NZ First to vote against FTA

NZ First have confirmed they will vote against the Free Trade Agreement with China.  So the NZ Government is going to have its own Foreign Minister vote and advocate against their most important foreign policy achievement.  What next? Will Helen Clark allow the Minister of Finance to vote against the Budget?

NZ First are saying there are not enough concessions from the Chinese side. This is absolute nonsense. Professional negotiators such as Tim Groser are saying that it is one of the cleanest (ie few hold out areas) FTAs around.  Considering our relative sizes, NZ has negotiated a great deal.

Anyway NZ First have made their decision, which puts the ball in Clark’s court. Does she regard it as acceptable her Foreign Minister votes against and advocates against her Government’s most important foreign policy achievement?

Children’s Book Cover you never see

Recriprocal Working Holiday Visas

NZPA reports some minor criticism of the FTA with regard to Working Holiday Visas:

Under the agreement up to 1000 Chinese aged between 18 and 30 can enter New Zealand for a temporary time to work in the tourism industry or other work.

The scheme is similar to that offered to a number of other countries that New Zealand is keen to build links with.

In China’s case this deal has not been offered in return.

Miss Clark said China has a legal framework did not make that possible.

“That hasn’t been largely of concern to us,” Miss Clark said.

“Where we think it is in New Zealand’s interests to have a working holiday scheme with another country we will do it unilaterally, as we have with the United States.”

Miss Clark said it was possible China could reciprocate in the future, but New Zealand had found that with such schemes there had been greater interest in young people from emerging economies coming to work in New Zealand than the other way round.

This was probably due to the fact that developing economies paid lower wages than young New Zealanders could earn in other countries.

The PM is dead right in this regard. I can’t imagine there are great numbers of Kiwis wanting to do a working holiday in China, because the amount they will earn would be so limited.

I think it is vital NZ tries to expand working holiday opportunities in Europe and North America especially. The moves by the UK to remove traditional working rights for young New Zealanders is of great concern. But the lack of a formal programme with China is not.

An Open XML application

The result of the OOXML vote reminded me of this blog post which I had bookmarked a few weeks ago, about a nice wee application called TextGlow, which has been developed locally by Intergen.

TextGlow is a cutting edge browser application for viewing Word 2007 documents on the Internet. With TextGlow it is possible to instantly view a document within a web page, with no Microsoft Office applications installed, or the user even running Windows!

The value of an application like TextGlow is that it makes browsing documents on a website much faster. There is no need to download each individual document and open it with Word to preview its contents. With the rise of web based document management systems such as SharePoint Server, I believe that being able to quickly preview documents within the browser using TextGlow will be a real productivity boost.

That sounds bloody good to me. I have not quite worked out how or where to download it but am going to give it a try.

A West Wing script for the Democrats

This is a great read for fans of the great West Wing TV series.

The New  York Magazine has got one of the former West Wing writers to produce a script for what may happen if the Democrats do not get a result before their convention, and it is a brokered convention (as it was on the West Wing).

It’s a hilarious script, taking the piss out of Clinton, Obama and especially the ever lurking Al Gore.

Fibre, fibre, fibre

Very welcome news on Monday that Kordia is going to invest in a new fibre cable between New Zealand and Australia. Initially it will have 240 Gb/s of capacity. But it it not just the capacity that is welcpome, but the competition it will provide to Southern Cross Cable and Telstra who have pretty much all the international bandwidth.

Southern Cross Cable has also announced a boost in capacity to 860 Gb/s so we will in a few years have 1 Tb/s capacity. But that only allows 125,000 to be using the Internet at the same time at 8 Mb/s or 1 MB/s.  The SCC has 2.5Tb/s maximum capacity but new technology may push this even further.

The other fibre that has been in the news had been the NZ Institute’s proposal for how to get fibre rolled out to 75% of premises by 2018.  Basically they propose the creation of a dedicated fibe company which will do the last mile fibre to homes, and provide open access to all providers at a regulated price. They estimate this will cost between $4 and $5 billion based on 25,000 kms of fibre duct at $150,000 per km.

