SIS spying

The Press reports that the SIS has released files on individuals whom they no longer monitor. They should be commended for such openness – this seems an initiative of new Director Warren Tucker who is well regarded.

Obviously various current or former Marxists, communists and Maoists are upset about the fact their files reveal the SIS were monitoring them.

But the reality is the world today is very different to the 1970s and 1980s. The western world was, to be blunt, engaged in a massive struggle with the Soviet Union for global control. They communist states were enemies of freedom and the West, and posed a huge threat to our way of life.

And these people who were monitored were active in groups that were on the side of the communist totalitarian states, not our side. They won’t put it like that, but that was the reality. They never ever condemned the communist states – in fact they did friendship visits there and extolled how good they are.

Luckily the Soviet empire collapsed in 1990. We now have the wonderful luxury of having mainly put that threat between us. Today a communist is just a hardline economic socialist. The only threat they pose is to good economic policy, and that is not a matter of national security. It is appropriate the SIS no longer regards people active in communist groups as people who should be monitored.

But again it was different before the collapse of the Soviet Union. It wasn’t just about disagreeing on economic policy.

Now this is not to give carte blanch to everything the SIS did. Some of the revelations don’t put them in a good light and they themselves today probably don’t defend certain things. Again it is to their credit they they are releasing it. But just to make the case that the context in the 70s and 80s was vastly different to today. Unless you lived through it, you can’t no how much the world changed after that glorious summer where totalitarian communist states fell one after another until they were almost all gone.

Winston did attend!

Why the Otago District Health Board Chair and CEO should be sacked

I’ve been meaning to blog about this for some time, and it is topical today as the Herald reports the ODHB Chair is refusing to resign and faces the sack.

The $17 million fraud perpetrated by the former CIO, Michael Swann, is in my opinion a failure of good governance, and that is squarely the role of the Board, with the Chair holding prime accountability. I also include the CEO as they are the Board’s chief advisor, and should have ensured better systems were in place.

Swann is the crook, and of course primarily to blame. Getting away with some fraud for a small period of time is near impossible to stop when a senior official is corrupt.

But the size and duration of the offending removes the excuses from the Board. There were a number of things the Board and/or the CEO could have done to stop the fraud or make it much more difficult to have had it continue.

And this is regardless of the obvious warning signs about a senior official who had around 20 cars and a handful of yachts that should have rung warning bells.

I’m actually a company director myself for a company with around $10 million turnover. Now no company is perfect and fraud proof, but we do have a strong focus on governance and good process. I suspect the ODHB (and part of the problem is they are partially elected) focuses more on stuff like spending the money, rather than the boring side of processes to do with governance and accountability.

I think of all the ways that the CEO and/or the Board should have got some idea there was something wrong:

  1. Was there an internal audit function? External audits generally do not detect fraud. A large organisation should have an internal audit function.
  2. Many of the fake invoices were for software updates that were never done. Was there a policy around independent security checks of the IT system for vulnerabilities that would have exposed these were not done.
  3. Why was the contract for services not competitively tendered? A contract of $17 million over some years should be decided at board or at least CEO level and be a competitive tender. A CIO should not be delegated the authority to decide this alone. A competitive tender would have probably exposed the company was a sham.
  4. Why did the CEO or CFO never get suspicious that they had never met staff from this company they had paid $17 million to? When you are spending that much with a company you should have a relationship with them – you may even have had their Directors come along for discussion.
  5. Did those who signs cheques ever question the invoices? The company I am on is of course much smaller than a DHB, but as a signatory and Director I often question several of the cheques I have to sign. Not in a hostile way, but in a “I don’t know what services this company provided for us, tell me what they did and which approved activity it relates to”
  6. Why did the Board and/or CEO never question the cost of the IT support services? Even if the services this firm was providing was real, they seem to be to be massively expensive. Did no-one have any experience of value for money for such stuff? Did they question the increase in the IT budget? Did they ever say “Let’s tender this out to see if we can reduce it?”
  7. Did the Board have a policy of regular reviews of major suppliers and major contracts? The Board should not do the detailed reviews of course, but they should set the policy and require the CEO to implement it, and make recommendations to them?
  8. Did the Board have a robust financial delegations policy? At what level did expenses have to be approved by the Board, but the CEO, the CFO, Departmental Heads etc? How often did they review this policy?
  9. When a supplier is a major cost (such as $17 million over several years) you expect them to be a well known firm. No one expects the $5,000 a year supplier to be more well known than the ABC computer shop but if you are paying millions to a company you expect it to be well known (especially in a small city like Dunedin), to have a shopfront, be in the yellowpages, have a website. You may even expect to have had some first or second hand dealings with it.

