McCarten on Labour

Matt McCarten writes in the HOS:

Labour had a terrible finish to last year. Any hope for respite in 2008 was smashed within minutes of the New Year. Just after midnight, some wannabe drove up on a scooter to Helen Clark’s electoral office and threw a brick at the window…

But the political relevance of this action was that the offender released a press statement afterwards saying it was motivated by the new Electoral Finance Act which came into force on January 1. It’s clear the controversy over this legislation isn’t going away as the Government hoped. Labour’s party strategists would sense this is a warning of more headaches to come.

For example, in the past few days a website was set up opposing the re-election of the Labour Party. The website creator refuses to register himself as required by the new act.

The ensuing media attention has resulted in this website’s domain name being extensively published and will make the website more successful than the creator could have hoped.

More dangerously for Labour, Invercargill Mayor and occasional revolutionary, Tim Shadbolt, is heading up a campaign to also tip the Government out of office because of education funding cuts to the Southland Institute of Technology.

Shadbolt is also required to register himself under the act, which he has no intention of doing. I’m sure he can’t believe his good luck his campaign will get even more profile.

I agree with former Labour leader Mike Moore, when he says the new laws are badly constructed and target the wrong problems. It is clear the print media is going to run a year-long campaign opposing this legislation and will highlight breaches. I can’t think of another time the national media was so united in a political campaign. It’s extraordinary that Labour has put itself in this position.

A political colleague of mine told me on the eve of the bill’s passing that if Labour had any hope of retaining the Treasury benches, it must pull it.

The electoral finance reform was well-intentioned and tried to address secret funding. But Labour’s paranoia has created problems far worse than the solution. Ironically, political party spending isn’t, in the scheme of things, that important. The big parties are limited to spending $2 million on their election campaigns and rarely raise that amount of money anyway.

Less well-known is the leaders of both main parties get more than $2m each in their parliamentary leader’s budget to spend essentially on whatever they like. When you consider hidden subsidies, such as MP and political staff salaries and expenses during an election period, it amounts to more than $20m.

Even then, most voters are influenced more by media reporting on politics through the year than 30-second ads on television in the last few weeks of the campaign. Party election spending only matters significantly when the support for both parties is close leading up to the election.

… In the next few months, political survival may focus their minds. If face-saving and practicality does not involve a full repeal of this law, they should at least address the more draconian parts of it.

If they don’t, the legislation designed to protect them from their political opponents could well be what tips them out of office on election day.

I don’t think there is any chance at all Labour will repeal or amend the Electoral Finance Act.  Admitting mistakes isn’t something they are into.

My take on the 2007 Dom Post predictions

On Monday I blogged how the Dom Post scored their own predictions, giving themselves 145/190.

Just realised that I blogged a year ago my own predictions on their predictions.  I’ve just scored my own predictions and ended up with 144/190.

My scores in order (and Dom Post in brackets) are

  1. 8 (2)
  2. 10 (10)
  3. 10 (10)
  4. 8 (10)
  5. 7 (6)
  6. 10 (6)
  7. 10 (10)
  8. 7 (8)
  9. 9 (1)
  10. 7 (10)
  11. 4 (3)
  12. 7 (7)
  13. 9 (9)
  14. 8 (10)
  15. 7 (10)
  16. 0 (10)
  17. 6 (10)
  18. 10 (10)
  19. 7 (8)

Death of a blogger

One of the bloggers at Obsidian Wings was Andy Olmsted had been serving in Iraq since  July 2007, training up members of the Iraqi Army.

They have just blogged a post from him, that was to appear only in the event of his death.

He also blogged for Rocky Mountain News which covers his death.

The farewell post from Olmsted is very moving, and the reaction from his friends, family and readers is very raw grief.  It’s a poignant reminder of the tragedy of war, regardless of one’s beliefs in its wisdom or necessity.

The comic genius of Robin Williams

The first David Letterman show of 2008 screened in NZ last night. For those not following, a writers’ guild strike has grounded many shows. Letterman owns his own show so was able to do a deal with the union. Jay Leno is in trouble with the union because he dared to write his own jokes, which makes him a strike breaker!

