Alternate reality alert

MacDoctor highlights a visit to an alternate reality by Phil Goff”

There is an old adage that if you are going to lie, then you are more likely to get away with it the more outrageous and barefaced the lie. I’m not sure if that is true, but Phil Goff certainly believes this. On the same day that the “hole” in the ACC accounts mushroomed to a staggering $2.5 billion, Phil “I want to be a real boy” Goff made this statement:

Labour leader Phil Goff said Treasury’s briefing highlighted that National had inherited a healthy set of books and it should not be squandered.

I’m impressed, Phil. Machiavelli himself couldn’t have told such a whopper. I particularly enjoyed the suggestion that National might squander the money that you have so carefully built up. Very ballsy of you, I must say.

Unfortunately, I think you might find that that nice Mr Key is just lacing up his hobnail boots…

Can someone let me know in what dimension the following is considered a healthy set of books:

  • A decade of deficits projected
  • Debt to increase by over $30 billion from 20% of GDP to 30% of GDP
  • Inflation at 5%
  • Unemployment projected to hit 6%
  • A recession
  • Billions of dollars needed to bailout ACC

At the first question time, some Govt backbenchers should ask questions to Mr English on whether he agrees Mr Goff has left him “a healthy set of books”.

UPDATE: The crown accounts out today show the Government’s surplus has plunged by $5 billion from a $1.5 surplus to a $3.5 billion deficit. More of Phil’s healthy set of books! The plunge is primarily due to unrealised losses on investments, but they will have flow on effects to income and lead to increased debt.

Bevan Burgess

I saw a small item in the Dominion Post about Mary Potter Hospice and was surprised and saddened to see that the patient pictured is a fomer colleague of mine – Bevan Burgess.

Bevan worked for Bill Birch in the 1990s, but was more well known as Press Secretary to Roger Douglas in the 1980s. Bevan was credited with being a crucial force for reform in the Government. And when things started to go sour between Douglas and Lange, Douglas kept triumphing in Cabinet partly because Bevan was so much better at his job than the 9th floor were at theirs.

The legend goes that when Bevan’s ministerial contract came up for renewal, Lange rescinded the delegation to Ministerial Services for staffing, personally vetoed Beven’s contract renewal, and then handed the delegation back. Lange’s actions in doing this are acknowledged as being the major catalyst that led to Douglas leaving Cabinet.

I don’t know Bevan particularly well but did chat to him a few times and always found him fascinating to talk to, and difficult to reconcile this softly spoken man with the legendary caricature of his role in the fourth Labour Government, where I had imagined him as some sort of cross between Machiavelli and John Pagani on steroids – a spin doctor par excellence. I realised Bevan had been so sucessful not because of any “spin” skills but because of his enormous capability for work and rational analysis.

It goes without saying that as Bevan is at Mary Potter, I assume the outlook is sadly not positive. Without it sounding like an inapproriate eulogy in advance, I do hope that his enoromous contribution to New Zealand is recognised, and how it was much more than just being the press secretary sacked by David Lange.

The blame game

Had a very pleasant night at the Agenda Christmas Party. What I like about it is so many of the people there are interesting and you can have fascinating discussions on topics from the Canadian constitutional crisis to Cicero.

One of the attendees was NBR Editor Nevil Gibson. It was when I was chatting to him that I suddenly realised I hadn’t written my weekly NBR online column. Doing it last night wasn’t a sensible option, but thankfully I have now done it this morning and it is online at NBR, called The Blame Game.

Treasury get best play of the week for being brave enough to say unpopular things in their BIM, the Defence Force gets worst play of the week and the undisclosed ACC bailouts win scandal of the week.

ODT on ACC cover up

The ODT concludes Labour has not changed its sports:

In 1990, 16 hours after he took office as prime minister, National’s Jim Bolger was informed by the Treasury and the Reserve Bank that the Bank of New Zealand – then Government-owned – was on the verge of insolvency.

Its failure might put at risk the entire financial system. A capital injection was required immediately, and it was no small sum: $600 million.

The outgoing Labour government, led by Mike Moore, had not disclosed the need or that the overall fiscal situation had deteriorated by a further $1.5 billion.

The 1994 Fiscal Responsibility Act was a consequence of this, with the intention of full disclosure by a sitting government of the State’s financial situation before a general election – the so called pre-election update.

