Two high profile Pacific endorsements

The Herald reports:

Former All Blacks Michael Jones and Inga Tuigamala have today backed John Key’s National Party. …

“We don’t want our people just working in factories”, said Tuigamala. “We want them starting to own those factories.”

They were attending National leader John Key’s announcement of his party’s plan to create five new trades academies, which was made at the Southern Cross campus, a centre for Maori and Pacific Island education located in Mangere, Auckland.

Pity they are not standing – the parliamentary rugby team woud be much improved!

The Herald on Sunday also focused on some endorsements, which were interesting:

  • Sir Paul Reeves – Labour party vote, Maori Party electorate vote – used to give Labour electorate vote
  • Graham Lowe – voting ACT after 40 years with Labour
  • Oscar Kightley – remaining Labour
  • Miriama Smith – Greens on both votes – used to give Labour electorate vote
  • Michael Hill – National – has never endorsed before
  • Bevan Docherty – voting National – normally a Labour voter

So of the six people, two are defecting on the party vote from Labour, and two defecting on the electorate vote.

UPDATE: Colin Espiner blogs:

… getting Inga and Michael Jones on board is a stroke of genius. The pair are absolute legends amongst their communities – well, the whole country actually – but particularly in South Auckland. They were mobbed at Southern Cross school by ecstatic youngsters who knew exactly who they were, despite the fact that most of them weren’t even born when these guys last played.

At Progressive, Inga and Michael drew a big crowd of mainly Pacific Island workers in their overalls and steel caps, who cheered and clapped after they spoke.

I know what you’re thinking. So what? It was the rugby heros they were applauding, not Key. And yet talking to some of them afterwards, it was clear they were mighily impressed that Key had the support of Inga and Michael. And they didn’t just endorse Key. They called him their friend, and told the factory workers that they could trust him and he would make their lives and their families lives better.

The pair argued that while Labour had worked hard for Pacific people, there was nothing to be feared from change and that their community should lift its sights. “We don’t want to just work in this factory, we should own this factory. Our children should own this factory,” Jones told them. It was a powerful message.

Better late than never

Well done to the Greens for ruling out sitting around a Cabinet table with Winston. I am pleased. This isolates Helen Clark further as the only party leader still supporting Winston and saying he did nothing wrong and she would be happy to have him as a Minister again.

However there are a few things to note:

  • The decision, while welcome, contradicts the reason that had been given previously for not ruling Winston out – that such decisions can only be made by the members in general meeting.
  • They have not ruled out giving confidence and supply to a Government with Winston in it – they have just said they will not be Cabinet Ministers themselves in it.
  • It is unclear whether they would refuse to serve in Cabinet if Peters is a Minister outside Cabinet
  • They have said they would serve in Government with NZ First, so long as Peters personally is not a Minister. This is not was unequivocal as John Key’s position.

I also support the Greens on having a commission of inquiry into the allegations in the Meurant papers. I also support establishment of a permament anti-corruption commission that can police Ministers, government agencies and senior officals not just for breaches of the criminal law but for abuse of office for personal gain.

Hilarious but not intentionally

Readers will have followed how Winston denied on Agenda that he had ever used a helicopter for campaigning, and within hours photos of him doing just that emerged.

Well here is what he now says:

It is difficult to believe, but just five days from polling day and we are having to waste time talking about past campaigns and helicopters! This is just another media sideshow to divert voters from the real issues they face.

Actually the issue is whether you sold policy for use of the helicopter.

New Zealand First has used helicopters for travel during two election campaigns – but not for campaigning itself.

Oh, of course a vital difference. It only provided travel so you could campaign, but did not campaign itself. And here was me thinking the helicopter was actualyl going to front up and deliver the speech also.

The way a question was framed on Agenda yesterday implied that we had used a helicopter to campaign from, which of course was ridiculous because of the physical impossibility of speaking to crowds in a noisy gale.

Indeed that is ridiculous, which is why no one would interpret it that way. Everyone knows what was meant was did you have free use of a helicopter (normally $1,000+ an hour) for your travel for the election campaign.

We used a helicopter to travel and I do not deny that, but to suggest that I somehow stood at the door of a flying helicopter shouting at voters is preposterous. We were campaigning – not deerstalking!

It would almost be funny, if it were not for the very serious issues around why the helicopter was donated. That is the real issue – are the Meurant documents correct that there was a quid pro quo?

New Users

I’m always amazed at the number of different people who comment on this blog. The number of registered users has just about hit 3,500. Every day half a dozen more people register so they can make a comment. Of course on top of that there are all the masses or lurkers out there.

In October there were around 12,000 comments made. If each comment takes 15 seconds to read it would take 3,000 minutes or 50 hours to read them all!

