NZIER calls stagflation

Stagflation is the nightmare of the 70s – high inflation and negative economic growth.

NZIER has just put out its quarterly survey of business opinion.

Statistics New Zealand recently reported that real Gross Domestic Product (GDP) fell by 0.3% in the March 2008 quarter. Indicators of domestic trading activity from the latest QSBO suggest economic activity declined further in the June quarter and is likely to decline again in the September quarter which will make it three quarters of negative economic growth in a row.

That takes it beyond a technical recession to a full recession. They says firms are more negative abotu their own activity and their trading activity since 1998 and 1982 respectively.

Now what about inflation:

The net balance of firms intending to increase selling prices in the next three months has increased. The balance was 45% in the March survey and 49% in the June survey. The 49% figure is the highest since March 1987. The net balance expecting an increase in costs has increased from 62% in March to 71% in June. The 71% figure is the highest since December 1986.

This is why their press release refers to stagflation.

Welch on Labour

Former Listener columnist Denis Welch blogs on Labour’s recent antics:

Like several commentators I have to say that the Labour Government is going too far in trying to demolish John Key’s personal credibility. I agree with John Armstrong of the New Zealand Herald when he concludes that the Prime Minister’s attack on Key last week may have done more damage to her credibility than his. It smacks of unsavoury politics, digging for dirt like this. …

Even leaving aside the morality of it, it just looks plain desperate. Coupled with a recent tendency to arrogance, into which both Clark and Michael Cullen have lapsed at times, such tactics demean a government with a proud record of social-democratic progress. It owes itself and its potential voters a clean hard-fought campaign based on policies, not personalities.

I think Denis is going to be very disappointed. Clark was having a go at Key again yesterday, almost calling Key a sissy or something. It’s hilarious if not so sad.

Are blogs media

An interesting issue from the provinces. Up in Hawke’s Bay, the blog BayBuzz keeps an eye on local government issues.

Now the BayBuzz editor wanted to record a meeting of the Hastings District Council which was debating a $60 million project. The standing orders say:

“When a meeting of the local authority is open to the public the following provisions shall apply:

(a) Bona fide members of the news media (including newspaper, radio and television) shall be entitled to attend any meeting or any part of a meeting for the purpose of reporting the proceedings for any news media.

(b) Any member of the public who is not a bona fide member of the news media shall obtain the consent of the meeting to the use of visual recording devices.

(c) Any recording of meetings shall be carried out in an unobtrusive manner, and shall not be distracting to members.

(d) Any recording of meetings shall be notified to the Chairperson at the commencement of the meeting.”

The Council went into closed session to debate whether the Baybuzz blog counts as media and they eventually decided it did not as there were no ground rules of fairness and they thought the video could be misued.

I think the Council is going against the tide by denying a local blog the same rights as other media.

In the United States bloggers can attend White House press conferences and get accredited to party conventions.

In NZ bloggers are often inited to conferences as media, and are even allowed in the Budget lockup.

As for ground rules of fairness, I think it is worth noting that the Press Council can possibly hear complaints about blogs. They consider complaints even about those which do not recognise the Press Council. This is not to guarantee they would rule on a blog, but it is possible they would.

Hawke’s Bay District Health Board

Tukituki MP Craig Foss has been blogging a series of documents about the HB DHB, released under the OIA. These deserve some critical scrutiny.

The latest is fascinating.

  • 14 months before the DHB was sacked, Peter Hausmann was suggesting future appointees to the Minister
  • He was proposing a way to stop the Board Chair being elected to the Board
  • He suggests an Ian Wilson be appointed Deputy Chair
  • Ian Wilson, was appointed as Chair of the Review Panel which coincided with the Board being sacked

While WIlson may have been unaware Hasumann was promoting him, it certainly shows that Hausmann was plotting against the democratically elected Board for a long period of time, and presumably having a receptive ear in the Minister who eventually sacked them.

Following the script

I have found it very amusing that Labour have been accusing John Key of following focus group supplied scripting, because they are so good at it themselves. The media have already reported on how they spent one entire month trying to label Key as “slippery”.

Their other tactic is to label every policy or move by National’s as “privatisation”. Their focus groups have shown the public don’t like this word. So whatever National does or say, will be labelled privatisation by Labour.

We saw this yesterday with Helen Clark and Trevor Mallard’s response to what is hardly an earth shattering policy by National (rather tepid in my views).

NZPA reported:

He [Mallard] was suspicious that a National government would look to commercialise or even privatise Radio New Zealand.

Now what was the actual policy:

Continue funding for Radio New Zealand, National Pacific Radio Trust, and Access Radio

So a policy of maintaining funding, is described by Trevor as a policy to privatise. It’s hilarious.

Then we have TVNZ:

Broadcasting Minister Trevor Mallard said without TVNZ having charter obligations there was little point in having it remain as state-owned broadcaster.

