Union Boss on Obama

From the Times:

Tom Buffenbarger, the president of the machinists’ union, put it more bluntly at her rally in Ohio on Tuesday night, telling the crowd: “I’ve got news for all the latte-drinking, Prius-driving, Birkenstock-wearing, trust-fund babies crowding in to hear him speak! This guy won’t last a round against the Republican attack machine. He’s a poet, not a fighter.”

Heh that is a great quote.  He might also be right.

BSA rules TVNZ and TV3 coverage of Electoral Finance Bill flawed

The Broadcasting Standards Authority has ruled, in two decisions, that coverage of the Electoral Finance Bill broke broadcasting standards.

Now before everyone in Labour breaks out the champagne, I have bad news for you.

The complaints of inaccuracy are about the fact TVNZ and TV3 said the initial Bill would outlaw secret and big donations. As most will know it did no such thing – there were no changes at all in the initial bill to donations to parties.

Now to be fair to TVNZ and TV3, they made the mistake of trusting the Minister, Mark Burton, who gave that impression at his press conference.  But regardless they should have checked.
I am amazed the broadcasters didn’t plead guilty – they tried to argue  that their story about big donors was referring to third parties, who are donors in some sort of generic sense.  It was a pathetic defence. In fact they should have run a correction at the earliest opportunity.

Big kudos to Steven Price who laid the complaint, especially as Steven became a supporter of the revised Bill. It’s a great example of putting the interests of accuracy first.

He also has an Press Council complaint in about the NZ Herald, complaining they didn’t make clear that the registration regime for third parties only is required if you spend over $12K, or over $1K in an electorate.

Caption Contest Time

ogtrevor1.JPG

I should have thought of this straight away but someone suggested it to me on the bus this morning. Fire away with best captions for this NZ Herald front page photo.

Captions can be for Owen, Trevor or even Helen!

Keeping Stock is taking captions also.

Homos causing earthquakes

A story in the Courier Mail reports:

AN Israeli parliamentarian says several earthquakes felt in Israel recently were a consequence of gays and the parliament’s acceptance of them.

Shlomo Benizri, of the ultra-Orthodox Jewish Shas Party, said the way to stop the tremors was for parliament to reverse its trend of liberalising laws concerning homosexuals.

Two quakes originating in neighbouring Lebanon shook much of Israel last week, the first coming two days after Israel’s attorney-general ruled that same-sex couples could adopt children.

“Why do earthquakes happen? One of the reasons is the things to which the Knesset (parliament) gives legitimacy, to sodomy,” Mr Benizri said during a parliamentary debate on earthquake preparedness.

A cost-effective way of averting earthquake damage, he added, would be to stop “passing legislation on how to encourage homosexual activity in the state of Israel, which anyway brings about earthquakes”.

This might give Brian Tamaki campaign ideas!

Owen Glenn Business School Courses

Cactus Kate has a copy of the course outlines for the new Owen Glenn Business School. Some extracts:

PROPERTY 100: Introduction To Super Yachts

During this paper you will learn all the basics of Super Yachts including brokering a deal, registering it in an effective offshore jurisdiction, designing offshore consulting contracts for your employees, the impact of oil prices to your Super Yacht and the meaning of carbon credits and advice on how to minimize them in the future.

PROPERTY 101: Super Yacht Essentials

Upkeeping your Super Yacht is crucial. This paper will teach you how to select your guests to maximize your outlay. From hiring staff, calculation of the optimal male to female guest ratio, selecting flooring to avoid damage from high heels, taking photographs, ordering the right alcohol and food and fitting all those high-tech specs that make your yacht better than the competition.

ECON 201: Special Topic: Advanced Relationships

A special topic with limited entry for men only. With all your new found wealth you will need advice on how to “select” and “protect”. Let our expert lecturers teach you some basics about members of the fairer sex. Topics will include special skills taught to young girls about how to generously offer to permanently look after your wealth. Watch in total awe as we take you through more advanced case studies and learn from the mistakes of others including how to use the diplomatic protection squad to your advantage when it all goes horridly wrong and how to say “no” effectively. We also discuss replacing contingent liabilities as they arise and how to make sure these contingent liabilities all get along fabulously as to bring peace and harmony to your life.

Lecturers: Deborah Hollings and Mrs X, Deborah Coddington, Jonah Lomu, Barry Colman.

