General Debate 25 February 2008

1990 election

Whale Oil points out that governing alone isn’t impossible under MMP, looking at the 1990 election result where National got 47.8%.  If one takes away the wasted vote that is
50.4% of the effective vote.

Most do expect that National will lose some support from its current leels of low to mid 50s. But where will that support go to? Will it be ACT or United Future?  Will Winston pick it up?  Will the Kiwi Party or the Family Party siphon some off?

Of course it is by no means certain National will lose support to minor partie during the campaign.  I have previously debunked this theory as being only weakly supported by the empirical evidence.

Key Derangement Syndrome

It has been amusing to witness the furious assault on John Key in recent months. Its intensity has only been matched at times by its stupidity. A useful term for it is Key Derangement Syndrome ((c) Whale Oil), Take for example John Key’s hongi with Tame Iti at Waitangi.

Labour seemed to think that was some sort of huge election losing blunder that would alienate all “mainstream” New Zealanders. They blew up photos of it, and waved it around the House. The vast majority of NZers of course could quite rationally conclude that this does not mean John Key has joined Te Qaeda, but that he is being polite and following protocol on a marae – when in Rome do as the Romans do. In fact it may even have gained him support and sympathy that unlike Clark he is prepared to front up and be cordial to people he might rather not spend time with.

Now the result of all these attacks has been to send John Key soaring in the Preferred PM polls. Now this one is not anywhere near as important as the party vote. Bolger for example won three elections and never scored highly as Preferred PM.

But 44% for an Opposition Leader is unheard of – especially 10 months out from the actual election. In the One News series which goes back to 1984, Bolger never got over 20% in Opposition. Moore peaked at 25%. Clark only once made it past 30% in Opposition – and that was at the time Bolger was being rolled. Shipley and English peaked at 20% and Brash twice cleared 30% but only just, and briefly.

So 44% is extraordinarily high for someone who is Opposition Leader, but it is also incredibly high for someone who actually is the PM. The only person ever to score over 44% as PM was Clark herself in 2000 and 2002/03. Even Lange at the height of his popularity never got over 40%.

Now as I said, the party vote is the important one. But politically it is fascinating that so many people are not just making a negative statement about wanting to change the Government, but also what appears to be an affirmative statement that they want to see John Key as Prime Minister and see what sort of job he’ll do.

NY Times helps McCain

The NY Times recently ran an article alleging John McCain had an affair with a lobbyist around 10 years ago.  They had no proof for the article, and not a single on the record source.

The story has been criticised widely, and now even by the paper’s own ombudsman.

Ironically it has served to unite the conservative base around McCain.  Previous conservative critics are now rallying to support him due to fury over the NY Times story – especially its timing.  The NY Times has had the story for months and months and by waiting until McCain was the presumptive nominee, their motives appear to be purely to damage the Republican Party – otherwise they would have run it earlier on before he was the presumptive nominee.

Winston denies there was any donation at all

Okay the Herald do seem to be trying to get some further info out of Winston before Wednesday – well done. Claire Trevett writes:

Yesterday Mr Peters refused to say where the money was from and appeared to deny its existence.

When asked, Mr Peters said: “There’s no question ever that any such a thing ever did happen.”

Asked if that meant “there was no big anonymous donation”, Mr Peters said “precisely”. When further pressed he said: “I have no idea what is being spoken of because no such thing ever happened.”

So there was no donation at all. Dail Jones was totally mistaken it seems. How could this happen? Here’s the reasons I can think of:

  1. Dail Jones confused his personal bank account with NZ First’s, when he claimed he had found a close to $100,000 mystery deposit
  2. It wasn’t a donation, it was an interest free loan!
  3. The donation was actually the term deposit maturing, and Jones got them confused (but it was maturing in December we were told)
  4. The money is actually aid money for North Korea from Condi, which Winston is meant to pass on.

Perhaps Dail Jones could release a copy of the bank statement to clear things up.

