National on the Maori seats

Ben Thomas at NBR quotes Pita Sharples:

Maori Party co-leader Pita Sharples says his party receives signals “privately” that the National Party is not too committed on its position of abolishing the Maori electorate seats.

Host Martyn Bradbury put to Dr Sharples right wing commentator Matthew Hooton’s view that “the desire to dump the Maori seats was simply window dressing for the more meat-eating National fringe than genuine policy,” and asked whether the announced policy  suggested National were more serious about abolishing the seats.

Mr Sharples replied: “No, I think Mr Hooton is pretty close. That’s the same message we’ve been getting privately, that in fact it’s well off.”

I’m not surprised by the story. But one has to be careful about what it means.

I have no doubt the vast majority of National MPs think that the Maori Seats should be abolished. As do I for that matter.

However they are also aware that abolishing them would be difficult, to put it mildly.

And it is not a burning issue for most National MPs. There are many things they would like to do, and some are more important than others. Abolishing the Maori seats probably ranks a long way below higher economic growth, better standards in education, welfare reform and a better performing health system.

So if the price of a deal with the Maori Party is to agree not to abolish the Maori seats (amongst other things), then that is not going be much of a dead rat to chew on. It would be what is called an easy concession.

Typical smears

Clinton Smith at The Standard responds to my post on the 11% increase in violent crime with what is really a nasty smearing post. I avoid responding to most of his stuff, as it reflects more on him than me. But as he basically calls me pro-rape, there is a limit. I’ll go through his post in turn:

David Farrar really is a disgusting person at times.

Yes how disgusting it is to point out violent crime increased 11% last year.

He writes that we shouldn’t look at overall crime rates (although he made a big fuss when the overall recorded crime rate went up because of changes in recording practice in 2006)

Smith is wrong. I have been making the point about violent crime, not overall crime rates, for years and years. To be precise:

  1. 3 March 2008
  2. 2 October 2007
  3. 2 April 2007
  4. 2 October 2006
  5. 4 April 2006
  6. 6 July 2004

Pretty much all of these said the same thing – the overall crime rate is not a very useful measure. I welcome people wanting to debate it is – but funnily enough few people ever engage that argument on the merits.

Instead we should just look at violent crime, after all “having 1,000 less [sic] cannabis crimes and 500 more rapes is a net decrease in crime, but would be a worrying trend”. He then goes on to act all shocked over the recorded violent crime stats. First, he’s trying to make you think there are more rapes

Yes that should be fewer. But I doubt anyone would read what I said as stating there were 500 more rapes. It was obviously an example given the round numbers used.

in fact, the number is down and he’s hardly one to fret about rape when he’s good mates with a pornographer).

Now I can not even describe how offensive Smith is with that statement. He basically says I don’t care about rape or rape victims. I can think of few things more defamatory let alone downright nasty to say about somebody. Next time Smith complains about the standards of a right wing blog, people should remember he considers accusing people of being unconcerned about rape as a legitimate tactic.

Smith deosn’t even try to debate the merits of violent crime stats vs total crime stats. He just decides to smear me. As I say that reflects far more on him than me.

Secondly, this professional statistician is deliberately trying to mislead you regarding the change in the crime stats. He knows that the explanation from the professionals is reporting of domestic crime is up but he hopes you don’t.

I am aware the Police provide excuses for why violent crime has gone up 11%, saying it is all due to increased reporting of domestic violence. However like all government agencies they of course try to put a favourable spin on the statistics. Does Clinton attack Dr Cullen when he disagrees with Treasury advice? More to the point when you look at specific categories such as:

  • Homicides from 96 to 112 – 16.7% increase
  • Wounding with Intent from 635 to 697 – 9.8% increase
  • Injuring with Intent from 996 to 1,180 – 18.5% increase
  • Assault with a weapon from 2,738 to 3,007 – 9.8% increase
  • Assaults on Police from 367 to 439 – 19.6% increase

You realise the explanation is not that credible.

I submit that these groups of crimes are not ones that would be greatly affected by increased reporting of domestic violence. Wounding with intent is the most serious assault possible, short of attempted murder. Assaults with a weapon don’t tend to be the exclusive domain of domestic violence, let alone assaults on police. And homicides speak for themselves.