They also estimate that $3 to $4 billion of that can be met by private investment and that a Government commitment of $1 billion over ten years ($100 million a year) is needed to reach 75% of the population.

Bernard Hickey supports the plan and says:

The goverment has already posted a budget surplus before accounting gains and losses of $3.649 billion in the seven months to the end of January. That’s an average of $521 million a month.

Meanwhile our productivity growth keeps slowing, as this chart on the left shows. Just imagine if many of us could work from home with much faster connections and we could access overseas markets more easily.

Surely it’s time our government did something useful with that money to invest in the nation’s future. I can think of nothing better than spending $1 billion of public money to build a broadband network that would generate around $4 billion a year in economic benefits. It would pay for itself in extra tax revenues within a year or two. Just imagine if the government had done this three years ago instead of wasting money with its nutty free student loans (bribe).

I’ve yet to fully get to grip with the pros and cons of the NZ Institute proposal, but I think it is an excellent contribution to the debate, and am trying to learn more about it.

Rod Drury has also blogged in support of it:

The FibreCo solution is very logical and I think takes into account the concerns of the many stakeholders around this issue. Some very smart people took the time to really think about this.

I like that it balances private and public sector needs. It builds on what we learned as a country in the 70’s, 80’s and 90’s. It is a savvy financial solution.

I think there is going to be a lot of discussion this year on fibre.

China Caption Contest

Peters must vote for the FTA or resign

If Winston Peters wants to vote against the free trade agreement with China, then he must resign as Minister of Foreign Affairs.

The arrangement he has with Clark where he is Foreign Affairs Minister, but not formally part of the Government, has already stretched the concept of collective responsibility. But this is about more than semantics.

The China FTA is not just a trade agreement – it has been and is a major foreign policy goal for the Government. Just listen to Helen:

Prime Minister Helen Clark and Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao described the agreement as a major step that would deepen New Zealand’s relations with the emerging economic superpower.

How the hell can Peters remain Foreign Minister if he votes on the record against an agreement that deepens our relationship with such an important country and trading partner?

This isn’t about voting against a minor policy in an unrelated policy area. This is about voting against a policy which will help define our future relationship with China, and sits at the heart of foreign policy.

Can Peters credibly represent the NZ Government to China, if he goes and votes against this agreement? Not at all, especially when combined with rhetoric from his deputy leader about how horrified he is about a horde (1,600 skilled workers) of Chinese flooding the country under this deal.

Dom Post calls for Local Government amalgamation in Wellington

The Dominion Post points out it is not only Auckland that needs a review of local government:

Here the 450,000 residents of greater Wellington are funding five councils on this side of the Rimutakas, another three in the Wairarapa, a regional council and a host of community boards, the purpose of which is a mystery to all but those who serve on them. …

But what could be more logical than a single body representing the interests of those who live within a region? What is the point of duplicating services and why should progress forever be delayed because of territorial disputes between councils?

Here it would make eminently good sense to merge the Upper Hutt and Lower Hutt councils, Porirua and Kapiti, and the three Wairarapa councils. But it would make even more sense to create a single entity to represent the entire Wellington region.

I doubt one can get agreement to immediately go to one authority for all of Greater Wellington, but reducing the numbers of local authorities from eight to four would be a good starting step.

Taito Philip Field depositions

The first day of depositions into Taito Philip Field (already previously declared by Clark and Cullen to only be guilty of trying to help his constituents) saw the Police summarise their alleged evidence:

  • Arranging for false invoices and receipts for work on the houses
  • Making false statements himself to the Ingram inquiry
  • Arranging for people to make false statements to the inquiry
  • Trying to arrange for people to make false statements to a police investigation launched following the Ingram inquiry
  • Examples of these included attempts to create receipts for payments for work when no such payments were made

Like Field, I hope it goes to trial before the election.