ACCTG 101: Introduction To Offshore Companies, Banks and Trusts

Details of the paper have been suppressed at time of print. This paper will be taught off campus.

Lecturer: Lecturer: Mr/Ms/Miss/Sir Anonymous.

POL 201: Politics for Business

This paper will advise you on how to best influence the political process to your advantage including close examination of at the Resource Management Act, Electoral Finance Act and an introduction to the mechanics of Local Councils. Learn from the mistakes of others in this practical case study based paper. Case studies will use practical examples where corporate directorships and union contacts can be used to your advantage.

Lecturers: Winston Peters, Dail Jones, Mike Williams, Visiting Lecturers: Peter Davis and Helen Clark.

EGO 405: Advanced Topic: Public Relations and You

The most important yet complex paper and a must for any budding entrepreneur as based on the Founder’s advice there is nothing more important than how you are perceived despite your wealth. Learn when to shut up and when to speak out. Learn who to play nicely with and who to bury. Learn about how to manage the media with experienced BloJo’s Audrey Young and Fran O’Sullivan taking you through the process of just how the media work to discredit you or assist you.

Lecturers: Steve Fisher of Baldwin Boyle Group (subject to current performance review), Michelle Boag, Bill Ralston, Richard Griffin, Audrey Young, Fran O’Sullivan.

I’ve also heard a rumour that if National wins the next election, John Key plans to rename Auckland University as the Sir Owen G. Glenn University, in recognition of his contribution to New Zealand Politics.

General Debate 22 February 2008

Hillary helping herself lose

Hillary Clinton’s chances of winning the Democratic nomination is all going to come down to Texas, but she isn’t helping herself with yesterday’s idiocy as reported in the SMH:

During a scheduled economic discussion at a restaurant in the US state of Ohio Senator Clinton rubbished wealthy investment bankers and hedge fund managers, saying they they weren’t doing “real work”.

Senator Clinton’s daughter, Chelsea, works for New York-based hedge fund Avenue Capital Group and previously held a post with international management consulting group, McKinsey and Company.

How stupid can you get. She should have known this would be the story.

Turning to the nomination Obama has now won 11 in a row and has 1,360 delegates to 1,266 for Clinton.   Clinton needs to win both Ohio and Texas on the 4th of March.  She is miles ahead in Ohio (which somewhat ironically means she gets less credit for winning it), so it will all turn to Texas.  Even me in NZ has received an e-mail from Obama’s campaign manager in Texas calling people to arms. Ironic that Bush’s home state may decide the nomination.

If Clinton wins Texas, she is still alive but not the nominee.  If she loses Texas, then I think the DNC will start to put pressure on her to withdraw.  If she doesn’t expect Edwards to endorse Obama and super delegates to start to declare en masse to get a result.

The three polls in Ohio in February has Clinton 15% ahead of Obama. Texas has had five polls and they have Clinton ahead by 8% on average but the range is from 2% ahead to 16% ahead.

Proof you are in the dogbox

ogtrevor.JPG

Oh hilarious, and not even subtle. They put Trevor on point duty to keep Glenn away from the PM, as this Herald photo shows. And look at his positioning. Boy I guess there are some things not even $500K makes up for.

And over at the Dom Post, they also have fun.  It seems Judith Tizard claims the reason Helen didn’t hongi with Owen is because it was:

“Ngati Whatua rules that women don’t hongi”

But, Ngati Whatua Orakei Maori Trust Board chairman Grant Hawke said there was no such custom.

“We all hongi.”

Classic. And the pressure is getting to Clark, as reported in The Press:

Clark was asked this morning in Christchurch to comment on speculation that Williams had offered to resign. “I hardly think that’s the time to be raising those issues, we’re here about Earth Hour.” She then walked off.

Don’t you love the arrogance.  She tells the journalist that you can only ask me about “Earth Hour” and thinks that there is something inappropriate about the media wanting to talk to her about her own Party President offering to resign.

And then we have Williams himself:

Williams refused to comment when approached a short time ago. “It’s between her and me and I will not comment.”

Hello??  The offered resignation of a Party President is not a private matter between the Leader and the President.  For a start the President is accountable to the NZ Council and the members, not the PM.

Who are the parties Owen has donated to?

