The Imported Car Campaign

 carlobby.JPG

The Independent Motor Vehicle Dealers Association launched a $300,000 campaign yesterday against the Government’s proposed emission standards.  They’ve done this after a year of lobbying and research has failed.

Now this is what politics is about.  Governments are criticised by lobby groups.  Hell when National were in power there was almost a queue needed for all the groups spending money criticising the Government.

Now one may or may not agree with the Independent Motor Vehicle Dealers Association. They claim the new standards will by restricting the age of imports, raise prices and force people to keep driving “old clunkers” for longer. They have an NZIER study which says:

… the government’s proposed rules “will most likely have the opposite result to what is intended and can be expected to reduce consumer welfare by around $620 million” and “the policy will most likely cause an increase in the number of vehicles in the fleet that do not comply with the proposed standards” and that “the average age of the fleet will rise, indicating that older, more polluting vehicles will remain in the fleet for longer than if this policy is not put in place”.

Now people can form their own views on whether they agree with the Government or the Independent Motor Vehicle Dealers Association.  But the question now has to be asked – would such a campaign be legal next year?

I would suggest that the ad, by labelling Labour’s policy as crazy, would be classified as an election advertisement, and would be illegal.  Even if they register, their campaign would be cut by two thirds.

So election year criticism of the Government will be minimised.

Paranoid and odious

Yes, that is the view of two newspapers on the “better” Electoral Finance Bill, and neitehr of them are the NZ Herald.

First the Hawke’s Bay Today says:

The Electoral Finance Bill was inspired by an instinctive hatred of personal wealth (especially when it benefits political opposition, as witnessed by the Exclusive Brethren’s ridiculous attack on Labour and the Greens) and resentment by the Government that it was unable to steal public funds for its election campaigning. However, the overarching impulse, revealed in the desire to raise the weights of any opposition, has been to legislate to remain in power.

Wow “hatred” and “steal”. Wonder if this is still just a beltway issue?

In its revised form, the bill moderates the naked desire to clear the decks of political dissent. Plans to give Government advertising campaigns immunity and to suppress pressure groups were ditched (though the use of megaphones falls under the bill’s ambit and an 11-month restriction on political expression before an election is the longest for any western democracy).

Despite the changes to what many of its critics correctly deemed irredeemable, the bill remains an obnoxious piece of lawmaking for what has driven it, for the disdain it has shown to the principles of freedom of expression and fairness and for the loathing and contempt that it generates for those who, in principle anyway, we ought to be able to show at least a modicum of respect.

Now we turn to the Dominion Post political editor, Tracy Watkins.  Now she won’t use strong words such as steal and hatred will she.  Oh wait she’s just called Labour “paranoid”.  The plan to con everyone that this new bill is wonderful and lovely seems to be failing.  Here’s Tracy:

A wise old man probably once said that you should never try to write a law while you’re feeling angry and paranoid.

And if he didn’t, then he should have.

Because all Labour’s problems over the Electoral Finance Bill stem from its decision to rewrite the rules for the next election campaign while it was still angry over 2005 and paranoid about 2008.

Labour’s electoral finance reforms might have been more convincing had it had tackled anonymous donations and secret trusts from the start – but its failure to do so for fear it might cause some of its own funding to dry up made the legislation look even more serving than it already was.

It may even have stayed on the side of the angels if it had kept its eye on the prize, tackled the most disturbing aspects of what groups like the Exclusive Brethren can get away with once they set their mind to it under the current law, and disdained to sweat the small stuff.

Instead it produced a piece of legislation which looks suspiciously like a scratch for every itch that’s ever bugged it or the select committee members on the campaign trail.

Megaphones? Hell yes. Let’s throw that in there as well.

Placards? Yup. We better spell that out.

Indeed.  Labour could have done a very simple bill to deal with the Exclusive Brethren type campaign.  But instead we have this monstrosity.

The rewritten bill is an improvement on the first. But National will use it to kick Labour with every step of the way to the next election. Which is what you get when you abandon the long standing principal of bi-partisanship around electoral law. And in case Labour forgot, that bipartisanship existed for a very sound reason. It was to avoid tit-for-tat law.

Cough, principle, cough. But the important point is that Labour has shattered the bi-partisanship convention. And frankly National would be mad if they ever allowed Labour to have any input into any future Electoral Act changes. They’ve lost the moral right to be consulted.

Heh

Hilarious hypocrisy

John A has just blogged in favour of requiring people who chant “don’t vote for Helen Clark” to be forced to reveal their name and address.  He thinks this is reasonable and anonymous advocacy is a bad thing.

And where does John A blog?  At the Standard, where every single contributor is anonymous, including John A himself.  I mean how stupid do you have to be that hypocritical?  Seriously can we pay money to give him his own comedy show on TV?

Luckily I will remain staunch in my defence of the right of John A to remain anonymous. I’m all for disclosure of people who spend significant money on advocacy.  But I think people should be able to express their views on a protest march or in Usenet without needing a name and address attached.

Definition of third party election advertising

Steven Price correctly pointed out this morning that you currently need to disclose name and address for a third party electoral advertisement. But the big change is how what counts as publishing an advertisement has changed. First let us look at the current law in the Electoral Act 1993 – Clause 221A(1).

Subject to subsection (2) of this section, no person shall publish or cause or permit to be published in any newspaper, periodical, poster, or handbill, or broadcast or cause or permit to be broadcast over any radio or television station, any advertisement relating to an election unless the advertisement contains a statement setting out the true name of the person for whom or at whose direction it is published and the address of that person’s place of residence or business.

