Clark says believing Fairfax poll like believing in fairies

NZPA reports:

Believing in polls that put National at more than 50 percent support is like believing in fairies, Prime Minister Helen Clark said today.

A Fairfax Media-Nielsen poll over the weekend put National Party support on 52 percent, 18 points ahead of the Labour Party.

Miss Clark told TVNZ that those numbers did not match her experience as she met people across the country.

“I would no more think that National’s polling over 50 percent than I thought there were fairies at the bottom of the garden, that is not reality,” Miss Clark said.

Not a touch of humility. Not a touch of “Yes we are behind and need to convince people”, just King Canute routine.

I’ve just done a count up and since John Key became Leader there have been 50 public polls showing National at 50% or greater, including seven from UMR who do Labour’s own polling.

That is a hell of a lot of fairies!

Dom Post on cheap shots

Today’s Dom Post editorial takes aim at cheap shots from Labour:

Labour’s attacks last week on National leader John Key reeked of the desperation engendered by that sort of poll result. First there was an attempt to diminish the lustre of Mr Key by linking his economic management skills to the failure of his former employer, Merrill Lynch.

Then there was an exercise in shroud-waving by Prime Minister Helen Clark. She produced a “back-of-the-envelope” calculation, based on American deaths in Iraq, to suggest 60 New Zealanders would have been killed had Mr Key been able to commit New Zealand to the coalition of the willing.

Neither stands up to scrutiny. Mr Key left Merrill Lynch long ago and, were he of a mind to respond in kind to what is a facile attack, could point out that it got into trouble only when deprived of his skills. As for Iraq, he could remind Miss Clark that most of the Americans killed there died after the initial invasion and that she committed defence personnel there for a good chunk of the subsequent occupation, operating under a United Nations mandate, without suffering casualties.

Yes. Finally a mention of the fact Clark had troops there for 12 months.

It is understandable that Miss Clark and her colleagues have decided to embark on negative campaigning, and attempt to shift the focus to Mr Key. That must seem a better strategy than leaving voters to focus on her inexplicable refusal to do the honourable thing and cut NZ First leader Winston Peters adrift. He and his party are now trapped in a swamp of evasion, half-truths and changed versions of events, which have left him at best guilty of rank hypocrisy over party funding and, at worst, of lying to the public. Yet she, by sticking with him, has waded into the same mire.

And not just lying one but time after time after time.

And finally on the EFA:

Attacking Mr Key must also seem better than leaving voters to focus on what Electoral Commission chief Helena Catt has called the “chilling effect” on democracy of the Electoral Finance Act. That act was pushed through by Labour despite warnings that it was an ill-considered, ill-drafted piece of legislation that would make taking part in the political process arduous and possibly dangerous.

It is small comfort that those caught in its stifling web are largely its advocates. Labour is uncertain how much of the cost of union pamphlets praising it and attacking National policies it will have to include in its election expenses, while Progressive Party leader Jim Anderton has been pinged twice, which he says is bizarre.

What is bizarre is that he tried to argue to the commission that his newsletter should not be subject to the same rules faced by members of the public, because he is an MP and it should be protected by parliamentary privilege. That is just another symptom of the arrogance of power that afflicts this Government, and that has seen voters turn against it.

They really do think they are above the law. Mind you, only because so often they have been and got away with it.

Meurant will talk to SFO

Harawira on Agenda

Agenda hve the transcript up of their interview with Mairo Party MP Hone Harawira. First the good parts:

HONE Oh sure, I mean they have, to assume that they can simply sit there and pass an Electoral Finance Act when the whole world was saying this sucks and in fact it’s come back to bite them on the bum shows how disconnected they were with reality to try and ram through legislation at this late stage in the game is arrogant, it suggests that they are really only – and then to stack all of these quangos with their cronies suggests that they see themselves going out and they’re really just trying to maintain as much power as possible, that’s arrogant, that’s nothing to do with coalition building, and in fact the Labour Party has yet to come out clearly and say these are the sorts of things we’d like to do with the Maori Party.