Crime is down because poverty and the conditions that breed crime have been reduced. At the same time, reporting of crimes is up. Thefts, car thefts, and burglaries (together, the largest group of crimes) have halved in the last ten years. Homicides are down.

  1. 98/99 – 94
  2. 99/00 – 104
  3. 00/01 – 97
  4. 01/02 – 112
  5. 02/03 – 108
  6. 03/04 – 100
  7. 04/05 – 80
  8. 05/06 – 105
  9. 06/07 – 96
  10. 07/08 – 112

That is the homicides for the last ten financial years. The latest year is the highest equal of the last ten. Note when I point out an error Clinton makes I don’t feel the need to call him disgusting and other names.

In fact, all classes of crime are down except two. Recorded violent crime is up because reporting is up. Recorded property damage offences have climbed in the last three years thanks to the moral panic over tagging. But those rises are attributed (not by me, by the Police) to higher reporting.

Recorded violent crime has increased almost 50% since 1999. Clinton attacks and smears anyone who points this out and dares to disagree with the assertion it is all because of increased reporting of domestioc violence.

Farrar needs to misrepresent the statistics to create the impression of a wave of crime where there is none. It’s all part of National’s ‘New Zealand sucks’ campaign. It disrespects his readers and the victims of crime. Disgusting.

I regard a 11% increase in violent crime in just one year as very significant. The fact almost every category of violent crime has had a significant increase makes it highly unlikely it is just a matter of increased reporting of domestic violence. I think one can debate these issues without calling peoeel disgusting and suggesting they don’t care about rape. Sadly Smith is unable to do so, he is so caught up in his hate towards others.

But in the end, I think his posts reflect far worse on himself than his intended targets. It may appeal to the highly partisan, but it tends to be counter productive with most people.

Coin Count

I did my annual break open the piggy banks today. Last time I did this, I had 1,601 coins which totalled $642.95.

This time I have 1,395 coins. Feel free to guess how much they totalled this time. To help

  1. The pile at the top is $2 coins
  2. Second top on the left is $1 coins
  3. Second top in the middle is the new 50c coins
  4. Second top on the right is the new 20c coins
  5. The small pile second from bottom on the left is the old 50c coins
  6. The pile second from bottom on the right is the old 20c coins
  7. The pile bottom left is the old 5c coins
  8. The pile bottom centre is the old 10 c coins
  9. The pile bottom right is the new 10c coins

Violent Crime

The Police released the latest crime statistics today. These are for the financial year 1 July 2007 to 30 June 2008 and are the last official figures to be released before the election.

The media and some ill informed commentators focus on the overall crime figures. While of some importance, this is ill advised for two reasons.

  1. Not all crime is equal. Having 1,000 less cannabis crimes and 500 more rapes is a net decrease in crime, but would be a worrying trend.
  2. There are two sorts of crimes – those recorded when complained about and those recorded when the Police catch someone doing it. The second sort of crime can record an increase because the Police are better resourced and more pro-active and can vice versa decrease merely because the Police have not been so pro-active or successful in policing that area. Examples of the first sort of crime are assaults, murders, rapes, and most burglaries and thefts. Examples of the second sort are disorder, drugs, gaming, liquor, receiving.

So the overall crime stats and crime rate are not particularly useful as a fall in crime may simply be the result of a decline in police activity.

Hence it is best to focus on the crimes where they are recorded due to a victim or complaintant coming forward. And violent crimes are those most likely to be reported.

And what has happened with violent crime in just the last 12 months? I repeat this is not going back muliple years – this is just the last 12 months:

  • The overall number of violent crimes increased by 11.1% or by almost 6,000.
  • The number of grievous assaults (the most serious) increased by 11.7%
  • The number of homicides increased by 16.7%
  • The violent crime rate per 10,000 pop increased by 10.0%

I’ll later blog data all the way back to 1999, but this is again for the last 12 months only. The period where homicides were blamed by the Justice Minister of the moon and the sun.

And what districts have had the biggest violent crime increases. They are:

  1. Tasman up 23.1%
  2. Southern up 20.5%
  3. Bay of Plenty up 17.2%
  4. Counties-Manukau up 18.9%
  5. Waikato up 16.8%

Again this is in the last 12 months only.