“The promise to retain ownership rings hollow. This policy is a Trojan horse privatisation down the track,” Mr Mallard said.

You have to give Trevor kudos for not acually trying to defend the charter as having produced anything worthwhile – he knows it has been a disaster giving TVNZ mixed priorities.

But let us look at his claim there is no point in hvaing TVNZ owned by the state without the charter. Well, apart from the 30 or so years it was happily state owned with no charter.

I am looking forward to future Labour responses to National policies. We will see stuff such as:

  • More money for MOTAT = privatising Te Papa
  • Greater subsidies for GPs = privatising primary health
  • more money for books on homes = privatising education
  • tax free charity donations = privatising welfare

Yes no matter what the policy is, Labour will call it privatisation.

Broadband Strategy Options

InternetNZ has an RFP out, calling for proposals to evaluate options for broadband infrastructure rollout in New Zealand.

The intention of the RFP is:

The RFP being released today closes on Friday 18 July 2008 at 4pm. The objective is to select an individual or organisation to research and analyse options that have been raised along with other approaches that have been utilised internationally.

There will be a two-stage process with Stage One including a discovery process and literature review leading to recommendations as to what will be achievable. Stage Two will result in the final report. InternetNZ is looking for a “strawman” model with costings, possible investment approaches and the identification of any further work required.

It will be an interesting mix of skills needed for RFP respondents. Economic modelling, investment financing, engineering to name a few.

The idea is to identify the best path forward for achieving widely available high speed broadband in New Zealand. The key principles are:

  1. Structured in such a way to ensure service providers can fairly compete
  2. Funded in such a way that at least 75% of families can afford services offered over the infrastructure
  3. Bandwidth should be unconstrained which in current environment is 100 Mbps for domestic users and 1 Gbps for commercial users

It is hoped the report, from the sucessful respondent, will greatly advance the policy debate about how best to have affordable high speed wide-spread broadband.

Tony Veitch

I have been a fan of his onscreen persona, but I have to say I’m pretty sickened by the reports that Tony Veitch assaulted his former partner so badly she was temporarily in a wheelchair.

I know there may be two sides to the story, but this is why Police should be involved – to determine the facts.

If the assault was as serious as it sounds (and any domestic violence is unacceptable), I am surprised the broadcasters are treating it is a private matter. Domestic violence is a criminal matter, not just a private affair.

Why is Labour so hypocritical on transparency?

Labour’s hypocrisy over transparency was reinforced this week with another anonymous attack site launched. It is a sad fact of life that the party which claims the Electoral Finance Act was needed to bring transparency to campaigning has a long history of establishing anonymous attack sites against its opponents.

First of all in the 2005 election there was the KeepLeftNZ site. This site launched attack after attack on Don Brash and other opponents of Labour. They kept their identities a closely guarded secret but after the election a member of the PM’s Office revealed at the NZUSA Christmas Party that the site was organized out of the PM’s Office.

Then in 2007 The Standard burst into life. They would have you believe it is a totally independent collection of activists who just happen to not like National. The reality is somewhat different.

It is understood that the Standard was conceived of by the PM’s Office, specifically by Rob Salmond, who was working there after the 2005 election. Salmond wrote a chapter “The Battle of the Blog” for the Victoria University publication on the 2005 election and is a long time Labour activist. He was known to work in the Beehive after the 2005 election, even though he did not appear on staff lists and he has confirmed he did work for the PM’s Office.

He is credited as having come up with the concept for The Standard, to counter centre right blogs. He also proposed the creation of a special role in the PMs Office for online communications – a role subsequently filled by Chris Elder. The source for this information is Elder himself who has told several people of Salmond’s role in setting up his job and creating or proposing The Standard. This does not mean the PM’s Office personally registered the site, but that it wasn’t just the idea of some independent activists.

The Standard says they are all independent bloggers. However the following e-mail has been forwarded onto me:

From: xxxxxxx xxxxxxx
Date: 11 June 2008 12:24:42 PM
To: [email protected]
Cc: [email protected], [email protected]
Subject: The Standard Blog

Dear all

I have a serious issue to raise with you all. It has come to my attention that two Ministerial staffers – Chris Elder and Andrew Kirton, both political employees – are blogging anonymously at the Labour-hosted, anti-John Key blog the Standard, www.thestandard.org.nz.

Given that a large number of these posts (most notably those by Chris Elder or all_your_base, a communications staffer on the ninth floor) occur during office hours, do you all believe it is appropriate that political employees are spending their time blogging anonymously? Is this approved behaviour?

Kind regards

xxxxxxx xxxxxx

After I was forwarded a copy of the e-mail by a parliamentary staffer, I asked the e-mailer the basis of the information, the e-mailer replied “A young Labour person I know who is also a blogger”

It has in fact long been speculated that Elder blogged as All-your-base as this was allegedly a favourite saying of his (referring to the tag line of a famous hacking group). He has denied being involved with The Standard, and it is of course impossible to prove or disprove without computer logs.