China FTA Details

Details are now flowing via NZPA:

  • Tariffs on 96% of exports to China to be eliminated
  • On 1 October 2008, tariffs removed on $200 million of exports, making 35% of exports tariff free
  • By 2013, 66% will be tariff free
  • By 2019 all but $80 million will be tariff free
  • If any future trade deal gives a country better access rights, we automatically get those also
  • All NZ tariffs on imports to be gone by 2016
  • 1,800 skilled Chinese workers can be in NZ at any one time (poor Peter Brown!)
  • Those workers will be in areas where we are lacking skills such as mandarin language teachers, Chinese chefs, nurses and plumbers

The time taken for some barriers to go is slower than many would want, but for me it is the end position which is most important, and that is having 96% of exports tariff free.

UPDATE: The Govt website on the FTA is now live.

And the cork total for 2007/08 is …

I blogged back in February the annual cork counting competition. 2005/06 was 456 and 2006/07 was 496.

Guesses from those who helped drink the wine ranged from 495 to 648, averaging 553.

Guesses on the blog were from 483 to 599.

corkres1.JPG

The result was less than most predicted, but still an increase over the previous year – 512. That includes 240 stelvins. Chicken Little was closest on the blog with 510 and Arnold K in real life guessed 512 exactly.

corkres2.JPG

Those stelvins do made it hard to guess.

Poll Results on Quote

The blog poll over the weekend was asking who, when asked their greatest concern for today’s America, responded “We have troops defending borders in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Korea … We need to bring our troops home from Iraq”

35% said Obama, 31% Wesley Clark, 21% Hillary Clinton and 13% Pastor Thomas Robb. Not many voted, but was fun to see choices.

The correct answer was Pastor Thomas Robb.

How to supersize the NZ economy

On the 15th of April, in Auckland, the Centre for Independent Studies is hosting a free forum on big ideas to supersize the NZ economy. The speakers are:

  • Dr Don Brash, former Reserve Bank Governor
  • Andrew Little, National Secretary, EPMU
  • Phil Rennie, CIS Policy Analyst
  • Dr David Skilling, Chief Executive, The NZ Institute

It is at 6 pm on Tuesday 15th  at theQuay West Suites, 8 Albert Street, Auckland.

It is free, but please go here to register.

I’ll certainly attend if in Auckland on that day. I like the balance of speakers they have arranged, so there will be plenty of ideas.

Dom Post slams Labour over funding

The Dom Post editorial is to the point:

There are ominous signs that Labour has learned little from the pledge card debacle of 2005 and will adopt the same shameful approach to the use of public money for its campaigns in 2008, The Dominion Post writes.

Not quite true. They have learnt to change the law so there is less chance they will get caught.

Its defence of its breach of the Electoral Finance Act over a booklet pubished using public money hints at a smoke and mirrors exercise to skip round the legislation it pushed through last year with the stated aim of cleaning up the electoral process and make everything above board.

And there is a lot of interest over how much money went on that booklet. I am hearing well into six figures. The big question is whether that election advertisement also counts as an election expense or does it qualify for the special Labour inserted exemption of being for parliamentary purposes.

It is a dangerous game and Labour MPs and party bosses should be left in no doubt that legal jiggery-pokery will be seen for what it is – yet another attempt to push the law to the very limit, and achieve more state funding of political parties by stealth.

Indeed, that was the purpose of the Electoral Finance Act and the Validating Act. To make legal their previously illegal expenditure funded by the taxpayer.

Labour has already misled the public over questions of political funding and embarrassed itself in the process after party president Mike Williams failed to mention a $100,000 loan from millionaire Owen Glenn.

And let us not forget the mystery of the NZ First donation – there one moment, gone the next.

Now it has distinguished itself by being the first to be named as breaching the Electoral Finance Act, though it will not be prosecuted, with the Electoral Commission unsurprisingly deciding that the booklet, We’re Making a Difference, is election material, designed to encourage people to vote in a particular way and needed to follow the rules for that and carry an authorisation from the party’s financial agent, along with that person’s home address.