Hooton’s final pre-election SST column

Matthew Hooton blogs his final pre-election SST column:

After the defeat in 1990 of the last Labour government, in which Helen Clark was deputy prime minister, the late, great left-wing writer, Bruce Jesson, confessed his difficulty in treating it fairly because, he wrote, he had come to despise them. “Everything I wrote about them,” he declared, “dripped with contempt. They were a government entirely without principle, cynical and untrustworthy, who clung to power for the sake of it.”

As a writer, I would not suggest to be even remotely in Jesson’s class, but I now know exactly how he felt.

There was a time when the Clark government was a breath of fresh air after the Bolger/Peters/Shipley fiasco. In 2000, I was perfectly happy to help the Labour Department sell Margaret Wilson’s Employment Relations Act and I even came to admire Clark’s leadership skills when I worked on the formation of Fonterra, a company that would not exist without her intervention.

I feel none of that now.

This is a sick, dying but dangerous government, reduced to sending its party president to Melbourne to dig through 13,000 pages of documents in the hope of finding something, anything, to smear its opponent. No matter that the Serious Fraud Office and all the Australian authorities have already gone through all the documents, jailed those who committed crimes, and exonerated those who were not involved, Mike Williams and his Labour operatives used taxpayers’ money to act as some sort of private, politically-motivated, parallel police force.

Nice.

It is keeping secret the true state of our accounts and instead of policy is offering only that, if re-elected, it will reveal its true intentions in a mini-Budget in December. Labour is turning the concept of a “hidden agenda” into an art form, yet Clark has the audacity to say the election is about trust.

The mini-Budget will inevitably be repugnant to New Zealanders. Just as Clark promised prior to the 2005 election that there would be no ban on smacking, she and Michael Cullen will be keeping secret measures they know would be opposed by the vast majority, otherwise they would announce them now.

Remember it’s all about trust!

John Key and the Economy

John Key, if he wins the election, may be the most economically literate Prime Minister New Zealand has had in recent decades. I think he will have a far greater understanding of business and the economy, than most people realise. Why do I say this?

Clark and Cullen never lose a chance to scoff at his former job, and call him a money trader, a currency dealer etc. And they are right – he was (amongst many other things). In fact he was one of the most successful people in the world at currency markets.

Now think about people who are world experts in a market. Take for example someone who is a world expert on the price of gold – they probably know more about gold than 99.99% of the population. They know all about production, distribution, prices, costs, delays, environmental issues etc so they can correctly predict what will happen to the price of gold.

The same applies to the world experts on futures markets about say bananas. These people will know more about the banana trade than most people would think you can know. They’ll know the diseases they can get, the temperature they grow best in, the cost and time to transport etc etc. For if they didn’t know this they wouldn’t be so successful year after year in making money predicting the price.

Now John Key is not an expert on the price of gold or the price of bananas. He is an expert on the price of a country’s currency, which is heaving influences by a country’s economic performance. This means he knows, and has a 20 year track record of stunning success on what factors push a currency up and down – interest rates, employment, labour productivity, level of taxation, construction activity, exports, imports, balance of payments current account etc etc. You do not make $50 million by accident on predicting what will happen to currencies. You understand the economic drivers of a couple of dozen economies and are better than almost all your peers at understanding them.

Agenda producer Richard Harman blogs:

Sunday did not begin auspiciously. We had agreed to interview Mr Key early. At 8.30 — so he could get a 10.00 a.m. flight to Wellington. Through either our stuff up or in Mr Key’s office, the Opposition leader arrived at 7.30. I got in just before 8 to find him in the Green Room with a press secretary quietly reading the Sunday papers. Shortly afterwards John Roughan and Vernon Small arrived and we were then treated to a fascinating 20 minutes from Mr Key as he explained (almost non stop) his own analysis of the American financial crisis and why it had happened. Along the way we got some revealing insights into the way Wall Street works and the mindsets of the traders in the markets. It was the kind of view only a top insider could give.

Today I have been talking to a former National MP who is close to Mr Key. He argues that the Opposition Leader has one of the sharpest minds he has ever met. That is not a view I have shared up till now. What I have seen of Mr Key has been pretty much what the public has seen; a warm, relaxed, sometimes bumbling person with a mind for numbers. But his talk in the Green Room revealed a different side and which today meant I could understand what the former MP meant.

John is very very sharp. Yes he is new to politics – only six years to Clark’s lifetime. But to say he is a fast learner is to put it mildly.

With the world facing the most difficult economic conditions in 70 years, I have absolutely no doubts about John Key’s ability to understand what is happening and to react to international economic events in a way of maximum benefit to New Zealand – not based on an narrow ideological system of beliefs, but with pragmatic responses based on two deacdes of experience.

So everytime a Labour MP scoffs at Key as a currency trader, just remember what that actually means – that John Key understands economies, and that MP does not.

Nice lines

NBR reports on some nice lines from John Key yesterday:

“I’ve had nine years of being told what lightbulb I can screw into the house, what shower I can take, what food I can eat, what things I can do, what thoughts I am allowed to have.