Had it existed in 1990, Labour could not have avoided disclosing the truth about the BNZ and the fiscal consequences of its policies. Or so it was thought.

If it is true that there may be a $1 billion “hole” needing to be filled by the new Government, and the Clark Cabinet decided not to tell anyone about it, then it is obvious Labour is back to its deceptive tricks.

There is more to come out about this. I’ve heard whispers that Labour were told of the need for a bailout in the non-earners account as far back as early 2007!!

Mr Parker’s response to all this is indicative of an attitude of mind that is childish.

It may well be that on a strictly legal basis former ministers are not obliged to warn their replacements in a new administration of major unfunded problems, and it may be very amusing for a losing administration to chortle at the resulting political and policy fall-out, but it is entirely against the spirit of good government and the intent of the “no surprises” Fiscal Responsibility Act.

The reality is Labour knew about the need for a bailout for months and months. They merely delayed making a decision on it, to avoid PREFU disclosure.

No jail for the perv

What do you have to do to get sent to jail? The ODT reports:

Central Otago hostel owner Phillip Anderson filmed his female guests for a year through a two-way mirror he installed in their bathroom, a court has been told.

When he finally felt remorseful about what he was doing, he ripped the camera out and destroyed the tapes — except for a two-hour highlights package which he watched during pornography evenings with a friend.

Let’s see if I have this right? He felt remorseful, so he made a highlights package!!!

Anderson, 44, who was running a backpackers hostel at Tarras, near Wanaka, was yesterday sentenced in Alexandra District Court to 150 hours’ community work and nine months’ supervision, The Southland Times reported.

That is such a betrayal of trust, I am amazed he only got community work. Disgusting.

Merry Christmas from Labour

Labour have left workers with another lovely christmas present. On top of the billion shortfall in the non-earners ACC account, is seems ACC also needs $1.337 billion more over the next three years for the earners account.

This is funded by almost every employee in NZ through a $1.40 per $100 levy. But Labour has left ACC so short of funds, that it needs to have the levy increased to $2.20 per $100.

What does this mean for your family? Well if both parents earn say $50,000 then that is $600 less they”ll have for Christmas next year, $700 less for the year after and $800 less for the year after that.

Have a Merry Christmas from Labour!

General Debate 4 December 2008

The Obama Cabinet

I have to say that Obama looks to have put together a very strong Cabinet. He has wisely abandoned his pre-election rhetoric about change, and stolen half the former Clinton Administration, including the Clintons! Also has abandoned the nonsense about just fleeing from Iraq by keeping on Bush’s Secretary of Defence. So who are the appointments:

  • Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. Brillant for Obama as neutralises them, forces Bill to have his diary vetted, and his administration gets to benefit from the massive set fo contacts the Clintons have internationally.
  • Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel. Emanuel is an economic liberal (anti regulation) and a very tough politician. Those who think Obama will pursue a socialist agenda, should look at Emanuel’s record. Of course Obama promised all sorts of socialist stuff, but he deosn’t actually have to deliver on that as people will love him anyway. Emanuel also voted for the Iraq War and doesn’t blame Israel for all the problems in the Middle East. He’s not a Republican, but he’s my sort of Democrat.
  • Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner. Geithner is President of the New York Federal Reserve. He actually arranged the Bear Stearns bailout, and is a very experienced choice for these times.
  • Peter Orszag is the Office of Management and Budget DIrector. He currently heads the Congressional Budget Office and even blogs from there!  A bit left for my liking but definitely experienced.
  • As previously mentioned Defence Secretary Robert Gates will remain in office – the first ever Defence Secretary to do so across parties. Gates was CIA Director under Bush 41.
  • Attorney-General Eric Holder has a very good career in his early days but blotted his copybook with involvment in the disgraceful Clinton pardon of Marc Rich. I suspect he will not last a full term.
  • Arizona Governor Janet Napolitano is to be Homeland Security Secretary and is well regarded as a competent Governor. Homeland Security is huge though and will be a challenge.
  • Bill Richardson as Commerce Secretary is anotehr former Governor. Very sensible making use of people with executive experience. Plus it is a reward for him for deserting the Clintons.
  • Tom Daschle I do not like. A nasty man.  I think Secretary of Health and Human Services is beyond him and like Mrs Clinton he will fail at healthcare reform.
  • Absolute genius to appoint Paul Volcker to head a Economic Recovery Advisory Board, Volcker is a God.
  • General James Jones is inspired choice for National Security Advisor. Jones is a four star Marine General and has served as Supreme Allied Commander Europe and as Commandant of the Marine Corps. Condi Rice tried to get him to be Deputy Secretary of State. He declined but has done work in the Middle East for her.

