Field charged on 40 counts

The Police have laid 15 counts of bribery and 25 counts of attempting to pervert justice against Taito Phillip Field.

I can’t wait for the trial!  Maybe they will call on Dr Cullen who even after the Ingram Report came out said that all Field is guilty of is trying to help constituents more than National MPs do.  Unlike Dr Cullen, I won’t pre-judge the result!

Skyline

I’m spending most of the day at a TUANZ strategic meeting, which is up in the Skyline at the top of the Cable Car.

There’s a twp hour period where I’m not involved, so I’m spending that time ctaching up with work. But it’s a pretty pleasant environment to be working in the bar, with a bit of sun, and a superb view of the city.

Thank goodness for data cards!

Christchurch March

On behalf of the organisers:

DEMOCRACY UNDER THREAT

Protest March Victoria Square to Cathedral Square

Wednesday 28 November 12.30.  March starts 1.00pm.

Organiser of the Auckland and Wellington marches John Boscawen will speak.

The last week has seen the most blatant display of political hypocrisy in the nation’s history. At a time when MPs have voted themselves more of your money to express their views, your right to express your own views will be gagged. If this Bill becomes law NZ will have the most restrictive electoral law in the western world.

The New Zealand Human Rights Commission called the bill ‘inherently flawed’ and its provisions a ‘dramatic assault’ on the rights you cherish. Its call on the government to withdraw this bill has been ignored.

Its time to stand up and be counted!

Be there this Wednesday at Victoria Square by 12.30! 

Authorised by

John Boscawen,

P.O. Box 42267, Orakei

Santa and Falun Gong

There was a post yesterday on the Auckland City Vision blog, that I actually agreed with.  That’s noteworthy enough to blog!

They are calling on the Auckland Santa Parade organisers to allow the Falun Gong “Divine Land Marching Band” to take part.

I totally agree. I think it is disgraceful that we self censor ourselves to keep the PRC happy.

Now I wondered what the views of the C&R Councillors would be, especially as one of their own (Michael Barnett) is the Parade Chairman.

I was pleased to find that Aaron Bhatnagar had actually beaten City Vision to it, by blogging on Tuesday that he disagreed with his colleague, and explaining why.

In fact I have to give big kudos to Aaron for keeping the blog going, as a Councillor.  It’s a great way to be accountable, and also to educate people on the issues.  With the election itself over, it’s a great insight into the issues facing the Council – such as this post on what it means to keep rates increases down to inflation.

Also I did have a chuckle at his post showing off the billboards that the John Banks campaign thought up, but didn’t use.

Bunkle to seek diversion

Former Alliance Cabinet Minister Phillida Bunkle is expected to seek diversion in relation to her shoplifting charges.

Seems reasonable. It was only $22, but you do wonder what the hell was she doing.  Unless one is pathologically a thief, or you are so poor that $20 is more than you can afford, why would you shoplift?  And in fact she had $200 in cash on her it seems.  Maybe there was a grudge against the store owner?  It just seems so bizarre.

The law of common sense

The NZ Herald has a good story on Annette King’s new law of common sense, and the second reading of the Electoral Finance Bill.

I suspect lawyers up and down the length of New Zealand are drooling with anticipation at the money they stand to earn from this new law of common sense.

If I was a criminal lawyer with a client in court today, I’d try to get my client off citing this new law of common sense, citing the Minister of Justice. The Judge might just have enough of a sense of humour to at least give it marks for ingenuity.

Roy standing for Wellington Central

ACT Deputy Leader Heather Roy has announced she is standing for Wellington, and has launched her own website for this.

Heather’s my second favourite ACT MP.  Nah – just kidding – first equal with Rodney 🙂

More seriously, this is a good move for ACT.   Wellington Central has one of the highest party votes for ACT in the country. I can’t see any scenario where Grant Robertson won’t retain this seat for Labour (the combined Labour/Green party vote is very high), but it is high profile and having Heather stand here will increase her profile and ACT’s profile in the campaign.

What will be interesting is who stands for National and also who stands for the Greens.  If I were the Greens I would stand Russel Norman here as this is the best party vote seat in the country for the Greens.  If for some reason the Greens looked to get below 5%, Norman could ask voters to vote tactically and vote for him so they do not have centre left votes wasted.