Anyway I enjoy Letterman, especially the regular segments such as the Top Ten and Famous Presidential Speeches. Letterman is a good comedian.

But his guest last night was Robin Williams, and Williams is just non stop hilarious. It was quite a contrast as Williams came on and just took over the show for a few minutes.

The You Tube above shows the first eight minutes And Williams comes on at 4.45 minutes. The top ten is on before that so worth seeing it all. He just takes the piss out of Letterman’s beard calling him General Lee, Rabbi, Grandpa, etc. It’s take a full two minutes for Letterman to get a question in.

The 40 Most Obnoxious Quotes Of 2007

Okay here are from Right Wing News, so others may have their own list (but they do include an Ann Coulter quote on their list) but plenty here to despair at.  Some of the worst for me:

34) “Perhaps the outpouring of sympathy for [the falsely arrested Duke lacrosse players] Reade Seligman, Collin Finnerty and David Evans is just a bit misplaced….As students of Duke University or other elite institutions, these young men will get on with their privileged lives….They are very differently situated in life from, say, the young women of the Rutgers University women’s basketball team.” — Nightline co-anchor Terry Moran explains how the men falsely accused of rape got off light compared to the women who were called “nappy headed hos”

Oh yes being falsely accused and arrested for rape is nothing compared with being called a name, because one group is “privileged”.

29) “Well, because the Arabs who were involved in 9/11 cooperated with the Zionists, actually. It was a cooperation. They gave them the perfect excuse to denounce all Arabs. It’s a racist sort of thing, really racist – you know, picking out these 19 or 20 terrorists – they were terrorists – and saying all the Arabs are like them.” — Former Democratic Senator James Abourezk on Hizbullah TV

Didn’t you know 9/11 is a Zionist plot.  Jew the Jooos did it. What is said it to have this level of insanity coming from a former Senator.

15) “America needs to follow the policies it has introduced in Germany. We have to go through a certain de-Nazification process.” — George Soros

 Need anything be said.

25) “When I see a stroller now, I see it as someone who evicted a person with AIDS, right or wrong.” — Brian Basinger, president of the Harvey Milk Lesbian Gay Bisexual and Transsexual Democratic Club on the horror of having to live near heterosexual families in San Francisco.

Yes how dare those dirty heterosexuals live near us.  Quite amusing that gay rights has gone so far we now have gays bigoted against heterosexuals.

NZ Blogosphere blog

Tumkee has set up a blog to record the NZ blogosphere.  That’s a great public service, and through it I have already found some new blogs.

He also ranks the blogs with a score based on estimated average daily unique visits + incoming links + average posts per week.   You can quibble about the methodology but there is no right or wrong – it is all subjective.

Fairfax editorials differ on honours

Today both The Press and the Dom Post did editorials on the New Years Honours, with significant disagreement between them.

The Press says:

The unlikely figure of Don McKinnon, the former senior National politician and Commonwealth Secretary-General, was the sole new member of the ONZ, which is limited to no more than 20 living New Zealanders.

McKinnon is an amiable and consensual character, qualities that made him a successful chief whip and deputy prime minister for his National Party, but these same qualities might also help explain why the Commonwealth did not make significant progress under his executive leadership. Had he successfully restored the organisation’s relevance, there would have been an argument for his ONZ.

The Dom Post however takes the opposite view:

There can be few who would quibble with the inclusion of Don McKinnon in ranks of those with the Order of New Zealand, the pinnacle of a system that became fully domesticated in 1996. The secretary-general of the Commonwealth for the past eight years, Mr McKinnon was, before that, the affable deputy prime minister and foreign minister during the Bolger administration and played an important part in brokering the Bougainville ceasefire. His quiet achievement ranks well against the likes of fellow Order members Whetu Tirikatane Sullivan and Jonathan Hunt.

The rest of the editorial is the normal Saturday tongue in cheek:

However, it is those that should have been there but who are not that is of concern. Where, we wonder, was the announcement that Trevor Mallard was being made an Officer of the New Zealand Order of Merit for his services to boxing? And surely Tau Henare deserved an award of similar stature for his work in raising the art of provocation to new heights?