So far, so good for Obama. Of course the real challenges lie ahead.

OCR drops 1.5%

Small world

Am flying up to Auckland at 11 am today, but went to the Airport early so my flatmate could drop me off and use the car to get around.

As I sit down at a table in the Koru Club, the guy opposite me informs me I haven’t posted since 6.45 am this morning, and he has been hitting the refresh key!

Incidentally there will be a posting drought from late Friday afternoon to Sunday afternoon, as will be on Great Barrier Island again. I have to say I love that place – it is a great location to get away from it all.

Worst business jargon phrases

Sideswipe reports on a survey of the worst business jargon:

1. Thinking outside of the box.
2. Touch base.
3. At the end of the day.
4. Going forward.
5. All of it.
6. Blue sky thinking.
7. Out of the box.
8. Credit crunch.
9. Heads up.
10. Singing from the same hymn sheet.
11. Pro-active.
12. Downsizing.
13. Ducks in a row.
14. Brainstorming.
15. Thought shower.
16. 360-degree thinking.
17. Flag it up.
18. Pushing the envelope.
19. At this moment in time.
20. In the loop.

I am guilty of often using Nos 2, 6, 9, 11, 14 and 20!

Herald on ACC blowout

The NZ Herald Editorial:

Nasty surprises for incoming prime ministers were meant to be eliminated by Ruth Richardson’s 1994 Fiscal Responsibility Act. The legislation obliged Governments to throw open the books before an election, exposing the Treasury’s best estimates and forecasts. The praiseworthiness of such transparency was quickly recognised at home and abroad. But, unfortunately, the law’s good intention has not been accompanied by scrupulous observance of its spirit and thrust. The latest transgressor is Labour’s ACC spokesman, David Parker, who insists former Cabinet ministers were not obliged to reveal a $1 billion hole in the Accident Compensation Corporation budget before the election.

And remember Labour also say that the $1 billion blowout is not significant.

Mr Parker, for his part, said Maryan Street denied knowing details of the shortfall until October, when she immediately told the Finance Minister at the time, Michael Cullen, and the Treasury. That happened after the Treasury had prepared its pre-election fiscal update. While this meant no specifics of the ACC’s problem could be included in that document, Mr Parker did not explain why these could not have been revealed to the public once they were known.

This, of course, should have been the case. The spirit of the fiscal responsibility law demands as much. An addendum could have been attached to the pre-election update or a public statement about the ACC budget released. Even before then, a fiscal risk flag could have been placed on the pre-election update, as is customary for unquantified sums in pre-Budget documents.

The Herald nails it in one. They could have still released the info or as a minimum flagged it in PREFU as an unquantified risk.

The new Telecom

John Drinnan in the Herald looks at the new Telecom:

Telecommunications industry watchdog Ernie Newman likes the new, higher profile. He was especially impressed by a newspaper advertisement apologising to customers for disruptions to the broadband service Yahoo!Xtra in downtown Auckland on Friday night. It featured a signed photograph of Reynolds.

Yes a good move.

Telecom advertising had been as pervasive as ever but it had kept a low corporate profile since the Telecommunications Act 2006 when an overwhelming majority of MPs came down on Telecom.

“They hit Telecom hard and it really did not want to stick its head up very much.

“It had to retrench a little and show some humility. Before 2006 they were totally focused on the message and its marketing implications and honesty and integrity got lost in that.

“Paul Reynolds is a very good frontman who seriously believes in what he was doing and he is a very good look for Telecom.”

In fact it is almost impossible to find someone who will say a bad word about Reynolds. A rare feat in and industry or company, let alone the CEO of Telecom.

Rodney faces prosecution for his yellow jacket

The Electoral Commission has found four items were illegal election advertisements, and has referred three of them to the Police for possible prosecution. The one that will get all the news is that Rodney Hide’s yellow jacket has been referred.

