Don’t Vote National site!

Most pointless release ever

From Scoop:

Youth Encouraged to Make the Most of Summer
Tuesday, 8 January 2008, 9:28 am
Press Release: New Zealand Government
Youth Encouraged to Make the Most of Summer

Youth Affairs Minister Nanaia Mahuta is today encouraging young people to make the most of summer.

“The holidays are great for spending time with families and relaxing before they return to work or studies for another year. It’s also a great time to soak up the fantastic opportunities and creativity our country has to offer,” says Nanaia Mahuta.

“There is the outdoors, visiting galleries, writing poetry, or simply getting in some summer reading – not to mention getting their short films in for the ID360 competition which is a wonderful way for the young people of Aotearoa/New Zealand to tell the world about themselves and what identity and diversity means to them.”

ENDS

Yes young people need to be told by a Government Minister to enjoy summer.  Hell how would they cope without Big Sister there to tell them to enjoy summer?

National US polls

Some national polls are out. This is support for candidates over the whole country.  A Pew Research poll on 30 Dec had Clinton 20% ahead of Obama.  Gallup on 6 Jan has them in a tie.  Clinton has dropped 13%, Obama is up 7% and Edwards up 6%.  So a massive swing, but it does show Clinton is still competitive.

On the GOP side, Huckabee goes from 17% to 25% and leads nationally.  My God I hope he does not become the candidate.  I don’t think he will.

New Hampshire results out later today.  Almost beyond doubt Obama will win.  McCain is ahead in most polls, but one has shown him behind Romney.  Should be McCain but not as certain.

Huckabee is probably my bottom choice (amongst the serious candidates) on the GOP side.  On the Democratic side Edwards I can’t stand and would be my bottom pick amongst the big three.

Who would be your bottom picks for each race?

5 Myths About US Ballot-Box Behavior

A good read in the NY Times by Professor Bryan Caplan. The myths are:

1. People vote their self-interest.

In fact, there is only the tiniest correlation between income and party. The country is not divided into two camps: the poor, who vote Democrat, and the rich, who vote Republican…

Self-interest is also a bad predictor of views about specific issues. Yes, the elderly heavily support Social Security and Medicare, but so does almost everyone else. The old bumper sticker says, “If men could get pregnant, abortion would be a sacrament,” but men are actually slightly more pro-choice than women.

2. Unselfish voting will solve our problems.

We often blame political problems on the selfishness of our fellow citizens. If people would just sacrifice their own interests for the country’s good, our problems would be solved, right?

Hardly. Selfishness is not the only cause of political strife. The U.S. electorate is bitterly divided by ideology and religion, and that’s what makes our political disagreements so intractable. After all, if voters were truly selfish, they would negotiate amicable settlements and take what they could get, instead of zealously fighting the same battles year after year.

Even if the American public put aside ideological and religious differences, unselfish voting could easily be dangerous. If people are mistaken about how to make society better off, their good intentions will produce bad consequences. A selfless doctor who believes that leeches will cure cancer is dangerous. So is a selfless voter who truly believes that high tariffs will cure unemployment.

3. Voters’ errors balance out.

It’s fashionable to dismiss worries about the mistakes of the average voter by praising “the wisdom of crowds,” to use James Surowiecki’s phrase. Sure, the average voter knows little about politics, economics and policy. But for every voter who overestimates the benefits of tariffs, carbon taxes and the Iraq war, doesn’t another make the opposite mistake?

Actually, no. Voters are frequently wrong in the same way. This is particularly clear in economics. If you’ve never studied economics, you’re not equally likely to oversell or downplay the benefits of free trade. Instead, people who know nothing about economics are staunch protectionists, and people who know a lot of economics are avid free-traders…

In politics and economics, people believe what makes them feel good, even if the evidence is against them. For most Americans, it feels a lot better to scapegoat Mexicans or Chinese for the country’s economic woes than it does to calmly examine the facts.