Indeed.

More worrying, though, are the comments Finance Minister Michael Cullen made in Parliament in response to questions over the breach.

Dr Cullen explained that two pieces of legislation covered the spending on the booklet – the Electoral Finance Act that everybody outside Parliament must work under, and the Parliamentary Service Act, which gives MPs virtually open slather when it comes to spending the public’s money on their re-election, after they rewrote the law rather than accept Auditor-General Kevin Brady’s findings that they had been spending money on campaigning illegally.

Dr Cullen told Parliament that while the Electoral Commission determines what is election spending, “matters that are properly authorised as being for parliamentary purposes do not count as election advertising for the returns of expenses”, adding that “parliamentary purposes “cover a wide range of activities by members of Parliament”.

This is what Labour wanted the law to say. But they knew the backlash would be too great if they explicitly said “Anything with the crest on it is exempt” so they stuck in a parliamentary purposes exemption without defining what it means, with the highlight being Annette King recanting on her own definition after she realised it would rule out material such as their pledge card and the election booklet that was complained about.

The implication is clear. It means, as National deputy leader Bill English said in Parliament, that the Electoral Finance Act has been made a mockery of, and that “alongside the election expenses that are tightly monitored there is now a large slush fund of millions of dollars that political parties can spend in an election year”.

That is what Labour wants. But the law on this issue is yet to be decided. No one really knows what this parliamentary purposes exemption will mean.

That is simply unacceptable, and if Labour persists will rightly be seen as cynically manipulating the loopholes of a system it set up in the first place.

The loophole is deliberate.  We saw that with Annette King’s reversal of her own definition.

Hayek Essay Contest

The Mont Pelerin Society has an essay contest which may be of interest to some readers:

In The Constitution of Liberty Hayek says that “we are probably only at the threshold of an age in which the technological possibilities of mind control are likely to grow rapidly and what may appear at first as innocuous or beneficial powers over the personality of the individual will be at the disposal of government. The greatest threats to human freedom probably still lie in the future.”

Has Hayek’s gloomy warning been borne out by events, or has technology become more a force for liberating people from government?

A very relevant topic. The top three entries will win cash awards of US$2,500, US$1,500 and US$1,000 respectively plus all three winners get travel and expenses paid for to attend the AGM of the Mont Pelerin Society in Toyko from 7 to 12 September 2008. The conference will be focusing on technology and freedom.

Entry details are on the link above. Entries close 30 April 2008.

Unfair to brick walls

The NZ Herald reports the Association of Medical Specialists:

“We got nowhere with [former minister] Pete Hodgson on that. It was like beating our head against a brick wall,” Mr Powell said.

“When David Cunliffe came along, it felt as though there had been a change of Government.

High Speed Mobile Data

I am now a beta tester for Vodafone’s new high speed mobile data cards. I have to say so far so good.

The old data card had a maximum download speed of around 350 kb/s. These can go around 20 times as fast, and I routinely get over 2 Mb/s down and around 1 Mb/s up.

Giving up the DSL connection one day is not an impossibility.

Installing the new card was pretty simple. Step 1 is insert CD and install latest software. Step 2 is transfer sim card, and you are done.

While I am a big advocate for fibre to the home, mobile broadband is just as important – both for rural areas, but also for those like me who travel around. It really is so good being able to connect up, in most places in NZ.

Well done Helen & Phil

Today’s signing of a free trade agreement (at 3.30 pm NZST) with China is a very good day for New Zealand. And while there are many many people who have contributed to its successful conclusion, the two primary ones are Helen Clark and Phil Goff.

Goff deserves our thanks for being the primary negotiating Minister, and never dropping the ball on this. This is a highlight of his nine years as Foreign and Trade Minister.