“I don’t need another three years of Helen Clark telling me what to do. I don’t need another three years of Jeanette Fitzsimons telling me what to do, I don’t need another three years of Winston Peters telling me he needs a God damn helicopter.”

Heh.

Winston’s Downfall

Mel Josephs

Heh I had to laugh at this story in the Dom Post:

Just like her favourite boy band, John Key left Mel Josephs breathless.

“I haven’t been this excited since the Westlife concert,” she gasped after running the length of Lower Hutt’s Queensgate mall to meet Mr Key.

The encounter came as Mr Key went walkabout and the political groupie was prepared to go to extraordinary lengths to get there.

“My friend texted me and told me he was down, so I ran to my mum.

“She wasn’t going to bring me, so I went to put on my running shoes – I was going to run down the river – but then she said, `I’ll take you’.”

The 19-year-old says she will vote for Mr Key. “He’s just awesome. I love him, He’s a fun guy. We need a change.”

Goodness, that makes my support seem tepid and hestitant!

Key himself blogged:

Yesterday I visited Queensgate Mall in Lower Hutt and was frankly surprised by the reaction.

Not one person had a negative thing to say to me in this traditionally Labour-leaning area.

There were undoubtedly people who vote Labour there, but as I went around meeting people, I was surprised at the level of support. This was particularly the case with younger people I met, who wanted me to pose for cellphone camera pictures with them.

Even the ever-present Muffin Break poll had National ahead, although I’m not sure how scientific that particular poll really is.

As I’ve travelled the country I’ve found that people are not interested in the latest desperate dirt-digging attempts by Labour, or the latest news involving Winston Peters.

People want to know what National will do in the areas they care deeply about – the economy, health, education and law and order. It is these issues that will decide the election.

The Hutt is a very strong Labour area, so that is an interesting reaction.

Dunne also implicated in Meurant papers

Phil Kitchin (and Oskar Alley) shows his independence by revealing that Peter Dunne also gets a mention in the Meurant papers with a $5,000 donation linked to his vote on a UN fishing plan. Dunne is denying a link.

While on a much much smaller scale than Winston (who appears to have had his entire policy process for sale), even one case like this is a cause for concern.

I agree with the Greens with their call to have a commission of inquiry into the Winston Peters cash-for-policies allegations. It goes without saying that any party implicated, should also be included in the terms of reference.

Wasted Votes

Audrey Young usefully writes on whether votes for small party that does not make the 5%/1 seat threshold are re-allocated to all other parties. The answer is No, but the effect is much the same as if they were. Confused? Let’s take an example:

Let us say National got 400,000 votes out of 1,000,000 or 40.0% of the vote. Now on 40% of the vote National would get around 48/120 seats in Parliament. A formula is used to calculate the exact allocation, but for now I’ll use approximations.

Now what is the case if 40,000 of those 1,000,000 total votes were for parties that did not make the threshold. No, they are not re-allocated but they are disregarded for the purposes of allocating List MPs and it means the total number of “effective votes” was 960,000 not 1,000,000. And hence National got 41.7% of the “effective  vote” which would get them 50/120 seats in Parliament.

Now there is no actual reallocation of votes from parties that do not make the threshold, but because the number of effective votes is reduced people tend to say the 4% wasted vote was reallocated and National went from 40% of the total vote to 41.7% of the effective vote. If Labour was also on 40% of the total vote they would also be on 41.7% of the effective vote. Hence why people say that effectively a vote for a party that does not make the threshold is reallocated to all other parties.

They are wrong in using the word re-allocate, but correct in describing the effect.

Caught in another lie

As you read below that Winston has been caught in another lie, just remember that Helen Clark’s firm policy is that multiple and repeated lies to the public are no barrier to serving in her Government. The Herald reports:

NZ First leader Winston Peters says he did not use a helicopter for election campaigning – but the photographic evidence suggests otherwise.

Mr Peters has flatly denied using a helicopter to campaign, calling the suggestion “stupid”.

“Did you see me flying around in a helicopter? Who would try and campaign out of a helicopter?”

But the Herald has obtained a photographic sequence of a smiling Mr Peters posing before taking off from Gisborne Airport shortly before the 1999 election.

Even his lies are getting feeble.

Mr Peters’ denial followed a report he demanded the free use of a helicopter during the 1999 campaign from his wealthy backers in the Vela family.

The MP wanted to paint the helicopter in NZ First colours and fly it into rural areas, according to documents obtained by the Dominion-Post.

“Tell him [Philip Vela] to hire me an unmarked helicopter. So I can paint it black/white and NZ First. Then I can drop into small rural towns and schools,” he wrote in one.

“Tell those bastards I want a helicopter. Don’t give me this crap about the machine needing repairs.”

So this could be a good test case of how authentic those papers are. What was the actual helicopter used?

The helicopter in the Herald’s photographic sequence is black-and-white. It was registered to Philip Vela until June 1999, but had changed ownership to the Auckland office of Eurocopter by the time the photo was taken on the campaign trail that October/November.

