Economists Warn Anti-Bush Merchandise Market Close To Collapse
Economists Warn Anti-Bush Merchandise Market Close To Collapse
Enjoy this goodie from The Onion
Economists Warn Anti-Bush Merchandise Market Close To Collapse
Enjoy this goodie from The Onion
The seven part John Adams miniseries has won 13 Emmies, a record for a miniseries.
It is a compelling story of the first 50 years of the United States. Paul Gianatti did a powerful portrayal of John Adams, the first man to win and lose contested elections for President. The story of his friendship with Thomas Jefferson that turned to rivalvy and then loathing, before finally back to friendship is wonderfully told.
I hope a NZ broadcaster picks these up and shows them here.
The TVNZ7 debate with InternetNZ between four parties on Internet and ICT issues in on tonight starting at 9.10 pm. The first hour is on TVNZ7 and the second hour (plus the first hour also) is webcast at debate.net.nz.
It is a fully interactive debate and you can ask questions online, vote for the party (via website or text) with the best policies and have fun discussing it in a chat channel.
The MPs taking part are David Cunliffe, Maurice Williamson, Rodney Hide and Metira Turei.
The two journalists on the panel are Fran O’Sullivan and Russell Brown. The moderator was to be Sean Plunket but he has been replaced by Damien Christie.
The Herald reports on why Sean will not be doing the debate. Despite it being as small and un threatening as you can get, the Radio NZ Chief Executive refused permission for Sean to do it. This has led to Sean announcing he is planning to leave Radio NZ and is looking for a new job after 11 years there.
Damien will do a very good job, but I am annoyed Radio NZ has refused to let Sean do the debate – are they not meant to support public good broadcasting? I suggested Sean as the moderator, and never had any idea that it could lead to problems with Rado NZ. Some questions should be asked about whether Radio NZ are being too precious here.
Stuff has a story on the coroner’s report into the death of Folole Muliaga Key points:
I found the whole saga sad. I do think it was grossly politicised, which turned it into a game of who is right or wrong based on incomplete facts. The reality is that there were many contributing factors to what happened.
Certainly Mercury Energy do deserve some criticism as they were too quick to cut off, considering part payments were being made. Termination should be a last resort, not just a method to speed up payment.
I have no doubt the Vircom employee would not have cut it off, had he been aware of the oxygen machine. The evidence was he uses his discretion the same day to not disconnect other vulnerable households. Having said that he could have looked harder for clues such as the tubes.
As sad as it is for the family, I don’t think they they did everything they could have done. If you think someone is sick take them to the hospital.
Also, tragically Mrs Muliaga may have hid from her own family the extent of her illness. This was done with good motivation not to be a burden on them, but I am sure they would rather have known how sick she was.
And the DHB could also it seems have done better in their communicating to the family.
So the end of a sad chapter. By all accounts Mrs Muliaga was a lovely woman and she was prinmarily killed be her obesity, but complicated by the stress from the disconnection.
If people comment on the issue, it is fine you may have a variety of views as to what factors were or were not relevant and contributed most to what happened. But please do so in a respectful way.
This is amazing. Rodney Hide has just questioned Helen Clark on whether she is happy with the $40,000 donation to Peters from a donor through the Spencer Trust. Peters tried to block it half a dozen times but he finally got to ask it.
Clark’s response was she has not seen the wiring diagram from the SFO that was in the Privileges Committee report.
So the PM has not even bothered to read the report. This takes her hear no evil, see no evil to new levels. That $40,000 strikes cast grave doubt on the integrity of decision making around the racing portfolio and the PM declares she hasn’t even looked at the evidence.
I mean seriously just when you think the standards can not drop any lower, they do.
So Helen Clark has cleared Winston Peters from any wrong doing, and she did it without even needing to read the report of the Privileges Committee. She will presumably be voting against the report – also without reading it.
I’ll start with Colin Espiner:
On the privileges committee report, I think the committee did an excellent job. It cut through all the Peters verbiage and red herrings and bluster. It simply didn’t believe him and rightly found him guilty of misleading Parliament. It recommended his censure. That is an extremely serious step, and any minister of the Crown would be sacked for such a finding.
