General Debate 17 November 2007
Enjoy the weekend.
Well a couple of lefties were sneering yesterday that they expected 75 people to turn up to the Auckland March. Newstalk ZB reports:
Queen Street in Auckland has been brought to a standstill today, with a crowd estimated at more than two thousand marching against the Electoral Finance Bill.
Helen Clark is being told her proposals are fascist and unwanted. Protest organiser John Boscawen wants the Prime Minister to kill the Bill, which will put a caps on spending by lobby groups during an election year.
Members of the Law Society, political parties and the Sensible Sentencing Trust are angry Labour’s trying to push through the legislation without consultation.
Members of the migrant community on the march say they came to New Zealand to escape dictatorship, and some have likened Miss Clark to Adolf Hitler.
While the comparison to Hitler is of course wrong, the underlying point is that the Electoral Finance Bill has clauses in it which you would expect from tinpot third world dictatorships. In fact even Nicky Hager said it was like something you would expect from the Nazi Party (even though he supports the intent).
Radio NZ also has an interesting report:
At least 1000 people marched through central Auckland on Saturday, loudly protesting a controversial law change proposal.
The Electoral Finance Bill aims to extend the electioneering period to a year and limits the monetary support third parities can offer.
A Radio New Zealand reporter at the march says many who took part were waving placards and had duct tape across their mouths.
The protesters believe the proposed legislation is a direct threat to democracy, a breach of human rights and will limit their rights to free speech.
Many of the protesters came from outside Auckland and have been staunch Labour Party supporters in the past. They say the law would be a “facist” one if passed.
Organisers say more marches will be held in Wellington and Christchurch if the bill, which could be bought up in Parliament as early as next week, is not scrapped.
The bill has been criticised by the Human Rights Commission and the Law Society.
Well done to all those who gave up part of their weekend to protest.
Enjoy the weekend.
John Key has asked Mark Prebble to re-engage Don Hunn to inquire into the hiring of Clare Curran after she was recommended by David Parker for a communications position. I want to focus on one quote:
“Ministers must know that any such comments they make to officials, no matter how casual they seem, carry the potential inference of ministerial wishes and will influence officials.”
Now this can not be stressed too strongly. If you want to know how high up the list of priorities, keeping the Minister happy is – it’s an 12 on a scale from 1 to 10. Even a musing out loud from a Minister can leads to teams of officials being assigned to look into that musing.
A Government Department has one and only one customer – their Minister. Sure they may interact with the public (and do a good job of it) but the person they need to keep happy above all others is the Minister.
So when a Minister suggests to Departmental officials that Mr X or Ms Y would be a useful person to hire, that isn’t the same as anyone else suggesting the same.
I was stunned to read that there are 18,000 court cases on hold primarily because defendents have not turned up or fled while on bail.
Hence it makes a lot of sense to liberalise the bail laws even further, as the Government is doing. Not. And the consequences are sometimes tragic.
Condolences to John Boscawen. Have just read at Peter Cresswell’s blog:
John Boscawen, the organiser of tomorrow’s Queen St march against the Clark Government’s assault on democracy, received news yesterday that his father has died.*
John will still be there. So should you.
The march gathers outside the Town Hall from ten o’clock, leaving to march down Queen St at ten thirty. Get down there to raise your voice against the rationing of political speech and the rorting of elections.
By coincidence, John’s father was Peter’s high school headmaster.
The full extent of the politicisation of the public service is being revealed.
First we learnt that for the high crime of having a journalist boyfriend who went off to work for John Key, that Madeleine Setchell was blacklisted by not one but two and maybe even three Ministries. Despite glowing recommendations about her ability and professionalism, cowardly CEOs deferred to their Minister’s wishes as to who not to hire.
But it gets even worse. They also defer to their Ministers as who to hire. At the same time as Setchell is getting illegally fired, Hugh Logan is hiring a Clare Curran to do some communications work for the Environment Ministry. Why did he hire Curran? Because David Parker suggested she be hired.
Now Clare Curran is an unusual name. Wasn’t there a Clare Curran who presented a paper to a Labour Party conference on the need to “reframe” Labour’s language to increase public interest in its policies?