I could go on and on. To be clear – no organisation can ever be so good they fraud is impossible. Corrupt staff can always work out a loophole to some degree. But the size of the scam, the ongoing duration of it, and the fact it would have been so simple to detect, points to a significant failure in policy, process and governance.

Yes there have been changes in Chairs and CEOs during this time. But unless they are brand new into the job, both the Chair and the CEO need to be held accountable for what happened, and not keep blaming it on the corrupt Swann. His scam was not the genius con of the century. It was simplistic and should have been detected far earlier.

OCR now 3.5%

ocrjan09

I remember the days when a 50 basis point drop was a big thing. Now we have 150 point drops that are in line with expectations.

This should start to push mortgages back into the affordable category for more people.  Of course depends where retail rates go.

Fonterra Director implicated in Sanlu scandal

General Debate 28 January 2009

For those with a lot of spare time

Arguments on Naitoko shooting

Just as I was critical of No Right Turn yesterday for demanding the Police officer who shot Halatau Naitoko be put on trial, I’m also critical to see in the NZ Herald the headline “Motorway shooting lawful, say experts”.

I’d quite like the facts to be established, before people jump to conclusions that the shooting is or is not legal.

Having said that, Gooner at No Minister responds to No Right Turn in an interesting post. Gooner is a former cop turned lawyer so has some experience here. What I like in his post is that it all has to be judged in individual context:

I/S is fair and square wrong. He conflates rights with responsibilities or duties. The police do have the right to shoot people in this country just as much as they have the right to handcuff suspects, use force, drive at excessive speed etc. You get the point. But their rights to do all these things have to be balanced with the situation they are facing at the time. You break the law if you drive at excesive speed to a report of a historic house burglary. And, there is (usually) no need to handcuff a 16 yr old female shoplifter. Each situation depends on the circumstances. As does this shooting.

He then says that if the officer was justified in shooting, it is an issue of how much care was taken, as he obviously shot the wrong person:

Having met this requirement, it seems it then becomes an issue of how much care the officer took in taking aim and pulling the trigger. Again, this cannot be judged against the ordinary standard of a deer hunter in the Ureweras. Such a deer hunter is simply not operating in the same circumstances as police are who make split-second decisions when aiming and pulling the trigger. The deer hunter might have minutes to settle himself, confirm his target etc. The police have seconds. I have been in this position. It is not pleasant. Nor is it easy.

Now it has not yet been established whether the officer had seconds, or minutes. Or what level of training the officer had. Or how close the victim was to the target. So again I reserve judgement until these are established by a competent and credible authority.

Still more MPs

And still more:

Christchurch Central MP Brendon Burns called for liquor laws such as the drinking age to become matters of party policy, saying the traditional use of conscience votes to decide them should be a relic of the past.

The new Labour MP said the need for reform was clear from his own electorate, where even if the bars refused to serve intoxicated people and there was a liquor ban, alcohol was still easily available. Local police and health bodies had told him alcohol accounted for 70 per cent of weekend crime and injuries in Christchurch.

“Liquor legislation is difficult to get right. In part I think that is because it remains a conscience vote for members. As further liquor legislation looms in the time of this Parliament, I suggest it is timely for parties to consider whether such law changes should become matters of party policy.”

I respectfully disagree. I think more issues should be conscience votes, not less. I love conscience votes – you get true debate. MPs lobby each other, amendments are considered on their merits, you get great passionate speeches etc.

Before turning to politics, he worked for 12 years in the parliamentary press gallery, and said he was the first former gallery member to become an MP since Sir Frederick Doidge 70 years ago.

I didn’t know that.

Melissa Lee

Background:
Former journalist and presenter on Asia Down Under, which has been produced by her company for the past 13 years. Born in Korea, family moved to New Zealand in 1988.