It is on the public record that Owen Glenn has stated he has donated to more than one political party in NZ, which means at least one party on top of Labour.

Audrey Young reveals the state of play as to denials:

National: Won’t discuss donors.
NZ First: Leader Winston Peters says no, president Dail Jones doesn’t know
Greens: No
Maori Party: No
United Future: No
Act:No

It would be very very amusing if Owen Glenn had donated to National as well as Labour.  For now I am assuming he has not as it would be near unheard of to donate $500,000 to one major party and also donate to their main opponent.

Now if Winston is correct that Owen Glenn has not donated (or arranged a donation) to NZ First, then the only other party in Parliament is the Progressive Party.  Has Jim Anderton also been “honoured”?

If it is not the Progressives, and it is not NZ First, well then who is it?  It must then be a party not in Parliament – is Owen Glenn the secret funder of the Libertarianz or the Animals First Party?

I don’t know.  It is just proving very hard to reconcile what Glenn has said (and while you might be confused on many things, it is hard to get wrong a fact such as having donated to more than one party) with the denials received.

Cullen making progress

One of the better things the Government has done was replace Mark Burton with Michael Cullen as Treaty Negotiations Minister. They realise progress had stalled on many fronts, so a change was needed and say what you will about Cullen – he is an achiever.

The terms of negotiation for the Kaingaroa Forest look to be a useful step forward.  It has been one of the most complex cases.

Trade Me auction on Consulate still going strong

The Trade Me auction of the Honorary Consulate is still there a day later, with bidding at $500,770. It’s almost impossible an auction with bidding that high would not have been noticed by Trade Me management, so they must have decided Consulates are now legitimate goods for sale!

And the Q&A continue to be fun in places:

Q: I’ll take 2 honorary positions to the land of lost things, 1 for Atlantis, 1 for Iran (just in case they’ll win the war against the Bush) and 3 popcorn please. any discount? posted by: pakapaka (5 ) 11:55 am, Thu 21 Feb

A: You can choose whatever you want no problem. Win the auction first though huh! I thought I’d only get $100k so at $500k I’m quite happy for multiple Consulships to go. 11:57 am, Thu 21 Feb

Q: Will you accept a swap for a Holden Ute? posted by: feeder (48 ) 12:47 pm, Thu 21 Feb

A: Considering the bids are over half a milly, NO! There isn’t a Holden ute known to man that is worth $500k. It could be a down payment on a knighthood though. 12:50 pm, Thu 21 Feb

Q: Are black singlets and gumboots suitable attire for an honorary consul? posted by: oberkat (34 ) 1:48 pm, Thu 21 Feb

A: Sure, why not, you’ve paid for it. 2:20 pm, Thu 21 Feb

Q: Can I get the consuls job in Ruatoki in exchange for some firearms? If you haven’t got any consul positions left, can I be a consort? posted by: dodger20 (16 ) 2:12 pm, Thu 21 Feb

A: Possibly, depends on how many guns you have. If it is a truckful perhaps. You can be a consort if you can suck a golfball through a garden hose. 2:22 pm, Thu 21 Feb

Q: Would you consider trading the item in for a night of passion with Rachel Hunter and Elle Macpherson, who are both close personal friends? posted by: frjack (32 ) 4:23 pm, Thu 21 Feb

A: Sure, a long weekend I think would be better. I think that is fair. Have a chat to the girls see if they like that idea. 5:25 pm, Thu 21 Feb 

Q: Do you have any icebergs coming up for sale? posted by: flashgordonnz (123 ) 7:54 pm, Thu 21 Feb

A: No but I understand there is a shipment of Fridges going to the eskimos that you could invest in. 12:55 am, Fri 22 Feb

Q: I was wondering if you would like to do a deal. I will steal it off you (you kinda leave the door unlocked and all, or maybe the key under the mat) .. and then you report it to the police .. and then we get some rich prick to pop up a reward (say $300K?) and then I give it back .. collect the reward .. split it with you 50/50 and then you re-sell it. I believe thats OK with the police these days. Work for you? Has to be between you and me only though ok. posted by: richard6 (36 ) 8:17 pm, Thu 21 Feb

A: Mmmm…Are you a member of the Headhunters, will I have to jail time, not too keen on that right now. 12:55 am, Fri 22 Feb

I wonder who will win the auction?  WIll the mystery buyer also be the mystery donor?