Also I’m sure there is a Clare Curran who is actually on the ruling Council of the Labour Party?
Possibly the same Clare Curran who is seeking the Labour Party nomination for Dunedin South?
Now tie this all into Mark Prebble’s comments that he is concerned that the Environment Ministry may be planning to run an information campaign which will be too political, and hence that was a factor in getting rid of Setchell. Who then better to help devise the campaign than Labour’s own comms expert?
Ministers have been caught with their dirty little hands all over the public service. Almost as bad as the Ministers are the CEOs who are complicit. Martin Kay blogs on Hugh Logan’s woeful performance.
So why have no heads rolled? Benson-Pope was sacked for lying not for interfering. How widespread is the practice of CEOs consulting their Ministers over staff appointments?
It is absolutely outrageous that a cosy deal has been done to allow Labour to keep most of its anonymous donations.
If anonymous donations are seen to be bad, then they should be banned totally.
Here’s a challenge to the Greens who have championed ending anonymous donations – move an amendment at committee of the whole stage to the Electoral Finance Bill to abolish all anonymous donations above the discloseable limit. Will the Greens stand up for their principles or have they done a dirty deal with Labour to protect Labour’s anonymous donations?
Most on the left support a ban on anonymous donations. Here’s their chance to show some integrity – join in asking the Greens to move an amendment to ban all anonymous donations above the disclosure limit. Force Labour and National to vote on the amendment.
The principle is simple. Electoral Law should not be written to favour one party. Setting a level of acceptable anonymous donations that is obviously tailored to Labour is outrageous. It is an Americanisation of our electoral system, such as where they set boundaries to favour one party. Reject the Americanisation of NZ politics and reject the cosy deal cooked up by Labour and the Greens.
The NZ Herald explains why opposing the Electoral Finance Bill is about democracy.
We have called our campaign against the Electoral Finance Bill “Democracy under Attack”. Some have questioned this, saying surely it is an issue of freedom of speech, not democracy. They are perhaps defining democracy in the narrow sense as the right to vote.
Democracy without free speech is a sham. Some of the most repressive states in recent history have called themselves democratic on the grounds that the solitary party permitted to express political views and take part in elections allowed people to vote.
I’ve said a few times that I value my right to free speech as being more important than my right to vote. I only get to vote once every three years, but through my right to speak out and criticise I can have far more influence.
Nobody is suggesting the Electoral Finance Bill will constrain political debate to that degree. The only element our Government has in common with those further left is that it shares their fear of private money in political debate. The bill is aimed not at outright bribery of voters – long outlawed – but at the right of independent organisations to promote issues of concern to them in an election year.
The Electoral Finance Bill would rule out exercises such as that. Any organisation wishing to spend money to advance a view in election year would be required to disclose its intentions in advance to the Electoral Office, disclose the sources of its finance and face a limit on the amount it could spend.
Political parties must do all of that, though the bill as drafted puts non-parties under a much tighter financial restriction than parties, and another bill in the House this week allows parties to bypass the concerns of the Auditor-General about their use of public funds for electioneering. The political playing field is being tilted very much in favour of parties in Parliament.
Indeed. Labour’s pledge card will be state funded and exempt from spending caps. Organisations which might disagree with the pledge card will be severely limited in their ability to communicate their view.
Labour could pass another foreshore & seabed type law confiscating property rights off Maori, and there would be serious barriers for groups opposed to that law to be able to communicate their views.
Professor Andrew Geddis talks about the Electoral Finance Bill. First he notes the four major problems with how Labour has gone about this:
Geddis goes on to then say that it is reasonable to have some restrictions on third party advertising:
We also should remember that the issue of third party spending does not exist in a vacuum. It is rather a part of an overall system of regulating the conduct of election campaigns in New Zealand; along with the role money plays in these.
Our current rules place a range of restrictions on the use of money to try to bring about a particular result at election time. Using cash to bribe voters, or treat them to food and drink, has been unlawful since 1858. Individual candidates have faced limits on their total campaign expenses since 1895. Limits on political party election spending have existed since 1995.
And I agree with him. The problem is that Labour has soiled it by breaking all the conventions, as alluded to in point one. It is writing the rules for pure partisan gain. It is seeking to legalise its illegal activities from 2005, and has shut the public and non supporting parties out of the pre-legislative process.