Harawira is of course right with his analysis.

GUYON What about National then are you comfortable, could you actually work with National?

HONE Another difficult one there, but no more difficult than working with Labour as far as we’re concerned. People have this big fear of National and Maori in terms of oh they’d get rid of the Maori seats wouldn’t they, but my response constantly is always the greatest land theft of my generation has actually been the Foreshore and Seabed and that wasn’t stolen by National that was stolen by Labour, would you expect us to jump into bed with them happily.

That is a very different tune to a few years ago.

But some idea of the challenges ahead:

GUYON Let’s talk about a couple of the things that you said you want to do if you have influence over a government, you wrote recently in the Northland Age that you want to remove GST from food and abolish tax for people earning $25,000 and under, how much would that cost?

HONE Actually Guyon I couldn’t care less how much that costs, what I do know is this.

Guyon says Treasury worked the cost out for them:

GUYON Well we did something that you should have done, we asked Treasury how much this would cost, they said it would cost two billion to remove GST from food and three billion more to cut taxes for those earning less than $25,000. You want free health care for kaumatua and kuia too, where is the money coming from?

I have a figure of $2.4 billion for removing GST from food. The no tax on those earning less than $25,000 could be even more than $3 billion. That is the cost of zero tax for everyone who earns $25K or less. But if you read it as being zero tax on the first $25,000 of income (which you would need to do otherwise someone at $25k pays $0 and someone on $26K pays pays says $5k) then the fiscal cost is arouynd $11.4 billion (according to NZIER calculator).

HONE Well let’s say the tax off cigarettes for the last we’ll say five years, that’s five billion dollars. This isn’t very hard eh, this isn’t rocket science, the government is taking a billion dollars a year off tobacco tax, they could certainly spend it in this area.

Hone is correct that tobacco excise tax is around $1 billion a year. But that tax is already budgeted for.

Even if Hone was suggesting we double the excise tax on tobacco, that would bring in an additional billion a year at most. Probably quite a bit less as the amount of tobacco purchased would decline. But even if it was $1 billion that is not even close to the $5 billion to $13 billion cost of what he wants to do.

The slogans policy

You read the story on ACT’s law and order policy and you get the impressions it is a policy to have more slogans. At first glance we have:

  • Will “turn back the clock”
  • zero tolerance for crime
  • a communities-first approach to policing
  • one law for all
  • harsh quick justice

None of which mean much to me. The only actual policy detail in the story was “to deport any non-New Zealand citizen convicted of a serious violent offence upon completion of sentence or earlier” which sounds a good idea to me. More specifics like that would have been good.

Rodney’s speech doesn’t contain any details. They do have a law & order policy which states they will:

  • Bring back private prisons
  • speed up courts (no details as to how though)
  • Promotes “broken windows” and “zero tolerance”

Now before all the ACT supporters yell at me, I also criticised National for the (previous) paucity of their policy statements.

E-Voting

An article in the NZ Herald on how we will not have e-voting until 2023 at the earliest under current plans. I’m one of those quoted criticising the timetable and advocating we should be moving to trails in the very near future.

Anthony Doesburg points out that groups such as the Teachers Council have sucessfully run online elections with 80.000 voters.

A change I have advocated in the past is that the Chief Electoral Office be put in charge of all local body elections also (working with the local authorities). This change is beneficial in its own right, but would also allow testing of e-voting in one or two areas in 2010.

A funny ad

I love Snapper

Have been using my Snapper card for a few weeks now and I have to say I love it. Not every bus is accepting it yet but most of them are, and it really is easy – just swipe on and off.

What I really like is one can login to the Snapper website and see your transactions and account balance. You can also top the card up online wih the right interface. And it emails or texts you when your balance is low.