The Masterton child assault case

While I was against the Bradford law (and still are), I have no problems at all with the outcome in Masterton where a father has pleaded guilty to assault and been given nine months’ supervision, including parenting and anger-management courses.

To quote the Police:

The prosecutor in the case, Sergeant Garry Wilson, said police evidence included photos of bruises on the boy’s shoulder and buttocks.

“It irritates me to hear about people being criminalised about light smacking. These were heavy smacks that had a traumatic effect on the child. And the family members were sufficiently concerned to contact police.

“The family have said that it wasn’t the first time,” he added.

The man, who pleaded guilty, told police that he had lost his temper and overreacted.

The boy’s mother was so concerned that she took photos of her son’s injuries and showed them to a relative, who contacted police.

The Borrows amendment (which was my preference as it gave certainty by defining what is reasonable force) would clearly have removed Section 59 as a defence for this offence.  It was quite clear that anything which left bruising would not be able to use Section 59. So if the Borrows amendment had been agreed to, this case would still have been prosecuted (as it should be).

It is arguable that even with no law change at all, this case may still have been prosecuted and won. But I had no problems with a law change to reduce the availability of Section 59 so it clearly would not apply to cases like this – I just thought the Borrows amendment was preferable to clearly exclude the trifling cases.

General Debate 23 November 2007

Australian Election Party

There’s an Australian Election Party in Auckland at Thomas Forde’s bar, 122 Anzac Avenue., starting at 6 pm on Saturday, November 24, 2007 at 6:00pm

“Come and join hundreds of others at Thomas Forde’s Australian Bar (for one day only). Dress up as your favourite Australian. There will be prizes for the best dressed. Thongs, singlets and akubras allowed.

This event is open to people of all political hues. Even Pauline Hanson supporters!

It is guarenteed to be a night of high tension, unbearable excitement, drinking and out of tune renditions of waltzing matilda.

For one night only Thomas Forde’s Irish bar becomes Australian and welcomes anyone interested in following the election of the year.”

Talking of the election, I’d say any chance of the Government hanging on (and there was a small chance as Labor were not doing as well in some marginals as they are nationally) died today after the revelation of a bogus pamphlet being distributed in a marginal seat claiming that Labor supported the Bali bombers.

This was both despicable and moronic.  And while the hierarchy of the party would never have endorsed such a stunt, the fact the husbands of an (retiring) MP and a  candidate were involved, means that they will be damned for it.

The people involved should be prosecuted,and further they should be given brain transplants.  Did they really think that it would work, let alone that it would not be traced back to them?

For those interested, the pamphlet is here. It really is a nasty bigoted smear.

I was thinking Labor would win 20 seats or so.  It may be a whole lot more now.

Protesters and Parliament

No Right Turn has blogged about the case raised in the House by Gordon Copeland, about how there is a Speaker’s Ruling that anyone who has been on a protest march is not allowed to enter Parliament for 24 hours, without the permission of the Speaker’s Office.

This actually affected myself and Stephen Franks also. After the protest march Jackie Blue kindly invited us into Copperfields (Parliament’s cafe) for lunch.  As we went through security, we were told we couldn’t be let in, even though we were with an MP, without the permission of the Speaker’s Office.

I found it rather amusing to be classified as an official security threat to Parliament – I suspect Stephen was the same!

Rickards resigns

At long last, it is over. Clint Rickards has resigned from the NZ Police.

The disciplinary tribunal was to be in February. Rickards presumably realised it was almost inevitable he would not win, or at best he would get a payout but not reinstatement.

Also I suspect by resigning he gets to perf, and that will be a hell of a lot of money for 25 years and having risen to Assistant Commissioner.

UPDATE: There may have been a golden handshake.  I guess Annette King will face some questions about this, if so.

General Debate 22 November 2007

Helena Catt on Nine to Noon

Electoral Commission CEO Helena Catt was on Nine to Noon. Some extracts that should make everyone but the total zealots realise the Electoral Finance Bill should not proceed in its current form:

PRESENTER: It is your problem because you’re the one in the hot seat, or one of two senior officials in the hot seat, making just those decisions and you’re saying, as this bill stands, you can’t make them.

