SST says Field to face a trial

The SST says it has heard from sources in Wellington that Taito Phillip Field will be charged and face a trial for corruption and perverting the course of justice.

Sources in Wellington is generally code for Helen. In this case it may be Cullen as Attorney-General.

John Key Tour Guide

If John Key doesn’t get to be Prime Minister he has a fine future ahead of him as a parliamentary tour guide. The video above is 11 minutes long but surprisingly watchable with a tour through the debating chamber, the grand hall, the parliamentary press gallery and then his own offices. Key is keeping up the video blogging pretty well with two or three updates a week.

But a life as a tour guide looks somewhat less likely tonight after the startling turn-around in the TV3 poll. TV3/TNS have shown Labour leading in every single poll since the election. Their May poll not only has National ahead, but a 14% turnaround from Labour 2% ahead to National 12% ahead. Also for the first time since Helen Clark became Prime Minister, they show her in second place as Preferred PM.

I swear I can recall some people saying the smacking compromise was a disaster for Key. Well looks to be a fairly pleasant disaster as disasters go.

Joke

Investigate’s allegations against the Police

Ian Wishart in Investigate Magazine has made a huge number of staggering claims against top police officers, including Commissioner Howard Broad who has already admitted that at least one allegation of a bestiality video (involving a man fornicating with a chicken!) did happen, even though he claims not to have been in the room at his house when it showed.

The allegations are not just of private consensual conduct, but include:

* A 1984 child sex [illegal], bondage [not illegal if consensual] and bestiality [illegal] ring operating in Dunedin in 1984 run by the father of a police officer and attended by at least one Labour cabinet minister [I think this refers to someone who was a Labour Minister in 1984]

* the existence of videotapes of police rapes and bestiality involving police officers

* Indecent assaults by current high ranking police officers

* Dunedin and Christchurch Police had arrangements to turn a blind eye to organised crime – including underage sex and drug dealing – in return for sexual favours from brothels

* Dunedin police officers, former and current, have been involved in multiple rapes of junior female police staff, prostitutes and civilians, drug deals, and conspiracy to pervert the course of justice, including falsifying charges

I have not read the full article, and can not judge the reliability or authenticity of the allegations except to note that the Commissioner has confirmed at least one aspect is correct.

If the allegations can not be substantiated, those named should sue for defamation to clear their names. These are very serious allegations.

Wishart has called for a royal commission of inquiry into the performance of the New Zealand Police, with wide terms of reference and full powers to subpoena, compel and take evidence on oath. I would like to know why some of this info was not placed before the Bazley inquiry, and whether maybe the PCA (so long as it does not use any current Police officers) could not investigate the claims?

National sets carbon targets

Carbon emissions have grown faster in NZ since 1999 than in most other countries, despite the rhetoric of Labour, but with no action.

Clark has spoken of being carbon neutral but absolutely refuses to set any timeframe around that. John Key however has announced a policy commitment today of a 50% reduction in carbon-equivalent net emissions by 2050 (compared to 1990).

Some extracts from the speech (not online yet)

In the decades ahead, peoples’ perceptions around climate change will affect the brand image of New Zealand and its exports. New Zealand must take credible steps to reduce greenhouse gas emissions or risk becoming a trading pariah.

We’re going to need some serious climate ‘cred’ to tackle the ‘Food Miles’ bullies.

We also need to be on the economic offensive.

Climate change awareness will create new markets for Kiwi industries, tourism, and technology. It’s estimated that demand for low-carbon products will be worth at least $500 billion per year by 2050. Countries and consumers will be crying out for climate-friendly products and innovations.

Helen Clark’s policies have seen New Zealand’s greenhouse gas emissions grow faster than ever before. Between 2000 and 2005 alone, New Zealand’s emissions grew by 6.8 million tonnes. The weight of that gas is more than 16,000 fully laden jumbo jets, 260 titanics or 20 Empire State Buildings. It’s a big increase.

Labour’s policy framework has been characterised by uncertainty and indecision. Their eight years in Government have seen a revolving door of climate-change interventions: The fart tax, the carbon tax, and the negotiated greenhouse gas agreements have all been abandoned. Tens of millions of dollars have been spent on an energy-efficiency strategy that saw the annual rate of improvement in energy-efficiency fall.