Gosche leaves Maungakiekie

Mark Gosche has announced he will not restand in Maungakiekie.  At this stage he says he will seek to go List only – but do not be surprised if, like Tim Barnett, he does not stand at all eventually.

National would have struggled to win Maungakiekie off Gosche.  However with his retirement, it should now be regarded as a winnable seat.

Most focus has been on the party vote polling, and what that means for overall seats in Parliament. But people should consider what a 20% gap may mean in terms of electorates held, if the electorate vote follows similiar trends. Labour currently has 31 electorate seats (including Mangere) and could be reduced to low 20s.

Gallery soft on Winston

I am somewhat amazed that the press gallery have deemed it acceptable to allow Winston Peters to not provide any more details of his denial of what his own party president has claimed, until Wednesday.  This gives him six days to shall we say align what everyone says.

What other politician would be let off so lightly?  He in in Seoul tomorrow for the swearing in of the new President.  I hope one of the media outlets at least has a reporter there to ask him to explain exactly how Dail Jones is wrong, and who the money actually came from.

Kiwiblog 2.0

Okay after many dedicated hours and days of design, configuration plugin installation and testing, thanks to the good folks of Inspire Net, we have moved over to the new installation.

Obvious changes are moving to the two sidebar format, having the display fill the screen width more, and a cute wee banner. It is also set up to take more advertising. Thanks to the dozen or so businesses who are patiently waiting for a rate card. The new blog has a Neilsen Net Ratings subscription so after a couple of weeks of using their system to measure traffic, we should be able to produce a rate card.

There are quite a few extra features for readers:

  1. Comment Karma – you can now vote good comments up and bad comments down. Will be a good way of highlighting good comments. We did try and install another plugin which similiar to slashdot would also allow one to filter by comment rating and assign default karma to a user so good commenters start off with higher defaults. But that plugin is designed for low traffic blogs, not one with over a hundred thousand comments on it – the server died despite all attempts. But even this one should be fun
  2. Tags – each post will have tags (which can be any word or words) as well as categories. You can bring up all posts with a particular tag, view the most popular tags in a tag cloud, and even set up an RSS feed for a particular tag.
  3. Online Users – The blog will show how many people are online and if they are logged in users, who they are. Again should be fun. There could be privacy issues in theory (your boss notices you are on Kiwiblog all day long) but common sense should prevail.
  4. Polls – we now have a very easy to use, and easy to answer, poll plugin. Expect lots of fun polls in the sidebar. And in theory it track votes by both cookie and IP address so the vote stacking some media website polls get should be avoided. Just remember still totally unscientific though.
  5. Edit your own comments! Yes for the period of 15 minutes you will be able to edit your own comments if you make a typo etc.
  6. See how many comments made. Next to a commenters name, it will now display how many comments in total they have made on this blog.

Hope you all enjoy it.

[Update: I have disabled some of the useronline functionality for now, as it was just revealing a bit too much detail such as referring URLs and IP addresses]

General Debate 24 Feb 2008

Dunne compares Clark to Clinton and Key to Obama

Peter Dunne, one of Helen Clark’s Ministers, has compared Clark to Hillary Clinton and Key to Obama.

The Key-Obama theory is fascinating.  How are they alike, apart from the polls?

  1. Both had a parent born in another country
  2. Both are in their 40s
  3. The little known fact that Key’s full name is John Hussein Key
  4. Obama beat Alan Keyes to win his Senate seat, Key beat Brian Neeson win his.
  5. Both were helped into power by a Michelle – Michelle Obama and Michelle Boag
  6. Obama and Key have both lived in New York
  7. Both have campaigned against electoral fraud
  8. Both have two children
  9. John Key has served on a advisory board to the US Federal Reserve, and Obama if he wins will appoint the Fed Chairman
  10. John Key is actually very good at dancing

So I think Peter Dunne is onto something here.  I am surprised more media have not picked up the similarities.

Wall not targeting Electorate Vote

Optimistic News

Govt previously refused Monaco appointment

A very significant development in the Owen Glenn story today, in Fran O’Sullivan’s column.

