Business NZ Conference Part VII

John Key is the final speaker of the day. Some key points:

  • If the fundamentals of the economy do not change, we will not become wealthier
  • Cullen has worried too much about savings and not enough on growth
  • Ongoing programme of personal tax cuts.
  • Irish economy driven by world class education system, low company tax and good infrastructure
  • No radical changes to monetary policy
  • Domestic inflation too high due to capacity constraints
  • Will have some local government reform but not second guess Royal Commission on Auckland.
  • Size of the state does matter – 10,000 more core bureaucrats – but not just about numbers but efficiency.
  • Are taking a hard look at role of Electricity Commission – do we need a bunch of engineers second guessing Transpower?
  • 90 day probation period is not a right to fire clause but a right to hire clause. Is timid compared to many other countries.
  • Most Chinese are more capitalist than anyone else we know
  • At danger of becoming a giant educational facility for Australia

The conference is now ending. Yay. Seven stories isn’t a bad output if I say so myself.

Business NZ Conference Part VI

This is on workplace issues. Panelists:

  • Trevor Mallard (Lab)
  • Sue Bradford (Greens)
  • Kate Wilkinson (National)
  • Peter Brown (NZ First)

Questions

  1. What changes to KiwiSaver and why?
  2. What changes to ACC and why?
  3. Will you allow grievance free probationary periods?
  4. Will you remove the union monopoly on on collective bargaining?
  5. Will you change the “relevant daily pay” provisions of the Holidays Act

Kate Wilkinson

  1. No policy released. Key has indicated some modest changes to be announced in due course. Against Labour’s KiwiSaver amendment passed this morning that makes total remuneration packages illegal
  2. Will investigate opening the work account to competition so incentives are there for good safety practices, and allow employers to insure for a higher stand of cover. Also will have an independent disputes tribunal for ACC to be fair to claimants
  3. Yes a 90 day trial period for businesses with less than 20 employees.
  4. Yes will allow a collective agreement with no union. Making employees form an incorporated society just to negotiate a collective contract is cumbersome.
  5. The Holidays Act is like the blackboard scribblings in A Beautiful Mind. Will appoint business and union reps to a working group to review the Act, esp for relevant daily pay definition. Not to reduce rights but make law more clear.
  6. General comment – important to be fair to all parties – no major changes but some improvements

Peter Brown

  1. Want to make KiwiSaver compulsory
  2. Do not support competition to ACC. Does support an independent disputes tribunal.
  3. Missed
  4. Passionate about allowing employees to do a collective contract without forming a union, but NZ First does not have policy.
  5. Thinks law has settled down but willing to be persuaded otherwise.

Sue Bradford

  1. Support Government, think it is great.
  2. Oppose any moves to competition. Want more emphasis on equitable compensation regardless of how someone is impaired.
  3. No.
  4. No.
  5. No.

Trevor Mallard

  1. Missed but I guess no major changes
  2. Against
  3. Current Act has probationary periods (but grievances still possible)
  4. Against
  5. Missed

What was interesting is that every speaker against Trevor just spoke to policies and issues while Trevor sounded like he was blogging at The Standard and was referring to Crosby/Textor and the like.

Business NZ Conference Part V

Business NZ CEO Phil O’Reilly reported on the results of their survey of members. Over 2,000 members responded – mainly small business:

  1. Skills Shortage biggest issue – can not get skilled staff despite rising unemployment
  2. Firms want to innovate but don’t feel well positioned to do so
  3. Concerns about “environment” for business  – Holidays Act, ERA, ACC

Skills

  • 72% say education system not meeting skills gap
  • 94% say more work needed on apprenticeships and industry training. Need action not rhetoric
  • 91% say all school leavers should achieve NCEA Level 1 for literacy and numeracy
  • Not just student loans driving people overseas
  • The underlying problem is competitiveness
  • NZ economy not growing enough high-paying jobs so skilled Kiwis being sucked overseas

Innovation

  • 89% say R&D tax credits will nit lift R&D spend. Pointed out many small business who responded do no R&D
  • 54% say policies needed to improve access to venture capital
  • 54% say government assistance should be through a contestable fund

Environment for Business

  • 71% say the dismissals provision in ERA is below average
  • 54% say ERA collective approach is wrong way – less than in past
  • 89% do not want laws for work-life balance
  • 61% want ACC opened up for competition

Open ACC to Competition (Bus 61% yes)

ACT – yes
Labour, NZF, Greens, UFNZ – No
National, Maori – will consider it

Flatter Taxes

National, ACT, UFNZ – Yes
Labour, Greens, Maori – No
NZF – no clear policy

Local Government stick to core business (Bus 64% yes)

ACT – yes
Labour, Greens, Maori – no
National, NZF, UFNZ – no clear answer

Support FTA with China (Bus 55% yes)

Labour, National, NZF, ACT – yes
NZF, Greens, Maori – no

Should NZ be international leader on climate change? (Bus 73% No)

Labour – yes
ACT, UF – No
National, NZF, Greens – unclear answer

Who does the accounts for NZ First?

