Wellington sticks with STV – just

Price on Parliament and court cases

Readers may recall a massive scarp between Rodney Hide and the Speaker when she refused to allow him to talk about the Wayne Crapper perjury video, because Winston claimed it was the subject of a court case.

Steven Price takes a look at how the Speaker ruled:

In the end, the Speaker ruled in Peters’ favour, saying Hide was in breach. “Nothing said in the House should prejudice, however slightly, the decision of any court,” the Speaker said. “The House applies more rigorous inhibitory standards on itself than apply to the media in reporting judicial proceedings.” This is because the legislature “should take extreme care not to undermine confidence in the judicial resolution of disputes by intruding on individual cases”.

I don’t know what precisely is in issue in the lawsuit. But I think that ruling is wrong. I’m worried about the phrase “however slightly”.  It’s a ridiculously low threshold, far lower than that applicable to the media. The rules applying to them say they can’t create a “real risk of prejudice” to an upcoming trial. That’s nebulous and chilling enough. This “however slightly” nonsense goes much further.Is it required by a sensible reading of the rules? Nope. In fact it flies in the face of the language that demands “a real and substantial danger of prejudice”.

Is it required by the needs of the administration of justice? Nope. If the courts can tolerate the media commenting on cases as long as they don’t create real risks of prejudice, then they can put up with MPs doing the same.

Is it good policy? Nope. There seems even more reason to cut our elected representatives some slack when conducting the business of the nation than there does for the media.

Is is good law? Nope again. The Speaker has forgotten that the Bill of Rights Act, which was passed by Parliament and says explicitly that it applies to Parliament, requires any restrictions on free speech to be demonstrably justified. You’d think that might be a relevant factor when considering how to interpret Standing Order 111. Apparently not.

I also thought it was a bad ruling. It actually allows any MP to gag any other MP by claiming that what they are referring to is the subject of a lawsuit.

A packed hall in Timaru

Peter packs them in, in Timaru.

But to make up for that Bob Jones says something nice:

Much more of this could induce such voter distaste that the surprise beneficiary could be Peter Dunne, as voters accord him points for staying above the fray. Right now, there’s a market opening for gentlemen politicians.

Field on Peters

Taito Phillip Field explains why he voted to censure Peters in the Herald.

Mr Peters has claimed the privileges committee was biased and hit out at the Maori Party for betraying him and at Mr Field, saying theMangere MP “did not understand loyalty”.

This is loyalty, as practised in Siciliy I suspect?

Mr Field acknowledged Mr Peters had supported him. “I have a lot of time for Winston and I am supportive of him. I’ve always considered Winston a friend, but I had to make an honest decision which had respect for the privileges committee process.”

Winston thinks it is all about him, but for many MPs it was about recognising the fact the Privileges Committee heard all the evidence, and reached fair conclusions.

In the same report:

Meanwhile a complaint to the Advertising Standards Authority about a Tui billboard saying: “When Winston says no, he means no. Yeah right.” has failed.

The complainant, N. Keesing, said it was “defamatory and racially discriminating towards Winston Peters”.

The authority ruled that it would be seen in a humorous light and did not meet the “threshold to effect a breach of the code of ethics”.

How is the Tui billboard racially discriminating??

It may however be an election advertisement. I have asked the Electoral Commission to rule on whether or not it is.

World of Wearable Arts

Went to World of Wearable Arts last night with Accident Girl. I’ve been every year for four years now, and it really does get better every year.

This is not just some fashion show. It is a spectacular mixture of dance, music, acrobatics, models, art and fashion. I doubt there are any tickets left, but it really is a must see.

This year we managed to get tickets for the awards night. Managed to guess most of the winners correctly, including the supreme winner above (photo from Dom Post). Was nice to see the designers come up and get their prizes. Helen Clark presented one of the awards and spoke briefly. She is very comfortable at these things and did speak well, with some real passion. I was tempted to try and start a chant of “Sack Winston” in the TSB Events Arenda, but managed to resist the urge. I do wonder how many I may have got to join in though 🙂

NZPA Images has a great photo gallery of some of the art works.

This was a crowd favourite. The shadow is in fact another person, but at times you wouldn’t have known.

A walking public health campaign!

This design was also very popular. What I spent some time puzzling over is whether the model inside was crouched over. I suspect they must have been.

The Bizarre Bra section is always colourful!

Smart Goff

Fran O’Sullivan notes that while Michael Cullen and Helen Clark have been falling over themselves to keep Winston happy, Phil Goff has been hapily overseas working on the US trade agreement.

Up until the last couple of weeks I would have said that Clark, even if she loses, would manage her own departure and delay it long enough for Cunliffe to have the numbers to beat Goff.

