The phony war

The media have reported Helen Clark as saying it is a phony war until National reveals more of its hand. A reader e-mails the following thoughts:

It’s a phony war until Clark announces when the election will be
People should seriously start calling her on this. She expects National to announce policy for an election that she won’t announce? They’re holding off for tactical purposes and so is she, and it strikes me as a little hypocritical that she expects them to relinquish their tactical advantage when she won’t relinquish hers.
Hard to disagree with that logic.

Daily Show on Obama’s flip-flop

The Immigration Bill and torture

I’m actually supportive of most aspects of the Government’s Immigration Bill. The current system is explited by lawyers so that simple cases takes the best part of a decade to resolve.

However there are some worrying aspects, ably covered by Idiot/Savant at No Right Turn and Gordon Campbell at Scoop.

In a welcome move, the Immigration Bill does enshrine various UN conventions – including the Convention Against Torture – in our domestic law. However, in my earlier post, I outlined how the Immigration Bill violates key provisions of that same UN Convention Against Torture – by, for instance requiring ( see clause 122b ) an asylum seeker to prove they would face a worse risk of torture if returned home, than would be usual in their country.

The test should not (and is not under the UN convention) a worse risk of torture than other citizens, but whether there is any significant risk at all.

Ironically it means the more despotic a regime is, the more easily one could deport people back there as if they torture and maim everyone with impunity then you are at no worse risk.

I am sure that this clause will be changed, but you do have to worry about how it got in there in the first place.

The costly bureaucracy

The Herald and the Dom Post report on a paper by ANZ National Bank chief economist Cameron Bagrie. The paper looks at how much spending actually goes into back-office costs rather than front-line services.

In a paper released yesterday Bagrie plots the changing – and by implication deteriorating – mix of Government spending over the past 10 years.

One measure distinguishes departments’ front-line spending on things such as paying nurses, teachers and policemen from back-office functions such as administering, approving and monitoring things.

“Growth in total departmental outputs has averaged close to 7 per cent a year since 1997, while front-line spending has averaged 5 per cent a year,” Bagrie said.

“If the ratio of back-office to front-line spending had remained constant there would have been close to $1 billion free for other initiatives in 2007.”

Certain other blogs will claim that $1 billion is only $250 per person which is only $5 a week which is only $0.70c a a day and laugh at this being any evidence of anything.

Me, I think a billion here and a billion there does matter.

For example, spending on welfare benefits had increased by an average of 3 per cent a year, but back-office departmental spending by 7.5 per cent.

It puzzles me that fewer people on benefits means it costs more not less to administer them.

There is some good news:

But another indicator, which distinguishes “hand-out” spending such as welfare payments from “hand-up” spending like education and employment initiatives, showed relatively more money going to the latter.

“That’s encouraging.” he said. “However it is not so rosy if we exclude the unemployment benefit, which has fallen dramatically as a consequence of an extended period of economic expansion.”

Hands-up is preferable indeed.

Bagrie stressed that the issue he was raising related to the mix of Government spending, not the level.

He is agonistic about what an optimal level of Government spending relative to the size of the economy would be. The international evidence was inconclusive on that, he said.

Here I disagree. I am very unagnostic, and think there is considerable evidence linking higher econoomic growth to smaller Government. Instead of arguing about one or two countries over one or two years, I prefer the studies of all OECD countries over 30 – 40 years and the correlation is strong.

On the mix of Government spending, the Treasury had been “strangely silent” for years, he said. “They have a responsibility not just to their minister but to the wider taxpayer.”

Alas the Treasury of old is no longer.

Finally Bagrie asks:

“Do we really need 41 Government departments and 65 Crown entities, not to mention the 21 district health boards and nine Crown research institutes, for a population of four million?”

This is an area I am especially interested in. I think the trend (started by National actually) into smaller agencies has produced far too many, and that we should be looking at amalgamating like agencies together.

Derek Fox

The NZ Herald reports on Maori Party candidate Derek Fox and what appears to be a violent incident in his past:

Maori Party candidate Derek Fox has alluded to a violent incident against a woman in his past, but says he is a reformed man.

The reference was made in a statement to the Truth newspaper which has a story this week suggesting violence in his past.

“I have done some things in the past that I now regret,” said Mr Fox.

“I surrendered myself to the authorities, I sought help to address those issues, and I believe I am a very different person now.

“I have made my peace. I have fronted up, and I take responsibility for my unacceptable behaviour.

“All this happened a long time ago and I have spent my life since then trying to do good and to contribute positively to our society.”