CATT: Yes we can’t make them. What we, what we said to the Select Committee was as it stands at the moment, the advice we would have to give to parties is seek your own legal advice.

This is a pretty serious statement.  Parties rely on the Electoral Commission for advice, and they say the Bill is so flawed that they will not be able to advise in key areas as to what is or is not illegal.  So parties will get their own legal advice (which will differ of course, as they like the EC won’t know what the law is) and it will inevitably lead to big court battles.

PRESENTER: Is this a case of poorly drafted legislation.

CATT: Ah, in some of these terms ah, yes. I think it is a case of not thinking through the ramifications for how you administer some of the components.

PRESENTER: What are then, your biggest concerns.

CATT: Our biggest concern as you said is how we define when an MP is acting in their capacity as an MP. The laws, the new bill says that if they’re acting in their capacity as a MP, then that activity is not to count towards election expenses. Our problem is we don’t know where that line is between acting in their capacity as an MP on the one hand and inducements to vote on the other hand.

As I keep saying, there is an easy answer for this.  Nothing is so blatantly seeking to persuade or encourage votes as an election pledge card.  So the Government needs to clearly state if it is their intention that an election pledge card is exempted from being a cost against a party’s limit if done via the Leader’s Budget.

They will not want to answer this question though, because the answer is yes, but they do not want to say yes because the public won’t like it.  So instead we have bad unclear law.

PRESENTER: And yet we know from history that, that was precisely the debate in 2005, and MPs saw it one way and the Auditor-General saw it another way. You’re saying that there has been nothing to clarify or prevent that exact same debate going on again.

CATT: Exactly. There could be that debate again and that’s what, where the problem is. I mean the, the regulated period for this election starts on the first of January assuming the bill is passed. Everyone involved really needs to know where they are in terms of the law on the first of January. On any situation where we’ve got one, two, maybe three, four different interpretations then we run the risk of um, problems during the time between the first of January and election day.

CATT: Our fear is that um, that litigation will become part of the election campaign, you know, it will go the American route where each party lawyers-up and firing the lawyers at each other becomes as much part of the campaign as the traditional advertising, I mean, that’s the worst-case scenario, that’s our fear, that everywhere where we’ve got areas where interpretation isn’t clear that the parties will start using that as part of their attack on each other and that’s not going to do anything to encourage public interest in politics, trust in the election campaign.

Oh the way this Bill was developed has almost guaranteed this.  If the Bill proceeds, I can almost guarantee we will end up like the US with litigation.  It’s almost inevitable when the Commission themselves say hey we can not interpret this law.

And I think it is a safe prediction to make that every single publication that appears after 1 January with a parliamentary crest on it will be complained about by members of the public, and rulings sought on whether it should count to a party cap.  MPs electorate newsletters will be targeted, brochures, everything.

Third party groups will sue over whether their campaign is an advertisement or not.

Press releases which do not comply with the law will be targeted. If a candidate makes a speech to a public meeting and does not give his address, they will be complained about.

Labour has destroyed the decades old convention of bipartisanship on these issues.

National had agreed to reasonable third party restrictions and a clamp down on anonymous donations.

All Labour had to do was convene multi-party talks in late 2006 or early 2007 and seek agreement on some key issues.  They would have been able to get them.  They didn’t even try.  Then they should have produced a Bill which just added on a few clauses to the Electoral Act, and it would have sailed through.

Law Society on Electoral Finance Bill

The President of the NZ Law Society, John Marshall QC, was on Morning Report this morning. Here’s some extracts from what he said:

MARSHALL: We’d say ideally, we should start again from first principles and the purposes which are good. Realistically that’s not going to happen, it seems. But as an alternative, we strongly suggest to the Government and to the Parliament that they send it back to the select committee so that, the people who made the submissions last time can have another say on what is a very heavily amended bit of legislation.

PRESENTER: Because we have to remember that the amendments came in after it had been to this select committee so in fact in real terms, the public groups like their own, have not had a chance to have a real go or a real say, in, as far as what is before the House now, is concerned.

MARSHALL: Exactly and frankly we need time to do that, it’s a very complex bit of legislation, it’s, difficult to make off the cuff comments on it and it really does require detailed consideration by the submitters and by the select committee. We’ve got to get this right.