The most damaging area of Labour’s climate change policy is what happened in forestry. In the 50 years to 2003, New Zealand each year planted an average thirty thousand hectares of new forests. After Labour broke its word on forestry credits, we’ve had deforestation for the first time since those records began. The media is describing this as a “chainsaw massacre”.

I’m confident that many New Zealand businesses and individuals can and will become carbon neutral. I’m pleased that more and more are striving for it.

But making one household carbon neutral is quite a different thing to making the entire country carbon neutral. Not even the Green Party thinks that will be achievable in Clark’s lifetime.

Take their flagship scheme of getting six government departments to go “carbon neutral” in 2008. The emissions that will save over one year will be wiped out in just over half a day by greenhouse gas emissions from electricity generation alone.

And the 180 tonnes estimated to be saved from Parliament’s proposed new fuel-efficient cars – that will go in less than half an hour.

So today I say this: don’t be sucked into believing that Labour has the solutions on climate change. When Helen Clark talks about achieving carbon neutrality, Kiwis need to remember her track-record of skyrocketing emissions.

So today I will do something Helen Clark has never done and I doubt she ever will.

I will set the achievable emission reduction target for New Zealand.

Here it is: A 50% reduction in carbon-equivalent net emissions, as compared to 1990 levels, by 2050.

In shorthand: A 50% cut by 2050. 50 by 50.

If I am Prime Minister of New Zealand I will write this target into law.

This target is comparable with targets being set by other developed nations and it makes sense for New Zealand’s agriculture-intensive economy.

I make no apologies for promising less than Labour; because National will deliver more.

I think the points about a trading and economic need to cut carbon, otherwise face trade boycotts is a strong one. We are starting to see the danger already from food miles campaigns.

I’m glad to see National set a specific target, as it allows for meaningful debate – something one can’t do with Clark’s meaningless spin on carbon neutrality. What I would like to see is some ballpark estimates of the costs of the 50% reduction by 2050, and what the projected benefits will be, in fiscal terms. If for example trade fell by 5% due to a lack of action on carbon, would this cost more than the carbon reduction?

Quote of the Week

Kerre Woodham advocates a tough line on gangs, rejecting the assertion that some gang members are law abiding citizens.

But what made me laugh out loud was this line:

I’m with Michael Laws, and normally I’d rather swill snake vomit than agree with him.

Superb!

Now I’m wondering what snake vomit tastes like?

Should Bain be retried?

Two key issues loom for David Bain. Will the Crown seek a new trial, and if so will he get bail before it? What are the pros and cons of a new trial? We discussed this briefly on Agenda. Chris Baldock (Sunday News Editor) thought they should not, and Lisa Owen made the point that it would be very hard to get a jury who have not formed some conclusions based on media reporting of the case (unless you found 12 hermits). I lean a bit more towards a new trial, on the grounds that if they do not retry him, then the Crown is morally bound to pay millions of compensation to Bain, and that should only happen if he has been actually acquitted.

Anyway here are some pros and cons of a new trial:

Pros

* If acquitted in a new trial, Bain clears his name
* If found guilty in a new trial, gives finality to the issue
* Compensation should not be paid unless he is acquitted
* Unfair to Robin Bain to leave the killer allegation upon him untested
* If convicted, ensures Bain serves full sentence
* If convicted again, Bain less able to profit from his crime through books etc.

Cons

* Difficult to find a neutral jury
* Expert testimony less reliable 13 years on
* Bain has already served over 75% of his non parole period
* Bain is not a danger to the community – even if he did do it
* Prosecution will look vindictive

Any others?

Incidentally one of the original Jurors has come out saying that they placed little reliance on the stuff dealt with by the Privy Council and what they found compellling was the fight with the other son, as they could not believe an old man like Robin Bain could have endured such a furious fight and also be unscathed from it.

Transtasman Tax Rates

The Herald on Sunday has devoted both an editorial and a news story to the Australian tax cuts and how this will attract even more Kiwis to Australia. Both items quote the tax tables I did last week.

The editorial concludes:

But his [Dr Cullen] stony-faced opposition to personal income-tax cuts is now beginning to look like ideological hard-heartedness.