The Herald understands he is alluding to a historic case that may be subject to court orders.

Sounds pretty messy. But very interesting to note this comment:

It is understood the Labour Party has been planning to make allegations against Mr Fox in the House under parliamentary privilege.

Now Labour appointed Derek Fox to be Chair of Maori TV. Did they know of this alleged historical violence when they appointed him and only when he then stands against Parekura chose to release it?

Go Paula Go

There are few people who really inspire me, but my friend Paula Tesoriero who was on TV3 last night is one of them:

Wellington cyclist Paula Tesoriero is gunning for gold at this year’s Paralympics, and the world record holder in the 500 metre time trial is expecting nothing less than gold in Beijing.

Paula Tesoriero has always been determined to disable her disability.  A rare condition meant three of her limbs were damaged before she was born and even though she has only been cycling two years, she is already world class.

Even before she took up cycling, Paula was amazing for never letting her disability being a handicap. And the effort she puts into training for the cycling champs is beyond belief.

I’m not going to be watching too many races in the main Olympics. But myself and many others will be following the Paralympics cycling minute by minute!

DNS security flaw

Australia and NZ ETS

Brian Fallow makes some very sensible points on the move by both countries towards an ETS:

Australian professor Ross Garnaut has some good advice for our Government as well as his own.

“The review suggests that prior to the indelible conclusion of [emissions trading] scheme design in either country, the Australian and New Zealand Governments meet at ministerial level to discuss linking and to identify any impediments to linking that may warrant adjustment to one or both scheme designs.”

This is sensible, and it is in fact quite vital that the NZ and Australian schemes are as compatible as possible as Australia is our largest trading partner. This is one reason I think we should be slightly less hasty with pushing our ETS into law. Having trans-Tasman harmony is more important than artifical dates such as the election.

Its draft report was released last Friday and a government green paper is due soon. Climate Change Minister Penny Wong is standing by a timetable that has legislation introduced by the end of this year and an emissions trading scheme up and running in 2010.

Which is compatible with NZ – esp that Clark has delayed all sectors but forestry until 2011.

If Australia’s scheme is along the lines recommended by the Garnaut review there will be a family resemblance with the New Zealand scheme, but there are notable differences.

They need not constitute a barrier to linkage between the schemes – a common carbon market, if you will. The environmental integrity of both schemes should be the determining factor there.

But it would be prudent to be sure the differences do not pre-empt linking before anything is set in concrete.

Absolutely.

MPs and Holidays

Generally an MP’s family status is pretty irrelevant to their public duties, and shouldn’t be part of public debate.

But you know if Helen Clark is going to do cheap whacks at John Key and Bill English with lines such as:

They do seem to work pretty short weeks and years in my experience. I’ve found this job is pretty all-consuming

Then it is 100% legitimate for people to consider issues of family status. Because it is massively different when you have kids. They’re not the same as partners, parents or nephews.

Suggesting Key or English are lazy or uncommitted is a cheap jibe from Clark, and she should know better than to criticise when it is inevitable that people would critique her comments in the context of the fact that for her politics is all-consuming – but others do not have that luxury. That does not make them uncommitted – just trying to balance competing demands.

Now to be fair to Clark, she was responding to a question from a journalist who asked if the holidays were a sign of over-confidence. But she’s been in politics for 30 years and should be better trained to resist the urge to take a swipe.

And anyone complaining about the response from Key or English that they are spending time with their kids. Well what the hell do you expect their response to be? I mean it is the truth. They are. They’re not in Vegas playing Blackjack or backpacking through Europe.

Most MPs are hard working. This not a 40 hour a week job. I doubt any but a very few obscure List MPs do less than 60 hour weeks. Senior politicians such as Key and English would routinely be working 15 hour days for six days a week which is 90+ hours a week. That is not a “pretty short week”.

Ad for Plasma TV

Linda Clark on anti-democratic Electoral Finance Act

Most readers will remember Linda Clark from her days in the media – TVNZ’s political editor and then nine to noon host on Radio NZ. Linda is now a lawyer consultant with Chapman Tripp and has written an article with colleague Andy Nicholls for the Listener on the Electoral Finance Act:

An Act rushed through late last year is threatening our right to really know who we will be voting for – even our politicians are playing a waiting game, and it needs to be fixed now.

Stick-on tattoos, old T-shirts and the Finance Minister referring to his own Government in Budget media releases all have something in common: all three could be in breach of the Electoral Finance Act.

That good old law of common sense.