4. Political disagreement is all about values.

Values matter a great deal, but facts do, too. On almost every major issue, both sides have a different story, not just a different spin. For example, a 2004 Harris poll on the Iraq war found that supporters of President Bush and Sen. John F. Kerry had radically different beliefs about Saddam Hussein’s regime. A striking 58 percent of Bush partisans thought Iraq had weapons of mass destruction when the United States invaded it in 2003, as opposed to just 16 percent of Kerry backers.

5. Voters want serious change.

Pundits love telling us that voters are “fed up” with politics as usual. Candidates follow suit, insisting that — unlike their competition — they’re really listening to the American people.

Nonsense. Public opinion data strongly confirm that the status quo is popular. All the big components of the federal budget enjoy broad support. When asked whether government should do less of something, more of something or stick with the status quo, the average American almost always sticks with what he has.

Herald on effects of Electoral Finance Act

The Herald’s editorial uses the case of Andy Moore’s Don’t Vote Labour website to remind people why it opposed the Electoral Finance Act:

Barely a week into the year and the Electoral Finance Act has bared its teeth. The body charged with policing the act, the Electoral Commission, has contacted a 21-year-old about his website, named “dontvotelabour”. He was told he had to put his name and address on the site.

Is this going to be the story of the year: constant vigilance of any form of public speech to ensure it complies with all 148 clauses of the act? How absurd that New Zealanders can no longer make a political statement in an election year without satisfying a welter of petty regulation.

Indeed.  The EFA extends the regulated period from around 8% of an electoral cycle to a massive 30%.  It also extends what is considered a regulated election advertisement from paid advertising to basically any form of written advocacy for or against a party.

… Andrew Moore, whose site has come to the commission’s attention, would prefer not to put his home address on his site partly to protect his family. Why does he have to?

… It is outrageous that they even need to concern themselves with such rules. When people come to wonder what has happened to a freedom they once took for granted, the answer is seldom a single, memorable edict. It is more often a hundred trifling rules, requirements and restrictions, each defensible within the logic of the law but together oppressive in their effect.

Fortunately the Government’s attempt to monitor political expression will not long outlast its lease on power. But if the commission continues as it has started, the spectacle will be ridiculous.

I actually feel very sorry for the Electoral Commission.  Their job is to enforce the law, not to write it. They, and the Chief Electoral Officer, acted bravely in 2005 by referring Labour to the Police for over-spending.  They take their job very seriously of running fair and undisputed elections.  Of course it doesn’t mean they are beyond criticism and like anyone can’t make mistakes, but I’ve dealt with various electoral agencies over the years and they try to be scrupulously fair and professional.

They’re a bit damned if you do and damned if you don’t.  If a breach of the law is made known to them, and especially is very public, then if they do not take action they can be criticised for allowing people to choose which parts of the law they obey.  And if they do take action, they get seen as the bad guys.

STV reduces vote from 46% to 36%

I am actually a fan of STV in some circumstances.  For Mayoral elections I think it works well for example.  But my gut reaction for the last two health board elections has been that it discourages people from voting.  I mean even a political junkie like me groans at trying to rank 30 candidates from 1 to 30.  It’s meaningless, arbitrary and time consuming.

So it is no surprise to read on Stuff an NZPA story that last elections 100,000 ballots were disqualified as people did not use STV correctly, and a further 110,000 were left blank. This means only 36% of NZers cast a valid vote.

I’m not convinced we should have DHB elections at all, but if we are they should be meaningful.

Emos not shot

Two emos in Christchurch kicked a passing car.  The driver stopped and remonstrated with the emos who claimed they had a knife.  So he showed them the gun in his boot and has been arrested for it.

Would anyone have complained if he had shot them?  I mean we are talking emos here.
He’d get community service at best.

A long meeting

Got called into a meeting yesterday at around 3 pm.  Thought it would be for around half an hour.  By the time the meeting finished and I walked home, I noticed today’s Dominion Post was on sale.  A very pleasant meeting indeed.