But it is likely that two of the bloggers are Beehive communications employees, and a third is the Labour Party Head Office Communications Manager. A fourth and maybe a fifth are employed by the EPMU – Labour’s largest affiliated union. This would be seen very differently by most members of the public than the official line of “a collective who saw a gap in the New Zealand political blogosphere and decided that we should have a go at filling it. We write here in our personal capacities and the opinions that are expressed on the blog are individual.”

If they were public over their identities, then people could judge for themselves how much of a personal capacity they are in.

The issue is not that they blog, but the total lack of transparency over what they do. The Green Party has some of its parliamentary employees (and MPs) blog at Frog Blog. But they are open about this, and accept responsibility for what they publish. The Greens deserve praise for their commitment to transparency, which is at total contrast to Labour.

It is certainly true that there are other bloggers at The Standard who do not work for Labour. But nevertheless how can one argue for transparency in campaigning yet argue that the PM can have a Communications Advisor blogging anonymously on a site proposed by her office as part of a communications strategy?

Some of the material on The Standard, such as a pdf document, reveals in its properties that it was created on a Ministerial Services computer. Other material links it to the EPMU.

The final link is the new No8wire website launched this week. The Standard reported this is the same team which did the KeepLeftNZ site in 2005 – in other words it is probably also run out of the PM’s Office. The site even makes it clear that the material appearing on the site is contributed by multiple persons – it is not an individual effort.

In an ultimate fit of hypocrisy they have registered the site in the .org top level domain as this allows anonymous domain name registrants. They also claim to be exempt from the Electoral Finance Act as it is hosted overseas and managed by a NZers who lives overseas.

Their lack of transparency clearly breaches the spirit of the Electoral Finance Act, and quite possibly also the statute itself. I will be lodging official complaints over the site and asking electoral authorities to fully investigate it.

As leftwing blogger Idiot/Savant notes at No Right Turn:

The problem is that both of the exemptions they cite look decidedly dodgy – it all looks a bit slick and well funded to be “non-commercial”, while their declaration that they are “ready to ensure the election of an LPG Government” blows their appeal to the media exemption out of the water. Many people, I think, will be concerned whether those videos are really being produced outside New Zealand – and National will no doubt seek to counter them by claiming they are really being hatched in the Beehive. By allowing that, they’re undermining their cause, and the credibility of fair controls to prevent the rich from buying elections.

Even having the official editor and hosting overseas may not put them beyond the reach of the law. If material for the site is produced by people in NZ, then they are arguably promoting election advertisements, and risk being in breach of the law.

The overseas NZer is widely believed to be the same Rob Salmond who set up The Standard, previously a staffer or contractor in the Beehive. A quick look at the site shows it to have professionally edited graphics and obviously considerable resource behind it. They have already ripped off an anti David Cameron video from 2006 and used it as an anti John Key video.

This is not a personal blog. It is beyond doubt supported by and resourced by the parliamentary Labour Party and/or their affiliated unions. The fact they have one anonymous ex staffer or contractor on the other side of the world uploading the material for them, doesn’t change that reality. It is a “hollow” attempt to avoid the most basic requirements of transparency, let alone their own Electoral Finance Act.

The Internet is a medium where people should be able to express their opinions, and have a whack at parties they don’t agree with. But political parties should stand behind their own work. Why doesn’t Labour do as the Greens do, and take responsibility for their work?

One suspects it is because they want to be able to attack their opponents without taking responsibility for such attacks. The exact thing they claim to be against.

These anonymous attacks are not an isolated incident, such as a parliamentary staffer submitting a one off idea to a blog. Labour’s entire involvement since 2005 has been lacking in the transparency they claim to champion. It is a hypocrisy that rankles with those who do stand behind their own names.

The purpose of this post is not to challenge the right of The Standard and/or 08wire to run material attacking John Key. I happen to think it is mostly counter-productive anyway as it is so lacking in subtlety. But the purpose is to ask for Labour to stop hiding behind anonymous proxies and to take responsibility for their own work.

Again, this is not an isolated incident. Their entire online history of the last three years has been to hide behind anonymous attack sites.They do it time and time again.

I know something about the challenges of online advocacy from Parliament. I was a parliamentary staffer for eight years. From 1996 to 2004 I posted tens of thousands of times to the Usenet Internet newsgroups on political issues. Every single time I did so under my own name. The first nine months of my blogging was as a parliamentary staffer, and again that was always under my own name. I have no issue with parliamentary staffers blogging – I welcome it – they can offer more to the debate than most people with their access to information. But they should be open about who they are.

As a final note, some will ask for the proof that Labour has been involved with these three sites. Well obviously direct proof is near impossible unless one does a Nicky Hager and gets hold of e-mails or has video recordings of people at work.