The EFA, as insiders call it, is the law pushed through, amid bitter debate, just before Parliament rose last Christmas. It was supposedly designed to prevent the Exclusive Brethren taking another covert run at the Labour Party. But in the tradition of cracking a nut with a sledgehammer, it went much further than that – and the Government was warned. The EFA’s dampening effect on the current election campaign is so serious, it is anti-democratic.

Strong but accurate language. It was a massive over-reaction and motivated by utu rather than workable law.

Though National has said, if elected, it will repeal the EFA, it needs to be fixed now if this campaign is to be a fair contest. Voters should be able to see for themselves what and who is up for election and not just in a flurry at the last minute.

At the moment parties are so nervous about breaching spending caps set down in the Act, they are holding back their candidates from campaigning and robbing voters of the opportunity to be informed.

The cynical response to all this is to sigh with relief. After all it means mailboxes free from political leaflets and city intersections not overcrowded by billboards of smiling wannabe MPs. But in truth, the advertising will come, just not until much later in the campaign. Election advertising serves an important purpose. It commits political parties to key promises, for a start. And in the contests for electorates, which these days are given scant media coverage, it helps voters identify one candidate over another.

In the electorate contests especially, the EFA is particularly bad making it near impossible for a non incumbent candidate to get known.

The Maori Party recently produced stick-on tattoos of its distinctive red and black logo. The plan was to give them away to kids at festivals and party fundraisers. The tattoos are small, temporary and hardly an invocation to vote. They simply say “Maori”.

But acting on advice from the Electoral Commission, the Maori Party was forced to somehow get the name and address of the party official who authorised production and publication onto the tattoos, since they may yet be deemed to be advertising – and all advertising must carry authorisation.

Now this is an interesting case. What if someone got a permanent tattoo done without an authorisation statement. They would be charged everytime they went out in public if it was visible!

The Commission, which can with some justification sit back and say, “We told you so” (because it did speak out publicly against the law before it was passed), has opted not to provide any sign-off of expenditure before the election. But it will give parties basic guidelines which, according to party strategists, are often little more than a conservative interpretation of the Act and a nudge to be careful.

The trouble is none of this offers any of the parties any certainty that what they are doing is not in breach of the EFA. It appears the electoral commissioners have struggled to form a unanimous view on some issues referred to them, but their lawyers, Crown Law, have already been proved wrong in the High Court on one basic aspect of the Act.

In normal circumstances, Crown Law should be able to be relied upon to provide firm guidance, but in this case its copybook is blotted by its initial failure to declare that the Electoral Finance Bill breached the Bill of Rights Act – that is also being challenged in the courts. None of this makes for good law.

Trusting Crown Law advice on any aspect of the ACT would be a silly thing to do, in my opinion.

Already party activists are compiling dossiers of every communication published by rivals since New Year’s Day, with plans to file for electoral petitions in selected electorates after polling day. If opinion polls prove right and the National Party maintains its dominance of the party vote, these court cases probably won’t hold up the formation of a government, but they could if the numbers turn out to be more finely balanced.

Such an outcome serves nobody. Elections should never be decided by the courts and electioneering should not be such a guessing game.

But court battles are inevitable due to the Act.

The Electoral Commission, and only the Commission, should be given authority to make binding rulings on any issues brought before it.

The process should be fast and public, and the rulings, once made, should apply equally to all parties. Rulings should be able to be reviewed before the election, but overturned only if a breach of process is proven.

The benefits should be obvious. As each party seeks approval for a certain type of spending, a clear set of guidelines will be built up. Everyone will know what is legal spending, so there should be no need for a succession of legal cases testing the law, and the possibility of post-election legal challenges should be greatly reduced.

Not a bad idea at all.

If the 63 MPs who voted for the EFA really wanted to promote participation in our democracy (one of the stated purposes of the Act), they should see that this election campaign is being unduly restricted by the Act and take the necessary steps now to make this law more workable.

I have heard on the grapevine that the Greens now regret voting for the law. The problem is Labour will never admit they were wrong. And Winston just ignores it!

Cameron attacks moral neutrality

The Telegraph reports on a superb speech by David Cameron attacking moral neutrality:

“We talk about people being ‘at risk of obesity’ instead of talking about people who eat too much and take too little exercise. We talk about people being at risk of poverty, or social exclusion: it’s as if these things – obesity, alcohol abuse, drug addiction – are purely external events like a plague or bad weather.

And the same in NZ.

“Of course, circumstances – where you are born, your neighbourhood, your school, and the choices your parents make – have a huge impact. But social problems are often the consequence of the choices that people make.”