Website warned it breaches Electoral Finance Act

I blogged last week on young Andy Moore’s Don’t Vote Labour website, and pointed out that it is now classified as an election advertisement and breaches the Electoral Finance Act, as it does not state on the site te name and residential address of the person responsible or promoter.

Labour and the Greens voted against an amendment which would have had all non commercial speech on the Internet defined as not being an election advertisement.  At present it is only such speech on blogs and media sites.  This is of course very silly as
the difference between a blog and the website Andy set up is what sort of technology it uses.  But again this is not a drafting error – they voted down an amendment which would have solved this problem.

Now there was a vigorous discussion on the previous thread about whether the Electoral Commission would take any action against the website. Roger Gnome especially insisted there was no chance at all.

The Herald reports today that the Electoral Commission has contacted Andy Moore, and that an authorisation requirement is needed on the site.

We also have another law breaker in Internet personality Bruce Simpson.  Bruce has been having his say on the Internet since before I knew there was an Internet.  And he isn’t too keen about registering either.

So on his Aardvark site, Bruce has an illegal election advertisement.  Not against the Government, but in fact campaigning for Helen Clark in Mt Albert.  He has ascribed it a value of $100 a day, so believes he will be prosecuted in 40 days time once the value as reahed $4,000.

In fact Bruce will run into trouble before then.  As it is an advertisement urging support for a candidate, he needs the permission of Helen Clark’s financial agent.  Yes you can not put a banner on your own website urging support of a candidate without their permission.  The old law also required permission, of course, but did not view a statement on your own website as an ad.

So Bruce is looking to breach several sections of the Act.  He doesn’t have his name and address on an advertisement.  He doesn’t ave the permission of the candidate’s financial agent and he will breach the spending limit for third party advertising for a candidate.

He will actually breach the limit at $1,000 not $4,000 as the latter amount only applies if you are a registered third party, which Bruce is not.

A cool My Sky feature

As many will know I am a devoted fan of My Sky. For a one off costs it transforms how you use and watch TV. The series link feature, plus the ability to fast forwards ad in eight seconds are great.

Most of what I want to record (finding time to watch it is another issue) is on a series link. So I get both TV One and TV3 news each night etc. But around twice a week I scan the seven main channels, the movie channels and the History channel for interesting programmes that I want to record.

Now yesterday I noticed for the first time that at the very bottom of the screen of the channel guide page is an option for search programmes. And under that you have an option of seeing in alphabetical order all programmes for the upcoming week. You can filter it by type of channel and also by type of programme.

So I’ve used that for the first time and found some programmes I didn’t even know were on. I didn’t even know there was a MTV entertainment channel.

Now all we need is a text searchable feature, and it will be perfect!

The report on sole-parent families and MSD

The NZ Herald has an NZPA report which appears to be a Green press release rehashed on some terrible suppression of a report by the Government.  It would have been nice to have had someone ask well why did the Families Commission decide not to publish it, and work that into the story.

Luckily Lindsay Mitchell does know the background to this, and mentions the report was based on a sample of 15 DPB recipients whom the author was already providing advocacy work for.  It hardly sounds like like it would be published in a peer reviewed journal.

World War I Blog

The family of a WWI soldier are posting the letters he sent home onto a blog, exactly 90 days years after they were originally written. The blog is called WW1: Experiences of an English Soldier.

I read about it on Stuff who have a Reuters story on it. I have not read all the back posts, but have subscribed to it and will be hoping he gets to the end of 1918 safely. An innovative way to get people interested in what it was like.

Sony drops DRM

Song has joined the other three major music companies in making their songs available for sale without Digital Rights Management software which has stopped users being able to do things such as copy it from one device to another.

This is a huge change of tune for the big music companies.  They have spent years trying to lock their music up, but have now realised that it just hasn’t worked and in fact encouraged people to illegally download music, as that is the only way to get it DRM free.

The irony in NZ is Parliament is poised to pass a new law, which will give special protection to DRM.  Both the Government, and National, need to seriously consider the merits of continuing with a law which will be out of date before it is even passed.  I’m not saying the Copyright Amendment Act should be thrown out because much of it is needed.  But the changes over the last year would be worth considering before they pass it.  At present it is halfway through the second reading, so can be amended at the Committee of the Whole stage.