However the information about the identities of the people involved in these sites come from multiple people in multiple settings, collected over time. I have no reason to doubt its veracity. It would also be very simple for the facts to be established – for example Helen Clark could state in Parliament that no Ministerial staff members do blog or has blogged at The Standard and that no Beehive (or Labour Research Unit) staffer is producing material for 08wire or The Standard. Her word, if given in Parliament, would be accepted. Somehow I doubt she will.

UPDATE: Rob Salmond has posted a comment admitting he worked last year for the PMs Office and is behind 08wire and that he does not produce all the material himself but receives it from others. He of course refutes some of my assertions – specifically any involvement setting up The Standard, and I have responded to his comments. What is not denied is that material for all three anonymous sites is produced by parliamentary staffers.

Whale Oil also posts on the issue.

The Zimbabwe dictatorship

The Washington Post has a chilling story of how Mugabe was willing initially to stand down, but that his military commanders would not let him. It confirms that Zimbabwe is now a military dictatorship:

President Robert Mugabe summoned his top security officials to a government training center near his rural home in central Zimbabwe on the afternoon of March 30. In a voice barely audible at first, he informed the leaders of the state security apparatus that had enforced his rule for 28 years that he had lost the presidential vote held the previous day.

Then Mugabe told the gathering he planned to give up power in a televised speech to the nation the next day, according to the written notes of one participant that were corroborated by two other people with direct knowledge of the meeting.

But Zimbabwe’s military chief, Gen. Constantine Chiwenga, responded that the choice was not Mugabe’s alone to make. According to two firsthand accounts of the meeting, Chiwenga told Mugabe his military would take control of the country to keep him in office or the president could contest a runoff election, directed in the field by senior army officers supervising a military-style campaign against the opposition.

They choose the second option but it really is much the same as the first option.

Hat Tip: Tumeke

How Good Is …

An interesting website at How Good. It is primary designed for allowing you to rank professionals (a commendable idea) but also now has a section allowing you to rate politicians.

Bill Ralston has written profiles of the party leaders for the site. They are quite funny.

Only annoying thing is you have to register to write a review.

I HATE BEING SICK!!!

National’s Broadcasting Policy

National has announced its 2008 Broadcasting Policy.

Let’s look at the different aspects:

Maintain state ownership of Television New Zealand

No surprises there. Personally I would like an investigation done of whether you could sell off TV2 and turn TV One into a public broadcaster, but that is a radical change.

Continue support for Maori Television

They’ve certainly done a good job, especially compared to previous efforts. However I would like to see reliable rating data released.

Continue funding for Radio New Zealand, National Pacific Radio Trust, and Access Radio

Again, as expected.

Make TVNZ charter funding contestable through NZ on Air and make it available to other free-to-air broadcasters on a competitive basis so that the best projects get onto our screens

Now this is a significant change. Basically the failed Maharey charter model will be abandoned. The model is a failure – even ex TVNZ CEO Ian Fraser (a huge fan of public broadcasting) has said it was impossible giving TVNZ competing demands of being commercial and being a public broadcaster. Plus we have seen charter money go into ludicrous areas.

This means TVNZ will focus on being a commercial broadcaster, and the charter money will go into NZ on Air as additional funding for NZ programmes – which all channels and producers can compete for.

Switch off analogue by 2015

I’ll believe it when it happens.

Maintain funding for the Freeview platform

How much is this?

Demand public accountability for the $79 million of direct funding allocated to TVNZ6 & TVNZ7

Does this mean that they will make these channels available on Sky? I hope so, as if I am paying $79 million through my taxes on them, I want to get then through the medium I prefer.

Ensure transparent processes for radio frequency allocation and renewal that create fair competition and take into account the range of community and broadcaster interests.

Yawn.

Insist on regular publication of rating/audience/ household penetration data for any broadcasting entity receiving state funding.

This aspect is very good. It is disgraceful that Radio NZ (and Maori TV) do not allow those who fund them (taxpayers) know how many viewers their various programmes get. Information is key.

NZPA Political Column

NZPA Political Editor Peter Wilson reviews the week (no link):

On Friday night another poll showed National holding more than 50 percent of the party vote and leading Labour by more than 20 points.

Three previous surveys during the last three weeks, taken by different polling organisations, delivered very similar results.

They all put National above 50 percent, they all showed the gap at more than 20 points.

Contrary to the Government’s comments, public opinion isn’t volatile.

It’s about a solid as it gets, and the message for Labour is about as bad as it gets.

How long will Helen keep rubbishing every single poll as extreme? And I note that the John Key attack site has stopped publishing poll results since mid May, after previously recording every single one.

The trucking industry’s protest against the latest rise in their road user charges — clogging up feeder routes into cities around the country — would normally have been expected to provoke confrontations with motorists on their way to work.