Choices do matter, and that is why you need incentives to encourage the right choices.

Blog Bits

Not PC looks at some quotes from Green Party candidates such as how the solution to Maori smoking is to honour the Treaty of Waitangi.

JafaPete makes an apology to Lynton Crosby.

Tumeke opens a book on the 2008 election date. I was one of a dozen ro so who correctly picked the date last time. My pick at this stage is 8 November.

Whale Oil compares some quotes:

Isn’t it funny how people keep repeating things because they just need to convince themselves that despite all evidence to the contrary they are actually right?

John Howard was one of them.

“Mr Howard has predicted the poll margin will narrow once the election is called”

and Helen Clark is another.

“I believe that in the home straight before the election itself the polls will begin to narrow.”

Yates has been appointed to four Boards in three months!

My God. Tim Donoghue in the Dom Post reveals that former Hamilton List MP Di Yates has been appointed to four Boards in the three months since she left Parliament to make way for Su’a William Sio.

That is just obscene. Sure ex MPs can contribute a lot to some organisations, but not even senior Cabinet Ministers get four appointments in a row, let alone highly obscure backbenchers.

The Labour Party insider told The Dominion Post: “It’s the price the Government has paid to allow Mr Sio to enter Parliament.”

Except we are paying the price, not the Government. And the fees for three of the Boards come to $69,000 so the total revenue from the four appointments is probably over $80,000 a year.

How many more appointments like this will happen before the election?

A dedicated polling blog

As I mentioned a few weeks ago, I have established a dedicated blog on polls and polling – curiablog.

Curiablog will be a specialist blog on polls and polling, with a mainly (but not exclusively) New Zealand focus.

I hope it will provide the following information:

  1. A record of all public polls published within New Zealand, and links to the original data or at least media reports based on that data. This is not just party political polls, but also issue polls.
  2. A size and time weighted average of the public political party polls
  3. Over time, a guide to useful information on polls and polling including FAQs on issues such as exit polls, why polls disagree etc etc. I will generally link the best overseas content where appropriate.
  4. Links to significant overseas polls.
  5. Links to and commentary on blog posts on polling from some of the international specialist blog sites.

It is not intended to be a partisan debating forum. Comments are welcome of course, but it intended to be somewhat more sedate than Kiwiblog.

One feature of the blog, which people may find useful, is a sidebar graphic showing the latest size and time weighted average of the public polls.

There is also an excel spreadsheet on the blog which people can download and they can see the individual polls, the weightings, the electorate seat assumptions, and the projected/likely Electorate and List MPs in the future Parliament.

Note that this is all based on the publicly available and published polls. It should not be regarded as a prediction by me on individual seats or candidates. Generally no seat is assumed to change hands unless a poll has been published in the media showing a change.

Other bloggers are welcome to display the graphic on their own sites. It will be updated daily and will automatically update on your site when it is updated here, except at month end. To add it to your own sidebar just copy the text below:

<a href=”http://curiablog.wordpress.com/2008-public-poll-average-calculations/”><img class=”alignnone size-full wp-image-15″ src=”http://curiablog.wordpress.com/files/2008/07/curiappa.jpg” alt=”” width=”161″ height=”355″ /></a>

WordPress doesn’t allow me to place updated graphics in the same location for the whole year, as it files by month. This means at the end of the month the graphic location will change (from “…/2008/07/…” to “…/2008/08/…” etc. So once a month just need to change your text, or copy the new location from here.

I hope people find it useful, It has only modest content for now, but overtime I hope it will be a useful permanent repository of public polling information in New Zealand.

The Press on Broadcasting

The Press looks at National’s broadcasting policy:

Before the charter was introduced, it was clear that trying to serve two roles the commercial and the public service would be difficult, and so it has proved. TVNZ’s former chief executive, Ian Fraser, said as much when he acrimoniously left the corporation’s job two years ago. Although he was a strong advocate of public-service broadcasting and had taken the job with the intention of making the charter work, it was, he declared bluntly soon after his departure, impossible to “deliver to both God and Caesar”.

Precisely. The charter has been a shambles.

He regretted that he had not made that clear to the Government, and he advocated selling off TV2 and the merger of the remaining Television One with Radio New Zealand and Maori Television to create a fully State-funded, non-commercial broadcaster guided solely by a public-service ethic.

That is something I’d love to see costed and investigated.