Even leaving aside the shock omission of Mr Mallard, the Government was far too modest when it came to considering honours for its own members. Michael Cullen has worked long and hard to stop New Zealanders from unwise spending, admittedly using the rather blunt tool of taking a good chunk of their cash off them in taxes and hoarding it on their behalf rather than convincing them to save, but received no recognition. Helen Clark herself has performed similarly sterling work in keeping New Zealanders safe from exposure to dangerous opinions in shepherding through the Electoral Finance Act. Again, she was passed over.

Heh.

UN and suicide bombings

Following the suicide bombing which killed Benazir Bhutto (or at least her supporters), the Simon Wiesenthal Center has taken out a full page ad in the NY Times calling for the UN to address suicide bombings which have now killed people in 30 different countries.  They warn one day a suicide bomber with access to biological weapons will create a headline of 100,000 killed.

The UN may not have time to do this though.  They have been busy voting to condemn “defamation of religions”. Are they concerned about people rubbishing scientology?
No they express “deep concern that Islam is frequently and wrongly associated with human rights violations and terrorism”.

So instead of condemning suicide bombings, they condemn those who point out the common factor in almost all suicide bombings.

Dom Post on Nandor

The Dom Post gets onto the Nandor quitting story today. It’s a pity they didn’t acknowledge the Whoar blog as the source of the “speculation”. The story makes it fairly clear it is well beyond speculation incidentally:

Mr Norman confirmed that Mr Tanczos had approached the party leaders and caucus about the possibility of leaving but had made no firm decision yet.

Ms Fitzsimons said she would not ask Mr Tanczos to stay if he decided to leave.

Mr Norman praised Mr Tanczos’ service to New Zealand politics, regardless of what he decided to do. “Nandor’s made a tremendous contribution.”

Sounds like a eulogy to me. Incidentally one wrong detail in the story:

If Mr Tanczos does quit, the next person on the party list would normally take his place. Though there are two before Mr Norman – former MP Mike Ward and Catherine Delahunty – neither co-leader would deny suggestions the two would step aside to allow Mr Norman to enter Parliament, and boost the party’s profile, in the runup to the election. Mr Ward and Ms Delahunty could not be reached.

When a vacancy for a List MP occurs, the Chief Electoral Office has a two stage process to go through. First they check with the party secretary if the candidate is still a party member, and then they check if the candidate will accept the post.

In the case of Mike Ward, I suspect he is no longer a party member. If memory serves me correctly he announced he was supporting or joining National at the end of 2006.

My memory failed.  I was confusing Ward with Ian Ewen-Street.  Both from the same region.

Iowa Entrance Polls

CNN has some interesting data in the entrance polls they did in Iowa.  First the Republicans:

  •  Huckabee had 40% support from women and only 29% from men.  Thompson took some of his male support.
  • McCain got 17% amongst those who thought events in Pakistan were very important and 3% amongst those who said not too important.
  • 60% of Iowa Republicans are born-agains or evangelicals and they were 46% Huckabee to 19% Romney.  Amongst those who are not, it is 33% Romney, 14% Huckabee
  • 13% of those voting were Independents and 29% of them voted Ron Paul
  • 67% said religious beliefs matter a great deal or somewhat

Now the Democrats:

  • Obama beats Clinton amongst female voters 35% to 30%
  • Clinton gets 33% to 31% for Obama for those who says events in Pakistan very important
  • Amongst registered Democrats it is Obama 32% to Clinton 31%.  But for Independents (who were 20% of the caucus attendees) it is 41% Obama to 17% Clinton
  • Clinton narrowly leads 29% to 28% amongst married attendees but for singles it is Obama 43% to 24% for Clinton.
  • Obama does better amongst very liberal and somewhat liberal attendees than moderates.
  • Edwards was highest amongst people who had attended a caucus before (30%) but for first timers Obama got 41%.
  • 52% say the top quality is ability to bring about change, and of those 51% voted Obama.
  • Obama got 57% of under 30s (who made up 22% of the attendees) to 11% for Clinton.  Of those over 65 (also 22%) it is 45% Clinton and 18% Obama.

This is all invaluable data for the campaign strategists.  Looking at this Clinton is in real trouble.  Also Huckabee’s victory is less impressive when you see where his support comes from.

Chill Simon!