Indeed. Someone commented the last Mp to be censured was in 1975. Could the historians amongst us find the last time a Minister of the Crown was censured and lost his job.
Except Winston Peters. Labour’s handling of this crisis has been nothing short of shameful. Every day Prime Minister Helen Clark and her deputy on the committee, Michael Cullen, have found a different excuse for why Peters should not be sacked. There is simply no wiggle room left. So instead they’ve started attacking the committee itself. And this is perhaps the most shameful approach of all. The privileges committee used to be seen as beyond reproach – powerful, elite, Parliament’s highest body. Its decisions were unquestioned.
Labour claims the committee has been politicised and it has – by Labour and NZ First. The only attempt to hijack its findings was made by those members, not those who questioned Peters and found his answers wanting. How Labour can say it is National that has hijacked the committee when its own support parties – the Greens and United Future, and the Maori Party – all sided with National and Act beggars belief.
I think it is the maxim that if you repeat a lie enough time, then some people will believe it.
If, in Parliament today, Labour again attacks the committee and tries to vote down its findings, Parliament will have reached a new low in my opinion. Labour should accept that it lost the fight at the committee and respect its majority verdict. That’s what happens in our justice system when you’re found guilty by a jury of your peers.
I predict Labour will spend most its time attacking John Key and not taking the censure seriously.
Next we have John Armstrong:
Winston Peters’ letter of resignation as a minister ought to be on the Prime Minister’s desk this morning.
It won’t be. However, the damning report of Parliament’s privileges committee demands nothing less, even though its finding that Peters is in contempt was not unanimous.
You really have to wonder sometimes why Helen Clark refusesto take any meaningful action against Peters. Instead she runs attack lines on his behalf against the Privileges Committee and the SFO.
But he cannot get such accusations to stick when it comes to the Greens, United Future and Maori Party representatives who made up the remainder of the majority view. Those parties had no axe to grind with Peters. They simply reached the only conclusion that could be drawn from the evidence – that Peters had “some knowledge” of Glenn’s intention to make a donation.
The next time Clark runs the line that the Privileges Committee finding is politically motivated, ask her why Peter Dunne (one of her Ministers) and Russel Norman support the finding?
The big question is whether she can ever trust him again. With National not wanting a bar of him, it would now seem inconceivable that Peters could again become a minister even if Labour wins the election.
Not at all. If Peters makes it back and can give her a fourth term, of course she’ll have it back. Why else would you go through all the pain now, if not to do a deal later.
Labour’s reluctance to upset Peters with rigorous questioning during his appearances in front of the committee was understandable given Labour’s dependence on him for the past three years and conceivably for the next three as well. But it is to Labour’s eternal shame that it behaved thus.
In the end, the majority verdict is a victory for principle over expediency and for the integrity of the privileges committee.
Eternal shame is a good phrase.
We also have Frog from the Greens:
It does make me wonder weather the Team LPG fanboiz should really be getting so grumpy at Green supporters for not wanting to declare our undying love to Helen Clark and Labour. Because it seems from its recent behaviour that Labour has already found its preferred coalition partner, and it’s Winston Peters, come what may. But then I guess Labour doesn’t have so much to gain from a internet campaign for Team LNZF?
Can one imagine Helen Clark defending a Green MP to the extent she has defended Winston?
You also have comments from two of the MPs on NZPA. First Peter Dunne:
United Future leader Peter Dunne said he had gone into the committee with an opinion: “I entered the committee thinking this was probably a beat up.”
But after hearing evidence he changed his mind.
Mr Dunne said Mr Peters had repeated opportunities to give his side.
“Really I think the committee genuinely tried to get to the bottom of what went on and reached its conclusions accordingly.”
Mr Dunne said crucial for him was contradictory evidence and then “cute” recall of events by Mr Peters’ lawyer Brian Henry after evidence was presented.
So Dunne went from thinking it was a beat up, to deciding on the evidence that Peters knew about the donation and should have declared it.
Green Party co-leader Russel Norman disagreed [with Helen Clark]. He said he went into the inquiry with an open mind and based his decision on the evidence put before him.