The 25% on bus fares is good, but could be better. In London for zone one you pay 1.50 pounds using the Oyster card on the tube and 4.00 pounds if cash. On a bus it is 90p vs 2.000 pounds. If you really want customers to start using Snapper, you need that sort of margin. Oyster also has a daily price cap over all forms of public transport.

McCarten on a Labour-led Cabinet

Matt McCarten suggests this will be the Cabinet, if Clark wins a fourth term:

  1. Helen Clark, PM
  2. Michael Cullen, Finance
  3. Jeanette Fitzsimons, Environment, Energy
  4. Phil Goff, Foreign, Defence
  5. Jim Anderton, Agriculture
  6. Parekura Horomia,
  7. David Cunliffe, Health
  8. Trevor Mallard, Labour
  9. Ruth Dyson, Employment
  10. Chris Carter, Education
  11. Sue Bradford, Social Development
  12. Pete Hodgson, Economic Development
  13. Lianne Dalziel, Justice or Attorney-General
  14. Maryan Street, Housing
  15. Shane Jones, Maori Affairs
  16. Sue Kedgley

McCarten makes a number of contentions that are highly arguable:

  1. That Clark won’t have Peters back as a Minister. I totally disagree. She has explicitly said she will if NZ First makes it back.
  2. Claims Goff, Cunliffe and Jones will all become Leader at some stage. Unless they change leaders as often as National has been, they won’t all make it.
  3. That this would be more of a fresh face than National. Well four of the top five entered Parliament when Muldoon was PM.

UPDATE: A reader points out that I am pushing the case to claim Anderton entered Parliament when Muldoon was PM. I was techically correct in that Anderton entered Parliament at the 1984 election on 14 July, and Muldoon was PM until 26 July 1984, but he wasn’t really there for the Muldoon era.

Coddington on experience

Deborah Coddington makes some good points o re Cullen’s attacks on Key:

If Otago University’s medical research department announced it had discovered a cure for cancer, which some years later turned out to be an over-hyped pill made of grass clippings, would we apportion blame to the current Attorney General and Minister of Finance because before he was elected to Parliament he lectured in another department at that university?

A good analogy.

I know who I’d rather have running the country’s economy in these increasingly depressing financial times – someone who’s been out in the real world and knows what it’s like to work in the private sector, where you’re only as good as your last transaction.

As far as I know, neither Clark nor Cullen have ever worked in the private sector, aside from I expect the odd part-time or casual job while studying.

More changes to Winston’s stories

Audrey Young has a very useful blog entry analysing what Winston says now, and what he said before the truth came out.

As readers will know, Winston is outraged because the SFO passed on evidence to the Privleges Committee that proved Peters and Henry lied. In Winston’s world it is outraegous if law enforcement agencies expose his lies.

Audrey notes:

Peters confirmed that the Spencer Trust had reimbursed his lawyer Brian Henry the $40,000 Henry had personally paid for costs awarded against Peters in the Tauranga electoral petition, talking to drive-time host Larry Williams on Friday night:

This is quite crucial because if anyone but Peters paid that $40,000 debt then beyond doubt that had to be declared on the Register of Pecuniary Interests.

”Mr Henry paid the money initially. He was later reimbursed out of the trust account from the Spencer Trust funds. In that sense yes,” Peters said. ”But that was a trust to assist the New Zealand First Party and any actions it might take. What’s wrong with that?”

What is wrong is Winston failed to disclose this. Just as NZ First failed to disclose donations from the Spencer Trust.  This is not a series of one off “mistakes”.

The great service done by the SFO investigation has been to expose the failure of NZ First and Peters personally to disclose funding from the Spencer Trust. And in case anyone really thinks it was all a mistake – consider the fact that these “mistakes” only came to light due to the SFO. Peters did not at any stage move to correct on his own initiative his public statements. He only admits to something once law enforcement agencies pry it out of him.

