Two more candidates

Delighted to report that Sam Lotu-liga has won on the first ballot the Maungakiekie nomination for National. With Mark Gosche retiring as Electorate MP, Sam has an enhanced chance to win the seat.

Sam has an MBA from Cambridge, is a very personable guy, and has a great future ahead of him.

Also congrats to Ravi Musuku who has recently been selected for National in Mt Albert. National only has selections left in Dunedin North, Hutt South, Mangere, Manukau East, Manurewa, Mt Roskill and of course Selwyn.

I am missing candidate information for Labour for Clutha-Southland, Tamaki and Waikato. Have they been selected yet? The candidates list has been updated.

Finally National also announced today their new General Manager is Mark Oldershaw. Mark is currently CEO of the Hotel Council of NZ and a former General Manager of World of Wearable Art Ltd.

Back Benches

I popped into the Backbencher last night to observe the live filming of the first episode of a new TVNZ 7 show – Back Benches.

It will be on every Wednesday at around 9 pm, and features Wallace Chapman hosting a panel debate between (mainly) backbench MPs. Damien Christie and Mary-Anne Ahern produce it.

The MPs last night were Maurice Williamson, Louisa Wall, Jacqui Dean and Hone Harawira. There were many dozen people watching – a big crowd from TVNZ (whose account my meal almost got charged to), other press gallery members, a few Vic Uni students, some ACT and Green supporters, plus a few MPs and staff from National.

It was a fun occasion, and I’d recommend locals go along when they can. They debated party pill bans, free trade with China and Peter Brown’s comments.  Lots of clapping for various MPs.  Hone was funny, with a fair bit of grand-standing. Louisa Wall was pretty good, with a good command of the issues for a new MP.

The comment I liked most of all was Maurice Williamson who said that his ideal free trade deal would be one page, and would simply say “You can sell anything you like to us, and we can sell anything we like to you”. Sounds good to me.

Selwyn selection delayed due to injunction

National has had to postpone its Selwyn selection, due the granting this afternoon of an injunction to Roger Payne.

Payne failed to gain an injunction last week, but filed further reasons, and Justice Panckhurst has reversed his earlier decision, and granted an injunction.

The injunction can be viewed here as a PDF.

I have had a read through it, and some key aspects:

  • No decision has been made on the merits of the case
  • The criteria for an injunction is firstly merely whether there is a serious question to be tried, and Justice Panckhurst has said he now accepts there is a question due to reference to Section 71 of the Electoral Act.
  •  It then comes down to the balance of convenience, and this is really why the injunction was granted. If it was not granted, Payne would have permanently lost his chance to gain selection as a candidate. By comparison, National is inconvenienced (especially the accepted nominees and the delegates) but not permanently disadvantaged.

A substantive hearing will have to be arranged. This should be a matter of just weeks, not months. But until there is a substantive decision, the selection meeting scheduled for next week can not be held.

It is unfortunate for National, that it happened in Selwyn where there had already been issues around process. But this could have happened in any seat at all, where someone rejected decides to take legal action.

I’ll briefly touch on the substance of the case.  I’ll reinforce that again no decision has been made on the substance, so any conclusions about the eventual outcome are premature. The key aspect is Section 71 of the Electoral Act 1993:

Requirement for registered parties to follow democratic procedures in candidate selection

Every political party that is for the time being registered under this Part of this Act shall ensure that provision is made for participation in the selection of candidates representing the party for election as members of Parliament by—
(a) Current financial members of the party who are or would be entitled to vote for those candidates at any election; or
(b) Delegates who have (whether directly or indirectly) in turn been elected or otherwise selected by current financial members of the party; or
(c) A combination of the persons or classes of persons referred to in paragraphs (a) and (b) of this section.

 Now the National Party Rule 94(b) says:

The Board shall consider the material submitted and shall have an unfettered discretion to approve or disapprove a nomination received. The Board may undertake an investigation on its own behalf of any candidate but shall not be bound to interview a candidate it rejects or assign any reason for rejection.

Now this rule has been there in various forms for some decades.  It is very very rarely used, and I indicated in my previous blog post what I thought was suitable reasons for its use – the fact Mr Payne had previously failed to abide by the obligations he entered into, when seeking the candidacy in 1999.

Now in terms of  s71, the requirement is only for local members and delegates to participate in the selection. It does not state they are the only people to be involved. As it happens National has extensive involvement, as the *only* people who select the candidate are local members and delegates *once* they have cleared the hurdle of board approval and pre-selection.

