Auckland hospitality job sought

I’m not going to make a habit of these, but as I have been asked.

An Auckland student with eight years experience in hospitality is looking for part-time work on Fridays, Saturdays and/or Sunday.

He has three references from previous employers. If you need a staffer, then he would be happy to receive your e-mail.

Bad Diplomats

In the House

Heather Roy (ACT’s Whip) has a useful feature on her website called “In the House“.

Heather lists every bill due to be voted on that week, a short summary of it, what reading it is and how ACT are voting.

Every party should be doing this!

Comedy Central here at last

I am loving having Comedy Central now available on Sky. Colbert Report, Southpark etc etc.

Best of all it is part of the overall Sky package so no extra charge.

Now all Sky has to do is get the SciFi Channel here. Heaps of people would pay for it.

uGov

NZ Govt CIO resigns

Computerworld reports that Laurence Millar, the NZ Government Chief Information Officer, following the Walter Report into contracting between the SSC and Voco for the Government Shared Network.

The report found there was no deliberate wrongdoing or improper behaviour, but that procedures were not followed adequately and it shouldnot have been a closed tender.

I have a lot of respect for Laurence Millar, and his departure is a loss. Plus it is to his credit that he has resigned to accept responsibility for the problems. This is something that has been all too rare. Laurence has said:

The material details a number of areas where the project was not managed to the standard that New Zealanders’ would expect for a project of this size. As sponsor of the GSN I accept full accountability, and advised the Commissioner of that when I offered my resignation, which he has accepted.

“Mr Walter’s report confirms that there are no instances of any lapse of personal integrity, which is of fundamental importance to me personally and for the State Services Commission. The reports also comment on the challenges faced by the project and the commitment from individuals working on the project in responding to these challenges.

“I joined SSC from the private sector in March 2004, and have been involved in a wide range of successful initiatives, and been privileged to have worked with outstanding individuals and teams across New Zealand’s State Services.

“Along the way, I have taken some risks and made some mistakes. I have learned from these experiences and have used them to improve the way that we use ICT. I think the State Services is in better shape as a result of my contribution over the last five years.

I beleive it is. There have been many good initiatives in that time. But kudos to both Laurence, and his boss Ian Rennie, for this display of accountability for when things go wrong.

Henry vs McCully

Electoral reform done properly

I’m delighted with the process outlined by Simon Power to consider electoral finance issues.

Readers will recall that Labour, Greens and NZ First negotiated the Electoral Finance Bill in secret. There was no opportunity for any public input until it reached select committee. And we also all know how terribly flawed that bill was.

So what is National proposing as a process:

  1. An issues paper released in May 2009
  2. Public Forums in Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch
  3. Submissions on Issues Paper
  4. Govt releases summary of submissions
  5. Govt then releases a proposed policy for reform in August 2009
  6. Submissions on proposed policy
  7. Govt releases summary of submissions
  8. Then Govt introduces bill into Parliament in late 2009 or early 2010,  with normal select committee process

I’m really pleased that they are doing two, not one, stages of public consultation – on both the issues paper and on the proposed policy – that way it is all no surprises.

Also very pleased to see public forums are scheduled. I had been talking to some NGOs about organising some forums to fit in with the consultation. It is even better that the Government itself will organise such forums. I encourage people to take advantage of the opportunity to have a say.

The following topics are being considered:

  • Guiding Principles
  • Candidate and Party Funding
  • Campaign Spending
  • Advertising
  • Parallel Campaigning
  • Monitoring & Compliance

Off-topic for the review is:

  • The MMP electoral system
  • Maori representation
  • Structure of electoral agencies
  • Electoral roll administration
  • Electorate boundaries
  • Local Government electoral law

I agree these are best dealt with separetly. I do hoep the Government will look at some of these issues independently and consider changes – especially to the electoral agencies structure and electoral roll administration.

Interest.co.nz

Congrats to interest.co.nz. They made one million page impressions in March, which is hugely impressive. The site has become a must read for anyone who follows business and economics.