Green Beer Mats

At Backbenches last week the Greens were handing out their beer mats, which went down well. And yes they do have an EFA authorisation statement on them.

A patron advertises for a Green girlfriend 🙂

While another is less choosy 🙂

Vic Election Debate 2008

The Victoria University Debating Society Election Debate 2008
That we need a centre-right government
Affirmative:
Stephen Franks – National candidate for Wellington Central
Christopher Finlayson MP – National List MP and Rongotai candidate
Stephen Whittington – champion Victoria student debater
Negative:
Grant Robertson – Labour candidate for Wellington Central
Sue Kedgley MP – Green candidate for Wellington Central
Polly Higbee – champion Victoria student debater
Chair: Sean Plunket
Monday 6 October, 6.30pm – 8pm
Lecture Theatre One, Rutherford House, Victoria University of Wellington
Gold coin entry. Questions after the debate, then tea and cofffee.
Also debating fans may wish to check out this footage of Jen Savage on Breakfast. Savage was judged best speaker at the Secondary School World Champs, and you get some idea why with her performance on Breakfast. Someone to watch out for – she has declared she wants Paul Henry’s job 🙂

Canine Catnip?

Greeting Ambassadors

The Dom Post report on the new Chinese Ambassador and these two Army sergeants who perform the Maori ceremonial challenge to new diplomats.

It occurs to me that foreign Governments may get an increase in applications from female diplomats requesting a posting to New Zealand!

Incidentally quite a few of the female diplomats posted here do end up marrying a Kiwi guy, or at least the ones I know!

Wellington Central

Two fun opportunities for people interested in the Wellington Central race.

First we have the four main candidates on Backbenches tonight. Stephen Franks, Grant Robertson, Sue Kedgley and Heather Roy. They’;; be talking about the economy, tax cuts and why you should vote for them!

I suspect a big audience tonight so pay to be there early. The show screens at 9.10 pm on TVNZ7.

Also iPredict has launched a set of three Wellington Central stocks.

You can invest in a Grant Robertson victory, a Stephen Franks victory or a “Other” victory in Wellington Central. The share will pay $1 if you win and the initial offer price is 55.5c for Grant, 43.5c for Stephen and 1c for Other.

Advanced investors can also buy a bundle of all three shares for exactly $1. If the combined price of all three is over $1, then you can make money buying the bundle and selling the individual stocks (or just the stock you think is over priced).

Police National HQ and the Brash E-mails

Matthew Hooton blogs some disturbing information he has obtained from the Police. It has taken him 18 months to get the information under the Official Information Act, even though it should have taken only 20 days.

It deals with the Police investigation into the Brash or so called Hollow Men e-mails. Key points are:

  • The alleged theft was notified to Police in August 2005
  • The Police did not begin their investigation until September 2006 – 13 months later!
  • The Police did not interview anyone as part of the investigation until June 2007 – 22 months after the complaint
  • The Police lied when they said in April 2008 the file was closed, as they now claim it is open but not active.
  • It took 18 months to get even this information out of the Police
  • The Police are refusing to release the file, even though they say the file is no longer active
  • The Officer in charge is the same Officer who decided not to prosecute Labour for their $800.000 of over spending in 2005

Now some will say there is nothing bad or sinister about this. They will claim the e-mails were never stolen. But why did the Police spend 20 months fighting the OIA release?

13 hectares of more bureaucrats

Gerry Brownlee has put out a PR about the space taken up by the pulic service in Wellington. This has had a massive impact on office rentals for the private sector. People like Bob Jones have made scores or hundreds of millions of dollars under Labour in Wellington, because of the massive increase. Small and medium businesses have struggled due to the cost of office space.

In the past five years Labour has overseen an increase in the amount of extra floor space leased for bureaucrats in central Wellington equivalent to almost four Te Papas, says National’s State Services spokesman, Gerry Brownlee.

“How can people have faith and trust in Labour’s stewardship of the public service when it has overseen an increase in the amount of extra floor space leased for bureaucrats in the past five years that equates to an additional 13.2 hectares?”

That is a lot of space!