The dirty sordid deal on anonymous donations between Labour and the Greens shows that it is a bill not based on what is good for the public, or for democracy. It is a blatant attempt to screw the scrum to help get re-elected.
The precedent it will set, if the bill is passed, is horrible. The Electoral Act will be up for grabs every election. How could anyone on the left criticise National if they do the reverse of what Labour has done this time? Sure John Key has pledged to do the right thing and have some sort of Royal Commission of Inquiry make recommendations on the big issues. But National would be 100% justified to do what Labour has done and design a bill in secret with its allies. Do people really want the governing party after every election secretly negotiating changes to the Electoral Act to screw over their critics and opponents?
Just had a message from an ex in the United States who asked me if she could ring me urgently.
Of course I said yes and I’m busy wondering what it is about. Does she want to talk about her job? Is she annoyed at me for something? Does she want to talk relationships? It’s 10 pm at night so it must be important.
Well she calls, and her urgent query is asking how to solve the problem x/2 + x/4 = 1. Her boss’ daughter needs it solved for her homework and despite being a firm of accountants, no one at their workplace could remember how to do it. The boss is calling all his staff for an answer.
Luckily I can recall some basic algebra manipulation with numerators etc and told her how to solve it.
So nice to know she thinks of me for the really big issues. We haven’t chatted for several months and our only phone call is about algebra!
I was very pleased I managed to get along to The Hollow Men after they did a second season in Wellington. I thought it was most appropriate to attend with the National Party General Manager, plus the Young Nats President and Auckland Girl.
We had a great time. Laughed at a lot of the same places as everyone else. Also a few time only we were laughing because of our knowledge of the people portrayed. And we started to get stares from people as everyone got the giggles after Stephen Papps said that no one is alive today who took part in the Maori Land Wars, and I whispered that I thought Sir George Chapman might have been. We almost lost it at that point.
Anyway, what worked, and what didn’t work:
Good
The script generally was very good, especially when it kept true to the actual e-mails. There are some great lines and they reflect what basically happens in every major political party. It would be even more amusing if they bugged some of the strategy meetings instead of just having e-mails to rely on.
Stephen Papps physically was a good Don Brash. He played the role well, even though it was an invented role – not 100% like the real Don. They tried to portray him as a pretty stupid guy with no sense of humour. Don has an excellent well developed sense of humour, and is a bloody genius. Yes he was politically naive in some areas, but they overplayed that – but that’s the nature of the beast and it was still a good performance as he did capture the core issue of the battle between what you would like to do and what you can do.
Arthur Meek does a wonderful Bryan Sinclair. The confidence and energy are all there.
Michael Keir Morrissey did a reasonably good Peter Keenan as the wise advisor, except he made Peter somewhat gay. He also didn’t pick up on the considerable humour which Peter displayed. But overall not bad.
The star for me was Will Harris who played Phil Goff, Richard Long, Michael Bassett , Murray McCully and a couple of others. His Goff impression was just superb. It was just like listening to him in the actual debating chamber.
The scene where Don and Dick Allen sing the national anthem together was hilarious. I don’t know if that was invented or is something referred to in e-mails, but it was good.
The overall play direction worked well. The use of music to move on a scene, and the brisk pace of the cast as they walked off and on the stage reminded a wee bit of some good West Wing scenes.
Not so Good
Sam Snedden didn’t capture Matthew Hooton that well I found – to be fair Matthew is a larger than life character in some ways. Also it may be partly because the book doesn’t understand the real dynamics around National at that time. They have all the leaked e-mails, but not a single insider who could fill in the gaps (hence why I doubt an insider leaked them because they didn’t supply any additional info which would show). The play portrayed Matthew as if he was a staffer there with Don constantly. There were no string of meetings where Matthew and Bryan and Peter were fighting.
Lyndee-Jane Rutherford played Diane Foreman, Sue Wood, and several others. I hated most of her performance. Nothing against her as an actress, but portraying Sue Wood as some sort of simpering fluffy idiot is a total mismatch. She did the same for Diane Foreman. In fact pretty much all the female characters came across as dizzy airheads, which if I were more politically correct would suggest showed a streak of sexism.