Whatever the merits of that idea, the National Party policy on broadcasting just announced is a good deal less radical. National uncontroversially pledges itself to maintain ownership of TVNZ and to continue funding for Maori Television, Radio New Zealand and a number of other outlets. National has, however, proposed the abolition of TVNZ’s charter and making the $15 million in funding that goes with it contestable among all free-to-air channels and producers.

It will not please those who believe that the system needs a more thorough reform, but it is a modest proposal that deserves consideration. It would free TVNZ from the burden of trying, and inevitably failing, to please everybody, and it would take away an undesirable monopoly on the production of public-service programmes.

I called the policy “tepid” on National Radio, but despite being a modest policy it is an improvement on the status quo.

The proliferation of outlets and choice means that who broadcasts a programme and when is becoming far less significant than it once was. The downloading of programmes, for instance, is certain to become more common. This will mean that if programmes are broadcast by some outfit other than TVNZ, the body commissioning them, New Zealand on Air, may have a much greater role in promoting them, wherever they may be found. The focus, though, should be on getting good-quality material made.

Over time the identity of the broadcaster will be less and less important. Content providers will have a direct relationship with the viewing public.

Veitch broke her back?

The Dom Post is stating the the alleged assault by Tony Veitch on former partner Kristin Dunne-Powell was so bad,it broke her back.

*If* this is true, I can’t see how he could work in broadcasting alone. I couldn’t bring myself to watch a programme with him.

However, he has not confirmed whether this is true or not, and no charges have been laid – so one can’t totally pre-judge.

What I can not work out, if the Dom Post story is accurate, is why the hell Dunne-Powell didn’t call the cops. $100,000 isn’t enough I’d say.

SFO Director slams Government on serious fraud

The SFO’s record in recent years has not been up to its stellar early years. But I have always been nervous about simply abolishing it, especially as the sucessor agency will not have the same powers as the SFO. NZPA quotes the outgoing SFO Director:

Former Serious Fraud Office director David Bradshaw warned scrapping his agency would terminate high-end white-collar criminal investigations and prosecutions in New Zealand.

And a proposal to ditch special SFO powers would “sound the death knell for fraud investigations in New Zealand”, Mr Bradshaw wrote to Attorney-General Michael Cullen on August 29 last year.

Doesn’t sound good.

On August 29, Mr Bradshaw wrote to Dr Cullen: “The investigation and prosecution of serious and complex white-collar crime is almost certain to become nonexistent if the Serious Fraud Office is subsumed within the Organised Crime Agency.”

Mr Bradshaw said most serious and complex fraud was not organised crime and that a paper prepared by the Ministry of Justice and police for ministers was misleading.

I just hope the Police prove better at serious fraud than they did with electoral fraud.

The Cheap Petrol Project

A worthy idea at The Cheap Petrol Project.

Basically they are tryng to get as many people as possible signed up to a petrol discount card, and then negotiate an exclusive discount with the chain offering the best deal.

So farthey have 5,000 people signed up.

Justifying the appointment

Lianne Dalziel has appointed former Labour List MP Dianne Yates to the Food Standards Australia New Zealand Board. Yates stood for election last October to the Hamilton City Council and filed to even get elected as a City Councillor despite being an MP at the time.

So why did Lianne appoint Yates:

Dianne is ideally suited to this role on all levels. She’s from the Waikato, arguably the food bowl of New Zealand …

Yes, her qualification is she lives in Hamilton, and Hamilton is in the Waikato and Waikato grows a lot of food, so hence she is qualified to sit on the Food Standards Board of Australia and New Zealand.

You really know they are stretched for justification, when they have to rely on “She’s from the Waikato”.

And what do we pay Ms Yates for her hard work:

According to the Australian Remuneration Tribunal, Ms Yates will be paid $A30,000 ($NZ38,440) a year and reimbursed for first and business class travel as well as accommodation and other expenses.

FSANZ’s last annual report said most board members attended about five meetings last year.

Wow first class travel just to cross the Tasman. And $8,000 per meeting. Not bad.

If there is a change of Government, I would like to be considered for appointment to the FSANZ. My qualifications are I live near Boudeaux Bakery in Thorndon and they sell food. We also have a Subway down the road.

Veitch off TV and radio

Within a few hours Tony Veitch has been taken off both TVNZ and Radio Network, due to allegations of assault against his former partner.

I am not surprised the broadcasters have made this call. I suspect many of their own staff would have been uncomfortable with just pretending nothing had happened.

Now of course we still don’t know how correct the allegations are, but just ignoring them isn’t viable. What I think sticks in most people’s craws is the possibility that a serious domestic assault did happen, and that there is no contrition or consequences over what happened – just a hush money settlement.