Just a coincidence I am sure!

Well done to Gray Eatwell for keeping and supplying the photos. He stood for NZ First in 1999 and is standing as an Independent in Tauranga this year.

The Dom Post also covers this:

Winston Peters appeared to be posing a rhetorical question when he asked “have you seen me flying around in helicopters?”

The problem was that several people – including a Dominion Post journalist and a former political colleague – were happy to answer that they had seen just that.

Once again I stress, that Helen Clark is saying she has no problems working with Winston again. She is unconcerned that he is a serial liar. She is unconcerned that her Government’s decision making may be tainted by a cash for policy scandal. She just says it is nothing to do with her and if Winston makes it back she will have him as a Minister again.

Matt Robson on John McCain

I blogged a couple of days ago about what Matt Robson said on Back Benches about John McCain:

As I said at the time:

They were talking about the US election and Obama and McCain. Wallace Chapman mentioned that McCain was around the same age as Jim Anderton, and Robson’s nasty littlre retort was:

But Jim can put his hands up over his head and claim victory, McCain can’t do that

How disgusting is that? To denigrate a man who is crippled due to years of torture as a prisoner of war? From Wikipedia:

In August 1968, a program of severe torture began on McCain. He was subjected to rope bindings and repeated beatings every two hours.

Some of the injuries came from his initial treatment when shot down:

Some North Vietnamese pulled him ashore, then others crushed his shoulder with a rifle butt and bayoneted him.

Now this is a war crime and against the Geneva Conventions. Robson has spent a lifetime going on about the Geneva Conventions, and war crimes, but then shows his real colours, by justifying the torture of McCain (after Paul Quinn pulled him up for his offensive comments), and bayoneting of a wounded surrendered solider on the basis that McCain had taken part in a war that killed a lot of people.

Now above is the video extracted onto You Tube, so people can easily judge for themselves what Robson was doing. Prog Blog has ludicrously tried to argue Robson was referring to McCain not winning as why he would not be raising his hands in victory, but that is crap as Robson explictly refers to the inability to raise his hands. Prog Blog should be ashamed it is trying to defend such a loathsome comment from Robson.

It is worth remembering that Robson is the Deputy Leader of the Progressive Party which is a formal part of the Government. Wonder what Phil Goff thinks of his comments?

Thanks to Helen, the way to entrench the Maori seats is to have Maori Party go with National

In an extraordinary and desperate flip-flop, One News reported tonight that Helen Clark said she now supports entrenching the Maori Seats, a policy the Maori Party has indicated may be a bottom line. Never mind she didn’t a few days ago – TVNZ amusingly showed her also saying that was not their policy in 2005, yet denying it was a flip-flop.

But what is really amusing is she has scored a massive own goal. How? Go back and read what Chapman Tripp said on entrenching the Maori Seats:

However, to add the Maori seats to the list of entrenched matters will require more than a majority vote in Parliament. When entrenching something new, the Standing Orders and our constitutional conventions come into play.

The Standing Orders state: “A proposal for entrenchment must itself be carried in a committee of the whole House by the majority that it would require for the amendment or repeal of the provision to be entrenched.” In other words, a proposal for entrenchment can only be passed by the super-majority it proposes – in this case, 75 per cent. …

On current polls, a 75 per cent vote in the next Parliament will require getting both National and Labour into the “ayes” lobby.

What this means for the Maori Party, even if it is in the position post-election to decide who gets to lead the next government, is it will have to somehow persuade both the suitor it is accepting and the suitor it is rejecting to support it.

Now think about how things play out now that Labour have said their policy is to support entrenchment and National has said its policy is not to.

If the Maori Party go with Labour, then they will not have a 75% majority. National will have no reason to change its policy and Labour/Maori Party will fail to entrench the seats. Labour can not deliver on entrenchment without National.

Now what happens if the Maori Party go with National, and as part of that they manage to negotiate that National support entrenchment in exchange for various concessions on other issues. Well they also will not have 75%, But here is the great thing – Helen has already announced that Labour’s policy is now to support entrenchment. Labour will have to vote to entrench the seats, even though they are not in Government, or risk a mighty backlash from Maoridom for having lied to them about supporting entrenchment.

In her desperation to get close to the Maori Party, she has massively blundered by giving away one of her major post-election negotiating items. She has actually given the Maori Party an increased incentive to go with National, as that is the only way to get the 75% needed to entrench the Maori seats.

Well done, Chief Political Strategist Clark.