The substantive case will be very interesting, and no doubt observed eagerly by all political parties, as I think every significant party has a similar power for its central board.

But that substantive case is a week or so away.  All that has been decided so far is that there is a serious question to be answered, and that as Payne would be permanently disadvantaged without the injunction, and National only temporarily disadvantaged, the injunction is granted.

Green Party List

I have had leaked to me a copy of the initial party list for the Greens for the 2008 election. This is the list which has been put together by the “Candidates, Electorate Delegates, the Co-Leaders, Co-Convenors & Policy Co-Convenors”.

It is not final, as Green Party members are asked to do their own rankings, but obviously the initial rankings are highly influential. The initial list rankings are:

1. Jeanette Fitzsimons

2. Russel Norman

3. Sue Bradford

4. Metira Turei

5. Sue Kedgley

6. Keith Locke

7. Kevin Hague (Chief Executive- West Coast DHB)

8. Catherine Delahunty (Kotare Trust tutor)

9. Kennedy Graham (UC Law Adjunct Senior Fellow)

10. Paul de Spa [WITHDRAWN]

11. Gareth Hughes (Green Parliamentary Services staffer)

12. David Clendon (Sustainable Business Advisor, failed leadership candidate)

13. Steffan Browning (Spokesman for SOIL)

14 Mikarere Curtis (Software Developer)

15. Quentin Duthie (Green Parliamentary Services staffer)

16. Rick Leckinger (“Ministerial Advisor to Jeanette Fitzsimons”)

17. Mojo Mathers (Strategic Policy Advisor- Green Party)

18  Jon Carapiet (Market Research)

19. Donna Wynd (Research Analyst CPAG)

20. Jeanette Elley (Info Systems Manager for CADS at Waitemata DHB)

21. Richard Green (Director/Producer)

22. Virginia Horrocks

23. Ivan Sowry [WITHDRAWN]

24. James Redwood

25. David Hay (not the famous one)

26. Lisa Er

27. Diana Mellor

28. Jan McGlachlan
29. Mike Ward (former MP)

30. Paul Qualtrough

31. Rayna Fahey

32. Peter Taylor

33. Lynette Vigrass

34. Ryan Garland

35. Michael Woodcock

36. Lizzie Gillett

37. James Shaw

38. Craig Carson

39. Tane Woodley [WITHDRAWN]

40. Claire Bleakley

41. Michael Gilchrist

42. Linda Persson

43. Paul Doherty

44. Gary Stewart

45. Richard Tindall

46. Kent Duston [WITHDRAWN]

47. Baker Postelnik

48. Jon Sadler

49. Alan Liefting

Several interesting aspects. Four out of the top five are female (I thought there was a required gender balance.

Former MP Mike Ward has offended someone, as he is down in spot 29.

Also four of the top ranked candidates appear to be on the parliamentary payroll already.

It will be interesting to see what the final list looks like, and whether it differs much.

Huge blow to Government on Environment

The Government has trumpeted biofuels as part of its environmental and energy strategy. Helen Clark announced it last year.

I believe New Zealand has the potential to lead the world in its commitment to renewable energy.

On biofuels, the time has come to implement a sales obligation.

Biofuels can replace diesel or petrol, and reduce our greenhouse gas emissions. With domestic production they can also be positive for the current account.

The government has decided that a Biofuel Sales Obligation will be set at 3.4 per cent of the annual energy content of total annual petrol and diesel sales by 2012. This initial target is considered sufficient to encourage the uptake of biodiesel and the development of infrastructure for ethanol distribution.

NZPA have just reported the following submission from the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment on Helen’s biofuels legislation:

The Government’s biofuels legislation has been dealt a major blow, with the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment calling for it to be scrapped. …

But Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment Jan Wright today told the committee the bill had major problems and would possibly do more harm than good.

While biofuels had a big advantage over fossil fuels in that they absorbed carbon dioxide while they were growing — potentially lowering their emissions — some had a carbon footprint equal to or higher than fossil fuels due to high emissions from infrastructure and cultivation. …

To meet the mandatory requirements New Zealand would have to import biofuels, which in some cases were worse than fossil fuels.

Ms Wright said the growth of biofuel crops overseas could also result in the felling of forests to free up land and shortages in land for food production that would push up prices disadvantaging the world’s poor.

Ouch. Eight years of huge growth in greenhouse gas emissions, and the Government’s sole response has been we have developed some really good policy.  That policy isn’t looking so flash now.