So is Helen calling Russel tainted or unfair?
Dr Norman said the committee’s chairman, National MP Simon Power, ran a fair process.
In fact even Michael Cullen went out of his way to say that Simon Power was very fair as the Chairman. I think that is a huge credit to Simon for the way he has conducted himself.
As one minor example of his integrity I was talking to him on an unrelated issue a few weeks ago. I had heard on the radio that Owen Glenn would be testifying but not whether or not it would be in person or by video conference. So I just asked Simon whether it was in person or not as I happened to be speaking to him. Simon, just to avoid even the possibility or suggestion of having an inappropriate conversation, just referred me to the press release the Committee had put out. Now I wasn’t asking for anything which wasn’t public, but Simon erred on the side of caution by not even answering my question but just referring me to the press release. He has bent over backwards to be fair and impartial in this matter.
Finally, I note that Jim Anderton is going to show a tiny amount of spine and abstain rather than vote against the Privileges Committee recommendations. Don’t give him too much credit though as he repeat the bullshit from the PM that the process has been unfair to Winston. He does at leats ping Peters for his hypocrisy:
“NZ First was clearly accepting donations at a time when it was attacking everyone else for taking money from big business. For that the party has some explaining to do to the voting public,” Mr Anderton said.
Perhaps Mr Anderton could offer an opinion on whether he, as a member of the Cabinet, felt he should have known about the donations from the Velas to Peters, when he voted to go along with Winston’s generous funding for the racing industry?
Two fascinating comments from Cullen, according to NZPA:
Attorney-General Michael Cullen says the Serious Fraud Office’s judgment over releasing information to a parliamentary inquiry is questionable.
Not really, but Michael isn’t a lawyer so doesn’t understand the concept of law over politics.
But let us think more about this. The SFO has revealed the then Foreign Affairs Minister lied to the Privileges Committee. Also that he had an undisclosed $40,000 donation. And is our Chief Law Officer concerned about the content? No – not at all. He is just concerned that the SFO revealed the truth.
He also raised concerns over the SFO decision to investigate New Zealand First donations at a time when its future was being decided by politicians.
And here we have partisan hypocrisy. The SFO invstigated the National Party just prior to the 2002 election. Was he concerned about that? of course not.
Cullen also says:
This morning Deputy Prime Minister Michael Cullen said Mr Peters would not be reinstated to his ministerial portfolios before the election which is to be held on November 8.
Now this is significant. The suspension from portfolios was due to the SFO inquiry only. Cullen is now sayign even if the SFO clears him, they will not reinstate his protfolios – yet they will keep him on as a Minister without portfolio and all his baubles.
Isn’t that ridicolous?
Pleased to see this statement by John Key:
This is the exact opposite of what Peters has done. Give us the facts, and admit that it should have been handled better. Key has noted that he could have exited the Tranz Rail shares earlier and that is a call I agree with. He was still in his first year of being an MP then, and as he started to get promoted, he became more aware of the potential conflicts. In fact I understand during that year he instructed his brokers to divest themselves of pretty much all NZ stocks, to minimise any actual or perceived conflicts. But it would have been better for this to have been done slightly earlier than it was.
National has put online a letter from his broker setting out all transactions with Tranzrail. They have also put up all the actual share contracts. Again smart work to get it all out there. As Key says, it would have been better to do this earlier also.
In terms of this, and other related issues, I’d make two comments:
Clark to this day still denies she did anything wrong by sitting on the revelation by Owen Glenn he had donated to Winston for six months. In fact she still denies Peters even did anything wrong except by rude to the media!
Okay stop the e-mails of complaint. I give up.
I switched the RSS feeds over to summary instead of full yesterday. I have switched them back to full.
I did it spur of the moment, wondering if summary RSS would affect the blog stats for visits. I didn’t realise quite how many people rely on the RSS, such as people at work who can not view the blog due to work filters.
Having now seen the evidence from the SFO, it is no surprise that the Prime Minister is furious that they told the truth to the Privileges Committee. Clark is still questioning the judgement of the SFO Director, and complaining he did not consult Crown Law.