There are more and more questions over NZ First and their accounts. Both NZPA and the Dominion Post have said that Nick Kosoof is both NZ First’s Auditor and their Accountant. Surely not?

So can someone find out the following:

  1. Who was NZ First’s Auditor in 2005?
  2. Who was NZ First’s Accountant in 2005?
  3. Who was NZ First’s Treasurer in 2005?
  4. Who was NZ First’s Party Secretary in 2005?

To the best of my iformation the Party Secretary in 2005 was not some poor office person (as Helen suggests) but Edwin Perry who was an NZ First MP at the time.

Also Audrey Young blogged in February 2008 that the Party Treasurer in 2007 was also a former NZ First MP – Brent Catchpole. Was he also Treasurer in 2005?

And then we have an interview on Nine to Noon with Peter Williams. Parts are amusing as he rants about Matthew Hooton, and parts are clearly wrong.

Williams said around 5 minutes 20 secs in:

The money that they paid, I think it was about $80,000 wasn’t it? … The moneys that were subscribed by the Vela family were paid to the Spencer trust, and in turn the Spencer trust paid the money to NZ First.

But the Spencer Trust was set up in August 2005, and the Vela donations were between 1999 and 2003.

No wonder the SFO doesn’t go along with Mr Williams insistence that it can all be cleared up in five minutes and his latest line that they have made one little mistake in 15 years of flawless behaviour.

Two other stories of note. Martin Kay in the Dom Post says:

When The Dominion Post first put to him in July that NZ First received money through a trust, he said through a spokesman: “It’s a lie.”

Mr Peters’ brother, Wayne, is one of three Spencer trustees. Fellow trustee Grant Currie said on Monday that its only purpose was to channel money to NZ First.

So Peters said it was a lie, yet the lie was his.I am sure Helen just sees it all as another innocent mistake.

Ben Thomas at NBR also points out NZ First are recycling excuses:

New Zealand First’s explanation for why it didn’t disclose a $25,000 donation allegedly funneled through the Spencer Trust will sound strangely familiar to Winston watchers.

The party’s auditor said yesterday it failed to declare the $25,000 donation from Sir Robert Jones in the 2005 year because it slipped people’s attention “during a change in administrative staff.”

That is now the second time – and for the second separate set of accounts – that the party has used the excuse of a personnel changeover for ostensibly breaching electoral finance disclosure laws.

Like all Winston Peters’ rhetorical greatest hits – “if you stop telling lies about me,  I’ll stop telling the truth about you,” for example – “administrative error” may have been too exquisite a line to only use once.

In August this year New Zealand First was let off on the late filing of its return of donations for the 2007 year, because the Electoral Commission accepted its explanation the delay was caused by “changes in the upper levels of office holders such that many had not been through the donation return process before.”

New Zealand First missed the April 30 deadline for filing its donation returns. When the late return did arrive it didn’t disclose any donations – so why the delay? It should have been a simple matter to verify no donations over $10,000 (the minimum amount that has to be declared) had been received.

The party denied media reports that its president and secretary had been waiting for the return of Parliamentary party leader Winston Peters from overseas to sign off the accounts (which would have been unusual, since he is not a legal office holder as far as the party is concerned).

Instead the secretary offered up the “office-holder changeover” scenario, and aid there had been a miscommunication between the treasurer and the auditor. The commission decided that was a reasonable excuse, and so no breach of the Act had been committed.

Given how long it seems to take the New Zealand First party to sort out its finances after these periods of flux, the commission may be tempted to ask office holders to double check the zero-return filed for 2007. It is after all apparently quite easy for cash to slip between the cracks in times of HR churn.

I think it would be very prudent for the Electoral Commission to double check the zero return for 2007, especially before the deadline for prosecution expires. The fact that the Party President is on record as referring to a large anonymous donation (a stance he has never publicly recanted) gives them more than enough grounds to start checking.

Business NZ Conference Part IV

The Infrastructure Forum had six questions:

  1. How will you stop the risk of power blackouts?
  2. Will you privatise power generation SOEs to get more competition and lower prices?
  3. How will you get broadband into more homes and businesses?
  4. What changes will you make to the RMA?
  5. Do you support more protection for businesses at risk from the ETS?
  6. Do you support carbon credit allocation based on carbon intensity

Gerry Brownlee

  1. Energy Policy released details improvements to both security and supply. Planning for far more growth than Labour. Major consent decisions to be made within nine months
  2. No SOE sales
  3. Ran out of time
  4. Referred to in 1
  5. Not a yes/no answer but said credit allocation should be decided by a select committee process and a National ETS will do that. Gave a great example of how concrete plants in Europe will pay far less for carbon credits so just force industry offshore.
  6. Ran out of time