Every day more problems are being exposed, and when you have the Electoral Commission itself saying We can not interpret this law, you know you have problems. And if the Government had published their draft bill when they were scheduled to – in early 2007, then there would have been plenty of time to get it right.  But they kept the secret negotiations with their allies going for months, minimising the chance to have decent public consultation.  So the Government are the only people to blame for leaving the bill so late.

What the Electoral Commission said

It is timely to look at what the Electoral Commission said on the Electoral Finance Bill. Before we do that, let us look at who makes up the Electoral Commission. It is:

  • Hon. Anthony (Tony) Ellis QC (Sadly Mr Ellis has passed away, replacement Chair yet to be appointed)
  • Joe Williams
  • Belinda Clark
  • Dr Helena Catt

More useful is their roles. Two of them are current or former Judges, one is the Secretary for Justice and Dr Catt is the CE of the Commission. Beyond doubt politically neutral, and have no partisan interest in the outcome – unlike MPs. This doesn’t mean their views can not be disagreed with, but it means you have to think very very carefully about why you wouldn’t listen to the people who are non partisan, and the experts in this area. For they have to make the law work.

I’ve not yet gone through all their advice, but here’s some major elements which differ from the Select Committee:

  1. No restrictions on when you can register as a third party.
  2. To index spending and registration limits to inflation every three years (failure to do so means one is decreasing the effective limit)
  3. Only requiring registration as a third party if the spend is over $40,000 (unless the amount is significant, why discourage people from participating)
  4. Allowing third parties to spend up to $250,000 to $300,000
  5. Setting the limit at which parties can accept anonymous donations as $3,000 to $5,000 instead of $1,000

All pretty sensible stuff.

The amount third parties can spend is a key one. I incidentially also advocated $250,000. You see there are two levels of spending one should look at, in setting a limit.

  1. How much does a third party need to spend to be effective? You see if the limit is set below that level, then you defeat the entire purpose of having advocacy in a democratic society. How much money do you need to spend to be able to effectively communicate a message to the target of 2.7 million people.
  2. How much spending constitutes starting to drown out or dominate the debate? The limit at which the ad on TV is appearing every day for weeks on end, or in every newspaper repeatedly.

So the limit for third parties (there is an argument that there should be no limit, but this is accepting that you have a limit as political parties have a limit) should be between (1) and (2).

I think (1) is around $250,000. I’d put (2) at probably $750,000+ type territory. So by even going for a limit of $250,000 (which I and the Electoral Commission proposed) you are far closer to the lower level (1) than the higher level (2).

$120,000 does not buy you much advertising. It is around 5c per voter. So having a limit at half of what the neutral officials have advised, raises the very real suspicion that it is designed not to stop a third party from unfairly dominating the election, but to stop them being able to effectively communicate their view.

And remember the ad spend for almost all government promotional campaign is well over $1 million. Now even if you do not think these campaigns are particularly political, think about the fact that the Government itself says hey you need to spend this much money to get your message across.

Parker must step aside

If you watched TV Three News last night (video here) you would have seen a former employee/contractor to the Environment Ministry make allegations which, if true, will end the careers of David Parker and Hugh Logan.

Erin Leigh said that Parker had Labour Party activist Clare Curran hired to push his own personal agenda, and that she was so angry at the appointment both she and her boss resigned in protest.

The Herald has a story here.

Parker is playing semantics when he says he did not instruct her to be hired. Of course he did not – he is unable to do so. But he obviously made the suggestion in such a way (and he never ever should even have made a suggestion) that it was taken as something to be done, breaking the Ministry’s own rules on competitive tenders, and against existing staff and contractors wishes who saw it as a political appointment.

Parker is Minister of State Services. The SSC is enquiring into this issue. I hope they do so by interviewing all witnesses under oath . But beyond doubt Parker must temporarily (at least) step aside as State Services Minister while the inquiry is under way.

Electoral Commission on EFB

I’m busy today so am just lightly touching on this issue for now, but will return to it.  The Electoral Commission’s advice to the Select Committee is now public, and it is a real shame it was not taken up.

