My name is Earl

I never had time to watch My Name is Earl but heard from friends it was very good.  Luckily Sky put on an all day special of the entire first season, so thanks to My Sky box I’ve now got them all to watch.

It is a bloody great show.  I just love his ex-wife Joy.  Oh yes Randy is great also.

Good sites for students

Just been clearing old e-mails and found one about a useful site – Unifriend, designed for tertiary students.  One section of it, is Rate my Courses.  I think public course appraisals are a great resource for intending students.  And the good thing is the more people who use it, the more reliable it becomes.

NZ webcams

Iowa

Well later today it will be the 3rd in the US, so what is the latest for the nominations?

In the markets, Clinton has made a recovery and gone from 55c to around 62c, While Obama drops from 25c to 25c.  That is the cost of buying “shares” which will pay $1 if that candidate wins.  However this is not for the outcome in Iowa, but who will get the nomination overall.  But the direction is interesting.

Turning to specific polls in Iowa, there have been five in the last few days.  They have shown (from oldest to most recent) Clinton +1%,  Clinton +2%, Obama +7%, Obama +3% and a Clinton-Obama tie.  So who the hell knows.  The average of those five has Clinton on 28.6%, Obama on 29.0% and Edwards 26.0% so it is a very close three-way race.

The next state up is New Hampshire and Clinton leads by 5.7% on average there.  However whoever wins Ohio should get momentum from that and New Hampshire may change.

The markets for the Republican nomination has Romney at 33c, McCain 25c, Giuliani 22c, and Huckabee 13c.  But again that is for the evental nominee.  In the last week Giuliani has dropped from 1st to 3rd.

The state polls for Iowa are just as close as the Democrats. Four polls in the last few days and the results have been Romney +3%, Huckabee +6%, Romney +2%, Huckabee +2%.  That’s an average of 29.0% Huckabee, 28.3% Romney.

There’s some speculation Ron Paul could come third.  McCain is on 13%, Thompson 12% and Paul 8%.  Giuliani effectively isn’t contesting this state.

New Hampshire also looking a great bunfight.  Of the last three polls there where it is McCain vs Romney two have been ties, and one has McCain 9% ahead.  The first poll after the Iowa result will be interesting.  McCain may be the beneficiary of Romney and Huckabee bashing each other.

BBC’s 100 things we did not know last year

The BBC has done its annual list of 100 things we did not know last year. Ones I found interesting:

11. Astronauts wear nappies during launch and re-entry because they can’t stop what they’re doing should they need to urinate.

17. Two cups of spearmint tea a day is thought to control excessive hair growth for women.

23. To be found attractive, women should sway their hips and men their shoulders (although researchers call this a “shoulder swagger”).

31. There is mobile phone reception from the summit of Mount Everest.

33. Female civil servants in India are questioned about their menstrual cycle as part of their appraisal.

48. You can be arrested for using someone’s wi-fi network without permission.

53. Renowned atheist Professor Richard Dawkins likes singing Christmas carols.

60. The Queen took her corgi on honeymoon.

62. Until the late 1990s, the RAF’s nuclear bombs could be activated using a bicycle lock key.

69. Dogs occasionally shoot their owners in the US.

75. CO2 emissions from shipping are twice the level of aviation.

78. A bdelloid rotifer is a pond-dwelling organism that has survived 80 million years without sex.

85. A 23.8lb baby was born in the US in 1879, but it only survived 11 hours. (ouch ouch ouch)

90. Chickens can be diagnosed with depression.

Hat Tip: NewZblog

Sanctions policy criticised

I doubt anyone can disagree with The Press’s criticism of the inconsistent nature of the Government’s sanctions policy towards Fiji.  The key para:

The ease with which sanctions can be undone is shown in New Zealand’s refusal to allow children connected to the Fiji dictatorship’s elite attend the Christchurch scout jamboree. Mild criticism greeted the move, but the criticism grew when the Prime Minister’s secretary was allowed entry. Children, the critics rightly said, were barred from a fun event but a leading member of the dictatorship was allowed in to sit at his wife’s bedside. The critics would have been less effective had the Government consistently enforced its ban.

A blogger’s breakfast!

Former Labour Prime Minister Mike Moore has described the Electoral Finance Act
as a “blogger’s breakfast”.  I love that term. Some extracts:

“It was rushed, badly drafted, can’t be understood, (is) full of inviting loopholes, amendments were made at the last minute without scrutiny, and it’s a blogger’s breakfast,” said Moore, also former director of the World Trade Organisation.