Apart from the fact there is no requirement he do so, I say thank God he didn’t. Crown Law would have informed the Attorney-General who was moonlighting as Co Chief Defence Counsel for Winston Peters at the Privileges Committee.
Look at who the Director did consult:
There really is no question that the Director acted properly. Those suggesting he did not, are trying to divert attention from the devastating evidence he provided. You see we learnt that the Spencer Trust did not just deliver money to NZ First, but to Winston Peters personally by paying off a $40,000 debt of his.
ACT tried to get the Privileges Committee to further investigate the Spencer Trust after the SFO investigation. And they are right that the issue of secret donations through the Spencer Trust to pay off a $40,000 debt of Peters is of massive concern.
The reason the PM is so furious is because the SFO evidence directly calls into question the integrity of decision making in her Government.
It is hard to not conclude that the ultimate donor of the $40,000 was the Vela Family. The descriptions in the SFO report strongly suggest that. And the Vela Family make much of their money from horse racing.
Now I am not suggesting the Velas had bad motives with their donations. I support their right to donate to parties they support. But there is a massive difference between a donation to a party and a donation or gift to an MP personally. The former is absolutely common. The latter is unheard of in NZ at the level of $40,000.
Winston Peters got the Government to give a lot of money to the racing industry. He had to persaude Clark and Cullen to ignore Treasury advice and go along with his plans for the Giovernment to provide prize money for some horse races.
Now if he was the personal beneficiary of a $40,000 donation (through paying his debt) from racing industry figures, then that absolutely 100% had to be disclosed. In fact the Prime Minister has to approve retention of any gift over $500 this is such a serious issue for Ministers.
Consider how scandalous this would be in a different portfolio. Let us say Winston was Minister of Health and he persuaded Cabinet to fund a new drug against the advice of Pharmac. And then it turned out the drug company that manufactures that drug had given him $40,000. You start to get the idea of how serious it is.
The PM needs to urgently find out whether that $40,000 was in fact donated by the Velas. The secrecy of donations through trusts (a practice I sumitted to Parliament should end incidentially) has only ever applied for donations to political parties. There can be no secrecy for donations to Ministers of the Crown.
News that the US is looking to join an existing agreement between New Zealand, Chile, Singapore and Brunei and turn it into a five way free trade pact is excellent news.
Helen Clark and Phil Goff should be thanked by everyone for the work they have done in the free trade area. Their record in this area has been highly admirable. They have moved Labour away from its protectionist roots, so that the only anti free trade parties in Parliament are New Zealand First and the Greens.
It is important to note this is only a first step. An actual deal is some years away and will have challenges such as a change of President and getting through Congress.
Danyl has suggested that Helen Clark may have sold her vote to George W Bush on letting India legally develop nuclear reactors, in exchange for this free trade deal. If this is true, then again Helen deserves praise for getting such a high price tag for NZ’s pro-nuclear vote.
If John McCain becomes President, then I there is no barrier to the FTA. He is in favour of FTAs with literally everyone but Cuba and North Korea.
Obama’s rhetoric has been strongly against free trade. Will he pressure a Democratic controlled Congress to accept it, even if there is short term pain to some of their constituents?
Anyway this is seriously good news, and let us hope progress towards free trade continues. Oh yes, and will someone ask the former Minister of Foreign Affairs whether he thinks this is good or bad news? 🙂
It is of huge significance that the Maori, Greens and United Future parties all voted not just to recommend Peters be censured, but to state they believe he lied to the Privileges Committee. This leaves Labour isolated with NZ First, and puts paid to Winston’s hysterical cries about “echoes of Zimbabwe” as if he is some sort of victim.
There is an echo of Zimbabwe all right – a politican who thinks he is above the law, who is unaccountable and untouchable, and is protected by the ruling party.
All five parties in the majority deserve congratulation for not shying away from their duty, each for a somewhat different reason.
Now assuming their recommendations are accepted by the House 63-58, then the question arises as to whether those minor parties could support a Government that includes Peters in it. I mean, if you have just voted to (politely) condemn the man as a cheat and a liar, then how credible would it be to support a Government which has him as a Minister?