Very little of that happened, and although industry claims of nearly 100 percent public support were probably exaggerated the truckies were getting the thumbs up from drivers.

Most of them probably weren’t aware of the details behind the Government’s actions that had infuriated the industry but they knew one thing — the protest was about rising costs and the truckies were fed up.

People are fed up. They’re fed up with the price of petrol and the price of food. They’re fed up with the Reserve Bank using the mortgage rate to control inflation and they’re fed up with the slump in the housing market.

Well I doubt many understand how the Reserve Bank acts but they are certainly fed up with high prices, high interest rates and falling property prices.

Before that, many of them perceived the Government as bossy and interfering. The law change that banned smacking was the catalyst for a swing against Labour, although it was a Green Party bill.

The Electoral Finance Act was introduced late last year amid strident opposition protest and a rash of mostly bad publicity.

And they deserve to lose for both laws. The first for the blatant dishonestry around what they were doing, and the second for trying to silence its critics and legalise its own use of taxpayer money for campaigning without it counting towards their limit.

The budget in May this year delivered tax cuts, but it did nothing at all to improve the Government’s poll rating. The reaction seemed to be “thanks, but you should have given it to us three years ago”.

This set of circumstances has come about at a really bad time for a third term government, and the impact could be catastrophic.

Not just in terms of the party vote, but in individual electorates. It is possible one could see Labour reduced to a mere dozen or so electorate seats, if the electorate vote margin is similar to the party vote. And the challenge for Labour will be whether to protect incumbent MPs on the list or allow some new blood to come in.

Against this backdrop, Labour’s attacks on National’s leader John Key risk looking like desperate diversions.

Voters don’t want more negative news, they want to hear something that will make them believe things are going to get better.

They are looking to National and John Key to deliver it, and whether or not he sold his family trust shares in Tranz Rail before or after he asked a question in Parliament about the railways isn’t going to make a damn bit of difference.

Yes, Labour’s biggest concern. That plus Crosby/Textor.

Population Myths

Some nice work by the Government’s population website. They’ve done some pages on 12 common myths about population. A very user-friendly way to get information across:

Myth 1: Half of all marriages end in divorce

Myth 2: There was a surge of returning New Zealanders after 9/11

Myth 3: “The browning of New Zealand”

Myth 4: New Zealand women are now having their first baby at age 30

Myth 5: New Zealand’s population is only growing because of migration

Myth 6: “In 2003 four of every five pregnant Asian women aborted their babies”

Myth 7: The average life expectancy of males is 6 years less than females

Myth 8: New Zealand has 3 million people and 60 million sheep

Myth 9: The Brain Drain

Myth 10: There are at least 1 million New Zealanders living overseas

Myth 11: “There are more people alive now than have ever lived”

Myth 12: “New Zealand is in the midst of a baby boom”

I should point out that not everything here is a myth per se. For example the increased migration home after 9/11 is inconclusive – with it likely there was some impact but that otehr factors are at play. Also one can dispute their brain drain arguments as they do not look just as NZ citizens migration in and out but also new immigrants. Just because our migration policy brings in skilled persons doesn’t mean we are not losing skilled persons. They would be on better ground if they looked at migrations flows of NZ citizens and non citizens.

Also it would be useful if they provided links to source material. But none the less still a good effort.

Hat Tip: Miramar Mike and Llew

Nominate a President

One day New Zealand will be able to choose a New Zealander as Head of State. We’re not quite there yet, but to get people thinking about it, the Repubican Movement has opened nominations for New Zealand’s 1st President.

Just go on through and nominate the New Zealand you would most like as our first NZ Head of State.

The top five nominees will then be announced, and a series of votes held to select a winner.

The NZ connection

As France and Colombia celebrate the release of Ingrid Betancourt, a reader points out to me the NZ connection as detailed in Wikipedia:

After graduating, she married fellow student Fabrice Delloye in 1983, and they had two children, Mélanie (born 1985) and Lorenzo (born 1988). Through this marriage she became a French citizen. Her husband served in the French diplomatic corps, and the couple lived in multiple countries, including New Zealand and the Seychelles. During the 1980s, she briefly lived in Quito, Ecuador, where she worked as an aerobics instructor.

In the mid 1990s, Betancourt and Delloye divorced, and she married Colombian advertising executive, Juan Carlos Lecompte in 1997.

Her children Melanie and Lorenzo moved to New Zealand to live with their father due to death threats stemming from her political activities. They were 16 and 13 when she was kidnapped in 2002.

I don’t think I have seen that NZ connection mentioned in the traditional media, which is surprising as normally any connection to New Zealand – no matter how tenuous – is seized upon.