The somewhat manic portrayal of Ruth Richardson wasn’t bad though – I think I’ve heard a similiar speech from Ruth myself on occasion 🙂
I’m halfway through the book itself, and will also review that when finished. As I said the play is a good watch, and for those interested in politics especially I’d recommend you go before final day on the 17th. It’s a good laugh and does portray some of what happens behind the scenes quite well. It is exaggerated of course for dramatic effect. It happens to be about National as they are the ones who got all their e-mails stolen. I’d dare say you would get a similar (but not identical) play from any major party in the western world. It is about balancing what you personally think is best, with what will appeal to the electorate. It is about how to make speeches effective and resonate. It is about working out what the policy priorities should be. That’s all part of the parcel.
So it was a good night out. To keep with the political theme we dined at the Green Parrot beforehand and then Auckland Girl and I had a couple of drinks at the Malt House – I then headed home after I cleared the call saying I had to be on TV at 7 am – otherwise might have become a very late night!
There is no limit to the extent that Labour will go to write electoral laws to suit itself. We’ve heard that the revised bill will have some limits on anonymous donations.
But instead of abolishing them (over the reporting limit), which I would support, the Dom Post reports that one will be allowed $240,000 of anonymous donations over three years.
Now how much money did Labour get in the last election from anon donations? $315,000
Now $65,000 of their anonymous donations could be done non-anoymously if they had people give $10k a year. So taking that away from the $315,000 and you get $250,000 – almost a perfect match.
This is fucking outrageous. We the public have had no chance to have input into that limit. I want a zero limit for anonymous donations (above the reporting threshold). Instead we have a limit hand picked by Labour as allowing them to retain basically all of their anonymous donations.
The public have been totally excluded from any input into what level of anonymous donations, if any, should be allowed. Instead Labour and allies cook up a sweetheart deal designed to do just one thing – preserve Labour’s funding.
Labour have a democracy deficit in their thinking. The Herald nailed them – they think democracy is only useful as a tool to get them elected.
Here’s what National should do. They should move an amendment at the committee of the whole stage to outlaw all anonymous donations (over the reporting limit)
and see if the Greens and NZ First have the balls to vote on principle or vote for their cosy deal with Labour to protect Labour’s funding sources.
Phillida Bunkle, who served in Helen Clark’s Cabinet from 1999 to 2001, as Minister of Consumer Affairs has been arrested after allegedly trying to steal food to consume. The alleged goods shoplifted are a bottle of Stone’s green ginger wine worth $15.20 and two blocks of Fagg’s coffee each worth $7.19 in her bag.
Well the Government did always believe in redistribution of wealth, but that’s taking it to a new level!
A big reminder to those in or near Auckland that John Boscawen had organised a march against the Electoral Finance Bill this Saturday 17 November from the Auckland Town Hall at 10.30am (assemble from 10am).
Remember that under the current version of the Electoral Finance Bill, such a protest march would be illegal next year unless one did statutory declarations for all the placards.
Molesworth & Featherston‘s always interesting weekly newsletter has a good column on the the Hunn Report. Extracts:
Above all, Mr Hunn’s report on the episode report is an indictment of Hugh Logan and senior staff at the Ministry of the Environment. Throughout, Environment’s behaviour smacked of petty bureaucracy by officials promoted beyond their competence. Once Mr Logan decided to remove Ms Setchell, the department’s behaviour was duplicitous and blundering.
The report damningly finds that Mr Logan at no point had any discussion about how a potential conflict of interest could be managed. No effort was made to protect Ms Setchell’s personal integrity.
The Ministry fought bitterly to defend its view that not enough was disclosed at Ms Setchell’s initial interview. Mr Hunn rejects the ministry view, leaving it in an utterly untenable position.
The evidence is conclusive that the potential conflict of interest question was raised at interview and Ms Setchell was blameless. The ministry’s attempts to raise confusion over what was disclosed were petty and vindictive.
It all adds up to failures on Mr Logan’s part not only Ms Setchell’ employer, but in his management of his ministry.
