The Palin rumour cleared up

I caused some consternation on Facebook yesterday when I mused whether the allegations on Daily Kos might be correct, that Sarah Palin’s 5th child was in fact her grandchild.

The photos of Sarah Palin looking very slim at seven months pregnant and her daughter not so slim, did make me wonder. I almost could qualifty for NZ First membership, as I wondered if it was possible.

But no it is not a plot stolen from Desperate Housewives. Daily Kos got it half right. Reuters reports 17 year old Bristol Palin is pregnant – with her own baby though, not her brother Trig.

The extraordinary behaviour of the Prime Minister

Yesterday saw a remarkable series of allegations from the Prime Minister, which I am going to go through in detail. There are two explanations for them:

  1. She is a desperate paranoid leader who really thinks her own law enforcement agencies are colluding with the Opposition.
  2. She deliberately accused the SFO of leaking, knowing the “media meerkats” would forget all about asking her questions about how she knew “No” meant “Yes” in reference to Owen Glenn’s donation, and instead focus on the SFO instead.

I suspect No 2, as the media did all fall for it. Very little coverage on the Owen Glenn issue. But whether her allegations are desperate or calculating, they are extraordinary to tolerate from the country’s Prime Minister. It almost brings Nixon to mind, railing against the FBI.

Let’s start with her performance on Breakfast yesterday.

I find the National Party statement and timing interesting. Because I would say it is almost certain they got a tip from the Serious Fraud Office that it was about to move.

So Helen Clark can not work out if Winston is telling the truth, but she is “almost certain” that the SFO tipped off the National Party. Does she has a shred of evidence for her claim? No.

And I challenge them directly to come clean on that, because it is a very serious thing if an agency like the Serious Fraud Office is leaking to the Opposition.

It is a very serious thing. Almost as serious as inventing allegations against the Serious Fraud Office. Note that Clark has gone from inventing the allegation to now demanding that the guilty parties come clean on it.

I’m saying they acted on a tip. There was news around Wellington on Tuesday night last week they were about to move. The next day the National Party moved.

This is a classic 2 + 2 = 7. First of all National moved the day Owen Glenn directly contradicted Winston Peters’ version of events, shattering what remained of his credibility. Helen Clark seems to be the only person left in NZ who believes Peters knew nothing of the donation until July. In fact not even she can beleive it because at a minimum she told Peters about it in February.

And as for the PM’s Sherlock Holmes like conclusion that there was gossip in Wellington, so the SFO must be leaking to National, it is more like Inspector Clouseau.

First of all it had been reported in the media that the SFO had been interviewing key parties. Hence it was not surprising that people would speculate that they may launch a formal investigation at some stage. I’d been hearing such gossip for one to two weeks.

Second, Clark overlooks the obvious. That some of those who were interviewed by the SFO, formed a conclusion that they thought a formal investigation was likely, and were saying so – hence the source of the gossip.

Then the SFO responds:

“We do not believe that there has been any leak from the SFO and have received assurances to that end from all SFO personnel involved with the donations matter, and we do not intend to make further comment.”

So is that the end of the matter?

NZPA:

Miss Clark said she had “no option” but to take the SFO’s word.

Good God. She invents a wild accusation with no proof. The SFO talk to every staff member and respond, and her response is to say she has “no option” but to believe them. That is code for saying she doesn’t beleive them, but can’t prove it. And of course she can’t prove it, as she invented the allegation.

The Press:

Late in the day, Clark widened her claims to include two other agencies.

“I have no doubt whatsoever that word seeped out that the SFO was about to make a move,” she said at her post-Cabinet press conference. “Whether it seeped from there or from others in the loop remains to be seen.”

Asked who else was in the loop, Clark said: “Crown Law and the police”.

Now remember, Clark still has not produced a shred of evidence, apart from the fact there was gossip in Wellington (something that happens every day of the year), yet now she claims Crown Law or the Police may be leaking to National.

She said she was not dealing in rumour.

Not dealing in rumour??? She is creating the rumours!!!

The Herald reports

A Crown Law spokeswoman, who confirmed Mr Collins was involved, said he “absolutely did not leak to the National Party, or anyone else for that matter”.

Next Clark will claim it must have been the Cabinet Office, or DPMC or Heather Simpson or anyone at all she can fit up, because Helen is “almost certain” someone leaked to National.