For now just have a look at this story about how the Electoral Commission has said it is “almost impossible” to interpret parts of the new Bill.  This is exactly why the Law Society and others have said it should have been scrapped or at the least have another round of public submissions.

As I said I will post later on who makes up the Electoral Commission, their strict neutrality, and their advice.  Plus also some surveys they have released on some key issues.

One of the biggest issues for the Commission is what exactly does Clause 80 do, in terms of exempting anything done by an MP in his or her capacity as an MP as an election expense.

Now I would suggest there is a simple litmus test.  The 2005 Labour Party pledge card.  It was ruled by both electoral agencies to be an election expense in 2005 because it very clearly sought to persuade or encourage votes for Labour.  It was as blatant electioneering as one could get without actually using the words “Vote Labour”.

So the question the Minister of Justice should answer for the Electoral Commission, is this: “Is it the intention of the Government that the pledge card would no longer be an election expense under the Electoral Finance Bill 2007”.

The Government must answer this question. Labour complained last time that they did not relaise their pledge card would be an election expense.  They attacked senior electoral officials for classifying it as so.  So it would be hypocritical not to answer the question, when those officials have specifically asked for the law to be clarified.

My solution is simple.  Abolish Clause 80.  It should not matter one iota who pays for a publication.  If a publication encourages or persuades people to support a party, then it should be an election expense for that party.

The best-laid plans of mice and men often go awry

Okay just got back from the march.  Didn’t quite go as I envisioned.  You see while I have promoted the march here, I’m not one of the organisers and my involvement was purely to stroll along at the back, and see how it goes.

Sadly these plans went awry. The cessna flipping at Wellington Airport took out two of the three speakers and an extended Select Committee hearing took out the third.

So around 5 minutes before the march started I was told I am now the main speaker.  Yay – and I have so much time to prepare. It is hard to describe the clenching feeling you get in your stomach when you suddenly realise you have to do something with no preparation, and in front of every media outlet in NZ. Reminds me of bungy jumping.

Then as the march started I got told this also entails having to march in front of the main banner.  Great – I’m leading a protest march.  The last time I did this was in 1989 against Phil Goff in Dunedin as a student activist.  And I wasn’t even a speaker, just one of those who got to chant into a megaphone “Eff off Goff” several hundred times.

As expected Young Labour did a spirited counter protest complete with masks and megaphones.  They didn’t appreciate the irony that what they were doing would itself be illegal next year. They will make the news I am sure which is what they wanted.

Not a large turnout (but around what I expected for a weekday in Wellington) and got to Parliament fairly quickly.  I spoke a couple of times, we gave counter protesters a couple of minutes also.  Then Stephen Franks spoke.  Jeanette Fitzsimons asked to speak.  I knew the organisers hadn’t wanted any MP speaking as it was meant to be a message to them, but seeing Young Labour (to be fair the guy who spoke said he was not a Labour member, but almost all his colleagues were) got to speak we let Jeanette speak.  Then Nick Smith and Gordon Copeland also spoke to be balanced and that was it.

Afterwards was in a taxi when the 2 pm news came on.  Heard my voice blaring as the first item, and the taxi driver turns to me and say “You know that guy sounds a lot like you”.  Hilarious.

Very sad that John Boscawen couldn’t make it.  Not just because it would have got me off the hook, but that he has put so much time and energy (and his own money) into this cause he is passionate about.  I’ll blog a copy fo the speech he would have given once I have an electronic copy. But I think he has more marches planned for Christchurch and Hamilton anyway.

Count the press secretaries

I remember an article in 1998 or 1999 criticising Jenny Shipley’s office for having too many comms/media people when we had six and a half or something. I was the half.

The latest ministerial phone list has a total of ten people in the comms/media area for Helen Clark. That’s more than the entire National Opposition.

If we add on the other Cabinet offices, there is a further 25 for 19 Cabinet Ministers. Half the front bench it seems now have two, not one, press secretaries.

Also add on the six outside Cabinet and that’s a grand total of 41 press secretaries or communications staffers.

No wonder unemployment is so low in Wellington 🙂

The Wellington March

A reminder to everyone interested that the Wellington march against the Electoral Finance Bill is today, leaving Civic Square at 12.30 pm.