Who said this?

A reader has sent me a speech made by an MP who voted for the Electoral Finance Act. His speech was on 12 Nov 2003, and he seems to have forgotten it – some extracts:

In other words, we live under a system that amounts to a Labour dictatorship and MMP has made little difference to that.Democracy is too important to be left to the politicians. We say it is far better to rely on the commonsense of ordinary people to make decisions on the important issues facing New Zealand. Why? Because politicians simply cannot be relied on to do the right thing and to act in accordance with the wishes of the majority. They have forgotten that they should be the trusted servants of the people. They must face the consequences of their memory loss.

We desperately need checks and balances and a system that makes politicians accountable. We simply have to trust the people and to rely on their good will and commonsense. In a democracy people have the right to govern themselves and take matters into their own hands when their MPs fail them. When people elect a government to safeguard their society, their security, culture, their liberty and their future, their elected representatives must listen to them. Democracy is lost when that elected government and its officials fail to hear the voices of the people. It is then that ordinary people have a moral duty to rise up and restore democracy themselves.

Amazing how forgetful you get after a few baubles.

Heading to New Hampshire

Well the Iowa result has shaken the two races up and things are not so close now.

The markets now have the cost of betting $1 on getting the nomination as 66c for Obama and 30c for Clinton. Edwards is around 3c.

On the GOP side, McCain is leading on 37c, Giuliani next on 27c, Romney 18c, Huckabee 16c, Thompson 2c.

Turning to the polls, there have been five in New Hampshire and Obama’s lead over Clinton ranges from 3% to 13% and it is hard to see him not winning New Hampshire.

And again on the GOP side, McCain leads Romney in all five polls – from 4% to 14%.  So unless there is a massive upset, McCain should win there.

After New Hampshire it is more murky.  One has Michigan, Nevada, South Carolina and Florida.  Florida may be a big battle for three reasons.  Firstly it has a lot of delegates.  Secondly it is a key swing state and electability there is important and finally it is the last chance to get momentum before Super Duper Tuesday on 5 February.

Oh yes the Republicans also have Louisiana, Hawaii and Maine before SDT.

Obama is generating excitement on a level not seen for some decades.  He is becoming a symbol as much as a candidate.  Liberal Republicans such as Andrew Sullivan rave about him. I’m not quite so convinced.

On the symbolic level yes he does have significant promise.  But his lack of experience make him a risky choice.  As I have said before my preferred Democrat is Hillary Clinton.  Not because I like her.  In fact quite the opposite.  But she would be a safe and competent President. However she is so tied into the battles of the past, while Obama is branded as a candidate for the future,  that she is in danger of becoming irrelevant.

More Parker intereference?

Just seen a press release from Gerry Brownlee highlighting an affadavit (in a court case over power pylons) from the former Chairman of the Electricity Commission, Roy Hemmingway. The Commission was set up by the Labour Government and Hemmingway hand picked to be its first Chair. Hemmingway has a Yale Doctorate in Law.and has 30 years experience in utlility regulation. What has he said in his affadavit?

Well he praises Pete Hodgson for not interfering and especially praises Trevor Mallard as very competent and diligent. It is when Parker took over, that we saw intererence. There is a growing pattern here, and in hindsight it is becoming clear Parker was promoted too quickly and not briefed on appropriate boundaries.

Hemmingway swears in his affadavit how Parker was engaged in a level of detail inappropriate for a Minister and that he was trying to circumvent the public input process.

Cullen is also referenced:

Michael Cullen started the meeting by saying that if anyone ever asked that this meeting had occured, he would deny it.

I hope a journalist asks Dr Cullen whether or not he did have such a meeting. Do remember this is a sworn affadavit.

Then we have the illegal instruction from Parker:

The Minister stated we should defer to Transpower’s expertise on technical matters. Notably this comment was completely out of line with the requirements of the Electricity Governance rules, which require the Commission to make independent judgements following its own evaluation of the technical material.