NZ Blogs on Peter Brown

I thought it would be interesting to see what the most well known political blogs have said on Peter Brown’s atrocious attacks on Asian immigrants.

  1. Kiwiblog – criticised hypocritical Brown
  2. Public Address – no comment
  3. Whale Oil – calls him hypocritical racist
  4. No Right Turn – vile rhetoric
  5. Not PC – labels Brown a bigot
  6. Frog Blog – no comment
  7. The Standard – calls him racist and links to excellent Campbell Live interview
  8. Kiwiblogblog – no comment
  9. The Hive – calls it despicable
  10. Tumeke – Bomber covers issue, negative on Brown

Good to see The Standard joining No Right Turn in attacking Brown, despite Brown’s party supporting the Government on supply and confidence.

NZ First condemned by everyone

People have been expecting NZ First to start bashing Asian immigrants for months, to try and lift their poll ratings like it did in 1996. Peter Brown’s outburst yesterday was not him just thinking aloud, but part of a planned strategy. It had to fall to him, as Winston being Foreign Minister can’t do it directly.  He is now refusing to comment on his own Deputy Leader’s comments.

The EMA Northern have condemned (hat tip: The Hive) NZ First and Brown:

Comments by New Zealand First MP Peter Brown are racial stereotyping of the worst sort, says Alasdair Thompson, chief executive of the Employers & Manufacturers Association (Northern).

“It was post war migrants like Mr Brown who brought here the bigotry of the British class system and a rabid form of unionism,” Mr Thompson said.

“Mr Brown should stop being hypocritical.

And the Auckland Chamber of Commerce weighs in:

“Asian New Zealanders, and those overseas, should see this for what it is: a pathetic piece of political posturing by a minority party.

Hon Chris Carter:

 “I think he’s absolutely being racist,” Carter said. “He shouldn’t be condemning people because of their race or culture.”

Hon Clayton Cosgrove:

 Immigration Minister Clayton Cosgrove told NZPA Mr Brown’s comments were ironic, given that he was a “native born British chap”.

He hoped Mr Brown did not “take his own advice” and return to the UK.

We wait to hear what the Minister of Foreign Affairs and Leader of New Zealand First has to say on the issue.

On a slightly related note, it reminds me of a further Cactus Kate story from Tuesday night. As we were heading along Blair Street, we ran into Keith Ng. Cactus looks at Keith somewhat warily when I mention he blogs for Public Address. I then mention he won a Press Council complaint against Deborah Coddington over her Asian crime story, and Cactus literally leaps forward and embraces Keith in full bear hug, finally releasing him after thanking him for his work.  It was very very funny.

The balloon law

The Electoral Commission met yesterday and released some decisions, and is seeking further information on other cases. What literally had me bursting out with laughter was this statement:

The commission deferred consideration of whether a balloon bearing a party logo and website address was an election advertisement pending Crown Law advice

This is just too funny for words. Crown Law has to give advice on balloons!! Will they be researching overseas precedents concerning balloons? Will they look at other laws around the world which regulate balloons? I mean how will society cope without regulated balloons.

Will Crown Law blow up the balloon, and inspect it from all angles? Will the colour of the balloon be a factor? How about the shape of the balloon? And let us not forget size – at what point does a balloon become a blimp?

The Crown Law advice will normally be signed off by the Solicitor-General. An excellent use of time for the Government’s chief legal advisor!

Audrey Young had referred a number of taxpayer funded items to the Electoral Commission, including said ballons. In their response, they rule:

  1. Labour broke the law with their “We’re making a difference” booklet as it an election advertisement and lacked an authorisation statement. This may mean that the cost of such booklet (despite being paid for by the taxpayer) should be included in Labour’s expenses return.
  2. National’s Blue Green Vision did not break the law, as it was not an election advertisement.
  3. ACT’s “Not your typical party” booklet is an election advertisement, but the lack of authorisation may not have broken the law as it is unsure whether distributing to journalists at a party conference counts as publishing it. Again, this suggests the cost of it should be included in their expense return (less of an issue for ACT as unlikely to reach the $2.4 m limit) unless it qualifies for the parliamentary purposes exemption.
  4. The Labour Party balloon is having advice sought on it

The Electoral Commission decided not to ask the Police to prosecute Labour for their breach of the Electoral Finance Act, and to use it as an educational example. This is a reasonable decision. It does highlight however that Labour have basically broken their own law. They have also been breaking the law by using a non residential address in their authorisation statements.

The issue of the EPMU’s eligibility to be listed as a third party has been decided, but that decision will not be communicated until next week, after it has been written up in full.