Also a few days ago they had an interesting story about how John Key’s interview in the Wall Street Journal helped ANZ National secure $1 billionf of finance:

Last week ANZ National CEO Graham Hodges went to the United States for a roadshow to promote this US$1 billion bond issue. Its success was no sure thing.

Time and again, Hodges says, investors told him Key’s interview in the Wall St Journal had reassured them, despite the uncertainty of a potential credit rating downgrade. Sometimes it’s a struggle to get foreign investors to look past the shorthand of credit ratings and the headlines of research notes. Key’s interview made them sit up and take notice.

Hodges said it seemed to strike a chord.

It turns out the interview was a crucial factor in the success of the bond issue, the first long term issue by a New Zealand bank since July last year. It is likely to set the tone for more.

Stuff like this you just never see in most other media.

How I would do representation in Auckland

I’ve spent a bit of time discussing parts of the Royal Commission report that are not that flash (I should note I am a strong supporter of the overall direction of one Council and an elected Mayor with enhanced powers), so here is where I spell out what I would do.

First of all I would scrap the at large seats, or at least reduce their number. Ten at large seats is a huge amount and what it means is that you may have say 50 people standing for 10 positions, and in that scenario it becomes name recognition only – not informed decision making.

It also means that an area such as Manukau could end up with only 2 Councillors out of 23, despite being 30% of the Region.

Plus it will be confusing to have people vote for three sets of Councillors – local Councillors, ward Councillors on Auckland Council and at large Councillors on Auckland Council.

No Right Turn has a model that works well with no at large, and 1 to 6 Councillors per ward, which has equality of representation.

My second decision would be to have local Council boundaries and Ward boundaries the same. The Royal Commission allows them to be different which is confusing.

My third decision would be to have more, yet smaller, local Councils (and in fact don’t call them Councils as that confuses them with the Auckland Council, so I will call them Local Boards).

The local boards should be small enough to not need further wards underneath them. I quite like the 11 council/board option in the RC report.

If you had 11 smaller boards and wards, then each of them could elect two Councillors each (if their boundaries were adjusted so populations were similar enough) to the Auckland Council. And each of them would have perhaps just half a dozen members.

Finally you have the Maori reps. Putting aside my personal views that long-term these take us down the wrong path, I think it is inevitable the Council will have some as they have been recommended. But under the current proposal, their number is way too high as you have one per 30,000 residents compared to one per 120,000 in the main wards.

However if one gets rid of the at large seats, then the correct number of Maori seats would be around 1.5 – so say two Councillors elected off the Maori roll. I don’t think mana whenua should directly appoint a Councillor, but can live with a Maori roll election as we do have the precedent.

So in total my principles would be:

  1. Abolish at large Councillors
  2. Ward boundaries for Auckland Council should match local Council/Board boundaries
  3. Have more, smaller local Councils/Boards
  4. Have local Councils/Boards small enough so that they in turn do not need another set of wards beneath them
  5. Have a Maori roll ward with one or two Crs, but do not have direct appointment by mana whenua

As I said I am supportive of most of the Royal Commission’s recommendations, but the representation model they have devised is one that can be improved upon – in my opinion.

Goldsmith on Maori seats

Auckland City Councillor Paul Goldsmith has a forceful op-ed:

What’s the harm of having three Maori seats on the new Auckland City Council, as recommended by Justice Peter Salmon and his Royal Commission on Auckland Governance? In my view, plenty.

The best indication of potential harm is the bizarre suggestion democracy should be thrown out the window for one of the Maori seats so that one councillor is appointed by mana whenua.

What is the model that we’re emulating? Fiji’s Great Council of Chiefs, the British aristocracy’s hereditary rights to sit in the House of Lords? An unelected group of men from one ethnic group, and possibly one network of families, decides who goes on to the council?

I have to say that if one is to have direct Maori representation, it is reatly preferable that it be by democratic vote of those on the Maori electoral roll, not a private appointment by an Iwi.

It reflects a worrying trend. The implication in retaining democratically elected Maori seats has been that to be represented in a democracy in the same way as everyone else is not good enough for Maori. Now we are being told that having specific Maori seats is also not sufficient for Maori, there needs to be direct appointments by Maori elders as well.