But if Labour loses, there could be a significant internal backlash against Clark and Cullen for their appalling judgement over Peters. Some of those Labour MPs were very unhappy about being forced to vote for Peters.

This gives Goff an opportunity to force a leadership ballot earlier rather than later, and campaign on a ticket of needing to remove those associated with the defence of Peters.

Caching and WordPress

Most people will have seen the sidebar graphic with the Curiablog poll average. I update it everytime there is a new poll by replacing the graphic file at curiablog with a new graphic.

By keeping the file name the same, it means other sites (such as Kiwiblog and Policy Net) can have the graphic automatically updated.

But there is a problem. WordPress seems to cache the old graphic and it takes one to two days for the new graphic to appear.

Anyone know of a way to stop this by clearing the cache? Note that curiablog is run on wordpress.org – it is not my own installation.

More Labour voters deserting

Another leftie friend told me last night that she now thought she might hold her nose and vote National. Now a month ago she was absolutely adamant she would vote Labour, but the sticking up for Winston is just a step too far for her.

Simon Collins in the NZ Herald has also been out interviewing a mammoth 600 people on their thoughts, and finds many Labour people deserting:

Shane Wairau is ready to take the plunge into a new era without a Labour Government.

At 34, the former Labour voter is now married with a 1-year-old son and working as business manager for a tourist bungy jump operation in Queenstown.

After years of loyalty, he’s disillusioned.

And

Even lifetime party supporters like 60-year-old tour driver “Hoppy” Hopwood, interviewed at Cape Reinga, are straying from the faith …

“I usually support Labour, but I’ll probably go with National. With a bit of luck we’ll get rid of the Prime Minister.”

I say don’t leave things to luck!

… two Invercargill retailers in their 50s who give their names as Caroline and Heather feel abandoned by their party. …

“My father is 90. He’s been a Labour man all his life. He is lost. He doesn’t know who to give his vote to.”

Heather, whose only child has also gone to Australia, says: “I’ve been a Labour person all my life and I’m absolutely lost. It really hurts me and I almost feel like not voting – and I used to go out and canvass for Labour.”

Both life time Labour voters.

The mood for change sweeps from low-income suburbs such as Manukau’s Clendon, where 18-year-old hairdressing student Ashley Kumeroa is voting National because she resents paying taxes for people who are “fit enough to work but decide to stay home”, to comfortable Half Moon Bay, where 31-year-old mother-of-two Janet Corbett is switching from Labour to National.

I wonder if she read about Mr Mohan ysterday who has been unemployed for five years and voting Labour for their generous welfare policies?

“Everything’s going up. No one’s getting any wage increases,” says Onehunga mechanic Graeme Wedding, 54, who is voting National for the first time since the Muldoon era in the 1970s.

“I always thought Labour was supposed to look after the working people, but they’re not. I think they could have given us some relief on our fuel instead of taking a percentage of the increase.”

Or some bigger tax cuts!

Cullen breaks his own debt target

Michael Cullen has admitted that the opening of the books the week after next will reveal he has broken his own gross debt target of 20% of GDP. And this is after all the hysteria about the end of civilisation if this happened under National.

Dr Cullen said there was room for only “very modest” new spending commitments from Labour during the campaign.

I suspect Dr Cullen’s idea of very modest may not be what anyone else calls modest!

No minors

There will be two head to head debates with Clark and Key, but no debates with all eight party leaders.

Can’t say I blame either of them – would you want to appear with Winston?

I presume they will also have a debate or two with the leaders of the six minor parties in Parliament

The recession is now official

Stats NZ confirmed today the New Zealand is in recession for the first time since the Asian crisis in 1998.

The economy in the last two quarters is around $300 million smaller than the last quarter of 2007.

But the worst may yet be to come. The second quarter drop was 0.2%. And expectations for the third quarter are now as bad as a 0.5% drop. That would be a 1% drop over nine months.

The Winnebago Blogmobile

We are going mobile for the 2008 election campaign, with the donation of a Winnebago Motorhome for six weeks to serve as a mobile office for the campaign. The motorhome is being dubbed the “Winnebago Blogmobile”.

Barrons Recreational Vehicles in Taupo has donated the use of a Winnebago Motorhome to myself and Whale Oil for the election campaign.

I think this is going to elevate blog coverage of the election to new levels. Thanks to the blogmobile we will be able to follow some of the party leaders about, and also travel to provincial cities and towns to interview people about local candidates and issues. Our aim is to provide election coverage from anywhere in NZ, and have a lot of fun doing it.

Now this is not an exclusive thing. We want to make the blogmobile available to any bloggers, or even media, who wish to travel on board for a day or two. It has heaps of room and comes fully equipped with tables for working at, a TV for following the news broadcasts, a full kitchen and mobile and wireless Internet for the vehicle”.