Clark also should be praised by supporters of free trade. Those on the right instinctively support free trade. On the left it has always been treated with far more scepticism, or often hostility. Clark has led her party away from its protectionism instincts and has embraced globalisation rather than tried to fight it like King Canute. The political risks for her has not been insignificant, especially in terms of doing a deal with China – a country so easy to criticise for so many things. She deserves our thanks for putting NZ’s interests first. Her legacy will be not just the FTA with New Zealand, but a modern Labour Party not stuck in the protectionist past.

Why is this free trade deal a good thing – both economically, and politically? My reasons:

  1. It will removes tariffs on 95% of NZ exports to China, saving exporters $115 million a year.
  2. The tariff reduction is projected to increase exports to China by $225 to $350 million a year.
  3. The vast majority of Chinese imports to NZ already have no tariffs on them.
  4.  Consumers will benefit with cheaper prices in those areas where tariffs are to be removed.
  5. While employees in some areas which have protection removed can and do experience short-term pain, moving capital and labour into areas where we have a competitive advantage is good for employers and employees in the medium to long term.
  6. Industries can become more wealthy with the loss of protection. When we used to have large duties on wine imports, the NZ wine industry produced cheap low quality wine as no imported wine could compete on price. As protectionism was removed, the wine industry generally went from trying to compete on price in the domestic market only to competing on quality globally. From 1987 to 1997 exports as a percentage of production went from 3% to 29%, and both production and staff levels increased. This has continued today with exports of wine in 2007 totalling 84 million litres selling for$760 million.
  7. Free Trade lifts people out of poverty. I am amazed that people argue against free trade agreements on the grounds that (for example) it means people in China are working for say NZ$1 an hour. Do they think that if we refuse to trade with them, that that person will be better off on NZ$0 an hour earning nothing? China has reduced the proportion of its population in absolute poverty from 64% in the 70s to 10% in 2004 and India has gone from 51% in 1978 to 28% in 2005. have between them lifted  . Think how many people in Africa could be lifted out of poverty if the EU did not spend 50% of its budget on agricultural subsidies, if Japan did not spend US47 billion on agricultural subsidies (four times its foreign aid) and the US did not spend $4 billion a year subsidising cotton growers.
  8. We are first. China is a growing economic super-power and being the first developed country to sign a free trade agreement strengthens economic ties for the future.
  9. Dialogue and trade is better than the alternative. Yes the Chinese Government is a repressive regime, and has little regard for fundamental human rights. But a policy of shunning China is not likely to be effective, or help the Chinese people (why punish them for a Government they do not get to choose). And while there are still a million miles to go, China is gradually becoming a more free, not a less free, society. Exposing China to trade, to information, to market economies is more likely (no guarantees) to help bring about gradual improvements than refusing to deal with them, because we disapprove of their human rights record.
  10. NZ can criticise as a non threatening friend. I believe that the closer economic ties, will put NZ in a position where we can have some influence, precisely because we are so small and insignificant. When the US or Australia criticise China, they react with hostility as they regard those countries as having ambitions of influence globally or regionally. If a “friend” such as NZ is also there saying “Hey this is not a good idea, and makes it hard for us to deal with you”, I think that voice is listened to as we do have an excellent international reputation.

So I do regard this as a very good day for New Zealand (and China). And while I have many many things I disagree with the Government on, I do praise Clark and Goff especially for their leadership on this issue. As a small trading nation, we need barriers to trade to be lowered, and this is a great step forward.

Health Productivity

Treasury has been warning for some years about the lack of productivity or lack of increased outputs (let alone outcomes) in health despite the massive increases in funding.

Tony Ryall has pointed out that the number of first specialist appointments in 2007 was in fact 10,000 lower than in 2001 when records begun.

specappts.JPG

Note primary Y axis starts at 340,000 to align starting point with health spending.

The graph above shows both the level of first specialist appointments (a slight downwards trend) and the level of funding (in real terms) for Vote Health. Health spending has gone up 33% in real terms in six years, yet less people are seeing specialists for first appointments.