Simon Power is doing a great job getting daily headlines about the seriously dysfunctional Corrections Department.

But I don’t think we need to get too worked up about two Corrections staffers turning up to a famous NZers themed Xmas Party as David Bain and Ahmed Zaoui.

I would rather costumes for parties are not political issues!

Business ideas which won’t work

Rod Drury writes in the Herald about business ideas that won’t work.  A very interesting read.  Some of those he advises against:

  • Anything that involves text messaging or mobile data as margins from carriers too low
  • Taking on Trade Me as they already have all the customers
  • Anything aimed at taking bricks and mortar retailers online due to history of failure
  • Anything to do with document or content management as done before
  • A start up involving retail point of sale will not work as cost of sales and support too high
  • An export-focused business where the founders are not willing to travel abroad
  • A business where the founder is not happy to step aside and let another person be the CEO
  • Any business depending on low-cost Google AdWords as their cost will rise
  • Any software business where the software development is outsourced to a consulting company as not nimble enough
  • Any business without a business plan will not work

Looks a pretty useful list to me.  Any that people disagree with or that they would add on?

National Review on Obama victory

A good comment on Obama winning the caucus vote in a state which is 90% white:

Obama’s immense victory. Yes, it’s early, yes, a lot could happen. But a man who could not have used certain restrooms forty years ago is in the center ring, not as a freak in the manner of Alberto Fujimori or Sonia Gandhi, nor even as a faction fighter in the style of Jesse Jackson, but as a real player. One of our great national sins is being obliterated, as the years pass, by the virtues of our national system. I don’t agree with Obama and I don’t particularly like him, but I am proud of this moment.

It is somewhat staggering that indeed just 40 years ago there was segregation in the US, and now Obama is a very serious candidate for the presidency.

It’s Obama and Huckabee

Fox News reports that Obama has won Iowa on the Democratic side, with Clinton and Edwards locked in battle for 2nd place.

Huckabee has won on the Republican side, with Romney 2nd and Thompson a distant 3rd.

More details to come.

UPDATE: Huckabee at 34%, Romney at 25%.  Thompson 14%.  Romney really needs to beat McCain in New Hampshire now.

Obama got a very big margin also at 37% to 30% for both Clinton and Edwards.

The close races have led to a huge increase in turnout it seems. They expected 230,000 over both parties and will have over 300,000.  That’s 10% of the state taking time to actually attend a meeting (not just cast a vote at any time of the day) and participate.

Pinched Policies

Just seen a release from Craig Foss on another pinched policy. According to him,Labour has swiped the following policies from National, so no wonder they are not all released too early:

  1. agriculture and horticulture as NCEA scholarship-level subjects
  2. trades training
  3. instant protection orders
  4. no limit on tax rebates for charitiy donations
  5. literacy policies
  6. income tax cuts

I haven’t checked the details of all these, but could be a useful post to do later this year.

Saudi Blogger arrested

The arrest of the most well known Saudi blogger is covered by The Hive and Poneke.

Poneke says:

Saudi Arabia has no freedoms of speech, political belief, religion or other basic civil rights taken for granted in New Zealand and other democracies. The Koran is the Islamic kingdom’s constitution. When a young Saudi woman sentenced to 90 lashes after being gang-raped had the sentence increased to 200 lashes when she appealed, international pressure forced King Abdullah to pardon her. Some of that pressure came from our own prime minister. She could do well to speak out in support of Fouad al-Farhan too.

And the Hive is explicit:

New Zealand also doesn’t normally hold back when Saudi Arabia oversteps the mark. Even when we are in the middle of free trade negotiations with Saudi Arabia and the other members of the Gulf Cooperation Council. So why doesn’t New Zealand say something about Fouad al-Farham?? We have checked the Beehive website, Winston Peters’ Beehive page, MFAT’s homepage, and Scoop, but find nothing. The Hive team hopes that New Zealand attitudes to freedom of expression abroad have not changed as a result of the Electoral Finance Act coming into force.

I of course support their call for the NZ Government to make representations to the Saud Government on behalf of Fouad al-Farhan.

No Right Turn has details of how to e-mail the Ambassador to protest.