I am trying to think of a parallel where a Prime Minister has just invented allegations against three senior law enforcement agencies, like Clark has. I honestly don’t think even Muldoon acted in such a way.

Finally we do know there was one definite tip-off:

But Helen Clark was also tipped off on Wednesday by Deputy Prime Minister Michael Cullen – who had learned of the impending investigation in his capacity as Attorney-General.

She said she was told late on Wednesday, after Mr Key held a press conference saying a National government he formed was highly unlikely to work with Mr Peters.

Maybe she will accuse Dr Cullen of tipping off National?

The sad thing is the media all played along with her bizarre claims, and let her off the hook on her knowledge of the Owen Glenn donation.

Are you a virtual fascist?

A quote:

I’ve just been listening to a fascinating interview between cultural critic, Lee Siegal, and “Nine-to-Noon”’s Kathryn Ryan, about the blogosphere’s malign influence on the quality of public discourse.

After a fortnight’s blogging, I have to admit to having some sympathy for his viewpoint. There is indeed a “fascist” quality to the blogosphere. And before anyone declares a “Godwin”, let me explain exactly what I mean by that comparison.

I have to agree with Danyl in the comments who quotes:

The word Fascism has now no meaning except in so far as it signifies “something not desirable.

George Orwell, Politics and the English Language

I think it is very foolish to fling terms such as fascism around, when describing online advocacy.

Why Hurricane Gustav is good for McCain

Inflation Expectations

Lord Ashcroft

TV3 has got rather excited that John Key recently met with Michael, Lord Ashcroft (best known for $200,000 reward for the return fo the VCs). Lord Ashcroft is a Deputy Chairman of the UK Conservative Party and Treasurer of the International Democratic Union.

Now I hope there is nothing wrong with meeting Lord Ashcroft, as I’ve done so a dozen times. He’s a very funny, very smart guy.

TV3 are trying to link the meeting into being like Winston getting donations from Owen Glenn. However the law is very clear – Lord Ashcroft can not donate more than $1,000 to a NZ political party directly or indirectly. Incidentally Owen Glenn can still donate as much as he wants, because Labour specifically changed the Electoral Finance Bill to allow foreign expats such as Glenn to still give donations even though they have not lived her for 40 years.

On one point TV3 have a fair point. Key was evasive when asked if Ashcroft has met with anyone from National, saying “Yes, I think they have”. He did give a more helpful direct answer to the question whether he had personally met Ashcroft, replying “Yes I have. I met him at my home”. By not giving the direct answer to the initial question, John makes it look like there is something to hide, even though there isn’t.

More Labour polling

Betty Blue got polled on behalf of Labour it seems. She says:

Pollster’s next question; how sure are you that you are going to vote National? Then, did I believe that Labour was doing a good job, etc. Same old, same old. Did the guy not listen to my previous answers? Further down the track he brought up John Key and how well I knew his policies, if I believed he can be trusted, how did I feel he handled tricky situations, if I considered him a strong or weak leader, if he made many mistakes, etc, etc. Leading stuff, I would have thought – trying to put a thought or two in my mind…

Next, the pollster informed me that if National won, Roger Douglas would be a likely canidate for the post of finance minister, and how did I feel about that? So, where were the leading questions about Helen and co? This was a concern I voiced. I also pointed out that Bill English was likely to be the next finance minister, that Roger Douglas was ruled strongly out in this role by Key some time ago. Anyway, was good for a laugh, if nothing else, I guess. I did have pleasure in taking part, even if the pollster’s questions rang of the absurdly desperate…by the absurdly desperate…for the absurdly desperate.

Now just to correct Betty Blue, this was not a push poll. It was testing attack lines. A push poll would involve calling tens of thousands, not a small random sample.

But having said that, it is interesting to see the likely attack lines from Labour. Despite Key’s statement, they look to be planning to use the line that voting for National will see Sir Roger Douglas as Finance Minister again.

Getting it right

Adam Smith points out that both the NZ Herald and Radio NZ have repeated the incorrect assertion in Labour’s press release that Jacinda Ardern’s employer (Sir Ronnie Flanagan) is the UK Home Secretary.

What has happened to fact checkers in the media?

Sir Ronald is in fact not even an MP. He is a professional cop working in the Home Office.