So it would be interesting to ask Jeanette or Russel if there are any circumstances now in which they would support a Government that had Peters in it. Likewise for United Future and the Maori Party.
It is obvious that Labour can not be easily shaken from their position that they will keep Peters on, no matter what. But the minor parties can remove that choice from them by maing it an either/or (which is what Peters did to the Greens last election ironically).
Politically it would be better for National if Labour were not forced to rule Peters out. Winston as a Minister will be a good tool to bash them with. And imagine the fun we can have at Meet the Candidates meetings asking Labour candidates to defend Peters.
To quote Idiot/Savant at No Right Turn:
Typically, Winston is unrepentant to the end. And sadly, Labour is backing him all the way. Which is a good reason to be contemptuous of them as well. Some things are more important than politics, and political transparency is one of them. Sadly, Labour seems to have forgotten that. And they deserve everything they get from the public as a result.
But there is a greater good here. Keeping Peters out of power is more important than getting a National-led Government. One just can not have a Minister of the Crown who gives false evidence to the Privileges Committee, let alone one who receives personal $40,000 gifts from people in an indsutry he uses his portfolio to pour money into.
So even though it will remove a stick that one can bash Labour with, it is important for the integrity of our democracry that Labour rules Peters out. And if they won’t do it willingly, then let us hope the honest minor parties will force them to do it.
There are a number of different aspects to this issue, worth exploring.
The first is that in my opinion it is a legitimate issue for TVNZ to run a story on, even though they hyped it up beyond its value. And it was legitimate work by Labour Research to dig up the share registers. This is not in the same category as the nonsense over Merril Lynch or 60 body bags.
The second is that Dr Cullen is right when he says this is not insider trading. It would be impossible to be so. Asking written questions of Ministers elicits information that is published publicly. I do regard it as unwise for an MP to be involved in share trading, because of the perception of self interest that can attack to such activity. In fact I think MPs should really put as much stuff as possible in a blind trust with someone managing it. Now to be fair to John Key, he did realise in June 2003 that his shares in Tranz Rail could create a conflict and that is why he sold them. It would have been preferable in my eyes for him to get out at an earlier date but he had been an MP for less than a year then, and this is prior to having a Register of Interests even.
The issue of how many shares he and/or his family trust had, was not well managed. Now the value of the shares represents only around 0.1% of Key’s estimated worth but they are still a considerable amount of money to the average voter. Key did immediately correct himself when TVNZ prompted him about the transaction, but having to correct yourself is not a good look.
Some will of course compare this to the Helen and Winston show. While I cam critical of the substandard way Key has managed this issue, it is a long long way off Helen staying silent about Owen Glenn’s donation to Peters – especially as she knew Peters was pushing Glenn for Consul. But its release yesterday will have achieved its aim – to give Labour something to hit John Key back with during the Privileges Committee debate.
As I said at the beginning, the issue was over hyped by TVNZ. It was already a matter of public record that Key has Tranz Rail shares back then, and he still made an overall loss on them. There is absolutely no suggestion he broke any law, rule or standing orders. But it would have been better if when the issue first arose, that a check was made of all transactions, and this released at the time. It is always better to do it yourself, than allow your opponents to do it for you and package it with their own spin. That is the lesson for the future.
The Privileges Committee report has just been released and is online here.
I will comment on it shortly once I have read it. It is 280 pages long.
By a majority vote, they have recommended Peters be censured by the House. I can not recall the last time an MP was censured.
The majority includes United Future’s Peter Dunne, the Greens’ Russel Norman and Te Ururoa Flavvel from the Maori Party. This is every party on the Privileges Committee except members of Labour First. Note Peter Dunne is a Minister in the Government and the Greens have a co-operation agreement with Labour and the Maori Party abstain on supply and confidence.
They note on the issue of Henry refusing to disclose who suggested Henry approach Glenn for money:
We have received advice that legal professional privilege relates to communications made for the purpose of conveying legal advice and that it does not relate to the identity of a client, particularly when the issue does not relate to the communication of legal advice.