The report shows, but doesn’t highlight, that at senior levels of the public service there are grotesque misjudgements about what constitutes an unmanageable conflict of interest. At MAF, Murray Sherwin disgracefully rejected Ms Setchell from consideration for a subsequent job not because she couldn’t do the job, but because he was too frightened of the pressure he may have faced.
The idea a woman can be fired because of her partner’s job is neanderthal (the silence of senior Labour women MPs on the issue is deafening.)
Suggestions the Sherwin-Logan view is shared by other ceos suggest backside-covering is more important than performance in the public service. The public service is smeared by this unspoken policy, because it means public servants are appointed for their servility, not ability.
Not much there one can disagree with.
Also No Right Turn has a good missive on the issue.
I’ll let Garth’s own words speak for him:
If ever there were a reason to turf this Government out, it is the arrogance and hypocrisy of the Dear Leader in refusing point blank to scrap the despicable Electoral Finance Bill.
Here is a woman who has been blathering on about human rights ever since she became a public face, who rails against the military takeover in Fiji and demands a return to democracy there, and who gallivants round the world attending wartime anniversaries.
The irony seems to escape her that this bill, which has been written for no other reason than to give Labour an advantage during next year’s election campaign, is the most serious attack on human rights in this country that has ever been mounted.
It is an assault on democracy every bit as dangerous as the antics of Frank Bainimarama, for it is the sort of legislation that prospective dictators force through to shut down public dissent.
And it is an insult to the thousands of New Zealanders who died in two world wars to turn back those who would have enslaved us and preserve our democracy and our human rights.
I have contempt, too, for the Labour running dogs who have indicated they will support this Government bill – the MPs of United Future, NZ First and the Greens.
I suppose it is expected of that master of self-interested compromise, Winston Peters, who is about to visit North Korea as our non-Cabinet Minister of Foreign Affairs.
If Kim Jong-il hears about the Electoral Finance Bill, he’ll probably invite Winston to dinner.
Peter Dunne has never been anything but Labour lite and can be trusted only to lick the Government’s boots.
But I must say I’m a bit surprised at the Greens. I would have thought blokes like Keith Locke and Nandor Tanczos, those champions of the underdog, would have cavilled at this piece of legislation. But no. Politics overrides principle yet again.
It is ironic, isn’t it, that the excuse being used to put this bill forward is the activities of the leaders of an obscure religious cult during the last election campaign who wanted rid of Labour and the Greens and were prepared to put their money where their mouths were to the tune of $1.2 million.
Setting aside the fact that they were perfectly entitled to carry out this democratic activity, the irony is that it backfired on National and probably cost it that election.
The other thing, of course, that is pricking Clark and Co to go through with this bill – in spite of the opposition, some of it from Labour-friendly sources such as the Law and Human Rights Commissions – is simmering resentment over having to pay back $1.2 million for illegal taxpayer-funded election advertising last time.
So the Dear Leader and her minions are determined that next time advertising condemning or criticising the Government will be heavily restricted, while the Government will be able to spend what it likes promoting its own policies at no cost to the party.
If ever there was a misuse of political power, this is it. As this newspaper said in only its second front-page editorial in five years, “democracy is not a device to keep Labour in power”.
And, as with all addictions, the longer it is practised the worse it gets. Thus, the dumping of Labour a year from now would really be a humane act. Its members need saving from themselves.
I am intrigued that one of the Dear Leader’s arguments in favour of the bill is that “the National Party benefits enormously from big money in New Zealand politics”.
If that is true, how come National was almost wiped out in 2002 and failed to win Government in 2005?
Labour strategists seem to think that anger over this bill, if it becomes law in the next few weeks, will be forgotten come next year.
Not so. I, for one, certainly won’t forget. But who knows?
Perhaps by then this column will be banned by law, too.
Labour’s hopes are that this issue will go away in a few weeks. They thought that also with the pledge card. They were wrong. They thought they could stand up for Taito Philip Field and that would go away. They were wrong.
The Herald editorial is on the Electoral Finance Bill again. I won’t quote most of it, but teh conclusion is important:
In essence, the Appropriations Bill provides political incumbents with parliamentary money for their campaigning, while the Electoral Finance Bill prevents the public using its own money. In sum, this double-whammy represents an assault on this country’s democratic wellbeing.