… “I tried to tell old friends that it was wrong in principle, wrong in substance, and will do the opposite of what its authors planned.

“People are going to deliberately test the law and the courts will be in an impossible situation.

“This will be great election year sport because it’s the solemn duty, even obligation, of citizens in a democracy to take on the powerful.”

Indeed it is.

A nice tribute to Don McKinnon

The Herald editorial plays tribute to Don McKinnon.  Some extracts:

There are more Don McKinnons in politics than we usually acknowledge – capable, dependable men and women who could have made a decent Prime Minister and might well have been given the chance in different circumstances. They are typically too loyal to try to topple an incumbent and do not need higher status anyhow to derive immense satisfaction from their public service.

Mr McKinnon can look back on 30 years in public life, the last eight in London leading the Commonwealth Secretariat, in the knowledge that he has always worked to bring people together, not divide them.

… His election made him Deputy Prime Minister when National returned to power in 1990 and he took the job of Foreign Minister. The country has possibly never had a better one. He served longer in the job than anyone before or since and his sure diplomatic touch was never more apparent than when he presided over talks that brought the Bougainville rebellion to a ceasefire that has stuck.

He did not grandstand, as he could have done, when the disputants were brought to a military camp near Christchurch and did not try to make political capital out of the result. He would be the first to share the kudos with his ministry officers.

He was a team player, not a force for change. Had he been more forceful he might have convinced the Bolger government it did not need to parrot Labour’s nuclear policy for political safety. He had a more realistic view of defence.

… Not all members of the Order of New Zealand have seemed worthy of such select company. Don McKinnon is.

A fitting tribute.

I also remember with fondness the story that on the day in June 1984 when Muldoon called the snap election, and was a bit ahem under the weather, McKinnon arranged for all four tires on his car to be let down so Muldoon couldn’t drive himself home!

No more taxpayer-funded massages for civil servants

Wrinkled

Spent a gorgeous four hours or so last night drinking champagne in a spa pool until around midnight.  A friend is house sitting up in Roseneath, so half a dozen of us had a small gathering there.  The house is amazing, and the spa pool over looks the harbour with an amazing view.

As expected though, when you finally get out of the water, you are more wrinkled than a Winston voter.  I don’t think I’ve ever stayed in a spa pool quite so long before.

Domestic DPF

NYE had around a dozen of us at Auckland Girl’s place for a party.  We had most of the evening there and then went down to Blair Street a bit before midnight.  Lots of fun, and good catching up with old friends.

The amusing part for me was during the evening.  All the other guys had gone out to buy some pizza, so was just me and the girls.  And one of them tripped or stumbled in her heels and pushed a bowl and a glass of red wine off the bench.

The wine glass smashed and the red wine, as it does, created a huge stain on the carpet.

Now I am not the most domestic person, but one thing I do know is cleaning up red wine stains (thanks to Cork King).  So as the girls were debating what to do, I got them to pass me some salt and a knife, and kneeling down on the floor carefully spread mounds of salt over the wine to soak it up.

At that stage a couple of the guys turns up, and it is a pretty funny scene with the girls standing about while I’m the one down on my hands and knees laying salt to clean up.

The good news is the salt did its job, with most of the colour gone.

Making money from student loans

The Press has an article about how student debt is up and repayments are down since student loans went interest-free.

I was interested to see Duty Minister say this:

Duty Minister David Parker said people using the interest-free loans to make money for themselves was “deplorable behaviour”, but it was not widespread.

It is not deplorable, but common sense.  If you hand out money and don’t have any incentives for people to pay it back when are able to, then of course some will use it to invest.  Dr Cullen should be pleased that people save it instead of spend it.

A new website

People are stubborn creatures. If you tell us you can’t do something, then someone will go and do it, even though they never would have done it before it became prohibited.

The irony of the Electoral Finance Act is it may lead to many more people going out of their way to campaign against a party or parties, then would have been the case when there were no significant restrictions on doing so.

So with that I note some people have set up a website called Don’t Vote Labour. It is clearly an illegal election advertisement under the Electoral Finance Act as it advocates against a party, and does not have a name and address of its promoter on the site.

They even have this badge people can put on their own sites:

www.dontvotelabour.org.nz

Of course if Labour, United Future, NZ First and the Greens had not voted down the amendment which would have expanded the exemption for non-commercial blogs to all non-commercial Internet speech, then the site wouldn’t be illegal.