It means that the information Peters gave in a speech on August 20 to supposedly “clarify” what had been said about the $40,000 at the privileges committee two days earlier was actually not true.

“Mr Henry paid the money [$40,000] to ensure the bill was paid in time – and he was later reimbursed by myself,” Peters told Grey Power in Upper Hutt.

“He checked his records yesterday and found this was indeed the case.”

A clarifying letter was sent to the privileges committee to that effect.

People should be very aware of this point. The lie which has been exposed by the SFO is not about what was said at Privileges Commitee in response to Russel Norman. Most people would accept that you could be mistaken when responding to an unexpected query on the spot.

But what we have here is Peters claiming two days later, in a formal speech, that he had “checked the records” and Peters had reimbursed Henry. And they were so certain of this info, they sent a letter to the Privileges Committee stating this.

Their claim and letter was false. The Prime Minister once again keeps Winston with his baubles of office despite the fact he has been exposed at deliberately deceiving the public and the Privileges Committee. This was no mistake made in the heat of the moment. It was a statement made two days later which they claimed was based on a check of records.

Peters’ admission about the reimbursement also raises questions about whether the $40,000 should have been declared to Parliament in 2007 in the Register of Pecuniary Interests.

There is no question that it should have been.

We now know the Spencer Trust was run by Winstons’ brother, law partner of his brother and a staff member in Winston’s office. And it paid personal bills on behalf of Peters. So Audrey reminds us of this press conference:

Q: Mr Peters are you seriously saying that people are meant to believe that you don’t know what the ST is used for?
A: Yes I do. You know why? Because those are the facts.
Q: We asked your brother yesterday and he wouldn’t answer the question.
A: Well Audrey you should show a bit of knowledge, experience and a bit of commonsense, right? Go and ask him again.
Q: Who should we ask?
A: You’re entitled to ask it all the questions you like.
Q: But you’re not answering them.
A: How can I answer them if I’m not in charge of the trust.
Q: Because you know what that trust is using the money for.
A: Sorry I don’t.
Q: Really?
A: Well I just said no I don’t.

And as you read what are really bare faced lies (unless you think Winston can somehow not know that the Spencer Trust paid a $40,000 debt on his behalf), remember once again that Helen Clark has no problems keeping Peters on.

Audrey also goes back to the original Privileges Committee hearing when Brian Henry lied and insisted he paid for it personally (you would know the difference between paying $40,000 out of your own pocket and temporarily paying $40,000 and getting reimbursed). He obviously did not want to admit the Spencer Trust effectively paid for it, so in response to an incredulous Wayne Mapp:

Mapp: Are you seriously suggesting that you would’ve paid $40,000 in court costs which were against Mr Peters and you advised Mr Peters of that fact, and that Mr Peters would not have understood that that would’ve effectively come out of the $100,000 – well the donations received?

Henry: Mr Mapp, I’m not ‘seriously’ saying it; I am saying it. I’m not suggesting it. I’m telling you exactly what I did…..So don’t slur it – this is what I did. I’d like to finish with Mr Mapp….Mr Mapp I am telling you what I did. So please do not slur it or belittle it by saying ‘Are you seriously suggesting….’ This is actually what I did. You mightn’t like it but that’s what I did.

Such outrage, all faked.

Whale Oil also blogs about further revelations from Spencer Trustee Grant Currie. On radio Currie said that they spent money on behalf of NZ First, after consulting with “someone” who was not a duly elected office holder of NZ First. That someone would be McClay on behalf of Peters I suspect.

You have to wonder if there is a single MP or office holder in NZ First with any spine? The party president didn’t even know of the Spencer Trust. Money meant for NZ First went into the trust, and then spent on behalf of the party bypassing the authority of the NZ First President and Board.

A great photo

Dirty politics in cyberspace

HoS on Vegas

The HoS returns again to the Vegas side-trip Winston Peters took last year, in breach of the Cabinet Manual.