David Parker

  1. Record investment in energy under Labour. National did not invest in the 1990s
  2. No
  3. Broadband essential. $500 million fund next five years. WIll not favour incumbent.
  4. Does not accept RMA is a barrier
  5. Missed
  6. Missed

Jeanette Fitzsimons

  1. One can have security by over-building capacity so it is wasted every year but the peak year. Not efficient. Better to have a standby plant. Says we had a 1 in 60 dry year. Third way is make smart adjustments to demand to reduce at times of shortage and that is what is missing.
  2. Will not sell SOEs. Rejects that it would lead to lower prices.
  3. Supported LLU. Broadband key to reducing transport. But not support large state investment.
  4. Most changes Gerry wants to RMA already done. Problem is implementation and no national guidelines.
  5. Trade-exposed businesses are already highly protected. Some businesses may end up with surplus credits without reducing emissions.
  6. No – an intensity basis will lead to continued emissions.

Rodney Hide

  1. Does not think we can rule out all the power generation methods the Greens do. Need to reduce cost of capital by lowering taxes.
  2. Yes would sell them. No sense in Govt owing competitive businesses. Ownign them locks up taxpayers money and limits companies ability to raise capital for investment it deems necessary.
  3. Broadband important but regulation stopping its rollout. Need a stronger economy to be able to afford it. Against National’s policy in this area. Investment is slowing down due to uncertainity.
  4. Private property rights need to be enhanced, The RMA damages these rights.

Peter Dunne

  1. Rejects ideology. Needs security of supply. Say question is an alarmist straw man. Currently power is an un-cordinated jigsaw (so why are we paying $90 million a year to the Electricity Commission then). Agrees we have had over supply in past – supports smaller local plants but big hydro plants.
  2. I think it was a no.
  3. RMA needs national policy guidelines. DO not throw away RMA – streamline it and keep core principles.
  4. Missed.
  5. Do not support further protection to at risk businesses as we do not know enough about impact.
  6. No does not support but is subject to how the Act works out. Reason they oppose bill is because so much is uncertain and is being rushed through purely for political gain. Wants it passed by 1 April 2009.

Another caption contest

Photo from the Mid Canterbury Herald.

Let’s have your best captions. For the sake of not getting this blogged by the Indecent Publications Tribunal, you may not include any reference to David Benson-Pope in the caption!

Very funny

Peter Dunne arrived late for the minor party leader’s forum (it wasn’t his fault – he was given wrong time) towards the end of the question time. Sean Plunket said that what he proposes is we now have Peters speak to us, and then go to lunch.

Rodney Hide pipes up “Or we could all go to lunch, and then have Peter start speaking”. It was very very funny.

PM accepts it was a “mistake”

Someone should sell Helen the Golden Gate Bridge. NZPA quotes here:

Prime Minister Helen Clark says she accepts NZ First made a mistake when it apparently broke donations law but there is no reason to strip its leader Winston Peters of his ministerial benefits.

All baubles and no work!

She was not considering sacking Mr Peters over the legal point.

“No, because this has happened at the level of party administration. I wouldn’t expect to be held accountable for some sort of mistake at the Labour Party head office.”

The party administration had never ever heard of the Spencer Trust. The President and Deputy Leader had never heard of it. Only Winston and his staff knew about it.

Neither he nor the party explained another $25,000 banked four days later on August 22 2005.

Also just a mistake I am sure.

Miss Clark said she was taking NZ First’s explanation at face value: “They’re a small party with a rather amateur organisation, these things can happen.”

Helen will accept any explanation from WInston, no matter how outrageous, how contradictory or how desperate it is. If he claimed the moon was green, she would say that it is an honest mistake.

Business NZ Conference Part III

Three minor “leaders”

  1. Rodney Hide, ACT
  2. Russel Norman, Greens
  3. Derek Fox, Maori Party

Russel Norman

Environment movement needs to move beyond treating humans as a virus infecting the planet. Not about just doing less bad, but more good. Business sector is key part of this.

Need to transition to a sustainable economy. I then drifted off as various enviromental and resources issues were outlined. I do find the Q&A sessions much more useful than just plenary speeches.

Rodney Hide

Talked of Sir Roger’s goal to beat Australia by 2020 – and not just in the rugby or the netball. Says he loved it. Much more inspiring than some OECD average.

Said that he wanted Sir Roger around cabinet table as if he could convince a Labour Cabinet the merits of free market policies, sh should be able to do the same with a National Cabinet 🙂

Repeated Douglas on holding govt spending to inflation and population will allow a personal and company tax rate of 20%.

Derek Fox

I’ve got bored with the leaders and am working on some further Winston stuff, so no summary of Derek. Generally not a useful content compared to the Q&A which I thought worked very well.