Cullen compares NZ journalist to David Irving

The Greens raised in Parliament yesterday the case of Capital Chinese News editor Nick Wang, who had been denied a visa to cover the signing of the China FTA by Helen Clark.

Wang is a critic of China’s policies, and in a shameful display last year was evicted from a press conference hosted by Cullen, after Chinese authorities objected to his presence.

If the Government is willing to let China dictate policy for press conferences in NZ, I suppose it is no surprise they will not object to China setting policy for press conferences in China. Still – would have been nice to at least stand up for the Kiwi journalist.

But instead Dr Cullen says this:

Cullen said: “No New Zealand citizen has a right to enter China. China, like every other country, reserves the right to withhold entry across its own borders.

“New Zealand does exactly the same thing, and indeed this Government … declined to give a visa for the entry into New Zealand of David Irving in the past.”

David Irving is a vile holocaust denier. The comparison of Nick Wang to David Irving is appalling.

SFO Powers

Violent Crime

violent-crime.JPG

The Police released the latest crime statistics this week. I tend to focus on violent and sexual crime for two reasons.  Firstly because it tends to be the most serious and damaging offending. The overall crime rate holds little meaning as very minor offences such as cannabis possession are given the same weight as a serious assault or worse.

The second reason is that violent crimes especially are the most likely to be reported, and less susceptible to changes in policing practice.  Changes in the level of “victimless” crimes are almost totally related to the amount of targeting the Police put into those areas.

There are four distinct trend periods in the graph above.  Firstly violent crime did rise from 1990 to 1994. They were tough times for a number of reasons. But from 1994 to 1999 the level of violent crime basically stayed cnstant, and even declined in terms of the population rate.

Then from 2000 to 2004 there was a modest level of growth in the violent crime level and rate. And from 2004 to 2007 there has been basically massive increases in violent crime levels.  The number of record violent crimes is 44% higher than in 1999, and the rate of violent crime is 32% higher.

Now the Police have said the latest increase is mainly domestic violence, and may be as a result of publicity encouraging greater reporting. I’m somewhat sceptical that an increase in recorded violent crime of 6,250 is solely due to increased reporting than an increased actual level of violent crime.

So let us look at the sub-categories of violent crime and how each has grown in the last year:

  1. Homicides dropped 10 (10%) from 98 to 88. Less full moons last year I guess
  2. Kidnappings dropped 6 (2%) from 263 to 257
  3. Robberies dropped 191 (7%) from 2801 to 2610
  4. Grievous Assaults increased 715 (17%) from 4,116 to 4,831
  5. Serious Assaults increased 2,894 (16%) from 17,729 to 20,623
  6. Minor Assaults increased 1,321 (10%) from 12,700 to 14,021
  7. Intimidations increased 1,410 (11%) from 12,567 to 13,977
  8. Group Assemblies increased 119 (26%) from 457 to 576
  9. Wounding with Intent increased 168 (30%) from 554 to 722
  10. Injuring with Intent increased 182 (20%) from 895 to 1,077
  11. Assaults on Police increased 79 (23%) from 342 to 421

Now remember this is just the increase in the last calendar year – it is not the increase since 1999.

It is worrying that the greatest percentage increases are in the more serious assault categories. And they are the ones most likely to not have been under-reported in the past. Minor assaults may have been not reported as often as they should, but if someone has actually stabbed you with a knife, that tends to get reported I suspect.

Salem Witch Trials

Colin Espiner, Political Editor at The Press, has blogged on an amusing Hollow Man song, but more pointedly on the TVNZ beatup last night, which I blogged on this morning.

Colin takes a similiar view to myself:

On another issue, is anyone else puzzled by TVNZ’s lead story last night? Two National MPs, Lockwood Smith and Maurice Williamson, allegedly don’t “believe” in climate change. What? Quelle horreur! Have them arrested at once! Surely this is a hanging offence now in this country?

For a start, I’d be amazed if the Right-leaning and ultra-dry, cynical and conservative Locky or Maurice did accept the science behind climate change. Not that TVNZ had any proof of this, besides the pair’s refusal to state on the record that they were “believers”.

It has been going around the traps that both MPs have made scoffing noises at a couple of private gatherings about climate change. But so what? Both told TVNZ they accepted and supported National’s party policy, which is that climate change is a real and present danger. So what’s the problem here? I’d be staggered if all 48 National MPs did accept climate change. After all, Key himself is a relatively recent convert.