Indeed. And already there are calls that one mana whenua representative is not enough, but there must be two – one for Ngati Whatua and one for Tainui. They can’t possibly share.

Twittering

A great quote in the Herald story:

This time, Mr Cunliffe stands and gravely intones that not only does he not have an account with Twitter, but “I have never sent a tweet and I have never even, to my knowledge, received a tweet”.

I’m not sure what is funnier. That Labour MPs have parody accounts, or that John Key fell for it and didn’t realise that they were a parody.

Dalai Lama

The Herald reports:

An umbrella group representing 28 local Chinese organisations wants the Government to follow South Africa’s lead in refusing to grant the Dalai Lama a visa to visit. …

The Dalai Lama was to visit South Africa last week after being invited to attend a peace conference of Nobel laureates, but was refused a visa.

The United Chinese Association of New Zealand will be writing to the Prime Minister and Immigration Minister requesting that New Zealand does the same.

The South African government admitted its decision was taken to avoid harming relations with China.

I find it disappointing that any group of New Zealanders would call on the state to ban someone from visiting just because they don’t like what that person says.

Top Ten Punishments for Chris Bishop

Labour devoted a parliamentary question and a press release to exposing the Facebook status updates of Chris Bishop, in Gerry Brownlee’s Office. Chris’ sin was scepticism over Earth Hour.

Anyway I have been leaked the list of punishments that have been devised for Mr Bishop. They are:

  1. Placed in charge of Beehive recycling programme
  2. Secondment to Darien Fenton’s office every second Friday
  3. Now responsible for turning off the lights at night in every Beehive office
  4. Chris appointed Private Secretary for Gender Equity programmes
  5. Required to do a cost/benefit analysis for the national cycleway showing it will cost only $50 million and crate 4,000 jobs
  6. Then required to test the cycleway out during winter
  7. Made responsible for monitoring the Twitter accounts of all Labour Party staff
  8. Duties now include daily inspections of Bellamys food to check no pies or fizzy drinks are on sale
  9. As show of contrition to the Greens, Bishop made speech writer for foreign policy speeches for Keith Locke
  10. Compulsory entrant into Ministerial piggyback race at Easter

Thanks to all of Chris’ friends who helped compile the list!

The violent crime legacy

crimerate

As one can see the second half of the 1990s saw the violent crime rate consistently drop. The increase since 1999 speaks for itself, and the release of the 2008 crime stats show that it continued throught 2008.

From Dec 1999 to Dec 2008, the number of recorded violent crimes went up 51%, and the rate per 10,000 residents went up 35%.

And before you try and claim it is just an increase in non reported domestic violence, grievous assaults increased 105% or adjusting for population by 85%. And those assaults are very very hard to go unreported as they include stabbings etc.

Let us hope that the next nine years do not see another 35% increase in recorded violent crime rates.

Clark due in new job on 20 April

Helen Clark has been confirmed by the UN General Assembly and is due to start on 20 April.

Now she may not manage that, but when could a by-election be if she does leave on 20 April?

  1. Clark will resign under s55(1)(f) of the Electoral Act – Mon 20 Apr
  2. Vacancy published in Gazette – Tue 21 Apr
  3. GG must issue writ within 21days of Gazette – so from 22 Apr to 12 May.
  4. Nominations normally close 6 days after the writ – from 28 Apr to 18 May
  5. Polling Day could be any Saturday from 25 May to 13 June (20 to 27 days after noms close)
  6. The writ must be returned within 50 days so that is by 11 Jun to 1 July

Graeme E will no doubt correct me, if the dates are wrong!

I doubt they want a by-election in May when the budget has just been passed, and likewise not over a long (QB) weekend, so I would pick 13 June at this stage.

Yay – we are free

I blogged two days ago that there was a potential huge win-win if NZ withdrew from the race for a place on the thoroughly discredited Human Rights Council, as the Obama administration was clean to re-engage with it, and reform it (I doubt anyone can but good on Obama for trying).

Murray McCully seemingly agrees, and has announced NZ is withdrawing to make room for the US.