I’ve already had some expressions of interest, and we are working on an itinerary for the blogmobile. What would be useful is if people e-mailed me (or commented below) if they know of any local events (a high profile debate etc) that could be worth covering and/or if you are interested in spending some time on board. We can’t guarantee specific dates and places at this stage but should be able to within a week or so.

Solictor-General under police investigation

Voting Labour to keep 5 years of dole

A reader helpfully left a message on my cellphone telling me to read the story on Page A8 of the Herald carefully, about someone voting Labour because they have allowed him to be on welfare for five years.

I thought he had it wrong, but sure enough we go to this article on how some immigrants are voting and get:

Indian immigrant B. Mohan said his support for Labour stemmed from the party’s “number-one welfare policies” which had helped him to “survive five years of unemployment”.

“The National Party and its millionaire leader, John Key, will never be able to understand the poor, and we cannot trust the rich politicians who listen to consultants rather than their hearts,” said Mr Mohan, who has been without a job since moving to New Zealand in 2003.

I skim read the article early this morning and missed the significance of this. He has been without a job for five years, since he moved here in 2003. What an indictment on our welfare system.

With the lowest unemployment in the world almost, Mr Mohan has not managed to find any work at all in 250 weeks. How preposterous. And no wonder he is supporting Labour – he knows he won’t have five years on the dole under National.

Malaysian blogger jailed for two years

More valedictories

ODT on Clark

The ODT editorial today starts off on John Key and Tranz Rail but really focuses on Clark.

The New Zealand First leader’s lawyer, Brian Henry, told the privileges committee he personally paid $40,000 in court costs awarded against Mr Peters to National MP Bob Clarkson.

Mr Peters then told the committee that he repaid his lawyer, which meant he did not have to declare the sum under Parliament’s rules.

However, in evidence to the committee, the Serious Fraud Office said its investigations showed Mr Peters did not repay the money; the Spencer Trust, through which NZ First’s donations were channelled, did so.

Miss Clark’s response to this, when questioned by journalists, was that she did not intend to waste any more time on the matter.

Rock solid proof that Peters lied to both the public and the privileges committee. And all Clark can say is she had not bothered to read the report and doing so would be a waste of time.

“Our mission,” declared Helen Clark when opening her successful 1999 election campaign, “is to clean up government, and to clean up Parliament . . . the public’s faith in the democratic process must be restored.”

That is a pledge which voters should now measure, nine years later, and judge it to have been a spectacular failure.

Yes, a spectacular failure. The abandonment of any standards of honesty for her administration is spectacular.

Today’s Dispatch from Helengrad

This week’s column is online at NBR. My summary is:

  • Best Play of the Week: Michael Cullen gets an A for the CNI Forests Settlement
  • Worst Play of the Week: Labour gets an E- for their defence and condoning of Winston Peters
  • Scandal of the Week: John Key gets a D for Tranz Rail
  • Blog Analysis of the Week: Bernard Hickey on why the United States decision to join the P4 trade bloc probably will not lead to much free trade

Sharples on Clark

From the Press:

Party co-leader Pita Sharples said he was no longer sure if he trusted Prime Minister Helen Clark, and said she was nearing the end of her time.

“She has been a great leader; she has done great things for the country,” Dr Sharples said in an interview recorded yesterday for TVNZ 7. “But maybe she is nearing the end of her time.”

Recent events in Parliament showed Miss Clark was clinging to power, he said.

“She is appearing quite desperate … she is behaving like someone who is really, really desperate to get back into Parliament at any cost.”

That is because she is desperate to retain power at any cost!

RIP Brian Donnelly

I got texted a short while ago to tell me that Brian Donnelly died shortly after midday.

I knew Brian was sick, but did not realise how sick. Like almost everyone who knew him, I deeply mourn his loss.

He was an excellent Minister, a conscientious MP and a damn nice guy.  He was a true believer in the value of public service and spent his life trying to enrich the lives of other people.

Stuff has a story up.

David Benson-Pope unveils his campaign billboard

I’ve been leaked an exclusive copy of the campaign billboard for David Benson-Pope for Dunedin South.

He does have a point. Helen has let Winston away with lies to the media, lies to her, lies to the public, lies to the Privileges Committee and he is still there with all his baubles. While DBP got chopped down for far far less – not only losing his Ministerial baubles but also deselected.

Once upon a time I would have said Benson-Pope would have no chance ofkeeping his seat as an Independent. But I am hearing there is real anger at ths disparity of treatment between Peters and Benson-Pope. It will be interesting to see how many activists stay with Curran and how many leave with Benson-Pope – if he stands.

An alternative billboard