ACT told the Electoral Commission that Rodney rectified any problems by affixing an authorisation inside the jacket that can be shown to anyone who asks to see it, but this wasn’t deemed sufficient. So Rodney and his jacket may end up in the dock. That’s a shame as no doubt he’ll start weariing it again!

It does show of course how stupid the law is.

The Greens had some unauthorised fence signs in Palmerston North, but ruled the breach inconsequential.

National MP Nicky Wagner has been referred to the Police. It seems she distributed printouts of some powerpoint slides at a meeting and the final slide had tick Wagner and tick National. That made it an election advertisement. I think this is the first National breach of the law.

Finally a flyer for Roger Douglas put together by his local campaign team was not authorised by the ACT Party Secretary, so was also a breach of the EFA and has been referred to the Police.

I wonder if the law will be repealed before any prosecutions occur?

The crisis in Canada

Extraordinary things have been happening in Canada. Just two months ago they had a general election, and as I blogged at the time it was very sucessful for the incumbent minority Conservative Government of Stephen Harper. They missed out on winning a majority in Parliament (something very hard to do) but they gained 19 seats, the Liberals lost 27.

It was such a trouncing that the Leader of the Liberal Party, Stéphane Dion, announced he was resigning as Leader, and elections are underway to select his replacement. These take several months as they involve party members. Anyway next week Dion may become the 23rd Prime Minister of Cabinet. How? Well it’s an intriguing story.

First of all you need to understand that the tradition in Canada is that the largest party gets to form the Government, even as a minority. They may not last the full term, but they usually get a couple of years at least of governing. On top of the the two main parties you have the New Democratic Party which is like the Alliance in NZ and generally wins seats in British Colombia in the west, plus the Bloc Québécois who win most of the seats in Quebec and are a separatist party.

Generally after every election these two smaller parties will give confidence and supply to the largest party, even though NDP is a lot closer to Liberals than Conservatives. They do not guarantee it for the full term, but if they change their mind, normally it triggers a new election.

After the October election, the Conservatives had support from both the NDP and the Bloc. It was business as normal. But the credit crisis hit, and the response from the Conservatives was to trim Government spending such as no pay incraeses for Judges, restrictions on MPs travel, cancellign Xmas bonus for publuic servants. This was bad enough for the leftwing parties, but even worse Harper’s Government announced it would save money by trimming the $27 million of taxpayer state funding for political parties.

This threat to the other parties funding base (since state funding they had become very dependent on it) was intolerable, so they got together to roll the Government on the grounds of an inadequate response to the credit crisis.

Now what they have done is not force a new election, but they have formed a Government in waiting. The Liberal, NDP and Bloc parties have written to the Governor-General announcing they wish to form a new Government being a Liberal-NDP coalition, with support from the Bloc.

The Liberal and NDP parties are usually fiercious rivals, but have put that aside to agree NDP get one quarter of the Cabinet seats in the first ever coalition between them.

But the extraordinary thing is that they have agreed to make Stéphane Dion Prime Minister despite Dion getting the worst result in history for the Liberals – just 26%. He will be PM for half a year or so until the Liberals elect a new leader.

Now this is all constitutional – Parliament can form whatever Government it wants. But is it what the Canadian people wanted or voted for? There was no pre-election possibility of NDP and the Bloc supporting the Liberals if they came second.

It also creates a headache for the Governor-General (who is flying home urgently from an overseas trip) as she has to decide what to do given the following scenarios:

  1. PM Harper asks the Governor-General to prorogue Parliament until next year. The Governor-General has the legal right to refuse a request from the prime minister to prorogue, and in NZ would arguably refuse such a request as the PM can no longer demonstrate the confidence of the House. But most experts in Canada say the GG would grant the request. The prorogue would mean that the no confidence vote scheduled for Monday would never be put. Parliament only has to meet once a year, so it could be prorogued until late next year in theory.
  2. PM Harper asks the Governor-General to call a new election. Again the same dilemma – does the GG follow the advice of a PM that no longer has the confidence of the House?
  3. Parliament is prorogued but the Opposition Leader demands the GG appoint him Prime Minister as he has a majority of MPs supporting him. Does the GG have to wait for a confidence vote to determine that the House has lost confidence? In NZ I would say they do not, but in Canada this is new territory.

In 1926 the Canadian Governor-General, Lord Byng refused a request by Prime Minister King for a general election as Byng did not have the confidence of the House.