March 2008 Blog Stats

The ever popular list of search terms:

kiwiblog 4932 10.6 %
computers internet blog 1225 2.6 %
david farrar 941 2 %
kiwi blog 523 1.1 %
animal sex 448 0.9 %
kiwiblog.co.nz 285 0.6 %
farrar 275 0.5 %
clayton weatherston 206 0.4 %
nikki kaye 184 0.3 %
john howard lawson 149 0.3 %
animalsex 148 0.3 %
reasons to stay in iraq 146 0.3 %
cactus kate 143 0.3 %
hayley holt 124 0.2 %
okta mondo 117 0.2 %
tila nguyen thong 111 0.2 %
black jokes 110 0.2 %
liz shaw 99 0.2 %
sex animal 90 0.1 %
what is the aprox. average height of a full grown man in the us? 86 0.1 %
shane wenzel 84 0.1 %
you tube 84 0.1 %
women of the israeli defense forces 79 0.1 %
blog 71 0.1 %
peter hausmann 70 0.1 %
david farrar blog 69 0.1 %
dpf 66 0.1 %
louisa wall 66 0.1 %
nicole begg 66 0.1 %
the hive 66 0.1 %
estonian women 60 0.1 %
kiwisaver fees 56 0.1 %
www.kiwiblog.co.nz 55 0.1 %
amy walker 54 0.1 %
kiwisaver providers 54 0.1 %
chicks with guns 53 0.1 %
scott watson 52 0.1 %
south park season 12 50 0.1 %

I am unsure that it is a good thing the blog is in the top ten hits in Google for animal sex! Especially that all the other sites seem to umm specialise in it. I blame the West Coast wombat plus the Netherlands (I blogged about their vote to make sex with animals illegal).

Blog Bits

Poneke has a vigorous debate on his blog about a BBC story that cast doubt on the extent of global warming, and how the BBC then changed its story.

Bernard Hickey writes on why the Reserve Bank should not yet lower the cash rate. I agree with him that there remain domestic inflationary pressures.

Bridget Saunders has an amusing blog on who are the real men. She names as real men – Richard Sigley, Rodney Hide, Matthew Ridge, Pat Rippin and Dave Henderson. Non real men are Brent Todd, Tea Ropati, Daniel Moyes, Helen Clark and Julie Christie.

Politico look at the possible VP choices for Obama.

Profile of NZ Electorates

Last Sunday the Herald on Sunday ran a two-page feature from me profiling New Zealand, using the Electorate Profiles I had blogged about in March.

This wasn’t a political feature, but demographic. We analysed around half a dozen of the more interesting electorates – Auckland Central, Botany, Clutha-Southland, Tauranga, Epsom, Mangere and Northland, to see what was distinctive in each area.

Ironically I have not seen the final article myself as I missed getting a paper that day, but have had some very nice feedback on it.

One of the things I did in researching it also, was draw up a list of “most” and leasts” for various indicators. For those interested, here it is:

  • Most under 15s – Mangere – 30%
  • Most 15 – 19 year olds – Dunedin North – 14%
  • Most 20 – 29 year olds – Auckland Central – 30%
  • Most 30 – 49 year olds – Ohariu – 35%
  • Most 50 – 64 year olds – Coromandel – 21%
  • Most over 65s – Otaki – 23%
  • Youngest median age – Manurewa – 28 years
  • Oldest median age – Otaki – 44 years 
  • Most residents born overseas – Botany – 49%
  • Most born in New Zealand – Invercargill – 90%
  • Most Buddhists – Botany – 4.6%
  • Most Catholics – Hutt South – 18%
  • Most Christians – Mangere – 71%
  • Most Hindus – Mt Roskill – 12%
  • Most Muslims – Mt Roskill – 7%
  • Least Catholics – Nelson – 10%
  • Most Ratana – Northland – 5.4%
  • Most Brethren – Palmerston North – 1.3%
  • Most Jews – Tamaki – 1.4% 
  • Most Married – Selwyn – 56%
  • Most one-person households – Christchurch Central – 32%
  • Most mortgaged – Helensville – 43%
  • Most mortgage free homes – Ilam – 37%
  • Most Home Owners – Selwyn – 78%
  • Most renting – Wellington Central – 44%
  • Most Europeans – Rodney – 83%
  • Most Maori – East Coast – 46%
  • Most Pacific Islanders – Mangere – 59%
  • Most Asians – Mt Roskill – 40% 
  • Most family incomes over $100,000 – Epsom – 46%
  • Lowest median family income – Northland – $43,500
  • Most home phones – Ilam 96%
  • Most cellphones – Ohariu – 82%
  • Most Internet access – Ohariu – 76% 
  • Most unqualified – Invercargill – 32%
  • Most educated – Wellington Central – 41% degree holding
  • Most unemployed – Manukau East – 5.6%
  • Most Labourers – Rangitata – 20%
  • Most miners – West Coast-Tasman – 2.1%
  • Most agricultural workers – Taranaki-King Country – 24% 
  • Smallest – Epsom – 23 sq kms
  • Largest – Clutha/Southland – 38,000 sq kms