David Parker, the Minister Responsible for Climate Change Issues, has put out a braying release this morning taunting National for having a couple of MPs with the temerity to suggest his portfolio is not as important as he would think. He should be careful. I’d be equally staggered if every MP in the Labour Party accepted climate change either. In fact, I can think of a couple of names off the top of my head who I’m pretty sure think it’s a load of bunk.

Isn’t it interesting the religious overtones that have crept into this debate? We talk about “believing” in climate change, and having “converted” to it. It’s like a new branch of Scientology.

Personally I accept the weight of scientific opinion that the planet is warming, and that human activity is at least partly responsible. I am, however, unclear as to whether the efforts being made to date to mitigate this are anything more than political tokenism and window-dressing.

I also defend the right of Lockwood Smith and Maurice Williamson to remain dubious about it. I just wish they’d have the guts to say it in public.

Salem witch trials, anyone?

Colin has been blogging for a while now and he is often forthright in putting forward blunt opinions on how he sees things. That’s the whole point of blogging.

What is somewhat noteworthy on this issue, is that the journalist who fronted the TVNZ story is One New Political Editor, Guyon Espiner,. As many know, Guyon and Colin are brothers. Now I don’t point this out to embarrass or cause hassles for either of them. I respect both Espiners for the jobs they do (while reserving the right to criticise on individual stories).

I just think it is a healthy sign that the sibling relationship didn’t stop Colin from stating his disagreement with the TVNZ story. And that is not to suggest that he has done so in the past – it is just the first time I can recall a fairly direct (albeit unnamed) criticism in such a situation.

On the same topic The Greens made some fair and useful points:

Labour’s attacks on John Key and various National MPs for not believing in climate change are interesting, but ultimately a bit of a sideshow. It doesn’t matter whether Cullen and his team believe in climate change or not if their actions are not doing anything to address the problem. Believing is a relatively easy step to take given there is a global scientific consensus that climate change is happening and is caused by humans.

Cullen and Clark can talk about sustainability and carbon neutrality as much as they like, but they are currently responsible for an increase in coal mining, dairy conversions and carbon emissions. Greenpeace says that their own target for the acceptable level of global warming is not low enough. On this issue Labour’s record is not significantly different than National’s.

Indeed. The percentage increase (which Kyoto is based on) of greenhouse gas emissions for NZ under Clark has been higher than for the US under Bush and Australia under Howard.

Hypocrisy Watch

Newstalk ZB reports:

New Zealand First deputy leader Peter Brown has attacked immigration policies due to the estimated increase in the Asian population. …
The Asian population here is set to rise to 790,000 by 2026.

Mr Brown says he is particularly concerned that Asians will outnumber Maori.

He says “it is a bit rich when the original inhabitants get shoved further down the pile because successive governments keep throwing open the doors to this country.”

At this point I should point out Mr Brown is an immigrant.

If he is worried about the original inhabitants getting outnumbered and shoved further down the pile, then he could do his bit to help and return to the UK.

Or is he saying it is a bad thing only when the yellow immigrants are outnumbering Maori, and the white immigrants are okay?

Who stole the Craccums?

A very disturbing story about the theft of 800 copies of Craccum, which featured on TVNZ last night.

One could argue about whether one can steal a free newspaper, but the clear intent of the thieves was to stop people being able to read it, because they objected to some content.

So what was the content objected to? Was it how to kill yourself? Was it about drug rape? Was it how to wip WINZ off? No it was about Falun Gong.

The thieves say they stole the copies because of an advertisement in the magazine promoting people to buy tickets for a dance group that has links to the Falun Gong, the spiritual movement that is outlawed by China’s government.

They say they had asked Craccum to withdraw the advert because they believed it was too political.

“We don’t want to see these advertisements…it does not represent the Chinese people (the dance group) at all,” said Jim Sun, on of the advertisement’s opponent’s.

I think it is incredibly disturbing that a group of (presumably) students would conclude that they have the right to remove content they disapprove of.

Freedom of speech is a fundamental right and if people are not willing to respect the rights of others to advertise a message they do not like, then they should face serious consequences for it.

Threats to freedom of speech are growing. The threats over cartoons, the pressure on Councils to censor, the diplomatic and trade pressure on certain issues have all combined to undermine what is almost the most fundamental right. I value my right to free speech far far more than my right to vote – I only vote once every three years.

One of the ideas I might push at some stage, is whether NZ should have a Free Speech Commissioner.  Yes I know it is part of the Human Rights Commission (and they were admirably strong on the Electoral Finance Bill) but just as you have a dedicated Commissioner sticking up for our rights to privacy, what about a dedicated Commissioner whose job it is to highlight and resist all encroachments on our rights to free speech and rights to access information?