Much as he may wish it were not the case, the average New Zealander needs and deserves a tax cut – now. Next year, when it is likely to look like an election bribe, will be too late.

I’ve done a new table showing how much Peter Costello has cut tax for Australians since 2000, the same year Dr Cullen became our Finance Minister. Dr Cullen’s sole act to date for personal income tax was to increase it for those earning more than $60,000. Look at what Costello has done:

austax.JPG

Every person earning $30,000 or less has had their tax more than cut in half. You don’t even start paying tax until you now earn $11,000 in Australia. And everyone between $30,000 to $100,000 has had a greater than 30% tax cut.

Over the break is the revised NZ/Aus comparisons. It differs slightly from last week as I eventually discovered the income levels at which the $750 low earner tax offset phases out. It means you actually start paying less tax in NZ at $230,000 instead of $250,000. Wow wee!
Continue reading »

Bestiality film shown at Police Commissioners’s home

Good God. Yesterday morning I was asking, on Agenda, Police Minister Annette King if she felt by police hierarchy (I wasn’t actually meaning Broad or Pope but the person who mismanaged the stabproof vests project) sometimes let down the frontline officers, and she stressed how much confidence she has in new Commissioner Howard Broad, and then later that day Investigate publishes that Broad hosted a police party at his home in the 1980s, during which a illegal objectionable film involving bestiality was screened.

The Herald on Sunday reports that Broad has admitted that the facts relating to him are right, and is willing to resign. Annette King is refusing to comment and Helen Clark expressed her confidence in Broad.

The issue is not one of morality, but of police having broken the law and covered it up, and whether one can have confidence in Broad to be the new broom to clean up the legacy of the 1980s, when he is now seen as part of it. The Police Commissioner, like Caesar’s wife, needs to be above suspicion.

I suspect the Government will have to accept his resignation. How can anyone else be prosecuted for objectionable publications, if the Police Commissioner is publicly known to have broken the same law. At a minimum some sort of independent inquiry would be needed into what happened. At present the Government will just be thinking how much they hate Ian Wishart, and their responses will instinctively be to not do anything which may make Wishart seem a “winner”, but given time and if necessary some questioning in Parliament, they will soon realise there are bigger questions at stake.

Investigate, according to their cover, are also alleging involvement of some current and former politicians in related issues. I have not read Investigate, so can’t comment on what is or is not alleged but understand from Ian Wishart’s blog there will be a press release this afternoon. So the only uncontested fact at this stage is that a bestiality video was shown at Broad’s home. This doesn’t necessarily mean all allegations are true. Time will tell.

Farewell, Jacques Chirac

Despite Chirac being from the “right” I have never liked the man, but sometimes struggle to say why, escept for his arrogance, but he is hardly the only Frenchman with that Gallic trait.

Anne Applebaum in the Washington Post says goodbye and good riddance to him, and really gets to the heart of Chriac – his disdain for democracy. Some quotes:

During a visit to the Ivory Coast, Chirac once called “multi-partyism” a “kind of luxury,”

“Africa is not ready for democracy,” he told a group of African leaders in the early 1990s.

On Saddam Hussein: “You are my personal friend. Let me assure you of my esteem, consideration and bond.”

On Eastern Europe supporting the United States in the United Nations: “It is not really responsible behavior. It is not well brought-up behavior. They missed a good opportunity to shut up.”

On Iran’s nuclear program: “Having one or perhaps a second bomb a little later, well, that’s not very dangerous.” Theoretically, Chirac was supposed to be negotiating with Iran to give up its nuclear program at the time.

As I say, it’s an important legacy: one of consistent scorn for the Anglo-American world in general and the English language in particular; of suspicion of Central Europe and profound disinterest in the wave of democratic transformation that swept the world in the 1980s and 1990s; of preference for the Arab and African dictators who had been, and remained, clients of France.

It was, in other words, the legacy of a man who was deeply conservative, almost Brezhnevite in his view of the world — so much so that the word most often used to describe his political beliefs is “stagnation.”

Little to wait until 2011

EPMU Secretary Andrew Little has announced he will not stand for Labour in 2008, but is likely to try and stand in 2011.