So an electoral advertisement is defined pretty narrowly – an advertisement in a newspaper, periodical, poster or handbill or an advertisement on radio or TV. And it only applies for 90 days and it has to be “relating to an election”.

Now we turn to the Electoral Finance Bill 2007. First we go to Clause 4(1) for the definition of publish, as it applies to us:

publish, in relation to an advertisement, means to—

(a) print or insert in a periodical published or distributed in New Zealand; or
(b) issue, hand out, or display; or
(c) send to any member of the public by any means; or
(d) deliver to any member of the public, or leave at a place owned or occupied by a member of the public; or
(e) broadcast; or
(f) include in a film or video displayed to the public; or
(g) disseminate by means of the Internet or any other electronic medium; or
(h) store electronically in a way that is accessible to the public; or
(i) bring to the notice of the public in any other manner

Now you can see the massive difference. This is why placards, and megaphones, and e-mails, and messages on Usenet, and even speaking at a public meeting is now counted as publishing an advertisement. The law is explicit. The 1993 Act very tightly defined what was an advertisement. This Bill defines basically everything as an advertisement if it brings it to the notice of the public. And this was pointed out to the Select Committee, and they made it even worse by including (i).

Also worth remembering that this now applies all of election year.

Now we turn to the companion definition of what is an election advertisement, because hey surely speaking into a megaphone or posting to Usenet is not an advertisement as we understand it. But sadly statute law trumps common usage, and the law means what the law defines something as. If a law is passed defining me as a tall person, then I would be legally a tall person able to access the benefits of the Tall Persons Act 2009. Even if common sense says I am a shortie.

So we turn to Clause 5(1):

In this Act, election advertisement—
(a) means any form of words or graphics, or both, that can reasonably be regarded as doing 1 or more of the following:
(i) encouraging or persuading voters to vote, or not to vote, for 1 or more specified parties or for 1 or more candidates or for any combination of such parties and candidates:
(ii) encouraging or persuading voters to vote, or not to vote, for a type of party or for a type of candidate that is described or indicated by reference to views, positions, or policies that are or are not held, taken, or pursued (whether or not the name of a party or the name of a candidate is stated);

Now look at para (a) – any form of words or graphics. yes any form. Oral, written, on a placard, in a Usenet post.

And the definition in (ii) also includes statements such as “Down with parties who are against Kyoto” or “Only support parties which support legal party pills” or “Don’t vote for the Ginga (only illegal in Otaki). Okay last one is a bit far fetched. But the key is you do not have to explicitly say “Vote for” or “Vote against” to be covered and advocating on an issue such as “People should only vote for parties that support lower taxes” is covered – even if just on a post to Usenet.

So why have they gone with a law which includes speaking at public meetings, chanting in a protest, a placard, a post to Usenet as an election advert? The problem is their fundamental approach is flawed.

The old Act starts with a narrow definition of election advertising, and has just a couple of exemptions for media and the electoral agencies. That is how it should be. Sure you may want to widen the definition a bit to include some new media, but that’s it.

This Bill has been designed the opposite way. It defines absolutely everything in election year as election advertising, if a view is expressed publicly for or against a party. The starting point is everything in election year is to be regulated, and then they have come up with a list of exceptions, which keeps growing as they realise that the original bill banned media websites for example, and this version regulates megaphones on protest marches.

Now you can keep expanding the exceptions, but as I point out above, the fundamental approach is flawed. You shouldn’t start with regulating everything and then do exceptions when it comes to our rights to speak up on political issues. You should only regulate stuff over a certain threshold.

Hence this is why the EFB will not survive for long, regardless of who is in power. It starts from the wrong premise – that all political advocacy for or against parties is to be regulated. It needs to start from a premise that we want people to voice their views as much as possible, and we only then regulate those which involve significant expenditure

Message for Annette

I just been told Annette King had a go at me in Parliament, claiming what I am saying is rubbish. Well of course Annette can and would say that, but what is interesting is she has been refusing to cite anything to back up her answers.

We saw the same from Mark Burton. National sent a letter to voluntary groups which basically just quoted from the Bill – specific clauses. Burton sent a letter full of lies which just said hey National is scaremongering and didn’t even refer to a single clause in the Bill. We now know Burton was wrong – even the Greens have said the original Bill was “appalling”.

King is doing the same thing. She attacks the messenger and dismisses it. But what the Minister has not done, and in fact no one has done, is make a clear concise argument based on the statute that one does not need names and addresses on placards (for example).

The Greens have agreed with me on the megaphone law. Steven Price has agreed (on radio this morning) on the placards (but pointed out existing law required disclosure on some third party advocacy also).

So my challenge to Annette as Minister of Justice is to provide a clear statement to the NZ public based on the EFB that explains how placards which advocate for or against a party do not fall under the definitions of publishing an election advertisement, and hence need a name and address on them.

Either that, or start work on a Supplementary Order Paper.

Key vs Rudd

In a break from the EFB (but will be talking later today some more on the new definitions of publish and advertise), I’ll turn to a good Colin James column:

He gives four reasons why John Key may not win despite the lead in the polls, noting that Kevin Rudd has much much more experience in politics and Government.