Editorials praise Minister

Tuesday’s Dom Post Editorial praises David Cunliffe for the split of Telecom:

The changes are a credit to Mr Cunliffe, who has done what no communications minister before him has done despite overwhelming evidence that Telecom was using its control of the fixed line network to advantage shareholders and unfairly disadvantage rivals and customers. …

The new board and new chief executive, Paul Reynolds, have adopted a more constructive approach to dealing with other industry players and the Government.

That is a welcome development. But the lesson of the Telecom experiment should never be forgotten.

Governments should not sell monopolies unless they are able to regulate to protect the national interest. The failure of successive governments to do so, has cost consumers hundreds of millions, if not billions, of dollars and set back infrastructural development several years.

And today The Press also devotes an editorial to it:

Telecom had no real choice but to accept the separation agreement, albeit after some to-ing and fro-ing over the detail with David Cunliffe, the Communications Minister. Cunliffe, who is fast emerging as a Cabinet go-getter in both his communications and health portfolios, made it clear that he wanted the agreement with Telecom to be robust and he appears to have achieved this. …

But the separation also presents new opportunities, especially through growth in its wholesale business as new retailers enter the market. If the company can grasp these opportunities, then separation could produce a triple win result, for Telecom, its competitors and, most importantly, for New Zealand consumers.

The editorials speak for themselves.

Surviving Cactus

Cactus Kate has been in town for a couple of days, and has been lots of fun catching up.

I first met Cactus over a decade ago after she went on a Centre of Independent Studies course, along with a couple of friends of mine. I expressed surprise that she didn’t actually hook up with anyone on the CIS course, and she stated that it was because everyone at CIS is far too left wing 🙂

Monday Night was meant to be a catch up with Un-PC Lesbian but she pulled a sickie. Cactus and I consoled ourselves with some nice bottles of Moet down at Concrete. We were later joined by Karen Fuchs and eventually Ten after her prick of a boss allowed her to finish work at 10 pm. I have to say that there are few things as good as decent champagne – not the usual crap which passes for it in NZ.

Eventually dinner seemed a good idea but very little open at 11.30 pm on a Monday night. Eventually went to an Indian restaurant on Courtney Place whose name I can’t remember and whose food was pretty umm about forgettable also.

Tuesday was Cactus’s annual date with her secret Business Roundtable lover. I am their official chaperone. We had a stunning lunch at Shed Five – mainly thanks to the new waiter Scott who was just hilarious. After I took a call from someone, Scott confisicated both my phones for the next two hours and told any callers I was lunching with company and not to be disturbed. He arranged a non stop flow of Moet (Cactus lives off it) and mineral water, and kept us highly entertained. He refused to allow secret lover to have coffee until he had finished his dessert, as it will spoil the taste. The highlight was after we have moved onto cocktails and I had a raspberry Manhattan which didn’t quite work for me, so I left it slightly undrunk. Despite me not complaining, Scott insists on tasting it to check if anything was wrong, and it was priceless as his face screwed up and he loudly proclaimed the cocktail as disgusting and undrinkable, and he went off to the bar to point out you put raspberry not cherry into that particular cocktail. Scott was great and made the lunch a great success, on top of the excellent food.

Cactus then put on her union president hat for her Fairfax meeting, and we caught up after that at Monsoon Poon – always a good reliable choice. It was packed full, so we ended up dining up at the bar, which of course suited us fine.

Fortunately for my continued good health, Cactus flies out this evening, but we do have lunch with Parliament’s second most famous blogging MP today, after he wouldn’t miss a few unimportant votes last night to join us.

UPDATE: For the benefits of all the wives and existing mistresses of Business Roundtable members, I will clarify that if Cactus did have a secret BRT lover, I would not be blogging about it here! It is just carrying on a joke I made last February and carried on as to my delight I was asked by journalists last week in Auckland if it was true Cactus was having umm relations with a member of that fine body. Mind you I do hear she is preparing an application as to why she should be hired as their intern 🙂

English flys King over Electoral Law breaches

NZPA reports on a flaying Bill English gave Annette King in the House yesterday over breaches of the Electoral Finance Act – they’re all being done by the three main parties which voted for it.

Keeping Stock has the exchange from Hansard – go read the whole thing.