Go read the affadavit to see who bad it was. Also the exhibits.

The whole point of having independent regulators is so decisions are not just made by who has lobbied the Minister the hardest. If the Minister wants to personally approve proposals, then he should say he is doing so and take the responsibility for them. But to have an independent regulator which you try and turn into a rubberstamp is a serious breach of the purpose of having them independent.

Since then the Minister has filled the Electricity Commission up with Labour loyalists so there is no chance it won’t go along with the Minister again. The Commission has four or five out of six Labour people on it. It is one thing to have one or two maybe but this is totally stacked.

Caygill and Rodger are former Labour Ministers. Peter Harris is ex CTU and worked for Cullen for many years. Linda Constable was a City Councillor on the Labour aligned 2021 ticket and David Bull is a former Wellington City and Regional Councillor and I think (can’t find a reference) stood on the Labour ticket. Only one of the six Commissioners is definitely not aligned with Labour, and it is meant to be an independent regulator!

UPDATE: A reader says they are almost certain David Bull was not a Labour Councillor. So that is 4/6 not 5/6.

More on Saudi blogger

Poneke covers the latest on the case of the detained Saudi blogger.  Both myself and Poneke were on Radio NZ this morning talking about the case and asking the NZ Government to lobby the Saudi Government on his behalf, as the US Government has done.

Very nice to see EPMU’s Andrew Little  supporting the call for government intervention.

Engineering Printing and Manufacturing Union national secretary Andrew Little says intervention would be appropriate in this case too.

He says detaining people for expressing a set of views or opinions is simply not acceptable in the modern world.

Andrew Little says the Government made a successful intervention in the case of the detention of a Philippines congressman and trade unionist.

Hopefully this will help get MFAT or the Duty Minister onto the case.

Dom Post on Secret Donations

The Dom Post talks about how the Electoral Finance Bill does not stop anonymous donations:

Had the Labour Party the courage of its convictions, it would not have introduced to Parliament the offensive Electoral Finance Bill in the form it has been enacted, The Dominion Post writes.

It would have done what Prime Minister Helen Clark promised when she undertook to rewrite election campaign law, and ended the secrecy that surrounds some political donations.

Voters want to know who is funding political parties so they can assess for themselves whether the donors are attempting to buy policies that suit their interests. They do not want any more of their taxes going into politicians’ pockets than finds its way there now. But the Electoral Finance Act will not tell them the former – anonymous funding will continue, wrong though it is.

The Act does put some limits on anonymous funding, but one could for example still give $250,000 a year anonymously through a loophole, and even without the loopholes a donor can give $66,000 over an electoral cycle and not have their identity disclosed.

And of course the original bill had absolutely no restrictions at all.  Labour were shamed into doign something, but even then it is a messy compromise that will do little.

Mr Brown, like his counterpart in the Antipodes, prefers state funding for political parties. There, like here, it is an idea that needs stout resistance. If political parties want to be able to say they have popular support, they must earn it in the bearpit of everyday debate by proposing and defending policies they believe in. They need also to be able to withstand assault on their stance from without the political elite. Had New Zealand had state funding of political parties, the Maori Party, for example, would have been hard pressed to have broken into the magic circle.

Indeed, and it is important parties are reliant on their supporters.  National got hurt badly in 1991 when its policies led to many members quitting.  A governing party shouldn’t be immunised from the impact of its decisions.  Under state funding you’ll get money based on your vote last election, not based on what you have done since then.

Plus as Bryce Edwards often points out, we already have some de facto state funding for the parliamentary parties.

2007 Kiwiblog Stats

I’ve had to wait a few days to get the 2007 stats before my ISP complains traffic is so heavy they had to change the stats package from daily to weekly updates!