If you need a succinct reason as to why you should march, here’s it is:

Under the Electoral Finance Bill, a placard in a protest march in January 2008 which says “Down with Labour’s Electoral Finance Bill” will be an election advertisement.

However Labour’s election pledgecard, the centrepiece of their election campaign, will not be an election advertisement if it funded by the taxpayer – even if released in the final week of the election.

Labour broke the law in 2005.  The broke it in two ways.

The Electoral Commission and the Chief Electoral Officer both said that Labour’s pledge card was an illegal election advertisement. The Electoral Finance Bill will mean that it will now not have to be counted as part of their election advertising.

The Auditor-General and the Solicitor-General both said that it was illegal for the pledge card to be funded by the taxpayer.  However Labour is broke so they are changing the law through their Appropriations Validating Act to allow them to send the bill to the taxpayer again.

I have a huge level of respect for these neutral institutions of state. I think it is important we have an Electoral Commission, a Chief Electoral Office, an Auditor-General who fairly interpret the laws. They are not conflicted with an interest in the outcome.

Since Labour’s illegal behaviour was publicised in 2006, they have had a relentless campaign against some of these officials.  They have claimed the Chief Electoral Officer and the Auditor-General were biased, were incompetent, were wrong, were making things up, were inconsistent. It’s been disgraceful to have the Government of NZ attack its own senior officials in such a way.

They were finally made to pay back $800,000.  But now in a fit of revenge they are changing the law to fit their bizarre interpretation.  Can anything be more ridiculous than a law which will now exempt an election pledge card from being considered an election expense? And worse a companion law which allows them to send the taxpayer the bill for their election pledge card?

So if you do not think Labour’s election pledge card should be exempt from the Electoral Act, then have your say today.

General Debate 21 November 2007

Fisking Annette King

Annette King did not have a good question time. Have to feel a bit sorry as she inherited this hospital pass from Burton, but not up to her normal standard. If you have time watch her on You Tube, or just read some extracts below:

I suggest everyone read this post on how the definitions of what constitutes an election advertisement have changed from the Electoral Act 1993 to the Electoral Finance Bill 2007. Then let’s look at her answers:

First Heather Roy pinches one of my points:

Heather Roy: How does this bill not breach freedom of speech under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act when, by closing third party registrations before candidate nominations, a group could spend only $1,000 on speaking out about a candidate whose views it opposes, and is this Government not railroading this bill through the House before it can be challenged in the courts for being inconsistent with the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act?

Hon ANNETTE KING: The date by which a third party can register that it wants to be involved in the electoral system—in fact, wants to campaign for a party or candidate—is, in this bill, *writ day. I believe that the date could be changed to the date for closure of nominations.

So that’s one admission of a flawed law. They really need to change it to be say three days after nominations close. Or why have a period at all where you can’t register.

Hon Bill English: Is the Minister aware that the new definition of “publish” in terms of election advertisements now includes any manner of bringing a political view to the public, including comments on Internet forums, press releases that are put out, even if they are not published by the media, and someone going down the street *door-knocking and saying: “Vote National.”?

Hon ANNETTE KING: That question borders on the ridiculous. The law of *common sense applies, as it always has in electoral Acts. The law of common sense applies, and the member knows that. One could argue that under the Electoral Act now a press release could be covered, but it is not covered because trivial matters are not taken into account. The law of common sense applies. A bit of common sense from the National Party would be appreciated.

Here Annette has real problems. The Electoral Act 1993 does not include a press release as an election advertisement, because such things are very narrowly defined. The EFB however defines anything which communicates with the public as publishing an advertisement.

And sadly Annette’s law of common sense will not over-ride the very specific provisions of the Electoral Finance Bill. Myself, and others, asked the Select Committee to have a more narrow interpretation, but instead they made it worse.

Hon Bill English: Is the Minister aware that if someone goes *door-knocking down a street, knocking on doors and saying: “Vote National.”, then under her law that action constitutes the publication of an election advertisement, and therefore such persons constitute a promoters under the law; and if those persons are promoters, then when they knock on a door, they will have to give their name and address to the person they are addressing, present the authorisation by the financial agent for the party for which they are canvassing, and then say: “Good morning.”?