New Zealand has decided not to pursue its candidature for election to the Human Rights Council in 2009, Foreign Minister Murray McCully announced today.

Mr McCully said the decision had been made to avoid four nations contesting three positions, following the United States’ indication that it would seek a Council seat.

This will gain us some serious kudos with the Obama Administration. They will repay the favour at some stage. So we gain a big IOU from the most powerful country on Earth, and best of all the concession is something we should have done anyway.

“The Human Rights Council has been widely criticised. It was our intention, in seeking election, to provide a force for change and improvement. However we believe that US membership of the Council will strengthen it, and make it more effective.

“That is in the interests of all those who, like New Zealand, want to see the Council respond robustly and effectively to human rights violations wherever they occur.

“Frankly, by any objective measure, membership of the Council by the US is more likely to create positive changes more quickly than we could have hoped to achieve them.

“This decision was not taken lightly but we see New Zealand’s standing aside as being in the best interests of the advancement of international human rights at this time.

The best interests of international human rights would be to kick all the dictatorships off the Council. But failing that, the US is going to be have a higher chance of sucess than a minnow like NZ. In some areas like the Security Council (and there I support our bid 1000%) we can play a very constructive role. But the Human Rights Council has far too many vested interests with countries actually wanting to use it to supress the right to criticise religions.

So for someone like me who saw our bid as misguided, this is an absolute win-win. But even if you are one of those optimists who thinks we could have done some good there, there is no doubt we gain far more kudos for letting the US back on and having Obama owe us one.

The Dunedin Stadium

Douglas to Dancing covers a meeting about the Dunedin Stadium, where an estimated 1,800 opponents turned up.

I was there when the meeting was held, and not surprised they got 1,800. Almost every shop in town carried posters advertising it. Now normally it is the commercial sector that most favours stuff like stadiums as they get the tourism benefits. The fact so many local businesses think it costs way too much, let alone the residents, suggests it is seriously lacking in support.

The meeting called for Rodney Hide as Local Government Minister t scrutinise the decision making process around the stadium. It will be interesting to see what Rodney does.

Preventative Detention

The Dom Post reports:

A Napier paedophile has been sentenced to preventive detention on 38 charges involving 11 young boys during the past seven years.

Owen Stanley Draper, 66, pleaded guilty to the charges in February and was sentenced yesterday by Justice Ronald Young in the High Court at Napier.

Justice Young said Draper, who had three previous convictions for sexual offending, must serve at least six years in prison before he can apply to be freed.

This upset the mother of one of the victims, who said she was alarmed at the possibility that Draper might be out of prison in six years.

Preventative detention is the right sentence. Unlike parole, where you get it almost automatically unless you are clearly a risk – you don’t get out of preventative detention unless you are clearly not a risk – basically the burden of proof changes.

But despite that, it would be reassuring to have a longer period before he can be considered for release. He has molested 11 kids over seven years, and has convictions over the last 20 years. I just hope that the Parole Board are very very cynical about any professed rehabilitation when he comes up for consideration in six years.

UPDATE: A victim of Draper writes in:

my name is Hamish i am on of the victim’s Owen Stanley Draper of Napier Hawke’s Bay New zealand abused for many year’s i would like to have this message on his tag line please Owen abused me for many year’s, i was introduced by my best friend who still today is my best friend he thought what owen was doing was okay so did i we where both 10 year’s old at the time now 13 year’s later i have drug addiction problem been to jail twice and have lost alot of family for what this peodophile has done i cannot work or hold a job down due to mental impact’s this has given me i hope he rott’s in hell for what he did and should be sentenced to death but since we dont do that he got the harshest sentence in new zealand which isn’t much cheers

Bullshit over Broadband

Ever since National announced its $1.5 billion fibre to the home policy in May 2008, Labour has told fibs about it. Great big fibs.  As National was pledging an amount around 400% more than Labour, they couldn’t do their normal cries of “It isn’t enough”.

So they claimed it would all go to Telecom, and entrench their monopoly status. And they kept repeating the lie.