Note that I am not in any way suggesting Ardern is respondisble for promoting her boss to Home Secretary. I suspect someone in Labour just summarised her CV incorrectly.

The list is good for Cunliffe

Ben Thomas at NBR points something out about the Labour Party List:

Of those, five have worked directly as staffers for Prime Minister Helen Clark: Chris Hipkins (47), Grant Robertson (46) and Ms Ardern (20) are present or former advisors in the PM’s office; Brendon Burns (49) is the former head of the beehive’s communications unit established by Clark; Phil Twyford (26) worked in the Prime Minister’s electorate office in Mt Albert in 2005.

Now I don’t think working for a PM should rule you out of selection. In fact those candidates, if they become MPs, will be relatively experienced in parliamentary processes (although some of them somewhat lacking in life experience).

But the real significance, is what will happen if Labour loses. The leadership is likely to be a fight between Phil Goff and David Cunliffe. And five former Clark staffers will all vote with Helen to support Cunliffe over Goff. In no way does Clark want Goff as her sucessor.

So David Cunliffe should be very happy with the list, and Phil Goff less so.

Let the campaign begin!

National have released their first billboard. The PR says:

The billboard, on taxation and migration, was launched in Auckland this afternoon. The same billboard is going up at sites in Wellington, Christchurch, Hamilton, and Tauranga.

“Our first election billboard promotes our intention to introduce an ongoing programme of personal tax cuts. It will be a responsible and a transparent programme,” says Mr Key.

“National will build on Labour’s planned October tax cuts. We will treat those as the first tranche in our tax cut programme. There will be further tax reductions on 1 April 2009, and again on 1 April 2010.

“The billboard also highlights Labour’s failure to stem the tide of people voting with their feet and leaving New Zealand.

“The figures are sky-high. Recent statistics show that more people than ever are leaving. In the year to July, 80,872 people packed their bags and headed overseas for good.

“That’s the highest loss for a year ended July since 1979, and the second highest loss ever. The figure equates to more than 1,500 people per week.

It’s election time alright!

Who is Trevor talking about?

Who is Trevor Loudon talking about?

He is regarded as a political maverick, who in the past has challenged his own party’s leadership.

He hales from the southern part of his country, an area known for its hot dry winds and often arid parched soils. Its people are tough but very laid back.

He has been embroiled in a do or die battle with another politician that has held the country’s interest like no other political event in decades.

His opponent is a lawyer turned politician, a “man of color” as the Americans say. His opponent is telegenic, charming, charismatic and known for his oratory. …

Recently he confirmed his electoral 2IC.

She is a 44 year old, gun-toting super mother of 5. She is attractive, dedicated, intelligent and youthful. She is known as a strong campaigner against government waste and is a committed supporter of her country’s Armed Forces.

Click on the link above to see who he is referring to. Quite smart.

SFO denies leaking

With absolutely no evidence at all, Helen Clark stated on television this morning that the Serious Fraud Office almost certainly leaked to National that they were about to announce their investigation of Winston Peters.

Ben Thomas at NBR has been in contact with the SFO and their response:

The Serious Fraud Office has denied leaking information about its investigation of Winston Peters to the National Party, contradicting allegations made by Prime Minister Helen Clark.

Acting SFO director Gib Beattie said, through a spokewoman:

“We do not believe that there has been any leak from the SFO and have received assurances to that end from all SFO personnel involved with the donations matter, and we do not intend to make further comment.”

So the Acting Director has checked with every staff member involved. Will Helen Clark accept their word against her invented accusations?

Winston’s Song

A reader recorded this off Leighton Smith on NewstalkZB. A reader phoned in and sang a song about Winston. Leighton started off very cautious about it, saying one verse only but loved it so much as he heard it, let her sing the whole thing.

The song is here: winnies-song.

Kiwiblog Stats

A huge increase in views this week. Tuesday saw page views jump to 20,307, then Wednesday 25,182 and Thursday 24,156.

The second most popular search term yesterday was Jacinda Ardern.