  1. But” No 1: The state of the parties. A Martian visitor knowing the two main parties only by their annual conferences would have rated Labour well ahead. Labour’s was big, energetically explored issues and policies and sprouted young people and national diversity. National’s was tight, white and slight on debate.
  2. Key’s knowledge base. Key was overseas from 1994 to 2001. That is a hole in his understanding of what went on here. Only six years in Parliament, he lacks the ingrained knowledge of issues which comes by osmosis with years in active party and parliamentary politics.
  3. Grasp of government. Rudd was seven years boss of the Queensland Premier’s office and, by all accounts, a centralising, finger-in-every-pie one. He knows how a government works. Clark made Deputy Prime Minister 10 years before reaching the top. Key’s private sector governing experience is not training for governing a country, which is done with the media sniffing and hooting and the public primed to condemn.
  4. Gravitas and the flash of steel. Key has an up-register voice which does not command. He has yet to show teeth in a dogfight. Clark is battle-scarred and battle-ready.

But he then also gives some “buts to the buts” as to why he still may.  These are:

  1. Key has a disarming humour – a quality that escapes the public Clark
  2. Key gets on with Tariana Turia
  3. Highly sensitive antennae through which he also absorbs information and options from the wider world. Add that to instincts about what makes a cohesive society and you get a “one-of-us” leader.
  4. He has cleared away counterproductive “extremist” (to use his word) differences with Labour
  5. But Key is not “Labour-lite”. He projects a “philosophy” that emphasises the economic return from state interventions, including for the “underclass” and prisoners about both of whom you will hear more, and promotes a smaller state and a bigger private sector delivery role.
  6. Key processes information quickly, reaches a decision, backs himself and acts
  7. Key learns. He doesn’t make the same mistake twice.

I could quibble with parts, but overall a pretty fair analysis.

Morning Report

Steven Price from the Campaign for Open Government and myself debated the bill on Morning Report this morning. I have a lot of respect for Steven and the COG, even though I disagree with them on the overall desirability of the Bill.

Before we went on air Steven talked me out of describing the Electoral Commission as a “pimp” for anonymous donations for parties, and I mentally changed it to “money launderer” but as it happens we never touched much on the donations side which was a pity.

Anyway here is the audio for anyone interested.

Herald on revised EFB

Let’s start with Audrey Young’s blog:

The definition of political advertising in the bill has been reined in somewhat but is still ambiguous enough for Government department campaigns to court legal challenge around technicalities when they start to roll out in election year. They could prove to be politically dangerous.

The Greens manoeuvred themselves well to get greater transparency to donations though there is something a little unnatural about having the Electoral Commission being the conduit of money from one private source to another.

There will be a lot of back-slapping by a slim majority in Parliament which convinces itself it has removed the worse excesses from the bill and there is no need to dump it.

They sky won’t fall in. It won’t affect people’s pockets. Opponents of the bill will be painted as having hidden agendas. Apologists for the bill like Dr Peter Davis will convince themselves that the bill does no harm at all.

But those changes do not alter the big picture.

Along with the advantage incumbent Governments will have, the advantages to incumbent MPs remain unchanged by the select committee, when seen in conjunction with the Continuation of the Validation For MPs to Spend-Up Large on Political Ads Bill due to get its third reading tomorrow.

As bad will be the likely chilling effect on participation in democracy produced by imposing a new set of rules around so-called third parties.

The most pernicious effects of the bill will be unseen and unmeasured.

The editorial is harsher:

The revised Electoral Finance Bill remains a constitutional outrage – for the hasty and partisan way that it is proceeding as well as its repression of election participation. Parliament’s justice and electoral committee has removed some of the draconian elements, not all, and introduced a completely new dimension to our electoral rules, requiring large donations to be channelled through a public body, the Electoral Commission.

Nobody needs to read very far into the 151-page report to realise this subject is too big and too important for a select committee, dominated as such panels are by the governing parties. The drastic plan for the channelling of donations seems to have appeared before the committee not much more than a fortnight ago, and the bill will need to be rushed through remaining stages before the year’s end to bring all private political finance under state control from the beginning of election year.

As originally drafted, the bill would have captured any group “taking a position associated with one or more parties”. That preposterous clause has been culled by the committee but another remains. It will be an offence to encourage people to vote, or not vote, for “a type of party or type of candidate described by reference to views, positions or policies … ” whether or not the party is named.

Thus if civil libertarians, for example, want to urge New Zealanders to stand up for their freedom to publish their political views in election year, they will be caught by the bill from January 1. That sort of message would clearly be intended to encourage people not to vote for the Labour Party.

The bill is a drastic alteration of electoral law, going to the heart of our freedoms and democracy. It is being rushed and reeks of partisan opportunism. It should go no further.

John Armstrong says:

The Electoral Finance Bill emerges from its select committee scrutiny slightly better, but still a fundamentally flawed piece of legislation.

Justice Minister Annette King told the Herald the longer period would allow parties to “better plan” how they would spend their money in election year because previously they did not know when the regulated period would begin.

No one will buy that rationale. As the select committee’s report reveals, under questioning, Ministry of Justice officials could not offer committee members any rationale for the extended regulated period. To have done so would have meant embarrassing the Government.

Also the Herald has an article on the new megaphone clause.

National-aligned blogger David Farrar said that meant loudhailers joined other staples of protest movements such as placards in the list of political advertisements covered by the bill.

He received some backing from Green MP Metiria Turei, who said that the clause was intended to the cover commercial use of loudhailers, such as atop candidate’s vehicles.

Oh for all those claiming I am wrong

From NZPA:

The Free Speech Coalition spokesman David Farrar, who also runs a right wing website, said the bill would now cover megaphones as well as other materials such as placards which were always covered.

