Glenn hints he was NZ First donor

Audrey Young has updated her blog (no wonder Helen does not like journalists who blog) and has said:

Glenn’s response to my questions about whether he was the sources have come via Steve Fisher at Baldwin Boyle PR firm in Auckland who spoke with Glenn this afternoon.

“He had absolutely nothing to do with any monetary offer to the Maori Party, nothing to do with it at all,” Fisher said. “As far as New Zealand First is concerned, he said to go and talk to them.”

When I said I had talked to president Dail Jones and that he didn’t know, he said Glenn was aware of that but alluded to the fact that the party was trying to track down leader Winston Peters in Africa.

It was simple enough for Glenn to deny he was behind the Maori Party offer, and that is totally accepted.

It would have been simple enough to deny he had donated to New Zealand First.

The fact that he didn’t suggests that he did. He just thinks it is up to Peters to say.

This is huge.  The hypocrisy, if correct, is of monumental proportions.

The Electoral Commission should also be very concerned if NZ First’s view (under the old Electoral Act 1993) of an anonymous donaton is one in which the Leader negotiates or is informed of the donation, but he simply doesn’t tell the President.

And how credible is it that a Party President would receive an anonymous donation and not ask the Leader if he knows anything at all about it – especially when he says he was so curious he even asked the bank to trace it?

Dinner in Auckland

I am up in Auckland from Thursday evening to Sunday afternoon.  I am part of a panel speaking on media and public policy to a Business Roundtable retreat on Friday.

I arrive up 7 pm Thursday, and a few friends and fellow VRWC bloggers are keen to do dinner that evening – probably at 8 pm.  If you want to come along, drop me an e-mail so we can book for the right number.

Nice Cartoon

Did Glenn bail out Winston?

There have long been rumours that Owen Glenn bailed out the NZ First Party with the $158,000 they owe (and still owe) the taxpayer.  When I referred to the rumours on ZB yesterday even Larry sounded nervous, but I made it very clear that there is no proof at all that Glenn has donated to them, but likewise it has never been denied and Glenn is on the record as having donated to more than one party.

Audrey Young’s blog post today is potentially explosive. She reveals that NZ First did receive a large donation in December last year:

Jones told the Herald this morning the sum was between $10,000 and $100,000.” but added: “It is probably closer to $100,000.”

This it seems was an anonymous donation, made a few days before the Electoral Finance Act came in.  NZ First has railed against anon donations, voted for a law to stop them, while banking a huge one themselves.

If Owen Glenn is the donor, and nothing short of a on the record denial is satisfactory now, then this casts a whole new light on it.  The scenario you have is Winston being wined and dined by the man who has saved his party from financial ruin, while pledging to work to get him a Government appointment as Honorary Consul.

Audrey Young also thinks Glenn should have to now deny on the record whether or not he is the man the Maori Party referred to:

It is hard to get through to Glenn to ask him directly – and while we are at it, to ask him whether he was the wealthy Labour backer living overseas who, according to Maori Party co-leader Tariana Turia, offered the Maori Party $250,000 at the last election to go with Labour.

Indeed.

Dail Jones says he has no idea where they money came from.  He says he even asked the bank to trace it but they refused.  Did he ask Winston if he knows?

Fascinating press releases

NZPA is most well known for the stories written by its staff that appear in various newspapers. But they also have a press release service known as mediacom, where companies and pr agencies send a press release to NZPA and they forward it on to media outlets.

Now in recent days they have extended this to some online media, including myself. So I now get press releases from various companies, if they are in areas I have marked as of interest. Now I’m not sure what category of interest I had selected for this press release I received today, but it was interesting:

BRISBANE, Feb. 19 /Medianet International-AsiaNet/ —

The days of outsized frumpiness are gone. Thanks to Big Girls Don’t Cry Anymore, fuller figured women now have the choice of a huge variety of fashionable and feminine lingerie, right up to an L cup.

An L cup?? I have heard of E and F cups, but an L cup sounds like a lifetime of backpain. How big is an L cup?