Business NZ Conference Part II

We have five Finance Spokespersons after Winston pulled out. They are:

  1. Bill English, National
  2. Dr Michael Cullen, Labour
  3. Russel Norman, Greens
  4. Peter Dunne, United Future
  5. Sir Roger Douglas, ACT

Each was asked three questions:

  1. Will you cut company and personal tax and by how much and when?
  2. Will you have a cap on government spending as a percentage of GDP?
  3. Will you include labour and environmental restrictions in free trade agreements

Bill English

  1. Yes we will lower tax rates. Details soon. Important to do so to put cash in pockets, but more importantly incentives to work, save and invest. Also want a more efficient tax system.
  2. No as GDP goes up and down. Focus on quality of spending not a set target. Expect PREFU will show Crown is in deficit. So period of restraint needed. Govt spending excluding welfare growing at 8% per annum. Can’t carry on at that rate so will slow growth down, but will still grow in absolute terms.
  3. Not desired, but US Congress turning protectionist and they may demand them so we may need to be flexible. Generally supportive of Govt work on FTAs.
  4. Generally comment: no more cheap credit – growth will come from earning it and need to lift productivity.

Personally I think a target for expenditure as a percentage of GDP would be a very good thing.

Sir Roger Douglas

  1. Could reduce personal and corporate tax to under 20%, maybe even 16%. Also could lower GST to 10%.
  2. Need to say yes to this, so one can say yes to Q1 (he answered in reverse order). Says Govt expenditure should be held at rate of inflation of 2.5% and population growth of 1%. So an annual 3.6% increase only. Sounds good to me!! Any increase over 3.6% should be met with savings elsewhere. If we hold expenditure to 3.6%, each household will pay $13,000 less in annual taxes in 10 years time. Govt expenditure has increased under Labour by $17 billion, after taking inflation and population growth into account. That is $220 a week per household. What did you get for that $220 a week? Could you have spent it better yourself? No equity or fairness without efficiency in expenditure. Thinks expenditure of 25% of GDP is a good target.
  3. Support free trade agreements without these restrictions

I have to say Sir Roger was brillant. He may get some very serious support for ACT if enough people hear him. Very smart to not talk about slashing expenditure but just propose keep spending to inflation and population growth. Families can relate to that.

Peter Dunne

  1. Would cut personal taxes on April 2010 to 10% for income to $12K, 20% to $38K, above $38K at 30%. Supports income splitting. And align business and trust rates at 30%. Should do regular tax reviews, rather than wait 12 years between tax cuts (hear hear).
  2. No set cap. GDP not sole measure of wealth of economy. Does have concern over current level of spending but more concerned about quality and direction of spending. Proposes merging some DHB functions centrally such as equipment purchasing. A spending cut may lead to a service cut – $50 million into IRD so it can answer phones quicker as an example.
  3. Supports FTAs. Don’t need specific standards on environment and labour, as they are dealt with in the wider business environment. We are most trade dependent nation in the world.

Dunne did well also. Some nice specifics.

Dr Russel Norman

  1. Wants a transition to a sustainable economy. More ecological taxes and reduce taxes on income. Incentive then to reduce scarce resource use and pollution. Wants incentives to use less water. Supports ring fencing of losses on investment propoerties. Not supporting a decrease in overall tax – just how it is made up.
  2. Does not have a policy for a cap on spending. It is about efficiency.
  3. Does support standards, but notes usually just involves consultative committees.
  4. General comment on need to prepare economy for higher oil prices. No other party has policy around this.

Dr Michael Cullen

  1. Lowered company rate to 30% and legislated for three rounds of personal tax cuts. Also increased depreciation rates and R&D tax credits.
  2. No. Spending at he moment same as 99/00 as percentage of GDP. Goes up and down. A cap is artificial.
  3. Yes will try and include these standards as agrees with Bill needed for US Congress
  4. General comment on the need to lift exports from 30% of GDP. New tertiary funding policy is essential. Backed Clark up on how our bottom 30% of school leavers are very poor. Middle and top are both very good. More rail needed plus more roads. Also roll-out of broadband is important. Higher savings needed and our capital markets are very weak. Sustainability also important.

All five spoke well and knew their stuff. I do have to say I think Sir Roger was by far the best – both his level of detail, his forceful arguments and the actual policy. I would put Peter Dunne second best.

I don’t think Bill English came across that well. Not due to him (Bill was very much on top of the arguments), but because he could not give any details of the tax policy yet (which I think would have been popular). Would have been good though if National had decided to release some sort of business policy today, so there is something new. Maybe that will come in a later session?

Regulatory Responsibility Act

A question on whether they would support a Regulatory responsibility Act.

English says there is support for defining the principles of good regulation, and using the bureaucracy to fight the bureaucracy so regulations can not proceed without ticking all the boxes which justify the regulation. Also said very keen to reform RMA. Bottom line is would support some sort of RRA.

Douglas supports a Minister of Regulatory Reform and an RRA.

Dunne says ironic to use legislation to fight against legislative regulations. Thinsk local govt sector is more of a problem.

Missed what Norman said.

Cullen says will make process too bureaucratic.