Peters insists he met the cost of his airfares and accommodation in Las Vegas and later reimbursed “an acquaintance” who had supplied him with the boxing tickets.

Is that like how he reimbursed Brian Henry for the $40,000 costs to Bob Clarkson? In that case Peters claimed he had reimbursed someone and it turned out he hadn’t.

Fran on party strategists

Fran O’Sullivan takes a look at who is driving the campaign strategy in each party.

But at the tactical level, some decisions are backfiring. Clark says the election is about “trust”. She reinforces that message by using “dog whistle” tactics which could have come from the Crosby Textor campaign textbook she usually decries.

Yep.

In the past she has deputed senior politicians such as Trevor Mallard or Phil Goff to be the party’s attack dogs and rark up her opponents, but this time she is getting into the gutter.

Leading the descent downwards.

National does not have an uber-fuhrer as strategist. What it has is a strategy team which has been meeting on a daily basis “for months now”.

Strategy by committee – hmmmn.

Party insiders expect author Nicky Hager, who wrote The Hollow Men, to try to drive a public wedge between English and Key by dropping more damaging emails during the election campaign.

No doubt.

Some clued up National MPs are even using digital tape-recorders to record their public utterances so they have a log of what has been said in case they are subject to a re-run of the secret recordings at their own annual conference.

A very good idea.

Maori MP Hone Harawira is the party’s campaign manager and also in charge of fund-raising.

A smart choice – lots of street smarts.

The shield is finally coming home

Okay there are still 20 minutes to go, but unless something dramatic happens it looks like it will be moving to Wellington. 15-0 and 20 minutes to go.

Wellington has not had the shield for 26 years and two days after we lost it to Canterbury on 18 September 1982. I remember the match!

It has been won 16 times since then by Auckland, Canterbury, Waikato, Taranaki, Bay of Plenty and North Harbour.

We should be able to avoid holding it for only a week, as the next game in Wellington is against Tasman.

UPDATE1: Now 27-0 and five minutes to go. Also the commentators just mentioned the Wellington Captain in 1981 when Wellington last won the shield was Paul Quinn. Paul is now the National Party candidate for National in Hutt South!

UPDATE2: And that is the final score. My God that was a long drought.

Saturday Cactus

Cactus Kate writes a wonderful piece of how useless many meetings are. If she ever gets convicted of a serious crime, I am going to recommend to the Judge that he sentences her to three month’s servitude in a Government Dpeartment. She’ll be in a strai jacket within a week.

Kate also picks up on Winston talking about his accounts:

They’ve not been able to find a thing wrong with New Zealand First’s accounts outside and around New Zealand

Kate wonders why NZ First has bank accounts or records outside New Zealand. A good question.

Family First rates the Leaders

Family First has rated every party leader for their “family friendliness” as they see it. This is a great idea, as those who agree with Family First’s values can use it as a positive guide, and those who disagree can use it as a negative guide. More lobby groups should do this sort of stuff.

The overall ratings (in order) for each Leader is:

  1. Winston Peters 77%
  2. Peter Dunne 69%
  3. Pita Sharples 57%
  4. Tariana Turia 54%
  5. John Key 54%
  6. Jim Anderton 38%
  7. Rodney Hide 31%
  8. Jeanette Fitzsimons 15%
  9. Helen Clark 8%

Winston is the poster boy for social conservatism which is why it is so hilarious that so many on the left are doing everything possible to defend him.

There were 13 issues or votes they judged the Leaders on. I list them below, along with how I would have voted on it if I was an MP.