“Meanwhile, Bayleys Real Estate estimates that the government sector now occupies almost 40% of the total commercial space in the Wellington CBD, and says the ‘surge’ of floor uptake involves ‘quite staggering numbers’.”

Gerry included a table of agencies and office space from 1999 to 2008. During that time the amount of office space has increased from 252,000 square metres to 446,000 – a 77% increase.

Some of the largest increases:

  1. Human Rights Commission up 178%
  2. Commerce Commission up 176%
  3. Education Ministry up 155%
  4. Social Development Ministry up 122%
  5. Transport up 117%
  6. Environment Ministry up 110%

In absolute terms the IRD has grown by 25,000 square metres, Education Ministry by 13,000 square metres, Labour Department by almost 7,000 square metres, ACC by 6,000 square metres, NZQA by 5,000 square metres, Justice Ministry by 5,000 square metres.

Congratulations to Treasury who reduced their office space by 2,000 square metres or 18%.

Dom Post on gangs

The Dom Post has a better proposal for dealing with gangs than banning patches and tatoos:

Gangs are an evil, contributing nothing useful to society. But the way to deal with them is not to stop them identifying themselves – something that in practice will prove impossible – but for the police to use the extensive means at their disposal to harass them out of existence. They should tear down their fortified pa(d)s, cripple their drug businesses and prevent them gathering together in public places to intimidate and jeer at their fellow citizens, something that is already prohibited in law.

Police will know they’ve got the balance right when gang members decide of their own volition that wearing patches is not worth the trouble it invites.

I think banning gang patches is the wrong answer to the right problem.

Carbon neutral campaigns

Nicola Kean in the Southland Times reports how National MP Eric Roy has planted 20 trees to offset the carbon emissions from the 1500 kms he will travel during the campaign.

What I found interesting is this part of the story:

Invercargill’s Green Party candidate Craig Carson applauded Mr Roy’s attempt to go carbon neutral.

“I think it’s great that he’s doing it. How well it works or not I’m not sure.” Mr Carson said that because he worked fulltime and had limited resources, he was not able to follow suit.

Think about the implications of that.

The Progressive list

The Kiwi Party and Progressive Party have released their party lists – I have updated my candidates section.

The top three for the Progressives are:

  1. Jim Anderton, Cabinet minister (Wigram)
  2. Matt Robson, barrister, (Maungakiekie)
  3. Josie Pagani, communications consultant   (Otaki)

Josie would be a great MP. She is a former Alliance press secretary, and one of life’s really neat people. I’d almost be tempted to vote Progressive if it were not for the fact that I’d get Matt Robson back also!

Okay I’m not really tempted to vote Progressive – but I do now rank them higher than Labour due to Anderton’s abstention on the Privileges Committee report. My rankings now are:

  1. National (nc)
  2. ACT (nc)
  3. United Future (nc)
  4. Maori Party (+1)
  5. Greens (+1)
  6. Progressive (+2)
  7. Labour (-3)
  8. NZ First (-1)

The figures in brackets are a change from April 2007, when my ratings were:

  1. National
  2. ACT
  3. United Future
  4. Labour
  5. Maori
  6. Greens
  7. NZ First
  8. Progressive

Labour’s defence of Winston Peters and undermining of the Privileges Committee has disgusted me, and changed them from a party which I merely strongly disagree with, to a party I have almost no respect for. Well not so much the party which has many good people in it, but the current leadership.

Herald on tax cuts

A good Herald editorial:

At very nearly the conclusion of three terms in government and after nine consecutive years of growth, the Minister of Finance is giving workers between $12 and $28 more a week in their pay packets as the first round of personal tax cuts. The step is as welcome as it is belated.

Very very belated.

But the economic environment also creates doubt about the extent of the tax cuts. Just as the reductions begin, Michael Cullen has admitted that he is uneasy about the debt level sparked by economic weakness and other factors, such as a higher than expected take-up of KiwiSaver.

The take-up rate is not higher than I expected. The official forecasts were always ridiculously conservative. Many employees get a 2:1 subsidy to go into KiwiSaver, plus it is compulsory in a new job unless you specifically opt out. That was always going to generate a massive take-up rate.