Company Tax Rate

EMA Northern advocated cut company tax rate to 20% as lead to more investment and eventually more tax paid over ten years.  Cullen attacks dodgy modeling of EMA. Says we have had lower company tax rate for most of last 20 years than Australia.  English says 20% rate would be fantastic but priority for now is reducing personal tax rates. If we drop company tax rate to 20% without personl rates going down, many more people will alter their tax affairs to take advantage.

EMA’s Thompson replied that when company tax rate has been cut in the past, the level of company tax has still risen.

Infrastructure

Cullen made good point that not all infrastructure contributes to economic growth – new planes for Air Force for example. But roads do.

Dunne strong support of PPPs and infrastructure bonds.

English – planning debt 2% of GDP higher than Labour but still one of lowest in developed world. Govt is running cash deficits also. National’s infrastructure plan is a prudent investment. Also thinks Govt manages assets badly, and there is room for improvement. PPPs not just about money, but about getting private sector skills around risk and management. Bill much better on this stuff. Lots of people commented at the tea break that they thought not enough detail on the earlier stuff, but very strong on infrastructure.

Business NZ Conference Part I

I will be at the Business NZ Conference for most of the day. Both Clark and Key are speaking, as well as various Finance Spokespersons. Winston had accepted, but pulled out last night due to other issues needing his attention 🙂

First up is Helen Clark. Some key points:

  • Affirmed that Business NZ is apolitical and that she has enjoyed a constructive relationship with it.
  • Said NZ has had the longest run of consecutive economic growth since WWII. Unemployment law, crown finances exceptionally good shape.
  • Expects RBNZ to keep lowering cash rate, and dollar has lowered a bit. Some evidence food prices may ease.
  • Near full employment has masked some unpleasant truths.
  • Half of existing workforce not have skills to function adequately in future. Our school system keeps failing too many.
  • School Plus leads to an education age of 18. More details to come in election campaign
  • We do not have a future as a high volume low cost exporter. Can not compete on volume or costs with emerging economies
  • Fast Forward is about changing our agricultural sector, so they are in a niche
  • Importance of sustainability. Consumers increasingly making ethical decisions about what to buy.
  • Have to be part of the solution, not part of the problem, hence ETS.

No questions, which is a pity. Next we have the Finance Spokepersons.

A very solid speech. One does have to ask why it has taken so long to conclude the school system is failing!

Electoral Finance Law Forum

LexisNexus hosted a forum yesterday on Electoral Finance Law. They were kind enough to allow me to attend as media, so I could report on it. I couldn’t afford the $900 fee as I have no commercial interest in the area. There was a great line up of speakers including:

  • Associate Professor Bill Hodge
  • Electoral Commission CEO Dr Helena Catt
  • Mai Chen
  • Peter Kiely
  • Bryce Edwards
  • Nikki Pender
  • Doug Bailey
  • Catherine Marks

I only attended some of the afternoon session, and will blog on these later. What I want to cover is the session in the morning with Electoral Commission CEO Helena Catt. I was not physically present for it, but was given a copy of the written notes Dr Catt used. Some extracts are below:

  • A lack of broad political consensus through the passage of the bill has resulted in difficult law delivered into a litigious environment.
  • “It is clear that having uncertainty remaining within the regulated period has had a chilling effect on the extent and type of participation in political and campaign activity”.
  • The meanings of significant sections of the legislation are obscure.
  • The commission is not confident that it will be able to reach informed positions on the interpretation of some provisions within the election period.

I stress again that these are the views not of a partisan political player, but by the Chief Executive of the Electoral Commission.

Need more be said?

And another!

More billboards

People seemed to like the billboard I put up yesterday. Another reader has done a similiar one:

Very nice. Note that the graphic is an election ad if you use it anywhere but on a non-commercial blog!

There have also been some amusing parodies of the National billboards. The Standard has some:

I quite like the “Choose a righter future”.

08wire also has a few – some funny, some less so. My favourites:

Heh. I also like the changed tagline. Humour is much more effective when it is funny, and not nasty. Let the billboard wars continue!

Whale Oil also has some new billboards but site seems to be down at the moment. I’ll try grabbing them later.

Do the dead talk to you?

From the Dom Post:

Many people were buried outside official cemeteries, and some Maori were attuned to them, Mr Tomoana said. Matakite could “see the dead”.

“They rise out of the ground and tell them they’re there. They can see them just hanging there. It happens very often.”

Wow. They must be just like that nice John Edward. He can talk to the dead also. Maybe they could get their own TV show also?

More details likely from Glenn

The NZ Herald reports that more details tomorrow are likely from Owen Glenn. Good.

Apart from the motivation issue (Glenn has no motivation to lie, while Peters/Henry have plenty) of who is telling the truth, there is also the timing issue. Glenn has not just suddenly stated that Peters solicited the money. He told the PM this back in February. Peters denied it, and denied a donation, and the donation was later established to be correct.