Well Wikipedia comes to the rescue. It seems an L cup using the US/Europe standard (an HH in Australia and the UK) is when the bust is 12 inches larger than the underbust. For comparison a D is 4 inches longer.

For more information about the Big Girls Don’t Cry Anymore and their products and fittings, or to request a free catalogue please call them on + 61 7 3257 1644 or visit www.biggirls.com.au.

Incidentally while many probably always thing bigger is better, I have a few friends with DD or larger cups and almost without exception they would like them reduced – both because of the medical problems it can give them, but also the hassle with clothes.

Well done Peter

Like many, I was sceptical of Peter Dunne’s last minute vote change against the Electoral Finance Act.  After voting with the Government on every single vote and amendment, it seemed he voted against for pragmatic reasons (knew it would pass without him) and still seemed to support the law – just said that NZers were so worked up about it he was respecting their wishes.

I know Peter’s office were not happy he still featured on one of our billboards (albeit it with his name crossed out and the Greens written in), after he voted against at third reading.

But today Peter Dunne said in a speech:

Last year, UnitedFuture learned a powerful lesson – via the medium of the Electoral Finance Bill – about listening to the community.

Let me say this as I clearly as I can: we were wrong to support that legislation for as long as we did, and while I am pleased we eventually came to our senses and opposed the Bill, it remains one of my greatest regrets in politics that we misread the situation for so long.

But we have learned our lesson as a consequence – we will listen to the voice of New Zealanders far more closely in future, and then we will act accordingly.

We will undoubtedly disagree from time to time – I am not suggesting we should become a blank piece of paper to be written all over as the mood suits – but as best we can, we will redouble our commitment to put the public interest ahead of that of party or government.

I can’t say how much this statement pleases me.  People may still doubt the sincerity of it, but I am taking it at face value and believe it is a genuine expression of Peter’s views on the issue.

Rudman blames C&R for selecting dying candidate

Aaron Bhatnagar has attacked City Vision for selecting a member of a community board for the Council by-election to replace Linda Leighton, as if their candidate wins it will trigger a coummunity board by-election which will cost $40K on top of the $90K for this by-election.

Brian Rudman claims this is hypocrisy as C&R are to blame for the $90K cost by selecting a gravely ill candidate who was unlikely to last the full term in office.

My first reaction is I wouldn’t want to be the person who tells a candidate they we have decided they can’t stand for office because we are worried we will be criticised for the cost of the by-election to replace them when they die.

On the other hand if it was known her life expectancy was weeks rather than months, then one can argue the decision wasn’t the most prudent.  However my experience with cancer sufferers is that sometimes they live on for months and even years past their expected prognosis.

Indeed since I started writing this, Aaron has blogged that it was only after the election that Leighton started to seriously deteriorate.

Pacific Party

Taito Phillip Field has applied to register his Christian and family values based Pacific Party.  This area is getting pretty crowded. I thought that the demise of Christian Heritage would clear things up, but the field is getting crowded. Who do we have:

  1. United Future – not very united now, and has lost the mob that made up the Future part. Peter Dunne has always stated his party is not a Christian party (and now the Christian wing has defected this is basically correct), but they are still probably competing to some degree for the family values voters.
  2. The Family Party – Destiny in drag. Think of a Christian version of sharia law 🙂
  3. The Kiwi Party – basically the breakaway faction from United Future – former Christian Democrats
  4. Pacific Party – Taito Philip Field’s enterprise – we can expect them to at least have a novel policy for housing affordability – have grateful migrants work for free on your houses!

That’s a lot of parties competing for 7% or so.  Dunne will be back, but uncertain whether he will even have a second MP.

A Maori Party roleplay

The Herald reports Maori Party MP Te Ururoa Flavell has said “police and their political masters” appear to be waging a campaign against the people of Ruatoki.

Now the Maori Party could well help decide who forms the next Government – even more likely if they increase their number of electorate seats from four (and I think they are presently looking good for at leats five).

While there will be many policy areas both National and Labour can work with them on, this is a useful reminder that there will be a number of areas where Maori Party MPs will say something that is highly controversial or adversarial.  And if you are in coalition with the Maori Party, then you may get caught in the debate over their comments and/or behaviour – as happened to National with NZ First in 1996.