Indeed, Labour may yet have to borrow to fund its tax-cut programme. If so, much of the blame can be apportioned to the generosity of some of its policies, such as those on student loans and free early childhood education.

It’s not free.

Tax cuts, not credits, should have been accorded a far higher priority, given the public’s understandable irritation with bountiful operating surpluses and Labour’s reluctance to acknowledge that the state should take no more of people’s earnings than it reasonably needed.

Labour still do not acknowledge this. They do not see tax cuts as a moral issue (take no more than needed) or an economic issue (tax cuts boost economic growth) – purely as a political issue. Labour sees tax cuts as welfare for the rich – not as something good to do.

Almost Labour’s first act after taking power in 1999 was to raise the top rate of personal tax. This was done for no other reason than to restore the tax scale’s former bite on high earners. Five years on, a farcical “chewing gum” tax reduction was proposed and then abandoned.

Nine years on, a move in the opposite direction has finally been made. It should be greeted warmly. If it is viewed widely as overdue and underwhelming, Labour has only itself to blame.

Indeed.

200 more doctors a year

National has pledged to lift the number of annual places in medical school from 365 to 565, over five years. This would be the biggest increase ever.

We are currently one of the biggest importer of doctors in the world, and producing more doctors locally is sensible. And the student loan abatement for staying in NZ, along with lower taxes, should help keep them here.

Hawkins attacked by bible

Power Prices

Kiwiblog Stats

As it is end of the month, have taken a look at the various stat packages. First we have Alexa. This only measures traffic and ranks amongst those who have downloaded the toolbar. However in terms of trend, it gives some useful perspective:

This shows Kiwiblog’s rank amongst websites bowsed by NZers (who have the Alexa toolbar). The approaching election really seems to be having an impact, with Kiwiblog now in 90th place. The top 10 are:

  1. google.co.nz
  2. trademe.co.nz
  3. yahoo.com
  4. google.com
  5. live.com
  6. youtube.com
  7. facebook.com
  8. bebo.com
  9. wikipedia.org
  10. nzherald.co.nz

Then we have the stats from WordPress

And finally Google Analytics gives me the top referring sites in September:

  1. No Minister – 3,951
  2. Whale Oil – 2,161
  3. The Hive – 2,038
  4. The Standard – 1,894
  5. Keeping Stock – 1,491
  6. Scoop – 963
  7. Public Address – 800
  8. Roar Prawn – 714
  9. Cactus Kate – 630
  10. Stuff – 596

And top search terms:

  1. Kiwiblog – 6,600
  2. Owen Glenn – 1,533
  3. kiwi blog – 1,160
  4. Laura Ede – 1,157
  5. David Farrar – 817
  6. tax cuts – 539
  7. owen glen – 529
  8. The Hive – 509
  9. Rochelle Rees – 486
  10. Whale Oil – 481

Most read pages

  1. Blogroll – 13,577
  2. Must Read Blogs – 7.920
  3. The Owen Glenn Hearing – 4,225
  4. Sharples says Labour – 3,050
  5. 2008 election candidates – 2,936
  6. general debate 26 Sep – 2,478
  7. Clarks claims Key would kill 60 – 1,866
  8. Election date announcement – 1,838
  9. Owen Glenn – 1,813
  10. The Election Dates – 1,768

Voting now open

Voting is now open in the 2008 Kiwiblog Awards. They close at 3 pm Friday 3 October. You can vote in the sidebar.

The most popular nominations in each category are:

MP of the Year

  • Rodney Hide – not even a finalist last year but a popular nominee for his campaign to expose Peters, amongst other things
  • Bill English – a repeat nominee – his year of picking apart the EFA was often cited
  • Pita Sharples – has become the Maori MP, Pakeha love to love, and helped position the Maori Party as Kingmakers.
  • Phil Goff – a China FTA plus a possible United States FTA endears Goff to many readers

Labour MP of the Year

  • Phil Goff was nominated by many but disqualified as the 2007 winner
  • Michael Cullen cited by many for his mastery of the House
  • David Cunliffe also impressed several with his determination to improve the Health sector
  • Winston Peters was nominated multiple times in this category, so who are we to stand in the way of the public!