The fact of the donation has been established. Owen Glenn has stated Peters solicted it, and thanked him for it. And it is almost beyond belief that you would donate $100,000 to help someone and not tell them about it. Especially if you are Owen Glenn!

Now Peters and Henry have their story that Winston knew nothing (despite even Helen telling him about it) and that Henry heard from someone else to contact Glenn. Well Henry now has to substantiate his version of events. Was that “other person” Roger McClay or a member of Winston’s staff? If so, guess who told them about it! Does he have a copy of phone records or e-mails to show he contacted Glenn and solicited the money himself? Or will the e-mail just show he sent through bank account details?

Non-disclosure an “administrative error”

To say NZ First’s latest explanation fails the Tui test, is putting it mildy. Before we totally dismiss it out of hand, let us look at what they say:

The New Zealand First Party has admited they made a mistake by not declaring a donation they recieved from Sir Robert Jones.

The party is putting the non declaration down to an administrative error which happened at a time when they say there was an extensive changeover in administrative staff, who were new to their responsibilities.

They say the $25,000 donation was correctly banked into the New Zealand First account, along with other donations which were unfortunately overlooked when it came to declaring anything over $10,000.

The latest revelation comes after the Serious Fraud Office obtained Spencer Trust records.

The letter from auditor Nick Kosoof says New Zealand First made an administrative error by not declaring the money.

It says the amount was banked into the party’s bank account in September 2005, and unfortunately went overlooked by error, along with other donations.

This fails the credibility test on so many levels, it is not funny.

  1. The TV3 item on the Spencer Trust showed a payment of $50,000 not $25,000 paid to NZ First.
  2. NZ First has never ever declared a single donation from the Spencer Trust, so are we to believe that in three years of existence it has only received and passed onto NZ First a singular donation from Bob Jones?
  3. NZ First claim to have only had a couple of donations over $10,000 in the last decade, so how one could overlook your largest ever donation since 1996 is beyond belief.
  4. Since the Jones donation was exposed a couple of months ago there has been speculation that the NZ First 2005 return may be inaccurate. Why did no one in NZ First check until today?
  5. Why is the auditor, not the accountant, explaining the error? Are they the same person as suggested in the NZPA report?

There is a constant pattern here with NZ First – deny the donation until it is no longer credible to deny it, and then suddenly discover it somewhere. They do not deserve any benefit of the doubt. Thank God the SFO is investigating.

Even though they can not be prosecuted under the Electoral Act for the breach, it doesn’t mean that the SFO shouldn’t disclose how many other donations were illegally not declared to the Electoral Commission.

This also poses a challenge for Helen Clark. She has said she will act if there is evidence of illegal behaviour. We now have an admission from NZ First that it broke the Electoral Act 2003 in April 2006 (and maybe again since then). And filing a false donations return is not a minor or technical breach – it is incredibly serious.

Remember this message

It’s all just a mistake

The Dom Post reports:

Mr Brown described the failure to declare the donation as a genuine mistake.

“I can’t explain it. I think it was a genuine mistake,” Mr Brown told reporters as he entered Parliament this afternoon.

Of course it was. All a genuine mistake. We thought the $50,000 was actually a withdrawal, not a deposit.

Ngai Tahu claims $100 million for ETS

NBR reports that Ngai Tahu is seeking compensation for a loss in value of forests it received as part of its historic Treaty claim.

This is due to the Emissions Trading Scheme legislation about to be passed into law.

How much value?

The Hive heard Mark Solomon say on Morning Report:

PRESENTER: Right, so the ETS has essentially robbed you of value from that settlement.
SOLOMON: Over $100 million.
PRESENTER: From that full and final settlement.
SOLOMON: Yes.

The Hive also explains how much households will get stung by the ETS:

1) The decision to block hot air AAUs has roughly doubled the price of carbon in the scheme from $20-$25 to $40-$50 (Radio NZ Morning Report http://www.radionz.co.nz/audio/national/mnr/2008/09/02/emmisions_trading_scheme_bill_debate ) .

2) The Government’s own numbers (from the explanatory note to the Bill) show the impacts on households (when fully implemented – now 2011) to be:

$100-$200 p.a. at C-Price of $15 / tCO2e
$170-$350 p.a. at C-Price of $25 / tCO2e
$330-$660 p.a. at C-Price of $50 / tCO2e

3) So at the Minister’s spokesperson’s C-price basis of $25 / tCO2e, the “good news of an electricity $120 rebate in 2010” is little comfort for the real cost in the years that follow!

Peter Dunne is also very unimpressed with the “compensation” of $2.50 a week.

It is also worth noting that the Government has just introduced 77 pages of amendments to the ETS legislation!!