A further example that Bill didn’t even use was the launch of the Tongan branch of Labour a few days ago.  Huge banners supporting Labour on the TV news, and no authorisation statement on them at all, plus other electoral breaches.

Also very amusing to see Winston trying to help Annette out. Winston, whose was so outraged that the media asked questions over his secret donations to charities (instead of the taxpayer), that he has now directly threatened the media with a review of media ownership laws.

Such a good look to have a senior Minister threaten the media with a change to media ownership laws, because they question him in a way he does not like.

Zimbabwe Results

It’s taking Robert Mugabe a long time to rig the results of the Zimbabwe elections. He used to be far more efficient at it, and do it within a day.  Now we are up to three days and no results.

How can any results be credible?

I loved the line from the Mugabe Ambassador to the UN:

A Zimbabwe diplomat told CNN the delay in releasing the presidential results is simply to ensure every vote is counted.

Indeed, but first they have to create all the extra votes for Mugabe, so they can count them. And it is a new system of counting votes that you only give out a total at the end, rather than any progress results.

Government to gut Serious Fraud Office powers

A total beatup on One News last night

I don’t think I have seen a bigger beatup than what One News led with last night. It was puerile and almost offensive as they demanded two National MPs bow down and answer questions on their personal views on global warming.

Let us first start with some known political reality. On every single issue that a party decides policy on, there are a range of views within Caucus. Sir Keith Holyoake is on the record as saying that even as PM, he only personally agreed with 80% of what his Government did.  This is the nature of collective decision making and compromise.

Does every National MP support the silly ban on party pills? Absolutely not. But they decided as a caucus to support the Government’s legislation. Does every Labour MP support the ban? Again, absolutely not.

It is absolutely routine and everyday that MPs have private views, which are sceptical or different to a party’s policy. It is impossible to imagine otherwise – MPs are not clones.

It is absolutely no surprise that some National MPs are sceptical of the extent of global warming. But as Williamson and Smith said last night, they are committed to the party’s policy to reduce emissions through an emissions trading scheme.  That is what matters. If National is elected, they will be judged on their record with policy and actual emissions (and let us face it can hardly have a worse emissions record than Labour has had).
Let us look at a comparison for another party. Labour (like National on Kyoto) have recently done a policy change.  For Labour it was on tax cuts.  After years of opposing them and even hiking taxes, they have as a party adopted a policy of lowering personal tax rates.

Now is there anyone dumb enough to think that every single Labour MP genuinely believes that lowering personal tax rates is a good thing (as oppossed to a politically desirable thing). Of course not – there isn’t a chance in hell. Good God they have spent years demonising tax cuts.

But Labour as a Caucus, have decided to implement tax cuts, and hence their MPs are committed to voting for them.

So why has One News not furiously chased down Labour MPs and asked them to all state on camera what their *personal* views are on reducing taxes? Not, whether or not they support what their party’s policy is, but whether they personally think tax cuts are more desirable than increased spending?

OOXML approved

Chris Auld has the results of the international standards meeting on Open Office XML (OOXML), and reports it has been overwhelmingly approved.

I doubt many have followed this debate, but it has to some degree become a proxy (even though it shouldn’t have been) for Microsoft vs open source and a closely followed issue by many of the IT industry. The very simple explanation is it was about whether one needed to have OOXML adopted as a standard when there was already an open source ODF standard. There were strong arguments both ways.

An unofficial tally as the following votes cast:

Approve

  1. Azerbaijan
  2. Cote-d’Ivore
  3. Cyprus
  4. Czech Republic
  5. Denmark
  6. Finland
  7. Germany
  8. Ireland
  9. Japan
  10. Jamaica
  11. Kazakhstan
  12. Lebanon
  13. Malta
  14. Norway
  15. Pakistan
  16. Saudi Arabia
  17. Singapore
  18. Slovenia
  19. South Korea
  20. Switzerland
  21. Trinidad and Tobago
  22. United Kingdom
  23. USA
  24. Uruguay

Disapprove

  1. Canada
  2. China
  3. Ecuador
  4. India
  5. Iran
  6. New Zealand
  7. South Africa
  8. Venezuela

Abstain

  1. Australia
  2. Belgium
  3. France
  4. Italy
  5. Kenya
  6. Malaysia
  7. Netherlands
  8. Spain
  9. Turkey

There has been some ferocious (and controversial) lobbying around this vote, plus one should acknowledge a lot of work to improve the OOXML standard from the previous version which was rejected.

This means Open XML now joins HTML, PDF and ODF as ISO- and IEC-recognized open document format standards.