 Took a long time going through all 63 electorate profiles, but was an interesting job.

March Public Polls

seatsmar08.JPG

The monthly polling newsletter is out later today. Reminder that to subscribe you can go to http://listserver.actrix.co.nz/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/polling-newsletter to subscribe yourself for the full seven page newsletter.

The seats projection show how things got tighter in March, but would still have a CR majority. The centre parties are NZ First, Maori Party and United Future. I am considering adding in a calculation which adds NZ First and United Future to whichever party is largest in the polls, as they have both said they will give first negotiating priority to the largest party. Mind you that would not affect this graph much as NZ First are calculated at zero seats, but may be important later if they pick up.

minorsmar08.JPG

The minor parties are interesting. The Greens have dropped again from their high in January. NZ First has been declining since November 2007 and are now in 5th place behind the Maori Party.

UN Human Rights Council

The structural deficiencies of the UN are once again on display, with the recent activities of the UN Human Rights Council.

First of all they elected Jean Ziegler to the council’s advisory committee. Ziegler has compared Israeli soldiers to concentration camp guards and lauding a professed Holocaust denier. Even better he, get this, co-founded in 1989 the Moammar Khaddafi Human Rights Prize. He founded this four months after Libya bombed Pam Am Flight 103 killing 270 people.

Winners of his Prize has been Fidel Castro, Louis Farrakhan, and a leader of a Ba’ath party women’s organisation in Saddam’s Iraq. plus oh yeah Ziegler himself.

He also nicely helped the Ethiopian dictator Mengistu draft his one-party constitution and in 2002, he praised the Zimbabwean dictator, saying, “Mugabe has history and morality with him.”

But he is not against human rights.  He has proclaimed the US a dictatorship guility of genocide, and oh yes western capitalism leaders deliberately organising starvation as a “weapon of mass destruction”.

So what else is the UN Human Rights Council doing. It has voted to urge nation states to ban defamation of religion. God forbid, religions are criticised.

But there may be some good news. They have directed a special investigator to concentrate on free speech and expression. Oh, but not to defend it. No, no. Their job is now to report on people who “abuse” free speech. They explain they are not against all free speech, just that free speech must be exercised responsibly.

Reporters Without Borders have said, the U.N. body was focusing on limiting criticism of state and religious interests. Amnesty International said the resolution showed “troubling signs that the Council is moving away from its mandate to promote human rights in the direction of policing the exercise of human rights.”

Oh while busy worried about the scourge of free speech, they were unable to find time to address human rights violations in Tibet.  But they did have time to declare climate change a human rights issue.

It would be funny if it was not so dangerous. And it is no surprise. I blogged two years ago about how this new UN Human Rights Council was no different to its discredited predecessor. The ultimate irony is that this body is funded 95% by the countries with the best human rights records so those countries with the worst human rights records can pass resolutions which undermine human rights.

Hat Tip: The Hive