, and knowing David was due home, that Robin would wait 44 seconds for the computer to boot up to leave a message
  18. Robin would decide David deserved to live, but go out of his way to frame him for murder
  19. Robin Bain placed fibres from Davids jersey under Stephen’s finger nails
  20. Robin Bain would shoot himself with a gun in the most awkward way possible?
  21. That Robin Bain changed jerseys after he had killed his family and in particular Stephen Bain, washed the jersey, hung it on the line and then change into a brown jersey before killing himself?
  22. That there is a logical reason that David Bain can not account for the injuries on his face, the bruise or the scraped knee, yet knows he did not have them during his paper run.
  23. That Robin Bain put blood on the inside of David’s duvet and on his light switch
  24. That there is an innocent explanation for why David says he put on washing before he discovered the bodies, yet there is a blood print on the washing machine.
  25. That Laniet was being paranoid when she told friends she was scared of David
  26. That the “family meeting” David called the previous night and insisted everyone attended was not a way to make sure everyone would be at home to kill.
  27. That Robin Bain would wear a hat while shooting himself in the head.
  28. That even though David told a relative he hated his father, his father did not know this and deliberately decided David was the only one who deserved to live
  29. That David either imagined hearing Laniet gurgling or she gurgled 20 minutes after death
  30. That Laniet allegations of incent with Robin was true, as was her claims she had given birth three times by the age of 12 and a half.
  31. That Robin Bain managed to kill four family members without a single trace of his blood, skin, or DNA being left at the scene.
  32. That it is a coincidence that on the morning of the murders Bain took his dog onto a property, ensuring he would be noticed to give him an alibi.
  33. That the magazine found balanced on an edge next to Robin was not placed there by David but fell onto its edge from Robin’s arms.
  34. That a sickly Robin Bain managed to overpower his teendage son who put up a furious fight
  35. That Robin Bain went and got the newspaper from outside, despite planning to shoot himself

I remember during the first trial being convinced David was guilty and over the years you feel less certain as things get chipped away. I found the reports of the trial very useful at reminding me of the overwhelming foresnic evidence against Robin having done it.

Now the defence has been very cunning. They have challenged every piece of evidence and cast doubts on it. Some may say this is reasonable doubt.

I think it is important to look at the totality of the evidence, rather than individual aspects. While one can not define reasonable doubt, let us be stats geeks and say if you could it is doubt beyond 99.99%. And let us say that there are ten crucial forescnic items that point to David being the killer. But let us say that in each case the defence has introduced a 10% doubt.

But the defence have to knock out all ten items. And that 10% doubt, gets multipled and over the ten items is a 0.00000001% doubt.

Now before people howl at me, of course it is not a formula. But the point is you have to look at reasonable doubt over all the evidence, not just each individual aspect.

But before I say what I think the jury will do, let us look at what you need to beleive, to think David is the killer.

Well there isn’t a lot. Almost all the evidance fits in perfectly with the theory. The best I can come up with is:

  1. That he managed to finish his paper run quicker than normal
  2. That his foot at 300 mm couldn’t make a 280 mm luminol print
  3. That he was prepared to risk his father waking up early and finding the family dead

The defence summing up was very weak – trying to play on sympathy for poor David, and saying look at him – does he look like a psychopath.

So personally I have absolutely no doubt that David Bain killed his family. Regardless of what the jury finds, I just do not regard the Robin theory as having any serious credibility.

But I am not at all confident the jury will find him guilty? Why? Because the Police did stuff up a lot of the initial evidence gathering. Their failure to test everything and keep everything may have allowed the defence to plant reasonable doubt with the jury – or even get a hung jury that would be as good as an aquittal for Bain.

If Bain is found not guilty, or it is a hung jury, it will be interesting to see if he applies for compensation. You see the test for compensation is not reasonable doubt, but whether he is innocent on the balance of probabilities as assessed by an Independent QC on the evidence. People may debate reasonable doubt – but I do not think anyone would debate the balance of probabilities.