Electorate Polls

I’ve blogged over on curiablog the results fo several recent electorate polls, including tonight’s one in Tauranga. The topline results are:

  • Tauranga – Bridges 26% ahead of Peters. Labour’s Pankhurst in 4th place at 5%. NZ First Party Vote down from 13% in 2005 to 6%.
  • Palmerston North – National candidate Malcolm Plimmer ahead by 3%
  • Ikaroa-Rawhiti – Parekura Horomia 5.4% ahead of Derek Fox
  • Nelson – Nick Smith 36% ahead of Maryan Street
  • West Coast-Tasman – Damien O’Connor 3.5% ahead of Chris Auchinvole
  • Te Tai Tonga – Maori TV/TNS has Mahara Okeroa ahead of Rahui Katene by 10% – 49% to 39%. However Marae Digipoll has Okeroa bejind by 6% – 40% to 46%
  • Hauraki-Waikato – Nanaia Mahuta ahead of Angeline Greensill by 0.6%

All three Maori seats held by Labour are highly competitive. In two seats Labour is ahead and in the seat with conflcitign results, an averaging of them out would see Labour ahead. This means that the Maori Party may not have much of an overhang at all – in fact they could even gain a List MP if they got 4% or so party vote.

Palmerston North is the only Labour held seat that a public poll has shown National ahead in, so far. Due to boundary changes Taupo and Rotorua are technically National’s on paper.

Based on boundary changes and public polls (and note this is not a personal prediction) the electorate seats would be:

  1. National 35
  2. Labour 28
  3. Maori 4
  4. ACT 1
  5. United Future 1
  6. Progressive 1

Labour will in one sense be very pleased to be ahead in all three Maori seats. However this does lessen their chances of winning via overhang.

And the Tauranga result is superb. With only 5% voting Labour on the electorate vote anyway, it means no amount of tactical voting in Tauranga can put Winston back in that way.

National’s Fiscal Policy Paper

I was very pleased but slightly concerned to see National announce an extra $2 billion over four years to improve our schools. But the concern disappeared when they made clear they had included the cost in their overall fiscal package.

Even better they have released their total fiscal policy paper, so one can see how all the promises can be paid. This is something Labour has not done despite all the resources of incumbency.

Inflation

Kerre’s conversion is complete

I think we can declare Kerre Woodham’s conversion to the dark side complete. She has shown primising signs before of having abandoned latte liberal or Chardonnay socialist leanings, but her latest column qualifies her for full entry. I will arrange the initiation ceremony the next time the High Council meets.

Kerre writes:

Can anybody explain why we need these redundancy packages? Will we always have them? Or do we only get redundancy packages when recessions fall in election years?

Kerre has it in one.

One man told me it was all the banks’ fault for luring people into mortgages, so the Government should pay if people couldn’t afford to pay the bills when times got tough.

For a start, no bank staff pointed guns at homeowners and insisted they take out mortgages. People did that of their own volition.

And if you’d listened to your grandparents, they would have told you not to borrow more than you could afford to pay back.

All good points.

And for another, it’s not “the Government” that will be giving you money. It’s me. And your friends and neighbours.

The Government is not a money machine. It’s an institution that is funded by taxes taken from all of us.

And the final proof of the conversion to the dark side – the realisation that the money the Governments gives out is not their money, but your money.

Where does personal responsibility come into it? I’ve earned low wages and I’ve earned high, and I’ve learned you cut your cloth according to your income.

Heresy, heresy to the left.

One of the reasons for this worldwide recession is that people have taken on more debt than they could afford to give themselves a better lifestyle.

What the recession is doing is shaking everything and everyone up, and restoring a natural order and balance. But that won’t happen if political parties set about subverting the sequence.

This column really gets a 10/10. Not only emphasises taxpayers, and individual responsibility but also talks about long-term effects of short-term interventions. Has Kerre been doing an economics degree on the sly?

Labour’s package is particularly loopy. If a person is made redundant, they will get the equivalent of the unemployment benefit for up to 13 weeks even if their spouse or spouse equivalent is on $200,000 a year.

How does that make sense?

It is about as sensible as giving welfare through Working for Families to couples earning $120,000.

National’s is targeted at lower income earners and builds on the Working for Families scheme and is marginally more practical _ if you agree that these redundancy packages are necessary. And I don’t.

I have no problem with taxes going to people who need a bit of extra help. Who are working low-wage jobs and looking after their families and who don’t have a lot to come and go on.

But we have programmes targeting those people already. I see absolutely no point in flinging money at people who have made poor economic choices or who don’t really need it. But then I’m not a politician looking to get elected.

Kerre’s membership will be approved by acclamation I predict. You have done well young Padawan.

HoS interviews Bronagh Key

The Herald on Sunday interviews Bronagh Key – possibly her first mainstream media sole interview. Extracts:

Bronagh Key is a woman of contrasts. She wears subtle jewellery that could be the equivalent of Niue’s GDP.

Yet, she says, she is a “bit of a tomboy actually”, who’s learning how to kickbox, avoids make-up during the day and can’t cook properly.

Kickboxing – cool! Who needs the DPS 🙂

She will, however, talk about Helen Clark. The two women have never met but Bronagh has admiration for her husband’s rival. She insists Clark was wrong in the first leaders’ television debate when she implied John Key shouted over people at home.