Lenin on Ice

An amazing little find in the South Pole.  Stuff reports that a old Soviet team from 1958 stuck the bust of Lenin on top of their hut, and it can now be seen.

leninice.JPG

Ironic that in the old USSR they have town down most of the statues to Lenin, so only in the most remote place in the world does his legacy survive!

102 year old moving to NZ

My first reaction upon reading the NZPA story about a 102 year old moving to NZ was negative.  Immigration policy is usually not to allow people in who are no longer earning as they are a burden and cost to the taxpayer.

Then I read on about how he is married to a 87 year old NZ born wife, and of course that changes things – he has every right to move here with her.

And then even further on I read that he served in WWII as a Surgeon Commander on the aircraft carrier HMS Indomitable, and my view is he would be welcome to move here at any age, regardless of whether he is married to a Kiwi or not.

That would be a good policy.  That NZ will allow any veteran of WWII [well any Allied veteran :-)] to live in NZ, as gratitude to their service. We owe them so much.

Read the full story also about how they fell in love.  It’s charming.

Most popular names

The Press has the list of most popular baby names in 2007.  Top tens are:

Boys:
1 Jack
2 James
3 Joshua
4 Daniel
5 William
6 Oliver
7 Samuel
8 Benjamin
9 Ethan
10 Ryan

Girls:
1 Ella
2 Sophie
3 Olivia
4 Emma
5 Charlotte
6 Emily
7 Lily
8 Grace
9 Hannah
10 Isabella

On the boys side I am surprised David doesn’t make the top 30.  It is normally fairly high up the ranks. How can there be more Noahs!  None of the boy names are too bad though.  I like Christopher as a name but note that is also not on top 30 – I am very much out of fashion.

Emma, Charlotte, and Grace are all names I love for girls. Lucy, Holly and Samantha I like also.  I would never ever call a child Chloe though – blame Wainuiomata for that one.

Trotter on Nandor

Chris Trotter writes in the Dominion Post on Nandor Tanczos.  He refers my blog post on Whoar stating that Nandor will stand down for Russel Norman this year.  It’s actually Whoar which should be credited incidentally.

Captain Oates’ heroic act of self-sacrifice is probably the best remembered episode in Robert Falcon Scott’s doomed expedition to the South Pole.

And now, if we are to believe David Farrar’s Kiwiblog, a similar one-way journey is to be made into the political storm currently immobilising New Zealand’s parties of the Left.

Tragically, the man about to step outside the tent would appear to be the most colourful, the most original, and the most principled of all the parliamentarians ushered in by the age of MMP: Nandor Tanczos.

Like Captain Oates, it seems that Mr Tanczos is motivated by the conviction that his departure will give his comrades a much better chance of survival.

I have to say when Nandor first became an MP, I have a particularly strong dislike of him. I thought the skateboarding stuff looked try hard, and he seemed to be a single issue politician on cannabis.

But my opinion has certainly changed over time.  While obviously still disagreeing on most policy areas, I’ve seen him  as a consicientous and hard working MP who takes his job seriously.  The clean slate legislation is due to him (I actually think it is bad law, but that doesn’t affect the fact he achieved a good result for something he supported) and he has been one of the best informed and well researched MPs on technology issues.  He even got The Parliamentary Service to allow him to put Firefox instead of IE on his laptop!

So I do agree with Chris Trotter that it will be a pity if Nandor does resign before his term is up.

Also Nandor is from the anarchist side of the Greens while Russel Norman is from the communist side, and given a choice between an anarchist and a communist, I’ll choose the anarchist 🙂

All you want to know about selecting a Presidential nominee

Graeme Edgeler at Public Address has blogged at length on how the US primary and caucuses work on selecting a presidential nominee for both party.  It’s very comprehensive and a great read.

Incidentally while winning the Iowa caucus is obviously very desirable for the candidates, it is by no means a lock for the nomination.  Far from it.

In 1992 Bill Clinton only got 3% in Iowa but went on to win the nomination. In 1988 the nominee Michael Dukakis got 22% and was 3rd

For the Republicans in 1988 Bob Dole beat VP (and nominee) George HW Bush by 37% to 19%.  Pat Robertson got 25%.