Ms Turei said that was technically correct. The bill aimed to include commercial use of loudhailers — for example on the top of a bus hired to drive around. The Greens would put up changes to amend the bill so individuals were not caught by it.

Now that the Greens have agreed with me in my interpretation, I guess this might calm down the nutters claiming I’m making this up.

Incidentally while I wish this Bill not to proceed, I am very happy to work with any party to draft amendments which will make the bill less oppressive.   But I also caution that having a constitutional bill such as the Electoral Act patched up in committee of the whole stage is very dangerous.  Mistakes will get made, and there are errors in the current bill yet to be recognised.

Disclosure Requirements

Several people have tried to claim that you do not need to include your name and address on a placard etc unless you spend $12,000 and register as a third party. They are wrong, and I shall quote the clause in full:

53 Election advertisements not to be published in regulated period unless certain conditions met

(1) No person may, during a regulated period, publish or cause or permit to be published any election advertisement unless—

(a) the advertisement contains a statement that sets out the name and address of the promoter of the advertisement; and
(b) the promoter is entitled to promote the advertisement.

(2) For the purposes of subsection (1)(b), a promoter is entitled to promote an election advertisement if the promoter is—

(a) the financial agent of a party, but only if the advertisement is a party advertisement promoted by, or on behalf of, that party; or
(b) the financial agent of a candidate, but only if the advertisement is a candidate advertisement promoted by, or on behalf of, 1 or more candidates; or
(c) the financial agent of a third party; or
(d) a promoter who promotes election advertisements during the regulated period in respect of which expenses are incurred that—

(i) in total do not exceed $12,000 (inclusive of goods 20 and services tax); and
(ii) in the case of advertisements that relate to a candidate in the candidate’s capacity as a candidate for an electoral district (whether or not the name of the candidate is stated), do not exceed $1,000 (inclusive of goods and services tax).

So 53(1) makes it crystal clear that any person who publishes an election advertisement must include their name and address.

And 53(2)(d) makes it even clearer by defining an eligible promoter as one who is not a third party but spends under $12,000 nationally or $1,000 in an electorate.

So make no mistake, any election advertisement published next year must have your name and address on it – even if they cost $1. In my next post we’ll look at what is defined as an advertisement and then what is defined as published. They are incredibly wide. An election advertisement is now a post in Usenet, a chant on a protest march, a placard, a speech to a group of people, a chalk slogan on a pavement.

19 problems still remaining with the Electoral Finance Bill

There are probably more than this, but here’s an initial list of 19 problems with the revised Electoral Finance Bill:

  1. It now includes speaking into a megaphone as a regulated election year activity. [Page 8 of Select Committee Report]

  2. The definition of publishing an election advertisement is extended to include the catchall “bring to the notice of the public in any other manner” which will include speaking in public. [Clause 4(1) – para (i) of definition to publish]

  3. Anonymous political advocacy on much of the Internet is outlawed as uploading a political video to You Tube even a post into the nz.politics Usenet newsgroup advocating for or against a party will require a name and residential address. [Clause 53(1) – para (a) and para (g) of Clause 4(1) definition of publish]
  4. The regulated period of all of election year remains one of the world’s longest at 30% of an electoral cycle (in Canada it is 6 – 8 weeks only for third parties) [Clause 4(1) – definition of regulated period]

  5. Third parties are restricted from advocating in all of election year to vote for or against parties on particular issues such as the environment or taxes. For example Greenpeace could not spend more than $10,000 a month advocating a vote against parties who do not support Kyoto.[Clause 5(1) para a(ii)]
  6. Blogs are left in an unsure legal position as only non-commercial blogs are exempted. All commercial blogs and other websites are now regulated if they express an opinion for or against a party or candidate. [Clause 5(2) para (g)]
  7. Other online forms of advocacy such as e-mail are now regulated. [para (g) of Clause 4(1) definition of publish]

  8. No right of reply for people attacked in an election campaign. You can spend only $12,000 nationally defending yourself if you or your organization is attacked during a campaign as third party registrations close on writ day. [Clause 17 para (a)(i)]
  9. By closing third party registrations after before candidate nominations close, a local residents group would be restricted to spending $1,000 opposing a last minute candidate whose views they find repugnant. [Clause 17 para (a)(i)]

  10. Different rules for third parties and political parties remain – political parties have twice the disclosure limit of third parties. [Clause 47(1) para (ab)]

  11. Spending limits not adjusted for population growth and/or inflation so an effective decrease in real per capita spending of 31%, plus that now has to last all year not just last 90 days [Clause 4(1) – definition of regulated period]

  12. Instead of banning anonymous donations, a compromise deal has seen them remain legal up to a certain limit, obviously designed to favour the incumbent Government. [Clause 28C(1)]

  13. All forms of political advocacy which promote votes for or against a party (or candidate) have to have a name and residential address supplied – even for placards, e-mails, speaking at street corners, posters, chalk on pavement. [Clause 53(1) para (a)]

  14. Parliamentary expenditure which was clearly electioneering under the existing Electoral Act (such as pledge cards) is now exempt from the spending caps [Clause 80 – para (d)]

  15. New candidates face a near impossible job against incumbent MPs as they are limited to just $20,000 over 11 months, and MPs parliamentary spending is exempt. [Clause 4(1) – definition of regulated period]

  16. Political parties are banned from running ads which advocate against candidates on particular issues (such as vote against MPs who voted for the Electoral Finance Bill) [Clause 53(2) para (a)]

  17. Political parties remain immune from prosecution for breaches of the Electoral Act – only individuals such as financial agents can be fined. This provides an incentive for parties to place pressure on individuals to risk breaking the law as the party itself will face no penalty.
  18. Smaller parties remain disadvantaged with broadcasting rules, as they are banned from purchasing their own broadcasting.