“I think [the comment] was in the heat of the moment and it was a bit unfortunate. What she said couldn’t be further from the truth.”

Considering that Bronagh could have aggressively attacked Clark for her comments, she is being very gracious.

They next met, accidentally, at the Russley Hotel, where Bronagh was waitressing. She was in a “long gaberdine maxi skirt and a peach chiffon blouse with a big bow… very tacky,” she laughs.

John, who was with his mum, didn’t know Bronagh worked there but she certainly made an impression. He told his mother: “See that girl, I am going to marry her.”

John seems very determined to suceed at whatever he pursues 🙂

A few weeks later he invited her to the A&P Show. “My mum and dad liked him straight away _ he was always very good with them _ and he would come around a lot on his skateboard… it’s not a pretty sight!”

Oh my God – a skateboarding John Key – now that is the dirt that Mike “Batman” WIlliams should be trying to dig up.  A photo of Key on a skateboard after age 12 would be enough to turn off 5% of the vote 🙂

KEY PROPOSED during her last year at Canterbury University, at the Chateau on the Park restaurant. “I remember saying to him on one condition _ that we had to buy a laundry basket on the way home, because he is really bad at dropping his clothes all over the bedroom floor.”

Heh.

I ask the same question I posed to Peter Davis, which appears to have upset a few readers _ the matter of their love life. In good spirits, Bronagh brushes it off. “I don’t even talk about that with my close friends, so I’m not going to tell you!”

Key has infamously said he’d turn gay for Brad Pitt. Bronagh says: “I think he’s more interested in Angelina Jolie _ but I’ll have Brad!”

Funnily enough many women also name Jolie as the woman they would go gay for. One can understand why of course!

McCarten’s advice to the left on how to win with fewer votes

Matt McCarten provides advice to left voters on tactical voting. Much of what he says is sensible, but his advocacy of a deliberate overhang strategy is dangerous and will destroy MMP and the Maori seats if he succeeds. His advice:

Centre-left voters

Staunch Labour voters will give their electorate and party vote to Labour. But the softer centre-left voters should give their party vote to the Greens.

Agree this is sensible. Also softer centre-left voters can vote for the best candidate in their electorate while still voting centre-left on the party vote. You don’t have to put up with a bad or lazy MP just because of their party – this is why we have MMP.

Staunch left voters

… If these left-wingers instead gave their party vote to the Greens it would give them another two MPs they wouldn’t otherwise get.

Matt is correct here. A vote for RAM, Alliance etc is wasted and helps National more than it does Labour or the left. They should vote Greens. The same goes on the right – a vote for Family Party, Kiwi Party etc is a wasted vote and they should vote for one of National, ACT or United Future.

New Zealand First supporters

It will take a miracle now for NZ First to get over the 5 per cent threshold given what’s happened to Winston Peters. Any of NZ First’s soft supporters should now probably throw their party vote to Labour.

That would be sensible. Having NZ First get 4% and wasted vote will help push National over the line. But of course not all NZ First voters are centre-left.

The only glimmer of hope for NZ First would be if all the non-National party supporters in Tauranga threw their electorate votes behind him. If he won Tauranga the party votes for NZ First would not be wasted and any list MPs he was able to drag through on his coat tails would be added to a Labour-led government. But don’t hold your breath on this.

I suggest people watch TV tonight before deciding on that strategy.

Progressive Party supporters

Their sole MP, Jim Anderton, is a reliable Labour ally. He won’t win enough votes to bring in an extra MP, so his supporters should give their party vote to Labour to help them win an extra seat that may make the difference in Clark keeping her job.

Here Matt gets dangerous. He is implicitly suggesting a deliberate overhang strategy which means he is trying to engineer a non-proportional result to allow the left to govern despite getting less party vote than the right.

Maori Party supporters

These are the crucial voters. If you are enrolled on the Maori electoral roll, it’s a no-brainer. You give your electorate vote to the Maori Party candidate so it wins all seven seats. Ironically, Clark’s only hope of being returned to power is if her Labour candidates are defeated by the Maori Party.

Even if Labour lost all their Maori seats, it has no effect on the total number of MPs that Labour gets. The total number of MPs a party gets is determined by the number of party votes they get – not the number of electorate seats they win.

If the Maori Party wins all the seven electorates it will still need 6 per cent of the party vote to get an eighth MP from its party list. That won’t happen and in those circumstances their list votes are wasted.

Therefore it’s better for the centre-left if the Maori Party gets a smaller party vote total provided it wins more electorate MPs than it would be entitled to from their party list vote. This would create a “parliamentary overhang”.

Therefore, if the Maori Party won all seven seats but only won 2 per cent of the party vote, it would have five more MPs than its list allocation. This would result in 125 MPs in a new parliament, rather than the usual 120. Clark or Key would then need 63 MPs rather than 61 to have a majority.