The bigger question is what will the public make of it. The Conservatives already have ads playing quoting a speech from Dion during the last election campaign in which he ruled out a coalition with the NDP. “You cannot have a coalition with a party that has a platform that would be damaging for the economy, period,” he says in the clip.

The Conservatives are using the lines that Dion has done a deal with the socialist and the separatists to seize power. Now that is emotive but little things can matter to people. When the three opposition leaders announced their agreement to change the Government, the Canadian flag backdrop was removed from the room of their press conference because the separatists don’t believe in Canada existing in its current form.

It is not impossible that this deal could see other provinces such as Alberta threaten to leave Canada. Also the Bloc have only promised support to the new Government in waiting until June 2010, so more elections are likely at some stage.

Also in a twist to the crisis, the NDP accidentially sent details of one of their conference calls to a Conservative MP and he taped the call and released it to the media. It revealed that the NDP had been trying to get the Bloc to agree to support a new Government for longer than previously though. The NDP are asking for Police to prosecute the Conservatives over the recording.

It is going to be fascinating to see what the PM does, what the Governor-General does and also what the Canadian public do.

Dim-Post on Thailand

The Dim-Post:

National leader John Key lashed out at the government today, calling their handling of the ongoing crisis in Thailand’s airports ‘hopeless, clumsy, inadequate and basically stink’….

‘This is unacceptable,’ Key said while addressing print and broadcast media during a parliamentary press conference. ‘When hundreds of Kiwi’s are stranded and in danger of their lives it is the role of the government to step in and help out. That they have failed to do so is nothing short of disgusting.’ …

Key intends to raise the matter in the house when Parliament returns next week.

‘The Prime Minister won’t be able to dodge the issues then,’ Key said. ‘He’s going to get the shock of his life.’

Heh.

Ironic

The ODT reports:

Drunken teenagers at a party funded by a high school’s anti-drink-driving group have trashed a rural Southland hall.

Bottles were thrown at passing cars and into a children’s playground during the out-of-control party, organised by high school pupils using money from the St Peter’s College SADD (Students Against Driving Drunk) committee, last Friday.

Good old Gore never disappoints 🙂

Labour don’t get it

Labour are squealing over the $1 billion ACC blowout that they kept secret. NZPA reports:

Labour’s ACC spokesman, David Parker, said today Mr Key’s assertions were wrong and the Government was trying to divert attention from its plans to privatise ACC.

You always know someone is cornered when they start trying to distract from the issue by raising the nasty bogeyman hiding under the bed of privatisation.

He said he had spoken to former ACC minister Maryan Street who denied knowing any details of the shortfall until October, when she immediately told former finance minister Michael Cullen and the Treasury.

Note her careful use of words – denied knowing the details. She was informed as far back as May of the blowout, just not the exact figure.

Mr Parker said officials told ministers at the time it would be improper for the extra money to be authorised during the election campaign.

And Parker also misses the point. Even if they did not authorise the extra money, they could have disclosed the blowout voluntarily. That is the point – they knew PREFU was lacking a very significant item. And it is not as if there is any choice about the bailout – the Government can’t simply chooise to stop paying out ACC claims. If the blowout had been in welfare, then the adjustment would have been automatically reflected in forecasts.

It is also debatable if it was improper for the Government to approve funding the shortfall. They approved $150 billion depost guarantee during the election, so what is $297 million compared to that? And again this wasn’t some sort of discretionary expenditure such as deciding to build a new road – it was an obligation.

“There’s some really alarmist language being used around this … it’s 6 per cent of the ACC budget, it’s been blown out of all proportion.”

And this shows why they are unfit to be given the fiscal pursestrings again. David Parker saying that $1 billion over three years is nothing to be alarmed about. Think about how many hip operations, how many exra nurses, how many more computers in schools that would buy?

And his 6% of ACC budget is misleading, as the blowout is in one fund and it is around a 25% blowout in that fund. But hey we now know Labour don’t think 25% blowouts to the tune of a million dollars are worth worrying about, let alone telling anyone about.

Waitaki River power station approved

Good news that commissioners have given consent to Meridian Energy for a 1100Gwh to 1400GWh power station on the Waitaki River.

If we want to transition away from non-renewable energy to renewables, then projects like these are essential.

Of course this is just the first step of the consent process. There are inevitable appeals to the Environment Court. Actual construction is still four years away from beginning!