And ironically in 1980 George HW Bush beat Ronald Reagan by 32% to 30%.

Nevertheless almost the entire political world is focused on Iowa today to get their first hint of who might be the future Commander-in-Chief.

NZ born Journalist wins person of the year in Hong Kong

Just read at the Herald:

Hong Kong’s best-known Western journalist, New Zealander Kevin Sinclair, who died of cancer last week, has been named person of the year in a prestigious annual poll.

Sinclair, 65, beat Hong Kong Chief Executive Donald Tsang and pro-democracy champion Anson Chan to the title in a poll by the Government-run radio station RTHK, winning four times as many votes as any other challenger.

I mean this with no disrespect to NZ journalists, but it is hard to imagine a journalist winning a popular contest for NZer of the Year.   Very very few journalists are household names.

Tourism at risk from carbon policy?

A somewhat alarming report on NBR about the effect on tourism to NZ from Government policy.  To quote:

New Zealand’s adoption of a carbon neutrality policy, and the world’s toughest emission reduction targets, will have a disastrous effect on its biggest foreign exchange earner, tourism, and there are no solutions in sight, university experts say.

… Physics researchers Dr Inga Smith and Dr Craig Rodger say their findings on the sheer size of the emissions and difficulties in offsetting them have far-reaching implications for both the tourism industry and efforts to achieve carbon neutrality.

Awareness of the environmental impact of long-haul flights is increasingly influencing tourists destination decisions. As tourism is New Zealands number one export earner, these findings are cause for some concern, Dr Rodger says.

… We investigated several domestically-based offsetting scenarios involving either increased reliance on sustainable energy sources or reducing emissions. Unfortunately, none of the scenarios currently appear to be economically or technically feasible, Dr Smith says.

For example, the installation of 4,250 one megawatt wind turbines to replace existing fossil fuel-based power generation would offset the visitors emissions, but only at a cost of at least $10 billion, or $4150 per visitor, she says.

Such a switch would be highly challenging both in cost and finding acceptable places to put them.

Helen’s aspirational goal is carbon neutrality.  So the question is do we stop tourists coming to NZ (which would kill many sectors of the economy) or do we spend $10 billion offsetting it?

The wonders of GPS

A Sydney Morning Herald story on the wonders of GPS.  I have GPS both for the car and on my phone and it is a wonder.

It’s interesting that up until 2000 they deliberately transmitted an error so that your location was incorrect by up to 30 metres.  This was to keep it primarily for military use.  Now it is generally accurate to under 10 metres.

I suspect within five years GPS will be a standard feature of new cars.  It will take longer to be a standard feature of new phones, but will start to become a regular option for phones with data capability.

The privacy issues are going to be fascinating as more and more people are transmitting their locations.  I wonder how many burglars might get caught because they were stupid enough not to turn off their GPS phone, which will prove they were in a location.

I wonder if you can reverse search GPS?  As in could one find out how many devices (and who they belong to) were in a 10 square metre area between two times?  Could be very powerful.

No Right Turn wrong on the law

Normally I would just leave a comment, but as you can’t comment any more on No Right Turn I should point out that he has it quite wrong when he says about the Don’t vote Labour website:

Where the site does violate the law is in not carrying a statement setting out the name and address of its promoter (s53 (1) (a) EFA). But that would have been true under the old law as well. Section 221A (1) of the Electoral Act required advertisements relating to an election to carry such a statement, not just within the regulated period as at present, but at all stages of the electoral cycle.

The old law did not require any authorisation statement because the old law did not define a personal viewpoint on a website as an election advertisement.  To quote Graeme Edgeler:

It would not have been. The provisions of the Electoral Act relating to names and addresses only applied to advertisements (not “any form of words or graphics”), and only applied when those advertisements were published in a newspaper, periodical, poster, or handbill, or were broadcast on radio or television.

And don’t think this is a mistake.  It is deliberate.  Labour and the Greens (and poodles) voted against the following amendment to the exemptions from Chris Flinalyson:

the publication by an individual, on a non-commercial basis, on the Internet of his or her political views

If they had voted for that amendment, then this problem would not be here.  Make sure at the meet the candidates meetings you all ask the Green and Labour candidates why they voted against this amendment.