At some quiet stage this year, National might be well advised to put aside a few hours and do at least a mental roleplay on how they would handle various situations – if after the election they are in coalition with the Maori Party, or some other form of agreement.  The results of such an exercise could help consideration of what sort of relationship would be best.

Questions I would start thinking about are, what would be the reaction of Prime Minister John Key to:

  1. One of his Ministers joining a protest march against Government policy in a particular area
  2. A Maori Party MP calling the Police racist
  3. A Maori Party Minister or MP referring to a visiting head of state/govt as a colonising bastard or some such

Do you refuse to comment?  Do you just say we agree to disagree? Do you hope the media don’t ask you?

I don’t write this to suggest National should not seek the support of the Maori Party after the next election.  I actually want National to seek the support of all parties (except Labour) – even if they do not need their numbers to form a Government.

But National should be aware dealing with the Maori Party won’t be the same as with United Future (for example).  There are issues so dear and passionate to Maori Party MPs they would put their rights to speak up on those issues as far more important than being in Cabinet, or keeping the Government in office.  So one needs to think about what sort of situations may arise, and how best to deal with them so you don’t have headlines such as “Ministers calls his own Government racist, PM won’t comment”.

In one sense it is a “nice” problem to have (means you are in Govt) and only one should worry about after the election.  And while I generally agree planning to win the election should be by far the main focus over how to govern after the election – spending a bit of time thinking about these issues in advance could save a lot of grief later.

Armstrong and Brown on Glenn

Russell Brown’s blog on the Owen Glenn issue is pretty fair.  One conclusion:

The nub of the story is the interest free loan of $100,000 he revealed he had made to Labour after the last election. Actually, not even the loan: but the fact that Labour Party president Mike Williams did not mention it when questioned by reporters last month.

The fact that the part of the loan that could be considered a donation — the $7000 or so interest foregone — fell below the declaration threshold under the old electoral laws does not matter. Williams misled journalists, and that very rarely ends well.

John Armstrong counts the cost:

It is the interest-free loan that has turned out to be far from interest-free. Labour may have benefited financially from Owen Glenn’s generosity. But the party is sure as heck paying an exorbitant rate of interest in political terms.

Despite getting the $100,000 interest-free loan on top of $500,000 in donations from the expat businessman, Labour must have been asking itself in recent days whether its association with the billionaire philanthropist has been worth the hassle.

I said something similiar on radio yesterday -Glenn has gone from their saviour to a walking disaster zone for them.

The party will have been pondering that question even more intently following the drubbing it received at the hands of National in Parliament yesterday.

The trouncing was almost complete before Justice Minister Annette King described Bill English as “Mr Nasty”. But that sealed victory for the Opposition.

When a minister as experienced and normally dominant on the parliamentary stage as King resorts to name-calling to avoid answering a question from an opponent, that is as close to an admission of defeat as you are going to get.

Indeed.  And I still maintain the Speaker should not have allowed that as an acceptable response.

Fran on Housing Affordability

Olympic sense

Good to see the NZOC and Government are backing down on the muzzling of NZ atheletes, with a proposed change to their contracts. I think this would have become very very damaging for the Govt if there had not been a backdown.

I agree with Keith Locke that the section banning atheletes from writing blogs should also be removed – the Australians have no restriction he points out.

The Silly Party has a name

Former blogger Andrew Falloon has won the Trade Me auction to name the Silly Party, and the name is:

The thornDon liberAtion movement oF the socialisT custard party

This will be a superb name to have on the ballot papers.

The DAFT party has also got some further policies

  • Free tertiary education in return for students working ten hours a week in a state owned vice enterprises
  • All student debt will be transferred to a private company which will then declare bankruptcy
  •  Ashburton will be pillaged by members of the DAFT Party on 20 May 2008 – residents are invited to join in.