Personal:
Her parents instilled a strong work ethic in their children. As a cadet reporter at the Sunday News she would go to work at the family’s dairy until 11pm after finishing her day’s work. Mother of 10-year-old son.

I covered Melissa at the time of her maiden speech.

Steven Joyce

Background:
Started what is now the RadioWorks network in the 1980s with four friends, all putting in $100 for a Massey station. After 17 years CanWest bought them out for $6 million.

Personal:
He comes from a long line of small business people. His parents both left school at 15 and “scrimped and borrowed” to buy a Four Square grocery store in New Plymouth.

Steven has been in charge of National’s last two campaigns, which saw National’s vote go from 21% to 45%. The first MP since Margaret Wilson to go straight into Cabinet.

Armstrong on Greens and National

John Armstrong notes:

Having slammed the door shut to working with National a mere three months ago, the Greens now want to reopen it.

How else to interpret Russel Norman’s speech last Sunday other than as a plea to National to talk?

Better late than never some may say!

The Prime Minister’s response was immediate and positive, inviting the Greens’ leadership to a sit-down chat when Parliament resumes next month.

That nice John Key. He’d better be careful. If he develops a working relationship with the Greens, he next may have Jim Anderton knocking on his door 🙂

What was significant was that Norman sought to promote dialogue by listing Green initiatives which National could support. They ranged from the public service being required to buy the most fuel-efficient vehicles to having “smart” electricity meters which would allow consumers to run appliances at cheaper off-peak times, thus reducing the need for new power stations.

I’m actually quite interested in those “smart” meters. Need to do a formal cost vs benefit analysis but stuff like this is the future.

The Greens’ shift from emphasising the differences to stressing areas where National and the Greens could take “united action” comes a couple of weeks after Nandor Tanczos bluntly described the Greens’ pre-election backing of Labour as “fastening your lifeboat to a sinking ship” and a “stupid thing to do”.

A column that didn’t get noticed very much, until highlighted on the blogs!

Karaka Sales

A nice story

From the SST:

ISRAELIS AND Palestinians in and around Gaza are picking up the pieces after 22 days of fighting, but an Auckland cafe is showing, with shared values and a love of food, they can work together. Ima an Ibn cafe in Shortland St is owned by Israeli Yael Shochat and Palestinian Khaled Masroujeh and politics play no part in their working day. …

She opened a cafe on Shortland St, Ima’s Kitchen, and hired Masroujeh, a young chef, who impressed her with his “intelligence and passion for food”.

When Shochat closed Ima’s Kitchen last year, she and Masroujeh decided to go into partnership. They opened Ima and Ibn, which means mother (in Hebrew) and son (in Arabic).

People have raised eyebrows about an Israeli and a Palestinian working together, but “the truth is that we are the same people from the same part of the world and have so much in common, especially our love of food”, says Shochat.

The cafe is popular among Middle Eastern customers; at night the backgammon and hookah are brought out. Shochat keeps the customers happy playing Israeli and Arabic music.

“We have basic values in common, like food and family,” she says, “You know, one-on-one, people probably get along really well. They just want to get on with their lives; to raise their families and make money and live well.”

An all too rare expression of common sense and decency.

Has United Future paid the money back?

NZ First never paid back the $140,000 + GST it owed the taxpayer.  We know this.

But a reader has reminded me that United Future also still owed some money. In the 2006/07 year they paid back only $31,000 o fthe $64,000 they owed (morally) the Parliamentary Service.

As far as I can tell from their annual report, no repayments were made in 2007/08 but there is a $3,000 other revenue line which might be a repayment.

So how much of the debt has been paid, and when will it be paid in full?

Obamas do a lot of fisting

Oh dear. Watch this commentator as she talks about how Barack and Michelle Obama are such an affectionate couple as they do a lot of touching, kissing and even fisting!!

Boing Boing points out

Our well-lubed commenters are probably correct in guessing that the Fox analyst [snort] means “making happy-fun terrorist fist-jabs in the air” when she says “fisting.” This just makes it funnier.