Incidentally I’ve had nothing to do with the site (as in first I knew about it was an e-mail), but one of the creators has asked me to do a short summary of the EFA for the site, which I have provided to them.

Risking power shortages

The former Electricity Commission chairman has said that NZ will be at risk of power shortages under the Government’s energy strategy.

NZ currently has one of the highest levels of renewable power in the word with around two thirds renewable.  The Government is going to move to 90% renewable, which will involve a lot more wind power.

Now I am a big fan of wind power but it has its limitations. As Hemmingway says:

It was possible to predict the amount of wind energy available over the course of a whole year, but it was “very difficult” to predict how much wind power might be possible at the exact time it was needed to meet demand.

This is why you need a balance.  More hydro will help but the RMA makes this very time consuming to get consent for.

The change is estimated to increase power costs by 30% to 40% over a few years.  That will hurt badly those on fixed incomes.

Fran on Owen Glenn

It’s all about me!

Adolf at No Minister has a very amusing comparison between Exodus 14:21-26 and the anti Electoral Finance Bill battle, in response to someone claiming I don’t walk on water (which is a pity as would be very useful in Wellington where even in summer the water is freezing).

People Power criticise me for criticising them for throwing a brick into Helen Clark’s electorate office window.

Poneke labels me a celebthority: “Journalists seeking a quick quote ask him about almost any topic known to humanity, and he always obliges”. Poneke is having a bit of fun – almost all my media activity is related to politics or technology, which are two areas I know a bit about.  And I did once refuse to comment on a story – TV wanted comment on the profile of a typical child porn user – I decided there are some things best not to appear an authority on!  The NZPA news database has me in the news 97 times in 2007, which is around 96 times more often than I would have thought likely when I started blogging.  It is a mixture of stuff – EFB/A, sedition, spam law, copyright law etc.

Andrei at TBR follows the progress of the eight for 2008 meme I passed on.

Ouch

The Order of NZ

The award to Don McKinnon of membership of The Order of New Zealand got me wondering about how often people with political affiliations get appointed to it.

Not that there is anything wrong with political affiliations.  Few would say someone who spent ten years as Head of the Commonwealth is undeserving, and I am sure he got it more for that than his years as National Deputy PM.

Anyway which appointees have had political affiliations:

National

Jim Bolger
Don McKinnon
Labour

Whetu Tirakatene-Sullivan
Ken Douglas
Mike Moore
Cath Tizard
Jonathan Hunt
Paul Reeves
Arnold Nordmeyer
Jim Knox
Sonia Davies
David Lange

So has it been each party appointing their own supporters to the highest honour?  Well let us see who appointed each:

Appointed by National

Mike Moore
Jim Bolger
Ken Douglas
Whetu Tirakatene-Sullivan
Appointed by Labour

Cath Tizard
Jonathan Hunt
Paul Reeves
Arnold Nordmeyer
Jim Knox
Sonia Davies
David Lange
Don McKinnon

So National has appointed one Nat, and three Labour members (plus many who are not political).  Labour has done seven Labour and one National (plus others).

Incidentally there are only 18 ordinary members at the moment, so two more appointments can still be made without waiting for someone to die.

Whoar says Nandor to resign

Phil U at Whoar has blogged the following:

… that nandor will resign from parliament soon.. that the next person on the green party list..catherine delahunty… ..will also stand aside… and that the next person on the green party list..co-leader russell norman..will then take nandors’ place in parliament…

… (disclaimer:..i have known of this fact (of tanczos resigning) for some time now..

way back..i approached him..off the record..and asked if it was true..

he confirmed this..

and i have kept to the ‘off the record’..

’till now..

but when i..and others..are hearing the mechanics of the whole deal being dicussed openly..

..in many many circles..(not just at this party..)

and now this ‘public discussion’..

means to me..that it is on the public record..

(had i just ‘overheard’ this conversation..with no prior knowledge..i would also/still be reporting it to you..just with a tad less certainty..)

..and that ‘off the record’ pledges are now void..

so..in a nutshell..

nandor to resign from parliament..

and soon..!

Three points:

  1. I have no independent confirmation of this story. I am merely quoting what Phil U has said. Phil is a former activist and member of the Greens, I believe.
  2. Anyone reporting this should credit to to Whoar.
  3. The combination of overhearing it, and the alleged confirmation make it more credible.

The easiest way to resolve this will be for someone to ask the Greens.

General Debate 1 January 2008

So very true

Right-wing?