Our intended companions on the UN Human Rights Council

Liberty Scott takes a look at some of the company we will share if our misguided attempt to get on the UN Human Rights Council succeeds:

– Cameroon, which imprisons men suspected of homosexual activity and forcibly engages in anal examinations of them to seek evidence.
– Djibouti, which tends to arrest and imprison journalists who criticise the government in isolation wards;
– Nigeria, whose Police boast of 795 extrajudicial killings in 3 months, with politicians leading gangs of thugs who terrorise with murder, rape and arson against opponents or supporters of opponents;
– South Africa, which treats Zimbabwean refugees as purely economic migrants and facilitates the ongoing oppression in Zimbabwe;
– Bangladesh, which engages in arbitrary arrests, frequent torture in custody, extrajudicial killings, journalists accused of defaming the government or military get arrested and sometimes tortured;
– China, which arrests, tortures and executes political opponents;
– Indonesia, which imprisons people for blasphemy against Islam, arrests political activists in West Papua;
– Jordan, which strictly punishes criticism of the King and civil servants, detains women to protect them from domestic violence;
– Egypt, which arrests political opponents without trial, tortures and engages in extrajudicial killings, imprisons editors of critical newspapers, requires government approval of NGOs;
– Qatar, which requires all NGOs to be registered and are monitored and bans political protests, or membership of any organisation critical of Arab governments;
– Saudi Arabia, which arrests without charge, puts critics in solitary confinement, sentences those convicted of sodomy to up to 7000 lashes, grants the death sentence by decapitation to those as young as 13, enforces strict limits on criticism of the government and Islam, denies women the right to work, travel, study, marry, receive health care, and access government agencies, including when they seek protection or redress as victims of domestic violence, unless authorised by a father or husband, flogs rape victims for illegally associating with the opposite sex;
– Azerbaijan, which regularly tortures those arrested, arrests and shuts down opposition media and journalists;
– Russia, which engages in extrajudicial and politically motivated executions, tortures and kills young soldiers in its own army as part of hazing, NGOs are required to register and the government shuts down and threatens opposition media;
– Cuba, which suppresses all forms of political dissent, prohibits gatherings of groups, arrests and imprisons political opponents including classifying some as mental patients.

National could save us all from embarrassment by announcing it will not pursue a place on the Council. Even if the vote is before the election, the mere fact the bid does not have bipartisan support should be enough to help us fail.

Generally I support a bipartisan approach to UN issues, but really it would just be sickening to have our credibility propping up these human rights abusers as Iran (which sometimes kills women who get raped) criticises the UK for its lack of progress on sexual equality issues.

Clark says she won’t go

NZPA reports:

Prime Minister Helen Clark says National’s lead in the polls will start to slip when the election campaign starts and she isn’t even thinking about handing the leadership to someone else.

Miss Clark was asked on NewstalkZB this morning whether she would consider stepping aside to give Labour “a new face” before the election if the polls don’t change.

The last four have shown National’s support at more than 50 percent, and its lead over Labour at more than 20 points.

“That’s a question I’m not even prepared to contemplate,” she said when she was asked about the leadership.

Generally it isn’t leaders who contemplate changes, but their MPs who panic at the thought of losing their seats.

Having said that, a change of leaders would not be credible for Labour and not even uber-ambitious Phil Goff wants to do a Mike Moore and be PM for just six weeks.  They should change nothing at all and keep on doing what they are doing.

More sensible would be to announce a new Deputy or Finance Minister. I respect Michael Cullen’s achievements, but there is little chance the public are going to vote for him to deliver another budget. Put Goff or Cunliffe into Finance and you might have the public think more kindly of the Government as willing to give them back more of their own money.

How to gain a bigger benefit

The Dom Post reports on the increasing number of drug and alcohol addicts who claim sickness and invalids benefits.

More than 5270 beneficiaries receive weekly sickness or invalid payments because of drug or alcohol problems. They are not compelled to receive treatment.

The escalating problem is estimated to cost taxpayers more than $1 million a week.

Data released under the Official Information Act show there are 2540 beneficiaries who have drug abuse listed as their primary reason for being unable to work – almost twice the 1297 listed in 2004.

There are also 2739 sickness and invalid beneficiaries who list alcoholism as the reason they cannot work.

And these are only the official numbers. I understand that in fact a much higher proportion are drug or alcohol addicts but they do not list this as their major cause of disability.

A single person on a sickness benefit aged 25 receives $219.25 a week gross. The invalid benefit pays $277.50 a week.

A lot better than being on the dole, and no having to turn up to job interviews.

Wouldn’t the truly compassionate thing to do, be to require drug and alcohol addicts to get treatment, in return for their benefit – rather than pay them to not get better?