National MP of the Year

  • Simon Power had the most nominations, having impressed with his constant highlighting of law & order problems, and also superb Chairmanship of the Privileges Committee.
  • John Key is still the country’s Preferred PM
  • Bill English was disqualified having won this category last year
  • Gerry Brownlee also often nominated for his take no prisoners methods in the House

Minor Party MP of the Year

  • Rodney Hide a popular nominee for many
  • Pita Sharples had 12 nominations in this category – will it be Minister Sharples in a few weeks?
  • Sue Bradford has had a quieter year than 2007 when she was runner up, but still gained some nominations
  • Hone Harawira also gained multiple nominations – the once reviled radical has been impressing a few people

Press Gallery of the Journalist

  • Audrey Young – Winston still has not apologised to her, but she was a favourite nominee amongst Kiwiblog readers
  • Duncan Garner – his “straight talking” doesn’t always win friends in Parliament, but has proven popular with some readers
  • Guyon Espiner – cool, clam and collected – the most viewed gallery reporter has some fans
  • Colin Espiner – the blogging journalist has many online fans

Public Servant of the Year

  • Grant Liddell – the SFO Director was a multiple nominee for doing what was right, regardless of what the Government wanted.
  • Owen Glenn – okay not technically a public servant, but many nominated him for having performed a public service.
  • Helena Catt – the Electoral Commission CEO wins the sympathy and nominations of many for having to try and work out what the Electoral Finance Act actually means, and for her willingness to criticise the law she has to enforce.

Enjoy voting.

Debates

The Herald backs Clark and Key in agreeing to debates between the two of them only:

They need make no apology for that. Theirs are the only parties capable of forming a government. Far from undermining MMP, their joint decision is perfectly in line with the way MMP has developed in this country. After 12 years, the voting system has not produced a three- or four-party contest as it did in Germany, the only close model.

There, the two smaller parties each attract around 10 per cent of the vote and can claim significant places on the stage at each election. The most successful of our smaller parties have half that support and it becomes harder to argue that they should be included in televised debates while others should not. …

National and Labour have a legitimate shared interest in minimising third-party influence. They are under no obligation to let minnows enjoy their limelight. They obviously see their prospects best served by a simple two-sided debate. The rest will no doubt get a separate televised forum for their contest.

And there is a debate on TV One on 27 October between the six minor parliamentary parties.

Meanwhile Pundit has a copy of the letter sent to Clark and Key from TVNZ and TV3 jointly:

A joint letter from news chiefs at TV3 and TVNZ last Monday pleaded with both Helen Clark and John Key not to turn their backs on multi-party debates, insisting they were of “fundamental importance in an MMP environment”.

I have said I think there should be one debate with all eight leaders. I would have four debates – two head to heads, one with all eight and one with only the minors.

But I do think people over-state MMP as the reason for including the minors. Social Credit has twice as many MPs as Jim Anderton, yet Bruce Beetham never got invited to the debates.

But talking of debates, the Alliance is complaining the CTU has refused to allow them to attend a Meet the Parties meeting in Christchurch:

Alliance Party Canterbury Convenor Quentin Findlay says the the local Council of Trade Unions leadership has locked the Alliance out of the debate.

He says Alliance members would be picketing the venue and would accept a last minute invitation to speak.

“All we are asking is for a chance to speak. No special treatment, we just to want to talk to the workers.”

Mr Findlay says the Alliance is a strongly pro-worker party that strongly supports the Union movement, and had not taken the decision to go public lightly.

Will Cullen cancel the tax cuts?

Bill English has raised the issue of whether Michael Cullen will, if re-elected, cancel the 2010 and 2011 tax cuts.

This is far from impossible. Consider the evidence:

  1. Michael Cullen promised tax cuts in 2005 and then cancelled them after the election on the basis of economic conditions.
  2. He has said that the level of debt has now passed his comfort zone
  3. His party is promising extra spending such as a pay jolt in education, a move to universal student allowances and longer period of paid parental leave, at a time when the economy is shrinking.

They probably won’t cancel them, but one could imagine if Dr Cullen delivers the 2009 budget, him announcing the 2010 tax cuts have had to be delayed due to the weak economy – probably until 2012 – after the next election again.

$880 million loss for the Cullen Fund

And Helen makes 60%