Readers will recall how the Owen Glenn said he had all but been promised Honorary Consul to Monaco, and he was just waiting for Winston to get off his arse about it.  Weknow Mike Williams lobbied Clark about it, and Glenn lobbied Peters and obviously he received no negative indications.

Now Fran reveals that the Government has refused to appoint an Honorary Consul repeated times in the last few years.  And not because the person suggested was inappropriate, but because they kept insisting there was no need for one. They even turned down a request which was backed by Monaco’s ruler, Prince Albert.

So after years and years of saying there is no need for a Consul, sugar daddy Owen Glenn says over breakfast he would like the role, and it seems people are falling over backwards to arrange it and give him the impression that it would be arranged.

This also suggest to me that Peters and Clark did not talk to Phil Goff about Glenn’s proposed appointment. Goff presumably would have said “you can’t appoint him – we have said on the record there is no need for a Consul”.  Or maybe they did talk to Goff and he is even more cunning that we’ve suspected.  Personally I don’t think he is that cunning, so hence assume they failed to talk to him.  They may have saved themselves a lot of trouble if they had.

The medals thieves

Facebook Fans

More on the sacked in hospital story

I blogged earlier today on the story of the boss who sacked one of his staff while recovering from a heart operation.  A lot of people have actually defended the boss who did it.  They seem ignorant of how one should handle a situation like this, so let me spell out how it should be handled.

First some important facts:

  • It is not a choice between sacking someone and paying them a full wage while they recover.  Once their sick leave entitlement is up, you can have them on unpaid leave.
  • The employer made the decision with no consultation or discussion. He just turned up with the dismissal notice.
  • The employer turned up to tell him, without even giving notice that he was coming in to discuss work issues- hence not giving the employee time to consider a response.
  • The employer expressed a medical opinion which he was not qualified to express, and which conflcited with the actual doctor

Here’s what a far better, fairer and legal process might look like:

  1. Visit employee in hospital just to see how they are doing, after the operation.
  2. Visit employee again, and say that you are glad to see them recovering, they are missing you at work and consequential to that they need some idea of how they will be placed in terms of resuming work, and whether there will be restrictions on what they can do.  Ask them to either allow their doctors to talk to you, or preferably to prepare a report on what is possible.
  3. Receive the report and consider it. Verify with the employee that they agree in terms of the timeframes mentioned, that this is the earliest they could return to work.
  4. Look for good faith options where the job can be held open, while they recover.  Can other staff work more shifts.  Can you get a temp. If they can be back in a month (for example) would a new employee even be able to start by then. Does the experience you will lose if you let that employee go make it worthwhile holding the role open.
  5. When you have formed an initial opinion, pop in and see them (and also put it in writing to the employee) and discuss options such as part-time work, whether other staff can cover.  The employee may be able to propose an acceptable solution.  Explain why you may be unable to keep a job open past a particular date.
  6. Make no decision on the spot.  After the meeting give the employee time to make a formal response in writing if they want – make sure they have had full ability to have their point of view considered.
  7. Then after you have all the facts, and the employee has had the ability to make representations to you, make a decision.

Employment lawyers might be able to add some extra steps to the above, but regardless the way it was done with a pre-determination based on assumptions not facts and with zero employee input is just wrong wrong wrong.

So apt

Tamihere hires Awatere-Huata

How not to treat staff

Good God, read this story in the Herald about the boss who sacked one of his staff, while he lay in hospital recovering from a heart operation.

I would be talking to employment lawyer Peter Cullen about this one, if I was the employee.  Sounds like one could set a record for damages.

Big Money buys power – in Australia

The Sydney Morning Herald reveals the influence of big money in Australian politics – the $10.1 million spent by the trade union federation against John Howard.

Other left wing groups spent sums of up to half a million dollars.  The only spending by an employer group was the WA Master Builders Association who spent $32,000.

Obviously the results of the last election are invalid, as according to the rhetoric of the left in NZ, Kevin Rudd purchased the election.  They will no doubt call for John Howard to be returned to office as Interim PM until new money free elections be called.