The Hive on Key

The Hive gives their perspective on John Key, and Clark’s attacks on him:

We have met every National leader since Holyoake. We have huge admiration for Bolger who has become a friend since leaving politics but we rate him behind Key. Bolger is also well ahead of Shipley, McLay, Marshall and Holyoake. Holyoake was a man for his times, and he was very fortunate living in those times. He would not have hacked it today. We despised Muldoon and his political tactics and we are worried that PM Clark is becoming increasingly Muldoonist in her tactics. In the end the electorate rebelled against Muldoon and it is preparing to do the same to Clark. She still has time to change tack, but had better move fast.

We also rate Bill English highly. He gets better all the time. He became Leader too early. We see him as John Howard. Don’t write him off as a future Leader and PM. But Key and English together are going to make a formidable team at the top of Government, should National win this year.

We also disagree over scripting. We have seen Key read set piece speeches many times and heard him ad lib several times. There is no doubt that he is best without the script.

He is far from shallow and is far more knowledgeable on general political and economic policy than the PM is suggesting. What makes money markets move Helen???? Political and economic developments. Key was one of the best in the world at reading these trends and making money from them.

You have been a very strong PM Helen, but what did you do before entering politics. Were you one of the best in the world in your field? Were you even one of the best in New Zealand in your field? Don’t underrate this guy.

I actually think it is funny when people do under-rate him. People are very wrong when they think it is all due to third termitis with Labour. John Key is the most popular Opposition Leader NZ has had in the last few decades. As a comparison, Bolger in 1990 never polled anywhere near as highly as Key did, despite having a Government teating itself apart with infighting.

The Hiev advises Helen:

Stop the personal attacks and denigration. Start focusing on policies that are going to add hope to those out their who are becoming increasingly worried about every economic statistic they see. Key knows this is what people want to hear. His speeches don’t denigrate you. Instead they paint an optimistic vision for New Zealand explain the general policies needed to get there.

Indeed Keye doesn’t spend a huge amount of time bagging the Government. He does speak optimistically of the country’s future – but with a more determined focus on increasing economic growth and closing the gap with Australia.

And the more time Helen spends on attacking Key rather than talking about issues of concern to NZers – well the more they will lose by.

Be careful what you wish for

I spent most of yesterday with a queazy stomach. I didn’t feel sick per se, didn’t have a temperature, just had that unsettled feeling where you know something is upset.

It lasted all day, and got to be quite annoying. I wanted it to go away, and it got to the point where I actually thought to myself it would be better to actually be sick, and get the bug (if I have one) flushed through the system.

Well be careful what you wish for. Since 4 am I have been to the bathroom over a dozen times, and with no sign of feeling better. I think it is going to be a very very long day. Hopefully will be able to get some drugs once the local pharmacy is open. Normally I prefer to not take drugs and let an illness take its course, but hell this is seriously not enjoyable.

Not sure what caused it but think it might be a seafood salad I got from New World on Saturday.

The only bright side is I have finished the last 300 pages of the latest Sara Douglass novel!

90 day probation for small businesses

It is good to see National confirm a policy of allowing a 90 day probation period for new employees, if the employer is a small business with under 20 staff. I think it is well targeted at small businesses as they can be crippled by a bad employee, and do not have the recourse to inhouse lawyers that larger businesses may have.

One will hear a lot of hysteria about this policy from the usual sources, despite the fact we are almost the only country in the developed world which doesn’t already have such a policy. Let’s look at the reality of small businesses and employees.

First of all, employers do not like losing staff generally. It costs a lot of money to recruit a staff member, and takes some time for them to gain experience and be as productive as they can be. So any hysteria about how employers will sack staff every 90 days so they never have a workforce with full employment rights is wild eyed fanaticism from people who had no idea how being an employer really works. Employers generally want to retain staff.

However sometimes a new staff member does not work out. No matter how much you interview someone or check references, some people are just manifestly unsuitable for a job they have gained. And you sometimes never find this out until they are in the job and it becomes clear.

In a small business, one sub-standard staff member can threaten the viability of the whole business. In the mid 1990s I worked at such a small business and margins were razor thing. The owners often took home less pay than the receptionist. And we did have one new employee who did not generate the revenue needed to cover his/her salary, with the result being it almost pushed the firm under.

After that we were very hesitant about taking on more staff, because it was so difficult to extract yourself if it did not work out. Sure the big employers can just pay them out with three to six months compensation, but you can’t afford that as a small business. And few small business owners can afford to spend the best part of six to twleve months going through the process needed to legally dismiss someone. It is in fact very difficult to dismiss someone just because they are not up to the job – as opposed to misconduct.

As I said at the beginning, an employer is going to be pretty hesitant to get rid of an employee in the 90 day period. It is costly to have to recruit a replacement and train them up. So such dismissals will be the exception, not the rule. As an employer you’d have to be pretty convinced that the employee is just not going to work out, to let them go so soon. And once the 90 days are up, they have the normal full employment rights.

With the economy heading into a likely recession, and unemployment tipped to reach 6%, one wants to make it more attractive for small businesses to take a risk and offer someone a job. A 90 day probation period for these small businesses will make it less risky to do so.