If Bain is found guilty again, then he will be resentenced. If he gets the same non parole period, I think he will be eligible for release in around three years.

As with everyone else, I await the verdict with great interest.

You just can’t help the terminally stupid

Some stupidities are so good, they need more publicity.

I blogged this morning on Obama’s huge US$1.8 trillion deficit.

Sonic then commented:

Those poor republicans, they have controlled congress and the presidency for most of the last 40 years yet somehow everything is still the Dems fault.

Now Sonic obviously did not do his homework. Anyone who knows much about US politics will know the Democrats controlled the House without a break from 1954 to the Republican Revolution of 1994.

I pointed out to Sonic:

Jesus mate do you ever get sick of showing how ignorant you are? I mean I guess it is why you don’t comment under your actual name. Since 1968, Democrats have controlled the Senate for 24 out of 40 years, and the House for 28 out fo 40 years

For those interested in details the Democrats controlled the House from 1968 to 1994, and 2006 to 2008. In the Senate they had control from 1968 to 1980, 1986 to 1994, some of 2000 – 2002, and from 2006- 2008.

Sonic then responds:

What are you gibbering about David, presidents since 1969.

Richard Nixon (1969-1974) R

Gerald Ford (1974-1977) R

Jimmy Carter (1977-1981) D

Ronald Reagan (1981-1989) R

George Bush (1989-1993) R

Bill Clinton (1993-2001) D

George W. Bush (2001-2009) R

So in the last 40 years republicans have been president for all but 12 of them.

Now this is a new levelof stupidity. He does not know the difference between the Presidency and Congress. I never disupted the statement about Presidents.

Even the most ignorant students know the difference between the Presidency and Congress. But not Sonic it seems.

Quoting Bill English

NZPA has a story (not onlne yet) quoting Bill English taking questions at a post budget speech.

He is talking about how he wants to make it easier for graduates, especially overseas, to pay off their loan. His exact words:

For example, he said it was extremely difficult for students to get information about and repay loans, especially when they were overseas.

He said graduates were computer literate and handled banking on-line so should be able to make payments to their loans the same way.

“If you are overseas with a student loan it’s very hard to even find the IRD’s phone number anywhere,” Mr English said.

“For any other service you just go on your laptop and they’ve got their pirated movies, and they’ve got their music downloads and they’ve got their email from mum.

“It’s all there — so why aren’t their student loans there? Then they’d repay them.”

So Bill is saying it should be as easy to pay off your student loan, as it is to pirate music and movies 🙂

The TAPAS US political trivial quiz

For those who couldn’t make it, here is the trivia quiz from last night’s American Politics Appreciation Society. I’ll post answers later in the day – feel free to comment you answers below – but don’t cheat by looking them up.

The inaugural winner was Labour MP Darren Hughes – well done Darren. We had a five way tie of people who scored 12/16, but Darren got closest on the Florida question.

1 One State is missing a Senator as the election result is still being contested in the courts. Which state is it, and for bonus points who is leading and by how much?

State:
Name:
Lead:

2 Who replaced Barrack Obama as Junior Senator for Illinois?

Name:

3 What number President of the United States is Barack Obama?

Number:

4 Who is Barack Obama’s Chief of Staff?

Name:

5. What three states allow gay marriage?

States:

6. A famous US court case is called Roe vs Wade. What was it about?

Roe v Wade is about:

7 Which US presidential candidate cheated on his cancer battling wife, and tried to mitigate his actions by saying that the cheating only occurred once she was in remission!

Name:

8 Which US Senator recently defected from the Republicans to the Democrats, giving them a likely 60 vote filibuster proof majority in the Senate?

Name: State:

9. Which US President said ” My plan reduces the national debt, and fast. So fast, in fact, that economists worry that we’re going to run out of debt to retire.”

Name:

10 Who won Florida in 2008 – McCain or Obama?

Name:
Margin:

Test your US general knowledge