Indeed it is vital to look at the bills together. They were designed to complement each other.
This is the time politicians should heed the torrent of public disapproval, scrap this bill and refer the subject to a nonpartisan body where constitutional rule-making belongs.
This is what the Government should have done after the last election. But they rejected openness and transparency for months and months of secret negotiations with Winston and the Greens.
The tragedy of how the Government has managed this process is that it has prevented people from getting together in good faith to debate and have input into the policy principles which any law should be based on.
Here’s the likely timeline for the Electoral Finance Bill:
Thu 15 Nov – Select Committee signs off report
Fri 16 Nov – Select Committee report tabled
Thu 22 Nov – 2nd reading of Electoral Finance Bill – probably from 3 pm to 5 pm
Tue 4 Dec – Committee of the Whole stage begins probably at 3 pm. Unlikely to finish that day and as Wed 5 Dec is a private member’s day, probably conclude Thu 6 Dec
Tue 11 Dec – 3rd reading of Electoral Finance Bill on what is currently the final scheduled day for Parliament to sit before Christmas – probably from 3 pm to 5 pm
Once the bill is reported back I will do an analysis of any changes.
Just had a phone call from TV3 and I am on their sunrise show tomorrow (Thursday) at around 7.10 am to discuss the Electoral Finance Bill.
A reader has just alerted me to a special subscription for the Listener – 12 months for $99 instead of $149 (and about to rise). You need to ring 0800 500 175 to get the special though up until 8 pm tonight.
Audrey Young blogs her take on the Hunn Report. She says:
The Don Hunn report gives greater cause for concern than we had before.
It seems our new coins are magnetic!
Craig Foss has detected a case of identity fraud at Parliament.
Perhaps this also explains why ACT voted in favour of legalising Helen Clark’s pledge card as okay to be taxpayer funded?
Some of these ideas will depend on the final version of the Bill when passed. The idea is to have fun, and keep the issue alive. If people have constructive ideas of their own, post them in comments.
Former State Services Commissioner Don Hunn has published his report into the treatment of Madeleine Setchell. It’s comprehensive and very well done.
Some extracts, and commentary:
The CE is also certain that the adviser said at some stage in the telephone exchanges on 28 May that he had told the Minister about the “rumour”: he gained the impression that the Minister was “exceptionally annoyed”.
But I am sure that had no influence!
Having himself been in a similar situation as the Communications Manager appeared to be, the Commissioner said the CE shouldn’t rush into things simply because of family connections. The first aim should be to see if the potential conflict could be managed. The Commissioner commented that if he were the CE he would not himself talk to the Minister in the circumstances as he understood them.
Bravo Dr Prebble. Indeed managing the conflict should be the first aim. In fact as one reads the entire report you realise Hugh Logan is principally to blame as he ignored the SSC advice and shut his mind to trying to manage the conflict. While Benson-Pope lied about what he did say, he is not principally to blame for what happened – Hugh Logan is.
The CE recalls the Minister responding that staff decisions were the CE’s to make, but that he would find it difficult to speak as freely as he would with other senior managers, in front of an employee who was in a close family relationship with someone working for the Leader of the Opposition. He reminded the CE that the Government had recently announced its intention to give environmental issues a much higher profile in the Government’s priorities and it would thus be open to much greater pressure from the Opposition on these issues. It was only to be expected that he would be more cautious in discussing matters of policy and tactics in front of such a person, so that meetings with the senior managers might not be as productive as, desirably they should be.
Now Logan may have already closed his mind to managing the conflict, but this is certainly a not very subtle way of saying get rid of this person.
For his part the Minister does not recall the detail of the conversation
Tsk, old age is sad.
The CE remembers the conversation as a “robust” one on the Minister’s part but not out of the ordinary. The Minister customarily expressed his views firmly and this was no exception.
Heh, this is code for the Minister swore at us for being idiots, but we’re used to it.
The Commissioner made the following points: – the increased emphasis on environmental policy was not the same as close political management of the Minister’s position;
– if the Government was planning a politically oriented environmental communications programme, the Ministry shouldn’t be doing it: if it wasn’t, it should be possible to find a way to manage the appointment;
Again, well done Dr Prebble. This sums it up nicely. If the campaign is that political it should not happen, and if it isn’t that political Setchell should be fine to keep her job. I think we have some idea of how political they were planning.