Anyway in 2007, Kiwiblog had the following:

Page Views: 9,222,545
Unique Visits: 2,697,578
Downloaded Data: 853 GB
Posts Made: 2,962
Comments Left: 70,247

While this is small fry compared to some of the US blogs (or global tech blogs), it actually is pretty high for our population. In the UK the most visited bloggers are Guido Fawkes and Iain Dale. Guido blogs here that he had 4,273,096 page views in 2007 and Iain Dale had 4,554,000 page views.  They did get more unique visits but still not bad considering the UK population is around 15 times larger than NZ.

Teenage beneficiaries

Regardless of the reasons, everyone should be concerned that since 2000 the number of teenagers on the sickness benefit has increased by 104% and the numbers on the invalids benefits is up 44%.  In people terms this is a combined increase of 1,964 from 3,011 to 4,975.

The welfare system is there for when people need it, but it is a concern that 2,000 extra teenagers have gone onto benefits which may be long-term.  It is when you are young especially you need work experience so you can get jobs later on. Unemployment numbers have dropped which is good, but complacency is bad.

It has been suggested that depression may be a factor.  And for sure teenage depression is a real issue. But then one has to start asking why would so many more teenagers be so depressed they are unable to work? Sadly many people on the sickness benefit are drug and alcohol addicts.  Now I am not saying that is what has driven the increase, but if so then it indicates a real real problem.  Hopefully some data may become available to explain the increases, because then one can target how to reverse them.

Ruth Dyson’s attitude of “not concerned about the figures” and “hardly a change at all” doesn’t suggest she sees a need to ask any further questions.  I disagree.  She shouldn’t be defensive on this issue.  Overall the Government has an pretty good record on lowering the numbers on benefits.  But that complacent attitude to the areas where there still is a problem, isn’t helpful.

The new road safety proposals

Just before Christmas, the Government announced some proposals for improving road safety.  There’s a lot of them, so worth going through in detail:

  •  to extend from six to twelve months the minimum time under 25 year olds spend on a learner licence – very sensible as allows for more supervision
  • breaches of Graduated Driver Licensing System conditions have penalty drop from $400 to $100 but demerit points increase from 25 to 35 points – excellent as few ever paid fines and demerits are a bigger disincentive
  • a second breach of learner or restricted licence conditions can result in a possible 28-day vehicle impoundment – great – if they won’t obey the law, get them off the road
  • all traffic offenders will be required to pass the appropriate driver licence theory test before their licence will be re-issued – about time, just automatically getting your licence back is too easy
  • a licence suspension for accumulating 100 or more demerit points will only reduce the total demerit points by 100 and will not remove all active demerit points on the licence – also good, as often someone could have 400 demerits and get them all wiped for just a three month suspension
  • penalties for speeding (caught by a cop) decrease in monetary value (now only $50 to $150) but demerits increase (25 to 75 points) – I support the general change but do think 50 demerits for doing 121 km/hr on a motorway is somewhat harsh.
  • radar detectors will be illegal and possession will cost $150 and 75 demerits – I don’t support this (and no I don’t have one). Merely owing a piece of equipment should not be illegal.  And this will just lead to such features being added to cellphones or blackberries, so they are undetectable.
  • failing to stop at give way sign, stop sign and red light will incur 25, 50 and 75 demerits.  A bit harsh at the upper ends but something I generally support – red light runners are a hazard.  I suspect with 75 demerits involved more people will litigate these in future.
  • Failing to wear a seatbelt will get 25 demerits and $50 fine.  The stupidest part of the proposals (which are generally good).  Taking away someone’s licence because they (for example) did not wear a seat belt as a passenger is daft.

Overall the strategy and direction seem sound.  However the exact thresholds and penalty levels may be somewhat too heavy handed and there is some risk of a backlash.  If hundreds of thousands of drivers end up getting suspended licenses because for example they got caught speeding once at 121 km/hr and then 18 months later were pinged for not having on a seatbelt in a quick taxi ride, well it could be as popular as a poll tax.

But overall it should help reduce the road toll, which is what we want.

Moore on Poverty

Mike Moore writes in the Herald linking democracy, or the lack of it, to poverty. Extracts:

Poor democracies have always outperformed authoritarian societies. Democracies score 20 to 40 per cent better even in poor nations, whether it be life expectancy, infant mortality, or farm production and clean water.