It is one thing to have an accidential overhang as happens from time to time. But to try and deliberately engineer an overhang is quite simply wrong. It will result in a crisis of confidence in the Government, destory MMP and provoke a nasty backlash against the Maori Seats. Matt should think about the long-term game. Here is why he supports it short-term:

If National got 48 per cent of the party vote it would get 58 MPs. Assuming its allies Act and United Future got four MPs between them, that would give the centre-right combo 62 MPs, making a majority in a 120-seat parliament.

But if there was an overhang parliament of 125, Key would be one seat short. That would mean if the Maori Party supported Labour, Clark would win a fourth term.

So Matt is saying that even if National/ACT United get 51% to 52% of the vote, a deliberate overhang strategy could allow a Government of the left to be formed.

Now under FPP sometimes a Government did get elected with fewer votes than the main Opposition party. But FPP was not a proportional system, put in place primarily to stop such a situation happening. If the public has chosen to have a non-proportional system (such as FPP or SM) then it is quite in order that there will be non-proportional results. But if the public have chosen to have a proportional voting system, then a deliberate strategy to produce a non-proportional result should be condemned.

It isn’t smart politics – it is desperate politics. Years ago people advocated National should do the same – have a rural party that contests rural electorates only and wins say 15 overhang seats, and a National Party that contest the party vote. People calculated this would give National a permament majority. And it would have. Until Labour did the same. Eventually you’d end up with both major parties splitting into list and electorate parties and a Parliament of 190 with 70 overhang seats!

Mutiny in the ranks?

The latest revelations about Winston and Ross Meurant, have led to some of his own MPs talking about their concerns.

If NZ First did not have Winston as Leader, there would be some MPs there that I would like to see return to Parliament. But as the price of having say Ron Mark or Peter Paraone back is to have Winston back, it is far too high a price to pay.

There is actually room on the political spectrum for a socially conservative but economically centre-left party. But again not with Winston. Anyway what has been reported:

On the campaign trail yesterday, only Prime Minister Helen Clark was still openly standing by the NZ First leader. She refused to retract previous expressions of confidence in Peters, saying the allegations were a matter for NZ First.

But they are not. He is her Minister of Racing. He forced her Government to splash out money on the racing industry, against official advice. There is considerable documented evidence that this advocacy was motivated by private donations to both NZ First and Peters personally as part of a strategy to attract money.

How the Prime Minister can say this is no issue for her, and she still has confidence is a classic case of see no evil, hear no evil.

National and Act have already ruled out sharing the Government benches with NZ First. And yesterday, Green Party co-leader Jeanette Fitzsimons said she would have great difficulty sitting around the Cabinet table with Peters, unless he was cleared of the new and serious accusations.

That’s a step in the right direction Jeanette but she has left herself wriggle room. Peters is not around the Cabinet table at the moment – he is Minister outside Cabinet. I remain unconvinced that if Helen can only form a Government with the Greens and NZ First, and that NZ First demand Winston remains Foreign Minister (outside Cabinet) that Jeanette and the Greens would turn down an opportunity to be in Government.

Yesterday, Ron Mark said he had warned Peters about his involvement with Meurant: “I have no relationship with Ross, other than advising Winston he should have nothing to do with him.”

This was very good advice that Winston should have taken. But he didn’t. And I hope Ron looks at what Meurant advocated to Peters, looks at the sceret money they have received (that I am sure he knew nothing about previously) and realise that Winston not just ignored Ron’s advice but he implemented Meurant’s strategy.

The fact that Ron is willing to publicly say he advised WInston off Meurant is significant. Now someone should ask Winston why he ignored his MPs, what did Meurant actually do for him.

Well done Nikki

Hos interview with John Key

The Herald on Sunday also interviews John Key. Some interesting stuff:

How would your voters feel if you turned around and supported the entrenchment of these seats, when your policy is to abolish them?

I think there would be very mixed views. Some people would accept that, but others would have real concerns, I think… MMP is inevitably about compromise – compromise from smaller parties and compromise from bigger parties.

That is one of the ironies of MMP – all manifestos are starting positions not final positions.

You don’t live in Helensville. Your electorate vote is in Epsom – Richard Worth or Rodney Hide?

I’m voting two ticks for National.

So presumably you’ll be advising all other National voters in Epsom to do the same? To give their electorate vote to Richard Worth?

We’re running a party vote campaign around the country. It’s no secret that we have a good relationship with Act. Obviously we’d encourage anybody to give two ticks to National, but we acknowledge that there will be people who split their vote in Epsom.

That was delicately handled!

After the past week, are you fairly comfortable with your decision to rule out Winston Peters?

Ultimately a Winston Peters government is always one that has dramas and scandals around it, and I think that New Zealanders want a fresh start.

Why do you think Helen Clark has been willing to wed herself so closely to Winston?