  19. The public have no meaningful opportunity for input into the revised bill, with its masses of changes

A lawyer’s view

Just had an e-mail from a lawyer, who is a senior partner of an Auckland law firm. He has agreed to let me reproduce his e-mail, but with name deleted while we still are allowed to have anonymity!

David,

You are right to say that the Bill as reported back is worse.

IMHO:

1. The deletion of section 5(1)(a)(iii) is meaningless as the same activity is already covered by s5(1)(a)(ii), which has been left in. It seems obvious to me that if one makes a statement about the “views, positions or policies” of a party or candidate one is “taking a position on a proposition with which 1 or more parties or 1 or more candidates is associated” (the deleted bit). Because under sub (iii) there is no need for a party/candidate to be mentioned and the test is objectified by referring to a “type” of party or candidate, it is pretty easy to argue that if one makes any supporting statement, then one is implicitly “encouraging or persuading voters to vote for …”

IOW, the strawman alone has been sacrificed.

2. The addition of the “bring to the notice of the public in any other manner” wording in the definition of publish makes it all the worse as you have said on your blog.

The stupid irony now is that you can say what you like on your blog (assuming its not commercial) but I can’t get in a room of people and say the same thing. In fact, I don’t even think it would need to be a room full of people – if I shouted out a supporting statement and it just so happened that only one person walking by heard me, that would be enough (Securities law has for years held that an investment is offered to the public even if it is made available to just one person who can be characterised as a member of the public).

What about driving around in a car which says “Get rid of Kyoto – Global Warming is Crap”. Seems to me that that is still caught. Or, what about “Raise the Private School Funding Cap” – Clearly Labour policy is to keep it and National’s is to raise it – caught again?

Actually, it is quite interesting when you try those examples. It seems to me that there is more likelihood of a negative statement being caught. i.e., statements against current govt policies are more easily caught than statements supporting opposition policies. In other words (I am sure inadvertently) the provision as it stands seems to prevent attacks.

“Kill the Bill” is easier to characterise as an attack on Labour (and therefore caught) compared to “Support Free Speech”, which is more difficult to argue as being an encouragement to vote for National.

Seems to me that a blog with a free membership option might be the way to go.

Regards,
XXX [name and address withheld]

Institute of Chartered Accountants says Kill the Bill

The Institute of Chartered Accountants joins the Law Society in asking the for Electoral Finance Bill to be killed:

The Institute is deeply concerned that expert advice from the accounting and legal communities has been substantially ignored. Accordingly, we join the New Zealand Law Society in calling for the bill to be dumped,” says David Pickens, the Institute’s director of government relations and strategic projects.

“The only way a workable solution will be achieved is for the bill to be dumped and redrafted from scratch.

“To proceed in the face of such widespread and considered opposition sets a dangerous precedent. Democracy is too valuable and delicate to allow it to be trampled by such a flawed process.”

Now when is the last time you heard accountants get so worked up about an issue??? Shows how bad it is.

They’ve made it worse!

Okay the Electoral Finance Bill is back with amendments. And I am stunned. You see I thought the Bill was so bad, so draconian, that it couldn’t possibly be made worse. But I was wrong.

Yes, they’ve actually managed to make it worse!

Not content with regulating written political advocacy, they’ve extended the definitions to also include verbal political advocacy!

The Electoral Finance Bill now even regulates someone who gets up on a soap box and starts communicating to the public.

And while they have scrapped the ludicrous system of statutory declarations, they still treat a placard in a protest march as an election advertisement (if it targets a political party) and that placard will need your name and residential address on it.

Remember all those protesters outside the Labour Party Conference? They would all have been breaking the law if they didn’t have their name and address on their placards. The ones with the megaphones – they would be breaking the law if they didn’t announce over the megaphone their name and residential address each time they chanted.

And this is no drafting error. The select committee report makes it clear they have intentionally widened the scope to capture “the use of loudspeakers and megaphones”. Yes Labour, NZ First, United Future and the Greens have deliberately moved to regulate verbal political advocacy. What sort of parties and Governments are threatened by megaphones?

Press releases that advocate for or against a party are still defined as election advertisements. If you e-mail out a press release, you’ll need to include your address on it.

Political Parties are still banned from certain types of advertisements. For example it would be illegal for the Maori Party to run an advertisement (which includes a press release!) which says “Voters should vote against any party or MP which voted for the Electoral Finance Bill”.

Labour’s usual tactic of trying to maximize advantage for itself is there. They restrict foreign donors to $1,000 yet define a foreign donor in such a way that Owen Glenn can still give his $500,000 to Labour despite not having lived here for 40 years.

Anonymous political advocacy on the Internet is gone. It will be illegal to make a post in the Usenet Internet Newsgroups that advocates for or against a party unless you include your name and residential address. And it’s the same with YouTube videos.

The exemption for non-commercial blogs remains, but there is no clarification of what non-commercial means, so Kiwiblog (which has some significant advertising lined up) may be at serious risk.