Opening of Owen Glenn Business School

As people know in a fit of good timing, Helen and Owen are opening the Owen Glenn Business School at Auckland University tonight.

An e-mail has gone around to all business school staff about this. One witty staff member replied to all in his or her department, inquiring:

Do you think the Dean has checked whether the PM still wants to cut the ribbon with Glenn and what she might be planning to do with the scissors if she’s that close to him?

Heh. One shouldn’t give her ideas.  To be fair if she did, a jury would probably find her not guilty on the ground of provocation and diminished responsibility 🙂

Williams offers his resignation

Labour Party President has offered his resignation, according to Stuff.

To be fair to Williams I don’t think what he did, while wrong, is at the level of resignation needed.  But that is on the basis of currently known info.  What sort of role he played in trying to get Owen Glenn made a Consul could change that view.

And to be fair to Williams, offering his resignation (even if he knows unlikely to be accepted) is an honourable thing to do.  He did stuff up with his comments denying any Glenn donation since 2005 – and this is him accepting accountability for it.

Circulation vs Readership

I blogged on Tuesday the media readership figures for 2007.  Now someone has kindly pointed me to the latest circulation figures also.  Now what is the difference you may ask?

Readership figures are generally compiled from random polling.  Ask 10,000 adult NZers which newspapers they read, and then you extrapolate that against the adult population so have readership figures.

Advertising prices tend to be based on readership.

Circulation figures, as I understand it, are basically an auditor going through the accounts of a publisher and verifying the number of newspapers being printed and paid for. So it should be more accurate than readership, but not necessarily more important.  It affects subscription revenue but advertising revenue for most media is bigger.

Readership will always be higher than circulation as more than one person reads a newspaper often.

So did readership changes mirror circulation changes?  Not much.  Below is the circulation change and readership change for each major paper:

  • Independent Financial Review +26%, -13.9%
  • Herald on Sunday +1.1%, +5.8%
  • Waikato Times +0.1%, +1.1%
  • The Press n/c, +4.5%
  • Dominion Post -0.1%, -3.6%
  • NZ Herald -0.8%, +3.0%
  • ODT -2.5%, -3.6%
  • Sunday News -4.3%, -11.2%
  • Sunday Star-Times -4.4%, -2.9%
  • National Business Review -5.5%, +12.0%

The IFR result is puzzling.  Their circulation increased by a quarter yet less people say they are reading them. Maybe their name change confused people in teh readership survey?

NBR is a bit the opposite direction.  Their circulation is down, but readership up strongly.  This may be that more people are reading communal copies, such as in offices etc.

Bid now for your own consulship

Trade Me has an auction where you can bid for your own consulship. There have been 12 bids and it is up to $500,200. So get in quick if you are a rich prick.

As always the Q&A are enjoyable. I liked this one especially:

Q: Can I pay with a short term interest free loan to you? posted by: rupesnz (24 ) 8:21 am, Thu 21 Feb

A: Sure why not. But I get to set the terms otherwise no deal.

And as it now has a track record of a service for sale, it should comply with Trade Me’s terms and conditions 🙂

The consulship

I feel like I am talking about the old Roman Republic when I blog about the consulship, but anyway let us look at one exchange in Parliament yesterday:

John Key: Further to her response to my question yesterday, has she at any time had any discussions with the President of the New Zealand Labour Party, Mike Williams, regarding the possible appointment of Owen Glenn as New Zealand’s honorary consul to Monaco?

Rt Hon HELEN CLARK: As I said to the House yesterday, I became aware that Mr Glenn had expressed such an interest. Since becoming aware, I have obviously had that as a matter of discussion with Mr Winston Peters. Mr Williams has also talked to me about it. I repeat that Mr Glenn’s interest was expressed in just the same way that Mr Richard Worth advanced the cause of a friend of his; when Mr Worth wrote to the previous Minister of Foreign Affairs about the matter, he told Mr Phil Goff: “There is an aspect of substantial self-interest behind my request that the New Zealand Government appoint a consul in Monaco.”

Now this confirms that Mike Williams talked to the PM about making Glenn an Honorary Consul.  Now why would the Prime Minister talk to her party fundraiser over a government appointment? I mean, they keep saying the two are not linked.