NewstalkZB has reported on the attack on the PM’s electorate office, and I was interested in this paragraph:

It is the second time the Prime Minister’s Electoral Office has been targeted by vandals. Right-wing activist Tim Selwyn took to the office with an axe in November 2004. He was later jailed for willful damage, publishing a seditious statement about the act and fraud.

Now labels are never that useful at the best of times, especially when it comes to Tim 🙂

But considering the 2004 brick incident was to protest the Foreshore & Seabed Act, labelling it as the work of a right-wing activist is somewhat misleading. If one has to use a label I would say a Maori sovereignty activist.

Incidentally I am quoted on Radio NZ criticising this attack.

Questions and Answers on the Electoral Finance Act

As a guide to readers, I have put together a Q&A on how the Electoral Finance Act works, so people can try and avoid breaking the law. Four points:

  1. I am not a lawyer.
  2. Read what the Electoral Commission has published and read the Act.
  3. Feedback, additions and corrections are welcome on the Q&A, which I will make a permanent link on the sidebar.
  4. It is designed to cover advocacy by members of the public only, it doesn’t try to cover everything about the Act.

What now qualifies as an election advertisement?

An election advertisement is “any form of words or graphics” which can reasonably be regarded as encouraging or persuading voters to vote for or not vote for a party or a candidate or a type of party or candidate [S5(1)]

So give me some examples?

Anything along the lines of “Do not vote for Party X” or “Do not support Candidate Y” is captured by S5(1)(a).

Stating “Vote for parties which support Kyoto” would be captured by S5(1)(b) as this refers to a type of party. It is highly likely “Vote for tax cuts” would also be captured.

Less clear, would be statements like “Party X is anti-worker” as it does not mention voting but could be reasonably regarded as encouraging people away from that party.

Statements for and against the Government, without mentioning parties, are also captured, as the Government represents a type of parties. So “throw out the Government” is definitely captured, and even “time for a change” could be captured if seen to relate to the election.

If one harshly condemns a Government policy, there is some risk depending on how you do it. Saying “We do not think the Government’s education policy is fair” should be okay. But if your rhetoric was “The Government’s education policy is unfair, unjust, and a disaster for provincial New Zealand and we want people to do everything they can to stop it” then a reasonable person could arguably regard that as encouraging people to vote against the Government.

One is best to get legal advice on the borderline cases.

What if we wish to publish in support of a party or candidate?

You can not do this at any stage (not just in election year) unless you gain written permission from the party’s financial agent [S65(1)] or the candidate’s financial agent [S65(2)].

What sorts of “words and graphics” are captured?

In essence everything except oral speech. The Electoral Act 1993 narrowly defined an advertisement as only something published in a newspaper, a periodical, a poster, a handbill, or broadcast on radio or TV [S221A(1)].

The Electoral Finance Act expands this definition to include anything at all issued, handed out or displayed to the public, anything sent to any member of the public, anything delivered to any member of the public, anything in a film or video, anything distributed over the Internet or stored electronically in any way which is accessible to the public. [S4(1)]. Basically every form of written communication there is.

So oral speech is okay?

Yes. The Select Committee did include a clause to capture oral speech, but after protests the Government removed that clause.

What is exempted?

The main exemption which could apply to members of the public are material on news media Internet sites and personal political views on blogs. [S5(2)]. Leaving comments on such sites or setting up your own (non-commercial) blog means posting your views on parties will not be an election advertisement.

How about other websites?

They are not exempted. A post on a Trade Me Forum or in an Internet newsgroup which advocates for or against a party or candidate is now a regulated election advertisement.

The same goes for You Tube. If you upload a video to You Tube which is seen to encourage or persuade people to vote for or against a party or candidate, then you need to comply with the identification requirements of the Act.

What do I have to do to not break the law if I wish to publish my view in such a way it will be deemed an election advertisement?

Under S63(2) you need to include your name and address with what you publish.

Even if it is a placard in a protest march?

Yes. If you make the placard itself (and it advocates against a party) you need to put your name and address on it. If a march organizer produced the placard for you, then it is their name and address that needs to be on it.

And even if I just make a post to an Internet newsgroup or upload a video to You Tube?

Yes. For example the anti John Key video done by The Standard would break the law if done in 2008, as it does not include a name and address of its promoter/producer.

And does this apply even if what I do costs very little, if any, money?