One has to avoid a lynch mob mentality, but there is a recognition that as a prominent TV and radio personality one can’t just avoid allegations that directly affect your credibility, when it involves alleged criminal behaviour.

I should get sick more often

Just counted up and have done a staggering 28 posts in the last day and a half. I guess a natural result of being stuck at home unable to go outside, so nothing to do but blogging and reading.

Fortunately I am starting to feel better, so blogging should fall back to less frenzied levels. Also means I should be slightly more coherent this afternoon on National Radio when I briefly join The Panel for a political chat.

Also being interviewed tomorrow morning for Road Trip Nation, who are currently in NZ. Should be fun.

One good thing about Zimbabwe

There is some bright news about Zimbabwe.

Now they do have some economic problems, such as:

  • 85% unemployment
  • Hyperinflation at around 1,700,000%
  • -5.7% annual GDP growth
  • 80% earn below US$50 a month

But the good news is they have massively reduced their carbon footprint. They no longer produce all their own electricity, the economy has shrunk 40% since 2000, and that nasty carbon polluting agricultural sector has largely shut up shop.

So let us celebrate Zimbabwe’s leadership role in obtaining carbon neutrality.

iPhone prices

Vodafone has announced its pricing for the iPhones which go on sale on Friday, and its certainly not cheap.

The phone itself starst at $199, but only if you to a $6,000 contract over two years. Yeah thought not.

Their cheapest plan is not so bad – $80 a month which includes 120 minutes of calls (4 minutes a day), 600 texts (20 a day) and 250 MB of data (8Mb a day which isn’t bad). The phone will cost $549 or $699 (for 16GB phone) on top of that.

The $250 a month plan gives you 600 minutes or 20 minutes a day. No increase in texts (600) and a nice 1 GB of data.

I hope prices will drop over time. They probably have them high now because they know there will be some peopel who will pay anything for an iPhone. Personally I would hold off and wait for some lower prices as will be inevitable when they want more customers.

ODT looks at new leadership for Labour

The ODT looks at who will be the new leaders for Labour:

However, within Labour circles the speculation has started on likely replacements. …

But if Labour loses and the election result is close, party sources believe Trade Minister Phil Goff is the principal candidate for the job.

He is seen as a safe replacement who would not shift Labour markedly away from its centre-left position.

Goff is centre-left but more centre than left. He would be far more in touch with the electorate and less likely to make massive blunders such as Clark’s positioning over Section 59.

Police Minister Annette King is seen as the logical deputy leader for Mr Goff, to give the party a gender balance and an Auckland-Wellington split.

Gender balance will be important for Labour. I am not sure King is looking to spend another nine years in politics though. Also her star has dipped this year.

If the polls hold up, Labour could lose up to 18 MPs, including electorate members.

If the defeat is not too broad, Mr Goff will be challenged by Health Minister David Cunliffe and Labour Minister Trevor Mallard.

The conventional wisdom is Cunliffe will stand against Goff. I can’t see Mallard being a contender after his demotion last year.

Both would bring with them an image problem.

Mr Cunliffe was identified early in his career as a potential leader, but has earned the disdain of some colleagues for his “superior” attitude.

However if he has Helen’s backing against Goff, I would not count him out.

A decimation of Labour will see other candidates chancing their arm in the belief that it will take Labour six years, or two terms, to win office.

Energy Minister David Parker and Immigration Minister Clayton Cosgrove will mount challenges.

Neither is particularly popular with colleagues, and Mr Cosgrove will be a fiercer competitor than Mr Parker.

Parker for Leader? I’m sorry but my first reaction is has the ODT gone mad? But then I realised no they are just parochial and feel the need to include a local person in the speculation.

Mr Cosgrove has been a member of the party since he was 14, and is a protege of former prime minister Mike Moore.

Which is about as helpful in Labour as being endorsed by Dick Cheney is in the US.

Mr Parker is seen more in the mould of former prime minister Sir Wallace (Bill) Rowling, and would offer a leadership style out of step with modern politics.

Hmmn, the ODT has a point. Parker is a lot like Rowling.

Also in the mix at this level will be Building and Construction Minister Shane Jones, a Maori MP of whom was expected great things.

He is said to be “hugely bright” but pompous and obviously ambitious.

I think they have the hugely before the wrong word 🙂

My genuine best advice for Labour after the election would be Goff Leader, Cunliffe as Finance and Street as Deputy.

Hat Tip: Homepaddock (which is now a daily read)