NRT on Owen Glenn

NRT smells something nasty in relation to the Monaco consul offer:

This stinks, even worse than Glenn being awarded a gong in the New Year’s honours list. “Honorary consul” isn’t much – I’m not sure if it even comes with a salary – but by even contemplating awarding such a position to their biggest donor, the government has created the impression that government office is for sale in this country. And in doing so, they’ve instantly dragged us back to the institutionalised corruption and patronage of the eighteenth century. FFS, that’s what the Americans do, and we ought to at least think we’re better than them.

Unless the Government is suicidal, I suspect they will not now be appointing him Honorary Consul. And to be fair, he have no one to blame but himself.  Glenn has transformed himself over a few days from Labour’s saviour to Labour’s walking cluster bomb.

Addressing the Question

I know Ministers only have to address the question, not answer it the way the MP asking wants, but really the answer should have some small relevance to the question.  Look at what Margaret Wilson now deems acceptable. Hansard yesterday:

Hon Bill English: Given her view, stated to this House, that an interest-free loan is, in fact, a donation, does she believe that the comment made by the president of the Labour Party after Owen Glenn received his New Year’s honour, saying that Mr Glenn had not made a donation was misleading, and probably deliberately misleading?

Hon ANNETTE KING: My name is not “Mr Nasty”, like that member’s; he is always throwing insults around people. To say that people deliberately mislead is not something I am going to comment on.

Gerry Brownlee: I raise a point of order, Madam Speaker. [Interruption]

Madam SPEAKER: Points of order are heard in silence.

Gerry Brownlee: Do you seriously consider that that was an answer to the question, or even an attempt to address it? She simply said: “My name is not ‘Mr Nasty’ ”. Perhaps she would like to tell us what her middle name is, inside the Labour Party?

Madam SPEAKER: I would say, Mr Brownlee, that that is an entirely inappropriate comment to direct to the Speaker. The Minister was asked for her opinion. She gave it. It may not be satisfactory to the member, but that is what the Standing Orders permit.

One of these new standards of Ministerial accountability that was promised. At least the PM is somewhat more forthcoming in her question:

 John Key: Was she or any other Minister present at the Cabinet committee aware that Mr Glenn had loaned the Labour Party $100,000 after the 2005 election, when they made the decision to recommend him for the honour?

Rt Hon HELEN CLARK: I certainly was but, of course, the honour was made irrespective of such factors.

Great – a straight answer. But look at the dodge in this question:

John Key: How did the Prime Minister become aware of Mr Glenn’s interest in the honorary consul position; was it because the matter was raised directly with her by Mr Glenn, or was his request relayed to her by Labour Party President, Mike Williams?

Rt Hon HELEN CLARK: Certainly there has been no conversation by me with Mr Glenn on this matter. I am aware that he has had breakfast with Mr Peters and it has been discussed. Where in the ether it came to me I do not know.

Note she has not ruled out that it was Mike Williams, the person who collects Glenn’s cheques, who raised the issue with her.  She just can not remember at all who told her about it.

Is this the same Miss Clark who was so scathing of Jenny Shipley when Mrs Shipley said she couldn’t recall something, under questioning? Her forgetfulness is so strange for someone normally renowned for an encyclopaedic recall of issues, policies and people.

Eternal Cat Nap

Condolences to Murray, whose faithful companion and cat, Jessica, has had to be put down.

It is amazing how strong the bond is between pets and their owners/staff.  I still think sometimes about our two former family cats – one of them lived to well past 20 which wasn’t bad, but still very sad.

Is this New Zealand?

The SST reports on the new law for the Rugby World Cup:

Officials will be allowed to enter private land and buildings if they are clearly visible from a clean zone.

Government enforcement officers can obtain search warrants to enter private property during clean periods and seize or cover up offending advertising. Police or enforcement officers accompanied by police officers can use any force that is “reasonable in the circumstances” to gain entry or break open any article.

Individuals wearing a rival company’s logo or slogan on clothes or shoes would not be prosecuted if they acted alone, although they could be if they acted in co-ordination with other people and intended to get the attention of event-goers.

An Economic Development Ministry spokesperson said it was likely groups wearing clothes advertising a rival company would be asked to leave a clean zone although they could be told to remove their clothing if they refused.