Hat Tip: Whale Oil

Dom Post on crime levy

The Dom Post criticises National’s levy on criminals:

New Justice Minister Simon Power is either a born optimist or ingenuous. Despite the deep flaws in his policy to fund reparations for victims of crime, he seems determined to proceed with a pre-election promise to levy a so-called crime tax of $50 on everyone convicted in a New Zealand court, The Dominion Post writes.

The scheme aims to offer one-off payments to cover the unexpected costs crime victims encounter that are not met by other government agencies, such as ACC.

This is one promise the Government could have quietly dropped. And that is not because it has no superficial appeal.

I always enjoy the media encouraging political parties to renege on their promises.

The major drawback of Mr Power’s proposal one he himself should see is the reality that those who refuse to pay what they owe now are those who will not pay under his new scheme, which hapless Courts Minister Georgina te Heuheu must help administer.

Conceding that the levy might lift the outstanding debt, she said last week that she hoped some proposals being worked on would help “minimise this increasing figure”. How loyal.

But greater enforcement, should it be achievable, will not tackle the inequity of the Government’s proposal. Why should a woman who unsuccessfully contests a $120 speeding fine pay the same levy as, say, a man convicted of mass murder?

There is no doubt that some criminals will not pay the levy. But some, maybe many will. And if enough pay that it provides a useful amount of money for assistance for victims, then it will have achieved some good.

As for the equity issue, I think the Dom Post overlooks this is not a scheme to further punish criminals. It is about raising money to help assist victims of crime. Hence it does not matter that it is a flat levy, as it is set so low. The sentence is the main punishment. This is a trivial extra fine which might help cover costs for some of the victims.

It is possible it may not work well. But it is too early to know. A key question will be what proportion of the fines/levies are actually paid. Is it over 50%? over 70%? over 80%?

And the other key question will be how much does it cost to administer the scheme. Will the costs of staff administering it, be grather than the amount collected? This is the bigger worry to me. But again, too early to know.

Parliament 2009 Sitting Calendar

The recommended House sitting programme for 2009 has been out for a while. So how does it look:

  1. Two weeks from 10 February
    One week recess
  2. Two weeks from 3 March
    One week recess
  3. Three weeks from 24 March
    Two weeks recess
  4. Three weeks from 28 April
    One week recess
  5. Two weeks from 26 May
    One week recess
  6. Three weeks from 16 June
    Two weeks recess
  7. Three weeks from 21 July
    One week recess
  8. Two weeks from 18 August
    One week recess
  9. Three weeks from 8 September
    Two weeks recess
  10. Three weeks from 13 October
    Two weeks recess
  11. Two weeks from 17 November
    One week recess
  12. Three weeks from 8 December
    Rise around 22 December

A total of 31 weeks spread over 12 sessions. This seems about normal off memory.

Contrary to what some may think, it is not holiday time for MPs in recess weeks. You still have constituency work, some select committees, caucus committees, policy development, stakeholder meetings, party activities, correspondence etc – plus of course Ministers are still governing.

.nz domain name growth

One of the things I follow quite intently is growth in domain names – both internationally, but also especially in the .nz top level domain.

One of the reasons for my interest, is I am a director of .nz Registry Services that runs the register for the .nz TLD. But I am also interested in what they may mean generally for Internet uptake and more recently the health of the economy.

For the last six years or so, there has been almsot ever increasing growth in .nz domain name registrations.

nz1

As uou can see, the growth has been rather healthy. But in the last year, the market has changed. It is still growing, but by far less than before.

nz2

So annual growth in .nz names has dropped from over 50,000 to under 35,000 and still declining.

nz3

Looking at the last few years in terms of percentage annual growth, we hit 25% around two years ago, and it is now down to just 10%. Now 10% annual growth is still pretty good – many businesses would give their right arm for it. But it is interesti ng trying to work out why the growth has reduced so much.

Is it everyone is now connected? Is it the best names are all gone? Is it the recession? That’s some of the quesions I’m grappling with.

One interesting thing is that the drop in growth seems to be due to increased cancellations of existing names, than a large drop off in registrations of new names. So some of it may be speculators reducing their stocks. Or it may be businesses just rationalising their portfolios.

At the end of the day the cost of a domain name is insignificant to most customers. The wholesale fee is $1.50 a month. So how elastic or inelastic is the market I wonder?