There are certainly improvements in other areas of the Bill, and I am working on a post detailing all the significant changes. But make no mistake – this remains a deeply deeply flawed undemocratic bill and it has had its reach extended from written political advocacy to verbal political advocacy also.

There can be only one response – Kill the Bill. Now.

Electoral Commission poll on MMP

The Electoral Commission has published some interesting results from their latest poll on political understanding.  I’ll go through them in turn:

“Fifty percent strongly agree with the view that list MPs are not as accountable to voters as electorate MPs. This is better than 61% seven years ago, but is still a long way from the view that all MPs are equally accountable through the ballot box.

I actually disagree with the EC that all MPs are equally accountable.  Yes they are all elected, but it is a totally legitimate view that an electorate MP is more accountable because one can directly vote an electorate MP out, while one can only indirectly vote List MPs out.

This isn’t to say it is better to be a List MP.  Almost every MP I know would much rather have an electorate than be reliant on the List. But that is not the same thing as asserting equal accountabilities.  Theyare both accountable but in different ways.

Also, there’s real uncertainty about the workload of list MPs. Nearly half (46%) of us are neutral or uncertain of our reaction to the statement that list MPs generally do as much work as electorate MPs, with the rest of us evenly split between agreeing and disagreeing.

I am not surprised there is uncertainity because I don’t think one can generalise.  If you have an MP who is lazy and wants to do the minimum workload then they would work less hours as a List MP because an Electorate MP does effectively have to have a fully staffed electorate office and spend time on some electorate issues.

But on the other hand some List MPs have offices in their local area and do just as much constituency work.   The hardest working MPs do 80 hours a week and are both electorate and list MPs.

“Finally, we checked out just how widespread concern apparent after the election concerning electorate losers returning through list seats was. In fact, 53% of us think that a sitting electorate MP losing an electorate seat should not be able to return to parliament through the party list. This is despite 71% agreeing, including 48% who strongly agree, that they take different things into account when deciding who gets their party and electorate votes,”

I am not surprised 43% want such a thing banned, but if it was all that would happen is MPs in danger of losing their seat would migrate to list only candidates.

Dr Catt noted that while 72% claimed to be interested in politics, four of six current issues put to respondents had each been discussed by between 82 and 85%, “suggesting politics might be seen narrowly as being about politicians and not issues”.

Yes often people proclaim they have no interest in politics, but they really do.

Now turning to the full results:

  • 51% consider MMP easy to understand
  • 65% correctly say the party vote is generally more important in deciding the number of MPs a party will get
  • Only 27% can correctly name the representation threshold as being 5% party vote or an electorate seat
  • 89% of over 75s say they are interested in politics compared to 40% of 18 and 19 year olds
  • Only 38% say they have a good idea what MPs do.  It would be good to explore ways to increase understanding of this.
  • 71% claim to take different things into account when deciding their party and electorate vote. This is not surprising as NZ has a large amount of vote splitting.

Those who lack trust …

I liked the final line of the Herald editorial on the Setchell affair:

We might also conclude that those who lack the capacity to trust cannot be trusted.

Absolutely.  Those who argue that Setchell should never have been given the job are mirroring their own behaviour – they can’t conceive that some people are not like them and can actually act ethically and professionally even when they don’t agree with the policies for example.

5.5% of GDP

The NZ Herald reports on the latest IPCC missive.  As always I am interested in the hard numbers so one can do meaningfull cost vs benefit analysis.

We have the already known prediction that by 2100 sea levels will rise by between 18cm and 59cm – an average rate of 1.8mm – 5.9 mm per year.

We then have the statement that stabilising CO2 levels by 2050 will mean decreasing global GDP by 5.5%.  Now I have not yet gone to the source data, but maybe someone could clarify if it means have GDP in 2050 5.5% less than it is today, or have the total GDP growth to 2050 5.5% less than it would have been otherwise.  For now I am assuming the latter.

Now what is 5.5% of global GDP? It’s US$2.65 trillion.  Not exactly spare change. And this is an annual amount of reduced wealth.  Now I’m not against this – just saying we need to be clear about the cost – reducing the world’s wealth by $2.65 trillion a year.
But hey if that is the price to keep temperatures stable, then that may be fine.  But is it?  You see that is the price to keep CO2 levels stable by 2050.  Now again I have yet to read the source report but maybe someone who has could explain whether that means keep them from increasing after 2050, or have them at 1990 levels by 2050?

And then once that is clarified can someone please find what either of those scenarios means in terms of average temperature by 2100 and average sea level rise?

Because if parties in NZ are talking about reducing the 2050 levels to 30% to 50% below 1990 levels, I guess that $2.65 trillion isn’t enough.  You see that’s the figures I really want to know.  How much money has to be spent to stop global warming due to CO2 totally by say 2050 or 2100?

Please note I am accepting everything the IPCC says as correct.  I am assuming they are experts in both climate science and economic forecasting and costing.  I just want to use their own figures to get clarity over the costs and the benefits.  Because at the moment they are expressed (at least in the NZ Herald summary) in a way which is incomparable. If we want the benefit to be stopping at 18 to 59 cm increase in sea levels, what is the cost of doing that?  Is is stabilising CO2 levels by 2050 or is it much more than that?

Finally given in

I’ve finally given into the temptation.

Day after day as Family First has complained about Californication, I’ve resisted the urge to watch it, as I don’t have time to watch another TV show.

As they knocked off sponsors one by one and reported daily progress, I’ve resisted the urge.