And her reference to Richard Worth is so stupid, it shows how rattled she is.  In case anyone does not know Richard is Monaco’s honorary consul to New Zealand.  I have no idea why the Monaco Government appointed him (around 15 years ago I think) but I think I am safe in assuming it was not because he donated $500,000 to Prince Albert.

Now it seems Dr Worth wrote a letter to the Minister of Foreign Affairs proposing someone as a suitable consul for NZ to Monaco.  And in that letter he noted his request had an “an aspect of substantial self-interest”.

Now this is exactly how it should be done.  No private secret discussions with no records.  Dr Worth wrote an on the record letter (and to a political enemy) proposing someone he thought would be suitable. And in the letter he noted he had a conflict of interest in making the recommendation.  Now that is exactly what you want people to do – declare their conflicts of interests.  So for Clark to hold this up as something improper just shows how bad her own judgement is.

Labour clarifies the loan

Labour’s Mike Smith (General Secretary) has very sensibly disclosed full details of the $100,000 loan from Owen Glenn, according to NZPA.

He said the loan was given in December 2006 and repaid in December 2007.

“At the time that the loan was made we established a market rate for the foregone interest on the loan with Owen Glenn’s accountant, in order that it could be declared to the party’s auditors in the return of donations for 2007,” he said.

“This return is due to be made to the Electoral Commission in April 2008 and is made under the provisions of the Electoral Act 1993.”

Excellent – that is exactly what they are required to do. In fact I would praise Mr Smith for establishing a market rate for the loan at the time.

He said the foregone interest was calculated to be about $8000, which had been declared to auditors.

Hmmn, let me see if I can work out the rate of interest to get to that. Yes I can. If the interest compounds daily then a 7.7% interest rate would come to $8,003 of interest. That is around the average secured rate.

Craig Foss does make the point that if the loan was unsecured (not against property) then one can argue a fair market rate would be 20%. I presume the party’s auditors are happy with the rate used – they are the ones who decide effectively. And to some degree it is not that important now as the loan is now public knowledge. At the 7.7% rate though, the donation fo the interest would not have reached the disclosure level unless Glenn had made any other donations in 2007.

Mr Smith said Mr Williams had made a mistake when he said last week Mr Glenn had not made any donations to the party since the last election.

Again kudos to Mr Smith for putting the record straight. Williams did stuff up – both legally, but also morally. Regardless of the exact wording of the Act, if reporters are asking if someone has donated, in the context of the Govt honouring them, then it is being too cute by half to be effectively saying “No, because you didn’t ask me about interest free loans”.

Now Mike Smith has shown he is a smart guy, who understands the law. Sadly our Minister of Justice does not. In Parliament yesterday:

Hon Bill English: So what action does the Minister expect would be taken by the Electoral Commission or the police when the president of a major party says: “We don’t declare these sort of donations, but we get lots of them.”, and will she be ensuring that the credibility of the Act is reinforced by some show of enforcement of its provisions?

Hon ANNETTE KING: A show of enforcement will be made either by the Chief Electoral Officer or the Electoral Commission, or the police if that is necessary—it is not for me to say that. But what I will say to the member is that up until the end of last year the provisions relating to donations were part of the 1993 Act. That member yesterday asked in this House whether I was aware that the Electoral Finance Act made it quite clear that interest-free loans would be counted as a donation. There is no mention in the 1993 Act of such a thing.

Now let us look at what the 1993 Act does say:

214F Interpretation
In sections 214G to 214J,—
party donation, in relation to a party registered under Part 4,—
(a) means a donation (whether of money or of the equivalent of money or of goods or services or of a combination of those things) …
(b) includes, where goods or services are provided to the party under a contract at 90% or less of their reasonable market value, the amount of the difference between the contractual price of the goods or services and the reasonable market value of those goods or services

Now certainly the EFA is more explicit but there can no real argument that the 1993 EA doesn’t also cover interest free loans.  Mike Smith certainly believes it does.  Providing a loan is a service. The interest on the loan is the cost of that service.  Calculating the reasonable market value of a loan is probably the easiest service in NZ to price, and there can be no one who passed third form maths who argues that a 0% cost is not less than 90% of the market cost.

The confusion over NZ First’s donor

The mystery of NZ First and their mystery donation is multi-layered. And while the media concentrate on the big issue of was it Owen Gelnn, and if not who was it, there are other aspects to also look at.