Hon ANNETTE KING: If the person were a National Party campaigner, he or she would probably be told to buzz off. I say to that member—[Interruption] I am answering the last part of the member’s question about saying “Good morning.” The member is wrong. That example does not apply. No one expects someone who knocks on the door to say: “This is an election advertisement.” That example is patently ridiculous, and everyone who has listened to those examples, given to the member by **David Farrier off the National Party blog, says they are ridiculous.

Note to Hansard: Farrar not Farrier 🙂

I agree it is ridiculous, but it is also what the Bill now says, because the Select Committee deliberately added in an extra clause to include oral communications. Rather disturbing that the Minister of Justice no less, can’t defend the Bill by quoting clauses from it, but just keeps referring to the law of common sense.

Hon Bill English: Has the Minister bothered to go and read her own law, which states that any expression of a view that encourages any member of the public to vote one way or another, communicated to the public in any manner, constitutes an election advertisement, and the other part of the law, which states that anyone who publishes an election advertisement is a promoter—that is in her law—and that any such advertisement must include his or her name and address, which is why, for instance, placards must now include the name and address of the person who is holding them?

Hon ANNETTE KING: Under the Electoral Act as it stands, one could argue that a placard should have an authorisation on it. But I have to say that nobody I know of has been prosecuted under the current Act because he or she held up a 1c placard that did not have his or her name on it. The law of common sense applies. I suggest to the member that he apply it.

Now once again the Minister is wrong on the facts. She really needs t read the current Act. The current Act does not include a placard as publishing an election advertisement. The EFB does.

Hon Bill English: Well, they are now. Can the Minister tell the public and the House what will happen when a well-meaning member of the public or community group looks up the Electoral Finance Bill and reads the Draconian provisions that mean that any person expressing a point of view in any form at all about whom to vote for is covered by the Act and has to comply with its regulations; and whom does that person approach to find out which rules now no longer apply because of common sense, and which rules will continue to apply because Labour wants to clamp down on public opinion?

Bill gets to the core point on this. The negative impact will not be that suddenly hundreds of people get arrested for unauthorised placards. It will be that it discourages the average citizen from participating in normal political activity, because the Act states they will be in breach of it, unless they comply with the regulations.

 

Read all the deleted parts

Oh dear, there will be some unhappy people.

Over on the Government’s Digital Strategy site, there is a press release about the setting up of “a new digital and community sector representative body for the benefits of all those people with information and communications technology (ICT) needs”.

Now the PR also refers to a linked cabinet paper in pdf form. It notes:

Some items in this cabinet paper has been removed because it refers to financial or other sensitive information.

Now I did read the PR because it is in an area of interest to me (and incidentally I am pretty supportive of the Government’s initiatives in this area), but didn’t read the cabinet paper at first. If you do look at it there are well over two dozen paragraphs blanked out.

But a smart wee thing has read the paper and sent an e-mail pointing out that it seems all the Government has done is change the font to white. So if you either highlight the text in your pdf reader or copy it to Word and highlight it with a dark colour, all the”deleted” text suddenly appears, and hey presto you have the full Cabinet paper.

I hope the Government applies the same censorship techniques to all its documents. The Budget papers especially would be great like this!

Hat Tip: Simon Lyall

The Curran scandal

It was revealed yesterday in Parliament that the Environment Ministry misled Parliament (technically the Minister did on their behalf) over the engagement of Clare Curran to do communications work on the recommendation of David Parker.

Here’s what NZPA reports as the true case:

  • In 2005 Curran sought work with the Environment Ministry in the area of  climate change communications and public awareness.  She did not gain any work.
  • Then in 2006 David Parker, the Climate Change Minister, recommended Curran to his officials.
  • The Ministry lied about her winning the contract through a competitive tender.  She was given a $24,000 contract for five weeks work with no tender.
  • Her contract was verbal, not written.
  • They engaged her without permission to enter into a contract without a tender.

Now remember Curran got this uncontested contract around the same time she was writing a “highly political paper” about Labour’s use of language in its fight to win re-election.  And what is intended to be their main campaign issue – sustainability and climate change.

It is going to be fascinating to find out under the OIA, what Curran produced for her $24,000.  Not that Curran is to blame – she has every right to seek communications work from Government Departments.  The people to blame are David Parker and Hugh Logan.