This has a number of interesting aspects to it. The first is that Andrew has probably judged the chance of Labour winning a 4th term in 2008 as not being great. The best time to enter Parliament is the election before you enter Government.

The second is who will stand for Rimutaka for Labour in 2008? It is a very red seat so the candidate is likely to be a MP. Will one of the many Wellington based aspiring candidates be willing to move up there?

The third is what seat might Little stand for in 2011? He’s far too smart to want to rely on a list place only, putting him at the whim of the hierarchy. The new WC MP won’t be about to retire. OB is not a Labour seat. Probably not the right person for Mana. So that leaves Hutt South or Rongotai. My pick for now is Little to replace Mallard in 2011.

More on tax comparisons

Jordan claimed that my comparison of tax rates to Australia was not fair as it was the Federal Government only. Several people pointed out that there are no state income taxes.

But it is an interesting question – what is the size of the total government tax take – at all levels, including local, for each country.

A very nice person has helpfully shared with me some data from the subscription only OECD Economic Outlook 80 database. The data shows general government total tax and non-tax receipts as a percentage of GDP since 1990. It is a consolidation of accounts for central, state and local governments plus social security.

Of the 27 countries in the data series, Australia has the 7th lowest tax/income as a % of GDP, being 36.5% in 2006. NZ is in 17th place at 43.4% – a massive 7.1% more.

But what is more fascinating is how NZ’s place has changed over time.

You see in 1999 NZ was in 9th place. On average every year we have dropped a place, increasing our tax take compared to other countries.

And who are the countries ahead of us? Ireland is in 5th place. Their lower taxes speak for themselves in terms of results. Switzerland is in 6th place.

Oh and Australia. Well by 2008 it is predicted they’ll be in 5th place, and that is before the latest tax cuts.

The Press on Sarkozy

It’s good to see The Press devoting an editorial to new French President Nicolas Sarkozy. As the soon to be head of state of one of the five permament members of the Security Council, he will be an important world figure.

They comment:

Although he is often denounced as a divisive figure, Sarkozy not only took the Right-wing vote, but also half the Centrist vote, despite failing to win the support of the Centrist leader, Francois Bayrou. Perhaps even more remarkably, the hard-headed, sharp-tongued Sarkozy, whose bruising political manoeuvres are notorious, won 52% of the female vote against his female rival.

In the last 26 years, neither the Left, in the shape of Socialist leader Francois Mitterand, nor the Right, represented by Jacques Chirac, has made a serious attempt to bring about the effective reform France needs. It is no coincidence that in the same period France has slid from seventh to 17th in economic output per person.

They do make one mistake in their editorial though, when they claim:

Sarkozy took 53% of the vote, a full six points ahead of his Socialist rival, Segolene Royal. It was the largest majority since the re-election of Charles De Gaulle more than 40 years.

It wasn’t. There have been three other elections post De Gaulle with a greater margin. Maybe one can overlook the last election where it was a 64% margin as that was vs Le Pen, not a mainstream rival, but the margins post De Gaulle have been:

1969 16%
1974 1.6%
1981 3.6%
1988 8.0%
1995 5.2%
2002 64%
2007 6%

So that was a pretty big error to call it the largest in 40 years. It is 4th of seven.

Immigrants and Inflation

Winston Peters is blaming the high inflation rate on our level of immigration. Now there is liitle dispute that immigration can fuel inflationary pressures, especially if infrastructure is not geared up to cope (which arguably is the case in Auckland where most go).

But if we look at the net migration, it is hard to conclude that is a big part of the problem. The net permanent and long-term migration for the years to March are:

2000 -8,990
2001 -12,600
2002 25,640
2003 41,590
2004 27,980
2005 10,010
2006 9,740
2007 12,080

So in 2002 to 2004 there was some pretty high levels. But since 2004 net migration of 10,000 a year is pretty modest, compared to overall population growth which averaged 58,000 a year.

So Winston has a bit of a point, Immigration can be a factor. But at present levels it isn’t much of one. Peters quotes gross migration as it suits him politically, but it is net migration that matters.

Rates

The Herald reports on how water bills are going up 9.1% in Auckland, along with rates up 33% under Dick Hubbard. City Vision promised at the last election increases of no more than 2% above inflation.