Search terms which had more than 100 people use them to find Kiwiblog during August were:

kiwiblog 4,717
david farrar 883
tony veitch 716
kiwi blog 574
medals per capita 573
kiwiblog.co.nz 367
farrar 344
random questions 334
mahi drysdale 282
hayley holt 249
kiwiblog nz 216
kiwi blog nz 197
lesbian photos 188
www.kiwiblog.co.nz 188
david farrar blog 151
steve crow 151
politics blog 143
phil lewin 140
schapelle corby 139
group sex 139
tgif 132
lisa lewis 132
owen glenn 124
you tube 117
wwe 105
blondes 104
jacinda ardern 103
shawn tan 102
national party list 102
blogs 102
ian wishart 102

Also now have the alltime top search terms for Kiwiblog. Well now alltime because only been using this states package since April, but still interesting:

  1. kiwiblog 18,609
  2. david farrar 2,910
  3. tony veitch 2,227
  4. kiwi blog 2,105
  5. mongrel mob 1,760
  6. kiwiblog.co.nz 1,479
  7. clayton weatherston 1,272
  8. you tube 988
  9. farrar 883
  10. hayley holt 761

Obama and Key

The media are unable to resist the quote from a Financial Times interview in which John Key compares himself to Barack Obama!

But before people get worried that Key seem himself somewhat immodestly, it is useful to put the quote in its full context:

“I’m a bit like (Barack) Obama,” Mr Key, 47, told the Financial Times in an interview published today. “I am not institutionalised in Wellington”.

“I had 18 years in the commercial world and I will be quite pragmatic,” the old former Merrill Lynch investment banker said.

Key was pointing out that like Obama, he was relatively inexperienced in capital politics, which has its pluses and minuses. He wasn’t suggesting the same oratorical ability and I don’t think National are planning on 80,000 for the campaign opening 🙂

Dim-Post on why Clark isn’t losing it

Some people have suggested that Helen Clark is losing it, with his smear this morning against the Serious Fraud Office. Danyl at the Dim-Post though has a more logical explanation:

At first glance the Prime Ministers allegation that the Serious Fraud Office is in league with the National Party – for which she has not a shred of proof – suggests that she has joined her former foreign minister for a stroll in the gloomy sunless woods of paranoid delusion.

I mean it is extraordinary to have the Prime Minister accuse the SFO of actively working against her Government.

I don’t think the PM is losing it – I think she’s partly throwing shit in the hope that some of it sticks but I also think Clark assumes that the SFO staff abuse their authority to empower their friends and destroy their enemies through leaks and political theater because that’s what she would do if she ran the department. The notion that these public servants carry out their investigations with integrity and diligence without turning them into a savage partisan farce is simply unimaginable to her.

I wouldn’t want to argue that Danyl is necessairly wrong!

Hypocrisy Watch

From Winston’s blog:

One of the biggest problems we have in New Zealand is that we judge the morality of larceny in accordance with the scale of it. Low socio-economic individuals who find themselves on the wrong side of the law are dealt with more harshly than those who take tens of millions in shonky deals and set up family trusts to hide their assets. In fact, in some cases, the unscrupulous rich are held up as role models of our society. These people have the cheek to hold themselves up as true pillars of the community, when they are really part of the rotten foundations.

Setting up trusts to hide your assets. Disgraceful indeed thunders Winston.

Hat Tip: Roar Prawn

Is this why Wall was placed so low?

A reader reminds me of this SST story:

Wall says she will not actively seek the electorate vote in the Auckland Maori seat of Tamaki Makaurau, held by Maori Party co-leader Pita Sharples. Instead she will be seeking the party vote.

Labour Party president Mike Williams said he was “surprised” at Wall’s comments, as it was “absolutely not” party policy to stand aside in electorate contests in favour of the Maori Party. “We’re two ticks everywhere,” he said.

Wall, who enters parliament early next month from Labour’s party list, replacing retiring list MP Ann Hartley, said she would not be going head to head with Sharples over the seat.

“It’s not about me and Pita fighting. I’m going to be there as party vote Labour and talk about the difference between Labour and National.”

That the only thing I can think of to justify giving her an unwinnable place. A pity if it is, because as I said she impressed me the times she has appeared on Back Benches.

Hooton was right

Matthew Hooton on Eye to Eye referred to NZ First voters as:

mad elderly Pakeha racists

Now Matthew has been known to hit the hyperbole occassionally, but in this case he is backed up by no less a source than the Sunday Star-Times. They report that NZ First voters are far far more likely to beleive in conspiracy theories:

  • The US government knew about or planned the 9/11 attacks (52 percent)
  • A secret elite cabal controls world affairs (38 percent)
  • Princess Diana was assassinated (38 percent)
  • World governments are hiding evidence of alien visits (35 percent)

Speaks for itself!