Good God, and I think both National and Labour voted for this law. So if you are sitting in your balcony on your Tui couch with your DB shirt or hat on, government officials will be able to break into your house, forcibly undress you and seize your clothes and probably your couch also.

I think a degree of overkill has happened.

Castro Resigns

New phones

I have a new cordless phone and a new mobile phone – but for different reasons.

My cordless phone at home is so old the battery now lasts only 15 minutes or so if speaking on it, and only a few hours away from the cradle without use.  Even worse when it decides to die it gives, oh somewhere between a millisecond and a nanosecond of warning.  So I am talking to someone, and then click and I am gone.  It used to beep for 30 seconds before dying.

So long overdue for the new cordless phone.

The mobile phone replacement is for a different reason.  I left my phone charger in India (for my Telecom Nokia, not my Vodafone Blackberry).  Now I could have purchased a new power cord, but I was past my contracted period and could upgrade my phone for free, so I did.  I had actually been putting off doing so for the best part of a year, so it was a good catalyst.

The very old Nokia 3865 (I think I had it when I left Parliament in 2004) is replaced with an Okta Mondo. It is very nice – good graphics, sensible menus and does everything I need.  The Blackberry does e-mail and calendar so just needed a phone mainly for calls and text.

At the Orb store, on Lampton Quay, the assistant’s business card said “Daniel Williams, Clued Up Sales Guy” which made me laugh.  But he was.  He was great at picking a phone and a plan, knowing the discounts, roaming everything.  Can highly recommend the store at 108 Lambton Quay.

In a blast from the past, the manager (Dave M) remembered me from ten years ago, 1998, when he supplied me with around 100 pagers.  I’d almost forgotten about them and what a fuss they were, until he reminded me.

In 1998, text messaging was not known (or widely known) and a Minister reported on how in the UK Tony Blair used pagers to communicate messages of the day to all his MPs. It was decided that the ability to send a short message to all MPs, key staff, and candidates would be highly useful, so I was given the job.  Was a logistical semi-nightmare purchasing and setting up 100 pagers – esp as some were billed to Min Servs, some to Parl Serv and some to National itself.

I recall having to do a training session in Caucus on how to use them (not hard- read and delete messages, plus noise and vibrate modes).  Quite amusing to see 44 MPs all jump off their chairs in unison as they got vibrated for the first time. One of the female MPs asked where she was meant to carry hers, or what to attach it to, and Jenny Shipley wittily replied that she should do what she does, and get Peter (her SPS) to carry it for her.

Everyone was all so excited over these wonderful pagers and we had a group number (which was a closely guarded secret) which would allow the same message to be sent to all 100 pagers (remember tech then was limited).  I was always tempted to  play a joke one day and send them all a message alone the lines of “Ring the PM’s Chief of Staff now over your comments in the media” – would have caused multiple nervous breakdowns.

Some messages were dememed too sensitive for even a Telecom operator to be told, so I had special software installed on my computer which would allow me to tap directly into the Telecom network and send a message directly to one or more pagers.  At the time this was seen as a wonderful innovation.  And for 1998/1999 it was bloody useful.  When a scandal broke we could tell people not to comment, or tell them the approved line.  We also would remind people of the major issue of the day to push with media.  And the good thing with being a pager is no MP or candidate could credibly claim they didn’t get the message.

The irony is we spent all this money on pagers, yet within a few years they were basically ancient technology as cellphone text messaging caught on, and it was realised that is just as convenient as a pager, and a lot cheaper. So somewhere in Parliament probably there is a large box of unwanted unloved pagers rusting away.

Owen’s still waiting for his Monaco bauble

Owen Glenn says he has been promised the NZ consulship to Monaco, and is in a hurry for it. The NZ Herald reports:

Labour’s biggest donor, expatriate businessman Owen Glenn, says the Government is planning to make him New Zealand’s honorary consul in Monaco, if Foreign Minister Winston Peters signs it off.

Mr Glenn said Prime Minister Helen Clark had approved it and had told Mr Peters to “get on with it”.

…The Herald had been asking about his living in Monaco and he replied: “The Government is planning to make me the consul-general [honorary consul] of Monaco.”