The article is quite timely as Local Government NZ made its submission yesterday to the Rates Inquiry. LGNZ invited a few media people along to a briefing afterwards, but for some reason I was the only one interested enough to turn up. What it meant though is I got to spend an hour exclusively quizzing the President, Vice-President and senior staff of Local Government NZ. Was a great opportunity.

LGNZ made the case quite strongly that communities are wanting better infrastructure, better facilities, more events, and that these cost money. We talked about alternatives to rates such as income or sales taxes, and also about the tension between keeping rates down and spending demands. They acknowledged that Local Govt is different to most organisations who know their income, and then spend within it. Local Govt works out its spending, and then sets rates to fund it.

A very valid point, covered in their submission, is that central Govt gets lots more money every year from bracket creep on taxes. Local Govt does not. Also found out there were around 19 classes of land exempted from paying rates, ranging from Crown land to some Maori land to church owned land.

Considering the wealth of many churches, I’m not thrilled by their exemption. Why exempt churches but not other charities?

The Auckland situation was discussed, and how some of their problem came from the three way combination of an increase in spending, a one off change to the commercial:residential differential and a five yearly revaluation. Hence some massive increases for some people.

Wellington has avoided many of these problems by shifting the commercial:residential differential over a ten year period, and doing annual revaluations so the big swings are avoided.

Also talked on public good vs private good. The town belt in Wellington is what I would call 100% public good. Swimming pools though vary from Council to Council – many are 50/50 funded from rates and user charges but one Council has free admission. Personally I view Libraries as close to 100% public good but they have reasonably significant user charges in many places.

LGNZ said many people are unaware of the extent of the services they get from their Councils, and don’t value them enough, which led to the above conversation that making people pay directly for them can help make people value them.

Also good discussions over how transparent funding should be. Central Govt funding is almost invisible to the average person as GST and PAYE are all done by businesses for you. However one gets regular rates bills which means they get scrutinised more than central Govt does. Personally I reckon a bold National Party should abolish PAYE and make the IRD invoice people monthly to pay their income tax. You’d have a huge and permanent lower tax constituency if people were actually writing out $1,000+ cheques every month to the IRD.

It will be interesting to see what the Inquiry team recommends to Govt. None of the 30 LGNZ recommendations are fundamental changes to how local govt is funded, and I doubt the Govt is interested in fundamental reform.

The one prediction I will make is that the Government will not agree to remove the rating exemption for crown land!

The best of Shortland Street

A three and a half minute compilation of some of the most dramatic Shortland Street scenes over the last 15 years. Was great seeing some of them again, but also somewhat disturbed at how many I had seen, despite being only an occasional viewer.

Hat Tip: Spare Room

Interview with WikiNews

Being on of the biggest fans around of WIkipedia and related sites, I was very chuffed when I was asked to do an interview for sister site Wikinews. The interview is here at WIkinews.

As a minor thing I didn’t quite mean it to sound like I am saying I may get three times the visitors of Public Address. I was asked if Kiwiblog was the most popular blog and I said that there are probably three big sites who get well over 100,000 visits (not visitors) – myself, PA and Spare Room, and gave my stats of 300,000 as an example. I also mentioned sites done by NZers but globally popular such as Read Write Web. I was in fact trying to not claim any such mantle. Incidentally also congrats to Public Address for their Netguide Award win again.

At the end of the interview I give some of my favourites blogs. Quite amusingly they have used my descriptions of the, but not their names, so there maybe a bit of guesswork about which sites I am referring to, but they are all hyperlinked.

It says something about my inner geek that I got more excited about being interviewed for Wikinews than I do for TV interviews 🙂

Blair sets the date

Tony Blair has announced he will resign as Prime Minister of the United Kingdom on 27 June 2007, giving him a reign in office of just over ten years, and just under 13 years as Labour Party Leader.

Sky News is full of tributes to him from around the world and in the UK. I’ve sometimes said that his biggest accomplishment was winning elections, and even if this ungenerous interpretation is true, that has not been insignificant in itself. Labour was out of office for a massive 18 years from 1979 to 1997. Blair has won three elections in a row and given Labour 12 or 13 years in office, making themselves the natural party of Government.