Bad News and Worse News for Labour

The bad news for Labour is the Morgan poll taken from 4 to 17 February which has National’s lead grow from 9% to 19%.

The worse news is the Fairfax/Neilsen poll taken from 13 to 19 February which has National’s lead grow from 5% (in Nov) to a staggering 23%.

Key also leads Clark as Preferred PM by a huge 15% – 44% to 29%.

Also worth noting that most of the damaging Owen Glenn stuff happened after these polls concluded!

The Dom Post is saying Clark’s leadership must now be under serious scrutiny.  While it will be scrutinised I do not believe there is any prospect at all of a coup before the election. Apart from her power throughout the party, Goff wouldn’t want the job at the moment.  And the time for a voluntary handover has passed.  There was a small chance if the polls had been this bad say all of the latter half of next year Clark may have thrown it in over Christmas, but National’s stumble in October gave them hope.

Of course things are not over – a lot can happen in nine months – but it would seem to be very much National’s election to lose.  And Labour’s problem may be that voters simply are not listening to them anymore, and not listening to Helen especially.

Castaways

Had a good night catching up with people last night.  Checked into City Life a bit after midnight and found they had upgraded me to one of the two Director’s Suites on the top floor.  What a waste – a huge lounge, three bedrooms, and I just use it to sleep in and shower. If I had known about the upgrade I would have hosted a party in my room!

Travelled west this morning by mini-coach to Waiuku, where the NZBR Retreat is – as I mentioned I am a guest panelist on a media and public policy discussion.

cast1.JPG

We are staying at Castaways, which is in a wonderfully isolated location on a hill overlooking the Tasman Sea on the West Coast.  Not that sunny today but still a magnificent view.

It is so remote here there is no cellphone coverage at all – either Telecom or Vodafone.  So don’t bother calling me today.

Owen Glenn and Bill Lloyd

Murray McCully writes in his weekly newsletter:

Remaining Mysteries
A week of excruciating embarrassment has been endured by our Prime Minister and her Government.  She, who last year climbed onto such a high horse on the subject of campaign finance disclosure, has been caught leading a party that misled New Zealanders over a $100,000 loan made by Owen Glenn.  Mr Glenn will by now have departed these shores, but one small mystery remains:

In a 2005 interview with “Unlimited” magazine, Mr Glenn made reference to “my friend Bill Lloyd,” with whom he hoped “to build some luxury yauchts up here in Hobsonville.”  Mr Lloyd, readers may recall, had been the controversial recipient of assistance from one Jim Anderton in the procurement of Defence land at Hobsonville.

Mr Glenn told his 2005 interviewer that Mr Lloyd had been “badly dealt by” in the matter.  “…but it’s all been resolved through the good services of Mike Williams, the President of the Labour Party, who’s done a mammoth job,” said Mr Glenn.

So, just what sort of “mammoth job” was that?

Mr Williams does indeed seem a tireless worker on behalf of his donors. And as it was taxpayer money given to Mr Lloyd, I think we would all like to know the nature and extent of this mammoth job done by Labour’s chief fundraiser.

Another one bites the dust

How stupid do they think we are?

From NZPA:

A spokeswoman for Miss Clark said the pair would not pose together for media, and their lack of contact was “just what happened” and had not been planned.

Oh yes, just a coincidence that you know the guest of honour didn’t even shake hands with the PM who was opening the building.  Can anyone think of a single comparable occassion where the presenter and the guest of honour don’t shake hands, let alone pose together for photos.

Now hell, if I was 9th floor I might have put Trevor onto bodyguard duties also.  Hopefully I would have picked someone more subtle, but regardless.  But please please don’t transparently lie about it, and say the lack of contact was not planned.  Just avoid the question rather than tell porkies.

The gallery do not like press  secretaries who tell porkies.  They may have a grudging respect for those who skillfully dodge, change the question, give an evasive answer, or even give a totally different answer to what the question was.  But never ever tell them a flat out lie.