  1. Prostitution Bill- DPF support – 0
  2. Civil Unions – DPF support – 0
  3. Relationships Bill – DPF support – 0
  4. Parental Notification for under 16 abortions – DPF support – 1 (I support notification, not approval)
  5. Euthanasia – DPF support – 0
  6. Care of Children – DPF oppose – 1
  7. Marriage Amendment (define as man/woman only) – DPF oppose – 0
  8. Anti-Smacking – DPF oppose – 1
  9. Easter Trading – DPF support – 0
  10. Easter Sunday Trading – DPF support – 0
  11. Drinking Age to 20 – DPF oppose – 0
  12. Street Prostitution (Manukau) – DPF oppose – 0
  13. Electoral Finance – DPF oppose – 1

So if I was a party leader I would be scored 4/13 or 31% – the same as Rodney Hide.

Paul Buchanan reinstated

This is good news. Auckland University has reinstated Paul Buchanan after sacking him over a year ago.

Buchanan won a case for unfair dismissal and $66,000 of damages but not an order for reinstatement. I believe he was appealing the decision not to reinstate and it looks like he has reached an agreement with Auckland University to avoid the court case. That is a win for both sides.

Roger McClay

No major surprise here – the NZ Herald has revealed that the third trustee of the Spencer Trust is Roger McClay.

I haven’t seen Roger for a couple of years but always got on well with him. Mind you – almost everyone does – he’s a very genial and likeable guy – well suited to a fund-raising role for Winston. Despite my views on Winston, I’ve got on well with many of his staff – I had coffee on Thursday with another former staffer.

The revelation of Roger’s fund-raising role creates a couple of issues for Winston – but fairly minor compared to the others. Pretending you know nothing about the Spencer Trust when one of your staff members runs it, doesn’t hold up well.

The other factor is having taxpayer funded staff members involved in fund-raising. Now I have to declare here that I was a parliamentary staffer for eight years and some of the jobs I ended up doing were interesting to say the least. The line between parliamentary and party is a fine one.

However to the best of my knowledge having a parliamentary staffer actually doing the party fundraising was a line never crossed. There were not many uncrossable lines but that was one of them.

The week at iPredict

It’s been a week of turmoil on some of the political markets as well as the sharemarkets. Mu weekly newsletter for iPredict went out today, where I try to anaylse the trends. It is repeated below:

Peters.Resign had another volatile week. It started off fairly constant at 70% and stayed there until Brian Henry started testifying Tuesday morning to the Privileges Committee. The early testimony saw the stock price fall to 35% as some sellers bailed out. But then as it became clear that Mr Henry’s evidence was actually backing up Owen Glenn’s version of events, the price skyrocketed to around 80%. Some huge profits made there.

The price then declined over the rest of Tuesday and Wednesday to settle at around 55%. As news broke Thursday morning of the SFO having provided information to the Privileges Committee the stock went up to 65%, But then at 3 pm Thursday the existence of a letter from an anonymous SFO staffer to Ron Mark was revealed and the stock fell to around 50%.

A related stock MP.Peters (will he make it back to Parliament) was less vigorous but shared some trends with Peters.Resign. It started at 37% and the day before the final open Privileges Committee hearing was at 35%. As the media reported NZ First insiders saying Henry would have evidence to clear Peters, the stock went up to 41%. But then the actual evidence pushed it down to under 35% and the SFO revelations pushed it further down to 33%. But a Roy Morgan poll published Thursday evening showing NZ First on 5% saw the stock rebound to 37%.

PM.Labour has spiked up and down between 24% and 30% this week. The 30% peak happened as Clark was reported saying a National Government would have resulted in 60 dead Kiwi soldiers n Iraq. However this peak lasted just a few minutes and by the evening they were down to 24%.

PM.National has had less trading, varying between 70% and 76%. The Pm’s announcement of the election date last Friday pushed them down from 73% to 71% but the weekend saw a continual increase to 76%. Cullen’s attack on Key’s career at Merrill Lynch saw the stock drop from 75% to 71%. The stock recovered to 74% but then got pushed down again with Clark’s Iraq claims, but only to 72%. National’s doctor retention policy may have had a moderate effect pushing National up from 72% to 74%.

Helen still in the lead