Just as Blair has to embrace much of what Thatcher did to become electable, likewise Cameron has had to do the same with Blair. Blair is very young for a former PM and at 54 will probably take up a Clinton like rock star status on the international scene.

I think there is little doubt Gordon Brown will become the next Labour Leader and PM. I doubt one can even get odds from a bookie for him. Brown vs Cameron will be interesting.

David Bain gets a retrial

The Privy Council in one of its final decisions for NZ has granted quintuple murderer David Bain a new trial. It doesn’t mean he is innocent but Joe Karam and of course David Bain will be happy men.

The Privy Council has said the case had unusual circumstances and it may have constituted a substantial miscarriage of justice so they have quashed his convictions for murdering his parents, sisters, and brother in 1994.

I still think he is guilty on the evidence, but I am not a Law Lord 🙂

Cell Phones & GPS

Reuters has an article on how personal navigation is becoming a cell phone feature. The Nokia N95 being one example.

It is not far off that your cellphone will tell you:

* Where you are
* Directions to get to anywhere
* The nearest cafe, bookstore, garage etc
* What specials are being offered within x metres of you
* Where all your friends are in relation to you
* How far away the bus or train is

The potential is almost unlimited.

Snippets

Kiwi Pundit asks the very good question:

Would you give $1.2 million a year of your money to a woman in the thrall of a charlatan who claims to cure incurable diseases through ancient knowledge and magic? If not, why the hell would you vote for a government that does so on your behalf?

Indeed.

Danish teachers are refusing to stop an annual striptease by pupils despite a video of an onstage lesbian love romp ending up on YouTube. And yes, there is video at the link!

NNDB has a list of nicknames George W Bush has for various people. Most un PC is calling Prince Bandar bin Sultan, Bandar Bush. Blair is called Landslide and Maureen Dowd is Cobra. Oh yes Putin is Pootie-Poot – makes you glad Bush did not have to deal with Stalin!

Michael Ellis links to the story of John Brandwick who was told he had pancreatic cancer and would die within a year. As you would, you quit your job, and go on a year long holiday. Then after he had not died, the doctors said it wasn’t cancer just an inflammation of the pancreas. Mr Brandwick is now bankrupt however. Imagine when he got told. You’d be half delighted with joy that you are not dying, but half very pissed off.

The Herald reports on plans for an online Encyclopedia of Life which will catalog all 1.8 million known plant and animal species. What a great project. It would be great if they could also give GPS locations for each species so one could then pull up an area on a map and see all the species in that area.

Stuff reports that when Judge Michael T Sauer, who sentenced Paris Hilton to 45 days jail, walked into his parish church on Saturday, he was greeted by rapturous applause. Heh.

Interesting Thinking

I’m quite proud of the research I did working out tax you pay in NZ and Australia on income. I’ve even got updated tables taking into account stuff like the Australian low income tax offset which means no tax until you earn over $11,000. Took me ages of searching to find out how it works.

Jordan, without providing any facts or research, except quoting five year old tax data, insists that I am wrong. He says “What you can be certain of is that people’s pay packets are not what is represented in DPF’s table.” He insists I have overlooked state taxes.

As Jordan’s commenters are pointing out, the states are generally funded from federal income tax and state payroll tax is a tax on businesses not individuals.

Now Jordan in five point font admits at the bottom that even back in 2002/03 as a % of GDP, govt revenue in NZ is 41.2% and Australia is 36.6%. Well 5% of GDP is a hell of a lot of money – $8 billion or so.

The reality is that in the last eight years Dr Cullen has only increased individual tax. He has not delivered a single cut to tax rates or thresholds. And what has Peter Costello done over the same eight years?

An individual on $20,000 now pays 51.3% less income tax
An individual on $30,000 now pays 54.2% less income tax
An individual on $40,000 now pays 36.2% less income tax

On the NZ average wage of $40,000 you pay 23% less income tax in Australia than you do here.

And we won’t even mention the NZ GST is 12.5% on everything and Australia GST is 10% on only some stuff.

Subway charges dropped

DPF on Agenda

I’m one of the two guest panelists on Agenda this Saturday, which means I get to ask the interviewees some questions, and talk about the issues of the week.

The good news for me is I get to spend Friday evening in Auckland, having some drinks with friends. The bad news is I’ll need to be up by 7am 🙁