He added: “If Winston ever gets off his arse – you can print that!”

Hmmn, one certainly has to credit Mr Glenn with a sense of humour – he obviously follows the news and read the story about Chester Borrows note to Winston in the House.

Mr Glenn said he had met Mr Peters for breakfast in Paris during the Rugby World Cup.

He said it might be presumptuous of him to say he was going to get the job, “because if they haven’t followed through, maybe they have changed their mind, but they haven’t said anything”.

“It’s up to Winston. He’s Foreign Minister.”

Mr Glenn gave Labour $500,000 before the 2005 election and it was revealed only last week that after the election he also gave it an interest-free $100,000 loan that has since been repaid.

I can almost hear the whooshing sound of OIAs galore being filed with Winston and MFAT, asking for documents relating to the proposed appointment.

Media Readership in 2007

Various media chains have been trumpeting the results of the latest readership surveys. Of course they quote the most favourable so the only way to get a real view of what is happening is go to to the source data at AC Nielsen.

First let us look at the newspapers, for the metro dailies in order of largest percentage increase down:

  1. The Press up 4.5% from 223,000 to 233,000
  2. NZ Herald up 3.0% from 568,000 to 585,000
  3. Waikato Times up 1.1% from 94,000 to 95,000
  4. ODT down 3.6% from 111,000 to 107,000
  5. Dom Post down 3.6% from 253,000 to 244,000

And for the three Sunday newspapers:

  1. Herald on Sunday up 5.8% from 326,000 to 345,000
  2. Sunday Star-Times down 2.9% from 577,000 to 560,000
  3. Sunday News down 11.2% from 376,000 to 334,000

And looking at some of the magazines:

  1. National Business Review up 12.0% from 92,000 to 104,000
  2. The Listener up 3.9% from 284,000 to 295,000
  3. Computerworld up 2.8% from 36,000 to 37,000
  4. Investigate down 1.5% from 68,000 to 67,000
  5. North & South down 2.4% from 297,000 to 290,000
  6. Independent Financial Review down 13.9% from 36,000 to 31,000
  7. Metro down 16.4% from 152,000 to 127,000
  8. Netguide down 24.8% from 137,000 to 103,000

The magazine changes make some sense to me.  I think NBR has had a very good year – required reading on Fridays.  Metro has been in real trouble and it shows and Netguide is long gone from the must read to learn something cool category.

The one that surprises me somewhat is the Independent Financial Review.  It is sometimes light on quantity, but has some very good stories and analysis.

I’ve also resubscribed to The Listener this year.  I really get it for the columns rather than the articles but some of the columns are addictive.

Derek the Fox

My goodness, no wonder his nickname is Derek the Fox.

His partner of 12 years, Atareta Poananga, dumps him because he is seeking the nomination for  the Maori Party for Ikaroa-Rawhiti, and so is she. She talks about this on radio yesterday with Willie Jackson.

This, it seems, comes as a surprise to his other partner for the last seven years – Jaewynn McKay.

Derek may be banished from the hen house!

Dom Post on UK and Sharia Law

The Dominion Post (very justifiably) takes Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams to task for his comments that the UK should officially sanctions aspects of sharia law:

Apart from the fact that, when congregations in many mainstream churches are falling, Dr Williams’ comments were singularly wounding to the Anglican Church, they were also unacceptable. He might have been motivated by the best of intentions – he is, perhaps, understandably unsettled by the practical consequences of Britain’s open-door policy – but his sentiments were wrong-headed and unhelpful.

The message they sent is that it is okay for various communities within the British Isles to hope to be bound by different laws.

A democracy is predicated on one law for all. End of story. If some British citizens – maybe newer ones from non-Western nations – do not like the laws and mores of the country to which they have emigrated or that has given them sanctuary, they do not have to stay. They should not expect their new host to subjugate its own traditions to accommodate all the devotees of faith.

Expressed bluntly, but absolutely correctly.

Britain – like New Zealand – is a secular country. It would be unsurprising if immigrants from theistic regimes found it hard to appreciate what they might perceive as civic indifference to religion in a society ruled by laws, not their particular holy book.