But this weekend it got too much for me as I read this press release from Family First:

The latest episode featured explicit sex scenes, constant explicit sexual talk and innuendo, was littered with foul language including 19 uses of the ‘F’ word, the young daughter calling her father an a**hole and boasting about having a shirt that says “Jesus is a C Word”, drug use, and an underage girl sexually touching the lead character.

They actually counted up the number of times the “F” word was used! 🙂

I give in.  My self control is not strong enough.  Just as I became hooked on Southpark after reading how Christian Heritage deplored the movie for having a homosexual sex scene between Saddam Hussein and Satan, I have now watched one episode of Californication and am grabbing a copy of the episode already shown.

My biggest fear is that one day Family First will condemn Coronation Street, and I’ll feel obliged to start watching that also!

McCarten on Electoral Finance Bill

Okay you know you have problems when even hard left activists such as Matt McCarten have their column labelled “Media gain more power when voice of democracy is muffled”:

Any Government that sets new rules for its own election that also affect its political opponents is going to create controversy. After all, we are talking about who gets to be prime minister and who gets to be an MP.

Incredulously, Labour’s common sense and well-honed political instincts seem to have deserted the party over this matter. It has been a botch-up from day one.

When this issue emerged, it was obvious that the only credible solution was to bring in a royal commission to consider all options.

Despite mounting opposition, Labour seems determined to push ahead. United Future and NZ First might support the bill but I’m surprised that the Greens are prepared to do back-room deals on it.

Seldom will the media run a partisan political campaign. So it was an extraordinary decision for the New Zealand Herald to launch a campaign against the proposed campaign law. A headline banner across the front page, reading “Democracy under attack” would have had most of us thinking that it was referring to the mischief created by the Urewera 16 – not the Government.

Such a defiant show of power by our nation’s biggest newspaper wouldn’t have been taken lightly. I’m sure this will result IN some MPs backing off on at least some of the proposed changes – which is good. However, the damage is done. The perception that Labour and its allies were up to no good is now ingrained in the public psyche.

Labour’s proposal is that everyone except political parties is neutralised and that parties’ private campaign funds are severely limited. That means the only viable way voters can get their political news and analysis is through the privately owned media, especially television and newspapers.

If Labour succeeds in curtailing non-party voices and influence, that puts even more power into the owners of our media outlets. The question not being asked is: during the next election, who’s going to be watching the watchers?

The increase in power to the media is of course a totally natural consequence of banning people from being able to effectively communicate their own message.  The media become the arbiter of which messages are worthy of being passed on to the public, and which are not.

McCarten is also quite correct in stating that some sort of neutral body such as a Royal Commission should have been engaged.   The public have been almost totally shut out of the debate – they got a one off submission to the select committee which is massively different to being able to respond to policy discussion papers, options papers, questionnaires etc.

So now that not even Matt McCarten is backing the Bill, Peter Davis remains the sole supporter!

TV coverage of Auckland protest

The TVNZ coverage was superb.  Go here to play the video if you missed it. The TV3 footage is also superb – especially focusing on the war veteran.

Those in or near Wellington – don’t forget Wednesday at 12.30 for our chance to have a protest march – a march that will literally be illegal next year (unless one signs a statutory declaration to take part) under the Electoral Finance Bill.

Hooton on neutral public service

Matthew Hooton has an excellent reasoned column on the public service, and the many examples of previous neutrality:

When he was trade minister, Lockwood Smith found that invariably the junior diplomats in our overseas posts had burned him in effigy a few years earlier when he was education minister and they were student protesters.

Smith was amused rather than offended. Old war stories could be swapped over dinner when the trade negotiations were done.

Winston Peters must know that many of his foreign affairs officials deplore his domestic agenda, but those same officials report that he behaves with the utmost courtesy and professionalism in all his dealings with his department.

Perhaps jet-setting foreign-policy ministers become more cosmopolitan and tolerant of political differences, but that does not explain why, as social welfare minister, the more aggressively partisan Roger Sowry worked entirely professionally with senior officials Vera Smith, who stood for Labour the previous election, and Alison Timms, whose husband Tony was a long-standing general secretary of the Labour Party and, at the time, was opposition leader Helen Clark’s right-hand man.

In 2000, I helped Margaret Wilson’s Labour Department communicate the Employment Relations Act to employers. Wilson, I’m told, was very happy with the work. Biosecurity New Zealand, I hope, received value when I reviewed their communications after the 2005 Waiheke Island foot and mouth scare.

Smith, Goff, Sutton, Peters, Sowry and Wilson are very different people, but they are all professionals. They understand that the departments for which they are temporarily responsible are not extensions of their political machines. However important they may think their work is, they know that one day they will be replaced, potentially by someone from a different party. In the meantime, they meet their obligations to protect their department’s reputation for integrity and independence, to ensure any future government will also have confidence in its work.

It’s a point well made.  Benson-Pope, Anderton and Parker have trampled on the neutrality convention, but not all Ministers do so. Some may be surprised that the Labour Department under Margaret Wilson hired Matthew Hooton to communicate the Employment Relations Act to employers, but that is how it should work – if he was the best person for the job, he should do it.  Professionals are able to separate out their personal views and not let them interfere with their professional duty.

In the next year, government departments will spend at least $60 million on advertising to inform us about government services and to explain the government’s policies.

If the public service is truly independent, it needs to satisfy itself that the tone and style of all this advertising would be identical under either Labour or National. It should reflect the brand personality of the department, not the party in power.

Indeed.