We note that legal professional privilege should not be used as an excuse to withhold information requested by the Privileges Committee, particularly in circumstances where this privilege does not apply.
They make the point that they have required a high standard of proof for their findings, as the allegations are serious – beyond the normal balance of probabilities.
They have determined that there was no debt from Peters to Henry, so no adverse finding there. But they have found the $100,000 constituted a gift as it benefited Peters:
We consider that the payment was of benefit to Mr Peters. Mr Henry’s work on the election petition did not create a direct legal obligation for Mr Peters to pay Mr Henry’s fees. However, Mr Henry told us that Mr Peters “knows that he owes me in the moral sense…”,18 and most clients would acknowledge such a moral obligation to pay a barrister.
A third-party payment to a member’s barrister benefits the member by discharging the moral (and potential legal) obligation to make payment and also by enabling the barrister to provide more assistance to the member in the future. Further, in these particular circumstances the payment contributed to funding an election petition which, if it had been successful, would have been of political benefit to Mr Peters.
They further note:
It is clear that the intent of the donor in this case was not to benefit the barrister. It was the member’s legal expenses that were being contributed to, not the barrister’s wellbeing. Mr Henry’s actions on receipt of Mr Glenn’s money were also unusual. Mr Henry wrote a “pro forma” invoice for GST and income tax purposes. We do not believe this is the normal response of the recipient of a gift. For a GST invoice to have been written, there must have been a taxable supply of services by Mr Henry. The relevant services were received by the member (or his solicitor, Mr Gates, on his behalf).
Together, these elements show clearly that the payment constituted a gift to Mr Peters.
On the issue of whether Peters knew:
The majority of us believe it is extremely unlikely that Mr Peters and Mr Glenn could have had a conversation on that date without the issue of a donation being raised, even if the original contact with Mr Glenn had been by Mr Henry, as claimed by Mr Peters and Mr Henry. The majority of us consider that the sequence of telephone calls followed immediately by an email containing bank account details indicates that the topic must have arisen during one or both of those conversations. It would have assisted our consideration if Mr Peters or Mr Henry had been able to recall more detail of their telephone conversation. Given the evidence before us, the majority of us concluded that Mr Peters had some knowledge of Mr Glenn’s intention to make a donation.
And their conclusion:
The majority of us find that Mr Peters had some knowledge of the $100,000 donation. Further, we find that Mr Peters, having an understanding of the arrangement by which funds were raised by Mr Henry, needed to make an honest attempt to file a correct return. For both these reasons, the majority of us find that a contempt occurred.
The proposed penalty:
Making a false or misleading return is a serious matter, akin to misleading the House. The majority of us therefore recommend that Mr Peters be censured for knowingly providing false or misleading information on a return of pecuniary interests, and ordered to file, within seven days of the House so ordering, amended returns for the years ended 31 January 2006, 2007, and 2008 covering any gifts, debts, or payments in kind that he has not previously registered. We request that the registrar ensure that the amended returns are published, recording that they are made subject to an order of the House.
This could be interesting, as it means any other donation to Peters legal fees, in excess of $500, has to be disclosed – if the House accepts the recommendation.
Now on the part regarding who paid for the $40,000 to Clarkson. Brian Henry is saying that as the cheque was from Wayne Peters’ trust account, he saw this as a reimbursement by Winston personally. Hilarious.
Now onto the letter from the SFO. The Director makes it very clear he got advise on whether to inform the Committee, and he has also bent over backwards to be fair to the donors who paid the $40,000 by redacting their names. He even asks the Privileges Committee not to order him to supply further information, even though he acknowledges a request from the Privileges Committee over-rides the secrecy provisions of the Serious Fraud Act.
The money laundering around the $40,000 is fascinating. Brian Henry did pay the $40,000 but the day before he sent Thompson WIlson (the law firm where two of the Spencer Trustees then worked) his bank account details.
The Spencer Trust only has $15,400 being left over donations from Donor A. Then Person B (not Winston Peters we are told) lent the Trust $24,600 so they could pay $40,000 to Brian Henry on 5 April.
Donor A (almpost certainly the Velas) then donated 4 cheques of $9,999 on the 7th of April 2006. Each cheque was from a different subsidiary company.