Democracies ideally embrace freedom and tolerance in allowing individuals to practise their faith – or not. The obverse of that compact, however, is that minorities who cleave to one god or another do not expect the wider society in which they operate to alter its very foundations to adapt to what most regard as a private matter.

Indeed.  People can be scientologists, or Buddhists or Destiny adherents – whatever they want.  They can personally practice their beliefs within the law of the land.  But the basis of a secular state is you do not change your laws just to reflect the beliefs of one particular version of God.

Would Britain allow polygamy to a, say, growing fundamentalist Mormon citizenry? Of course not. Neither should it.

Actually, the sad reality is they are supporting it for 1,000 or so families in the UK – the new social welfare guidelines state:

“Where there is a valid polygamous marriage the claimant and one spouse will be paid the couple rate (£92.80).

“The amount payable for each additional spouse is presently £33.65.”

Income support for all of the wives may be paid directly into the husband’s bank account, if the family so choose.

Back to the editorial:

Prime Minister Gordon Brown and the other inhabitants of Westminster, however, might find themselves in a difficult position here, despite their criticism of the archibishop’s misguided musings. Britain reportedly already allows Orthodox Jews to resolve disputes under traditional Jewish law. That might well make denying Muslims similar licence some time in the future much harder.

Equally unwelcome, if this means that this dispute resolution scheme has a special status in law.  Any two or more people are welcome to voluntarily resolve a dispute through non legal means.  But it can not take away their rights to the courts.

… New Zealand should be prepared should someone as clumsy as Dr Williams suggest a similar acceptance of parts of Sharia or other faith-based law here. Such advocacy is not inconceivable, given the number of Kiwis fleeing and that our population is being bolstered by migrants, often from non-Western traditions. If we will not agree, for good reason, to tinorangitiratanga for tangata whenua, whose claims to special treatment are greater than any other community’s, no government ought to countenance particular laws for anyone else.

Indeed.  Bad enough we have a blasphemous libel law – let us not introduce any more laws that undermine our secular state.

The Press on Glenn donation

The Press’ editorial focuses on Owen Glenn’s loan to Labour:

Now Glenn has acknowledged that he made a substantial interest-free loan to Labour last year, which would have come in handy as the party struggled to pay off its sizeable pledge-card bill. There is nothing illegal or unethical about the loan itself, which has since been paid back, but it is still embarrassing for Labour.

Its difficulty stems from the reported comment of its president, Mike Williams, just after the Honours list was released, that Glenn had not given a donation to the party since the 2005 election. At the very least Labour has benefited financially from the interest it would normally have had to pay on a $100,000 loan, so it is splitting hairs to say that no donation had been made.

In addition to revealing last year’s loan, Glenn also claimed that Clark had told him that he would be a “sitter” for the post of transport minister. The claim is far-fetched, as giving Glenn a safe party list position and a seat at Cabinet would be rightly seen as a pay-off for favours done. If Clark did mention a Cabinet post, it is far more likely she was joking.

The broader problem for Labour is that its secret loan from Glenn is contrary to the spirit of the Government’s own Electoral Finance Act. The legislation is deeply flawed, notably with respect to the harsh regime governing third-party lobby groups during election year, but the act did at least promise to make party financing more transparent.

I’m still waiting for Glenn to clarify why he claimed the Brethren campaign motivated him to donate to Labour, when this occurred 10 months after he donated.

Barnett retires

Tim Barnett has announced he will not seek a Labour list nomination this year (he had already previously announced he would not be standing for Christchurch Central).

This is no surprise – I blogged in June that Transtasman reported he would retire and maybe return to the UK. And the Dom Post predicted this at the end of last year also.

Has always been a mystery to me how Helen Clark made people like Rick Barker, Dover Samuels and Harry Duynhoven as Ministers ahead of Barnett.

Talking of Labour MPs, Ann Hartley gives her valedictory on Wednesday and will be replaced by Louisa Wall.  This means Labour will need to put an MP up as a replacement Assistant Speaker.  Not sure if they have indicated yet who this would be.