The other interesting aspect is competition. If you want a .nz domain name you can choose from around 70 different registrars or retailers, but they all interface with the unique register (it is a naturaly monopoly because you can have only one authoritative register). But people can choose to get a .com, .net, .info etc.  In some countries more registrants have a .com name than a .countrycode name. In NZ we have one of the higher country loyalties with most registrants having a .nz name over a .com.

If you are a domain name registrant, and you have been changing or reducing your “portfolio”, I’d be interested in any  stories as to why.

Spin of the Year Nominee

A deserved nominee for the good spin of the year award goes to my friend Paul Brislen from Vodafone for his comments in this article on how the cost of cellphones takes up more of a young person’s disposable income, and hence less young people are smoking.

British experts believe cellphones have replaced many of the social mechanisms cigarettes previously offered young people.

Vodafone New Zealand spokesman Paul Brislen said the cost of cellphones would take up more of a typical young person’s disposable income.

“The disposable income moves around and these days it’s far more important to them to have the latest phone with all the music on it than it is to have something else going on,” he said. “It’s a social status symbol.”

There should be a Qantas Award for such work 🙂

Monday’s Three MPs

The Herald continues its profiles of the 34 or so new MPs:

Nikki Kaye

New Auckland Central MP Nikki Kaye said the chance to reform Auckland’s regional governance was a “once in a generation opportunity” which if done right would be a critical legacy of the National government. …

She said the solution needed to balance a simpler structure while still ensuring community representation, and spoke about the diversity of her electorate and the different needs within it – from the apartment dwellers in the inner city to those living with the raw beauty and infrastructure needs of Great Barrier Island and the “Waihetians” – those from Waiheke Island.

Nikki is very lucky to have Waiheke and Great Barrier Island in her electorate. While they make it harder to get around the electorate, they’re both beautiful places to visit.

The second youngest MP in this term of Parliament, the 28-year-old Ms Kaye said to her generation would fall the task of coping with a new set of problems brought about by medical and technological advances.

While the information age had brought “immense power” so too had it brought challenges, such as ethical issues and privacy concerns.”Most people would applaud when they see genetics providing information that can help treat diseases such as cancer. However, our ability to obtain information about children not born yet is an example where not all of society may be on the same page. This Parliament and future Parliaments will grapple with these issues.”

Design your own child – it’s not that far away!

Todd McClay

Married with four children aged 1 to 10. Spent much of his working life overseas with the European Parliament where jobs included chief of staff to the leader of the British Conservatives and policy adviser.

Has also acted as policy adviser to the Irish Fianna Fail Political Group. In the private sector, he was founder and chief executive of the European Generic Medicines Association and a political adviser for lobby groups.

Was ambassador for Niue and the Cook Islands to the European Union from 2001 to 2007. Has honorary Cook Islands citizenship and is completing a masters degree in international public law.

There should be a bravery award also for living in Brussels for so long 🙂

In his own words:
“Many years ago, New Zealand society was based on the structure of the family. Neighbours knew and liked each other. Rural communities were strong and perhaps life was simpler. When a school needed a new swimming pool or a small community needed a hall, funds were raised to buy timber and cement. Now funds are raised for resource consent and development levies and many of our children no longer know how to catch a fish or climb a tree.”

All too sadly true.

Raymond Huo

Immigrated in 1994. He was son of a doctor and nurse, who had moved to a rural town in China to help fight schistosoma. Toward the end of the Cultural Revolution, his father – an “intellectual” – was ordered to stand at the gates of the hospital for an hour, three times a day with a white board stating “counter-revolutionary medical expert”. Mr Huo – then 5 – joined him with a smaller whiteboard saying “little counter-revolutionary medical expert”.

He said he secretly believed it was his little sign that ended the Cultural Revolution soon afterward.

That’s a superb story. Very cute.

In his own words:
“In hindsight, my journey to this House stretches back to my birth in that small rural town, from that small stage I once shared with my father and from the desire for free will that I inherited from my parents. That experience was relevant. It influenced and will continue to influence my politics and world outlook. I have learned to be resilient, I have learned to be kind, caring and more philosophical when confronting difficulties. To those who asked of my ‘secret weapon’ behind successful careers in Beijing and now New Zealand, I say it is simple: Double your efforts and halve your expectations.”