Some wise word from Doug Aldersdale at Chapman Tripp:

However, Doug Alderslade, an employment lawyer at Chapman Tripp, said he expected arbitrary dismissals under such a policy would be rare.

He said most employers put great effort into recruiting staff and were likely to use the provision only where there was a genuine problem.

“Just because employers have the opportunity to terminate doesn’t mean it will be used in a ruthless fashion to get rid of people.

“A lot of people will oppose this, saying it will be abused. But that defies economic reality. Employers need someone to work in that job and will be hoping the person they appoint succeeds.”

He said dismissing new workers was also a hassle for the employer, who then had to recruit a replacement.

It would make employing easier for smaller businesses which had often struggled to deal with the current probationary period under which staff required monitoring and had to be given areas for improvement before they could be dismissed.

Again such a probationary period is standard throughout the developed world. One will hear a lot of hysterical claims about evil abusive employers using such a period to trample on employees, but I predict that once it is in place, it will largely be a non-event and it will never be got rid of.

Death Penalty for blogging in Iran

Boing Boing reports that Iran is bringing in the death penalty for certain types of blogging.

Yes it will be a crime to establish a blog which disturbs mental security in society. Examples are promoting corruption, prostitution or apostasy. So athiests might be up for the chop.

The proposed Act lists such blogging amongst other crimes such as rape, armed robbery and kidnapping.

Now let me remind people that Iran is a member of the UN’s Human Rights Council. The one we are trying so hard to join. Now do you think that body will ever criticise Iran? Oh no.

Hat Tip: Larvatus Prodeo

Prince Caspian

I saw Prince Caspian at the weekend. The Narnia chronicles I first read at primary school, and have been re-read many times since.

It was pretty good. The battle scenes were well done, and the Telmarines played their part well. The Edmund character was far better than last time.

The biggest disappointment was Caspian himself. He came across too self-obsessed and whiny. He seemed too focused on his rightful inheritance rather than restoring Narnia.

Overall kept too the plot fairly well, except for the addition of the attack on the castle which never happened. I am glad they kept in the attempt to summon back the White Witch as that is a fundamental part of the book – the choice between good and evil power.

The Christian allegory was also well done. The emphasis on faith was well done, without overly dominating.

Oh yes and I loved Reepicheep – as I knew I would.

The Narnia movie I am really looking forward to is the next one – Voyage of the Dawn Treader. It’s a grand wee adventure.

Biofuels forced food prices up 75%

The Guardian (note the source) has a report which lays huge blame on biofuels for the current food crisis. In fact they cite biofuels as being responsible for 75% of food price increases. The secret World Bank report says:

Biofuels have forced global food prices up by 75% – far more than previously estimated – according to a confidential World Bank report obtained by the Guardian.

The figure emphatically contradicts the US government’s claims that plant-derived fuels contribute less than 3% to food-price rises. It will add to pressure on governments in Washington and across Europe, which have turned to plant-derived fuels to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases and reduce their dependence on imported oil.

“Political leaders seem intent on suppressing and ignoring the strong evidence that biofuels are a major factor in recent food price rises,” said Robert Bailey, policy adviser at Oxfam. “It is imperative that we have the full picture. While politicians concentrate on keeping industry lobbies happy, people in poor countries cannot afford enough to eat.”

Rising food prices have pushed 100m people worldwide below the poverty line, estimates the World Bank, and have sparked riots from Bangladesh to Egypt. Government ministers here have described higher food and fuel prices as “the first real economic crisis of globalisation”.

Since April, all petrol and diesel in Britain has had to include 2.5% from biofuels. The EU has been considering raising that target to 10% by 2020, but is faced with mounting evidence that that will only push food prices higher.

“Without the increase in biofuels, global wheat and maize stocks would not have declined appreciably and price increases due to other factors would have been moderate,” says the report. The basket of food prices examined in the study rose by 140% between 2002 and this February. The report estimates that higher energy and fertiliser prices accounted for an increase of only 15%, while biofuels have been responsible for a 75% jump over that period.

It argues that production of biofuels has distorted food markets in three main ways. First, it has diverted grain away from food for fuel, with over a third of US corn now used to produce ethanol and about half of vegetable oils in the EU going towards the production of biodiesel. Second, farmers have been encouraged to set land aside for biofuel production. Third, it has sparked financial speculation in grains, driving prices up higher.

“It is clear that some biofuels have huge impacts on food prices,” said Dr David King, the government’s former chief scientific adviser, last night. “All we are doing by supporting these is subsidising higher food prices, while doing nothing to tackle climate change.”

Of course this doesn’t stop Labour and the Greens with pushing ahead for mandatory biofuel uptake in NZ. Hey what’s an extra hundred million people in poverty so long as we are environmentally pure.

Hat Tip: Paul Walker