This allowed Person B’s loan to be repaid on 7 April.
What this means is that Donor A (almost certainly the Velas) personally donated $40,000 to pay off the $40,000 debt Peters owed Clarkson. He has to now declare this on his amended returns.
This raises massive issues relating to the conduct of his portfolios. The whole idea of disclosure is that the transparency it brings to whether Government decisions are affected by donations or gifts to an MP.
So the Minister for Racing in 2006 had Donor A – almost certainly the Velas, pay a $40,000 debt on his behalf. The Velas are multi-millionaires in the racing industry. And the Minister of Racing convinces the Government – against Treasury advice – to provide lots of money to the racing industry.
Does Helen Clark not think that this gift should have been disclosed as it strikes at the heart of decision making in her Government? And no it is nothing to do with NZ First – this is a personal gift to the Minister of Racing from persons massively affected by the policies he is responsible for in his portfolio.
Helen actually has three decisions to make. They are:
Here is the Cabinet Manual quote from section 2.79:
Ministers who accept gifts worth more than the prescribed value must not only disclose them to the Registrar of Pecuniary Interests of Members of Parliament, but also must relinquish them, unless they obtain the express permission of the Prime Minister to retain them.
So it is clear Helen has to decide whether Peters keeps the $40,000 gift (payment of a debt) from the Velas.
Now how corrupt will she look, if she says it is okay for her Minister of Racing to take and keep $40,000 from a family/company which has benefited hugely from the decisions of the Minister of Racing. He managed to force through millions of dollars of funding of racing prizes, against the advice of Treasury.
Clark has to make a decision on this. Peters has to relinquish the gift unless she gives her express permission he can keep it.
No wonder Winston wanted the SFO evidence suppressed. It was bad enough that NZ First had benefited by huge donations from the Velas, but to have it revealed that Peters personally was gifted $40,000 from them is hugely damaging.
Now it is possible the donations were not from the Velas but read the SFO letter and it looks highly likely. We should know more when Peters does his amended returns.
And as you consider all this, consider what depths the ethical standards of the Clark Government have descended to. Clark condones a Minister who:
Any one of these should be enough for dismissal arguably. But Clark is keeping him on despite all of the above. Could standards possibly get any lower?
Dear TV3,
Scott Campbell on Three News tonight in reporting on the PM’s reaction to the possible free trade agreement with the US, said she was “quite literally blown her away”.
Do I need to point out how silly this statement is.
Unless of course there has been a cyclone you forgot to report on.
iPredict has launched three new stocks:
I’d say Benson.Pope gives a pretty good opportunity to make some money.
Now you may be wondering who is this bimbo pretending she can play chess> Well her name is Alexandra Kosteniuk and she is no bimbo, having just won the World Chess Championship for women.
So much for the myth that beauty and brains do not mix.
Hat Tip: Not PC
As people will have read, NZ First is outraged that the SFO has revealed to the Privileges Committee that the evidence given by Peters and Henry is false. I mean shame on the SFO – how dare they reveal the truth. What sort of law enforcement body do they think they are.
So NZ First have complained to the Police about the SFO. Now this is of course a media stunt -designed to maybe convince the most stupid 5% of the electorate. For the benefit of the other 95%, I’ll link to Dean Knight – a public law specialist at Victoria University.
Dean makes four points:
So Peters and NZ First may be in contempt of Parliament (again) due to their attacks on the SFO for telling the truth to the Privileges Committee. If Parliament wasn’t about to dissolve, it would be worth an MP writing to the Speaker about!
The implicit attacks on the Serioud Fraud Office Director by Clark and Cullen (and Peters) are really final proof that this is a Government that thinks they are above the law. There is a very disturbing pattern of abuse directed towards senior officials who ever draw attention to the fact someone in the Government is breaking the law.
Here’s five examples:
Now consider this. The evidence the SFO seemingly gave to the Privileges Committee was that one of Helen’s Ministers lied to the media, lied to the public and gave a false statement to the Privileges Committee. This is an incredibly serious thing. The only reason it isn’t perjury is because they never swore their statements under oath.