I think she’s desperate for power. She’s trading away the principles she campaigned on in 1999 that she was going to hold ministers to account. She’s fired ministers before Winston for a lot less… The only reason she hasn’t [fired him] is because he’s her only hope to get a fourth term.

You know I can’t actualy think of what more Winston could do, that would cause Clark to fire him?

You said you regretted your slip-up over the Tranz Rail shares. Why shouldn’t that erode voters’ trust in you?

Because that was a genuine mistake, and when I made it I fronted up about it. What I did find out about a week later was that I had more shares than people had originally thought, but they were for the same time period… Now, for good order I should have gone back and corrected that, and if I was faced with that situation again I would.

Could people perceive that as you being “economical with the truth”?

Well, they could do, and that was certainly why Labour went to such great lengths to find that information about me – but people make mistakes.

I like people who can admit their mistakes. I don’t think Helen has ever admitted an error – not even signing a painting done by someone else as her own. She just tried to claim she autographed it, not signed it!!

Herald on Sunday calls for a clear mandate

The Herald on Sunday editorial calls for a clear mandate for a new Government, so they can cope with what might be the worst economic crisis in 70 years.

To have a real shot at cobbling together a majority, Labour would need the support of NZ First, an option unlikely to be available since the polls strongly point to extinction both of the party and its turbulent leader, Winston Peters. He cannot be ruled out entirely; history shows that if anyone can rise from a political deathbed he can. But if that happens, Helen Clark will have to ask herself whether she can – or should – work with him again.

Asked and answered. Yes, yes, and yes. She almost soudns enthusiastic about doing so.

For no matter how much Peters harrumphs and blusters, the donations fiasco has revealed him to be both a hypocrite and a man whose doubletalk has been hard to distinguish from calculated deceit. Clark would need to ask herself whether she should rely, like every administration in the MMP era, on such a perverse dissembler to keep her on the ninth floor of the Beehive. She may believe that she has a political mission to fulfil and that it is fair to resort to any expedient within the rules that allows her to do that. But a real leader knows when the prize is not worth the price.

A perverse dissembler. Now that’s a phrase I like.

It is almost sad to see Clark cling so tightly to Winston, even after the latest revelations.

In the end, Clark may not face that choice, since Peters will probably be consigned to the oblivion he so richly deserves. But she also faces the question of whether a minority Government she leads would have a legitimate claim to power. If Labour were to win significantly fewer party votes than National and yet assemble a ramshackle coalition with the Greens, the Maori Party and the Progressives, Clark could end up with a constitutional hold on power to which it had no moral entitlement. A Government so formed would risk being seen as cynically corrupting the intentions of MMP, which could lead to a regrettable backlash against proportional representation. And a Government whose very existence runs counter to the plainly expressed will of the people is not likely to go down very well in the country that invented the concept of the fair go.

Now there is no doubt that Labour has the legal and constitutional right to form a Government even if it gets less votes than National. I have never argued otherwise. But voter expectations of parties is another matter.

For example in Canada there is a strong convention that the largest party gets the chance to form a Government. This is, like in NZ, not a legal or constitutional requirement – it is a cultural or political expectation. You actually have the main opposition party (the Liberals) voting in favour of supply, to allow the Government to continue. They know they would be punlished by the electorate for causing the Government to dissolve, or not allowing it to form.

So while there is no question about the legal and constitutional position, there are cultural and political issues about how NZ would react to a party that came second, forming the Government. To my mind it depends on the exact situation.

If National beat Labour by only 2%, and Labour and Greens formed a majority Government I don’t think anyone would blink much.

If National beat Labour by say 14%, and Labour, Greens, NZ First and Maori Party and Progressive all combined to form a Government, then I think there would be some significant disgruntlement, regardless of the fact there is no legal barrier at all.

If National actually got over 50% of the vote, and didn’t get to form a Government due to overhang there would be very significant backlash I would say. And if the overhang was as a result of a deliberate strategy, then I would say things could get very messy.

The legal position is quite clear – any MP can be made Prime Minister and lead a Government so long as they can win confidence and supply in the House. But the political and cultural acceptability of those arrangements is not the same thing and will depend (if the biggest party does not form a Government) on how big the gap was.

And so, with a week to go, the polls suggest there is a mood for change. But the incoming Government needs to have a clear and unequivocal mandate. The crisis enveloping global financial systems will call for strong leadership from decision-makers untrammelled by the need to pander to the competing desires of coalition partners. The worst thing that voters could do on Saturday is to try to second-guess the main party leaders with so-called strategic voting.

We need a clear result to strengthen the hand on the tiller in the stormy seas ahead.

A clear result would be great. And it is worth remembering that National has said it will try and strike deals with ACT, United Future and the Maori Party even if it can govern without any or all of them. So you would have a Government able to govern with strong leadership when necessary, but one that voluntarily chooses to bring as many other parties as possible into Government – not to give them a veto and rule by committee, but to recognise talent and good ideas across the board.