No means no

Some people are having a hard time working out when no means no. NZPA reports:

National Party leader John Key has ruled out working with New Zealand First leader Winston Peters post-election altogether and says opponents are wrong to suggest that would change if he was struggling to form a government.

For those who are slow, John Key has explicitly ruled out Peters, even if it means he won’t become Prime Minister after the 2008 election.

Today Dr Cullen criticised Mr Key for his hardened position, saying he was disregarding natural justice and not letting inquiries finish before passing judgement.

“John Key’s stance shows that he has no respect for basic New Zealand values of fair play,” Dr Cullen said.

Mr Key said that the bar he set for who he would work with was higher than if they were cleared by investigations or not.

This is what Labour don’t understand. Labour’s bottom line is merely that an MP hasn’t actually been convicted of a crime. They don’t see any need to have the bar any higher than “has not actually been sent to jail”.

Mr Key ruled out having Mr Peters as a minister, forming a coalition with his party or entering any kind of support arrangement with NZ First.

“The lot. . . we have categorically ruled him out altogether.”

So what part of that is hard to understand?

Progressive leader Jim Anderton, speaking on TV One’s Agenda programme this morning, said Mr Key was not being brave and knew Mr Peters may not be in a position to negotiate following this year’s general election.

“I’ll give you this prediction that if Winston is there and he has the numbers to make John Key the prime minister you’ll find John Key finds very quick reasons why Winston’s a man of high integrity fast.”

Mr Key responded: “As is so often the case Jim Anderton has got it wrong.”

No means no.

Also on Agenda Green co-leader Jeanette Fitzsimons said it was up to her party, but her preference would be not to have to work with Mr Peters.

“If you’re sitting around a Cabinet table with someone you have to be able to trust them, you have to be able to take their word.”

That is a good start. But would the Greens give confidence and supply to Labour/NZ First, if they themselves are not in Cabinet?

United Future leader Peter Dunne said in the first instance his party would base who it worked with on policy. However the fact that Mr Peters let the controversy draw out without giving straight answers would be a factor “you take into account as to whether you can do business with that person subsequently”.

Goodness, that was almost a position Peter took! 🙂

Just remember these two lines:

A vote for NZ First is a vote for a Labour-led Government

A vote for Labour is a vote for Winston Peters in Government

Benson-Pope looks set to stand

The ODT talks to David Benson-Pope:

Asked yesterday whether he had decided about his future in politics, Mr Benson-Pope said it was not surprising his name was not on the list as he had not sought to be ranked there.

“I have no other comment to make other than to urge people to vote Labour with their party vote.”

There could be some indication of his future on September 9, 10 or 11.

On those days, retiring MPs will give their valedictory speeches in Parliament.

Now that sounds like a man planning to contest the electorate vote.

Benson-Pope will have a problem though. If he stands as an Independent It will be illegal for him to advocate in writing for people to party vote Labour, unless he has the permission of Labour’s Mike Smith to do so!

National’s Conway Powell will be hoping Benson-Pope stands!

UPDATE: Benson-Pope has removed all Labour Party colours and logos from his office according to Home Paddock.

The SFO smearing begins

First we had Winston Peters smearing the SFO, basically saying they are corrupt and would be investigating him because of criticisms he made a decade ago about them.

Then senior Cabinet Minister Jim Anderton on Agenda smeared them, saying he thought they were motivated to investigate Peters to stop the agency being wound up (never mind all the staff have jobs in its sucessor agency).

Now we have Helen Clark herself smearing the SFO, saying:

“I find the National Party’s statement and timing interesting because I would say it’s almost certain they got a tip from the Serious Fraud Office that it was about to move,” Miss Clark said today on TV One’s Breakfast programme.

“I challenge them directly to come clean because I think it’s a very serious thing if an agency like the SFO is leaking to the Opposition.”

This is unbelievable. This is not an Opposition politician accusing the SFO, but the Prime Minister of NZ. She is issuing public challenges through the media, when as PM she can ask the SFO directly if they leaked.
What do you call a Prime Minister and Government which attacks and smears a body investigating a Minister for corruption? Reminds me of Italy I have to say.