Yes. The regulation applies to any form of words or graphics. It is of course highly unlikely the electoral authorities and the Police are going to investigate or prosecute minor cases, but nevertheless you will be at some risk if you do not comply, and someone lodges a complaint against you.

Now what is the case if I do want to spend money advocating for or against a party or candidate?

Under S63(3) you can spend up to $12,000 advocating for or against a party before having to register as a third party. You should register once you even have the intention to spend more than that. If you are advocating for or against a candidate you can only spend $1,000 before registering. All amounts include GST.

And then if I register?

If you apply to register as a third party, and are successful with your application, you can spend up to $120,000 in total and if you are advocating for or against a candidate you can only spend $4,000 in relation to that candidate. These totals are for all of election year, until election day.

What are the penalties?

Not including your name and address is an illegal practice under S63(4).

If you spend more than $12,000 but less than $120,000 and do not register as a third party that is an illegal practice under S63(4).

If you do not register as a third party and spend more than $120,000 (or $4,000 in relation to a candidate) then that is a corrupt practice under S66(1).

If you do register as a third party and spend spend more than $120,000 (or $4,000 in relation to a candidate) then that is a corrupt practice if done knowingly [S122(1)(a)] and an illegal practice if not done knowingly [S122(1)(b)]

An illegal practice under S143 has a maximum fine of $40,000 for financial agents and $10,000 for others.

A corrupt practice under S142 has a maximum fine of $100,000 for financial agents and $40,000 for others plus up to two years imprisonment for either.

Statement about the Electoral Finance Act

It is now 1 January 2008 and much political advocacy for or against a political party and/or candidate [Section 5(1)]is now regulated by the Electoral Finance Act, and treated as an election advertisement unless you qualify for an exemption.

I assert that this website is a blog and published by me on a non-commercial basis, and any views expressed on it by me are my personal political views and under paragraph (g) of Section 5(2) of the Electoral Finance Act, is not an election advertisement.

I further assert that this website is a news media Internet site and that all posts on here are written by me, as the editor, solely for the purpose of informing, enlightening or entertaining readers, and hence also is not an election advertisement under paragraph (d) of Section 5(2) of the Electoral Finance Act.

Bloody Telecom

Okay this is a near unique reason to be peeved at Telecom.  Nothing to do with phone service.

Auckland Girl and I decided to go for a little jog, and I suggested we go to Shelly Bay, go up the path to Massey Memorial and then climb the track to the top of the hill, by the prion rugby league field.  Then after that you go over the hill a bit more and then go down a track by the pine forest, which eventually comes out on Fort Dorest Road next to the Telecom satellite there.  From there you go down onto Massey Road and it’s just 2 or so kms back to the start point along the coast.

masseymap.JPG

The (Google) map above  gives a general idea of where we we planning to go from and to.

I’ve been over the trail many times, but not for over a year.  Anyway we took off at 1 pm and headed up.  Eventually got to the top, and then a faster pace going down the track.  It is always a bit overgrown so you can’t go too fast, and it was rather swampy also.  Auckland Girl was less than pleased with her now stinky shoes.

Then I could see the Telecom satellite dish just 50 metres away and we were just about down to Fort Dorset Road.  And what the hell is at the end of the track?  A fucking great big barbed wire fence, stretching as far as one could see in each direction.

Now the satellite dish itself has of course always been protected, by both an electric fence and barbed wire.  But this is a totally new fence which blocked off all access to the road from the trail. Grrrr.

Couldn’t they have put a sign up at the start of the track saying it is now a dead end! So we had to turn about and head back through the swampy trail again back up to the pine forest.  We then decided that rather than go all the way back the way we came, we’d cut into the pine forest and try and get down to the road from there.  Not necessarily the safest thing we have done as the slope in places is oh 70 degrees or so. But we did find a reasonably safe route which got us down around 1 km from the start, so we could at least finish it with some flat road.

For some reason Auckland Girl is now not so keen for me to choose the next route.

Have actually been getting to do some nice routes over the last week.  On Friday  finally went and visited the Karori Wildlife Sanctuary and did a 2 hour loop track there.  They also have a track up to the Brooklyn wind turbine which I am keen to try out.

Saturday I explored some of the more obscure tracks on Tinakori Hill, going up from the top of the Park Street stairs, up until it joined the Northern Walkway and then north along that until you come out in Wilton.  It’s wonderful having such superb bush walks and tracks just a few minutes from the CBD. The town belt is a wonderful treasure.

Anyway NYE Party tonight, so best go off and get ready for that.  See everyone in 2008!