The term deposit

Whale Oil reminds us that Winston Peters in October said the party had the money to pay back the $158,000 but was waiting for their term deposit to mature in November. Dail Jones has said:

We had a board meeting on the 17th of December before which I paid the cheque to Starship because the money came in in the previous week. I remember it distinctly because I was looking for the money to pay the cheque.

This strongly suggests they did not have the money on term deposit, and that they were waiting for this mystery donation. And if it is a mystery donation, how did they know to be expecting it?

The bank couldn’t tell me

Dail Jones has told the media he asked the bank where the up to $100,000 allegedly anonymous donation had come from, and that they could not tell him.

Cactus Kate (who knows a great deal about banks and financial transactions) says that if this is the case the bank has broken the law in accepting this mystery donation, or that Dail Jones is telling porkies. She quotes at length from the Financial Transactions Reporting Act 1996, and how the size of the donation especially would trigger reporting obligations. She even has a pdf of the NZ Police best practice guide for verifying your customer.

Whale Oil also says that what Jones claims is impossible, and he has many years experience in rolling out a banking system for a NZ bank.

Who was it?

Winston Peters is reported as denying categorically that Owen Glenn has donated to New Zealand First.  One presumes this also involves any scenario where Glenn donates to someone else to donate etc etc. In the absence of any proof to the contrary, one of course accepts the statement at face value that it was not Glenn (even though Glenn himself has refused to deny it, but has denied offering to donate to the Maori Party, and has stated on the record he has donated to more than one party).

Now if Peters knows categorically the anonymous donor is not Owen Glenn, he must know who it is, and they must reveal it to the Electoral Commission.

Now in the media today we have a main article in the NZ Herald. They also have an article on Owen Glenn offering Sir Howard Morrison $1 million to stand for Parliament.

The Press reports on the rumours it was Glenn who donated, and Peters’ resolute denial of this. The Press claims that “several sources yesterday indicated the money had come from Glenn”. Maybe it was an interest free loan, not a donation 🙂

Tracy Watkins in the Dom Post covers the $1 million offer to Sir Howard also.

Oh yes plus all the media seem to be laughing loudly at Labour’s desperate attempt to create a scandal by alleging John Key has donated money to National.  He has, but never more than $10,000.  Wow we – an MP donating money to his own party.

Facebook Fun

facebookjk.JPG

A couple of amusing things on Facebook. Firstly reading in the news feed that John Key is now married. I suspect Bronagh is under the impression he has been for some time!

facebookog.JPG

And also this new group which is to support the new supreme overlord of New Zealand – Owen Glenn. If you join the group you can get listed in the officers as an honorary consul. But be in quick the tax havens of Hong Kong and the Cayman Islands have already been taken. I have applied to be the Honorary Consul to Disneyland.

Do not panic over errors and deaths

There are certainly problems in the health system, and no one at all would claim things can’t be better.  But I am wary of the uber-publicity over the report yesterday which detailed 182 serious errors in hospitals, including 40 patient deaths.

No health system will ever be error free, or even free from the tragedy of preventable deaths due to error.  Doesn’t matter who is in Government, doesn’t matter how much funding there is – errors will always happen, because as the saying goes “to err is human”.

Now this is not to say that the current level is acceptable.  I am not sure one could ever agree on any level of error being acceptable, but what I would say is important is to establish a trend where the error rate is decreasing over time, not increasing.

It is good that the Government is being more open about the level of error in our health system.  From the newspaper articles, it seems that this report is not entirely comprehensive but an “incomplete snapshot”.  The challenge is to document the complete picture, to measure it, and to put policies and resources in place to reduce it.  That is a task which could well occupy Health Ministers for some time to come.  And it will never reduce to zero. You just can’t get error free medicine.

Key on Wages

Labour has been attacking John Key for his purported comments in this article, about wanting wages to drop, John Key says he was referring to wages in Australia.

I wasn’t there, but I would be surprised if any party leader is seriously campaigning to cut wages in NZ. It might be Key didn’t make himself clear and that is a lesson to be remembered in election year – your mistakes (if it was one) will be pounced on.

It is also worth remembering though that wage rises not tied to productivity increases are not helpful in the long term.  Andrew Little himself has acknowledged the need for better productivity, as this is what fuels sustainable growth.