Armstrong on Key

John Armstrong writes:

In his handling of the first “crisis” to confront him as Prime Minister, John Key has been taught a few instructive lessons about not just keeping in step with public opinion, but the need to stay ahead of it.

In sending an Air Force Hercules to Malaysia in readiness to ferry stranded New Zealanders out of next-door Thailand, Key has emerged on the right side of the ledger after what was a mixed 24 hours for him.

For those who think it is the Government’s job to send planes to foreign countries, because those stranded don’t want to take the train.

On Monday, Key had talked confidently of the “options” available to his Government, including chartering an Air New Zealand plane or dispatching an Air Force passenger aircraft to Thailand to pick up the New Zealanders stuck there because of the blockade of Bangkok’s international airport.

Key, however, was left somewhat red-faced yesterday when he had to admit neither of the Air Force’s two Boeing 757s was available for a rescue mission because they were undergoing special maintenance in the United States.

Oh yes, the induction for all new PMs – learning how often there are no suitable Air Force planes available.

However, with Australia being seen to be doing more for its citizens marooned in the Thai capital, public sentiment was starting to shift away from the view that being stuck in Bangkok was simply bad luck to a view expecting the Government to make every effort to bring New Zealanders home as soon as possible.

I am not necessairly disagreeing, but I do wonder on what basis assertions such as “public sentiment was starting to shift” are made.

Donations over $20,000

Just had another look at the Electoral Commission page of donations over $20,000 to political parties. By now any pre-election donations must have been declared. So how much did each party receive in large (over $20k) donations?

  1. ACT $300,000 (Alan Gibbs $200K, John Boscawen $100k)
  2. Greens $182,926 (various)
  3. Labour $160,000 (Velas $100K, EPMU $60k)
  4. NZ First $100,000 (Velas $60k)
  5. National $60,000 (John Key $30k, Road Transport Trust $30k)

And almost every large donations is from an individual who is a known supporter. Well plus the Velas whose generosity to Labour was previously unknown.

But just remember these declarations the next time people go on about big money. National had the 5th largest amount of declared over $20k donations.

Of course this is not the full picture. National did receive a lot of money through trusts prior to 2008, but that is all history now. Also there are the anonymous donations through the Electoral Commission – but as it is a serious offence to inform a party you have donated that way, there can be no suspicion of favours for donations. Also in May next year we’ll see any donations over $10K and under $20K that were made.

Exhaustion

There may be some activity that is more tiring than spending an hour on a trampoline with a five year old and a six year old, but off hand I can’t think what it would be.

We came up with a new variation where I go underneath the trampoline and push upwards as they jump to see how high I can bounce them. Almost got them over the safety net a couple of times but not quite!

I’m quite used to babysitting my niece by now, but my brother forgot to mention she had a friend staying over tonight. Two of them is a lot more challenging than one. I really thinks parents who have to do this every night do deserve some sort of medal!

Anyway I suspect 9.39 pm is past their bedtime, despite their insistence it is not, so time to try and get them into bed. How many bedtime stories will it take? On average it has taken three in the past!

Ministerial Inquiry into ACC blowout

John Key has announced a ministerial inquiry into the previous Government’s underfunding of ACC. It seems that the non-earners account is going to run out of money by March, and overall is underfunded for the next three years by around a billion dollars.

Not quite as bad as the BNZ bailout, but you do wonder what other timebombs have Labour left behind?

What is especially bad is that even though a bailout is inevitable, Cabinet refused to make a decision, as by not making a decision, the shortfall would not show up in the pre-election accounts – PREFU.

OIA game playing

The Chief Ombudsmen has put diplomacy to one side and in the annual report to Parliament has accused some public servants of game playing with the Official Information Act.

This is what people mean when they refer to the politicisation of the public service.

Some public servants playing games with OIA requests

The Office of the Ombudsmen is concerned some parts of the public service have been deliberately delaying responses to Official Information requests.

In the office’s Annual Report to Parliament, Chief Ombudsmen Beverley Wakem says the practice is unacceptable and subverts the purpose of the legislation.

Beverley Wakem says the Office has observed an increasing tendency by a few government departments and Ministerial offices to ignore the provisions of the Official Information Act over the timing of responses to requesters.

They should name and shame Departments and Offices who have been game playing.