Logan then appointed a senior Labour Party official, Clare Curran, who was recommended by Climate Change Minister David Parker just days after she presented a paper to a Labour conference arguing Labour needed to “take greater charge of the language of debate and discussion in New Zealand”.

Curran is as entitled as anyone to secure work from the ministry, but given her political activity and the fact New Zealand has a bipartisan climate change policy, she needs to be absolutely sure that she would have given identical communications advice had National’s Nick Smith been its minister instead of Parker.

That has been questioned. As a result, all her work should be released publicly. If there is even a hint that it was politically slanted, she must never again be given a government contract and Logan and Parker must be fired.

There have been numerous OIA requests filed for Curran’s work and advice.  It will be most interesting to see what emerges.

Kiwiblog – where even “terrorists” debate the issues!

I was amused to get a call on Friday from the Herald on Sunday informing me that one of the Urewera 17, Te Rangikaiwhiria Kemara, had previously posted on my blog in relation to how sovereignity changes never come about via talk but “at the edge of a sword, bayonet or bombs”.  They just wanted me to confirm the posts were genuine, not from a fake e-mail address.

Of course my first reaction was “Cool – even the terrorists comes to Kiwiblog to debate the issues” 🙂

In case it isn’t obvious, please note I am using the term “terrorists” for humour effect. I am not suggesting guilt, innocence or even involvement in any particular alleged crime.

The Herald on Sunday article is here.

Trevor Loudon at New Zeal also has some other online writings from Te Rangikaiwhiria Kemara.

The Herald on Sunday also has a story on a visit to Iran by Tame Iti.

Also the HoS supports the publication of the alleged evidence:

He has declined to authorise prosecution under the Suppression of Terrorism Act, but we are not to be trusted with the information that prompted police to launch the most pre-emptive strike they have ever undertaken against civilians in this country.

And Deborah Coddington writes that the evidence is terrifying:

So now we know. Little surprise Solicitor-General David Collins said the evidence collected by police during the anti-terrorism raids was “very disturbing”.

Until now, allegations by lawyers and supporters of those arrested that the police action was illegal, brutal, racist and violent have been largely unchallenged (with notable, and surprising exceptions such as Chris Trotter). When Moana Jackson said police spread-eagled a mother on the ground and locked her screaming children in the shed for six hours without water, National Radio unquestioningly reported it.

Contempt of court or not, at least publication of the evidence gives us hard evidence, and it is terrifying.

I doubt any of the 180 or so people who purchased a half-page advertisement calling for the repeal of the anti-terrorism legislation, will buy equal space acknowledging they were wrong to state “it’s not terrorism, it is democratic dissent”.

I still have many unanswered questions.  The things said were all very bad, but we don’t know who exactly said what, and to whom. We don’t know how many firearms were actually picked up in the raids (I’ve seen numbers from four to 14), and we’ve yet to get real clarity on how often weapons were used in the Ureweras, and by whom.

Ralston this week

Bill Ralston traverses both the Setchell Affair and the Electoral Finance Bill:

To quickly summarise the cock-up: Madeleine Setchell was sacked as communications manager at the Ministry for the Environment because the minister did not like the fact her partner was an adviser to Opposition Leader John Key.

The Hunn report, which investigated the affair, found top public servants and ministers were colluding over who could and could not be hired as spin doctors.

Her [Clark] own staff co-ordinate not only all the press secretaries in the Beehive but manage the strategy for virtually every word that comes out of every department and agency of state.

Also, it coordinates multi-million-dollar departmental publicity campaigns to portray the Government as taking action on virtually any issue worrying voters. Curiously, every election year, these advertising campaigns seem to increase.

If the public is concerned about health issues, the relevant department runs a “public education” campaign about the wonderful advances being made in the health sector.

Worried about your retirement? If the Government’s constant polling picks up your concern you bet there will be a campaign to explain to you the glories of the KiwiSaver scheme and how you can benefit from it.

Under pressure from increased mortgage rates, married couples are worrying about how one partner can take time out of work to raise children. So the Government has a nifty early childhood education publicity campaign up its sleeve so it can demonstrate to struggling parents that not only can they offload the kids for several more hours a week but the little ankle-biters might even learn something while the parents are generating desperately needed cash for the household.

That does tend to make a mockery of the Electoral Finance Bill, which will severely restrict spending by Government critics in an election year while allowing Government departments a virtual free hand.

As long as a “public eduction” campaign doesn’t blatantly say “Vote Labour” the chances are the Auditor-General will okay the department’s publicity spending as non-political.

Isn’t it nice how we give the Government hundreds of millions of tax dollars so it can hire publicists to tell us how well it is doing?

Ralston, like many others, sees the obvious links between the Setchell affair and the Electoral Finance Bill – it’s all about spending as much taxpayer money as possible on re-election while preventing critics from spending their own money against you.

Finally an Electoral Finance Bill Supporter

At long last, after months of searching, we have found a supporter of the Electoral Finance Bill. Even the Greens have admitted the current Bill is appalling. Nicky Hager labelled it as something you’d expect from the Nazi Party. No one has been willing to defend it in public, but finally we have a brave latter writer to the NZ Herald.

davis.jpg

Yes a Peter Davis from the Auckland University Sociology Department is defending the Bill.

Now by coincidence the Peter Davis married to Helen Clark is also with the Auckland University Sociology Department.

Surely things are not so bad that the only person they could get to write in support of the Electoral Finance Bill was the PM’s husband?

Hat Tip: Too Right