For those worried about the future of ODF, I found a useful read this blog post giving ten reasons why ODF will not be greatly impacted by the adoption of OOXML. The author was against OOXML being approved, but doesn’t think in the end it will reverse the momentum ODF has.

The Standard on Real Wages

The Standard has done a post with a graph showing purported real average weekly earnings from 1990 to 2007.

In 1990 dollars it shows real average weekly earnings staying constant from 1990 to 1999, and then increasing from around $465 a week to $510 a week from 2000 to 2007. They conclude average weekly earnings under Labour increased at 30 times the rate of National.

But it is very very hard to verify the data for their graph. They do not state what the source of their data is. I’ve gone back to an old data series done by the Parliamentary Library (who are neutral) and verified it with the Stats NZ data in the quarterly employment survey.  It is very different to what The Standard claims. Now this maybe because they are using a different data series, but again with no reference I don’t know. I would welcome their clarification and posting of full data, as I have done.

Below I show the following data. The ordinary time average weekly earnings from the quarterly employment survey (series SBAZ9A), the CPI, the real average earnings and the real after tax average earnings. The Standard did not provide after tax figures, but I provide both before and after tax figures for people to do a full comparison.

Jun 90 – $502.95 av earnings, CPI 716, $502.95 real av earnings, $385.81 real av after tax earnings.

Jun 99 – $639.96 av earnings, CPI 832, $550.73 real av earnings, $436.78 real av after tax earnings.

Jun 07 – $846.19 av earnings, CPI 1020, $593.99 real av earnings, $459.32 real av after tax earnings.

Now one is over nine years, and one is over eight years.  If you divide the increase by the number of years you get the average annual increase in real ordinary time weekly earnings as $5.31 from 1990 to 1999, and $5.41 from 1999 to 2007.

And if you look at the average annual increase in real ordinary after tax earnings, then the increase is $5.66 from 1990 to 1999 and $2.82 from 1999 to 2007.

So on the Stats NZ figures, average real weekly ordinary time earnings increased by almost exactly the same annual amount from Jun 90 t0 Jun 99 and Jun 99 to Jun 07. And if you take into account tax, the increase was twice as high in the earlier time period.

Again, if The Standard can provide their full data and reference sources, I would be happy to try and work out why the data is so different.  I did look through many other data series in the QES to try and reverse engineer a series which fitted their data, but there didn’t seem an obvious one that fitted.

Revised Poll Results

I revised the blog poll results this evening, to delete any obvious multiple votes. The changes were:

  • National: 192 – 2 = 190
  • Labour: 654 – 610 = 44
  • Maori Party: 18 – 12 = 6
  • ACT: 92 – 15 = 77
  • NZ First: 4 – 0 = 4
  • United Future: 31 – 3 = 28
  • Kiwi Party: 92 – 26 = 66
  • Greens: 681- 645 = 36
  • Progressive: 3 – 0 = 3
  • Libertarianz: 5 – 0 = 5
  • Others: 4 – 0 = 4

Remember it is just a fun poll!

The day the tax cuts never arrived

The real April Fool’s trick today is the one played by Dr Cullen on us in 2005.

In the 2005 election year budget Dr Cullen announced that for the first time, he would lower personal taxes, to take effect from 1 April 2008.

He lied.

He cancelled them last year, despite massive surpluses.

Today is the day when for the first time since 1998, people would have ended up with a reduction in tax on their earnings. But it was just a cruel April Fool’s hoax.

Will we be fooled again?

Business Confidence crashing

The National Bank has released its latest monthly business confidence results and it is not pretty:

This month’s National Bank business confidence survey makes for grim reading. A net 58 percent of businesses expect business conditions to deteriorate over the coming year. This is down from 44 percent reported last month. Confidence is weaker across all the five major subgroups: retailing, manufacturing, agriculture, construction and services.

Firm’s expectations towards their own business has now turned negative, the first time since early 2006. A net 6 percent of businesses expect a deterioration in their own business over the coming year. Firm’s own activity expectations are seldom negative. Negative reads in firm’s own activity expectations have only been recorded 12 times in the 20-year history of the survey. Five of these were right at the start of the survey in 1988, as the 1987 crash washed through. The last time we saw firm’s own activity expectations this weak was in 1991.

Also National Bank needs to be a finalist for the 2008 spin awards with this line:

While recessionary fears are percolating, we prefer to characterise such challenging times as entering a stage of deferred achievement.

Ha. Watch Dr Cullen grab this line. It is not a recession, just a period of deferred growth 🙂