The notion that NZ would suddenly be 20% wealthier if  everyone in NZ got a 20% pay rise is false.  NZ would not be wealthier – we would just have much higher inflation and interest rates.

Also interesting to note that someone on the left is so excited about what Key said, they they have started spamming people about it. The e-mail looks professional enough that I doubt it is a lone operator.

Buchanan sacking in court

The Herald reports on the first day of an Employment Relations Authority hearing into Auckland University’s sacking of Paul Buchanan.

There was a massive outpouring of support for Dr Buchanan when he was sacked over an intemperate e-mail he sent a student wanting an extension for bereavement reasons.

Obviously the full facts of the case are yet to come out, but on what is known to date, it still seemed a massive over-reaction to me.

Bail for Medals

I blogged this week that I was comfortable with the reality that some of the reward money may have gone to people involved with stealing the VCs and other medals – that the main thing was getting them back.

The Bails for Medals tradeoff is more troubling though, even though Clark is defending it. That is a precedent we might regret one day.

Dom Post on dirty washing

I didn’t wake up until midday yesterday (still on Indian time) and so much happened in the afternoon that I didn’t get to read the Dom Post until very late in the evening. Hence I didn’t blog their editorial earlier on. Extracts:

Until last week there may somewhere have been someone who believed the Electoral Finance Act was a genuine, if misguided, attempt to “provide more transparency and accountability in the democratic process”. No longer, The Dominion Post writes.

The revelation that Labour Party president Mike Williams misled the public about a $100,000 loan made to the party by a wealthy expatriate businessman, Owen Glenn, shows the act for what it is – a stratagem to muzzle critics of the Government. Labour’s purpose in limiting “third party” advocacy was not to improve the transparency of the system or “to prevent the undue influence of wealth”, but to deny oxygen to its critics while allowing it to continue accepting the aid of its own wealthy backers.

Well partially.  It is also about allowing them to spend taxpayer money on their campaign with less controls.

… In accepting Mr Glenn’s generosity Labour did nothing that National has not done. Labour’s main rival has long relied on wealthy backers, many of whom have kept their identities secret, to fund its operations. And there is nothing wrong with Mr Glenn giving money to Labour. A healthy democracy relies upon people giving time and money to political parties.

Indeed.

But there is something very wrong about a party which has changed the law, supposedly to promote greater transparency and reduce the influence of what its deputy leader calls “rich pricks”, soliciting assistance from those same individuals and then denying it has received any assistance.

The word the editorial writer is looking for is “hypocrisy”.  As he or she is not in Parliament, they are allowed to use it.

Politically, Mr Glenn is now an embarrassment to Labour. His interest in being appointed honorary consul to Monaco and his “jest” that Miss Clark offered him a Cabinet post have become the subject of parliamentary scrutiny and his reason for making the original $500,000 donation – to counter the Exclusive Brethren’s “sneaky” campaign against the party – does not accord with the facts. The donation was made months before the Brethren campaign began.

I would still like someone to ask him on the record why he said it, and what was his real motivation. Or at least ask his PR firm so they can earn some extra money writing a good response.

But giving $7.5 million to the University of Auckland’s new business school and supporting it with scholarships worth $600,000 a year is as good a reason as most for making someone an Officer of the New Zealand Order of Merit. Thanks to Mr Williams’ evasiveness, however, the honour will always be clouded by the suspicion that it was awarded for services to the Labour Party rather than to business and the community.

Which is somewhat of a shame.  One doesn’t want to discourage people from being generous.  But Mr Glenn partially has himself to blame for the murkiness now surrounding his generosity.

Glenn also offered Sir Howard money to stand

Good God – where does this end?

TVNZ tonight reports that Owen Glenn offered Sir Howard Morrison one million dollars to stand for Parliament as an Independent.

For someone who has not lived in the country since 1966, he sure is interested in the politics of it a lot.

I wonder what seat he wanted Sir Howard to stand in? Not Mt Albert I presume?

UPDATE: Peters has told Guyon Espiner that Dail Jones is “completely wrong” and is astonished Jones would make those comments.  Peters is meant to be furious and says Owen Glenn has never ever donated money to NZ First.

This is strange.  Jones is not the one alleging Glenn has donated the money.  And if Glenn did not donate, why did he not just deny it as he did with the Maori Party?