Espiner also on the mark

Colin Espiner also has some good insights:

I am going to criticise the Prime Minister for something else, however. Her decision yesterday to launch into the Serious Fraud Office and claim the agency tipped off the National Party about its pending inquiry into donations to the New Zealand First Party was extraordinary. I don’t think a prime minister in this country has made such an accusation against a law enforcement agency before. …

It’s difficult to see Clark’s outburst as anything other than a deliberate attempt to undermine the credibility of the agency investigating one of her ministers, whom she clearly wishes to be cleared of wrongdoing as soon as possible. She has gone out on a limb on this one. The attack looks desperate, unwarranted, and unfair.

As Colin says, one can’t even recall Muldoon at his worst attacking law enforcement like Clark has.

Asked whether any of his MPs had met Lord Ashcroft, Key said: “I think so, yes.”

Here’s what Key should have said to Duncan Garner’s first question: “Sure I met Lord Ashcroft. Why wouldn’t I? He’s close to a friend of mine, David Cameron, and I always take the opportunity to meet my counterparts from like-minded parties overseas, as does the Prime Minister.”

It’s this automatic first instinct to avoid an issue that has got National into trouble before. Why wasn’t Key’s meeting with Lord Ashcroft in his diary released to the media? Why not offer journalists the opportunity to talk to the pair? I’m sure he’s an interesting fellow. If the meeting had been released, I could almost guarantee the media would have ignored it.

I agree strongly here. I guess it is easier with hindsight, but the meeting should have been in the diary. It would have prevented any suspicion, by front footing it. Clin provided the perfect response to any questions.

Finally a word on the billboards. So far: Lame. National is missing John Ansell, the man behind the party’s wickedly clever 2005 billboards terribly. Apparently National isn’t Right-wing enough for Ansell these days, and he’s gone off to support ACT – so look out for some clever billboards from them.

Colin must have missed the news that John parted ways with ACT.

There does seem to be a consensus that the first National billboard isn’t particularly good. The most common complaints is it has too many design elements, and is not clearly a National billboard.

Sense from Ralston

Bill Ralston fires at multiple targets, and hard to disagree with him too much:

Ok, you can argue, like Obama, Key is not part of the political establishment but anyone more politically experienced would know you get your staff to run quietly around the gallery comparing you to Obama and then, hopefully, some hack short of a line or two for their column will make the comparison for you.

By doing it yourself you merely look vain and immediately open yourself to ridicule and sneering from Clark and Cullen and, believe me, no-one can curl their upper lip and mock like those two. Which they duly did, in a schoolyard “nah, nah, nan, nah, nah” fashion.

Indeed they did, and Key took the ribbing in good humour in the House today.

There was a big backfire with Clark’s attempted counter-attack on Key’s refusal to work with Winston Peters, Clark first saying he must have been tipped-off about the Serious Fraud Office Inquiry by the SFO then, when the SFO strongly denied it, she said it must be the Police or the Crown Law Office who told him.

So much for her sad attempt to undercut John Key’s long awaited sudden growth of a political spine. He didn’t need a tip-off. I suspect he simply came to the conclusion most of us have already – Winston Peters is completely untrustworthy and a liability to any cabinet he serves in. Three Prime Ministers now have come to that same conclusion (even if Helen had that conclusion forced upon her).

Exactly. The Owen Glenn affair was proof enough.

The Prime Minister just looks desperate, she is guessing (wildly and I believe wrongly), she has just slandered her own public service and she has implied that she is facing some kind of internal revolt by her own top public servants. For someone who has always appeared so in control, so well grounded in maintaining constitutional proprieties, sternly retaining discipline over those who serve her government, Helen Clark has now given us the impression that she is weak, beset by traitors and reactionary forces plotting to bring her down.

Slandered her own public service. Indeed.

By the way, is it only me or are you too immensely amused by Labour aligned commentators and politicians trying to play their violins for Winston Peters?

I know several blogs have been sniggering at poor old Chris Trotter’s convulsions as he tries to extract some sympathy for the NZ First Leader, accusing the media of “pack raping” Winston. Aside from the ghastly imagery involved in that metaphor, dear old Chris seems to have forgotten Winston spent the last 25 years building his career on getting the media to “pack rape” other individuals and institutions he had targeted with the odd leaked document and claims of impropriety.

Those who live by the allegation, die by the allegation.

Touche.

NZ First’s 2005 donations return

TV3 last night interviewed one of the Trustees of the Spencer Trust. They report:

3 News has been given an extract of the Spencer Trust’s financial records which show a $25,000 donation made by Sir Robert Jones did go to New Zealand first. …

Grant Currie is one of three trustees of the Spencer Trust.

“The only purpose of the trust was to receive donations from supporters of NZ Trust and to pass them to New Zealand First,” explains Currie.

The Trust was formed in August 2005 – its intention was to channel money from donors to New Zealand First.

The statement shows that money along with another anonymous $25,000 donation was paid to New Zealand First less than a month later, on the 7th of September.

“If the allegation is that Mr Jones’ donation didn’t go where he intended it to then it completely refutes that allegation,” says Currie.