He should pass that advice on to Phil Goff 🙂

The tragic death of Halatau Naitoko

It appears to be the first occassion in NZ that the Police have accidentially killed an innocent bystander – Halatau Naitoko.

Your first sympathies are with the family, whose grief will never totally fade.

In my case there is also considerable sympathy for the Police involved. As the NZ Herald writes today, it appears they were forced to open fire to protect other’s lives. All the Police involved will feel awful at the loss of innocent life.

It goes without saying that there must be a fully independent inquiry (which the IPCA) of what happened, and also a determination of whether there is any criminal culpability.

I disagree with Idiot/Savant at No Right Turn who argues the Police shooter must face trial. He is actually arguing for a trial regardless of the facts. He is actually arguing for Police officers to have less rights than any other NZer.

I believe we should wait for the facts to be established, before you can possibly know whether or not this is a criminal offence. Having said that there will be some suspicion about what is and is not a fact. I recall the tube shooting in London a few years ago. Initially it seemed the Police actions were quite justified. Later it emerged it was a terrible terrible stuff up, and the facts were very different to what we first thought.

So I’m not going to place too much reliance on initial reports (including today’s one quoted above) and wait for the full investigation.

I’m also going to remember that the person who has major shared culpability is the gunman whom the Police were engaged in a firefight with.

Wellington’s Northern Walkway

Very happy to have completed Wellington’s Northern Walkway today.

I’ve walked various parts of it in the past, but never done the whole thing in one go. It is a 16 km trek, and with an extra walk home at the end probably did close to 20 kms all up.

dpf-008

The start of the Northern Walkway in Johnsonville. It’s reasonably steep getting up to Mt Kaukau.

dpf-014

The city view from Mt Kaukau. Almost worth the climb!

dpf-022

Mt Cowcow instead of Mt Kaukau 🙂

dpf-023

And the view towards the west coast from the trig station.

dpf-029

Part of the long path down from Mt Kaukau to Khandallah.

dpf-031

After Khandallah you walk along the road to Ngaoi, and then head through Trellissick Park, which then climbs steeply up to Wadestown.

dpf-033

The zoom lens captures the cruise ship docked by the stadium, from Tinakori Hill.

dpf-038

Thorndon and the harbour from Tinakori Hill on a very sunny day.

dpf-039

A great view of Premier House from behind and above it. We waved to JK but alas no-one seemed to be home.

dpf-041

Some nice colour near the end of the walkway, just before it ends opposite the Botanic Gardens.

Over the next few weekends, I’m hoping to do all the big walkways – Southern, Skyline, City to Sea etc. It’s a great way to spend a Sunday morning. However I suspect I will be very sore on Monday.

Paula confirmed as true Westie

As final proof that Social Development Minister Paula Bennett is a true Westie, the Herald on Sunday reveals that the father of her daughter’s daughter is a young gang member.

The Herald on Sunday have worked hard to make this newsworthy, proclaiming:

Police said Halaholo, 23, was a member of the Thugs of Canal, a so-called youth gang based around Canal St in Avondale. The gang members reportedly have a history of violence and intimidation, creating the risk inappropriate pressure could be brought to bear on the senior minister and her decisions.

I don’t see that Paula gets much choice in who her daughter chooses as a partner, and her “crime” seems to be allowing him to live with her a couple of years ago. The article goes on to say:

Yesterday, Halaholo’s father Lolo Halaholo, 42, said Bennett had been trying to support her daughter and family by taking in her granddaughter’s father.

Viliami Halaholo left Avondale College aged 17 and got work with a road crew. He had been in regular police trouble because of his involvement in up to 10 fights, his father said.

Halaholo’s aunty, Tolo Langi, said her nephew had settled down after meeting Ana, but had still hung around Avondale with his gang associates.

Ana studied at Excel Ministries School of Performing Arts before becoming a mum.

Ana and Halaholo plan to set up house with their child and Halaholo’s other toddler daughter when he gets out, Langi said. The family hoped he would be up for parole this year.

I think this just shows that Paula continues to face the challenges of being a mum, and a grandmum.