John Key ruled Winston Peters out the day Owen Glenn contradicted Peters, saying Peters had solicited the donation. But Helen says it is “almost certain” National has been tipped off about the announcement the next day. Well what proof does the Prime Minister has to be “almost certain” in smearing the SFO?

And here is the irony. When National was investigated by the SFO in 2002, a politician was tipped off by the SFO. Not allegedly, but confirmed by the SFO. That politican was Helen Clark through Mark Prebble.

National was obviously very upset that Helen Clark was told in advance, and attacked the SFO for that. But here is the difference – National did not allege something unproven. They reacted to being told by the SFO that it had informed DPMC of the investigation into National.

If Helen Clark has some proof that the SFO tipped off National that they would announce the formal investigation the next day, she should provide that proof. Otherwise she should stop smearing them.

Stories on Labour’s List

The NZ Herald has a positive story on Labour’s list, as does the Dominion Post.

I have to say, the more I think about it, the more Labour have really done a good job with their list. I’ll explain why below. People may find it strange that I praise their list when I will hope people do not vote for them, but I do think it is important that MPs in Parliament are of relatively high quality regardless of party.

Looking at my analysis yesterday, Labour have been smart in several ways.

  1. They have placed six new candidates in high enough spots that even if they only get 31%, they will be in Parliament. This means that if they fall into Opposition the Caucus will not just be the tired faces of the old Government, but will have some fresh talented blood such as Jacinda Ardern.
  2. No MP who sought a list spot got totally shafted – at 42% (they got 41% last time) they get all their List MPs back. This gives Caucus members an incentive to do as well as last time. I don’t think they will get 42% but it is not out of this world.
  3. With the exception of Louisa Wall, the MPs placed towards the bottom of the Caucus are those they can afford to lose – Soper, Heroera, Gallagher, Okeroa, Burton etc.
  4. MPs in marginal electorates have been placed right on the cusp so they have an incentive to maximise the party vote and their electorate vote – Chadwick, Burton, O’Connor, Tizard, Gallagher and Okeroa
  5. New candidates in seats currently held by Labour have all been grouped together and are unlikely to come in on the list (unless Labour gets over 42%), so are basically reliant on working their hearts out to win their seats. There are some risks with this though as candidates such as Grant Robertson will not make it to Parliament at all, if he loses to Stephen Franks.
  6. The occupational diversity of their selections seems to have improved. Yes there are still some unionists and teachers in the new intake, but quite so many as previously. And no I have nothing against unionists and teachers – just that Labour’s current caucus is seriously out of touch because so many current MPs are from those two occupational groups only. I wouldn’t want a National Caucus which is 75% farmers and lawyers either.

The list is a good reminder why one should not under-estimate Clark’s desire to win. She protected the Caucus in 2002 and 2005, but has been resolute enough to cut some adrift this time, and the list looks to be largely merit-based rather than based on factional deals.

It is fascinating that on current polls, National and Labour will both have six Maori MPs. I suspect it has been a very very long time since Labour had no more Maori MPs than National!

Guy Body cartoon

Historical treaty claims due in by midnight

The deadline for filing historical (prior to 1992) Treaty of Waitangi claims is at midnight tonight.

Claimants have had over 20 years to file their claims, so the deadline is far from hasty as the Maori Party claim. Indeed as Chris Finlayson says, there needs to be an end to litigation at some stage.

The Waitangi Tribunal has been publicising the deadline and has generated several hundred claims. I honestly doubt a single genuine claim has not managed to be filed.

The good thing about today, is that from tomorrow on the number of unresolved historical grievance claims can only start reducing. God knows how long it will take to consider and hopefully resolve them all, but we will have a known number of claims for the Tribunal and Government to work through.

Dr Cullen has done a sterling job in advancing Treaty settlements since he took over from Mark Burton. If National win the election, they should aim to match Dr Cullen’s pace. Luckily they have considerable resources to call on:

  • Chris Finlayson, who speny many years as Ngai Tahu’s lawyer and is very knowledgable in this area
  • Tim Groser, one of NZ’s top negotiators (and the settlements are very much a negotiation)
  • Georgina te Heuheu, a former member of the Waitangi Tribunal

Of course premature to speculate on what portfolios, MPs may get, but just wanting to show that the work of resolving historical grievances should continue, and settling such grievances in fair, full and final settlements is a win-win.