Mr Currie is right that that particular allegation does appear to be refuted, if bank records back up their books.

However the problem for NZ First is that these documents prove $50,000 was donated to NZ First on 7 September 2005 from the Spencer Trust. And in all probability, much more than that on other occassions.

And according to the Electoral Commission, NZ First made a nil donation return in 2005.

One the face of it, this is impossible to reconcile, and prima facie the NZ First donations return was false – a very serious matter. The law in force at the time was the Electoral Act 1993. S214G(4) says:

Every secretary of a political party registered under Part 4 who forwards to the Electoral Commission under subsection (1)(a) a return that is false in any material particular—

(a) is, if the secretary forwards the return knowing that the return is false in any material particular, guilty of a corrupt practice and is liable on conviction on indictment to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 1 year or to a fine not exceeding $20,000, or to both; and

(b) is, in any other case, guilty of an illegal practice and is liable on conviction on indictment to a fine not exceeding $20,000, unless the secretary proves—

(i) that he or she had no intention to mis-state or conceal the facts; and

(ii) that he or she took all reasonable steps in the circumstances to ensure that the information in the return was accurate.

So the NZ First Party Secretary may have commited a corrupt practice or an illegal practice. They may argue of course that the money from the Spencer Trust went into a special account controlled by, umm, say the Leader, and they knew nothing about it. This could explain why the NZF Party President says he has never heard of the Spencer Trust – something unlikely if it went into their main bank account.

Now even though the law appears prima facie to have been broken, s226 means they can not be prosecuted for it:

A prosecution against any person for a corrupt practice or an illegal practice shall be commenced within 6 months after the offence was committed

But this is not an issue just of will someone go to jail. Winston Peters needs to explain to the “court of public opinion”. The media needs to demand from NZ First how they can reconcile their nil 2005 donation return with the $50,000 donation from the Spencer Trust.

Now remember Helen Clark and Winston Peters campaigned on financial transparency. Regardless of the SFO findings, does the Prime Minister have no problems with a political party that appears to have filed a false donations return, or multiple false donation returns? How does she reconcile this with her stance on wanting greater electoral funding transparency?

It will be very interesting if the SFO investigation reveals exactly what bank account the $50,000 was paid into. Is it one known to and controlled by the party? Unless it is, then the money may still be found not to have gone to the intended recepient. If it did go into an account controlled by the party, then the donations return is false – you can not have it both ways.

NZ Herald on SFO

The Herald says the SFO should remain:

There are good reasons to retain the Serious Fraud Office. One of the most obvious was mentioned last week by the Finance Minister, Michael Cullen, when he noted New Zealand was facing the most complex and challenging economic forces for 20 years. The fall-out from this will demand a dedicated fraud-detection agency.

Several commentators have said that in the midst of finance company collapses in entirely the wrong time to abolish them.

To suggest, however, as Progressives leader Jim Anderton has, that this inquiry was initiated by the SFO to serve its own purposes is ludicrous. Even greater depths of shamefulness were plumbed by the Prime Minister yesterday when she claimed it was “almost certain” the SFO tipped off National about its intention to investigate NZ First. The two extraordinary accusations suggest nothing less than a wilful and self-serving Government campaign to undermine the credibility of one of its own law-enforcement agencies.

And what do you call a Government which campaigns against its own law enforcement agencies?

Harsh times inevitably bring to light practices that tend to remain concealed when things are going well. Already, the SFO is investigating the Blue Chip property companies that went into liquidation this year owing $80 million to 2000 investors, and Bridgecorp, a finance company that owes about $500 million to 18,000 depositors. History suggests other probes will follow. This mocks the Government’s claim that substantial white-collar crime is no longer part of the landscape, and that it is safe to dispense with the agency.

But what about the sucessor?

There is little chance that alleged rorts by finance-company executives would be tackled adequately by the police’s Organised and Financial Crime Agency, which, according to the Government plans, would absorb the SFO. The Police Minister, Annette King, has admitted the agency’s focus would “very much” be gangs, as part of a strategy of getting tough on organised crime. The type of investigation typically undertaken by the SFO would not be a priority, and would also be seen as far more onerous than tackling gang activity. Fraud is the the most difficult of crimes to detect and prove its intent beyond reasonable doubt.

Indeed.

The flag

All during the Olympics Games I kept getting reminded of how much I want to change the NZ Flag. It was near impossible to tell it apart from the Australian flag, as it went up a flagpole.

At least we are not the only ones who get confused. Sideswipe reports:

During a ceremony at Ku-ring-gai Council recently, his friends – an English family of five – had just received their Australian citizenship documentation and posed with the mayor for a photograph. “A helpful councillor came forward with a flag suggesting it would make a nice prop for the photograph,” he writes. The family agreed, but asked whether he had an Australian flag. “Oh my God,” said the councillor, “We’ve been using a New Zealand flag all night.”

One of us needs to change flags, as they are so similar. I bags us!