And then yesterday when National announces further details of its policy, Labour has the cheek to claim that National has shifted its policy, and adopted Labour’s policy.

So get this – you tell lies about what a party’s policy is, and when it is clear the lies will no longer work, you then claim they have done a u-turn.

In the House Labour claimed:

Can the Minister confirm that by shifting from its pre-election policy of a single, regulated, utility model for delivering broadband to one that is regional, open, contestable, and technology-neutral, National has adopted Labour’s broadband investment policy framework; if this is true, why did National not campaign for that rather than the opposite?

Now let us first look at National’s policy:

National will contribute an investment of up to $1.5 billion in Crown capital alongside additional privatesector investment to accelerate the roll-out of ultrafast broadband for New Zealand, subject to five key principles:

Totally consistent with what was announced yesterday.

That this investment does not line the pockets of or give undue advantage to existing broadband network providers.

Again totally consistent with what was outlined yesterday. And totally contradictory to Labour’s claims over the last year that all the money would go to Telecom.

That the network is open-access so that many service providers can compete to provide broadband services over it.

Again totally consistent with yesterday’s announcement.

Nowhere at all does the policy say National will have a “single, regulated, utility model for delivering broadband”. National made it very clear it was open minded on what the model will be, so long as the principles outlined were adhered to.

I’ve praised Labour for their engagement over the copyright issue. And I think the Comms/IT policies pursued by Labour over recent years have generally been very good. The co-operation and mood in the industry is radically different to five years ago, and Labour’s record has been very good as a major contributor to that.

But this is why I’m pissed off by the fibs/lies they told over National’s broadband policy.  Most of what Labour did was not opposed by National. I think National realised that this is an area where one shouldn’t be party partisan and at the Internet debates in 2005 and 2008, we got more agreement than disagreement.

But Labour, presumably shocked by the fact National pledged 400% more on broadband investment, has done nothing but spread bullshit over National’s policy, rather than actually say “Hey we support this goal”.

Unlike their admirable forward looking position on s92A, Labour seemed caught in the past trying to say that nothing should change from when they were in power. They foolishly attacked the Government for ceasing funding to the massive loss making Govt Secure Network (that almost no one in Government was using) and they complained about replacing a $340 million level of pledged investment with a $1.5 billion level of investment.

Anyway after months and months of lies about how Telecom had written National’s policy, how Telecom had donated to National, how this policy was a $1.5 billion subsidy to Telecom, how it would give Telecom a perpetual monopoly over our futures, maybe the bullshit will stop. I certainly hope so.

The Tizard time-bomb

The NZ Herald has upgraded Judith Tizard from a dilemma to a time-bomb.

Judith sees her return as a matter of  demographics:

Ms Tizard said Labour would be silly to buy into the “Tizard dilemma” and try and keep her out.

“If there is not a place for a 53-year-old woman who has been in elected positions for 26 of her 31 years, I guess I would want to know what the problem was.”

Well obviously I do not speak for Labour, but my responses would be:

  • It’s nothing to do with your gender or age
  • It is about rejuvenation – Labour got kicked out at the last election, and Labour won’t win next time unless they have some fresh faces

Labour leader Phil Goff said the Tizard dilemma was a “red herring”, but refused to openly back her return.

No shit.

National to appoint Cullen as Reserve Bank Governor

I understand that later today National will be announcing that they are appointing Michael Cullen as Governor of the Reserve Bank.

Their initial plans to make him Chairman of a major state-owned enterprise were criticised for his lack of commercial experience. Hence they have shifted course and now plan to make him Reserve Bank Governor as that is normally filled by people with more of an academic than commercial background.

Some MPs have told me they opposed the appointment, when it was notified to Caucus yesterday, but no formal vote was held. His appointment is part of the Key’s strategy to appear magnamious in victory and use talent from all parties.

The dissenting MPs are worried that here could be a minor loss of credibility for National to appoint to such an important role, the man whose financial and economic policies they have criticised for the last decade. But the clinching argument was that as National has adopted so many of them, they may as well adopt their architect also.

It will be interesting to see whether the dollar rises or falls, once the appointment is confirmed.