Democracies are less corrupt, more efficient because leaders are held accountable, and an active civil society and free media are the watchdogs, the cleansing air of transparency, and the adaptability of democracy drives up better results.

There has never been a famine in a democracy, no two democracies have even gone to war, and where there are democracies the numbers of civil wars go down. No evidence was produced to back up the claim that dictatorships do better.

While I am in total agreement with what Moore is saying, I think he slightly over-states the case about no democracies having gone to war.  There are a couple of dozen or arguable cases listed here.  However that does not detract that generally fully democratic states don’t tend to go to war against each other.

Democracy is more than having a vote, it’s also about freedoms such as property and human rights. This interests me because I’m a congenital do-gooder and know-all.

I think this point is worth stressing.  A vote every three years is a small part of the equation.  I value my voice more than my vote.  The right to free speech, to advocate, to criticise are crucial parts of a democratic society.

Why is it that countries that should be wealthy, that have resources, have continued to underperform? Poverty is a man-made thing so we can fix it, but how and what works and what fails? What’s the common denominator in success and failure?

Imagine how rich certain states with massive oil resources would be if they were governed democratically?

Open economies always do better. Trade and competition drive up results and help to combat corruption, as well as allocate resources more efficiently. Private ownership, spread through society, works.

Without secure property rights, poverty will endure, corruption remains endemic, and investment withers. People without property rights cannot realise on their assets.

Indeed.  Those who dismiss property rights lightly do not realise how crucial they are to a prosperous economy.  No, they are not an absolute, but they are incredibly important.  Just look at places without them.

When China established de facto securitisation of property and liberalised agriculture, productivity jumped some 42 per cent between 1978 and 1984. Its more open economy has helped to lift hundreds of millions out of extreme poverty.

China is just one example of the empirical evidence backing up the theory.  Look at their perfromance also in more recent times?  Also compare the stark contrast of West vs East Germany and North vs South Korea.  There is no need to keep debating the issue -we’ve had 40 year experiments with conclusive results. The challenge should be how to improve democracy, human rights and property rights throughout the globe.  Because that is the longer term solution to poverty.

The thin end of the wedge

A perfect example of the thin end of the wedge problem.

Switzerland has just installed speed cameras on its ski fields.  Ridiculous.  The aim is to go as fast as possible!

If they want less accidents then they should sell less tickets onto the fields.

Hat Tip: Instapundit

John Key – rock thief!

Hooton on 2008

Hooton makes an interesting point in the SST:

Labour will have no better luck with policy in 2008. The fragile consensus around its flagship emissions trading scheme will begin to crack as farmers and manufacturers ask why their industry representatives are acquiescing to a policy they believe is overly complex and which will impose costs on them well above their international competitors’, all in the name of allowing Clark to prattle on about carbon neutrality despite her government having a worse record on climate change than the administration of George W Bush. Cullen’s $1.5 billion in tax cuts will also fail to be credible to voters, but in proceeding with them he will legitimise National’s bolder moves. He will not be able to reconcile his claims that his $6.4 billion in election-year bribes would not be inflationary but National’s promises would be.

I think Labour has a significant risk of delivering tax cuts, yet getting no credit for them because everyone knows they have been done so grudgingly.  But what they will do is give political cover for National’s tax cuts.  Hard to demonise tax cuts when you deliver some yourself.

To become prime minister, Key needs merely to brace himself for the unprecedentedly vicious attacks on his character that are inevitable from Clark’s desperate gang; show he can restore the vital x-factor of national self-belief that has been eroded this past decade; demonstrate to the Maori Party that he will support their aspirations, and commit himself to the highest standards of personal and political integrity to ensure that 2011 is also in the bag.

Key’s character will be attacked, beyond doubt.  I fully expect that they will pull out some accuser who claims that 26 years ago John Key was rude to her or something.

I am told the print edition has Matthew’s 2008 predictions.  I don’t yet have that, so may blog that later.