The CE mentioned that one of the reasons for his decision had been the Minister’s reaction to the Communications Manager’s relationship with her partner. The Deputy Commissioner responded along the lines – “Well if the Minister does display concern, just tell him to get over it”. (The CE did not find this particularly helpful: the remark may have been a little colourful but the CE could not have had a more succinct encapsulation of the SSC view of where the Minister’s and the CE’s responsibilities began and ended).
And a big kudos to the Deputy Commissioner for indeed succintly provided the correct response.
Now we get to an intersting aspect – Setchell also applied to MAF as she was leaving Environment. She was a former staffer at MAF and had worked there with no problems under previous Labour Ministers. But she was turned down for this job also, after Jim Anderton was consulted:
In his view Ms Setchell’s previous experience both as a senior MAF communications adviser and as Communications Manager at Dairy Insight (a key agricultural stakeholder and partner of MAF), uniquely qualified her for the position he was proposing.
So she was uniquely qualified. But did she get the job or has the Government so politicsed the civil service that she can’t even get a job she is uniquely qualified for?
The Acting Communications Director replied: “Of course I will accept any decision the Minister makes but I am extremely worried about the potential precedent here. We have a number of employees with potential “perceived” conflicts that may come in to play with a change of government. I look forward to hearing the Minister’s office’s response.”
The Acting CD understands the wider issue. If the Setchell test was applied to current civil servants when National wins office, there would probably be hundreds out of work.
The CE again emailed his Director, saying: “I have discussed with (the Chief of Staff) and he has discussed with the Minister. The answer is a clear “no”. I can discuss further once you are back.”
Well that’s clear.
in 8 years as Minister he had had only one such previous case of a politically sensitive employment matter being raised with him by a CE,
Indeed and in that case also, Jim Anderton killed off the career of a respected civil servant who had already had his desire to seek a candiacy cleared with his manager and the CEO. He was no different to Parekura Horomia and Verna Smith who both stood for Labour, yet held senior roles involving close contact with National Ministers.
Now we have the conclusions from Dr Prebble:
But before discussing the performance of officials, I must first refer to the other person involved, Madeleine Setchell. I found that Ms Setchell has behaved entirely properly. She provided information about the potential conflict at appropriate times. It was not her fault that things did not turn out well.
Don Hunn also makes much the same point.
Third, Mr Logan was entitled to take the apparent conflict into account and to seek to manage that conflict, but I am not convinced that it was inevitable that Ms Setchell must transfer from the position of Communications Manager to another job.
Indeed, and this is important. Helen Clark and others have said Setchell should never have got the job in the first place. This is a rebuff to her, clearly stating that such conflicts can and should be managed – as happens every day with hunderds of other civil servants.
Turning to my personal performance, I accept Mr Hunn’s conclusion that I made an error in failing to ensure that the appropriate members of staff in SSC were aware of all the information that had been conveyed to me by Mr Logan. This, combined with my later forgetting the information about the discussion with the Minister, means I am responsible for some of the confusion that followed during July. I regret those mistakes. They do not reflect the standards that I seek to maintain while holding this office.
I was critical of Dr Prebble’s memory lapse, but I can’t fault his willingness to accept responsibility. I also think the Hunn Report shows him generally as having given very good advice and acted appropriately.
Accordingly, I have decided to act as closely as I can to what I would require of other Chief Executives in similar circumstances. I have consulted with senior colleagues; they agree that in similar circumstances with another Chief Executive I would impose a penalty of around 2.5% of salary. I see no reason why I should be exempt from my own standards, so I have made a payment to our departmental Chief Financial Officer which is equivalent to a deduction of 2.5% from my annual salary.
Hell that I did not expect. Sure, it is only symbolic – but it is a very powerful symbol and a real mark of leadership – showing accountability for actions. I’m very impressed.
I consider it reasonable that Ministers should hold me to very high standards. If Ministers, on considering this matter, believe that I should stay in the job I will continue to serve. If Ministers have lost confidence in my performance, I will leave.
That is an offer I am sure will be declined – as it should be.