Labour resent being held to account by the laws of this land. Whenever laws are broken they attack the law enforcement agencies. This goes well beyond a third term born to rule attitude. It is a sense of entitlement and being untouchable that is repugnant.
The NZ First President is reported to have complained to the Police about the SFO. This is a media stunt designed to hide the fact that the evidence the SFO is meant to have revealed is devasasting for Peters and Henry’s credibility. The NZ First President should in fact be thanking the SFO – he was one of those who knew nothing about the Spencer Trust before they shed light on it.
Spies in Dunedin tell me that David Benson-Pope has been hard to work campaigning, and handing out flyers urging people to give their party vote for Labour.
As he is not on the Labour list and is not a Labour candidate, that is very generous of him.
Anyone want to bet that he will not be standing?
Saturday Night Live did a very funny sketch of Sarah Palin with Hillary Clinton. Tina Fey looks and sound remarkably like Palin and is hilarious. The Clinton actress isn’t anywhere near as close a look, but is also bloody funny. Only five minutes and worth watching.
Oh and if you watch it and wonder what a FLURGE is, check here.
Helen Clark has confirmed, according to NewstalkZB, that she is keeping Peters on as a Minister regardless of the outcome from the Privileges Committee.
The Prime Minister says the whole process of investigation into New Zealand First’s finances has been tainted from the outset.
What is she referring to? Does she mean those Labour MPs who argued against or voted against even asking Owen Glenn to call evidence? If they had got their way it would have been a cover up – just like the original inquiry into Taito Phillip Field that cleared him.
Helen Clark says the privileges committee process has been totally unsatisfactory in terms of any natural justice. She says for that reason she is unlikely to be forced into a decision over Winston Peters this week. She says it has become so politicised with some MPs going into committee with made up minds before they had even heard a single piece of evidence.
Dail Jones arguably yes. I doubt anyone else had a closed mind. Even I have changed my mind on what Peters may have done wrong, as evidence emerged.
But the PM also misses the point here. The issue is not so much the outcome of the Privileges Committee, but the information disclosed by its inquiries. In one sense it does not matter greatly what the Committee recommends (the House decides). What matters is what has been disclosed about the veracity of a Minister in her Government.
The process used by the Privileges Committee has exposed that Peters has lied repeatedly – to the media, to the public and to the Privileges Committee. There is no real reasonable doubt about that. The evidence that Peters knew about the donations is as firm as you can get without an actual tape recording of their conversation.
So Clark is saying she has no problems with Ministers who lie, lie and lie again. So long as their parties vote to keep her in power. This is the standard of Government Helen Clark is happy with. And Clark wants to campaign on “trust” – bring it on.
However, Miss Clark very much doubts there will be anything to justify Mr Peters’ reinstatement. She intends to continue burning the midnight oil doing his old job as Foreign Minister.
It is important for people to realise how misleading those comments are. First of all Peters is still a Minister with all the baubles of office – except actually having to do any work. Secondly he was suspended from his portfolios purely on the basis of the SFO investigation, so Helen suggesting she is being restrained by not reinstating him due to the Privileges Committee is inane.
The big issue is whether Clark will rule out Peters as a Minister after the election. So long as she won’t, then people need to be reminded:
The latest monthly migration stats confirm the trend of the last five years. Graphed above are the annual migration figures for:
I have not included a graph for Net Permanent and Long-Term Departures from NZ as inwards migration iof non citizens is determined by Government policy and can be adjusted to any level desired as first world countries always have massive immigration supply available.
Overall PLT departures have reached 81,788 – a record high since the current data series began in 1985. This is equal to 1,569 departures a week or 224 a day.
If one excludes non citizens, then PLT departures are at 59,132 which is 1,134 a week or 162 a day.
Now if one takes into account the number of NZ citizens returning home, then the net PLT departures of citizens is 35,859. Five years ago it was only 10,000.
So in annual terms, what cities are equal to our population loss:
And what has been the total population loss of the last five years:
Inwards migration of new New Zealanders (which is a great thing) helps keep the overall population stable, but that does not mean there isn’t a serious problem with the numbers leaving.